|
ASPHALT FUME CHARACTERIZATION AND HAZARD IDENTIFICATION
RESEARCHER: Larry Olsen
AFFILIATION:
Division of Applied Research and Technology
National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (513) 533-8543
PURPOSE: Identify specific compounds or
compound classes in asphalt fumes that may cause irritation or genotoxicity.
RESEARCH SUMMARY: This research will be integral
to development of sampling and analytical methods used to assess exposures
to asphalt fumes and specific irritants and genotoxins. Laboratory research
will be useful in designing better worker exposure protocols, identifying
specific biomarkers to assess a worker's true exposure, and designing animal
studies to evaluate physiological and toxicological effects associated with
exposure.
Specifically, research will focus on the following tasks:
- Fractionate, analyze, and bioassay the biologically active asphalt
fume fractions from an earlier study to identify specific genotoxins
that may be responsible for observed tumors.
- Conduct research for the Federal Highway Administration to determine
if the addition of crumb-rubber to asphalt mixtures results in more-hazardous
asphalt fumes.
- Test paving asphalt fume samples for mutagenicity under an interagency
agreement with EPA.
- Characterize the chemistry of paving and roofing asphalt fume samples.
- Consult on the chemical characterization and assessment of the asphalt
fumes to which animals will be exposed to investigate physiological
and toxic responses.
- Collaborate on the development of sampling and analytical methods
for the benzene-soluble fraction and total particulates.
- Collaborate on ways to foster better communication regarding asphalt
fume research.
- Collaborate with industry researchers to evaluate high-performance
chromatography (HPLC)/fluorescence methods for the determination of
polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAH's) in asphalt fumes and compare
results with results using gas chromatography/mass spectrometry (GC/MS)
techniques.
KEYWORDS: Asphalt, hazard identification,
analytical methods
RECENT CITATIONS:
Butler, M.A., G. Burr, D. Dankovic, R.A. Lunsford, A. Miller, M. Nguyen,
L. Olsen, D. Sharpnack, J. Snawder, L. Stayner, M. Haring Sweeney, A. Teass,
J. Wess, and R. Zumwalde. 2001. Health effects of occupational exposure
to asphalt. NIOSH Hazard Review. DHHS (NIOSH) Pub. 2001-110.
Jaycox, L.B., and L.D. Olsen. 2000. Determination of total sulfur com-pounds
and benzothiazole in asphalt fume samples by gas chromatography with sulfur
chemiluminescence detection. Applied Occupational and Environmental Hygiene,
v. 15, no. 9, pp. 695-704.
Qian, H-W., W-Z. Whong, L. Olsen, J. Nath, and T. Ong. 1999. Induction of
micronuclei in V79 cells by fractions of roofing asphalt fume condenate.
Mutation Research, v. 441, no. 2, pp. 163-170.
RESEARCHER: Jin Wang
AFFILIATION:
Health Effects Laboratory Division
National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (304) 285-6329
PURPOSE: Develop state-of-the-art analytical
and bioanalytical methods to study the adverse health effects of asphalt
fume exposures.
RESEARCH SUMMARY: Millions of tons of asphalt
are produced and used every year in the paving and roofing industries. It
has been estimated that crude asphalt contains the most widely distributed
class of potent carcinogens present in the human environment. Exposure to
these mixtures may pose a health risk to workers; however, specific adverse
effects have not been established. In particular, the relationship between
exposure and DNA damage is not clear. Also, there is a concern about long-term
health effects following chronic exposure.
A sensitive, selective, and reliable analytical method has been developed
and validated for characterization of asphalt fumes generated under conditions
that simulate road paving sites. The new method could be used as an effective
tool to study the adverse health effects of workers exposed to hazardous
mixtures.
Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAH's) contained in asphalt are an important
class of chemical hazards. These compounds or their metabolites can interact
with DNA, resulting in covalent bonding between chemicals and biological
macromolecules and consequent damage to DNA. In this study, female Sprague-Dawley
rats and B6C3F1 mice were exposed to asphalt fumes in a whole-body inhalation
chamber. A new bioanalytical method was developed to characterize DNA adducts
and PAH metabolites. This method has a wide variety of applications in detecting
molecular markers during exposure to a number of different agents.
