An error has occured:
Attempt to read property 'getID' from NULL value
PHPTAL_VariableNotFoundException Object
(
[srcFile] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/templates/elcosh/record.html/collections
[srcLine] =>
[message:protected] => Attempt to read property 'getID' from NULL value
[string:Exception:private] =>
[code:protected] => 0
[file:protected] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/templates/elcosh/record.html/collections
[line:protected] =>
[trace:Exception:private] => Array
(
[0] => Array
(
[file] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/sblib/core/SB_PHPTAL/PHPTAL/PHPTAL/Context.php
[line] => 353
[function] => pathError
[class] => PHPTAL_Context
[type] => ::
[args] => Array
(
[0] =>
[1] => getID
[2] => getID
)
)
[1] => Array
(
[file] => /tmp/tpl_61515a6c_record_macros__gMFg5NvPLybiFfYjAv9Aag.php
[line] => 105
[function] => path
[class] => PHPTAL_Context
[type] => ::
[args] => Array
(
[0] =>
[1] => getID
)
)
[2] => Array
(
[file] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/sblib/core/SB_PHPTAL/PHPTAL/PHPTAL.php
[line] => 772
[function] => tpl_61515a6c_record_macros__gMFg5NvPLybiFfYjAv9Aag_collections
[args] => Array
(
[0] => PHPTAL Object
(
[_prefilters:protected] => Array
(
)
[_prefilter:PHPTAL:private] => REMOVED: DO NOT USE
[_postfilter:protected] =>
[_repositories:protected] => Array
(
[0] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/templates/elcosh
)
[_path:protected] => record_macros.html
[_resolvers:protected] => Array
(
)
[_source:protected] => PHPTAL_FileSource Object
(
[_path:PHPTAL_FileSource:private] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/templates/elcosh/record_macros.html
)
[_codeFile:protected] => /tmp/tpl_61515a6c_record_macros__gMFg5NvPLybiFfYjAv9Aag.php
[_functionName:protected] => tpl_61515a6c_record_macros__gMFg5NvPLybiFfYjAv9Aag
[_prepared:protected] => 1
[_triggers:protected] => Array
(
)
[_translator:protected] =>
[_globalContext:protected] => stdClass Object
(
)
[_context:protected] => PHPTAL_Context Object
(
[_line] =>
[_file] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/templates/elcosh/record.html
[repeat] => stdClass Object
(
)
[_xmlDeclaration] =>
[_docType] =>
[_nothrow:PHPTAL_Context:private] =>
[_slots:PHPTAL_Context:private] => Array
(
)
[_slotsStack:PHPTAL_Context:private] => Array
(
[0] => Array
(
)
[1] => Array
(
)
)
[_parentContext:PHPTAL_Context:private] => PHPTAL_Context Object
(
[_line] =>
[_file] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/templates/elcosh/record.html
[repeat] => stdClass Object
(
)
[_xmlDeclaration] =>
[_docType] =>
[_nothrow:PHPTAL_Context:private] =>
[_slots:PHPTAL_Context:private] => Array
(
)
[_slotsStack:PHPTAL_Context:private] => Array
(
[0] => Array
(
)
[1] => Array
(
)
)
[_parentContext:PHPTAL_Context:private] =>
[_globalContext:PHPTAL_Context:private] => stdClass Object
(
)
[_echoDeclarations:PHPTAL_Context:private] =>
[referer] => http://www.elcosh.org/document/3908/d001345/An%2BEvaluation%2Bof%2BSilica%2BExposure%2BControls%2Bfor%2BTuckpointing%253A%2BDustControl%2B2900c%2BVacuum%2Bwith%2Bthe%2BICS%2BDust%2BDirector%2BShroud%2Band%2BBosch%2BGrinder%2BModel%2B1775E%2BConducted%2BNovember%2B14-15%252C%2B2012.html
[curr_module] => Record
[styles] => Array
(
)
[javascript] => Array
(
[0] => jquery.min.js
)
[metas] => Array
(
[language] => en
[robots] => index, follow
)
[user] =>
[curr_url] => https://www.elcosh.org/index.php?module=Record&id=3908&type=document
[base_url] => https://www.elcosh.org/index.php?module=Record
[title] => eLCOSH : An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: DustControl 2900c Vacuum with the ICS Dust Director Shroud and Bosch Grinder Model 1775E Conducted November 14-15, 2012
[language] => en
[search_query] =>
[module] => Record
[new_records] => Array
(
[0] => Search_Result Object
(
[title] => Toolbox Talk: Fixed Ladder
[image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png
[blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Fixed Ladders addresses the potential risks associated with using fixed ladders. The resource includes a brief case example,...
[category] => Array
(
[0] => 15
[1] => 47
[2] => 49
[3] => 51
[4] => 53
[5] => 55
[6] => 60
[7] => 64
[8] => 73
[9] => 76
[10] => 78
[11] => 80
[12] => 86
[13] => 87
[14] => 90
[15] => 92
[16] => 93
[17] => 94
[18] => 100
)
[labels] => Array
(
[0] => Falls
[1] => Work Environment
[2] => Hazards
[3] => Bricklayer
[4] => Trades
[5] => Carpenter
[7] => Cement Mason
[9] => Concrete Polisher
[11] => Electrical Worker
[13] => HVAC
[15] => Laborer
[17] => PCC/Restoration
[19] => Plumber/Pipefitter
[21] => Roofer/Waterproofer
[23] => Sheetmetal Worker
[25] => Welder
[27] => Commercial & Institutional
[28] => Jobsites
[29] => Industrial
[31] => LEED/Green Construction
[33] => Renovations
[35] => Residential
[37] => Toolbox Talks
[38] => Documents
[39] => Media & Documents
)
[type] => Toolbox Talks
[sub_category] =>
[url] => /document/4430/d001660/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BFixed%2BLadder.html
[item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object
(
[records:protected] => Array
(
)
[recordId:protected] =>
[searchWordClass:protected] =>
[searchWordPeerClass:protected] =>
[bok_record:protected] =>
[authors:protected] =>
[organizations:protected] =>
[collections:protected] =>
[categories:protected] => Array
(
[15] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 15
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 7
[label:protected] => Falls
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[47] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 47
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Bricklayer
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[49] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 49
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Carpenter
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[51] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 51
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Cement Mason
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[53] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 53
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Concrete Polisher
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[55] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 55
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Electrical Worker
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[60] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 60
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => HVAC
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[64] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 64
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Laborer
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[73] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 73
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => PCC/Restoration
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[76] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 76
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[78] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 78
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[80] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 80
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[86] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 86
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Welder
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[87] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 87
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[90] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 90
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Industrial
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[92] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 92
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[93] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 93
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Renovations
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[94] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 94
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Residential
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[100] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 100
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 6
[label:protected] => Toolbox Talks
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
)
[categories_initialized:protected] => 1
[mapped_items:protected] =>
[content:protected] =>
[files:protected] =>
[language:protected] => Language Object
(
[id:protected] => 1
[code:protected] => en
[name:protected] => English
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[old_record:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 4430
[old_id:protected] =>
[elcosh_id:protected] => d001660
[type:protected] => document
[display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links)
[user_id:protected] => 0
[language_id:protected] => 1
[tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar
[priority_id:protected] => 1
[title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Fixed Ladder
[total_pages:protected] => 0
[billed_pages:protected] => 0
[publication_number:protected] =>
[part_of:protected] =>
[keywords:protected] => Fixed Ladders, Fall Prevention, Falls
[comments:protected] =>
[summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Fixed Ladders addresses the potential risks associated with using fixed ladders. The resource includes a brief case example, steps to prevent a related injury and questions for discussion. It includes an image that illustrates the hazard, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely.
Available in English
and Spanish.
[transition_comments:protected] =>
[external_link:protected] =>
[consol_link:protected] =>
[more_like_this:protected] => d001257,d001254,d001255,d001256,d001258,d001262,d001279
[permission_given_by:protected] =>
[published:protected] => T
[billable:protected] => F
[img_name:protected] =>
[img_ext:protected] =>
[img_width:protected] =>
[img_height:protected] =>
[img_credit:protected] =>
[img_practice:protected] =>
[vid_source_id:protected] =>
[vid_running_time:protected] =>
[vid_intended_audience:protected] =>
[vid_acquisition_info:protected] =>
[vid_cost:protected] =>
[vid_producer:protected] =>
[vid_filename:protected] =>
[vid_filename_downloadable:protected] =>
[date_summary:protected] =>
[date_permission_requested:protected] =>
[date_permission_received:protected] =>
[date_review_needed:protected] =>
[date_received:protected] => 06/10/22
[date_completed:protected] => 06/10/22
[date_billed:protected] =>
[date_modified:protected] => 05/22/23
[collBokExports:protected] =>
[lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] =>
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
)
[1] => Search_Result Object
(
[title] => Toolbox Talk: Challenges Preventing Falling Objects
[image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png
[blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Challenges Preventing Falling Objects addresses the hazards of being struck by falling objects on the job site. The resource...
[category] => Array
(
[0] => 12
[1] => 47
[2] => 49
[3] => 51
[4] => 55
[5] => 64
[6] => 68
[7] => 71
[8] => 75
[9] => 78
[10] => 79
[11] => 82
[12] => 62
[13] => 86
[14] => 87
[15] => 88
[16] => 89
[17] => 91
[18] => 90
[19] => 92
[20] => 93
[21] => 94
[22] => 95
[23] => 100
)
[labels] => Array
(
[0] => Crushed/Struck By
[1] => Work Environment
[2] => Hazards
[3] => Bricklayer
[4] => Trades
[5] => Carpenter
[7] => Cement Mason
[9] => Electrical Worker
[11] => Laborer
[13] => Maintenance Worker
[15] => Painter
[17] => Plasterer
[19] => Roofer/Waterproofer
[21] => Scaffold Erector
[23] => Stonemason
[25] => Structural Ironworker
[27] => Welder
[29] => Commercial & Institutional
[30] => Jobsites
[31] => Demolition
[33] => Disasters
[35] => Heavy & Highway
[37] => Industrial
[39] => LEED/Green Construction
[41] => Renovations
[43] => Residential
[45] => Underground
[47] => Toolbox Talks
[48] => Documents
[49] => Media & Documents
)
[type] => Toolbox Talks
[sub_category] =>
[url] => /document/4431/d001661/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BChallenges%2BPreventing%2BFalling%2BObjects.html
[item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object
(
[records:protected] => Array
(
)
[recordId:protected] =>
[searchWordClass:protected] =>
[searchWordPeerClass:protected] =>
[bok_record:protected] =>
[authors:protected] =>
[organizations:protected] =>
[collections:protected] =>
[categories:protected] => Array
(
[12] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 12
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 7
[label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[47] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 47
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Bricklayer
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[49] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 49
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Carpenter
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[51] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 51
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Cement Mason
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[55] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 55
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Electrical Worker
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[64] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 64
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Laborer
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[68] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 68
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Maintenance Worker
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[71] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 71
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Painter
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[75] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 75
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Plasterer
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[78] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 78
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[79] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 79
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Scaffold Erector
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[82] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 82
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Stonemason
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[62] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 62
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Structural Ironworker
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[86] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 86
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Welder
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[87] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 87
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[88] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 88
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Demolition
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[89] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 89
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Disasters
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[91] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 91
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Heavy & Highway
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[90] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 90
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Industrial
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[92] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 92
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[93] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 93
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Renovations
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[94] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 94
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Residential
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[95] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 95
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Underground
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[100] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 100
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 6
[label:protected] => Toolbox Talks
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
)
[categories_initialized:protected] => 1
[mapped_items:protected] =>
[content:protected] =>
[files:protected] =>
[language:protected] => Language Object
(
[id:protected] => 1
[code:protected] => en
[name:protected] => English
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[old_record:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 4431
[old_id:protected] =>
[elcosh_id:protected] => d001661
[type:protected] => document
[display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links)
[user_id:protected] => 0
[language_id:protected] => 1
[tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar
[priority_id:protected] => 1
[title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Challenges Preventing Falling Objects
[total_pages:protected] => 0
[billed_pages:protected] => 0
[publication_number:protected] =>
[part_of:protected] =>
[keywords:protected] => dropped objects, falling objects, struck by incidents, struck by fatalities
[comments:protected] =>
[summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Challenges Preventing Falling Objects addresses the hazards of being struck by falling objects on the job site. The resource includes a brief example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates a group workers observing a scaffold free of debris during high winds, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely.
Available in English and Spanish.
[transition_comments:protected] =>
[external_link:protected] =>
[consol_link:protected] =>
[more_like_this:protected] => d001234,d001238,d001244,d001251,d001253,d001260,d001268,d001278
[permission_given_by:protected] =>
[published:protected] => T
[billable:protected] => F
[img_name:protected] =>
[img_ext:protected] =>
[img_width:protected] =>
[img_height:protected] =>
[img_credit:protected] =>
[img_practice:protected] =>
[vid_source_id:protected] =>
[vid_running_time:protected] =>
[vid_intended_audience:protected] =>
[vid_acquisition_info:protected] =>
[vid_cost:protected] =>
[vid_producer:protected] =>
[vid_filename:protected] =>
[vid_filename_downloadable:protected] =>
[date_summary:protected] =>
[date_permission_requested:protected] =>
[date_permission_received:protected] =>
[date_review_needed:protected] =>
[date_received:protected] => 06/10/22
[date_completed:protected] => 06/10/22
[date_billed:protected] =>
[date_modified:protected] => 05/22/23
[collBokExports:protected] =>
[lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] =>
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
)
[2] => Search_Result Object
(
[title] => Toolbox Talk: Tower Crane Safety
[image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png
[blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Tower Crane Safety addresses the potential hazards of Tower Cranes and the importance of following procedure before and durin...
[category] => Array
(
[0] => 11
[1] => 12
[2] => 18
[3] => 70
[4] => 87
[5] => 88
[6] => 91
[7] => 90
[8] => 92
[9] => 100
)
[labels] => Array
(
[0] => Cranes & Hoists
[1] => Work Environment
[2] => Hazards
[3] => Crushed/Struck By
[6] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment
[9] => Operating Engineer
[10] => Trades
[11] => Commercial & Institutional
[12] => Jobsites
[13] => Demolition
[15] => Heavy & Highway
[17] => Industrial
[19] => LEED/Green Construction
[21] => Toolbox Talks
[22] => Documents
[23] => Media & Documents
)
[type] => Toolbox Talks
[sub_category] =>
[url] => /document/4427/d001657/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BTower%2BCrane%2BSafety.html
[item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object
(
[records:protected] => Array
(
)
[recordId:protected] =>
[searchWordClass:protected] =>
[searchWordPeerClass:protected] =>
[bok_record:protected] =>
[authors:protected] =>
[organizations:protected] =>
[collections:protected] =>
[categories:protected] => Array
(
[11] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 11
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 7
[label:protected] => Cranes & Hoists
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[12] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 12
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 7
[label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[18] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 18
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 7
[label:protected] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[70] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 70
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Operating Engineer
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[87] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 87
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[88] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 88
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Demolition
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[91] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 91
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Heavy & Highway
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[90] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 90
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Industrial
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[92] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 92
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[100] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 100
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 6
[label:protected] => Toolbox Talks
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
)
[categories_initialized:protected] => 1
[mapped_items:protected] =>
[content:protected] =>
[files:protected] =>
[language:protected] => Language Object
(
[id:protected] => 1
[code:protected] => en
[name:protected] => English
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[old_record:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 4427
[old_id:protected] =>
[elcosh_id:protected] => d001657
[type:protected] => document
[display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links)
[user_id:protected] => 0
[language_id:protected] => 1
[tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar
[priority_id:protected] => 1
[title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Tower Crane Safety
[total_pages:protected] => 0
[billed_pages:protected] => 0
[publication_number:protected] =>
[part_of:protected] =>
[keywords:protected] => Tower Crane, Crane, Stability, Tipping, Lift Zone Safety, Lift, Zone, Safety, Struck by
[comments:protected] =>
[summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Tower Crane Safety addresses the potential hazards of Tower Cranes and the importance of following procedure before and during Tower Crane operation. The resource includes a brief example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates a worker inspecting a Tower Crane before operation, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely.
Available in English and Spanish.
[transition_comments:protected] =>
[external_link:protected] =>
[consol_link:protected] =>
[more_like_this:protected] => d001234,d001238,d001250,d001251,d001253,d001258,d001262,d001273
[permission_given_by:protected] =>
[published:protected] => T
[billable:protected] => F
[img_name:protected] =>
[img_ext:protected] => jpg
[img_width:protected] =>
[img_height:protected] =>
[img_credit:protected] =>
[img_practice:protected] =>
[vid_source_id:protected] =>
[vid_running_time:protected] =>
[vid_intended_audience:protected] =>
[vid_acquisition_info:protected] =>
[vid_cost:protected] =>
[vid_producer:protected] =>
[vid_filename:protected] =>
[vid_filename_downloadable:protected] =>
[date_summary:protected] =>
[date_permission_requested:protected] =>
[date_permission_received:protected] =>
[date_review_needed:protected] =>
[date_received:protected] => 12/23/21
[date_completed:protected] => 12/23/21
[date_billed:protected] =>
[date_modified:protected] => 05/19/23
[collBokExports:protected] =>
[lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] =>
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
)
[3] => Search_Result Object
(
[title] => Toolbox Talk: Work Zone Safety: Working Around Vehicles
[image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png
[blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Working Around Vehicles in the Work Zone addresses methods to avoid being struck-by a vehicle on a construction site. The res...
[category] => Array
(
[0] => 12
[1] => 18
[2] => 52
[3] => 57
[4] => 70
[5] => 85
[6] => 87
[7] => 88
[8] => 89
[9] => 91
[10] => 90
[11] => 92
[12] => 93
[13] => 94
[14] => 95
[15] => 100
)
[labels] => Array
(
[0] => Crushed/Struck By
[1] => Work Environment
[2] => Hazards
[3] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment
[6] => Commercial Diver
[7] => Trades
[8] => Flagger
[10] => Operating Engineer
[12] => Truck Driver
[14] => Commercial & Institutional
[15] => Jobsites
[16] => Demolition
[18] => Disasters
[20] => Heavy & Highway
[22] => Industrial
[24] => LEED/Green Construction
[26] => Renovations
[28] => Residential
[30] => Underground
[32] => Toolbox Talks
[33] => Documents
[34] => Media & Documents
)
[type] => Toolbox Talks
[sub_category] =>
[url] => /document/4428/d001658/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BWork%2BZone%2BSafety%253A%2BWorking%2BAround%2BVehicles.html
[item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object
(
[records:protected] => Array
(
)
[recordId:protected] =>
[searchWordClass:protected] =>
[searchWordPeerClass:protected] =>
[bok_record:protected] =>
[authors:protected] =>
[organizations:protected] =>
[collections:protected] =>
[categories:protected] => Array
(
[12] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 12
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 7
[label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[18] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 18
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 7
[label:protected] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[52] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 52
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Commercial Diver
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[57] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 57
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Flagger
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[70] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 70
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Operating Engineer
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[85] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 85
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Truck Driver
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[87] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 87
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[88] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 88
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Demolition
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[89] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 89
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Disasters
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[91] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 91
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Heavy & Highway
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[90] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 90
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Industrial
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[92] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 92
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[93] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 93
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Renovations
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[94] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 94
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Residential
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[95] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 95
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Underground
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[100] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 100
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 6
[label:protected] => Toolbox Talks
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
)
[categories_initialized:protected] => 1
[mapped_items:protected] =>
[content:protected] =>
[files:protected] =>
[language:protected] => Language Object
(
[id:protected] => 1
[code:protected] => en
[name:protected] => English
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[old_record:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 4428
[old_id:protected] =>
[elcosh_id:protected] => d001658
[type:protected] => document
[display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links)
[user_id:protected] => 0
[language_id:protected] => 1
[tagging_id:protected] => Daniela Caceres
[priority_id:protected] => 1
[title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Work Zone Safety: Working Around Vehicles
[total_pages:protected] => 0
[billed_pages:protected] => 0
[publication_number:protected] =>
[part_of:protected] =>
[keywords:protected] => Struck, Struck by, Vehicle, Work Zone Safety, Truck, Operator, Driver, Mobile Equipment
[comments:protected] =>
[summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Working Around Vehicles in the Work Zone addresses methods to avoid being struck-by a vehicle on a construction site. The resource includes a case example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates the hazard, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish.
[transition_comments:protected] =>
[external_link:protected] =>
[consol_link:protected] =>
[more_like_this:protected] => d001640
[permission_given_by:protected] =>
[published:protected] => T
[billable:protected] => F
[img_name:protected] =>
[img_ext:protected] =>
[img_width:protected] =>
[img_height:protected] =>
[img_credit:protected] =>
[img_practice:protected] =>
[vid_source_id:protected] =>
[vid_running_time:protected] =>
[vid_intended_audience:protected] =>
[vid_acquisition_info:protected] =>
[vid_cost:protected] =>
[vid_producer:protected] =>
[vid_filename:protected] =>
[vid_filename_downloadable:protected] =>
[date_summary:protected] =>
[date_permission_requested:protected] =>
[date_permission_received:protected] =>
[date_review_needed:protected] =>
[date_received:protected] => 12/23/21
[date_completed:protected] => 12/23/21
[date_billed:protected] =>
[date_modified:protected] => 05/19/23
[collBokExports:protected] =>
[lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] =>
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
)
[4] => Search_Result Object
(
[title] => Construction Dive -- DeWalt's Jobsite Pro headphones recalled for fire hazards
[image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png
[blurb] => A recall notice by the United States Consumer Product Safety Commission affects over 300,000 DeWalt Jobsite Pro Headphones. The recall is a result of...
[category] => Array
(
[0] => 16
[1] => 44
[2] => 45
[3] => 46
[4] => 47
[5] => 48
[6] => 49
[7] => 50
[8] => 51
[9] => 52
[10] => 53
[11] => 54
[12] => 55
[13] => 56
[14] => 57
[15] => 58
[16] => 59
[17] => 60
[18] => 61
[19] => 64
[20] => 65
[21] => 66
[22] => 67
[23] => 68
[24] => 69
[25] => 70
[26] => 71
[27] => 72
[28] => 73
[29] => 74
[30] => 75
[31] => 76
[32] => 77
[33] => 63
[34] => 78
[35] => 79
[36] => 80
[37] => 81
[38] => 82
[39] => 62
[40] => 83
[41] => 84
[42] => 85
[43] => 86
[44] => 87
[45] => 88
[46] => 89
[47] => 91
[48] => 90
[49] => 92
[50] => 93
[51] => 94
[52] => 95
)
[labels] => Array
(
[0] => Fire & Explosions
[1] => Work Environment
[2] => Hazards
[3] => Acoustical Ceiling Carpenter
[4] => Trades
[5] => Asbestos/Insulator
[7] => Boilermaker
[9] => Bricklayer
[11] => Cabinetmaker
[13] => Carpenter
[15] => Carpet Layer
[17] => Cement Mason
[19] => Commercial Diver
[21] => Concrete Polisher
[23] => Drywall Applicator Specialist
[25] => Electrical Worker
[27] => Elevator Constructor
[29] => Flagger
[31] => Glazier
[33] => Hazardous Waste Cleanup
[35] => HVAC
[37] => Interior Systems Carpenter
[39] => Laborer
[41] => Landscaper
[43] => Lather
[45] => Lead Abatement Worker
[47] => Maintenance Worker
[49] => Millwright
[51] => Operating Engineer
[53] => Painter
[55] => Paper Hanger
[57] => PCC/Restoration
[59] => Pile Driver
[61] => Plasterer
[63] => Plumber/Pipefitter
[65] => Refractory Worker
[67] => Reinforcing Ironworker
[69] => Roofer/Waterproofer
[71] => Scaffold Erector
[73] => Sheetmetal Worker
[75] => Sprinkler Fitter
[77] => Stonemason
[79] => Structural Ironworker
[81] => Terrazzo Worker
[83] => Tile Setter
[85] => Truck Driver
[87] => Welder
[89] => Commercial & Institutional
[90] => Jobsites
[91] => Demolition
[93] => Disasters
[95] => Heavy & Highway
[97] => Industrial
[99] => LEED/Green Construction
[101] => Renovations
[103] => Residential
[105] => Underground
)
[type] =>
[sub_category] =>
[url] => /document/4426/d001656/Construction%2BDive%2B--%2BDeWalt%2527s%2BJobsite%2BPro%2Bheadphones%2Brecalled%2Bfor%2Bfire%2Bhazards.html
[item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object
(
[records:protected] => Array
(
)
[recordId:protected] =>
[searchWordClass:protected] =>
[searchWordPeerClass:protected] =>
[bok_record:protected] =>
[authors:protected] =>
[organizations:protected] =>
[collections:protected] =>
[categories:protected] => Array
(
[16] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 16
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 7
[label:protected] => Fire & Explosions
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[44] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 44
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Acoustical Ceiling Carpenter
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[45] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 45
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Asbestos/Insulator
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[46] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 46
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Boilermaker
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[47] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 47
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Bricklayer
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[48] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 48
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Cabinetmaker
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[49] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 49
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Carpenter
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[50] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 50
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Carpet Layer
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[51] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 51
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Cement Mason
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[52] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 52
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Commercial Diver
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[53] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 53
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Concrete Polisher
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[54] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 54
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Drywall Applicator Specialist
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[55] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 55
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Electrical Worker
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[56] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 56
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Elevator Constructor
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[57] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 57
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Flagger
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[58] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 58
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Glazier
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[59] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 59
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Hazardous Waste Cleanup
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[60] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 60
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => HVAC
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[61] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 61
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[64] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 64
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Laborer
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[65] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 65
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Landscaper
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[66] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 66
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Lather
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[67] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 67
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Lead Abatement Worker
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[68] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 68
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Maintenance Worker
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[69] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 69
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Millwright
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[70] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 70
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Operating Engineer
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[71] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 71
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Painter
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[72] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 72
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Paper Hanger
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[73] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 73
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => PCC/Restoration
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[74] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 74
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Pile Driver
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[75] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 75
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Plasterer
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[76] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 76
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[77] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 77
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Refractory Worker
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[63] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 63
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[78] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 78
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[79] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 79
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Scaffold Erector
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[80] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 80
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[81] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 81
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Sprinkler Fitter
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[82] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 82
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Stonemason
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[62] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 62
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Structural Ironworker
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[83] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 83
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Terrazzo Worker
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[84] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 84
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Tile Setter
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[85] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 85
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Truck Driver
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[86] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 86
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Welder
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[87] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 87
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[88] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 88
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Demolition
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[89] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 89
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Disasters
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[91] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 91
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Heavy & Highway
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[90] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 90
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Industrial
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[92] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 92
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[93] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 93
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Renovations
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[94] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 94
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Residential
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[95] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 95
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Underground
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
)
[categories_initialized:protected] => 1
[mapped_items:protected] =>
[content:protected] =>
[files:protected] =>
[language:protected] => Language Object
(
[id:protected] => 1
[code:protected] => en
[name:protected] => English
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[old_record:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 4426
[old_id:protected] =>
[elcosh_id:protected] => d001656
[type:protected] => document
[display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links)
[user_id:protected] => 0
[language_id:protected] => 1
[tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar
[priority_id:protected] => 1
[title:protected] => Construction Dive -- DeWalt's Jobsite Pro headphones recalled for fire hazards
[total_pages:protected] => 1
[billed_pages:protected] => 1
[publication_number:protected] =>
[part_of:protected] =>
[keywords:protected] => DeWalt, Fire Hazards, recall, headphones
[comments:protected] =>
[summary:protected] => A recall notice by the United States Consumer Product Safety Commission affects over 300,000 DeWalt Jobsite Pro Headphones. The recall is a result of a malfunction that can cause earbuds to overheat while charging or during use, leading to fire and burn hazards.
[transition_comments:protected] =>
[external_link:protected] => https://www.constructiondive.com/news/dewalts-jobsite-pro-headphones-recalled-for-fire-hazards/611248/?utm_source=Sailthru&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Issue:%202021-12-10%20Construction%20Dive%20Newsletter%20%5Bissue:38532%5D&utm_term=Construction%20Dive
[consol_link:protected] =>
[more_like_this:protected] =>
[permission_given_by:protected] =>
[published:protected] => T
[billable:protected] => F
[img_name:protected] =>
[img_ext:protected] =>
[img_width:protected] =>
[img_height:protected] =>
[img_credit:protected] =>
[img_practice:protected] =>
[vid_source_id:protected] =>
[vid_running_time:protected] =>
[vid_intended_audience:protected] =>
[vid_acquisition_info:protected] =>
[vid_cost:protected] =>
[vid_producer:protected] =>
[vid_filename:protected] =>
[vid_filename_downloadable:protected] =>
[date_summary:protected] =>
[date_permission_requested:protected] =>
[date_permission_received:protected] =>
[date_review_needed:protected] =>
[date_received:protected] => 12/13/21
[date_completed:protected] => 12/13/21
[date_billed:protected] =>
[date_modified:protected] => 12/13/21
[collBokExports:protected] =>
[lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] =>
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
)
)
[new_images] => Array
(
[0] => Search_Result Object
(
[title] => Morning Toolbox Talk
[image] => /record/images/4003-p.jpg
[blurb] => This photo is from an early morning toolbox talk on a construction job in Mclean, Virginia. It is being delivered in English and Spanish....
[category] => Array
(
[0] => 20
[1] => 51
[2] => 57
[3] => 64
[4] => 70
[5] => 63
[6] => 78
[7] => 82
[8] => 62
[9] => 87
[10] => 88
[11] => 89
[12] => 91
[13] => 90
[14] => 93
[15] => 94
[16] => 97
)
[labels] => Array
(
[0] => Safety Culture
[1] => Work Environment
[2] => Hazards
[3] => Cement Mason
[4] => Trades
[5] => Flagger
[7] => Laborer
[9] => Operating Engineer
[11] => Reinforcing Ironworker
[13] => Roofer/Waterproofer
[15] => Stonemason
[17] => Structural Ironworker
[19] => Commercial & Institutional
[20] => Jobsites
[21] => Demolition
[23] => Disasters
[25] => Heavy & Highway
[27] => Industrial
[29] => Renovations
[31] => Residential
[33] => Images
[34] => Media
[35] => Media & Documents
)
[type] => Images
[sub_category] =>
[url] => /image/4003/i002691/Morning%2BToolbox%2BTalk.html
[item:protected] => ImageRecord Object
(
[records:protected] => Array
(
)
[recordId:protected] =>
[searchWordClass:protected] =>
[searchWordPeerClass:protected] =>
[bok_record:protected] =>
[authors:protected] =>
[organizations:protected] =>
[collections:protected] =>
[categories:protected] => Array
(
[20] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 20
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 7
[label:protected] => Safety Culture
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[51] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 51
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Cement Mason
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[57] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 57
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Flagger
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[64] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 64
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Laborer
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[70] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 70
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Operating Engineer
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[63] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 63
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[78] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 78
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[82] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 82
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Stonemason
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[62] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 62
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Structural Ironworker
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[87] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 87
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[88] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 88
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Demolition
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[89] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 89
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Disasters
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[91] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 91
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Heavy & Highway
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[90] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 90
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Industrial
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[93] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 93
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Renovations
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[94] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 94
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Residential
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[97] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 97
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 5
[label:protected] => Images
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
)
[categories_initialized:protected] => 1
[mapped_items:protected] =>
[content:protected] =>
[files:protected] =>
[language:protected] => Language Object
(
[id:protected] => 1
[code:protected] => en
[name:protected] => English
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[old_record:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 4003
[old_id:protected] =>
[elcosh_id:protected] => i002691
[type:protected] => image
[display_type:protected] => Image
[user_id:protected] => 0
[language_id:protected] => 1
[tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy
[priority_id:protected] => 1
[title:protected] => Morning Toolbox Talk
[total_pages:protected] => 0
[billed_pages:protected] => 0
[publication_number:protected] =>
[part_of:protected] =>
[keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, Spanish, bilingual
[comments:protected] =>
[summary:protected] => This photo is from an early morning toolbox talk on a construction job in Mclean, Virginia. It is being delivered in English and Spanish.