The information obtained from these studies may assist risk assessment and
the development of prevention strategies for people exposed to such mixtures
in the workplace.
KEYWORDS: Asphalt fume exposure, biomarkers,
analytical and bioanalytical methods
RECENT CITATIONS:
Wang, J., D.M. Lewis, V. Castranova, D.G. Frazer, T. Goldsmith, S. Tomblyn,
J. Simpson, S. Stone, A. Afshari, and P.D. Siegel. 2001. Characterization
of asphalt fume composition under simulated road paving conditions by GC-MS
and microflow LC-Q-TOF MS. Analytical Chemistry, v. 73, no.15, pp.
3691-3700.
Wang, J., D.M. Lewis, J. Meade, B.F. Law, S. Tomblyn, and P.D. Siegel. 2001.
Characterization of DNA damage and PAHs metabolites in mice lung exposed
to asphalt fume by capillary flow Q-TOF MS. Presentation at 49th annual
meeting of American Society of Mass Spectrometry, Chicago, IL, May 2001.
Wang, J., D. Lewis, B.V. Law, D. Frazer, S. Stone, T. Goldsmith, A. Mosley,
J. Simpson, and P. Siegle. 2002. Urinary metabolites characterization of
asphalt fume exposure. Presentation at 41st annual meeting of Society of
Toxicology, Nashville, TN, Mar. 2002.
RESEARCHER: Jane Ma
AFFILIATION:
Health Effects Laboratory Division
National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (304) 285-5844
PURPOSE: Investigate the effects of asphalt
fumes on pulmonary irritation, inflammation, airway reactivity, and lung
injury.
RESEARCH SUMMARY: A 1983 NIOSH report showed
that at least 500,000 workers were exposed to asphalt fumes in the United
States. Exposure to asphalt fumes during road paving operations has been
associated with airway irritation and airway hyperreactivity in some pavers.
It is known that the fumes generated from both paving and roofing asphalts
are very complex mixtures, containing particulates and various organic com-pounds,
such as polycyclic aromatic compounds (PAH's). Exposures to mixed materials,
such as asphalt fumes, may result in greater pulmonary injury than exposure
to a single agent.
In this project, the effects of road paving asphalt fumes on airway irritation,
pulmonary inflammation, airway reactivity, and lung damage will be monitored
to assess the inflammatory potential of asphalt fumes and oxidative stress
in the lungs. Pulmonary injury will be evaluated by measuring oxidant generation,
inflammatory cytokine secretion, and metabolic activities in the lung. Airway
irritation will be monitored by histological evaluation of the nasal cavity.
Airway reactivity will be evaluated by measuring pulmonary function. These
studies will characterize in detail the major components of cytochrome 450,
cytochrome 1A1, and cytochrome 2B1 isozyme levels, and metabolic activities
of these isozymes. The results of these studies should aid in better understanding
of the mechanism of potential toxicity induced by asphalt fumes and the
potential health hazards associated with exposure to asphalt fumes.
KEYWORDS: Asphalt, hazards, mixed exposures
RECENT CITATIONS:
Gamble, J.F., M.J. Nicolich, N.J. Barone, and W.J. Vincent. 1999. Exposure-response
of asphalt fumes with changes in pulmonary function and symptoms. Scandinavian
Journal of Work and Environmental Health, v. 25, pp. 186-206.
Jarvholm, B., G. Nordstrom, B. Hogstedt, J.O. Levin, J. Wahlstrom, C. Ostman,
and C. Bergendahl. 1999. Exposure to polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons and
genotoxic effects on nonsmoking Swedish road pavement workers. Scandinavian
Journal of Work and Environmental Health, v. 25, pp. 131-136.
Ma, J.Y., M.W. Barger, A.J. Kriech, and V. Castranova. 2000. Effects of
asphalt fume condensate exposure on acute pulmonary responses. Archives
of Toxicology, v. 74, pp. 452-459.
Micillino, J.C., C. Coulais, S. Binet, M.C. Bottin, G. Keith, D. Moulin,
and B.H. Rihn. 2002. Lack of genotoxicity of bitumen fumes in transgenic
mouse lung. Toxicology, v. 170, pp. 11-20.