[transition_comments:protected] =>
[external_link:protected] =>
[consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html
[more_like_this:protected] => d001285,d001304,c000079
[permission_given_by:protected] =>
[published:protected] => T
[billable:protected] => F
[img_name:protected] =>
[img_ext:protected] => jpg
[img_width:protected] =>
[img_height:protected] =>
[img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction
[img_practice:protected] => good
[vid_source_id:protected] =>
[vid_running_time:protected] =>
[vid_intended_audience:protected] =>
[vid_acquisition_info:protected] =>
[vid_cost:protected] =>
[vid_producer:protected] =>
[vid_filename:protected] =>
[vid_filename_downloadable:protected] =>
[date_summary:protected] => November 2015
[date_permission_requested:protected] =>
[date_permission_received:protected] =>
[date_review_needed:protected] =>
[date_received:protected] => 03/02/16
[date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16
[date_billed:protected] =>
[date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16
[collBokExports:protected] =>
[lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] =>
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
)
[1] => Search_Result Object
(
[title] => Toolbox talk - crew view
[image] => /record/images/4005-p.jpg
[blurb] => Photo of crew listening to a toolbox safety talk before starting work....
[category] => Array
(
[0] => 97
[1] => 20
[2] => 47
[3] => 49
[4] => 51
[5] => 55
[6] => 61
[7] => 64
[8] => 71
[9] => 75
[10] => 63
[11] => 79
[12] => 62
[13] => 87
[14] => 88
[15] => 91
[16] => 90
[17] => 93
[18] => 94
[19] => 95
)
[labels] => Array
(
[0] => Images
[1] => Media
[2] => Media & Documents
[3] => Safety Culture
[4] => Work Environment
[5] => Hazards
[6] => Bricklayer
[7] => Trades
[8] => Carpenter
[10] => Cement Mason
[12] => Electrical Worker
[14] => Interior Systems Carpenter
[16] => Laborer
[18] => Painter
[20] => Plasterer
[22] => Reinforcing Ironworker
[24] => Scaffold Erector
[26] => Structural Ironworker
[28] => Commercial & Institutional
[29] => Jobsites
[30] => Demolition
[32] => Heavy & Highway
[34] => Industrial
[36] => Renovations
[38] => Residential
[40] => Underground
)
[type] => Images
[sub_category] =>
[url] => /image/4005/i002692/Toolbox%2Btalk%2B-%2Bcrew%2Bview.html
[item:protected] => ImageRecord Object
(
[records:protected] => Array
(
)
[recordId:protected] =>
[searchWordClass:protected] =>
[searchWordPeerClass:protected] =>
[bok_record:protected] =>
[authors:protected] =>
[organizations:protected] =>
[collections:protected] =>
[categories:protected] => Array
(
[97] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 97
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 5
[label:protected] => Images
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[20] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 20
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 7
[label:protected] => Safety Culture
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[47] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 47
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Bricklayer
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[49] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 49
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Carpenter
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[51] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 51
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Cement Mason
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[55] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 55
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Electrical Worker
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[61] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 61
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[64] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 64
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Laborer
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[71] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 71
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Painter
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[75] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 75
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Plasterer
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[63] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 63
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[79] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 79
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Scaffold Erector
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[62] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 62
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Structural Ironworker
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[87] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 87
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[88] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 88
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Demolition
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[91] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 91
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Heavy & Highway
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[90] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 90
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Industrial
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[93] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 93
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Renovations
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[94] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 94
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Residential
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[95] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 95
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Underground
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
)
[categories_initialized:protected] => 1
[mapped_items:protected] =>
[content:protected] =>
[files:protected] =>
[language:protected] => Language Object
(
[id:protected] => 1
[code:protected] => en
[name:protected] => English
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[old_record:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 4005
[old_id:protected] =>
[elcosh_id:protected] => i002692
[type:protected] => image
[display_type:protected] => Image
[user_id:protected] => 0
[language_id:protected] => 1
[tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy
[priority_id:protected] => 1
[title:protected] => Toolbox talk - crew view
[total_pages:protected] => 0
[billed_pages:protected] => 0
[publication_number:protected] =>
[part_of:protected] =>
[keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, safety talk, Spanish
[comments:protected] =>
[summary:protected] => Photo of crew listening to a toolbox safety talk before starting work.
[transition_comments:protected] =>
[external_link:protected] =>
[consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html
[more_like_this:protected] => i002691,d001269, c000079, d001285
[permission_given_by:protected] =>
[published:protected] => T
[billable:protected] => F
[img_name:protected] =>
[img_ext:protected] => jpg
[img_width:protected] =>
[img_height:protected] =>
[img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction
[img_practice:protected] => good
[vid_source_id:protected] =>
[vid_running_time:protected] =>
[vid_intended_audience:protected] =>
[vid_acquisition_info:protected] =>
[vid_cost:protected] =>
[vid_producer:protected] =>
[vid_filename:protected] =>
[vid_filename_downloadable:protected] =>
[date_summary:protected] => November 2015
[date_permission_requested:protected] =>
[date_permission_received:protected] =>
[date_review_needed:protected] =>
[date_received:protected] => 03/02/16
[date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16
[date_billed:protected] =>
[date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16
[collBokExports:protected] =>
[lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] =>
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
)
[2] => Search_Result Object
(
[title] => Toolbox talk - long shot
[image] => /record/images/4006-p.jpg
[blurb] => This crew gathered every morning before starting work to discuss a new safety topic....
[category] => Array
(
[0] => 20
[1] => 47
[2] => 49
[3] => 51
[4] => 55
[5] => 64
[6] => 68
[7] => 75
[8] => 76
[9] => 63
[10] => 78
[11] => 79
[12] => 82
[13] => 62
[14] => 87
[15] => 88
[16] => 91
[17] => 90
[18] => 93
[19] => 94
[20] => 95
[21] => 97
)
[labels] => Array
(
[0] => Safety Culture
[1] => Work Environment
[2] => Hazards
[3] => Bricklayer
[4] => Trades
[5] => Carpenter
[7] => Cement Mason
[9] => Electrical Worker
[11] => Laborer
[13] => Maintenance Worker
[15] => Plasterer
[17] => Plumber/Pipefitter
[19] => Reinforcing Ironworker
[21] => Roofer/Waterproofer
[23] => Scaffold Erector
[25] => Stonemason
[27] => Structural Ironworker
[29] => Commercial & Institutional
[30] => Jobsites
[31] => Demolition
[33] => Heavy & Highway
[35] => Industrial
[37] => Renovations
[39] => Residential
[41] => Underground
[43] => Images
[44] => Media
[45] => Media & Documents
)
[type] => Images
[sub_category] =>
[url] => /image/4006/i002693/Toolbox%2Btalk%2B-%2Blong%2Bshot.html
[item:protected] => ImageRecord Object
(
[records:protected] => Array
(
)
[recordId:protected] =>
[searchWordClass:protected] =>
[searchWordPeerClass:protected] =>
[bok_record:protected] =>
[authors:protected] =>
[organizations:protected] =>
[collections:protected] =>
[categories:protected] => Array
(
[20] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 20
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 7
[label:protected] => Safety Culture
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[47] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 47
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Bricklayer
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[49] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 49
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Carpenter
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[51] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 51
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Cement Mason
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[55] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 55
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Electrical Worker
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[64] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 64
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Laborer
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[68] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 68
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Maintenance Worker
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[75] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 75
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Plasterer
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[76] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 76
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[63] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 63
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[78] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 78
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[79] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 79
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Scaffold Erector
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[82] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 82
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Stonemason
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[62] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 62
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Structural Ironworker
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[87] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 87
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[88] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 88
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Demolition
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[91] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 91
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Heavy & Highway
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[90] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 90
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Industrial
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[93] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 93
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Renovations
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[94] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 94
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Residential
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[95] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 95
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Underground
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[97] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 97
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 5
[label:protected] => Images
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
)
[categories_initialized:protected] => 1
[mapped_items:protected] =>
[content:protected] =>
[files:protected] =>
[language:protected] => Language Object
(
[id:protected] => 1
[code:protected] => en
[name:protected] => English
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[old_record:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 4006
[old_id:protected] =>
[elcosh_id:protected] => i002693
[type:protected] => image
[display_type:protected] => Image
[user_id:protected] => 0
[language_id:protected] => 1
[tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy
[priority_id:protected] => 1
[title:protected] => Toolbox talk - long shot
[total_pages:protected] => 0
[billed_pages:protected] => 0
[publication_number:protected] =>
[part_of:protected] =>
[keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, safety minute
[comments:protected] =>
[summary:protected] => This crew gathered every morning before starting work to discuss a new safety topic.
[transition_comments:protected] =>
[external_link:protected] =>
[consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html
[more_like_this:protected] => i002691,i002692,d001269,d000527
[permission_given_by:protected] =>
[published:protected] => T
[billable:protected] => F
[img_name:protected] =>
[img_ext:protected] => jpg
[img_width:protected] =>
[img_height:protected] =>
[img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction
[img_practice:protected] => good
[vid_source_id:protected] =>
[vid_running_time:protected] =>
[vid_intended_audience:protected] =>
[vid_acquisition_info:protected] =>
[vid_cost:protected] =>
[vid_producer:protected] =>
[vid_filename:protected] =>
[vid_filename_downloadable:protected] =>
[date_summary:protected] => November 2015
[date_permission_requested:protected] =>
[date_permission_received:protected] =>
[date_review_needed:protected] =>
[date_received:protected] => 03/02/16
[date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16
[date_billed:protected] =>
[date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16
[collBokExports:protected] =>
[lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] =>
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
)
[3] => Search_Result Object
(
[title] => Safety officer discussing ongoing project with marketing coordinator
[image] => /record/images/4014-p.jpg
[blurb] => The safety officer (left) points out the good safety practices on this project that reflect well on the firm and may influence future clients....
[category] => Array
(
[0] => 97
[1] => 20
[2] => 46
[3] => 47
[4] => 49
[5] => 50
[6] => 51
[7] => 54
[8] => 55
[9] => 58
[10] => 60
[11] => 61
[12] => 64
[13] => 71
[14] => 75
[15] => 76
[16] => 63
[17] => 79
[18] => 80
[19] => 82
[20] => 62
[21] => 83
[22] => 87
[23] => 91
[24] => 90
[25] => 93
[26] => 94
)
[labels] => Array
(
[0] => Images
[1] => Media
[2] => Media & Documents
[3] => Safety Culture
[4] => Work Environment
[5] => Hazards
[6] => Boilermaker
[7] => Trades
[8] => Bricklayer
[10] => Carpenter
[12] => Carpet Layer
[14] => Cement Mason
[16] => Drywall Applicator Specialist
[18] => Electrical Worker
[20] => Glazier
[22] => HVAC
[24] => Interior Systems Carpenter
[26] => Laborer
[28] => Painter
[30] => Plasterer
[32] => Plumber/Pipefitter
[34] => Reinforcing Ironworker
[36] => Scaffold Erector
[38] => Sheetmetal Worker
[40] => Stonemason
[42] => Structural Ironworker
[44] => Terrazzo Worker
[46] => Commercial & Institutional
[47] => Jobsites
[48] => Heavy & Highway
[50] => Industrial
[52] => Renovations
[54] => Residential
)
[type] => Images
[sub_category] =>
[url] => /image/4014/i002700/Safety%2Bofficer%2Bdiscussing%2Bongoing%2Bproject%2Bwith%2Bmarketing%2Bcoordinator.html
[item:protected] => ImageRecord Object
(
[records:protected] => Array
(
)
[recordId:protected] =>
[searchWordClass:protected] =>
[searchWordPeerClass:protected] =>
[bok_record:protected] =>
[authors:protected] =>
[organizations:protected] =>
[collections:protected] =>
[categories:protected] => Array
(
[97] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 97
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 5
[label:protected] => Images
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[20] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 20
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 7
[label:protected] => Safety Culture
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[46] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 46
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Boilermaker
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[47] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 47
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Bricklayer
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[49] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 49
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Carpenter
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[50] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 50
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Carpet Layer
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[51] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 51
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Cement Mason
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[54] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 54
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Drywall Applicator Specialist
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[55] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 55
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Electrical Worker
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[58] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 58
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Glazier
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[60] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 60
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => HVAC
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[61] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 61
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[64] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 64
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Laborer
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[71] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 71
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Painter
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[75] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 75
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Plasterer
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[76] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 76
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[63] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 63
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[79] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 79
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Scaffold Erector
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[80] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 80
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[82] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 82
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Stonemason
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[62] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 62
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Structural Ironworker
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[83] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 83
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Terrazzo Worker
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[87] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 87
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[91] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 91
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Heavy & Highway
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[90] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 90
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Industrial
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[93] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 93
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Renovations
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[94] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 94
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Residential
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
)
[categories_initialized:protected] => 1
[mapped_items:protected] =>
[content:protected] =>
[files:protected] =>
[language:protected] => Language Object
(
[id:protected] => 1
[code:protected] => en
[name:protected] => English
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[old_record:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 4014
[old_id:protected] =>
[elcosh_id:protected] => i002700
[type:protected] => image
[display_type:protected] => Image
[user_id:protected] => 0
[language_id:protected] => 1
[tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy
[priority_id:protected] => 1
[title:protected] => Safety officer discussing ongoing project with marketing coordinator
[total_pages:protected] => 0
[billed_pages:protected] => 0
[publication_number:protected] =>
[part_of:protected] =>
[keywords:protected] => Latino, safety officer, safety culture
[comments:protected] =>
[summary:protected] => The safety officer (left) points out the good safety practices on this project that reflect well on the firm and may influence future clients.
[transition_comments:protected] =>
[external_link:protected] =>
[consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/index.php
[more_like_this:protected] => d000989,d001351,d001362,d000652, d001101, d000931, d001395
[permission_given_by:protected] =>
[published:protected] => T
[billable:protected] => F
[img_name:protected] =>
[img_ext:protected] => jpg
[img_width:protected] =>
[img_height:protected] =>
[img_credit:protected] => Hoar Construction, Photo by Neil Lippy
[img_practice:protected] => good
[vid_source_id:protected] =>
[vid_running_time:protected] =>
[vid_intended_audience:protected] =>
[vid_acquisition_info:protected] =>
[vid_cost:protected] =>
[vid_producer:protected] =>
[vid_filename:protected] =>
[vid_filename_downloadable:protected] =>
[date_summary:protected] => November 2015
[date_permission_requested:protected] =>
[date_permission_received:protected] =>
[date_review_needed:protected] =>
[date_received:protected] => 03/02/16
[date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16
[date_billed:protected] =>
[date_modified:protected] => 01/30/23
[collBokExports:protected] =>
[lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] =>
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
)
[4] => Search_Result Object
(
[title] => Scaffolding at top of large column
[image] => /record/images/3994-p.jpg
[blurb] => This shot shows innovative guarding around the top of a large concrete column in the base of a high rise structure going up....
[category] => Array
(
[0] => 15
[1] => 21
[2] => 47
[3] => 51
[4] => 63
[5] => 78
[6] => 79
[7] => 80
[8] => 62
[9] => 87
[10] => 97
[11] => 56
[12] => 64
[13] => 74
)
[labels] => Array
(
[0] => Falls
[1] => Work Environment
[2] => Hazards
[3] => Scaffolds
[6] => Bricklayer
[7] => Trades
[8] => Cement Mason
[10] => Reinforcing Ironworker
[12] => Roofer/Waterproofer
[14] => Scaffold Erector
[16] => Sheetmetal Worker
[18] => Structural Ironworker
[20] => Commercial & Institutional
[21] => Jobsites
[22] => Images
[23] => Media
[24] => Media & Documents
[25] => Elevator Constructor
[27] => Laborer
[29] => Pile Driver
)
[type] => Images
[sub_category] =>
[url] => /image/3994/i002689/Scaffolding%2Bat%2Btop%2Bof%2Blarge%2Bcolumn.html
[item:protected] => ImageRecord Object
(
[records:protected] => Array
(
)
[recordId:protected] =>
[searchWordClass:protected] =>
[searchWordPeerClass:protected] =>
[bok_record:protected] =>
[authors:protected] =>
[organizations:protected] =>
[collections:protected] =>
[categories:protected] => Array
(
[15] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 15
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 7
[label:protected] => Falls
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[21] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 21
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 7
[label:protected] => Scaffolds
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[47] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 47
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Bricklayer
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[51] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 51
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Cement Mason
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[63] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 63
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[78] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 78
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[79] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 79
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Scaffold Erector
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[80] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 80
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[62] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 62
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Structural Ironworker
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[87] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 87
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[97] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 97
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 5
[label:protected] => Images
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[56] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 56
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Elevator Constructor
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[64] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 64
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Laborer
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[74] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 74
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Pile Driver
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
)
[categories_initialized:protected] => 1
[mapped_items:protected] =>
[content:protected] =>
[files:protected] =>
[language:protected] => Language Object
(
[id:protected] => 1
[code:protected] => en
[name:protected] => English
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[old_record:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 3994
[old_id:protected] =>
[elcosh_id:protected] => i002689
[type:protected] => image
[display_type:protected] => Image
[user_id:protected] => 0
[language_id:protected] => 1
[tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy
[priority_id:protected] => 1
[title:protected] => Scaffolding at top of large column
[total_pages:protected] => 0
[billed_pages:protected] => 0
[publication_number:protected] =>
[part_of:protected] =>
[keywords:protected] => Guardrail, railing, fall prevention, falls
[comments:protected] =>
[summary:protected] => This shot shows innovative guarding around the top of a large concrete column in the base of a high rise structure going up.
[transition_comments:protected] =>
[external_link:protected] =>
[consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/8/adjustable-tower-scaffold.html
[more_like_this:protected] => c1002680,i002662,d000608,d001255
[permission_given_by:protected] =>
[published:protected] => T
[billable:protected] => F
[img_name:protected] =>
[img_ext:protected] => jpg
[img_width:protected] =>
[img_height:protected] =>
[img_credit:protected] => Photo by Pam Susi
[img_practice:protected] => good
[vid_source_id:protected] =>
[vid_running_time:protected] =>
[vid_intended_audience:protected] =>
[vid_acquisition_info:protected] =>
[vid_cost:protected] =>
[vid_producer:protected] =>
[vid_filename:protected] =>
[vid_filename_downloadable:protected] =>
[date_summary:protected] => January 2016
[date_permission_requested:protected] =>
[date_permission_received:protected] =>
[date_review_needed:protected] =>
[date_received:protected] => 02/01/16
[date_completed:protected] => 02/01/16
[date_billed:protected] =>
[date_modified:protected] => 02/01/16
[collBokExports:protected] =>
[lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] =>
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
)
[5] => Search_Result Object
(
[title] => Construction bracing
[image] => /record/images/3995-p.jpg
[blurb] => This shows structural support that prevents collapses during construction....
[category] => Array
(
[0] => 12
[1] => 15
[2] => 21
[3] => 49
[4] => 51
[5] => 55
[6] => 56
[7] => 60
[8] => 64
[9] => 68
[10] => 74
[11] => 63
[12] => 78
[13] => 79
[14] => 80
[15] => 62
[16] => 87
[17] => 90
[18] => 97
)
[labels] => Array
(
[0] => Crushed/Struck By
[1] => Work Environment
[2] => Hazards
[3] => Falls
[6] => Scaffolds
[9] => Carpenter
[10] => Trades
[11] => Cement Mason
[13] => Electrical Worker
[15] => Elevator Constructor
[17] => HVAC
[19] => Laborer
[21] => Maintenance Worker
[23] => Pile Driver
[25] => Reinforcing Ironworker
[27] => Roofer/Waterproofer
[29] => Scaffold Erector
[31] => Sheetmetal Worker
[33] => Structural Ironworker
[35] => Commercial & Institutional
[36] => Jobsites
[37] => Industrial
[39] => Images
[40] => Media
[41] => Media & Documents
)
[type] => Images
[sub_category] =>
[url] => /image/3995/i002690/Construction%2Bbracing.html
[item:protected] => ImageRecord Object
(
[records:protected] => Array
(
)
[recordId:protected] =>
[searchWordClass:protected] =>
[searchWordPeerClass:protected] =>
[bok_record:protected] =>
[authors:protected] =>
[organizations:protected] =>
[collections:protected] =>
[categories:protected] => Array
(
[12] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 12
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 7
[label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[15] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 15
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 7
[label:protected] => Falls
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[21] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 21
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 7
[label:protected] => Scaffolds
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[49] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 49
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Carpenter
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[51] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 51
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Cement Mason
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[55] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 55
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Electrical Worker
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[56] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 56
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Elevator Constructor
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[60] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 60
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => HVAC
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[64] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 64
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Laborer
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[68] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 68
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Maintenance Worker
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[74] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 74
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Pile Driver
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[63] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 63
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[78] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 78
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[79] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 79
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Scaffold Erector
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[80] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 80
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[62] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 62
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 2
[label:protected] => Structural Ironworker
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[87] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 87
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[90] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 90
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 3
[label:protected] => Industrial
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[97] => Category Object
(
[languages:protected] =>
[bok_resources:protected] =>
[bok_topics:protected] =>
[bok_keywords:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 97
[type:protected] => category
[parent:protected] => 5
[label:protected] => Images
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
)
[categories_initialized:protected] => 1
[mapped_items:protected] =>
[content:protected] =>
[files:protected] =>
[language:protected] => Language Object
(
[id:protected] => 1
[code:protected] => en
[name:protected] => English
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[old_record:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 3995
[old_id:protected] =>
[elcosh_id:protected] => i002690
[type:protected] => image
[display_type:protected] => Image
[user_id:protected] => 0
[language_id:protected] => 1
[tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy
[priority_id:protected] => 1
[title:protected] => Construction bracing
[total_pages:protected] => 0
[billed_pages:protected] => 0
[publication_number:protected] =>
[part_of:protected] =>
[keywords:protected] => Bracing, support, scaffold
[comments:protected] =>
[summary:protected] => This shows structural support that prevents collapses during construction.
[transition_comments:protected] =>
[external_link:protected] =>
[consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/8/adjustable-tower-scaffold.html
[more_like_this:protected] => i002660
[permission_given_by:protected] =>
[published:protected] => T
[billable:protected] => F
[img_name:protected] =>
[img_ext:protected] => jpg
[img_width:protected] =>
[img_height:protected] =>
[img_credit:protected] => Photo by Pam Susi
[img_practice:protected] => good
[vid_source_id:protected] =>
[vid_running_time:protected] =>
[vid_intended_audience:protected] =>
[vid_acquisition_info:protected] =>
[vid_cost:protected] =>
[vid_producer:protected] =>
[vid_filename:protected] =>
[vid_filename_downloadable:protected] =>
[date_summary:protected] => January 2016
[date_permission_requested:protected] =>
[date_permission_received:protected] =>
[date_review_needed:protected] =>
[date_received:protected] => 02/01/16
[date_completed:protected] => 02/01/16
[date_billed:protected] =>
[date_modified:protected] => 02/01/16
[collBokExports:protected] =>
[lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] =>
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
)
)
[preview_mode] =>
[description] => The results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit.
[keywords] => tuckpointing, HEPA vacuum, dust control, LEV, local exhaust ventilation, silica
[related_items] => Array
(
[Research Reports] => Array
(
[0] => DocumentRecord Object
(
[records:protected] => Array
(
)
[recordId:protected] =>
[searchWordClass:protected] =>
[searchWordPeerClass:protected] =>
[bok_record:protected] =>
[authors:protected] =>
[organizations:protected] =>
[collections:protected] =>
[categories:protected] =>
[categories_initialized:protected] =>
[mapped_items:protected] =>
[content:protected] =>
[files:protected] =>
[language:protected] => Language Object
(
[id:protected] => 1
[code:protected] => en
[name:protected] => English
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[old_record:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 1874
[old_id:protected] => 722
[elcosh_id:protected] => d000683
[type:protected] => document
[display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF
[user_id:protected] => 0
[language_id:protected] => 1
[tagging_id:protected] => Sharon Garber/COD
[priority_id:protected] => 1
[title:protected] => Protecting Tuckpointing Workers from Silica Dust: Draft Recommendations for a Ventilated Grinder
[total_pages:protected] => 12
[billed_pages:protected] => 12
[publication_number:protected] =>
[part_of:protected] =>
[keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, vacuum, grinder, mortar, respirator, OSHA, NIOSH, exhaust, Heitbrink, tuckpointer, silica, masonry, dust, silicosis, LEV
[comments:protected] =>
[summary:protected] => Describes draft recommendations for use of ventilated grinder to reduce dust during tuckpointing and describes field trials using these devices.
[transition_comments:protected] =>
[external_link:protected] =>
[consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/hazard/67/chip-scrape-and-grind-surfaces-or-joints-silica.html
[more_like_this:protected] => d001201,d000292,d000293,d000658
[permission_given_by:protected] =>
[published:protected] => T
[billable:protected] => F
[img_name:protected] =>
[img_ext:protected] =>
[img_width:protected] =>
[img_height:protected] =>
[img_credit:protected] =>
[img_practice:protected] =>
[vid_source_id:protected] =>
[vid_running_time:protected] =>
[vid_intended_audience:protected] =>
[vid_acquisition_info:protected] =>
[vid_cost:protected] =>
[vid_producer:protected] =>
[vid_filename:protected] =>
[vid_filename_downloadable:protected] =>
[date_summary:protected] => January 2005
[date_permission_requested:protected] =>
[date_permission_received:protected] =>
[date_review_needed:protected] =>
[date_received:protected] => 02/27/05
[date_completed:protected] => 04/26/05
[date_billed:protected] =>
[date_modified:protected] => 03/20/13
[collBokExports:protected] =>
[lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] =>
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[1] => DocumentRecord Object
(
[records:protected] => Array
(
)
[recordId:protected] =>
[searchWordClass:protected] =>
[searchWordPeerClass:protected] =>
[bok_record:protected] =>
[authors:protected] =>
[organizations:protected] =>
[collections:protected] =>
[categories:protected] =>
[categories_initialized:protected] =>
[mapped_items:protected] =>
[content:protected] =>
[files:protected] =>
[language:protected] => Language Object
(
[id:protected] => 1
[code:protected] => en
[name:protected] => English
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[old_record:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 1940
[old_id:protected] => 909
[elcosh_id:protected] => d000863
[type:protected] => document
[display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF
[user_id:protected] => 0
[language_id:protected] => 1
[tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta
[priority_id:protected] => 1
[title:protected] => Workplace Solutions: Control of Hazardous Dust During Tuckpointing
[total_pages:protected] => 4
[billed_pages:protected] => 4
[publication_number:protected] =>
[part_of:protected] =>
[keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, silica, dust, tuckpoint, grinder, masonry restoration, mortar, vacuum
[comments:protected] =>
[summary:protected] => A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust.
[transition_comments:protected] =>
[external_link:protected] =>
[consol_link:protected] =>
[more_like_this:protected] => d000819,d000820,d000730,d001201
[permission_given_by:protected] =>
[published:protected] => T
[billable:protected] => F
[img_name:protected] =>
[img_ext:protected] =>
[img_width:protected] =>
[img_height:protected] =>
[img_credit:protected] =>
[img_practice:protected] =>
[vid_source_id:protected] =>
[vid_running_time:protected] =>
[vid_intended_audience:protected] =>
[vid_acquisition_info:protected] =>
[vid_cost:protected] =>
[vid_producer:protected] =>
[vid_filename:protected] =>
[vid_filename_downloadable:protected] =>
[date_summary:protected] => 2008
[date_permission_requested:protected] =>
[date_permission_received:protected] =>
[date_review_needed:protected] =>
[date_received:protected] => 10/24/08
[date_completed:protected] => 02/05/09
[date_billed:protected] =>
[date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13
[collBokExports:protected] =>
[lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] =>
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[2] => DocumentRecord Object
(
[records:protected] => Array
(
)
[recordId:protected] =>
[searchWordClass:protected] =>
[searchWordPeerClass:protected] =>
[bok_record:protected] =>
[authors:protected] =>
[organizations:protected] =>
[collections:protected] =>
[categories:protected] =>
[categories_initialized:protected] =>
[mapped_items:protected] =>
[content:protected] =>
[files:protected] =>
[language:protected] => Language Object
(
[id:protected] => 1
[code:protected] => en
[name:protected] => English
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[old_record:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 3899
[old_id:protected] =>
[elcosh_id:protected] => d001342
[type:protected] => document
[display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF
[user_id:protected] => 23
[language_id:protected] => 1
[tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy
[priority_id:protected] => 1
[title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: Hilti VC40-U Vacuum with Hilti DC-EX Dust Guard and Hilti Grinder
[total_pages:protected] => 15
[billed_pages:protected] => 15
[publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP4
[part_of:protected] =>
[keywords:protected] => silica, tuckpointing, Hilti, local exhaust systems, LEV, shroud, quartz
[comments:protected] =>
[summary:protected] => This report describes the results of an evaluation of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Hilti VC40-U vacuum, a Hilti DC-EX shroud, and a Hilti DAG-500 grinder. Randomized trials with and without use of the dust control system were conducted in a controlled setting. Removing mortar with the Hilti grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 220 times the National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05mg/m3. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 97 percent. However, exposures measured during the use of the dust control system still exceeded the NIOSH REL.
[transition_comments:protected] =>
[external_link:protected] =>
[consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html
[more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342
[permission_given_by:protected] =>
[published:protected] => T
[billable:protected] => F
[img_name:protected] =>
[img_ext:protected] => png
[img_width:protected] =>
[img_height:protected] =>
[img_credit:protected] =>
[img_practice:protected] =>
[vid_source_id:protected] =>
[vid_running_time:protected] =>
[vid_intended_audience:protected] =>
[vid_acquisition_info:protected] =>
[vid_cost:protected] =>
[vid_producer:protected] =>
[vid_filename:protected] =>
[vid_filename_downloadable:protected] =>
[date_summary:protected] => December 1, 2014
[date_permission_requested:protected] =>
[date_permission_received:protected] =>
[date_review_needed:protected] =>
[date_received:protected] => 12/05/14
[date_completed:protected] => 02/04/15
[date_billed:protected] =>
[date_modified:protected] => 05/06/15
[collBokExports:protected] =>
[lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] =>
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
)
[Handouts] => Array
(
[0] => DocumentRecord Object
(
[records:protected] => Array
(
)
[recordId:protected] =>
[searchWordClass:protected] =>
[searchWordPeerClass:protected] =>
[bok_record:protected] =>
[authors:protected] =>
[organizations:protected] =>
[collections:protected] =>
[categories:protected] =>
[categories_initialized:protected] =>
[mapped_items:protected] =>
[content:protected] =>
[files:protected] =>
[language:protected] => Language Object
(
[id:protected] => 1
[code:protected] => en
[name:protected] => English
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[old_record:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 3656
[old_id:protected] =>
[elcosh_id:protected] => d001198
[type:protected] => document
[display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF
[user_id:protected] => 24
[language_id:protected] => 1
[tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy
[priority_id:protected] => 1
[title:protected] => Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction While Doing Tuckpointing/Mortar Removal
[total_pages:protected] => 2
[billed_pages:protected] => 2
[publication_number:protected] => DSG FS-3632
[part_of:protected] =>
[keywords:protected] => Brick, block, tuckpointing, silica, local exhaust ventilation, LEV, masonry
[comments:protected] =>
[summary:protected] => Tuckpointing creates some of the greatest exposures to silica in construction. This OSHA factsheet provides guidance on how to greatly reduce these exposures through the use of local exhaust ventilation.
[transition_comments:protected] =>
[external_link:protected] =>
[consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html
[more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863, d001201
[permission_given_by:protected] =>
[published:protected] => T
[billable:protected] => F
[img_name:protected] =>
[img_ext:protected] => jpg
[img_width:protected] =>
[img_height:protected] =>
[img_credit:protected] =>
[img_practice:protected] =>
[vid_source_id:protected] =>
[vid_running_time:protected] =>
[vid_intended_audience:protected] =>
[vid_acquisition_info:protected] =>
[vid_cost:protected] =>
[vid_producer:protected] =>
[vid_filename:protected] =>
[vid_filename_downloadable:protected] =>
[date_summary:protected] => February 2013
[date_permission_requested:protected] =>
[date_permission_received:protected] =>
[date_review_needed:protected] =>
[date_received:protected] => 03/04/13
[date_completed:protected] => 03/27/13
[date_billed:protected] =>
[date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13
[collBokExports:protected] =>
[lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] =>
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
)
)
[collections] => Array
(
[3913] =>
)
[record] => DocumentRecord Object
(
[records:protected] => Array
(
)
[recordId:protected] =>
[searchWordClass:protected] =>
[searchWordPeerClass:protected] =>
[bok_record:protected] =>
[authors:protected] => Array
(
[867] => Author Object
(
[id:protected] => 867
[organization_id:protected] => 0
[firstname:protected] => Michael
[lastname:protected] => Cooper
[address:protected] =>
[city:protected] =>
[province:protected] =>
[country:protected] =>
[postal_code:protected] =>
[department:protected] =>
[title:protected] =>
[phone:protected] =>
[fax:protected] =>
[email:protected] =>
[degree:protected] =>
[website:protected] =>
[about:protected] =>
[no_details:protected] => F
[date_received:protected] =>
[date_completed:protected] =>
[date_billed:protected] =>
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[481] => Author Object
(
[id:protected] => 481
[organization_id:protected] => 0
[firstname:protected] => Pam
[lastname:protected] => Susi
[address:protected] => 8484 Georgia Avenue, Suite 1000
[city:protected] => Silver Spring
[province:protected] => Maryland
[country:protected] => USA
[postal_code:protected] => 20910
[department:protected] =>
[title:protected] =>
[phone:protected] => 301-578-8500 ext.144
[fax:protected] => 301-578-8572
[email:protected] => plsusi@aol.com
[degree:protected] =>
[website:protected] => http://www.cpwr.com
[about:protected] =>
[no_details:protected] => F
[date_received:protected] => 2003-10-02
[date_completed:protected] => 2003-10-06
[date_billed:protected] => 2003-11-03
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
)
[organizations:protected] => Array
(
[1] => Organization Object
(
[id:protected] => 1
[elcosh_id:protected] => o000001
[user_id:protected] => 14
[province_id:protected] => 21
[country_id:protected] => 1
[title:protected] => CPWR - The Center for Construction Research and Training
[address:protected] => Suite 1000, 8484 Georgia Ave
[postal_code:protected] => 20910
[city:protected] => Silver Spring
[department:protected] =>
[phone:protected] => 301-578-8500
[fax:protected] => 301-578-8572
[email:protected] => cpwrwebsite@cpwr.com
[website:protected] => http://www.cpwr.com
[filename:protected] => o000001.gif
[about:protected] => CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training, developed, and continues to maintain/expand this website - The Electronic Library of Construction Occupational Safety and Health, www.elcosh.org. CPWR, formerly known as The Center to Protect Workers’ Rights, is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit research and training institution. Created by the Building and Construction Trades Department, AFL-CIO, CPWR serves as the research arm of the BCTD. Since the inception of its research agenda in 1990, CPWR has grown into a worldwide provider of safety and health information covering all aspects of the construction industry. CPWR launched eLCOSH in 2000, and the Spanish-language version of the site in 2001. CPWR also created, and continues to build, Construction Solutions - www.cpwrConstructionSolutions.org - a free, online database of construction hazards and ways to prevent, eliminate, or reduce them.
[comments:protected] =>
[logo_available:protected] => T
[no_details:protected] => F
[date_received:protected] => 2000-08-18
[date_completed:protected] => 2000-08-30
[date_billed:protected] => 2000-09-05
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
)
[collections:protected] => Array
(
[3913] =>
)
[categories:protected] =>
[categories_initialized:protected] =>
[mapped_items:protected] => Array
(
[1874] => DocumentRecord Object
(
[records:protected] => Array
(
)
[recordId:protected] =>
[searchWordClass:protected] =>
[searchWordPeerClass:protected] =>
[bok_record:protected] =>
[authors:protected] =>
[organizations:protected] =>
[collections:protected] =>
[categories:protected] =>
[categories_initialized:protected] =>
[mapped_items:protected] =>
[content:protected] =>
[files:protected] =>
[language:protected] =>
[old_record:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 1874
[old_id:protected] => 722
[elcosh_id:protected] => d000683
[type:protected] => document
[display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF
[user_id:protected] => 0
[language_id:protected] => 1
[tagging_id:protected] => Sharon Garber/COD
[priority_id:protected] => 1
[title:protected] => Protecting Tuckpointing Workers from Silica Dust: Draft Recommendations for a Ventilated Grinder
[total_pages:protected] => 12
[billed_pages:protected] => 12
[publication_number:protected] =>
[part_of:protected] =>
[keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, vacuum, grinder, mortar, respirator, OSHA, NIOSH, exhaust, Heitbrink, tuckpointer, silica, masonry, dust, silicosis, LEV
[comments:protected] =>
[summary:protected] => Describes draft recommendations for use of ventilated grinder to reduce dust during tuckpointing and describes field trials using these devices.
[transition_comments:protected] =>
[external_link:protected] =>
[consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/hazard/67/chip-scrape-and-grind-surfaces-or-joints-silica.html
[more_like_this:protected] => d001201,d000292,d000293,d000658
[permission_given_by:protected] =>
[published:protected] => T
[billable:protected] => F
[img_name:protected] =>
[img_ext:protected] =>
[img_width:protected] =>
[img_height:protected] =>
[img_credit:protected] =>
[img_practice:protected] =>
[vid_source_id:protected] =>
[vid_running_time:protected] =>
[vid_intended_audience:protected] =>
[vid_acquisition_info:protected] =>
[vid_cost:protected] =>
[vid_producer:protected] =>
[vid_filename:protected] =>
[vid_filename_downloadable:protected] =>
[date_summary:protected] => January 2005
[date_permission_requested:protected] =>
[date_permission_received:protected] =>
[date_review_needed:protected] =>
[date_received:protected] => 02/27/05
[date_completed:protected] => 04/26/05
[date_billed:protected] =>
[date_modified:protected] => 03/20/13
[collBokExports:protected] =>
[lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] =>
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[1940] => DocumentRecord Object
(
[records:protected] => Array
(
)
[recordId:protected] =>
[searchWordClass:protected] =>
[searchWordPeerClass:protected] =>
[bok_record:protected] =>
[authors:protected] =>
[organizations:protected] =>
[collections:protected] =>
[categories:protected] =>
[categories_initialized:protected] =>
[mapped_items:protected] =>
[content:protected] =>
[files:protected] =>
[language:protected] =>
[old_record:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 1940
[old_id:protected] => 909
[elcosh_id:protected] => d000863
[type:protected] => document
[display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF
[user_id:protected] => 0
[language_id:protected] => 1
[tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta
[priority_id:protected] => 1
[title:protected] => Workplace Solutions: Control of Hazardous Dust During Tuckpointing
[total_pages:protected] => 4
[billed_pages:protected] => 4
[publication_number:protected] =>
[part_of:protected] =>
[keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, silica, dust, tuckpoint, grinder, masonry restoration, mortar, vacuum
[comments:protected] =>
[summary:protected] => A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust.
[transition_comments:protected] =>
[external_link:protected] =>
[consol_link:protected] =>
[more_like_this:protected] => d000819,d000820,d000730,d001201
[permission_given_by:protected] =>
[published:protected] => T
[billable:protected] => F
[img_name:protected] =>
[img_ext:protected] =>
[img_width:protected] =>
[img_height:protected] =>
[img_credit:protected] =>
[img_practice:protected] =>
[vid_source_id:protected] =>
[vid_running_time:protected] =>
[vid_intended_audience:protected] =>
[vid_acquisition_info:protected] =>
[vid_cost:protected] =>
[vid_producer:protected] =>
[vid_filename:protected] =>
[vid_filename_downloadable:protected] =>
[date_summary:protected] => 2008
[date_permission_requested:protected] =>
[date_permission_received:protected] =>
[date_review_needed:protected] =>
[date_received:protected] => 10/24/08
[date_completed:protected] => 02/05/09
[date_billed:protected] =>
[date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13
[collBokExports:protected] =>
[lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] =>
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[2213] => DocumentRecord Object
(
[records:protected] => Array
(
)
[recordId:protected] =>
[searchWordClass:protected] =>
[searchWordPeerClass:protected] =>
[bok_record:protected] =>
[authors:protected] =>
[organizations:protected] =>
[collections:protected] =>
[categories:protected] =>
[categories_initialized:protected] =>
[mapped_items:protected] =>
[content:protected] =>
[files:protected] =>
[language:protected] =>
[old_record:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 2213
[old_id:protected] => 1090
[elcosh_id:protected] => d000863
[type:protected] => document
[display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF
[user_id:protected] =>
[language_id:protected] => 2
[tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta
[priority_id:protected] => 1
[title:protected] => Control del polvo peligroso que se genera durante los procesos de reparación de mortero
[total_pages:protected] => 4
[billed_pages:protected] => 4
[publication_number:protected] => 2008-126
[part_of:protected] =>
[keywords:protected] =>
[comments:protected] => http://www.cdc.gov/spanish/niosh/docs/wp-solutions/2008-126_sp/
[summary:protected] => A Workplace Solutions de NIOSH que resume un estudio de NIOSH sobre los riesgos de exposición cuando se reparan las estructuras y los métodos para controlar el polvo.
[A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust.]
[transition_comments:protected] =>
[external_link:protected] =>
[consol_link:protected] =>
[more_like_this:protected] => D000819,D000820,D000730,d000819
[permission_given_by:protected] =>
[published:protected] => T
[billable:protected] => F
[img_name:protected] =>
[img_ext:protected] =>
[img_width:protected] =>
[img_height:protected] =>
[img_credit:protected] =>
[img_practice:protected] =>
[vid_source_id:protected] =>
[vid_running_time:protected] =>
[vid_intended_audience:protected] =>
[vid_acquisition_info:protected] =>
[vid_cost:protected] =>
[vid_producer:protected] =>
[vid_filename:protected] =>
[vid_filename_downloadable:protected] =>
[date_summary:protected] => 2008
[date_permission_requested:protected] =>
[date_permission_received:protected] =>
[date_review_needed:protected] =>
[date_received:protected] => 01/07/10
[date_completed:protected] => 04/19/10
[date_billed:protected] =>
[date_modified:protected] => 07/08/12
[collBokExports:protected] =>
[lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] =>
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[3656] => DocumentRecord Object
(
[records:protected] => Array
(
)
[recordId:protected] =>
[searchWordClass:protected] =>
[searchWordPeerClass:protected] =>
[bok_record:protected] =>
[authors:protected] =>
[organizations:protected] =>
[collections:protected] =>
[categories:protected] =>
[categories_initialized:protected] =>
[mapped_items:protected] =>
[content:protected] =>
[files:protected] =>
[language:protected] =>
[old_record:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 3656
[old_id:protected] =>
[elcosh_id:protected] => d001198
[type:protected] => document
[display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF
[user_id:protected] => 24
[language_id:protected] => 1
[tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy
[priority_id:protected] => 1
[title:protected] => Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction While Doing Tuckpointing/Mortar Removal
[total_pages:protected] => 2
[billed_pages:protected] => 2
[publication_number:protected] => DSG FS-3632
[part_of:protected] =>
[keywords:protected] => Brick, block, tuckpointing, silica, local exhaust ventilation, LEV, masonry
[comments:protected] =>
[summary:protected] => Tuckpointing creates some of the greatest exposures to silica in construction. This OSHA factsheet provides guidance on how to greatly reduce these exposures through the use of local exhaust ventilation.
[transition_comments:protected] =>
[external_link:protected] =>
[consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html
[more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863, d001201
[permission_given_by:protected] =>
[published:protected] => T
[billable:protected] => F
[img_name:protected] =>
[img_ext:protected] => jpg
[img_width:protected] =>
[img_height:protected] =>
[img_credit:protected] =>
[img_practice:protected] =>
[vid_source_id:protected] =>
[vid_running_time:protected] =>
[vid_intended_audience:protected] =>
[vid_acquisition_info:protected] =>
[vid_cost:protected] =>
[vid_producer:protected] =>
[vid_filename:protected] =>
[vid_filename_downloadable:protected] =>
[date_summary:protected] => February 2013
[date_permission_requested:protected] =>
[date_permission_received:protected] =>
[date_review_needed:protected] =>
[date_received:protected] => 03/04/13
[date_completed:protected] => 03/27/13
[date_billed:protected] =>
[date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13
[collBokExports:protected] =>
[lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] =>
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[3899] => DocumentRecord Object
(
[records:protected] => Array
(
)
[recordId:protected] =>
[searchWordClass:protected] =>
[searchWordPeerClass:protected] =>
[bok_record:protected] =>
[authors:protected] =>
[organizations:protected] =>
[collections:protected] =>
[categories:protected] =>
[categories_initialized:protected] =>
[mapped_items:protected] =>
[content:protected] =>
[files:protected] =>
[language:protected] =>
[old_record:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 3899
[old_id:protected] =>
[elcosh_id:protected] => d001342
[type:protected] => document
[display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF
[user_id:protected] => 23
[language_id:protected] => 1
[tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy
[priority_id:protected] => 1
[title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: Hilti VC40-U Vacuum with Hilti DC-EX Dust Guard and Hilti Grinder
[total_pages:protected] => 15
[billed_pages:protected] => 15
[publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP4
[part_of:protected] =>
[keywords:protected] => silica, tuckpointing, Hilti, local exhaust systems, LEV, shroud, quartz
[comments:protected] =>
[summary:protected] => This report describes the results of an evaluation of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Hilti VC40-U vacuum, a Hilti DC-EX shroud, and a Hilti DAG-500 grinder. Randomized trials with and without use of the dust control system were conducted in a controlled setting. Removing mortar with the Hilti grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 220 times the National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05mg/m3. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 97 percent. However, exposures measured during the use of the dust control system still exceeded the NIOSH REL.
[transition_comments:protected] =>
[external_link:protected] =>
[consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html
[more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342
[permission_given_by:protected] =>
[published:protected] => T
[billable:protected] => F
[img_name:protected] =>
[img_ext:protected] => png
[img_width:protected] =>
[img_height:protected] =>
[img_credit:protected] =>
[img_practice:protected] =>
[vid_source_id:protected] =>
[vid_running_time:protected] =>
[vid_intended_audience:protected] =>
[vid_acquisition_info:protected] =>
[vid_cost:protected] =>
[vid_producer:protected] =>
[vid_filename:protected] =>
[vid_filename_downloadable:protected] =>
[date_summary:protected] => December 1, 2014
[date_permission_requested:protected] =>
[date_permission_received:protected] =>
[date_review_needed:protected] =>
[date_received:protected] => 12/05/14
[date_completed:protected] => 02/04/15
[date_billed:protected] =>
[date_modified:protected] => 05/06/15
[collBokExports:protected] =>
[lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] =>
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
)
[content:protected] =>
[files:protected] => Array
(
[559] =>
[560] =>
[546] => File Object
(
[id:protected] => 546
[filename:protected] => 3.jpg
[downloadable:protected] => F
[timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:22
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[566] => File Object
(
[id:protected] => 566
[filename:protected] => 4.jpg
[downloadable:protected] => F
[timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:23
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[720] => File Object
(
[id:protected] => 720
[filename:protected] => 5.jpg
[downloadable:protected] => F
[timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[721] => File Object
(
[id:protected] => 721
[filename:protected] => 6.jpg
[downloadable:protected] => F
[timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[722] => File Object
(
[id:protected] => 722
[filename:protected] => 7.jpg
[downloadable:protected] => F
[timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[9765] => File Object
(
[id:protected] => 9765
[filename:protected] => d001345.pdf
[downloadable:protected] => T
[timestamp:protected] => 2015-02-09 12:26:04
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
)
[language:protected] => Language Object
(
[id:protected] => 1
[code:protected] => en
[name:protected] => English
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[old_record:protected] =>
[id:protected] => 3908
[old_id:protected] =>
[elcosh_id:protected] => d001345
[type:protected] => document
[display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF
[user_id:protected] => 23
[language_id:protected] => 1
[tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy
[priority_id:protected] => 1
[title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: DustControl 2900c Vacuum with the ICS Dust Director Shroud and Bosch Grinder Model 1775E Conducted November 14-15, 2012
[total_pages:protected] => 13
[billed_pages:protected] => 13
[publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP2
[part_of:protected] =>
[keywords:protected] => tuckpointing, HEPA vacuum, dust control, LEV, local exhaust ventilation, silica
[comments:protected] =>
[summary:protected] => The results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit.
[transition_comments:protected] =>
[external_link:protected] =>
[consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html
[more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342
[permission_given_by:protected] =>
[published:protected] => T
[billable:protected] => F
[img_name:protected] =>
[img_ext:protected] => png
[img_width:protected] =>
[img_height:protected] =>
[img_credit:protected] =>
[img_practice:protected] =>
[vid_source_id:protected] =>
[vid_running_time:protected] =>
[vid_intended_audience:protected] =>
[vid_acquisition_info:protected] =>
[vid_cost:protected] =>
[vid_producer:protected] =>
[vid_filename:protected] =>
[vid_filename_downloadable:protected] =>
[date_summary:protected] => April 15, 2014
[date_permission_requested:protected] =>
[date_permission_received:protected] =>
[date_review_needed:protected] =>
[date_received:protected] => 01/26/15
[date_completed:protected] => 02/05/15
[date_billed:protected] =>
[date_modified:protected] => 02/09/15
[collBokExports:protected] =>
[lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] =>
[alreadyInSave:protected] =>
[alreadyInValidation:protected] =>
[validationFailures:protected] => Array
(
)
[_new:BaseObject:private] =>
[_deleted:BaseObject:private] =>
[modifiedColumns:protected] => Array
(
)
)
[show_text] =>
[document_content] => ElcoshItemDocumentContent Object
(
[id:protected] => 2934
[item_id:protected] => 3908
[type:protected] => main
[title:protected] =>
[content:protected] => Executive Summary
This report describes the results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. It should also be noted that the NIOSH REL is based on exposures averaged over a ten hour work day and our results represent time weighted averages of the sample task duration periods.
Acronyms
ACGIH - American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists
CPWR - CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training
Ce - coefficient of entry
HEPA - high-efficiency particulate air
IUBAC - International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craftworkers
LEV - local exhaust ventilation
PACT - Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies
NIOSH - National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health
OEL - occupational exposure limit
OSHA - Occupational Safety and Health Administration
PAPR - powered air-purifying respirator
PEL - Permissible Exposure Limit
PVC - polyvinyl chloride
REL - Recommended Exposure Limit
RPM - revolutions per minute
TWA - time-weighted average
SP - static pressure
I. Introduction and Background
In 2010 CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training began a four-year project which seeks to identify and evaluate tuckpointing local exhaust ventilation (LEV) systems and disseminate information on their availability and effectiveness. A Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies (PACT) comprised of masonry contractors, representatives from unions, government, equipment manufacturers, and health and safety researcher was formed as part of this project. PACT members participated in identifying important characteristics for control technologies and this information was used to identify LEV systems for tuckpointing using that criteria. Contractor and labor members of the PACT selected specific tuckpointing LEV systems to be considered for evaluation. Each system consisted of a tuckpointing grinder, shroud, and vacuum. This report describes the second of four systems to be evaluated between 2012 the end of 2014, with and without LEV, in a controlled setting to determine effectiveness in silica exposure reduction. This report describes the methods and results of our evaluation of a system consisting of the DustControl 2900c vacuum with the ICS Dust Director shroud and a Bosch Model 1775E grinder.
Excessive exposure to respirable silica can result in silicosis or other silica-related diseases including pulmonary tuberculosis, lung cancer, silicoproteinosis (Lyons et al, 2007) and autoimmune disorders such as rheumatoid arthritis, sarcoidosis and scleroderma (Miller et al, 2012). Respirable silica is generally defined as particles less than 10 micrometers (μm) in aerodynamic diameter (ACGIH, 2013). Silicosis can lead to symptoms including shortness of breath, fatigue, chest pains, susceptibility to infection and possibly death. There is no cure for silicosis, however it is totally preventable. Construction workers exposed to dust, including silica, are also known to have higher rates of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD).
There are many sources of silica in construction that result in exposures of varying intensity among workers. Masonry restoration workers are among the most highly silica-exposed trades in construction. The process of grinding out deteriorated mortar joints between masonry units and replacing or repointing with fresh mortar (often referred to as tuckpointing) is a fundamental part of masonry restoration work. The removal of mortar with powered angle grinders generates enormous levels of dust. Between 2004 and 2006, NIOSH and CPWR evaluated silica exposures while grinding mortar in a controlled setting, at a local training center, where tasks, sample times and task variables were defined by the study design. These studies demonstrated that grinding mortar without controls can result in elevated respirable silica exposures. Meeker et al., (2009) reported exposures between 5 and 25.8 milligrams per cubic meter (mg/m3) in a controlled setting. This study also showed that LEV systems for tuckpointing grinders can reduce exposures to respirable silica by greater than 90 percent.
II. Objectives
The objective of this evaluation was to assess the effectiveness of an LEV system for controlling exposure to silica during the grinding of mortar. The control technology was tested under controlled conditions, similar to those experienced by tuckpointers on actual job sites, using journeymen bricklayers experienced in tuckpointing and repeat, randomized trials with and without LEV. All other variables were held constant throughout so that the only variable was whether or not the tested control was used.
III. Description of Equipment Tested
A Bosch model 1775E grinder (Robert Bosch Tool Corporation, Prospect, IL) (Figures 1, 2 and 3) was fitted with a new 1/4-inch wide, 4½-inch diameter segmented diamond abrasive blade made by DeWalt (model #DW4740). The grinder weighs six and a half pounds, draws 8.5 amps and has a variable speed up to 11,000 revolutions per minute (RPMs). The DustControl 2900c vacuum (DustControl, Inc., Wilmington, NC) (Figure 3) was tested in combination with the Dust Director shroud (Industrial Contractors’ Supplies, Inc., Huntingdon, PA) (Figures 1 and 3) attached to the Bosch grinder.
Figure 1. Bosch grinder with Dust Director shroud
Figure 2. Bosch grinder without tuckpointing LEV system.
Figure 3: Bosch Grinder with LEV System
The vacuum is specified to weigh 31 pounds when empty and to provide a flow rate of 114 cubic feet of air per minute and a “static lift” or “vacuum suction pressure” of 84 inches of water. The vacuum is sold with a cyclonic pre-separator, to remove larger particles, a fine filter (rated 99.9 percent efficient) and a HEPA (high-efficiency particulate air) filter (rated to capture 99.97 percent of the particles with an aerodynamic diameter of 0.3 micrometers). The HEPA filter was removed based on the manufacturer’s recommendation due to the heavy dust loading associated with tuckpointing. CPWR sponsored research and contractor experience indicate that HEPA filters likely have an adverse effect on dust capture during tuckpointing because of extreme dust loading on filters. While the cyclone and the fine filter remove most of the dust, especially the large particles, before they reach the HEPA filter, the HEPA filter would still be subject to heavy loading, causing a substantial pressure drop and subsequent decrease in air flow rate. The relatively small increase in the efficiency of the filtration system while using the HEPA filter is expected to be quickly offset by a more significant decrease in capture efficiency as the air flow rate and ability to capture particles decreases.
Dust collects in relatively inexpensive, heavy-gauge plastic bags below and outside of the cyclone. The bags can be removed and replaced without opening the vacuum. Some vacuums are equipped with a light to indicate that the filters need to be cleaned or changed. The DC2900c features a “reverse air pulse cleaning system,” which removes accumulated dust from the filters without having to remove them from the vacuum. The system, as illustrated in Figure 4, requires the operator to disconnect the hose from the shroud, place it over an air stop so that air through the hose is cut off and pressure in the vacuum is maximized.
Figure 4. Procedure for "cleaning" of or dust removal from filters (source: http://dustcontrolusa.com/manuals/2800c.pdf)
The flap covering the port on the side of the vacuum is repeatedly flipped open to release built up pressure in strong pulses that dislodge dust from the filter.
The manufacturer indicates “the filter is generally cleaned once or twice daily during normal continuous operation.” The Dust Director shroud has a 2-inch diameter take-off that was connected to the antistatic, corrugated 1.5-inch diameter, 15-foot long vacuum hose supplied with the DustControl vacuum.
IV. Study Methods
This evaluation was conducted at the International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craft workers (IUBAC) Local 1 Philadelphia/Delaware Training Center in Philadelphia, PA on November 14 and 15, 2012. A single journeyman bricklayer, experienced in tuckpointing, used the grinder and LEV system being tested to remove mortar from joints wide enough to require two passes. The type S mortar had been allowed to cure for at least four weeks. The bricklayer either possessed or was provided with personal protective equipment including sturdy work boots, gloves, hearing protection and a powered air-purifying respirator (PAPR). The PAPR was a 3M GVP system with a bump cap, loose fitting face piece and a HEPA filter (3M, St Paul, MN).
The study was designed to include at least five rounds of sampling during mortar removal. Each round included a trial using the Bosch grinder with a Dust Director shroud and Dust Collector 2900c vacuum and a trial using the Bosch grinder with the factory-supplied guard and without a vacuum. The order of the two trials within each round was randomly selected to minimize bias that might be introduced due to variation associated with environmental factors, equipment operator, blade wear, vacuum performance over time and any other factors unrelated to LEV use. Tools were operated for approximately 16 minutes per trial with controls and for approximately 8 minutes when controls were not used. These times were selected based on the results of previous sampling efforts and estimates of the minimum sample time needed to achieve a limit of quantification low enough to accurately measure exposures down to or less than 0.05 mg/m3 – the NIOSH Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) for respirable silica. The bricklayer was required to take a 5 to 10 minute break in the middle of the 16-minute trials to reduce differences in fatigue, compared to the 8-minute trials. Personal air samples were collected in the breathing zone of the operator during each trial to measure respirable silica concentrations during grinding with and without LEV. The samples were collected using a GilAir-5 pump (Sensidyne, Inc., Clearwater, FL) to draw 4.2 liters of air per minute through a GK2.69 Respirable Cyclone (BGI Inc., Waltham, MA) with a pre-weighed, 37 mm diameter, 5-micron pore size polyvinyl chloride (PVC) filter positioned on the operator’s lapel.
The flow rates of the sampling pumps were calibrated at the beginning of each day using a DryCal DC-Lite Primary Flow Meter (Bios International Corporation, Butler, NJ). Flow rates were measured again near the middle and at the end of each day to ensure that sampling flow rates were maintained within 5% of pre-sampling flow rates throughout the day. Average flow rates were used to calculate sample air volumes. Samples were analyzed by R.J. Lee Group, Inc., (Monroeville, PA) using NIOSH Method 0600, to determine exposure to total mass of respirable dust. The same samples were also analyzed using X-Ray diffraction following NIOSH method 7500 to determine quartz, cristobalite and tridymite concentration in the respirable mass. Reported masses for these analytes were used with the sample air volumes to calculate airborne concentrations of total respirable dust, quartz, cristobalite and tridymite.
We used a reduction of greater than 50 percent in respirable silica exposure concentrations or a reduction to less than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 as our criteria for determining whether or not a control was considered efficacious. This is consistent with criteria used by NIOSH in conducting a similar study in 2004 described by Echt et al. (2007) and by CPWR in 2006 and described by Meeker et al. (2009). The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) and the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) publish additional occupational exposure limits (OELs) for silica which are listed in Table 1 with NIOSH RELs. OELs for silica are based on the respirable fraction of the aerosol, which consists of particles less than 10 micrometers in aerodynamic diameter.
| Organization or Agency | Form of Crystalline Silica | Occupational Exposure Limits (mg/m3) |
|---|---|---|
| NIOSHA | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 |
| OSHA - ConstructionB | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
PEL = 250 / (5 + % quartz) PEL = 250 / (5 + % cristobalite) PEL = 250 / (5 + % tridymite) |
| ACGIH | Crystalline Silica | TLV = 0.025 mg/m3 |
A NIOSH Publication No. 2005-151 indicates 10-hour time-weighted average during a 40-hr workweek B The PEL for silica in OSHA’s Safety and Health Regulations for Construction, 29 C.F.R. 1926.55(a), is an 8-hour time-weighted average (TWA) expressed in millions of particles per cubic foot (mppcf). However, the units mppcf can be converted to milligrams per cubic meter can by dividing mppcf by 10 (OSHA, 2009). The formula used by OSHA to determine the PEL for silica is dependent on the percentage of silica in each collected sample. The concentration of respirable dust measured is compared to the sample specific PEL to determine if the PEL has been exceeded. OSHA has proposed lowering the PEL to 0.05 mg/m3 of respirable silica as an 8 hour TWA. |
||
The flow of air in ventilation systems is governed by fundamental principles that describe the behavior of gases (in this case air). Pressure measurements taken within a ventilation system along with knowledge of hood (or shroud) entry losses can be used to calculate flow rates. Hood entry losses are dependent on the shape and configuration of a particular hood or shroud and described by the term “coefficient of entry (Ce)” which is the ratio of actual air flow through a hood and what the air flow would theoretically be if there were no hood entry losses. Given the coefficient of entry, static pressure measurements can be used to calculate air flow through a given hood. The coefficient of entry for the Dust Director shroud was previously determined by CPWR and used for calculating air flow based on static pressure measurements (Meeker et al., 2009). Static pressure, with the vacuum operating, was measured periodically throughout the evaluation to monitor the changes in air-flow rate following use and again after filter cleaning. The static pressure was measured at a port positioned more than 3 duct diameters downstream from the tool’s air intake using a UEi EM200 Electronic Manometer (Universal Enterprises, Inc., Beaverton, OR).