RESEARCHER: David Marlow
AFFILIATION:
Division of Applied Research and Technology
National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (513) 841-4204
PURPOSE: Evaluate existing engineering controls
of fume exposures to roofing kettle operators and redesign those controls
to reduce worker exposures.
RESEARCH SUMMARY: Because of extreme asphalt temperatures
during the roofing process, roofers may be at the highest risk of exposure
to asphalt fumes of all industry or trade workers. In 1990, an estimated
46,000 roofing workers in the United States were exposed, most of them employed
by small contractors (about 90% of roofing contractors have fewer than 20
employees) who do not have access to current technology for controlling
exposures. Epidemiological data indicate excess mortality from cancer of
the respiratory system, digestive system, and urinary system. Health effects
from exposure to asphalt fumes include irritation of the respiratory tract
and lung diseases such as bronchitis, emphysema, and asthma.
The evaluation and development of practical controls for roofing kettle
emissions could significantly reduce worker exposure to asphalt fumes. This
will be accomplished through a combination of isolation and local ventilation
techniques, changes in work processes, and industry and labor partnerships.
Specific recommendations will be based on initial surveys and quantitative
analyses of exposure levels. The exposure of roofing kettle operators to
asphalt fumes will be evaluated, the efficiency of existing exposure controls
will be examined, and recommendations will be provided as necessary. To
date, literature searches, discussions with roofing kettle manufacturers
and operators, and walk-through surveys have provided pertinent information
on asphalt fume generation and control. In-depth studies have been conducted
using conventional and real-time air sampling techniques to evaluate worker
exposure and the effectiveness of controls.
A pilot study demonstrated a statistically significant reduction of from
55% to 95% in the benzene-soluble fraction of total particulates in area
and personal exposures when a low-fuming, built-up roofing asphalt (BURA)
was used instead of a standard BURA. Low-fuming BURA contains a blend of
up to 1% polymers that form a crust that reduces the release of fumes from
asphalt.
Four field surveys were conducted to study whether similar reductions could
be seen in the workplace. Personal breathing zone and area air samples were
collected from both low-fuming asphalt and standard BURA and analyzed for
total particulates, benzene-soluble fraction, and polycyclic aromatic compounds.
Results of these surveys showed that when low-fuming BURA was used, kettle
operators' mean exposures were reduced by 75%, 85%, and 77%, respectively,
and roof-level workers exposures were reduced by 28%, 24%, and 27%, respectively.
KEYWORDS: Asphalt, small business, engineering controls,
roofers
RECENT CITATIONS:
Franzen, M.R., and D.C. Trumbore. 2000. Reduction of asphalt fumes in roofing
kettles. Environmental Science and Technology, v. 34, pp. 2582-2586.
RESEARCHER: Joann Wess
AFFILIATION:
Education and Information Division
National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (513) 533-8342
PURPOSE: Develop a technical document that addresses
work practices and methods for reducing exposure to asphalt fumes and other
potential hazards during the application of hot asphalt to roofs.
RESEARCH SUMMARY: Approximately 46,000 workers
are involved in the application of hot asphalt to roofs. Exposures have
been hypothesized to be related to increased incidence of some cancers,
as well as lung and skin irritation. A draft document produced jointly by
the Asphalt Roofing Manufacturers' Association (ARMA), the National Roofing
Contractors' Association (NRCA), the Asphalt Institute (AI), and the United
Union of Roofers, Waterproofers, and Allied Workers was presented to NIOSH
for review and further development in a collaborative effort.
The document will describe methods to control and reduce asphalt exposure
among workers in the asphalt roofing industry. The intended audience is
plant managers, safety and health personnel, and engineers in industry and
government. Dissemination of the document will be through trade unions,
trade associations, the Internet, and other means appropriate for this population.
KEYWORDS: Work practices, asphalt, hazards, roofers
RECENT CITATIONS:
National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health. 2001. Health effects
of occupational exposure to asphalt. NIOSH Hazard Review. DHHS (NIOSH) Pub.
2001-110.
National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health. 2001. Asphalt fume
exposure during the manufac-ture of asphalt roofing products: Current practices
for reducing exposures. DHHS (NIOSH) Pub. 2001-127.
Gamble, J.F., M.J. Nicolich, N.J. Barone, and J. Vincent. 1999. Exposure-response
of asphalt fumes with changes in pulmonary function and symptoms. Scandinavian
Journal of Work and Environmental Health, v. 25, no. 3, pp. 186-206.
RESEARCHER: Joann Wess
AFFILIATION:
Education and Information Division
National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (513) 533-8342
PURPOSE: Acquire the documentation and develop
a recommended standard that includes an occupational exposure limit for
asphalt based on a recently published NIOSH Hazard Review document on asphalt.
RESEARCH SUMMARY: Nationwide, 300,000 workers
are involved in the application of asphalt paving materials, and 46,000
workers apply hot roofing materials. These workers include laborers, operating
engineers, roofers, and waterproofers.
The information published in a recent NIOSH Hazard Review will be used along
with medical and exposure data collected by NIOSH during an evaluation of
paving workers to develop a recommended standard for asphalt. The standard
or criteria document will include recommendations for medical surveillance
and exposure monitoring, the use of personal protective equipment and engineering
controls, work practices, and the basis for a Recommended Exposure Limit
(REL).
Compliance with the REL should reduce risks of lung cancer and acute and
chronic respiratory effects in workers exposed to asphalt during road paving,
the manufacture of asphalt products, and the application of hot asphalt
roofing and asphalt-containing waterproofing materials.
KEYWORDS: Occupational exposure limits, asphalt, cancer
RECENT CITATIONS:
National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health. 2001. Health effects
of occupational exposure to asphalt. NIOSH Hazard Review. DHHS (NIOSH) Pub.
2001-110.
Miller, A.K., and G.A. Burr. 1998. Health hazard evaluation report: Bardon-Trimount,
Stoughton, Massachusetts. NIOSH HETA No. 97-0232-2674.
RESEARCHER: Joann Wess
AFFILIATION:
Education and Information Division
National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (513) 533-8342
PURPOSE: Develop a Concise International Chemical Assessment
Document (CICAD) in partnership with the World Health Organization concerning
asphalt fumes from paving, roofing, manufacturing, and other processes.
RESEARCH SUMMARY: In the United States, over 300,000
workers are employed in the asphalt paving and hot-mix industries, 53,000
workers are employed in roofing, and 1,500 are employed in producing asphalt-based
roofing materials. Asphalt fumes are a complex mixture of petroleum by-products.
The composition of this mixture and its resultant toxicity is dependent
on many factors, including the engineering controls used during various
stages of asphalt application. Limited toxicologic data suggest that asphalt
fumes composed of polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons are carcinogenic in animals.
A Concise International Chemical Assessment Document (CICAD) on asphalt
exposure will be developed in partnership with the World Health Organization
(WHO). CICAD's are concise documents that provide summaries of the relevant
scientific information concerning the potential effects of chemicals on
human health and the environment. The proposed CICAD will characterize exposures
to asphalt fumes and describe their potential effects on human health in
both the workplace and the environment. It will be based on information
generated by NIOSH research and partnership efforts with the asphalt industry
and representatives of workers in that industry. This information has been
published, in part, in NIOSH documents on controlling exposure to asphalt
fumes and in a Health Hazard Review on the health effects of occupational
exposure to asphalt. The project would involve limited searches in additional
literature on the environmental transport, distribution, and transportation
of asphalt and asphalt by-products. The available information would be compiled
and reviewed and developed into a CICAD and disseminated worldwide through
our partnership with WHO.
In addition to being an international resource document, this CICAD could
serve as concise publication for industrial hygienists in the United States
who are involved with construction workers who may be exposed to asphalt
fumes.
KEYWORDS: Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, occupational exposure
limits
RECENT CITATIONS:
National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health. 2001. Health effects
of occupational exposure to asphalt. NIOSH Hazard Review. DHHS (NIOSH) Pub.
2001-110.
Back
to Contents
This paper appears in the eLCOSH website with the permission of the author
and/or copyright holder and may not be reproduced without their consent. eLCOSH is an
information clearinghouse. eLCOSH and its sponsors are not responsible for the accuracy of
information provided on this web site, nor for its use or misuse.
|