The dust in the vacuum bag was monitored and, per the manufacturer’s instructions, the bag was changed before the dust level was within 5 centimeters of the valve at the bottom of the vacuum. Each time a vacuum bag was removed, it was weighed to the nearest pound. The bag weights and corresponding grinding durations were used to calculate the average weight of dust collected per unit time. After each trial, cut lengths were measured on the wall to determine total linear feet of vertical (head) and horizontal (bed) joints per unit time.
A Haz-Dust III, Model HD-1003, Real-Time Aerosol Monitor (Environmental Devices Corporation, Plaistow, NH) was used to confirm clearance of dust between trials. The Haz-Dust monitor was positioned on the test wall near the operator at approximately breathing zone level and configured to measure respirable particulate concentration.
V. Results
Personal air monitoring
Five pairs of respirable dust samples were collected while grinding with and without the vacuum system. In addition, three respirable dust samples were collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place. One measurement collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard was shown to be a statistical outlier and was omitted from analysis. Personal air monitoring results for respirable silica and a comparison of average exposures relative to the NIOSH REL for silica (0.05 mg/m3) appears in Table 2. The mean respirable dust levels measured without LEV was 31.4 mg/m3. However, samples collected with LEV were below the limit of quantification (LOQ) which ranged from <1.29 to <1.46 mg/m3. Use of LEV resulted in a greater than 95% reduction in mean respirable dust levels using a mean value with use of LEV of <1.41 (n=5 samples with use of LEV and n=7 without use of LEV). The respirable dust samples collected during grinding without the LEV system contained an average of 24 percent silica. The mass of respirable dust in the samples collected with use of the LEV system was too low to determine the silica content.| Mean, mg/m3 (range) | Std. Dev. | Percent Reduction | Hazard RatioB | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bosch with Dust Director Shroud and DustControl 2900c Vacuum |
0.091 (<0.069 – 0.137) |
0.027 | 98.7 | 1.81 |
| Bosch with no Control | 7.23 (4.57 – 9.90) |
1.94 | NA | 145 |
A n = 5 samples for each tool/control combination and n = 7 samples without the use of the LEV system B Hazard Ratio = measured exposure / NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 |
||||
Average respirable silica and dust exposures, with and without the dust control system, appear as Figures 5 and 6, respectively.
Figure 5. Average respirable silica exposures with and without the Dustcontrol 2900c vacuum and Dust Director shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air - mg/m3)
Figure 6. Average respirable dust exposures with and without Dustcontrol 2900c Vacuum and Dust Director Shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air – mg/m3)
The mean respirable silica concentration measured during use of the control was significantly less than the concentration measured while using the same tool without controls (p<0.01). Grinding mortar with the Bosch angle grinder without dust controls resulted in an average exposure to respirable silica that was 145 times the NIOSH REL. Grinding with the Bosch angle grinder in combination with the Dust Director shroud and the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced the average concentration of respirable silica by 98.7 percent. With use of these controls, the concentration of respirable silica was 1.8 times greater than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3. However the NIOSH REL is based on a time-weighted average (TWA) over a 10-hour workday. Given these were task TWAs and samples were collected over continuous periods of grinding, they may overestimate exposures over an actual work day since some time would be spent performing tasks that would likely have lower, or no, silica exposures (setup, breaks, cleanup, etc.).
Static pressure, dust mass collection and grinding rates.
Static pressure was used as a surrogate for air flow as described earlier. Hood static pressure was measured periodically at a tap near the grinder more than 3 duct diameters from the air intake in the shroud. The static pressure, and thus air flow, was generally higher when the vacuum’s filter had recently been cleaned. The mean, median, and range of calculated flow rates are presented in Table A1 of the Appendix.
Based on the data we collected, the air-flow rate upstream from the Bosch grinder and Dust Director shroud ranged from 78 to 93 cubic feet per minute (cfm) with the DustControl vacuum. When the manufacturer’s filter cleaning procedure was followed the vacuum performed relatively well and flow could be maintained at slightly less than 90 cfm with cleaning. However, mean flow rates dropped substantially to 80 cfm after as little as 8 minutes of grinding without any filter cleaning. The flow rate returned to an average of 89 cfm when filters were cleaned correctly (without stopping air flow to the vacuum). Collingwood and Heitbrink (2007) found that the minimum exhaust flow rate for capture of silica and other particulate under ideal conditions is 21.25 cfm per inch of grinder blade diameter. This is equal to about 96 cfm when using a 4.5 inch diameter grinding blade. We set 106 cfm as the minimum desired flow rate for this study to allow a safety margin for potential decline in equipment performance and the possibility of inadequate maintenance, both of which may be likely after repeated use under actual work conditions. The DustControl vacuum provided slightly less than the minimum flow rate described by Collingwood and Heitbrink for a 4.5-inch blade and the peak flow rate fell with use.
The duration of vacuum bag use and mass of dust collected were recorded and are presented in Table A2 of the Appendix. The vacuum bags were changed and weighed after each trial utilizing the LEV system. A total of five bags were used to complete the five rounds of grinding. The DustControl vacuum captured 45 pounds of dust over 83 minutes of grinding for an average rate of dust collection of 0.54 pounds per minute. The rate of dust collection ranged from 0.47 to 0.63 pounds per minute. Based on these measurements, approximately 130 pounds of dust would likely be captured after just 4 hours of continuous grinding.
The rate of grinding a combination of vertical and horizontal joints while using the LEV system ranged from 2.3 to 3.3 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the use of the LEV system ranged from 2.6 to 3.4 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place ranged from 4.7 to 5.1 feet per minute. It’s important to note that: 1) the operator had limited experience using dust control systems and cut rates appeared to improve slightly over the 2-day period he used the tested equipment; and 2) the upper range of cut rates with the dust control system overlapped with the lowest cut rate with the original guard and without the LEV system in place indicating no statistical difference between cut rates. Given that grinding rates with and without use of this LEV system are only available for one operator and he had limited experience with the LEV system, these reported cut rates are in no way intended to represent the impact use of this LEV system is likely to have on productivity rates overall.
VI. Discussion
The objective of these trials was to evaluate the effectiveness of a tuckpointing LEV system for controlling respirable silica while grinding out mortar joints. The Dust Director shroud with the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced respirable silica concentrations when grinding with the Bosch grinder by approximately 99 percent. Despite being considered effective by our test criteria (greater than 50% reduction), it still resulted in task TWA exposures that exceeded the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 by 1.8 times. Depending on how much time is spent grinding over the course of a work day and on exposures while performing other tasks, the 8-hour TWA exposures may or may not exceed the REL with this system. Use of this system by workers with experience and training in proficient use will likely improve dust capture performance. Exposure reduction is greatly influenced by correct use of this system which includes grinding from right to left, making sure the shroud is held flush against the wall and that the tool travels at a pace that doesn’t exceed the ability of the system to capture dust as it’s generated. Deviation from any of these measures produces visible dust clouds which were observed during trials.
VII. Conclusions
With a 99 percent reduction in respirable silica exposure, the Dust Director shroud and DustControl 2900c vacuum with a Bosch Model 1775E grinder was effective in reducing silica exposures based on our criteria. Use of the tested dust control system may be effective in reducing silica exposure on the job to less than the NIOSH REL if used in combination with administrative controls such as work scheduling to reduce cutting times as needed. Training on correct use of the tested system is also essential. Personal air monitoring is necessary to verify control effectiveness on actual job sites and under “real-world” conditions. However, these results clearly demonstrate the availability of viable and effective engineering controls for tuckpointing operations associated with elevated silica exposure.
VIII. References
American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists. Threshold limit values for chemical substances (TLV®-CS). [2013]. ACGIH, Cincinnati, Ohio.
Bergdahl I.A,. Toren K., Eriksson K., et al. [2004]. Increased mortality in COPD among construction workers exposed to inorganic dust. European Respiratory Journal, 23: 402–06.
Blanc P.D. & Torén K. [2007]. Occupation in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and chronic bronchitis: an update [State of the Art Series. Occupational lung disease in high-and low-income countries, Edited by M. Chan-Yeung. Number 2 in the series]. The International Journal of Tuberculosis and Lung Disease, 11(3), 251-257.
Collingwood S. & Heitbrink W.A. [2007] 'Field Evaluation of an Engineering Control for Respirable Crystalline Silica Exposures During Mortar Removal'. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, 4:11, 875 – 887.
DHHS (NIOSH) Publication No. 2002-129 April 2002 http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/2002-129/
Echt A., Sieber W.K., Lefkowitz D., Meeker J., Susi P., Cardwell B., Heitbrink, W.A. In-depth survey of dust control technology for cutting concrete block and tuckpointing brick at The International Masonry Institute Bordentown Training Center, Bordentown, NJ. Cincinnati, OH: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Report. No. EPHB 282-13; 2007. http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ECTB-282-13.pdf
Heitbrink W., Bennett J. [2006]. A numerical and experimental investigation of crystalline silica exposure control during tuck pointing. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, Vol. 3, pp 366-378.
Lyons et al, [2007]. A breathless builder. Breathe, Vol. 3, no. 4, pp 386-390.
Mastrangelo G., Tartari M., Fedeli U., Fadda E., Saia B. [2003]. Ascertaining the risk of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease in relation to occupation using a case-control design. Occupational Medicine, 53: 165–172.
Meeker J., Cooper M., Lefrowitz D., Susi P. [2009]. Engineering control technologies to reduce occupational silica exposures in masonry cutting and tuckpointing. Public Health Reports, Supplement 1, Vol. 124, June.
Meeker J, Flynn M, Susi P, Cardwell, B [2004]. Performance evaluation of a masonry concrete vacuum. Unpublished Report.
Miller F. W., Alfredsson L., Costenbader K. H., Kamen D. L., Nelson L. M., Norris J. M., & De Roos A. J. [2012]. Epidemiology of environmental exposures and human autoimmune diseases: findings from a National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences Expert Panel workshop. Journal of autoimmunity. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3496812/
Occupational Safety and Health Administration U.S Department of Labor. Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction. [2009]. OSHA 3362-05.
Rappaport SM, Goldberg M, Susi P, Herrick RF [2003]. Excessive exposure to silica in the U.S. construction industry. Annals of Occupational Hygiene, Vol. 47, pp. 111-122.
IX. Appendices
| Measurement Conditions |
n | Mean Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Median
Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before filter cleaning | 5 | 80 | 81 | 78-81 |
| After filter cleaning following manufacturer directions | 9 | 89 | 90 | 84-93 |
| * Static pressure was measured in millibars and converted to inches of water gauge. Flow rates were calculated using the formula Q = Ce (A) 4005 (SP)1/2 where: Q = flow in cubic feet per minute (cfm), Ce = coefficient of entry, A = area of the duct where static pressure measurements were taken in square feet, and SP = static pressure in inches of water gauge. | ||||
| Tool/Control | Collection Period (min.) |
Dust Collection Rate (lb/min.) |
|---|---|---|
| Bosch grinder/Dust Director shroud & DustControl 2900c vacuum |
8 11 8 8 10 |
0.50 0.61 0.50 0.47 0.63 |
| Average | 0.54 |
[content_transformed:protected] =>
Executive Summary
This report describes the results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. It should also be noted that the NIOSH REL is based on exposures averaged over a ten hour work day and our results represent time weighted averages of the sample task duration periods.
Acronyms
ACGIH - American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists
CPWR - CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training
Ce - coefficient of entry
HEPA - high-efficiency particulate air
IUBAC - International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craftworkers
LEV - local exhaust ventilation
PACT - Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies
NIOSH - National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health
OEL - occupational exposure limit
OSHA - Occupational Safety and Health Administration
PAPR - powered air-purifying respirator
PEL - Permissible Exposure Limit
PVC - polyvinyl chloride
REL - Recommended Exposure Limit
RPM - revolutions per minute
TWA - time-weighted average
SP - static pressure
I. Introduction and Background
In 2010 CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training began a four-year project which seeks to identify and evaluate tuckpointing local exhaust ventilation (LEV) systems and disseminate information on their availability and effectiveness. A Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies (PACT) comprised of masonry contractors, representatives from unions, government, equipment manufacturers, and health and safety researcher was formed as part of this project. PACT members participated in identifying important characteristics for control technologies and this information was used to identify LEV systems for tuckpointing using that criteria. Contractor and labor members of the PACT selected specific tuckpointing LEV systems to be considered for evaluation. Each system consisted of a tuckpointing grinder, shroud, and vacuum. This report describes the second of four systems to be evaluated between 2012 the end of 2014, with and without LEV, in a controlled setting to determine effectiveness in silica exposure reduction. This report describes the methods and results of our evaluation of a system consisting of the DustControl 2900c vacuum with the ICS Dust Director shroud and a Bosch Model 1775E grinder.
Excessive exposure to respirable silica can result in silicosis or other silica-related diseases including pulmonary tuberculosis, lung cancer, silicoproteinosis (Lyons et al, 2007) and autoimmune disorders such as rheumatoid arthritis, sarcoidosis and scleroderma (Miller et al, 2012). Respirable silica is generally defined as particles less than 10 micrometers (μm) in aerodynamic diameter (ACGIH, 2013). Silicosis can lead to symptoms including shortness of breath, fatigue, chest pains, susceptibility to infection and possibly death. There is no cure for silicosis, however it is totally preventable. Construction workers exposed to dust, including silica, are also known to have higher rates of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD).
There are many sources of silica in construction that result in exposures of varying intensity among workers. Masonry restoration workers are among the most highly silica-exposed trades in construction. The process of grinding out deteriorated mortar joints between masonry units and replacing or repointing with fresh mortar (often referred to as tuckpointing) is a fundamental part of masonry restoration work. The removal of mortar with powered angle grinders generates enormous levels of dust. Between 2004 and 2006, NIOSH and CPWR evaluated silica exposures while grinding mortar in a controlled setting, at a local training center, where tasks, sample times and task variables were defined by the study design. These studies demonstrated that grinding mortar without controls can result in elevated respirable silica exposures. Meeker et al., (2009) reported exposures between 5 and 25.8 milligrams per cubic meter (mg/m3) in a controlled setting. This study also showed that LEV systems for tuckpointing grinders can reduce exposures to respirable silica by greater than 90 percent.II. Objectives
The objective of this evaluation was to assess the effectiveness of an LEV system for controlling exposure to silica during the grinding of mortar. The control technology was tested under controlled conditions, similar to those experienced by tuckpointers on actual job sites, using journeymen bricklayers experienced in tuckpointing and repeat, randomized trials with and without LEV. All other variables were held constant throughout so that the only variable was whether or not the tested control was used.
III. Description of Equipment Tested
A Bosch model 1775E grinder (Robert Bosch Tool Corporation, Prospect, IL) (Figures 1, 2 and 3) was fitted with a new 1/4-inch wide, 4½-inch diameter segmented diamond abrasive blade made by DeWalt (model #DW4740). The grinder weighs six and a half pounds, draws 8.5 amps and has a variable speed up to 11,000 revolutions per minute (RPMs). The DustControl 2900c vacuum (DustControl, Inc., Wilmington, NC) (Figure 3) was tested in combination with the Dust Director shroud (Industrial Contractors’ Supplies, Inc., Huntingdon, PA) (Figures 1 and 3) attached to the Bosch grinder.
Figure 1. Bosch grinder with Dust Director shroud
Figure 2. Bosch grinder without tuckpointing LEV system.
Figure 3: Bosch Grinder with LEV System
The vacuum is specified to weigh 31 pounds when empty and to provide a flow rate of 114 cubic feet of air per minute and a “static lift” or “vacuum suction pressure” of 84 inches of water. The vacuum is sold with a cyclonic pre-separator, to remove larger particles, a fine filter (rated 99.9 percent efficient) and a HEPA (high-efficiency particulate air) filter (rated to capture 99.97 percent of the particles with an aerodynamic diameter of 0.3 micrometers). The HEPA filter was removed based on the manufacturer’s recommendation due to the heavy dust loading associated with tuckpointing. CPWR sponsored research and contractor experience indicate that HEPA filters likely have an adverse effect on dust capture during tuckpointing because of extreme dust loading on filters. While the cyclone and the fine filter remove most of the dust, especially the large particles, before they reach the HEPA filter, the HEPA filter would still be subject to heavy loading, causing a substantial pressure drop and subsequent decrease in air flow rate. The relatively small increase in the efficiency of the filtration system while using the HEPA filter is expected to be quickly offset by a more significant decrease in capture efficiency as the air flow rate and ability to capture particles decreases.
Dust collects in relatively inexpensive, heavy-gauge plastic bags below and outside of the cyclone. The bags can be removed and replaced without opening the vacuum. Some vacuums are equipped with a light to indicate that the filters need to be cleaned or changed. The DC2900c features a “reverse air pulse cleaning system,” which removes accumulated dust from the filters without having to remove them from the vacuum. The system, as illustrated in Figure 4, requires the operator to disconnect the hose from the shroud, place it over an air stop so that air through the hose is cut off and pressure in the vacuum is maximized.
Figure 4. Procedure for "cleaning" of or dust removal from filters (source: http://dustcontrolusa.com/manuals/2800c.pdf)
The flap covering the port on the side of the vacuum is repeatedly flipped open to release built up pressure in strong pulses that dislodge dust from the filter.
The manufacturer indicates “the filter is generally cleaned once or twice daily during normal continuous operation.” The Dust Director shroud has a 2-inch diameter take-off that was connected to the antistatic, corrugated 1.5-inch diameter, 15-foot long vacuum hose supplied with the DustControl vacuum.
IV. Study Methods
This evaluation was conducted at the International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craft workers (IUBAC) Local 1 Philadelphia/Delaware Training Center in Philadelphia, PA on November 14 and 15, 2012. A single journeyman bricklayer, experienced in tuckpointing, used the grinder and LEV system being tested to remove mortar from joints wide enough to require two passes. The type S mortar had been allowed to cure for at least four weeks. The bricklayer either possessed or was provided with personal protective equipment including sturdy work boots, gloves, hearing protection and a powered air-purifying respirator (PAPR). The PAPR was a 3M GVP system with a bump cap, loose fitting face piece and a HEPA filter (3M, St Paul, MN).
The study was designed to include at least five rounds of sampling during mortar removal. Each round included a trial using the Bosch grinder with a Dust Director shroud and Dust Collector 2900c vacuum and a trial using the Bosch grinder with the factory-supplied guard and without a vacuum. The order of the two trials within each round was randomly selected to minimize bias that might be introduced due to variation associated with environmental factors, equipment operator, blade wear, vacuum performance over time and any other factors unrelated to LEV use. Tools were operated for approximately 16 minutes per trial with controls and for approximately 8 minutes when controls were not used. These times were selected based on the results of previous sampling efforts and estimates of the minimum sample time needed to achieve a limit of quantification low enough to accurately measure exposures down to or less than 0.05 mg/m3 – the NIOSH Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) for respirable silica. The bricklayer was required to take a 5 to 10 minute break in the middle of the 16-minute trials to reduce differences in fatigue, compared to the 8-minute trials. Personal air samples were collected in the breathing zone of the operator during each trial to measure respirable silica concentrations during grinding with and without LEV. The samples were collected using a GilAir-5 pump (Sensidyne, Inc., Clearwater, FL) to draw 4.2 liters of air per minute through a GK2.69 Respirable Cyclone (BGI Inc., Waltham, MA) with a pre-weighed, 37 mm diameter, 5-micron pore size polyvinyl chloride (PVC) filter positioned on the operator’s lapel.
The flow rates of the sampling pumps were calibrated at the beginning of each day using a DryCal DC-Lite Primary Flow Meter (Bios International Corporation, Butler, NJ). Flow rates were measured again near the middle and at the end of each day to ensure that sampling flow rates were maintained within 5% of pre-sampling flow rates throughout the day. Average flow rates were used to calculate sample air volumes. Samples were analyzed by R.J. Lee Group, Inc., (Monroeville, PA) using NIOSH Method 0600, to determine exposure to total mass of respirable dust. The same samples were also analyzed using X-Ray diffraction following NIOSH method 7500 to determine quartz, cristobalite and tridymite concentration in the respirable mass. Reported masses for these analytes were used with the sample air volumes to calculate airborne concentrations of total respirable dust, quartz, cristobalite and tridymite.
We used a reduction of greater than 50 percent in respirable silica exposure concentrations or a reduction to less than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 as our criteria for determining whether or not a control was considered efficacious. This is consistent with criteria used by NIOSH in conducting a similar study in 2004 described by Echt et al. (2007) and by CPWR in 2006 and described by Meeker et al. (2009). The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) and the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) publish additional occupational exposure limits (OELs) for silica which are listed in Table 1 with NIOSH RELs. OELs for silica are based on the respirable fraction of the aerosol, which consists of particles less than 10 micrometers in aerodynamic diameter.
| Organization or Agency | Form of Crystalline Silica | Occupational Exposure Limits (mg/m3) |
|---|---|---|
| NIOSHA | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 |
| OSHA - ConstructionB | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
PEL = 250 / (5 + % quartz) PEL = 250 / (5 + % cristobalite) PEL = 250 / (5 + % tridymite) |
| ACGIH | Crystalline Silica | TLV = 0.025 mg/m3 |
A NIOSH Publication No. 2005-151 indicates 10-hour time-weighted average during a 40-hr workweek B The PEL for silica in OSHA’s Safety and Health Regulations for Construction, 29 C.F.R. 1926.55(a), is an 8-hour time-weighted average (TWA) expressed in millions of particles per cubic foot (mppcf). However, the units mppcf can be converted to milligrams per cubic meter can by dividing mppcf by 10 (OSHA, 2009). The formula used by OSHA to determine the PEL for silica is dependent on the percentage of silica in each collected sample. The concentration of respirable dust measured is compared to the sample specific PEL to determine if the PEL has been exceeded. OSHA has proposed lowering the PEL to 0.05 mg/m3 of respirable silica as an 8 hour TWA. |
||
The flow of air in ventilation systems is governed by fundamental principles that describe the behavior of gases (in this case air). Pressure measurements taken within a ventilation system along with knowledge of hood (or shroud) entry losses can be used to calculate flow rates. Hood entry losses are dependent on the shape and configuration of a particular hood or shroud and described by the term “coefficient of entry (Ce)” which is the ratio of actual air flow through a hood and what the air flow would theoretically be if there were no hood entry losses. Given the coefficient of entry, static pressure measurements can be used to calculate air flow through a given hood. The coefficient of entry for the Dust Director shroud was previously determined by CPWR and used for calculating air flow based on static pressure measurements (Meeker et al., 2009). Static pressure, with the vacuum operating, was measured periodically throughout the evaluation to monitor the changes in air-flow rate following use and again after filter cleaning. The static pressure was measured at a port positioned more than 3 duct diameters downstream from the tool’s air intake using a UEi EM200 Electronic Manometer (Universal Enterprises, Inc., Beaverton, OR).
The dust in the vacuum bag was monitored and, per the manufacturer’s instructions, the bag was changed before the dust level was within 5 centimeters of the valve at the bottom of the vacuum. Each time a vacuum bag was removed, it was weighed to the nearest pound. The bag weights and corresponding grinding durations were used to calculate the average weight of dust collected per unit time. After each trial, cut lengths were measured on the wall to determine total linear feet of vertical (head) and horizontal (bed) joints per unit time.
A Haz-Dust III, Model HD-1003, Real-Time Aerosol Monitor (Environmental Devices Corporation, Plaistow, NH) was used to confirm clearance of dust between trials. The Haz-Dust monitor was positioned on the test wall near the operator at approximately breathing zone level and configured to measure respirable particulate concentration.
V. Results
Personal air monitoring
Five pairs of respirable dust samples were collected while grinding with and without the vacuum system. In addition, three respirable dust samples were collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place. One measurement collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard was shown to be a statistical outlier and was omitted from analysis. Personal air monitoring results for respirable silica and a comparison of average exposures relative to the NIOSH REL for silica (0.05 mg/m3) appears in Table 2. The mean respirable dust levels measured without LEV was 31.4 mg/m3. However, samples collected with LEV were below the limit of quantification (LOQ) which ranged from <1.29 to <1.46 mg/m3. Use of LEV resulted in a greater than 95% reduction in mean respirable dust levels using a mean value with use of LEV of <1.41 (n=5 samples with use of LEV and n=7 without use of LEV). The respirable dust samples collected during grinding without the LEV system contained an average of 24 percent silica. The mass of respirable dust in the samples collected with use of the LEV system was too low to determine the silica content.| Mean, mg/m3 (range) | Std. Dev. | Percent Reduction | Hazard RatioB | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bosch with Dust Director Shroud and DustControl 2900c Vacuum |
0.091 (<0.069 – 0.137) |
0.027 | 98.7 | 1.81 |
| Bosch with no Control | 7.23 (4.57 – 9.90) |
1.94 | NA | 145 |
A n = 5 samples for each tool/control combination and n = 7 samples without the use of the LEV system B Hazard Ratio = measured exposure / NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 |
||||
Average respirable silica and dust exposures, with and without the dust control system, appear as Figures 5 and 6, respectively.
Figure 5. Average respirable silica exposures with and without the Dustcontrol 2900c vacuum and Dust Director shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air - mg/m3)
Figure 6. Average respirable dust exposures with and without Dustcontrol 2900c Vacuum and Dust Director Shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air – mg/m3)
The mean respirable silica concentration measured during use of the control was significantly less than the concentration measured while using the same tool without controls (p<0.01). Grinding mortar with the Bosch angle grinder without dust controls resulted in an average exposure to respirable silica that was 145 times the NIOSH REL. Grinding with the Bosch angle grinder in combination with the Dust Director shroud and the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced the average concentration of respirable silica by 98.7 percent. With use of these controls, the concentration of respirable silica was 1.8 times greater than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3. However the NIOSH REL is based on a time-weighted average (TWA) over a 10-hour workday. Given these were task TWAs and samples were collected over continuous periods of grinding, they may overestimate exposures over an actual work day since some time would be spent performing tasks that would likely have lower, or no, silica exposures (setup, breaks, cleanup, etc.).
Static pressure, dust mass collection and grinding rates.
Static pressure was used as a surrogate for air flow as described earlier. Hood static pressure was measured periodically at a tap near the grinder more than 3 duct diameters from the air intake in the shroud. The static pressure, and thus air flow, was generally higher when the vacuum’s filter had recently been cleaned. The mean, median, and range of calculated flow rates are presented in Table A1 of the Appendix.
Based on the data we collected, the air-flow rate upstream from the Bosch grinder and Dust Director shroud ranged from 78 to 93 cubic feet per minute (cfm) with the DustControl vacuum. When the manufacturer’s filter cleaning procedure was followed the vacuum performed relatively well and flow could be maintained at slightly less than 90 cfm with cleaning. However, mean flow rates dropped substantially to 80 cfm after as little as 8 minutes of grinding without any filter cleaning. The flow rate returned to an average of 89 cfm when filters were cleaned correctly (without stopping air flow to the vacuum). Collingwood and Heitbrink (2007) found that the minimum exhaust flow rate for capture of silica and other particulate under ideal conditions is 21.25 cfm per inch of grinder blade diameter. This is equal to about 96 cfm when using a 4.5 inch diameter grinding blade. We set 106 cfm as the minimum desired flow rate for this study to allow a safety margin for potential decline in equipment performance and the possibility of inadequate maintenance, both of which may be likely after repeated use under actual work conditions. The DustControl vacuum provided slightly less than the minimum flow rate described by Collingwood and Heitbrink for a 4.5-inch blade and the peak flow rate fell with use.
The duration of vacuum bag use and mass of dust collected were recorded and are presented in Table A2 of the Appendix. The vacuum bags were changed and weighed after each trial utilizing the LEV system. A total of five bags were used to complete the five rounds of grinding. The DustControl vacuum captured 45 pounds of dust over 83 minutes of grinding for an average rate of dust collection of 0.54 pounds per minute. The rate of dust collection ranged from 0.47 to 0.63 pounds per minute. Based on these measurements, approximately 130 pounds of dust would likely be captured after just 4 hours of continuous grinding.
The rate of grinding a combination of vertical and horizontal joints while using the LEV system ranged from 2.3 to 3.3 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the use of the LEV system ranged from 2.6 to 3.4 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place ranged from 4.7 to 5.1 feet per minute. It’s important to note that: 1) the operator had limited experience using dust control systems and cut rates appeared to improve slightly over the 2-day period he used the tested equipment; and 2) the upper range of cut rates with the dust control system overlapped with the lowest cut rate with the original guard and without the LEV system in place indicating no statistical difference between cut rates. Given that grinding rates with and without use of this LEV system are only available for one operator and he had limited experience with the LEV system, these reported cut rates are in no way intended to represent the impact use of this LEV system is likely to have on productivity rates overall.
VI. Discussion
The objective of these trials was to evaluate the effectiveness of a tuckpointing LEV system for controlling respirable silica while grinding out mortar joints. The Dust Director shroud with the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced respirable silica concentrations when grinding with the Bosch grinder by approximately 99 percent. Despite being considered effective by our test criteria (greater than 50% reduction), it still resulted in task TWA exposures that exceeded the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 by 1.8 times. Depending on how much time is spent grinding over the course of a work day and on exposures while performing other tasks, the 8-hour TWA exposures may or may not exceed the REL with this system. Use of this system by workers with experience and training in proficient use will likely improve dust capture performance. Exposure reduction is greatly influenced by correct use of this system which includes grinding from right to left, making sure the shroud is held flush against the wall and that the tool travels at a pace that doesn’t exceed the ability of the system to capture dust as it’s generated. Deviation from any of these measures produces visible dust clouds which were observed during trials.
VII. Conclusions
With a 99 percent reduction in respirable silica exposure, the Dust Director shroud and DustControl 2900c vacuum with a Bosch Model 1775E grinder was effective in reducing silica exposures based on our criteria. Use of the tested dust control system may be effective in reducing silica exposure on the job to less than the NIOSH REL if used in combination with administrative controls such as work scheduling to reduce cutting times as needed. Training on correct use of the tested system is also essential. Personal air monitoring is necessary to verify control effectiveness on actual job sites and under “real-world” conditions. However, these results clearly demonstrate the availability of viable and effective engineering controls for tuckpointing operations associated with elevated silica exposure.
VIII. References
American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists. Threshold limit values for chemical substances (TLV®-CS). [2013]. ACGIH, Cincinnati, Ohio.
Bergdahl I.A,. Toren K., Eriksson K., et al. [2004]. Increased mortality in COPD among construction workers exposed to inorganic dust. European Respiratory Journal, 23: 402–06.
Blanc P.D. & Torén K. [2007]. Occupation in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and chronic bronchitis: an update [State of the Art Series. Occupational lung disease in high-and low-income countries, Edited by M. Chan-Yeung. Number 2 in the series]. The International Journal of Tuberculosis and Lung Disease, 11(3), 251-257.
Collingwood S. & Heitbrink W.A. [2007] 'Field Evaluation of an Engineering Control for Respirable Crystalline Silica Exposures During Mortar Removal'. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, 4:11, 875 – 887.
DHHS (NIOSH) Publication No. 2002-129 April 2002 http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/2002-129/
Echt A., Sieber W.K., Lefkowitz D., Meeker J., Susi P., Cardwell B., Heitbrink, W.A. In-depth survey of dust control technology for cutting concrete block and tuckpointing brick at The International Masonry Institute Bordentown Training Center, Bordentown, NJ. Cincinnati, OH: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Report. No. EPHB 282-13; 2007. http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ECTB-282-13.pdf
Heitbrink W., Bennett J. [2006]. A numerical and experimental investigation of crystalline silica exposure control during tuck pointing. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, Vol. 3, pp 366-378.
Lyons et al, [2007]. A breathless builder. Breathe, Vol. 3, no. 4, pp 386-390.
Mastrangelo G., Tartari M., Fedeli U., Fadda E., Saia B. [2003]. Ascertaining the risk of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease in relation to occupation using a case-control design. Occupational Medicine, 53: 165–172.
Meeker J., Cooper M., Lefrowitz D., Susi P. [2009]. Engineering control technologies to reduce occupational silica exposures in masonry cutting and tuckpointing. Public Health Reports, Supplement 1, Vol. 124, June.
Meeker J, Flynn M, Susi P, Cardwell, B [2004]. Performance evaluation of a masonry concrete vacuum. Unpublished Report.
Miller F. W., Alfredsson L., Costenbader K. H., Kamen D. L., Nelson L. M., Norris J. M., & De Roos A. J. [2012]. Epidemiology of environmental exposures and human autoimmune diseases: findings from a National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences Expert Panel workshop. Journal of autoimmunity. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3496812/
Occupational Safety and Health Administration U.S Department of Labor. Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction. [2009]. OSHA 3362-05.
Rappaport SM, Goldberg M, Susi P, Herrick RF [2003]. Excessive exposure to silica in the U.S. construction industry. Annals of Occupational Hygiene, Vol. 47, pp. 111-122.
IX. Appendices
| Measurement Conditions |
n | Mean Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Median
Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before filter cleaning | 5 | 80 | 81 | 78-81 |
| After filter cleaning following manufacturer directions | 9 | 89 | 90 | 84-93 |
| * Static pressure was measured in millibars and converted to inches of water gauge. Flow rates were calculated using the formula Q = Ce (A) 4005 (SP)1/2 where: Q = flow in cubic feet per minute (cfm), Ce = coefficient of entry, A = area of the duct where static pressure measurements were taken in square feet, and SP = static pressure in inches of water gauge. | ||||
| Tool/Control | Collection Period (min.) |
Dust Collection Rate (lb/min.) |
|---|---|---|
| Bosch grinder/Dust Director shroud & DustControl 2900c vacuum |
8 11 8 8 10 |
0.50 0.61 0.50 0.47 0.63 |
| Average | 0.54 |
[disclaimer:protected] => [disclaimer_transformed:protected] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [template] => record ) [_globalContext:PHPTAL_Context:private] => stdClass Object ( ) [_echoDeclarations:PHPTAL_Context:private] => [referer] => http://www.elcosh.org/document/3908/d001345/An%2BEvaluation%2Bof%2BSilica%2BExposure%2BControls%2Bfor%2BTuckpointing%253A%2BDustControl%2B2900c%2BVacuum%2Bwith%2Bthe%2BICS%2BDust%2BDirector%2BShroud%2Band%2BBosch%2BGrinder%2BModel%2B1775E%2BConducted%2BNovember%2B14-15%252C%2B2012.html [curr_module] => Record [styles] => Array ( ) [javascript] => Array ( [0] => jquery.min.js ) [metas] => Array ( [language] => en [robots] => index, follow ) [user] => [curr_url] => https://www.elcosh.org/index.php?module=Record&id=3908&type=document [base_url] => https://www.elcosh.org/index.php?module=Record [title] => eLCOSH : An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: DustControl 2900c Vacuum with the ICS Dust Director Shroud and Bosch Grinder Model 1775E Conducted November 14-15, 2012 [language] => en [search_query] => [module] => Record [new_records] => Array ( [0] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Fixed Ladder [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Fixed Ladders addresses the potential risks associated with using fixed ladders. The resource includes a brief case example,... [category] => Array ( [0] => 15 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 53 [5] => 55 [6] => 60 [7] => 64 [8] => 73 [9] => 76 [10] => 78 [11] => 80 [12] => 86 [13] => 87 [14] => 90 [15] => 92 [16] => 93 [17] => 94 [18] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Falls [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Concrete Polisher [11] => Electrical Worker [13] => HVAC [15] => Laborer [17] => PCC/Restoration [19] => Plumber/Pipefitter [21] => Roofer/Waterproofer [23] => Sheetmetal Worker [25] => Welder [27] => Commercial & Institutional [28] => Jobsites [29] => Industrial [31] => LEED/Green Construction [33] => Renovations [35] => Residential [37] => Toolbox Talks [38] => Documents [39] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4430/d001660/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BFixed%2BLadder.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [53] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 53 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Concrete Polisher [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [73] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 73 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => PCC/Restoration [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4430 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001660 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Fixed Ladder [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Fixed Ladders, Fall Prevention, Falls [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Fixed Ladders addresses the potential risks associated with using fixed ladders. The resource includes a brief case example, steps to prevent a related injury and questions for discussion. It includes an image that illustrates the hazard, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001257,d001254,d001255,d001256,d001258,d001262,d001279 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_completed:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/22/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [1] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Challenges Preventing Falling Objects [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Challenges Preventing Falling Objects addresses the hazards of being struck by falling objects on the job site. The resource... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 55 [5] => 64 [6] => 68 [7] => 71 [8] => 75 [9] => 78 [10] => 79 [11] => 82 [12] => 62 [13] => 86 [14] => 87 [15] => 88 [16] => 89 [17] => 91 [18] => 90 [19] => 92 [20] => 93 [21] => 94 [22] => 95 [23] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Electrical Worker [11] => Laborer [13] => Maintenance Worker [15] => Painter [17] => Plasterer [19] => Roofer/Waterproofer [21] => Scaffold Erector [23] => Stonemason [25] => Structural Ironworker [27] => Welder [29] => Commercial & Institutional [30] => Jobsites [31] => Demolition [33] => Disasters [35] => Heavy & Highway [37] => Industrial [39] => LEED/Green Construction [41] => Renovations [43] => Residential [45] => Underground [47] => Toolbox Talks [48] => Documents [49] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4431/d001661/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BChallenges%2BPreventing%2BFalling%2BObjects.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4431 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001661 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Challenges Preventing Falling Objects [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => dropped objects, falling objects, struck by incidents, struck by fatalities [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Challenges Preventing Falling Objects addresses the hazards of being struck by falling objects on the job site. The resource includes a brief example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates a group workers observing a scaffold free of debris during high winds, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001234,d001238,d001244,d001251,d001253,d001260,d001268,d001278 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_completed:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/22/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [2] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Tower Crane Safety [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Tower Crane Safety addresses the potential hazards of Tower Cranes and the importance of following procedure before and durin... [category] => Array ( [0] => 11 [1] => 12 [2] => 18 [3] => 70 [4] => 87 [5] => 88 [6] => 91 [7] => 90 [8] => 92 [9] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Cranes & Hoists [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Crushed/Struck By [6] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [9] => Operating Engineer [10] => Trades [11] => Commercial & Institutional [12] => Jobsites [13] => Demolition [15] => Heavy & Highway [17] => Industrial [19] => LEED/Green Construction [21] => Toolbox Talks [22] => Documents [23] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4427/d001657/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BTower%2BCrane%2BSafety.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [11] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 11 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Cranes & Hoists [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [18] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 18 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4427 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001657 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Tower Crane Safety [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Tower Crane, Crane, Stability, Tipping, Lift Zone Safety, Lift, Zone, Safety, Struck by [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Tower Crane Safety addresses the potential hazards of Tower Cranes and the importance of following procedure before and during Tower Crane operation. The resource includes a brief example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates a worker inspecting a Tower Crane before operation, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001234,d001238,d001250,d001251,d001253,d001258,d001262,d001273 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/19/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [3] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Work Zone Safety: Working Around Vehicles [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Working Around Vehicles in the Work Zone addresses methods to avoid being struck-by a vehicle on a construction site. The res... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 18 [2] => 52 [3] => 57 [4] => 70 [5] => 85 [6] => 87 [7] => 88 [8] => 89 [9] => 91 [10] => 90 [11] => 92 [12] => 93 [13] => 94 [14] => 95 [15] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [6] => Commercial Diver [7] => Trades [8] => Flagger [10] => Operating Engineer [12] => Truck Driver [14] => Commercial & Institutional [15] => Jobsites [16] => Demolition [18] => Disasters [20] => Heavy & Highway [22] => Industrial [24] => LEED/Green Construction [26] => Renovations [28] => Residential [30] => Underground [32] => Toolbox Talks [33] => Documents [34] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4428/d001658/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BWork%2BZone%2BSafety%253A%2BWorking%2BAround%2BVehicles.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [18] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 18 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [52] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 52 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Commercial Diver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [85] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 85 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Truck Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4428 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001658 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Daniela Caceres [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Work Zone Safety: Working Around Vehicles [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Struck, Struck by, Vehicle, Work Zone Safety, Truck, Operator, Driver, Mobile Equipment [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Working Around Vehicles in the Work Zone addresses methods to avoid being struck-by a vehicle on a construction site. The resource includes a case example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates the hazard, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001640 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/19/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [4] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Construction Dive -- DeWalt's Jobsite Pro headphones recalled for fire hazards [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => A recall notice by the United States Consumer Product Safety Commission affects over 300,000 DeWalt Jobsite Pro Headphones. The recall is a result of... [category] => Array ( [0] => 16 [1] => 44 [2] => 45 [3] => 46 [4] => 47 [5] => 48 [6] => 49 [7] => 50 [8] => 51 [9] => 52 [10] => 53 [11] => 54 [12] => 55 [13] => 56 [14] => 57 [15] => 58 [16] => 59 [17] => 60 [18] => 61 [19] => 64 [20] => 65 [21] => 66 [22] => 67 [23] => 68 [24] => 69 [25] => 70 [26] => 71 [27] => 72 [28] => 73 [29] => 74 [30] => 75 [31] => 76 [32] => 77 [33] => 63 [34] => 78 [35] => 79 [36] => 80 [37] => 81 [38] => 82 [39] => 62 [40] => 83 [41] => 84 [42] => 85 [43] => 86 [44] => 87 [45] => 88 [46] => 89 [47] => 91 [48] => 90 [49] => 92 [50] => 93 [51] => 94 [52] => 95 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Fire & Explosions [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Acoustical Ceiling Carpenter [4] => Trades [5] => Asbestos/Insulator [7] => Boilermaker [9] => Bricklayer [11] => Cabinetmaker [13] => Carpenter [15] => Carpet Layer [17] => Cement Mason [19] => Commercial Diver [21] => Concrete Polisher [23] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [25] => Electrical Worker [27] => Elevator Constructor [29] => Flagger [31] => Glazier [33] => Hazardous Waste Cleanup [35] => HVAC [37] => Interior Systems Carpenter [39] => Laborer [41] => Landscaper [43] => Lather [45] => Lead Abatement Worker [47] => Maintenance Worker [49] => Millwright [51] => Operating Engineer [53] => Painter [55] => Paper Hanger [57] => PCC/Restoration [59] => Pile Driver [61] => Plasterer [63] => Plumber/Pipefitter [65] => Refractory Worker [67] => Reinforcing Ironworker [69] => Roofer/Waterproofer [71] => Scaffold Erector [73] => Sheetmetal Worker [75] => Sprinkler Fitter [77] => Stonemason [79] => Structural Ironworker [81] => Terrazzo Worker [83] => Tile Setter [85] => Truck Driver [87] => Welder [89] => Commercial & Institutional [90] => Jobsites [91] => Demolition [93] => Disasters [95] => Heavy & Highway [97] => Industrial [99] => LEED/Green Construction [101] => Renovations [103] => Residential [105] => Underground ) [type] => [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4426/d001656/Construction%2BDive%2B--%2BDeWalt%2527s%2BJobsite%2BPro%2Bheadphones%2Brecalled%2Bfor%2Bfire%2Bhazards.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [16] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 16 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Fire & Explosions [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [44] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 44 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Acoustical Ceiling Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [45] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 45 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Asbestos/Insulator [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [46] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 46 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Boilermaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [48] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 48 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cabinetmaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [50] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 50 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpet Layer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [52] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 52 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Commercial Diver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [53] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 53 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Concrete Polisher [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [54] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 54 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [58] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 58 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Glazier [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [59] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 59 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Hazardous Waste Cleanup [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [65] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 65 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Landscaper [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [66] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 66 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Lather [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [67] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 67 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Lead Abatement Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [69] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 69 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Millwright [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [72] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 72 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Paper Hanger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [73] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 73 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => PCC/Restoration [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [77] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 77 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Refractory Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [81] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 81 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sprinkler Fitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [83] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 83 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Terrazzo Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [84] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 84 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Tile Setter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [85] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 85 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Truck Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4426 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001656 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Construction Dive -- DeWalt's Jobsite Pro headphones recalled for fire hazards [total_pages:protected] => 1 [billed_pages:protected] => 1 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => DeWalt, Fire Hazards, recall, headphones [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A recall notice by the United States Consumer Product Safety Commission affects over 300,000 DeWalt Jobsite Pro Headphones. The recall is a result of a malfunction that can cause earbuds to overheat while charging or during use, leading to fire and burn hazards. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => https://www.constructiondive.com/news/dewalts-jobsite-pro-headphones-recalled-for-fire-hazards/611248/?utm_source=Sailthru&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Issue:%202021-12-10%20Construction%20Dive%20Newsletter%20%5Bissue:38532%5D&utm_term=Construction%20Dive [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/13/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/13/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 12/13/21 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [new_images] => Array ( [0] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Morning Toolbox Talk [image] => /record/images/4003-p.jpg [blurb] => This photo is from an early morning toolbox talk on a construction job in Mclean, Virginia. It is being delivered in English and Spanish.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 20 [1] => 51 [2] => 57 [3] => 64 [4] => 70 [5] => 63 [6] => 78 [7] => 82 [8] => 62 [9] => 87 [10] => 88 [11] => 89 [12] => 91 [13] => 90 [14] => 93 [15] => 94 [16] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Safety Culture [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Cement Mason [4] => Trades [5] => Flagger [7] => Laborer [9] => Operating Engineer [11] => Reinforcing Ironworker [13] => Roofer/Waterproofer [15] => Stonemason [17] => Structural Ironworker [19] => Commercial & Institutional [20] => Jobsites [21] => Demolition [23] => Disasters [25] => Heavy & Highway [27] => Industrial [29] => Renovations [31] => Residential [33] => Images [34] => Media [35] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4003/i002691/Morning%2BToolbox%2BTalk.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4003 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002691 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Morning Toolbox Talk [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, Spanish, bilingual [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This photo is from an early morning toolbox talk on a construction job in Mclean, Virginia. It is being delivered in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001285,d001304,c000079 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [1] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox talk - crew view [image] => /record/images/4005-p.jpg [blurb] => Photo of crew listening to a toolbox safety talk before starting work.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 97 [1] => 20 [2] => 47 [3] => 49 [4] => 51 [5] => 55 [6] => 61 [7] => 64 [8] => 71 [9] => 75 [10] => 63 [11] => 79 [12] => 62 [13] => 87 [14] => 88 [15] => 91 [16] => 90 [17] => 93 [18] => 94 [19] => 95 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Images [1] => Media [2] => Media & Documents [3] => Safety Culture [4] => Work Environment [5] => Hazards [6] => Bricklayer [7] => Trades [8] => Carpenter [10] => Cement Mason [12] => Electrical Worker [14] => Interior Systems Carpenter [16] => Laborer [18] => Painter [20] => Plasterer [22] => Reinforcing Ironworker [24] => Scaffold Erector [26] => Structural Ironworker [28] => Commercial & Institutional [29] => Jobsites [30] => Demolition [32] => Heavy & Highway [34] => Industrial [36] => Renovations [38] => Residential [40] => Underground ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4005/i002692/Toolbox%2Btalk%2B-%2Bcrew%2Bview.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4005 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002692 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox talk - crew view [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, safety talk, Spanish [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Photo of crew listening to a toolbox safety talk before starting work. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002691,d001269, c000079, d001285 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [2] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox talk - long shot [image] => /record/images/4006-p.jpg [blurb] => This crew gathered every morning before starting work to discuss a new safety topic.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 20 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 55 [5] => 64 [6] => 68 [7] => 75 [8] => 76 [9] => 63 [10] => 78 [11] => 79 [12] => 82 [13] => 62 [14] => 87 [15] => 88 [16] => 91 [17] => 90 [18] => 93 [19] => 94 [20] => 95 [21] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Safety Culture [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Electrical Worker [11] => Laborer [13] => Maintenance Worker [15] => Plasterer [17] => Plumber/Pipefitter [19] => Reinforcing Ironworker [21] => Roofer/Waterproofer [23] => Scaffold Erector [25] => Stonemason [27] => Structural Ironworker [29] => Commercial & Institutional [30] => Jobsites [31] => Demolition [33] => Heavy & Highway [35] => Industrial [37] => Renovations [39] => Residential [41] => Underground [43] => Images [44] => Media [45] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4006/i002693/Toolbox%2Btalk%2B-%2Blong%2Bshot.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4006 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002693 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox talk - long shot [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, safety minute [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This crew gathered every morning before starting work to discuss a new safety topic. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002691,i002692,d001269,d000527 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [3] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Safety officer discussing ongoing project with marketing coordinator [image] => /record/images/4014-p.jpg [blurb] => The safety officer (left) points out the good safety practices on this project that reflect well on the firm and may influence future clients.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 97 [1] => 20 [2] => 46 [3] => 47 [4] => 49 [5] => 50 [6] => 51 [7] => 54 [8] => 55 [9] => 58 [10] => 60 [11] => 61 [12] => 64 [13] => 71 [14] => 75 [15] => 76 [16] => 63 [17] => 79 [18] => 80 [19] => 82 [20] => 62 [21] => 83 [22] => 87 [23] => 91 [24] => 90 [25] => 93 [26] => 94 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Images [1] => Media [2] => Media & Documents [3] => Safety Culture [4] => Work Environment [5] => Hazards [6] => Boilermaker [7] => Trades [8] => Bricklayer [10] => Carpenter [12] => Carpet Layer [14] => Cement Mason [16] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [18] => Electrical Worker [20] => Glazier [22] => HVAC [24] => Interior Systems Carpenter [26] => Laborer [28] => Painter [30] => Plasterer [32] => Plumber/Pipefitter [34] => Reinforcing Ironworker [36] => Scaffold Erector [38] => Sheetmetal Worker [40] => Stonemason [42] => Structural Ironworker [44] => Terrazzo Worker [46] => Commercial & Institutional [47] => Jobsites [48] => Heavy & Highway [50] => Industrial [52] => Renovations [54] => Residential ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4014/i002700/Safety%2Bofficer%2Bdiscussing%2Bongoing%2Bproject%2Bwith%2Bmarketing%2Bcoordinator.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [46] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 46 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Boilermaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [50] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 50 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpet Layer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [54] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 54 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [58] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 58 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Glazier [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [83] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 83 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Terrazzo Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4014 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002700 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Safety officer discussing ongoing project with marketing coordinator [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Latino, safety officer, safety culture [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The safety officer (left) points out the good safety practices on this project that reflect well on the firm and may influence future clients. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/index.php [more_like_this:protected] => d000989,d001351,d001362,d000652, d001101, d000931, d001395 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Hoar Construction, Photo by Neil Lippy [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 01/30/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [4] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Scaffolding at top of large column [image] => /record/images/3994-p.jpg [blurb] => This shot shows innovative guarding around the top of a large concrete column in the base of a high rise structure going up.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 15 [1] => 21 [2] => 47 [3] => 51 [4] => 63 [5] => 78 [6] => 79 [7] => 80 [8] => 62 [9] => 87 [10] => 97 [11] => 56 [12] => 64 [13] => 74 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Falls [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Scaffolds [6] => Bricklayer [7] => Trades [8] => Cement Mason [10] => Reinforcing Ironworker [12] => Roofer/Waterproofer [14] => Scaffold Erector [16] => Sheetmetal Worker [18] => Structural Ironworker [20] => Commercial & Institutional [21] => Jobsites [22] => Images [23] => Media [24] => Media & Documents [25] => Elevator Constructor [27] => Laborer [29] => Pile Driver ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/3994/i002689/Scaffolding%2Bat%2Btop%2Bof%2Blarge%2Bcolumn.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [21] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 21 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Scaffolds [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3994 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002689 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Scaffolding at top of large column [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Guardrail, railing, fall prevention, falls [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This shot shows innovative guarding around the top of a large concrete column in the base of a high rise structure going up. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/8/adjustable-tower-scaffold.html [more_like_this:protected] => c1002680,i002662,d000608,d001255 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Photo by Pam Susi [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2016 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_completed:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/01/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [5] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Construction bracing [image] => /record/images/3995-p.jpg [blurb] => This shows structural support that prevents collapses during construction.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 15 [2] => 21 [3] => 49 [4] => 51 [5] => 55 [6] => 56 [7] => 60 [8] => 64 [9] => 68 [10] => 74 [11] => 63 [12] => 78 [13] => 79 [14] => 80 [15] => 62 [16] => 87 [17] => 90 [18] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Falls [6] => Scaffolds [9] => Carpenter [10] => Trades [11] => Cement Mason [13] => Electrical Worker [15] => Elevator Constructor [17] => HVAC [19] => Laborer [21] => Maintenance Worker [23] => Pile Driver [25] => Reinforcing Ironworker [27] => Roofer/Waterproofer [29] => Scaffold Erector [31] => Sheetmetal Worker [33] => Structural Ironworker [35] => Commercial & Institutional [36] => Jobsites [37] => Industrial [39] => Images [40] => Media [41] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/3995/i002690/Construction%2Bbracing.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [21] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 21 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Scaffolds [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3995 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002690 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Construction bracing [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Bracing, support, scaffold [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This shows structural support that prevents collapses during construction. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/8/adjustable-tower-scaffold.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002660 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Photo by Pam Susi [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2016 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_completed:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/01/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [preview_mode] => [description] => The results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. [keywords] => tuckpointing, HEPA vacuum, dust control, LEV, local exhaust ventilation, silica [related_items] => Array ( [Research Reports] => Array ( [0] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1874 [old_id:protected] => 722 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000683 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Sharon Garber/COD [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Protecting Tuckpointing Workers from Silica Dust: Draft Recommendations for a Ventilated Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 12 [billed_pages:protected] => 12 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, vacuum, grinder, mortar, respirator, OSHA, NIOSH, exhaust, Heitbrink, tuckpointer, silica, masonry, dust, silicosis, LEV [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Describes draft recommendations for use of ventilated grinder to reduce dust during tuckpointing and describes field trials using these devices. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/hazard/67/chip-scrape-and-grind-surfaces-or-joints-silica.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001201,d000292,d000293,d000658 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2005 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/27/05 [date_completed:protected] => 04/26/05 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/20/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [1] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1940 [old_id:protected] => 909 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Workplace Solutions: Control of Hazardous Dust During Tuckpointing [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, silica, dust, tuckpoint, grinder, masonry restoration, mortar, vacuum [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d000819,d000820,d000730,d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 10/24/08 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/09 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [2] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3899 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001342 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: Hilti VC40-U Vacuum with Hilti DC-EX Dust Guard and Hilti Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 15 [billed_pages:protected] => 15 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP4 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => silica, tuckpointing, Hilti, local exhaust systems, LEV, shroud, quartz [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This report describes the results of an evaluation of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Hilti VC40-U vacuum, a Hilti DC-EX shroud, and a Hilti DAG-500 grinder. Randomized trials with and without use of the dust control system were conducted in a controlled setting. Removing mortar with the Hilti grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 220 times the National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05mg/m3. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 97 percent. However, exposures measured during the use of the dust control system still exceeded the NIOSH REL. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => December 1, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/05/14 [date_completed:protected] => 02/04/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/06/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [Handouts] => Array ( [0] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3656 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001198 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 24 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction While Doing Tuckpointing/Mortar Removal [total_pages:protected] => 2 [billed_pages:protected] => 2 [publication_number:protected] => DSG FS-3632 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Brick, block, tuckpointing, silica, local exhaust ventilation, LEV, masonry [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Tuckpointing creates some of the greatest exposures to silica in construction. This OSHA factsheet provides guidance on how to greatly reduce these exposures through the use of local exhaust ventilation. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863, d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => February 2013 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/04/13 [date_completed:protected] => 03/27/13 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [collections] => Array ( [3913] => ) [record] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => Array ( [867] => Author Object ( [id:protected] => 867 [organization_id:protected] => 0 [firstname:protected] => Michael [lastname:protected] => Cooper [address:protected] => [city:protected] => [province:protected] => [country:protected] => [postal_code:protected] => [department:protected] => [title:protected] => [phone:protected] => [fax:protected] => [email:protected] => [degree:protected] => [website:protected] => [about:protected] => [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => [date_completed:protected] => [date_billed:protected] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [481] => Author Object ( [id:protected] => 481 [organization_id:protected] => 0 [firstname:protected] => Pam [lastname:protected] => Susi [address:protected] => 8484 Georgia Avenue, Suite 1000 [city:protected] => Silver Spring [province:protected] => Maryland [country:protected] => USA [postal_code:protected] => 20910 [department:protected] => [title:protected] => [phone:protected] => 301-578-8500 ext.144 [fax:protected] => 301-578-8572 [email:protected] => plsusi@aol.com [degree:protected] => [website:protected] => http://www.cpwr.com [about:protected] => [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => 2003-10-02 [date_completed:protected] => 2003-10-06 [date_billed:protected] => 2003-11-03 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [organizations:protected] => Array ( [1] => Organization Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [elcosh_id:protected] => o000001 [user_id:protected] => 14 [province_id:protected] => 21 [country_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => CPWR - The Center for Construction Research and Training [address:protected] => Suite 1000, 8484 Georgia Ave [postal_code:protected] => 20910 [city:protected] => Silver Spring [department:protected] => [phone:protected] => 301-578-8500 [fax:protected] => 301-578-8572 [email:protected] => cpwrwebsite@cpwr.com [website:protected] => http://www.cpwr.com [filename:protected] => o000001.gif [about:protected] => CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training, developed, and continues to maintain/expand this website - The Electronic Library of Construction Occupational Safety and Health, www.elcosh.org. CPWR, formerly known as The Center to Protect Workers’ Rights, is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit research and training institution. Created by the Building and Construction Trades Department, AFL-CIO, CPWR serves as the research arm of the BCTD. Since the inception of its research agenda in 1990, CPWR has grown into a worldwide provider of safety and health information covering all aspects of the construction industry. CPWR launched eLCOSH in 2000, and the Spanish-language version of the site in 2001. CPWR also created, and continues to build, Construction Solutions - www.cpwrConstructionSolutions.org - a free, online database of construction hazards and ways to prevent, eliminate, or reduce them. [comments:protected] => [logo_available:protected] => T [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => 2000-08-18 [date_completed:protected] => 2000-08-30 [date_billed:protected] => 2000-09-05 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [collections:protected] => Array ( [3913] => ) [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => Array ( [1874] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1874 [old_id:protected] => 722 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000683 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Sharon Garber/COD [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Protecting Tuckpointing Workers from Silica Dust: Draft Recommendations for a Ventilated Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 12 [billed_pages:protected] => 12 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, vacuum, grinder, mortar, respirator, OSHA, NIOSH, exhaust, Heitbrink, tuckpointer, silica, masonry, dust, silicosis, LEV [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Describes draft recommendations for use of ventilated grinder to reduce dust during tuckpointing and describes field trials using these devices. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/hazard/67/chip-scrape-and-grind-surfaces-or-joints-silica.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001201,d000292,d000293,d000658 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2005 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/27/05 [date_completed:protected] => 04/26/05 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/20/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [1940] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1940 [old_id:protected] => 909 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Workplace Solutions: Control of Hazardous Dust During Tuckpointing [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, silica, dust, tuckpoint, grinder, masonry restoration, mortar, vacuum [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d000819,d000820,d000730,d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 10/24/08 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/09 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [2213] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 2213 [old_id:protected] => 1090 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => [language_id:protected] => 2 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Control del polvo peligroso que se genera durante los procesos de reparación de mortero [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => 2008-126 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => [comments:protected] => http://www.cdc.gov/spanish/niosh/docs/wp-solutions/2008-126_sp/ [summary:protected] => A Workplace Solutions de NIOSH que resume un estudio de NIOSH sobre los riesgos de exposición cuando se reparan las estructuras y los métodos para controlar el polvo. [A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust.] [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => D000819,D000820,D000730,d000819 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 01/07/10 [date_completed:protected] => 04/19/10 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 07/08/12 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [3656] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3656 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001198 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 24 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction While Doing Tuckpointing/Mortar Removal [total_pages:protected] => 2 [billed_pages:protected] => 2 [publication_number:protected] => DSG FS-3632 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Brick, block, tuckpointing, silica, local exhaust ventilation, LEV, masonry [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Tuckpointing creates some of the greatest exposures to silica in construction. This OSHA factsheet provides guidance on how to greatly reduce these exposures through the use of local exhaust ventilation. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863, d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => February 2013 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/04/13 [date_completed:protected] => 03/27/13 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [3899] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3899 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001342 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: Hilti VC40-U Vacuum with Hilti DC-EX Dust Guard and Hilti Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 15 [billed_pages:protected] => 15 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP4 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => silica, tuckpointing, Hilti, local exhaust systems, LEV, shroud, quartz [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This report describes the results of an evaluation of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Hilti VC40-U vacuum, a Hilti DC-EX shroud, and a Hilti DAG-500 grinder. Randomized trials with and without use of the dust control system were conducted in a controlled setting. Removing mortar with the Hilti grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 220 times the National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05mg/m3. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 97 percent. However, exposures measured during the use of the dust control system still exceeded the NIOSH REL. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => December 1, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/05/14 [date_completed:protected] => 02/04/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/06/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [content:protected] => [files:protected] => Array ( [559] => [560] => [546] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 546 [filename:protected] => 3.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:22 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [566] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 566 [filename:protected] => 4.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:23 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [720] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 720 [filename:protected] => 5.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [721] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 721 [filename:protected] => 6.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [722] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 722 [filename:protected] => 7.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [9765] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 9765 [filename:protected] => d001345.pdf [downloadable:protected] => T [timestamp:protected] => 2015-02-09 12:26:04 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3908 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001345 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: DustControl 2900c Vacuum with the ICS Dust Director Shroud and Bosch Grinder Model 1775E Conducted November 14-15, 2012 [total_pages:protected] => 13 [billed_pages:protected] => 13 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP2 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => tuckpointing, HEPA vacuum, dust control, LEV, local exhaust ventilation, silica [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => April 15, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 01/26/15 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/09/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [show_text] => [document_content] => ElcoshItemDocumentContent Object ( [id:protected] => 2934 [item_id:protected] => 3908 [type:protected] => main [title:protected] => [content:protected] =>
Executive Summary
This report describes the results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. It should also be noted that the NIOSH REL is based on exposures averaged over a ten hour work day and our results represent time weighted averages of the sample task duration periods.
Acronyms
ACGIH - American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists
CPWR - CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training
Ce - coefficient of entry
HEPA - high-efficiency particulate air
IUBAC - International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craftworkers
LEV - local exhaust ventilation
PACT - Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies
NIOSH - National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health
OEL - occupational exposure limit
OSHA - Occupational Safety and Health Administration
PAPR - powered air-purifying respirator
PEL - Permissible Exposure Limit
PVC - polyvinyl chloride
REL - Recommended Exposure Limit
RPM - revolutions per minute
TWA - time-weighted average
SP - static pressure
I. Introduction and Background
In 2010 CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training began a four-year project which seeks to identify and evaluate tuckpointing local exhaust ventilation (LEV) systems and disseminate information on their availability and effectiveness. A Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies (PACT) comprised of masonry contractors, representatives from unions, government, equipment manufacturers, and health and safety researcher was formed as part of this project. PACT members participated in identifying important characteristics for control technologies and this information was used to identify LEV systems for tuckpointing using that criteria. Contractor and labor members of the PACT selected specific tuckpointing LEV systems to be considered for evaluation. Each system consisted of a tuckpointing grinder, shroud, and vacuum. This report describes the second of four systems to be evaluated between 2012 the end of 2014, with and without LEV, in a controlled setting to determine effectiveness in silica exposure reduction. This report describes the methods and results of our evaluation of a system consisting of the DustControl 2900c vacuum with the ICS Dust Director shroud and a Bosch Model 1775E grinder.
Excessive exposure to respirable silica can result in silicosis or other silica-related diseases including pulmonary tuberculosis, lung cancer, silicoproteinosis (Lyons et al, 2007) and autoimmune disorders such as rheumatoid arthritis, sarcoidosis and scleroderma (Miller et al, 2012). Respirable silica is generally defined as particles less than 10 micrometers (μm) in aerodynamic diameter (ACGIH, 2013). Silicosis can lead to symptoms including shortness of breath, fatigue, chest pains, susceptibility to infection and possibly death. There is no cure for silicosis, however it is totally preventable. Construction workers exposed to dust, including silica, are also known to have higher rates of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD).
There are many sources of silica in construction that result in exposures of varying intensity among workers. Masonry restoration workers are among the most highly silica-exposed trades in construction. The process of grinding out deteriorated mortar joints between masonry units and replacing or repointing with fresh mortar (often referred to as tuckpointing) is a fundamental part of masonry restoration work. The removal of mortar with powered angle grinders generates enormous levels of dust. Between 2004 and 2006, NIOSH and CPWR evaluated silica exposures while grinding mortar in a controlled setting, at a local training center, where tasks, sample times and task variables were defined by the study design. These studies demonstrated that grinding mortar without controls can result in elevated respirable silica exposures. Meeker et al., (2009) reported exposures between 5 and 25.8 milligrams per cubic meter (mg/m3) in a controlled setting. This study also showed that LEV systems for tuckpointing grinders can reduce exposures to respirable silica by greater than 90 percent.II. Objectives
The objective of this evaluation was to assess the effectiveness of an LEV system for controlling exposure to silica during the grinding of mortar. The control technology was tested under controlled conditions, similar to those experienced by tuckpointers on actual job sites, using journeymen bricklayers experienced in tuckpointing and repeat, randomized trials with and without LEV. All other variables were held constant throughout so that the only variable was whether or not the tested control was used.
III. Description of Equipment Tested
A Bosch model 1775E grinder (Robert Bosch Tool Corporation, Prospect, IL) (Figures 1, 2 and 3) was fitted with a new 1/4-inch wide, 4½-inch diameter segmented diamond abrasive blade made by DeWalt (model #DW4740). The grinder weighs six and a half pounds, draws 8.5 amps and has a variable speed up to 11,000 revolutions per minute (RPMs). The DustControl 2900c vacuum (DustControl, Inc., Wilmington, NC) (Figure 3) was tested in combination with the Dust Director shroud (Industrial Contractors’ Supplies, Inc., Huntingdon, PA) (Figures 1 and 3) attached to the Bosch grinder.
Figure 1. Bosch grinder with Dust Director shroud
Figure 2. Bosch grinder without tuckpointing LEV system.
Figure 3: Bosch Grinder with LEV System
The vacuum is specified to weigh 31 pounds when empty and to provide a flow rate of 114 cubic feet of air per minute and a “static lift” or “vacuum suction pressure” of 84 inches of water. The vacuum is sold with a cyclonic pre-separator, to remove larger particles, a fine filter (rated 99.9 percent efficient) and a HEPA (high-efficiency particulate air) filter (rated to capture 99.97 percent of the particles with an aerodynamic diameter of 0.3 micrometers). The HEPA filter was removed based on the manufacturer’s recommendation due to the heavy dust loading associated with tuckpointing. CPWR sponsored research and contractor experience indicate that HEPA filters likely have an adverse effect on dust capture during tuckpointing because of extreme dust loading on filters. While the cyclone and the fine filter remove most of the dust, especially the large particles, before they reach the HEPA filter, the HEPA filter would still be subject to heavy loading, causing a substantial pressure drop and subsequent decrease in air flow rate. The relatively small increase in the efficiency of the filtration system while using the HEPA filter is expected to be quickly offset by a more significant decrease in capture efficiency as the air flow rate and ability to capture particles decreases.
Dust collects in relatively inexpensive, heavy-gauge plastic bags below and outside of the cyclone. The bags can be removed and replaced without opening the vacuum. Some vacuums are equipped with a light to indicate that the filters need to be cleaned or changed. The DC2900c features a “reverse air pulse cleaning system,” which removes accumulated dust from the filters without having to remove them from the vacuum. The system, as illustrated in Figure 4, requires the operator to disconnect the hose from the shroud, place it over an air stop so that air through the hose is cut off and pressure in the vacuum is maximized.
Figure 4. Procedure for "cleaning" of or dust removal from filters (source: http://dustcontrolusa.com/manuals/2800c.pdf)
The flap covering the port on the side of the vacuum is repeatedly flipped open to release built up pressure in strong pulses that dislodge dust from the filter.
The manufacturer indicates “the filter is generally cleaned once or twice daily during normal continuous operation.” The Dust Director shroud has a 2-inch diameter take-off that was connected to the antistatic, corrugated 1.5-inch diameter, 15-foot long vacuum hose supplied with the DustControl vacuum.
IV. Study Methods
This evaluation was conducted at the International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craft workers (IUBAC) Local 1 Philadelphia/Delaware Training Center in Philadelphia, PA on November 14 and 15, 2012. A single journeyman bricklayer, experienced in tuckpointing, used the grinder and LEV system being tested to remove mortar from joints wide enough to require two passes. The type S mortar had been allowed to cure for at least four weeks. The bricklayer either possessed or was provided with personal protective equipment including sturdy work boots, gloves, hearing protection and a powered air-purifying respirator (PAPR). The PAPR was a 3M GVP system with a bump cap, loose fitting face piece and a HEPA filter (3M, St Paul, MN).
The study was designed to include at least five rounds of sampling during mortar removal. Each round included a trial using the Bosch grinder with a Dust Director shroud and Dust Collector 2900c vacuum and a trial using the Bosch grinder with the factory-supplied guard and without a vacuum. The order of the two trials within each round was randomly selected to minimize bias that might be introduced due to variation associated with environmental factors, equipment operator, blade wear, vacuum performance over time and any other factors unrelated to LEV use. Tools were operated for approximately 16 minutes per trial with controls and for approximately 8 minutes when controls were not used. These times were selected based on the results of previous sampling efforts and estimates of the minimum sample time needed to achieve a limit of quantification low enough to accurately measure exposures down to or less than 0.05 mg/m3 – the NIOSH Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) for respirable silica. The bricklayer was required to take a 5 to 10 minute break in the middle of the 16-minute trials to reduce differences in fatigue, compared to the 8-minute trials. Personal air samples were collected in the breathing zone of the operator during each trial to measure respirable silica concentrations during grinding with and without LEV. The samples were collected using a GilAir-5 pump (Sensidyne, Inc., Clearwater, FL) to draw 4.2 liters of air per minute through a GK2.69 Respirable Cyclone (BGI Inc., Waltham, MA) with a pre-weighed, 37 mm diameter, 5-micron pore size polyvinyl chloride (PVC) filter positioned on the operator’s lapel.
The flow rates of the sampling pumps were calibrated at the beginning of each day using a DryCal DC-Lite Primary Flow Meter (Bios International Corporation, Butler, NJ). Flow rates were measured again near the middle and at the end of each day to ensure that sampling flow rates were maintained within 5% of pre-sampling flow rates throughout the day. Average flow rates were used to calculate sample air volumes. Samples were analyzed by R.J. Lee Group, Inc., (Monroeville, PA) using NIOSH Method 0600, to determine exposure to total mass of respirable dust. The same samples were also analyzed using X-Ray diffraction following NIOSH method 7500 to determine quartz, cristobalite and tridymite concentration in the respirable mass. Reported masses for these analytes were used with the sample air volumes to calculate airborne concentrations of total respirable dust, quartz, cristobalite and tridymite.
We used a reduction of greater than 50 percent in respirable silica exposure concentrations or a reduction to less than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 as our criteria for determining whether or not a control was considered efficacious. This is consistent with criteria used by NIOSH in conducting a similar study in 2004 described by Echt et al. (2007) and by CPWR in 2006 and described by Meeker et al. (2009). The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) and the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) publish additional occupational exposure limits (OELs) for silica which are listed in Table 1 with NIOSH RELs. OELs for silica are based on the respirable fraction of the aerosol, which consists of particles less than 10 micrometers in aerodynamic diameter.
| Organization or Agency | Form of Crystalline Silica | Occupational Exposure Limits (mg/m3) |
|---|---|---|
| NIOSHA | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 |
| OSHA - ConstructionB | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
PEL = 250 / (5 + % quartz) PEL = 250 / (5 + % cristobalite) PEL = 250 / (5 + % tridymite) |
| ACGIH | Crystalline Silica | TLV = 0.025 mg/m3 |
A NIOSH Publication No. 2005-151 indicates 10-hour time-weighted average during a 40-hr workweek B The PEL for silica in OSHA’s Safety and Health Regulations for Construction, 29 C.F.R. 1926.55(a), is an 8-hour time-weighted average (TWA) expressed in millions of particles per cubic foot (mppcf). However, the units mppcf can be converted to milligrams per cubic meter can by dividing mppcf by 10 (OSHA, 2009). The formula used by OSHA to determine the PEL for silica is dependent on the percentage of silica in each collected sample. The concentration of respirable dust measured is compared to the sample specific PEL to determine if the PEL has been exceeded. OSHA has proposed lowering the PEL to 0.05 mg/m3 of respirable silica as an 8 hour TWA. |
||
The flow of air in ventilation systems is governed by fundamental principles that describe the behavior of gases (in this case air). Pressure measurements taken within a ventilation system along with knowledge of hood (or shroud) entry losses can be used to calculate flow rates. Hood entry losses are dependent on the shape and configuration of a particular hood or shroud and described by the term “coefficient of entry (Ce)” which is the ratio of actual air flow through a hood and what the air flow would theoretically be if there were no hood entry losses. Given the coefficient of entry, static pressure measurements can be used to calculate air flow through a given hood. The coefficient of entry for the Dust Director shroud was previously determined by CPWR and used for calculating air flow based on static pressure measurements (Meeker et al., 2009). Static pressure, with the vacuum operating, was measured periodically throughout the evaluation to monitor the changes in air-flow rate following use and again after filter cleaning. The static pressure was measured at a port positioned more than 3 duct diameters downstream from the tool’s air intake using a UEi EM200 Electronic Manometer (Universal Enterprises, Inc., Beaverton, OR).
The dust in the vacuum bag was monitored and, per the manufacturer’s instructions, the bag was changed before the dust level was within 5 centimeters of the valve at the bottom of the vacuum. Each time a vacuum bag was removed, it was weighed to the nearest pound. The bag weights and corresponding grinding durations were used to calculate the average weight of dust collected per unit time. After each trial, cut lengths were measured on the wall to determine total linear feet of vertical (head) and horizontal (bed) joints per unit time.
A Haz-Dust III, Model HD-1003, Real-Time Aerosol Monitor (Environmental Devices Corporation, Plaistow, NH) was used to confirm clearance of dust between trials. The Haz-Dust monitor was positioned on the test wall near the operator at approximately breathing zone level and configured to measure respirable particulate concentration.
V. Results
Personal air monitoring
Five pairs of respirable dust samples were collected while grinding with and without the vacuum system. In addition, three respirable dust samples were collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place. One measurement collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard was shown to be a statistical outlier and was omitted from analysis. Personal air monitoring results for respirable silica and a comparison of average exposures relative to the NIOSH REL for silica (0.05 mg/m3) appears in Table 2. The mean respirable dust levels measured without LEV was 31.4 mg/m3. However, samples collected with LEV were below the limit of quantification (LOQ) which ranged from <1.29 to <1.46 mg/m3. Use of LEV resulted in a greater than 95% reduction in mean respirable dust levels using a mean value with use of LEV of <1.41 (n=5 samples with use of LEV and n=7 without use of LEV). The respirable dust samples collected during grinding without the LEV system contained an average of 24 percent silica. The mass of respirable dust in the samples collected with use of the LEV system was too low to determine the silica content.| Mean, mg/m3 (range) | Std. Dev. | Percent Reduction | Hazard RatioB | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bosch with Dust Director Shroud and DustControl 2900c Vacuum |
0.091 (<0.069 – 0.137) |
0.027 | 98.7 | 1.81 |
| Bosch with no Control | 7.23 (4.57 – 9.90) |
1.94 | NA | 145 |
A n = 5 samples for each tool/control combination and n = 7 samples without the use of the LEV system B Hazard Ratio = measured exposure / NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 |
||||
Average respirable silica and dust exposures, with and without the dust control system, appear as Figures 5 and 6, respectively.
Figure 5. Average respirable silica exposures with and without the Dustcontrol 2900c vacuum and Dust Director shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air - mg/m3)
Figure 6. Average respirable dust exposures with and without Dustcontrol 2900c Vacuum and Dust Director Shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air – mg/m3)
The mean respirable silica concentration measured during use of the control was significantly less than the concentration measured while using the same tool without controls (p<0.01). Grinding mortar with the Bosch angle grinder without dust controls resulted in an average exposure to respirable silica that was 145 times the NIOSH REL. Grinding with the Bosch angle grinder in combination with the Dust Director shroud and the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced the average concentration of respirable silica by 98.7 percent. With use of these controls, the concentration of respirable silica was 1.8 times greater than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3. However the NIOSH REL is based on a time-weighted average (TWA) over a 10-hour workday. Given these were task TWAs and samples were collected over continuous periods of grinding, they may overestimate exposures over an actual work day since some time would be spent performing tasks that would likely have lower, or no, silica exposures (setup, breaks, cleanup, etc.).
Static pressure, dust mass collection and grinding rates.
Static pressure was used as a surrogate for air flow as described earlier. Hood static pressure was measured periodically at a tap near the grinder more than 3 duct diameters from the air intake in the shroud. The static pressure, and thus air flow, was generally higher when the vacuum’s filter had recently been cleaned. The mean, median, and range of calculated flow rates are presented in Table A1 of the Appendix.
Based on the data we collected, the air-flow rate upstream from the Bosch grinder and Dust Director shroud ranged from 78 to 93 cubic feet per minute (cfm) with the DustControl vacuum. When the manufacturer’s filter cleaning procedure was followed the vacuum performed relatively well and flow could be maintained at slightly less than 90 cfm with cleaning. However, mean flow rates dropped substantially to 80 cfm after as little as 8 minutes of grinding without any filter cleaning. The flow rate returned to an average of 89 cfm when filters were cleaned correctly (without stopping air flow to the vacuum). Collingwood and Heitbrink (2007) found that the minimum exhaust flow rate for capture of silica and other particulate under ideal conditions is 21.25 cfm per inch of grinder blade diameter. This is equal to about 96 cfm when using a 4.5 inch diameter grinding blade. We set 106 cfm as the minimum desired flow rate for this study to allow a safety margin for potential decline in equipment performance and the possibility of inadequate maintenance, both of which may be likely after repeated use under actual work conditions. The DustControl vacuum provided slightly less than the minimum flow rate described by Collingwood and Heitbrink for a 4.5-inch blade and the peak flow rate fell with use.
The duration of vacuum bag use and mass of dust collected were recorded and are presented in Table A2 of the Appendix. The vacuum bags were changed and weighed after each trial utilizing the LEV system. A total of five bags were used to complete the five rounds of grinding. The DustControl vacuum captured 45 pounds of dust over 83 minutes of grinding for an average rate of dust collection of 0.54 pounds per minute. The rate of dust collection ranged from 0.47 to 0.63 pounds per minute. Based on these measurements, approximately 130 pounds of dust would likely be captured after just 4 hours of continuous grinding.
The rate of grinding a combination of vertical and horizontal joints while using the LEV system ranged from 2.3 to 3.3 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the use of the LEV system ranged from 2.6 to 3.4 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place ranged from 4.7 to 5.1 feet per minute. It’s important to note that: 1) the operator had limited experience using dust control systems and cut rates appeared to improve slightly over the 2-day period he used the tested equipment; and 2) the upper range of cut rates with the dust control system overlapped with the lowest cut rate with the original guard and without the LEV system in place indicating no statistical difference between cut rates. Given that grinding rates with and without use of this LEV system are only available for one operator and he had limited experience with the LEV system, these reported cut rates are in no way intended to represent the impact use of this LEV system is likely to have on productivity rates overall.
VI. Discussion
The objective of these trials was to evaluate the effectiveness of a tuckpointing LEV system for controlling respirable silica while grinding out mortar joints. The Dust Director shroud with the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced respirable silica concentrations when grinding with the Bosch grinder by approximately 99 percent. Despite being considered effective by our test criteria (greater than 50% reduction), it still resulted in task TWA exposures that exceeded the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 by 1.8 times. Depending on how much time is spent grinding over the course of a work day and on exposures while performing other tasks, the 8-hour TWA exposures may or may not exceed the REL with this system. Use of this system by workers with experience and training in proficient use will likely improve dust capture performance. Exposure reduction is greatly influenced by correct use of this system which includes grinding from right to left, making sure the shroud is held flush against the wall and that the tool travels at a pace that doesn’t exceed the ability of the system to capture dust as it’s generated. Deviation from any of these measures produces visible dust clouds which were observed during trials.
VII. Conclusions
With a 99 percent reduction in respirable silica exposure, the Dust Director shroud and DustControl 2900c vacuum with a Bosch Model 1775E grinder was effective in reducing silica exposures based on our criteria. Use of the tested dust control system may be effective in reducing silica exposure on the job to less than the NIOSH REL if used in combination with administrative controls such as work scheduling to reduce cutting times as needed. Training on correct use of the tested system is also essential. Personal air monitoring is necessary to verify control effectiveness on actual job sites and under “real-world” conditions. However, these results clearly demonstrate the availability of viable and effective engineering controls for tuckpointing operations associated with elevated silica exposure.
VIII. References
American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists. Threshold limit values for chemical substances (TLV®-CS). [2013]. ACGIH, Cincinnati, Ohio.
Bergdahl I.A,. Toren K., Eriksson K., et al. [2004]. Increased mortality in COPD among construction workers exposed to inorganic dust. European Respiratory Journal, 23: 402–06.
Blanc P.D. & Torén K. [2007]. Occupation in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and chronic bronchitis: an update [State of the Art Series. Occupational lung disease in high-and low-income countries, Edited by M. Chan-Yeung. Number 2 in the series]. The International Journal of Tuberculosis and Lung Disease, 11(3), 251-257.
Collingwood S. & Heitbrink W.A. [2007] 'Field Evaluation of an Engineering Control for Respirable Crystalline Silica Exposures During Mortar Removal'. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, 4:11, 875 – 887.
DHHS (NIOSH) Publication No. 2002-129 April 2002 http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/2002-129/
Echt A., Sieber W.K., Lefkowitz D., Meeker J., Susi P., Cardwell B., Heitbrink, W.A. In-depth survey of dust control technology for cutting concrete block and tuckpointing brick at The International Masonry Institute Bordentown Training Center, Bordentown, NJ. Cincinnati, OH: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Report. No. EPHB 282-13; 2007. http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ECTB-282-13.pdf
Heitbrink W., Bennett J. [2006]. A numerical and experimental investigation of crystalline silica exposure control during tuck pointing. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, Vol. 3, pp 366-378.
Lyons et al, [2007]. A breathless builder. Breathe, Vol. 3, no. 4, pp 386-390.
Mastrangelo G., Tartari M., Fedeli U., Fadda E., Saia B. [2003]. Ascertaining the risk of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease in relation to occupation using a case-control design. Occupational Medicine, 53: 165–172.
Meeker J., Cooper M., Lefrowitz D., Susi P. [2009]. Engineering control technologies to reduce occupational silica exposures in masonry cutting and tuckpointing. Public Health Reports, Supplement 1, Vol. 124, June.
Meeker J, Flynn M, Susi P, Cardwell, B [2004]. Performance evaluation of a masonry concrete vacuum. Unpublished Report.
Miller F. W., Alfredsson L., Costenbader K. H., Kamen D. L., Nelson L. M., Norris J. M., & De Roos A. J. [2012]. Epidemiology of environmental exposures and human autoimmune diseases: findings from a National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences Expert Panel workshop. Journal of autoimmunity. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3496812/
Occupational Safety and Health Administration U.S Department of Labor. Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction. [2009]. OSHA 3362-05.
Rappaport SM, Goldberg M, Susi P, Herrick RF [2003]. Excessive exposure to silica in the U.S. construction industry. Annals of Occupational Hygiene, Vol. 47, pp. 111-122.
IX. Appendices
| Measurement Conditions |
n | Mean Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Median
Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before filter cleaning | 5 | 80 | 81 | 78-81 |
| After filter cleaning following manufacturer directions | 9 | 89 | 90 | 84-93 |
| * Static pressure was measured in millibars and converted to inches of water gauge. Flow rates were calculated using the formula Q = Ce (A) 4005 (SP)1/2 where: Q = flow in cubic feet per minute (cfm), Ce = coefficient of entry, A = area of the duct where static pressure measurements were taken in square feet, and SP = static pressure in inches of water gauge. | ||||
| Tool/Control | Collection Period (min.) |
Dust Collection Rate (lb/min.) |
|---|---|---|
| Bosch grinder/Dust Director shroud & DustControl 2900c vacuum |
8 11 8 8 10 |
0.50 0.61 0.50 0.47 0.63 |
| Average | 0.54 |
[content_transformed:protected] =>
Executive Summary
This report describes the results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. It should also be noted that the NIOSH REL is based on exposures averaged over a ten hour work day and our results represent time weighted averages of the sample task duration periods.
Acronyms
ACGIH - American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists
CPWR - CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training
Ce - coefficient of entry
HEPA - high-efficiency particulate air
IUBAC - International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craftworkers
LEV - local exhaust ventilation
PACT - Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies
NIOSH - National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health
OEL - occupational exposure limit
OSHA - Occupational Safety and Health Administration
PAPR - powered air-purifying respirator
PEL - Permissible Exposure Limit
PVC - polyvinyl chloride
REL - Recommended Exposure Limit
RPM - revolutions per minute
TWA - time-weighted average
SP - static pressure
I. Introduction and Background
In 2010 CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training began a four-year project which seeks to identify and evaluate tuckpointing local exhaust ventilation (LEV) systems and disseminate information on their availability and effectiveness. A Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies (PACT) comprised of masonry contractors, representatives from unions, government, equipment manufacturers, and health and safety researcher was formed as part of this project. PACT members participated in identifying important characteristics for control technologies and this information was used to identify LEV systems for tuckpointing using that criteria. Contractor and labor members of the PACT selected specific tuckpointing LEV systems to be considered for evaluation. Each system consisted of a tuckpointing grinder, shroud, and vacuum. This report describes the second of four systems to be evaluated between 2012 the end of 2014, with and without LEV, in a controlled setting to determine effectiveness in silica exposure reduction. This report describes the methods and results of our evaluation of a system consisting of the DustControl 2900c vacuum with the ICS Dust Director shroud and a Bosch Model 1775E grinder.
Excessive exposure to respirable silica can result in silicosis or other silica-related diseases including pulmonary tuberculosis, lung cancer, silicoproteinosis (Lyons et al, 2007) and autoimmune disorders such as rheumatoid arthritis, sarcoidosis and scleroderma (Miller et al, 2012). Respirable silica is generally defined as particles less than 10 micrometers (μm) in aerodynamic diameter (ACGIH, 2013). Silicosis can lead to symptoms including shortness of breath, fatigue, chest pains, susceptibility to infection and possibly death. There is no cure for silicosis, however it is totally preventable. Construction workers exposed to dust, including silica, are also known to have higher rates of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD).
There are many sources of silica in construction that result in exposures of varying intensity among workers. Masonry restoration workers are among the most highly silica-exposed trades in construction. The process of grinding out deteriorated mortar joints between masonry units and replacing or repointing with fresh mortar (often referred to as tuckpointing) is a fundamental part of masonry restoration work. The removal of mortar with powered angle grinders generates enormous levels of dust. Between 2004 and 2006, NIOSH and CPWR evaluated silica exposures while grinding mortar in a controlled setting, at a local training center, where tasks, sample times and task variables were defined by the study design. These studies demonstrated that grinding mortar without controls can result in elevated respirable silica exposures. Meeker et al., (2009) reported exposures between 5 and 25.8 milligrams per cubic meter (mg/m3) in a controlled setting. This study also showed that LEV systems for tuckpointing grinders can reduce exposures to respirable silica by greater than 90 percent.II. Objectives
The objective of this evaluation was to assess the effectiveness of an LEV system for controlling exposure to silica during the grinding of mortar. The control technology was tested under controlled conditions, similar to those experienced by tuckpointers on actual job sites, using journeymen bricklayers experienced in tuckpointing and repeat, randomized trials with and without LEV. All other variables were held constant throughout so that the only variable was whether or not the tested control was used.
III. Description of Equipment Tested
A Bosch model 1775E grinder (Robert Bosch Tool Corporation, Prospect, IL) (Figures 1, 2 and 3) was fitted with a new 1/4-inch wide, 4½-inch diameter segmented diamond abrasive blade made by DeWalt (model #DW4740). The grinder weighs six and a half pounds, draws 8.5 amps and has a variable speed up to 11,000 revolutions per minute (RPMs). The DustControl 2900c vacuum (DustControl, Inc., Wilmington, NC) (Figure 3) was tested in combination with the Dust Director shroud (Industrial Contractors’ Supplies, Inc., Huntingdon, PA) (Figures 1 and 3) attached to the Bosch grinder.
Figure 1. Bosch grinder with Dust Director shroud
Figure 2. Bosch grinder without tuckpointing LEV system.
Figure 3: Bosch Grinder with LEV System
The vacuum is specified to weigh 31 pounds when empty and to provide a flow rate of 114 cubic feet of air per minute and a “static lift” or “vacuum suction pressure” of 84 inches of water. The vacuum is sold with a cyclonic pre-separator, to remove larger particles, a fine filter (rated 99.9 percent efficient) and a HEPA (high-efficiency particulate air) filter (rated to capture 99.97 percent of the particles with an aerodynamic diameter of 0.3 micrometers). The HEPA filter was removed based on the manufacturer’s recommendation due to the heavy dust loading associated with tuckpointing. CPWR sponsored research and contractor experience indicate that HEPA filters likely have an adverse effect on dust capture during tuckpointing because of extreme dust loading on filters. While the cyclone and the fine filter remove most of the dust, especially the large particles, before they reach the HEPA filter, the HEPA filter would still be subject to heavy loading, causing a substantial pressure drop and subsequent decrease in air flow rate. The relatively small increase in the efficiency of the filtration system while using the HEPA filter is expected to be quickly offset by a more significant decrease in capture efficiency as the air flow rate and ability to capture particles decreases.
Dust collects in relatively inexpensive, heavy-gauge plastic bags below and outside of the cyclone. The bags can be removed and replaced without opening the vacuum. Some vacuums are equipped with a light to indicate that the filters need to be cleaned or changed. The DC2900c features a “reverse air pulse cleaning system,” which removes accumulated dust from the filters without having to remove them from the vacuum. The system, as illustrated in Figure 4, requires the operator to disconnect the hose from the shroud, place it over an air stop so that air through the hose is cut off and pressure in the vacuum is maximized.
Figure 4. Procedure for "cleaning" of or dust removal from filters (source: http://dustcontrolusa.com/manuals/2800c.pdf)
The flap covering the port on the side of the vacuum is repeatedly flipped open to release built up pressure in strong pulses that dislodge dust from the filter.
The manufacturer indicates “the filter is generally cleaned once or twice daily during normal continuous operation.” The Dust Director shroud has a 2-inch diameter take-off that was connected to the antistatic, corrugated 1.5-inch diameter, 15-foot long vacuum hose supplied with the DustControl vacuum.
IV. Study Methods
This evaluation was conducted at the International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craft workers (IUBAC) Local 1 Philadelphia/Delaware Training Center in Philadelphia, PA on November 14 and 15, 2012. A single journeyman bricklayer, experienced in tuckpointing, used the grinder and LEV system being tested to remove mortar from joints wide enough to require two passes. The type S mortar had been allowed to cure for at least four weeks. The bricklayer either possessed or was provided with personal protective equipment including sturdy work boots, gloves, hearing protection and a powered air-purifying respirator (PAPR). The PAPR was a 3M GVP system with a bump cap, loose fitting face piece and a HEPA filter (3M, St Paul, MN).
The study was designed to include at least five rounds of sampling during mortar removal. Each round included a trial using the Bosch grinder with a Dust Director shroud and Dust Collector 2900c vacuum and a trial using the Bosch grinder with the factory-supplied guard and without a vacuum. The order of the two trials within each round was randomly selected to minimize bias that might be introduced due to variation associated with environmental factors, equipment operator, blade wear, vacuum performance over time and any other factors unrelated to LEV use. Tools were operated for approximately 16 minutes per trial with controls and for approximately 8 minutes when controls were not used. These times were selected based on the results of previous sampling efforts and estimates of the minimum sample time needed to achieve a limit of quantification low enough to accurately measure exposures down to or less than 0.05 mg/m3 – the NIOSH Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) for respirable silica. The bricklayer was required to take a 5 to 10 minute break in the middle of the 16-minute trials to reduce differences in fatigue, compared to the 8-minute trials. Personal air samples were collected in the breathing zone of the operator during each trial to measure respirable silica concentrations during grinding with and without LEV. The samples were collected using a GilAir-5 pump (Sensidyne, Inc., Clearwater, FL) to draw 4.2 liters of air per minute through a GK2.69 Respirable Cyclone (BGI Inc., Waltham, MA) with a pre-weighed, 37 mm diameter, 5-micron pore size polyvinyl chloride (PVC) filter positioned on the operator’s lapel.
The flow rates of the sampling pumps were calibrated at the beginning of each day using a DryCal DC-Lite Primary Flow Meter (Bios International Corporation, Butler, NJ). Flow rates were measured again near the middle and at the end of each day to ensure that sampling flow rates were maintained within 5% of pre-sampling flow rates throughout the day. Average flow rates were used to calculate sample air volumes. Samples were analyzed by R.J. Lee Group, Inc., (Monroeville, PA) using NIOSH Method 0600, to determine exposure to total mass of respirable dust. The same samples were also analyzed using X-Ray diffraction following NIOSH method 7500 to determine quartz, cristobalite and tridymite concentration in the respirable mass. Reported masses for these analytes were used with the sample air volumes to calculate airborne concentrations of total respirable dust, quartz, cristobalite and tridymite.
We used a reduction of greater than 50 percent in respirable silica exposure concentrations or a reduction to less than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 as our criteria for determining whether or not a control was considered efficacious. This is consistent with criteria used by NIOSH in conducting a similar study in 2004 described by Echt et al. (2007) and by CPWR in 2006 and described by Meeker et al. (2009). The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) and the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) publish additional occupational exposure limits (OELs) for silica which are listed in Table 1 with NIOSH RELs. OELs for silica are based on the respirable fraction of the aerosol, which consists of particles less than 10 micrometers in aerodynamic diameter.
| Organization or Agency | Form of Crystalline Silica | Occupational Exposure Limits (mg/m3) |
|---|---|---|
| NIOSHA | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 |
| OSHA - ConstructionB | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
PEL = 250 / (5 + % quartz) PEL = 250 / (5 + % cristobalite) PEL = 250 / (5 + % tridymite) |
| ACGIH | Crystalline Silica | TLV = 0.025 mg/m3 |
A NIOSH Publication No. 2005-151 indicates 10-hour time-weighted average during a 40-hr workweek B The PEL for silica in OSHA’s Safety and Health Regulations for Construction, 29 C.F.R. 1926.55(a), is an 8-hour time-weighted average (TWA) expressed in millions of particles per cubic foot (mppcf). However, the units mppcf can be converted to milligrams per cubic meter can by dividing mppcf by 10 (OSHA, 2009). The formula used by OSHA to determine the PEL for silica is dependent on the percentage of silica in each collected sample. The concentration of respirable dust measured is compared to the sample specific PEL to determine if the PEL has been exceeded. OSHA has proposed lowering the PEL to 0.05 mg/m3 of respirable silica as an 8 hour TWA. |
||
The flow of air in ventilation systems is governed by fundamental principles that describe the behavior of gases (in this case air). Pressure measurements taken within a ventilation system along with knowledge of hood (or shroud) entry losses can be used to calculate flow rates. Hood entry losses are dependent on the shape and configuration of a particular hood or shroud and described by the term “coefficient of entry (Ce)” which is the ratio of actual air flow through a hood and what the air flow would theoretically be if there were no hood entry losses. Given the coefficient of entry, static pressure measurements can be used to calculate air flow through a given hood. The coefficient of entry for the Dust Director shroud was previously determined by CPWR and used for calculating air flow based on static pressure measurements (Meeker et al., 2009). Static pressure, with the vacuum operating, was measured periodically throughout the evaluation to monitor the changes in air-flow rate following use and again after filter cleaning. The static pressure was measured at a port positioned more than 3 duct diameters downstream from the tool’s air intake using a UEi EM200 Electronic Manometer (Universal Enterprises, Inc., Beaverton, OR).
The dust in the vacuum bag was monitored and, per the manufacturer’s instructions, the bag was changed before the dust level was within 5 centimeters of the valve at the bottom of the vacuum. Each time a vacuum bag was removed, it was weighed to the nearest pound. The bag weights and corresponding grinding durations were used to calculate the average weight of dust collected per unit time. After each trial, cut lengths were measured on the wall to determine total linear feet of vertical (head) and horizontal (bed) joints per unit time.
A Haz-Dust III, Model HD-1003, Real-Time Aerosol Monitor (Environmental Devices Corporation, Plaistow, NH) was used to confirm clearance of dust between trials. The Haz-Dust monitor was positioned on the test wall near the operator at approximately breathing zone level and configured to measure respirable particulate concentration.
V. Results
Personal air monitoring
Five pairs of respirable dust samples were collected while grinding with and without the vacuum system. In addition, three respirable dust samples were collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place. One measurement collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard was shown to be a statistical outlier and was omitted from analysis. Personal air monitoring results for respirable silica and a comparison of average exposures relative to the NIOSH REL for silica (0.05 mg/m3) appears in Table 2. The mean respirable dust levels measured without LEV was 31.4 mg/m3. However, samples collected with LEV were below the limit of quantification (LOQ) which ranged from <1.29 to <1.46 mg/m3. Use of LEV resulted in a greater than 95% reduction in mean respirable dust levels using a mean value with use of LEV of <1.41 (n=5 samples with use of LEV and n=7 without use of LEV). The respirable dust samples collected during grinding without the LEV system contained an average of 24 percent silica. The mass of respirable dust in the samples collected with use of the LEV system was too low to determine the silica content.| Mean, mg/m3 (range) | Std. Dev. | Percent Reduction | Hazard RatioB | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bosch with Dust Director Shroud and DustControl 2900c Vacuum |
0.091 (<0.069 – 0.137) |
0.027 | 98.7 | 1.81 |
| Bosch with no Control | 7.23 (4.57 – 9.90) |
1.94 | NA | 145 |
A n = 5 samples for each tool/control combination and n = 7 samples without the use of the LEV system B Hazard Ratio = measured exposure / NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 |
||||
Average respirable silica and dust exposures, with and without the dust control system, appear as Figures 5 and 6, respectively.
Figure 5. Average respirable silica exposures with and without the Dustcontrol 2900c vacuum and Dust Director shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air - mg/m3)
Figure 6. Average respirable dust exposures with and without Dustcontrol 2900c Vacuum and Dust Director Shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air – mg/m3)
The mean respirable silica concentration measured during use of the control was significantly less than the concentration measured while using the same tool without controls (p<0.01). Grinding mortar with the Bosch angle grinder without dust controls resulted in an average exposure to respirable silica that was 145 times the NIOSH REL. Grinding with the Bosch angle grinder in combination with the Dust Director shroud and the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced the average concentration of respirable silica by 98.7 percent. With use of these controls, the concentration of respirable silica was 1.8 times greater than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3. However the NIOSH REL is based on a time-weighted average (TWA) over a 10-hour workday. Given these were task TWAs and samples were collected over continuous periods of grinding, they may overestimate exposures over an actual work day since some time would be spent performing tasks that would likely have lower, or no, silica exposures (setup, breaks, cleanup, etc.).
Static pressure, dust mass collection and grinding rates.
Static pressure was used as a surrogate for air flow as described earlier. Hood static pressure was measured periodically at a tap near the grinder more than 3 duct diameters from the air intake in the shroud. The static pressure, and thus air flow, was generally higher when the vacuum’s filter had recently been cleaned. The mean, median, and range of calculated flow rates are presented in Table A1 of the Appendix.
Based on the data we collected, the air-flow rate upstream from the Bosch grinder and Dust Director shroud ranged from 78 to 93 cubic feet per minute (cfm) with the DustControl vacuum. When the manufacturer’s filter cleaning procedure was followed the vacuum performed relatively well and flow could be maintained at slightly less than 90 cfm with cleaning. However, mean flow rates dropped substantially to 80 cfm after as little as 8 minutes of grinding without any filter cleaning. The flow rate returned to an average of 89 cfm when filters were cleaned correctly (without stopping air flow to the vacuum). Collingwood and Heitbrink (2007) found that the minimum exhaust flow rate for capture of silica and other particulate under ideal conditions is 21.25 cfm per inch of grinder blade diameter. This is equal to about 96 cfm when using a 4.5 inch diameter grinding blade. We set 106 cfm as the minimum desired flow rate for this study to allow a safety margin for potential decline in equipment performance and the possibility of inadequate maintenance, both of which may be likely after repeated use under actual work conditions. The DustControl vacuum provided slightly less than the minimum flow rate described by Collingwood and Heitbrink for a 4.5-inch blade and the peak flow rate fell with use.
The duration of vacuum bag use and mass of dust collected were recorded and are presented in Table A2 of the Appendix. The vacuum bags were changed and weighed after each trial utilizing the LEV system. A total of five bags were used to complete the five rounds of grinding. The DustControl vacuum captured 45 pounds of dust over 83 minutes of grinding for an average rate of dust collection of 0.54 pounds per minute. The rate of dust collection ranged from 0.47 to 0.63 pounds per minute. Based on these measurements, approximately 130 pounds of dust would likely be captured after just 4 hours of continuous grinding.
The rate of grinding a combination of vertical and horizontal joints while using the LEV system ranged from 2.3 to 3.3 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the use of the LEV system ranged from 2.6 to 3.4 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place ranged from 4.7 to 5.1 feet per minute. It’s important to note that: 1) the operator had limited experience using dust control systems and cut rates appeared to improve slightly over the 2-day period he used the tested equipment; and 2) the upper range of cut rates with the dust control system overlapped with the lowest cut rate with the original guard and without the LEV system in place indicating no statistical difference between cut rates. Given that grinding rates with and without use of this LEV system are only available for one operator and he had limited experience with the LEV system, these reported cut rates are in no way intended to represent the impact use of this LEV system is likely to have on productivity rates overall.
VI. Discussion
The objective of these trials was to evaluate the effectiveness of a tuckpointing LEV system for controlling respirable silica while grinding out mortar joints. The Dust Director shroud with the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced respirable silica concentrations when grinding with the Bosch grinder by approximately 99 percent. Despite being considered effective by our test criteria (greater than 50% reduction), it still resulted in task TWA exposures that exceeded the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 by 1.8 times. Depending on how much time is spent grinding over the course of a work day and on exposures while performing other tasks, the 8-hour TWA exposures may or may not exceed the REL with this system. Use of this system by workers with experience and training in proficient use will likely improve dust capture performance. Exposure reduction is greatly influenced by correct use of this system which includes grinding from right to left, making sure the shroud is held flush against the wall and that the tool travels at a pace that doesn’t exceed the ability of the system to capture dust as it’s generated. Deviation from any of these measures produces visible dust clouds which were observed during trials.
VII. Conclusions
With a 99 percent reduction in respirable silica exposure, the Dust Director shroud and DustControl 2900c vacuum with a Bosch Model 1775E grinder was effective in reducing silica exposures based on our criteria. Use of the tested dust control system may be effective in reducing silica exposure on the job to less than the NIOSH REL if used in combination with administrative controls such as work scheduling to reduce cutting times as needed. Training on correct use of the tested system is also essential. Personal air monitoring is necessary to verify control effectiveness on actual job sites and under “real-world” conditions. However, these results clearly demonstrate the availability of viable and effective engineering controls for tuckpointing operations associated with elevated silica exposure.
VIII. References
American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists. Threshold limit values for chemical substances (TLV®-CS). [2013]. ACGIH, Cincinnati, Ohio.
Bergdahl I.A,. Toren K., Eriksson K., et al. [2004]. Increased mortality in COPD among construction workers exposed to inorganic dust. European Respiratory Journal, 23: 402–06.
Blanc P.D. & Torén K. [2007]. Occupation in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and chronic bronchitis: an update [State of the Art Series. Occupational lung disease in high-and low-income countries, Edited by M. Chan-Yeung. Number 2 in the series]. The International Journal of Tuberculosis and Lung Disease, 11(3), 251-257.
Collingwood S. & Heitbrink W.A. [2007] 'Field Evaluation of an Engineering Control for Respirable Crystalline Silica Exposures During Mortar Removal'. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, 4:11, 875 – 887.
DHHS (NIOSH) Publication No. 2002-129 April 2002 http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/2002-129/
Echt A., Sieber W.K., Lefkowitz D., Meeker J., Susi P., Cardwell B., Heitbrink, W.A. In-depth survey of dust control technology for cutting concrete block and tuckpointing brick at The International Masonry Institute Bordentown Training Center, Bordentown, NJ. Cincinnati, OH: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Report. No. EPHB 282-13; 2007. http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ECTB-282-13.pdf
Heitbrink W., Bennett J. [2006]. A numerical and experimental investigation of crystalline silica exposure control during tuck pointing. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, Vol. 3, pp 366-378.
Lyons et al, [2007]. A breathless builder. Breathe, Vol. 3, no. 4, pp 386-390.
Mastrangelo G., Tartari M., Fedeli U., Fadda E., Saia B. [2003]. Ascertaining the risk of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease in relation to occupation using a case-control design. Occupational Medicine, 53: 165–172.
Meeker J., Cooper M., Lefrowitz D., Susi P. [2009]. Engineering control technologies to reduce occupational silica exposures in masonry cutting and tuckpointing. Public Health Reports, Supplement 1, Vol. 124, June.
Meeker J, Flynn M, Susi P, Cardwell, B [2004]. Performance evaluation of a masonry concrete vacuum. Unpublished Report.
Miller F. W., Alfredsson L., Costenbader K. H., Kamen D. L., Nelson L. M., Norris J. M., & De Roos A. J. [2012]. Epidemiology of environmental exposures and human autoimmune diseases: findings from a National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences Expert Panel workshop. Journal of autoimmunity. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3496812/
Occupational Safety and Health Administration U.S Department of Labor. Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction. [2009]. OSHA 3362-05.
Rappaport SM, Goldberg M, Susi P, Herrick RF [2003]. Excessive exposure to silica in the U.S. construction industry. Annals of Occupational Hygiene, Vol. 47, pp. 111-122.
IX. Appendices
| Measurement Conditions |
n | Mean Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Median
Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before filter cleaning | 5 | 80 | 81 | 78-81 |
| After filter cleaning following manufacturer directions | 9 | 89 | 90 | 84-93 |
| * Static pressure was measured in millibars and converted to inches of water gauge. Flow rates were calculated using the formula Q = Ce (A) 4005 (SP)1/2 where: Q = flow in cubic feet per minute (cfm), Ce = coefficient of entry, A = area of the duct where static pressure measurements were taken in square feet, and SP = static pressure in inches of water gauge. | ||||
| Tool/Control | Collection Period (min.) |
Dust Collection Rate (lb/min.) |
|---|---|---|
| Bosch grinder/Dust Director shroud & DustControl 2900c vacuum |
8 11 8 8 10 |
0.50 0.61 0.50 0.47 0.63 |
| Average | 0.54 |
[disclaimer:protected] => [disclaimer_transformed:protected] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [template] => record ) [_file] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/templates/elcosh/record_macros.html [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_encoding:protected] => UTF-8 [_outputMode:protected] => 11 [_forceReparse:protected] => [_phpCodeDestination:protected] => /tmp/ [_phpCodeExtension:protected] => php [_cacheLifetime:protected] => 30 [_cachePurgeFrequency:protected] => 30 [externalMacroTemplatesCache:PHPTAL:private] => Array ( ) ) [1] => PHPTAL Object ( [_prefilters:protected] => Array ( ) [_prefilter:PHPTAL:private] => REMOVED: DO NOT USE [_postfilter:protected] => [_repositories:protected] => Array ( ) [_path:protected] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/templates/elcosh/record.html [_resolvers:protected] => Array ( ) [_source:protected] => PHPTAL_FileSource Object ( [_path:PHPTAL_FileSource:private] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/templates/elcosh/record.html ) [_codeFile:protected] => /tmp/tpl_61515a6c_record__uvBJJSo8xT_sgOY5gjP7ug.php [_functionName:protected] => tpl_61515a6c_record__uvBJJSo8xT_sgOY5gjP7ug [_prepared:protected] => 1 [_triggers:protected] => Array ( ) [_translator:protected] => [_globalContext:protected] => stdClass Object ( ) [_context:protected] => PHPTAL_Context Object ( [_line] => [_file] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/templates/elcosh/record_macros.html [repeat] => stdClass Object ( [collection] => PHPTAL_RepeatController Object ( [key] => 3913 [current:PHPTAL_RepeatController:private] => [valid:PHPTAL_RepeatController:private] => [validOnNext:PHPTAL_RepeatController:private] => [uses_groups:PHPTAL_RepeatController:private] => [iterator:protected] => ArrayIterator Object ( [storage:ArrayIterator:private] => Array ( [3913] => ) ) [index] => 0 [end] => 1 [length:PHPTAL_RepeatController:private] => ) ) [_xmlDeclaration] => [_docType] => [_nothrow:PHPTAL_Context:private] => [_slots:PHPTAL_Context:private] => Array ( ) [_slotsStack:PHPTAL_Context:private] => Array ( [0] => Array ( ) [1] => Array ( ) ) [_parentContext:PHPTAL_Context:private] => PHPTAL_Context Object ( [_line] => [_file] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/templates/elcosh/record_macros.html [repeat] => stdClass Object ( [collection] => PHPTAL_RepeatController Object ( [key] => 3913 [current:PHPTAL_RepeatController:private] => [valid:PHPTAL_RepeatController:private] => [validOnNext:PHPTAL_RepeatController:private] => [uses_groups:PHPTAL_RepeatController:private] => [iterator:protected] => ArrayIterator Object ( [storage:ArrayIterator:private] => Array ( [3913] => ) ) [index] => 0 [end] => 1 [length:PHPTAL_RepeatController:private] => ) ) [_xmlDeclaration] => [_docType] => [_nothrow:PHPTAL_Context:private] => [_slots:PHPTAL_Context:private] => Array ( ) [_slotsStack:PHPTAL_Context:private] => Array ( [0] => Array ( ) [1] => Array ( ) ) [_parentContext:PHPTAL_Context:private] => PHPTAL_Context Object ( [_line] => [_file] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/templates/elcosh/record.html [repeat] => stdClass Object ( ) [_xmlDeclaration] => [_docType] => [_nothrow:PHPTAL_Context:private] => [_slots:PHPTAL_Context:private] => Array ( ) [_slotsStack:PHPTAL_Context:private] => Array ( [0] => Array ( ) [1] => Array ( ) ) [_parentContext:PHPTAL_Context:private] => [_globalContext:PHPTAL_Context:private] => stdClass Object ( ) [_echoDeclarations:PHPTAL_Context:private] => [referer] => http://www.elcosh.org/document/3908/d001345/An%2BEvaluation%2Bof%2BSilica%2BExposure%2BControls%2Bfor%2BTuckpointing%253A%2BDustControl%2B2900c%2BVacuum%2Bwith%2Bthe%2BICS%2BDust%2BDirector%2BShroud%2Band%2BBosch%2BGrinder%2BModel%2B1775E%2BConducted%2BNovember%2B14-15%252C%2B2012.html [curr_module] => Record [styles] => Array ( ) [javascript] => Array ( [0] => jquery.min.js ) [metas] => Array ( [language] => en [robots] => index, follow ) [user] => [curr_url] => https://www.elcosh.org/index.php?module=Record&id=3908&type=document [base_url] => https://www.elcosh.org/index.php?module=Record [title] => eLCOSH : An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: DustControl 2900c Vacuum with the ICS Dust Director Shroud and Bosch Grinder Model 1775E Conducted November 14-15, 2012 [language] => en [search_query] => [module] => Record [new_records] => Array ( [0] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Fixed Ladder [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Fixed Ladders addresses the potential risks associated with using fixed ladders. The resource includes a brief case example,... [category] => Array ( [0] => 15 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 53 [5] => 55 [6] => 60 [7] => 64 [8] => 73 [9] => 76 [10] => 78 [11] => 80 [12] => 86 [13] => 87 [14] => 90 [15] => 92 [16] => 93 [17] => 94 [18] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Falls [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Concrete Polisher [11] => Electrical Worker [13] => HVAC [15] => Laborer [17] => PCC/Restoration [19] => Plumber/Pipefitter [21] => Roofer/Waterproofer [23] => Sheetmetal Worker [25] => Welder [27] => Commercial & Institutional [28] => Jobsites [29] => Industrial [31] => LEED/Green Construction [33] => Renovations [35] => Residential [37] => Toolbox Talks [38] => Documents [39] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4430/d001660/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BFixed%2BLadder.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [53] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 53 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Concrete Polisher [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [73] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 73 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => PCC/Restoration [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4430 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001660 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Fixed Ladder [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Fixed Ladders, Fall Prevention, Falls [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Fixed Ladders addresses the potential risks associated with using fixed ladders. The resource includes a brief case example, steps to prevent a related injury and questions for discussion. It includes an image that illustrates the hazard, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001257,d001254,d001255,d001256,d001258,d001262,d001279 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_completed:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/22/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [1] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Challenges Preventing Falling Objects [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Challenges Preventing Falling Objects addresses the hazards of being struck by falling objects on the job site. The resource... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 55 [5] => 64 [6] => 68 [7] => 71 [8] => 75 [9] => 78 [10] => 79 [11] => 82 [12] => 62 [13] => 86 [14] => 87 [15] => 88 [16] => 89 [17] => 91 [18] => 90 [19] => 92 [20] => 93 [21] => 94 [22] => 95 [23] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Electrical Worker [11] => Laborer [13] => Maintenance Worker [15] => Painter [17] => Plasterer [19] => Roofer/Waterproofer [21] => Scaffold Erector [23] => Stonemason [25] => Structural Ironworker [27] => Welder [29] => Commercial & Institutional [30] => Jobsites [31] => Demolition [33] => Disasters [35] => Heavy & Highway [37] => Industrial [39] => LEED/Green Construction [41] => Renovations [43] => Residential [45] => Underground [47] => Toolbox Talks [48] => Documents [49] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4431/d001661/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BChallenges%2BPreventing%2BFalling%2BObjects.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4431 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001661 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Challenges Preventing Falling Objects [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => dropped objects, falling objects, struck by incidents, struck by fatalities [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Challenges Preventing Falling Objects addresses the hazards of being struck by falling objects on the job site. The resource includes a brief example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates a group workers observing a scaffold free of debris during high winds, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001234,d001238,d001244,d001251,d001253,d001260,d001268,d001278 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_completed:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/22/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [2] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Tower Crane Safety [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Tower Crane Safety addresses the potential hazards of Tower Cranes and the importance of following procedure before and durin... [category] => Array ( [0] => 11 [1] => 12 [2] => 18 [3] => 70 [4] => 87 [5] => 88 [6] => 91 [7] => 90 [8] => 92 [9] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Cranes & Hoists [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Crushed/Struck By [6] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [9] => Operating Engineer [10] => Trades [11] => Commercial & Institutional [12] => Jobsites [13] => Demolition [15] => Heavy & Highway [17] => Industrial [19] => LEED/Green Construction [21] => Toolbox Talks [22] => Documents [23] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4427/d001657/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BTower%2BCrane%2BSafety.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [11] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 11 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Cranes & Hoists [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [18] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 18 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4427 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001657 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Tower Crane Safety [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Tower Crane, Crane, Stability, Tipping, Lift Zone Safety, Lift, Zone, Safety, Struck by [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Tower Crane Safety addresses the potential hazards of Tower Cranes and the importance of following procedure before and during Tower Crane operation. The resource includes a brief example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates a worker inspecting a Tower Crane before operation, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001234,d001238,d001250,d001251,d001253,d001258,d001262,d001273 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/19/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [3] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Work Zone Safety: Working Around Vehicles [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Working Around Vehicles in the Work Zone addresses methods to avoid being struck-by a vehicle on a construction site. The res... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 18 [2] => 52 [3] => 57 [4] => 70 [5] => 85 [6] => 87 [7] => 88 [8] => 89 [9] => 91 [10] => 90 [11] => 92 [12] => 93 [13] => 94 [14] => 95 [15] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [6] => Commercial Diver [7] => Trades [8] => Flagger [10] => Operating Engineer [12] => Truck Driver [14] => Commercial & Institutional [15] => Jobsites [16] => Demolition [18] => Disasters [20] => Heavy & Highway [22] => Industrial [24] => LEED/Green Construction [26] => Renovations [28] => Residential [30] => Underground [32] => Toolbox Talks [33] => Documents [34] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4428/d001658/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BWork%2BZone%2BSafety%253A%2BWorking%2BAround%2BVehicles.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [18] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 18 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [52] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 52 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Commercial Diver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [85] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 85 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Truck Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4428 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001658 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Daniela Caceres [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Work Zone Safety: Working Around Vehicles [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Struck, Struck by, Vehicle, Work Zone Safety, Truck, Operator, Driver, Mobile Equipment [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Working Around Vehicles in the Work Zone addresses methods to avoid being struck-by a vehicle on a construction site. The resource includes a case example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates the hazard, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001640 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/19/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [4] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Construction Dive -- DeWalt's Jobsite Pro headphones recalled for fire hazards [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => A recall notice by the United States Consumer Product Safety Commission affects over 300,000 DeWalt Jobsite Pro Headphones. The recall is a result of... [category] => Array ( [0] => 16 [1] => 44 [2] => 45 [3] => 46 [4] => 47 [5] => 48 [6] => 49 [7] => 50 [8] => 51 [9] => 52 [10] => 53 [11] => 54 [12] => 55 [13] => 56 [14] => 57 [15] => 58 [16] => 59 [17] => 60 [18] => 61 [19] => 64 [20] => 65 [21] => 66 [22] => 67 [23] => 68 [24] => 69 [25] => 70 [26] => 71 [27] => 72 [28] => 73 [29] => 74 [30] => 75 [31] => 76 [32] => 77 [33] => 63 [34] => 78 [35] => 79 [36] => 80 [37] => 81 [38] => 82 [39] => 62 [40] => 83 [41] => 84 [42] => 85 [43] => 86 [44] => 87 [45] => 88 [46] => 89 [47] => 91 [48] => 90 [49] => 92 [50] => 93 [51] => 94 [52] => 95 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Fire & Explosions [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Acoustical Ceiling Carpenter [4] => Trades [5] => Asbestos/Insulator [7] => Boilermaker [9] => Bricklayer [11] => Cabinetmaker [13] => Carpenter [15] => Carpet Layer [17] => Cement Mason [19] => Commercial Diver [21] => Concrete Polisher [23] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [25] => Electrical Worker [27] => Elevator Constructor [29] => Flagger [31] => Glazier [33] => Hazardous Waste Cleanup [35] => HVAC [37] => Interior Systems Carpenter [39] => Laborer [41] => Landscaper [43] => Lather [45] => Lead Abatement Worker [47] => Maintenance Worker [49] => Millwright [51] => Operating Engineer [53] => Painter [55] => Paper Hanger [57] => PCC/Restoration [59] => Pile Driver [61] => Plasterer [63] => Plumber/Pipefitter [65] => Refractory Worker [67] => Reinforcing Ironworker [69] => Roofer/Waterproofer [71] => Scaffold Erector [73] => Sheetmetal Worker [75] => Sprinkler Fitter [77] => Stonemason [79] => Structural Ironworker [81] => Terrazzo Worker [83] => Tile Setter [85] => Truck Driver [87] => Welder [89] => Commercial & Institutional [90] => Jobsites [91] => Demolition [93] => Disasters [95] => Heavy & Highway [97] => Industrial [99] => LEED/Green Construction [101] => Renovations [103] => Residential [105] => Underground ) [type] => [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4426/d001656/Construction%2BDive%2B--%2BDeWalt%2527s%2BJobsite%2BPro%2Bheadphones%2Brecalled%2Bfor%2Bfire%2Bhazards.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [16] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 16 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Fire & Explosions [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [44] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 44 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Acoustical Ceiling Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [45] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 45 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Asbestos/Insulator [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [46] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 46 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Boilermaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [48] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 48 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cabinetmaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [50] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 50 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpet Layer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [52] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 52 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Commercial Diver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [53] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 53 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Concrete Polisher [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [54] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 54 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [58] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 58 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Glazier [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [59] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 59 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Hazardous Waste Cleanup [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [65] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 65 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Landscaper [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [66] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 66 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Lather [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [67] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 67 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Lead Abatement Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [69] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 69 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Millwright [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [72] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 72 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Paper Hanger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [73] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 73 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => PCC/Restoration [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [77] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 77 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Refractory Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [81] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 81 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sprinkler Fitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [83] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 83 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Terrazzo Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [84] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 84 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Tile Setter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [85] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 85 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Truck Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4426 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001656 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Construction Dive -- DeWalt's Jobsite Pro headphones recalled for fire hazards [total_pages:protected] => 1 [billed_pages:protected] => 1 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => DeWalt, Fire Hazards, recall, headphones [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A recall notice by the United States Consumer Product Safety Commission affects over 300,000 DeWalt Jobsite Pro Headphones. The recall is a result of a malfunction that can cause earbuds to overheat while charging or during use, leading to fire and burn hazards. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => https://www.constructiondive.com/news/dewalts-jobsite-pro-headphones-recalled-for-fire-hazards/611248/?utm_source=Sailthru&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Issue:%202021-12-10%20Construction%20Dive%20Newsletter%20%5Bissue:38532%5D&utm_term=Construction%20Dive [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/13/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/13/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 12/13/21 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [new_images] => Array ( [0] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Morning Toolbox Talk [image] => /record/images/4003-p.jpg [blurb] => This photo is from an early morning toolbox talk on a construction job in Mclean, Virginia. It is being delivered in English and Spanish.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 20 [1] => 51 [2] => 57 [3] => 64 [4] => 70 [5] => 63 [6] => 78 [7] => 82 [8] => 62 [9] => 87 [10] => 88 [11] => 89 [12] => 91 [13] => 90 [14] => 93 [15] => 94 [16] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Safety Culture [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Cement Mason [4] => Trades [5] => Flagger [7] => Laborer [9] => Operating Engineer [11] => Reinforcing Ironworker [13] => Roofer/Waterproofer [15] => Stonemason [17] => Structural Ironworker [19] => Commercial & Institutional [20] => Jobsites [21] => Demolition [23] => Disasters [25] => Heavy & Highway [27] => Industrial [29] => Renovations [31] => Residential [33] => Images [34] => Media [35] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4003/i002691/Morning%2BToolbox%2BTalk.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4003 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002691 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Morning Toolbox Talk [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, Spanish, bilingual [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This photo is from an early morning toolbox talk on a construction job in Mclean, Virginia. It is being delivered in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001285,d001304,c000079 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [1] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox talk - crew view [image] => /record/images/4005-p.jpg [blurb] => Photo of crew listening to a toolbox safety talk before starting work.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 97 [1] => 20 [2] => 47 [3] => 49 [4] => 51 [5] => 55 [6] => 61 [7] => 64 [8] => 71 [9] => 75 [10] => 63 [11] => 79 [12] => 62 [13] => 87 [14] => 88 [15] => 91 [16] => 90 [17] => 93 [18] => 94 [19] => 95 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Images [1] => Media [2] => Media & Documents [3] => Safety Culture [4] => Work Environment [5] => Hazards [6] => Bricklayer [7] => Trades [8] => Carpenter [10] => Cement Mason [12] => Electrical Worker [14] => Interior Systems Carpenter [16] => Laborer [18] => Painter [20] => Plasterer [22] => Reinforcing Ironworker [24] => Scaffold Erector [26] => Structural Ironworker [28] => Commercial & Institutional [29] => Jobsites [30] => Demolition [32] => Heavy & Highway [34] => Industrial [36] => Renovations [38] => Residential [40] => Underground ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4005/i002692/Toolbox%2Btalk%2B-%2Bcrew%2Bview.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4005 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002692 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox talk - crew view [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, safety talk, Spanish [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Photo of crew listening to a toolbox safety talk before starting work. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002691,d001269, c000079, d001285 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [2] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox talk - long shot [image] => /record/images/4006-p.jpg [blurb] => This crew gathered every morning before starting work to discuss a new safety topic.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 20 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 55 [5] => 64 [6] => 68 [7] => 75 [8] => 76 [9] => 63 [10] => 78 [11] => 79 [12] => 82 [13] => 62 [14] => 87 [15] => 88 [16] => 91 [17] => 90 [18] => 93 [19] => 94 [20] => 95 [21] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Safety Culture [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Electrical Worker [11] => Laborer [13] => Maintenance Worker [15] => Plasterer [17] => Plumber/Pipefitter [19] => Reinforcing Ironworker [21] => Roofer/Waterproofer [23] => Scaffold Erector [25] => Stonemason [27] => Structural Ironworker [29] => Commercial & Institutional [30] => Jobsites [31] => Demolition [33] => Heavy & Highway [35] => Industrial [37] => Renovations [39] => Residential [41] => Underground [43] => Images [44] => Media [45] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4006/i002693/Toolbox%2Btalk%2B-%2Blong%2Bshot.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4006 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002693 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox talk - long shot [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, safety minute [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This crew gathered every morning before starting work to discuss a new safety topic. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002691,i002692,d001269,d000527 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [3] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Safety officer discussing ongoing project with marketing coordinator [image] => /record/images/4014-p.jpg [blurb] => The safety officer (left) points out the good safety practices on this project that reflect well on the firm and may influence future clients.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 97 [1] => 20 [2] => 46 [3] => 47 [4] => 49 [5] => 50 [6] => 51 [7] => 54 [8] => 55 [9] => 58 [10] => 60 [11] => 61 [12] => 64 [13] => 71 [14] => 75 [15] => 76 [16] => 63 [17] => 79 [18] => 80 [19] => 82 [20] => 62 [21] => 83 [22] => 87 [23] => 91 [24] => 90 [25] => 93 [26] => 94 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Images [1] => Media [2] => Media & Documents [3] => Safety Culture [4] => Work Environment [5] => Hazards [6] => Boilermaker [7] => Trades [8] => Bricklayer [10] => Carpenter [12] => Carpet Layer [14] => Cement Mason [16] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [18] => Electrical Worker [20] => Glazier [22] => HVAC [24] => Interior Systems Carpenter [26] => Laborer [28] => Painter [30] => Plasterer [32] => Plumber/Pipefitter [34] => Reinforcing Ironworker [36] => Scaffold Erector [38] => Sheetmetal Worker [40] => Stonemason [42] => Structural Ironworker [44] => Terrazzo Worker [46] => Commercial & Institutional [47] => Jobsites [48] => Heavy & Highway [50] => Industrial [52] => Renovations [54] => Residential ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4014/i002700/Safety%2Bofficer%2Bdiscussing%2Bongoing%2Bproject%2Bwith%2Bmarketing%2Bcoordinator.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [46] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 46 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Boilermaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [50] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 50 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpet Layer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [54] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 54 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [58] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 58 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Glazier [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [83] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 83 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Terrazzo Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4014 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002700 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Safety officer discussing ongoing project with marketing coordinator [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Latino, safety officer, safety culture [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The safety officer (left) points out the good safety practices on this project that reflect well on the firm and may influence future clients. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/index.php [more_like_this:protected] => d000989,d001351,d001362,d000652, d001101, d000931, d001395 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Hoar Construction, Photo by Neil Lippy [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 01/30/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [4] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Scaffolding at top of large column [image] => /record/images/3994-p.jpg [blurb] => This shot shows innovative guarding around the top of a large concrete column in the base of a high rise structure going up.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 15 [1] => 21 [2] => 47 [3] => 51 [4] => 63 [5] => 78 [6] => 79 [7] => 80 [8] => 62 [9] => 87 [10] => 97 [11] => 56 [12] => 64 [13] => 74 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Falls [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Scaffolds [6] => Bricklayer [7] => Trades [8] => Cement Mason [10] => Reinforcing Ironworker [12] => Roofer/Waterproofer [14] => Scaffold Erector [16] => Sheetmetal Worker [18] => Structural Ironworker [20] => Commercial & Institutional [21] => Jobsites [22] => Images [23] => Media [24] => Media & Documents [25] => Elevator Constructor [27] => Laborer [29] => Pile Driver ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/3994/i002689/Scaffolding%2Bat%2Btop%2Bof%2Blarge%2Bcolumn.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [21] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 21 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Scaffolds [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3994 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002689 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Scaffolding at top of large column [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Guardrail, railing, fall prevention, falls [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This shot shows innovative guarding around the top of a large concrete column in the base of a high rise structure going up. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/8/adjustable-tower-scaffold.html [more_like_this:protected] => c1002680,i002662,d000608,d001255 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Photo by Pam Susi [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2016 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_completed:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/01/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [5] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Construction bracing [image] => /record/images/3995-p.jpg [blurb] => This shows structural support that prevents collapses during construction.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 15 [2] => 21 [3] => 49 [4] => 51 [5] => 55 [6] => 56 [7] => 60 [8] => 64 [9] => 68 [10] => 74 [11] => 63 [12] => 78 [13] => 79 [14] => 80 [15] => 62 [16] => 87 [17] => 90 [18] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Falls [6] => Scaffolds [9] => Carpenter [10] => Trades [11] => Cement Mason [13] => Electrical Worker [15] => Elevator Constructor [17] => HVAC [19] => Laborer [21] => Maintenance Worker [23] => Pile Driver [25] => Reinforcing Ironworker [27] => Roofer/Waterproofer [29] => Scaffold Erector [31] => Sheetmetal Worker [33] => Structural Ironworker [35] => Commercial & Institutional [36] => Jobsites [37] => Industrial [39] => Images [40] => Media [41] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/3995/i002690/Construction%2Bbracing.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [21] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 21 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Scaffolds [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3995 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002690 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Construction bracing [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Bracing, support, scaffold [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This shows structural support that prevents collapses during construction. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/8/adjustable-tower-scaffold.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002660 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Photo by Pam Susi [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2016 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_completed:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/01/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [preview_mode] => [description] => The results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. [keywords] => tuckpointing, HEPA vacuum, dust control, LEV, local exhaust ventilation, silica [related_items] => Array ( [Research Reports] => Array ( [0] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1874 [old_id:protected] => 722 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000683 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Sharon Garber/COD [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Protecting Tuckpointing Workers from Silica Dust: Draft Recommendations for a Ventilated Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 12 [billed_pages:protected] => 12 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, vacuum, grinder, mortar, respirator, OSHA, NIOSH, exhaust, Heitbrink, tuckpointer, silica, masonry, dust, silicosis, LEV [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Describes draft recommendations for use of ventilated grinder to reduce dust during tuckpointing and describes field trials using these devices. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/hazard/67/chip-scrape-and-grind-surfaces-or-joints-silica.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001201,d000292,d000293,d000658 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2005 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/27/05 [date_completed:protected] => 04/26/05 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/20/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [1] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1940 [old_id:protected] => 909 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Workplace Solutions: Control of Hazardous Dust During Tuckpointing [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, silica, dust, tuckpoint, grinder, masonry restoration, mortar, vacuum [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d000819,d000820,d000730,d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 10/24/08 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/09 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [2] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3899 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001342 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: Hilti VC40-U Vacuum with Hilti DC-EX Dust Guard and Hilti Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 15 [billed_pages:protected] => 15 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP4 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => silica, tuckpointing, Hilti, local exhaust systems, LEV, shroud, quartz [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This report describes the results of an evaluation of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Hilti VC40-U vacuum, a Hilti DC-EX shroud, and a Hilti DAG-500 grinder. Randomized trials with and without use of the dust control system were conducted in a controlled setting. Removing mortar with the Hilti grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 220 times the National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05mg/m3. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 97 percent. However, exposures measured during the use of the dust control system still exceeded the NIOSH REL. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => December 1, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/05/14 [date_completed:protected] => 02/04/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/06/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [Handouts] => Array ( [0] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3656 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001198 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 24 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction While Doing Tuckpointing/Mortar Removal [total_pages:protected] => 2 [billed_pages:protected] => 2 [publication_number:protected] => DSG FS-3632 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Brick, block, tuckpointing, silica, local exhaust ventilation, LEV, masonry [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Tuckpointing creates some of the greatest exposures to silica in construction. This OSHA factsheet provides guidance on how to greatly reduce these exposures through the use of local exhaust ventilation. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863, d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => February 2013 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/04/13 [date_completed:protected] => 03/27/13 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [collections] => Array ( [3913] => ) [record] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => Array ( [867] => Author Object ( [id:protected] => 867 [organization_id:protected] => 0 [firstname:protected] => Michael [lastname:protected] => Cooper [address:protected] => [city:protected] => [province:protected] => [country:protected] => [postal_code:protected] => [department:protected] => [title:protected] => [phone:protected] => [fax:protected] => [email:protected] => [degree:protected] => [website:protected] => [about:protected] => [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => [date_completed:protected] => [date_billed:protected] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [481] => Author Object ( [id:protected] => 481 [organization_id:protected] => 0 [firstname:protected] => Pam [lastname:protected] => Susi [address:protected] => 8484 Georgia Avenue, Suite 1000 [city:protected] => Silver Spring [province:protected] => Maryland [country:protected] => USA [postal_code:protected] => 20910 [department:protected] => [title:protected] => [phone:protected] => 301-578-8500 ext.144 [fax:protected] => 301-578-8572 [email:protected] => plsusi@aol.com [degree:protected] => [website:protected] => http://www.cpwr.com [about:protected] => [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => 2003-10-02 [date_completed:protected] => 2003-10-06 [date_billed:protected] => 2003-11-03 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [organizations:protected] => Array ( [1] => Organization Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [elcosh_id:protected] => o000001 [user_id:protected] => 14 [province_id:protected] => 21 [country_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => CPWR - The Center for Construction Research and Training [address:protected] => Suite 1000, 8484 Georgia Ave [postal_code:protected] => 20910 [city:protected] => Silver Spring [department:protected] => [phone:protected] => 301-578-8500 [fax:protected] => 301-578-8572 [email:protected] => cpwrwebsite@cpwr.com [website:protected] => http://www.cpwr.com [filename:protected] => o000001.gif [about:protected] => CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training, developed, and continues to maintain/expand this website - The Electronic Library of Construction Occupational Safety and Health, www.elcosh.org. CPWR, formerly known as The Center to Protect Workers’ Rights, is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit research and training institution. Created by the Building and Construction Trades Department, AFL-CIO, CPWR serves as the research arm of the BCTD. Since the inception of its research agenda in 1990, CPWR has grown into a worldwide provider of safety and health information covering all aspects of the construction industry. CPWR launched eLCOSH in 2000, and the Spanish-language version of the site in 2001. CPWR also created, and continues to build, Construction Solutions - www.cpwrConstructionSolutions.org - a free, online database of construction hazards and ways to prevent, eliminate, or reduce them. [comments:protected] => [logo_available:protected] => T [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => 2000-08-18 [date_completed:protected] => 2000-08-30 [date_billed:protected] => 2000-09-05 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [collections:protected] => Array ( [3913] => ) [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => Array ( [1874] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1874 [old_id:protected] => 722 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000683 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Sharon Garber/COD [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Protecting Tuckpointing Workers from Silica Dust: Draft Recommendations for a Ventilated Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 12 [billed_pages:protected] => 12 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, vacuum, grinder, mortar, respirator, OSHA, NIOSH, exhaust, Heitbrink, tuckpointer, silica, masonry, dust, silicosis, LEV [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Describes draft recommendations for use of ventilated grinder to reduce dust during tuckpointing and describes field trials using these devices. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/hazard/67/chip-scrape-and-grind-surfaces-or-joints-silica.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001201,d000292,d000293,d000658 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2005 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/27/05 [date_completed:protected] => 04/26/05 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/20/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [1940] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1940 [old_id:protected] => 909 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Workplace Solutions: Control of Hazardous Dust During Tuckpointing [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, silica, dust, tuckpoint, grinder, masonry restoration, mortar, vacuum [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d000819,d000820,d000730,d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 10/24/08 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/09 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [2213] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 2213 [old_id:protected] => 1090 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => [language_id:protected] => 2 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Control del polvo peligroso que se genera durante los procesos de reparación de mortero [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => 2008-126 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => [comments:protected] => http://www.cdc.gov/spanish/niosh/docs/wp-solutions/2008-126_sp/ [summary:protected] => A Workplace Solutions de NIOSH que resume un estudio de NIOSH sobre los riesgos de exposición cuando se reparan las estructuras y los métodos para controlar el polvo. [A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust.] [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => D000819,D000820,D000730,d000819 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 01/07/10 [date_completed:protected] => 04/19/10 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 07/08/12 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [3656] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3656 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001198 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 24 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction While Doing Tuckpointing/Mortar Removal [total_pages:protected] => 2 [billed_pages:protected] => 2 [publication_number:protected] => DSG FS-3632 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Brick, block, tuckpointing, silica, local exhaust ventilation, LEV, masonry [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Tuckpointing creates some of the greatest exposures to silica in construction. This OSHA factsheet provides guidance on how to greatly reduce these exposures through the use of local exhaust ventilation. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863, d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => February 2013 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/04/13 [date_completed:protected] => 03/27/13 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [3899] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3899 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001342 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: Hilti VC40-U Vacuum with Hilti DC-EX Dust Guard and Hilti Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 15 [billed_pages:protected] => 15 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP4 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => silica, tuckpointing, Hilti, local exhaust systems, LEV, shroud, quartz [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This report describes the results of an evaluation of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Hilti VC40-U vacuum, a Hilti DC-EX shroud, and a Hilti DAG-500 grinder. Randomized trials with and without use of the dust control system were conducted in a controlled setting. Removing mortar with the Hilti grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 220 times the National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05mg/m3. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 97 percent. However, exposures measured during the use of the dust control system still exceeded the NIOSH REL. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => December 1, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/05/14 [date_completed:protected] => 02/04/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/06/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [content:protected] => [files:protected] => Array ( [559] => [560] => [546] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 546 [filename:protected] => 3.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:22 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [566] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 566 [filename:protected] => 4.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:23 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [720] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 720 [filename:protected] => 5.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [721] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 721 [filename:protected] => 6.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [722] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 722 [filename:protected] => 7.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [9765] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 9765 [filename:protected] => d001345.pdf [downloadable:protected] => T [timestamp:protected] => 2015-02-09 12:26:04 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3908 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001345 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: DustControl 2900c Vacuum with the ICS Dust Director Shroud and Bosch Grinder Model 1775E Conducted November 14-15, 2012 [total_pages:protected] => 13 [billed_pages:protected] => 13 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP2 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => tuckpointing, HEPA vacuum, dust control, LEV, local exhaust ventilation, silica [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => April 15, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 01/26/15 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/09/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [show_text] => [document_content] => ElcoshItemDocumentContent Object ( [id:protected] => 2934 [item_id:protected] => 3908 [type:protected] => main [title:protected] => [content:protected] =>
Executive Summary
This report describes the results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. It should also be noted that the NIOSH REL is based on exposures averaged over a ten hour work day and our results represent time weighted averages of the sample task duration periods.
Acronyms
ACGIH - American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists
CPWR - CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training
Ce - coefficient of entry
HEPA - high-efficiency particulate air
IUBAC - International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craftworkers
LEV - local exhaust ventilation
PACT - Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies
NIOSH - National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health
OEL - occupational exposure limit
OSHA - Occupational Safety and Health Administration
PAPR - powered air-purifying respirator
PEL - Permissible Exposure Limit
PVC - polyvinyl chloride
REL - Recommended Exposure Limit
RPM - revolutions per minute
TWA - time-weighted average
SP - static pressure
I. Introduction and Background
In 2010 CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training began a four-year project which seeks to identify and evaluate tuckpointing local exhaust ventilation (LEV) systems and disseminate information on their availability and effectiveness. A Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies (PACT) comprised of masonry contractors, representatives from unions, government, equipment manufacturers, and health and safety researcher was formed as part of this project. PACT members participated in identifying important characteristics for control technologies and this information was used to identify LEV systems for tuckpointing using that criteria. Contractor and labor members of the PACT selected specific tuckpointing LEV systems to be considered for evaluation. Each system consisted of a tuckpointing grinder, shroud, and vacuum. This report describes the second of four systems to be evaluated between 2012 the end of 2014, with and without LEV, in a controlled setting to determine effectiveness in silica exposure reduction. This report describes the methods and results of our evaluation of a system consisting of the DustControl 2900c vacuum with the ICS Dust Director shroud and a Bosch Model 1775E grinder.
Excessive exposure to respirable silica can result in silicosis or other silica-related diseases including pulmonary tuberculosis, lung cancer, silicoproteinosis (Lyons et al, 2007) and autoimmune disorders such as rheumatoid arthritis, sarcoidosis and scleroderma (Miller et al, 2012). Respirable silica is generally defined as particles less than 10 micrometers (μm) in aerodynamic diameter (ACGIH, 2013). Silicosis can lead to symptoms including shortness of breath, fatigue, chest pains, susceptibility to infection and possibly death. There is no cure for silicosis, however it is totally preventable. Construction workers exposed to dust, including silica, are also known to have higher rates of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD).
There are many sources of silica in construction that result in exposures of varying intensity among workers. Masonry restoration workers are among the most highly silica-exposed trades in construction. The process of grinding out deteriorated mortar joints between masonry units and replacing or repointing with fresh mortar (often referred to as tuckpointing) is a fundamental part of masonry restoration work. The removal of mortar with powered angle grinders generates enormous levels of dust. Between 2004 and 2006, NIOSH and CPWR evaluated silica exposures while grinding mortar in a controlled setting, at a local training center, where tasks, sample times and task variables were defined by the study design. These studies demonstrated that grinding mortar without controls can result in elevated respirable silica exposures. Meeker et al., (2009) reported exposures between 5 and 25.8 milligrams per cubic meter (mg/m3) in a controlled setting. This study also showed that LEV systems for tuckpointing grinders can reduce exposures to respirable silica by greater than 90 percent.II. Objectives
The objective of this evaluation was to assess the effectiveness of an LEV system for controlling exposure to silica during the grinding of mortar. The control technology was tested under controlled conditions, similar to those experienced by tuckpointers on actual job sites, using journeymen bricklayers experienced in tuckpointing and repeat, randomized trials with and without LEV. All other variables were held constant throughout so that the only variable was whether or not the tested control was used.
III. Description of Equipment Tested
A Bosch model 1775E grinder (Robert Bosch Tool Corporation, Prospect, IL) (Figures 1, 2 and 3) was fitted with a new 1/4-inch wide, 4½-inch diameter segmented diamond abrasive blade made by DeWalt (model #DW4740). The grinder weighs six and a half pounds, draws 8.5 amps and has a variable speed up to 11,000 revolutions per minute (RPMs). The DustControl 2900c vacuum (DustControl, Inc., Wilmington, NC) (Figure 3) was tested in combination with the Dust Director shroud (Industrial Contractors’ Supplies, Inc., Huntingdon, PA) (Figures 1 and 3) attached to the Bosch grinder.
Figure 1. Bosch grinder with Dust Director shroud
Figure 2. Bosch grinder without tuckpointing LEV system.
Figure 3: Bosch Grinder with LEV System
The vacuum is specified to weigh 31 pounds when empty and to provide a flow rate of 114 cubic feet of air per minute and a “static lift” or “vacuum suction pressure” of 84 inches of water. The vacuum is sold with a cyclonic pre-separator, to remove larger particles, a fine filter (rated 99.9 percent efficient) and a HEPA (high-efficiency particulate air) filter (rated to capture 99.97 percent of the particles with an aerodynamic diameter of 0.3 micrometers). The HEPA filter was removed based on the manufacturer’s recommendation due to the heavy dust loading associated with tuckpointing. CPWR sponsored research and contractor experience indicate that HEPA filters likely have an adverse effect on dust capture during tuckpointing because of extreme dust loading on filters. While the cyclone and the fine filter remove most of the dust, especially the large particles, before they reach the HEPA filter, the HEPA filter would still be subject to heavy loading, causing a substantial pressure drop and subsequent decrease in air flow rate. The relatively small increase in the efficiency of the filtration system while using the HEPA filter is expected to be quickly offset by a more significant decrease in capture efficiency as the air flow rate and ability to capture particles decreases.
Dust collects in relatively inexpensive, heavy-gauge plastic bags below and outside of the cyclone. The bags can be removed and replaced without opening the vacuum. Some vacuums are equipped with a light to indicate that the filters need to be cleaned or changed. The DC2900c features a “reverse air pulse cleaning system,” which removes accumulated dust from the filters without having to remove them from the vacuum. The system, as illustrated in Figure 4, requires the operator to disconnect the hose from the shroud, place it over an air stop so that air through the hose is cut off and pressure in the vacuum is maximized.
Figure 4. Procedure for "cleaning" of or dust removal from filters (source: http://dustcontrolusa.com/manuals/2800c.pdf)
The flap covering the port on the side of the vacuum is repeatedly flipped open to release built up pressure in strong pulses that dislodge dust from the filter.
The manufacturer indicates “the filter is generally cleaned once or twice daily during normal continuous operation.” The Dust Director shroud has a 2-inch diameter take-off that was connected to the antistatic, corrugated 1.5-inch diameter, 15-foot long vacuum hose supplied with the DustControl vacuum.
IV. Study Methods
This evaluation was conducted at the International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craft workers (IUBAC) Local 1 Philadelphia/Delaware Training Center in Philadelphia, PA on November 14 and 15, 2012. A single journeyman bricklayer, experienced in tuckpointing, used the grinder and LEV system being tested to remove mortar from joints wide enough to require two passes. The type S mortar had been allowed to cure for at least four weeks. The bricklayer either possessed or was provided with personal protective equipment including sturdy work boots, gloves, hearing protection and a powered air-purifying respirator (PAPR). The PAPR was a 3M GVP system with a bump cap, loose fitting face piece and a HEPA filter (3M, St Paul, MN).
The study was designed to include at least five rounds of sampling during mortar removal. Each round included a trial using the Bosch grinder with a Dust Director shroud and Dust Collector 2900c vacuum and a trial using the Bosch grinder with the factory-supplied guard and without a vacuum. The order of the two trials within each round was randomly selected to minimize bias that might be introduced due to variation associated with environmental factors, equipment operator, blade wear, vacuum performance over time and any other factors unrelated to LEV use. Tools were operated for approximately 16 minutes per trial with controls and for approximately 8 minutes when controls were not used. These times were selected based on the results of previous sampling efforts and estimates of the minimum sample time needed to achieve a limit of quantification low enough to accurately measure exposures down to or less than 0.05 mg/m3 – the NIOSH Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) for respirable silica. The bricklayer was required to take a 5 to 10 minute break in the middle of the 16-minute trials to reduce differences in fatigue, compared to the 8-minute trials. Personal air samples were collected in the breathing zone of the operator during each trial to measure respirable silica concentrations during grinding with and without LEV. The samples were collected using a GilAir-5 pump (Sensidyne, Inc., Clearwater, FL) to draw 4.2 liters of air per minute through a GK2.69 Respirable Cyclone (BGI Inc., Waltham, MA) with a pre-weighed, 37 mm diameter, 5-micron pore size polyvinyl chloride (PVC) filter positioned on the operator’s lapel.
The flow rates of the sampling pumps were calibrated at the beginning of each day using a DryCal DC-Lite Primary Flow Meter (Bios International Corporation, Butler, NJ). Flow rates were measured again near the middle and at the end of each day to ensure that sampling flow rates were maintained within 5% of pre-sampling flow rates throughout the day. Average flow rates were used to calculate sample air volumes. Samples were analyzed by R.J. Lee Group, Inc., (Monroeville, PA) using NIOSH Method 0600, to determine exposure to total mass of respirable dust. The same samples were also analyzed using X-Ray diffraction following NIOSH method 7500 to determine quartz, cristobalite and tridymite concentration in the respirable mass. Reported masses for these analytes were used with the sample air volumes to calculate airborne concentrations of total respirable dust, quartz, cristobalite and tridymite.
We used a reduction of greater than 50 percent in respirable silica exposure concentrations or a reduction to less than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 as our criteria for determining whether or not a control was considered efficacious. This is consistent with criteria used by NIOSH in conducting a similar study in 2004 described by Echt et al. (2007) and by CPWR in 2006 and described by Meeker et al. (2009). The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) and the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) publish additional occupational exposure limits (OELs) for silica which are listed in Table 1 with NIOSH RELs. OELs for silica are based on the respirable fraction of the aerosol, which consists of particles less than 10 micrometers in aerodynamic diameter.
| Organization or Agency | Form of Crystalline Silica | Occupational Exposure Limits (mg/m3) |
|---|---|---|
| NIOSHA | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 |
| OSHA - ConstructionB | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
PEL = 250 / (5 + % quartz) PEL = 250 / (5 + % cristobalite) PEL = 250 / (5 + % tridymite) |
| ACGIH | Crystalline Silica | TLV = 0.025 mg/m3 |
A NIOSH Publication No. 2005-151 indicates 10-hour time-weighted average during a 40-hr workweek B The PEL for silica in OSHA’s Safety and Health Regulations for Construction, 29 C.F.R. 1926.55(a), is an 8-hour time-weighted average (TWA) expressed in millions of particles per cubic foot (mppcf). However, the units mppcf can be converted to milligrams per cubic meter can by dividing mppcf by 10 (OSHA, 2009). The formula used by OSHA to determine the PEL for silica is dependent on the percentage of silica in each collected sample. The concentration of respirable dust measured is compared to the sample specific PEL to determine if the PEL has been exceeded. OSHA has proposed lowering the PEL to 0.05 mg/m3 of respirable silica as an 8 hour TWA. |
||
The flow of air in ventilation systems is governed by fundamental principles that describe the behavior of gases (in this case air). Pressure measurements taken within a ventilation system along with knowledge of hood (or shroud) entry losses can be used to calculate flow rates. Hood entry losses are dependent on the shape and configuration of a particular hood or shroud and described by the term “coefficient of entry (Ce)” which is the ratio of actual air flow through a hood and what the air flow would theoretically be if there were no hood entry losses. Given the coefficient of entry, static pressure measurements can be used to calculate air flow through a given hood. The coefficient of entry for the Dust Director shroud was previously determined by CPWR and used for calculating air flow based on static pressure measurements (Meeker et al., 2009). Static pressure, with the vacuum operating, was measured periodically throughout the evaluation to monitor the changes in air-flow rate following use and again after filter cleaning. The static pressure was measured at a port positioned more than 3 duct diameters downstream from the tool’s air intake using a UEi EM200 Electronic Manometer (Universal Enterprises, Inc., Beaverton, OR).
The dust in the vacuum bag was monitored and, per the manufacturer’s instructions, the bag was changed before the dust level was within 5 centimeters of the valve at the bottom of the vacuum. Each time a vacuum bag was removed, it was weighed to the nearest pound. The bag weights and corresponding grinding durations were used to calculate the average weight of dust collected per unit time. After each trial, cut lengths were measured on the wall to determine total linear feet of vertical (head) and horizontal (bed) joints per unit time.
A Haz-Dust III, Model HD-1003, Real-Time Aerosol Monitor (Environmental Devices Corporation, Plaistow, NH) was used to confirm clearance of dust between trials. The Haz-Dust monitor was positioned on the test wall near the operator at approximately breathing zone level and configured to measure respirable particulate concentration.
V. Results
Personal air monitoring
Five pairs of respirable dust samples were collected while grinding with and without the vacuum system. In addition, three respirable dust samples were collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place. One measurement collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard was shown to be a statistical outlier and was omitted from analysis. Personal air monitoring results for respirable silica and a comparison of average exposures relative to the NIOSH REL for silica (0.05 mg/m3) appears in Table 2. The mean respirable dust levels measured without LEV was 31.4 mg/m3. However, samples collected with LEV were below the limit of quantification (LOQ) which ranged from <1.29 to <1.46 mg/m3. Use of LEV resulted in a greater than 95% reduction in mean respirable dust levels using a mean value with use of LEV of <1.41 (n=5 samples with use of LEV and n=7 without use of LEV). The respirable dust samples collected during grinding without the LEV system contained an average of 24 percent silica. The mass of respirable dust in the samples collected with use of the LEV system was too low to determine the silica content.| Mean, mg/m3 (range) | Std. Dev. | Percent Reduction | Hazard RatioB | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bosch with Dust Director Shroud and DustControl 2900c Vacuum |
0.091 (<0.069 – 0.137) |
0.027 | 98.7 | 1.81 |
| Bosch with no Control | 7.23 (4.57 – 9.90) |
1.94 | NA | 145 |
A n = 5 samples for each tool/control combination and n = 7 samples without the use of the LEV system B Hazard Ratio = measured exposure / NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 |
||||
Average respirable silica and dust exposures, with and without the dust control system, appear as Figures 5 and 6, respectively.
Figure 5. Average respirable silica exposures with and without the Dustcontrol 2900c vacuum and Dust Director shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air - mg/m3)
Figure 6. Average respirable dust exposures with and without Dustcontrol 2900c Vacuum and Dust Director Shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air – mg/m3)
The mean respirable silica concentration measured during use of the control was significantly less than the concentration measured while using the same tool without controls (p<0.01). Grinding mortar with the Bosch angle grinder without dust controls resulted in an average exposure to respirable silica that was 145 times the NIOSH REL. Grinding with the Bosch angle grinder in combination with the Dust Director shroud and the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced the average concentration of respirable silica by 98.7 percent. With use of these controls, the concentration of respirable silica was 1.8 times greater than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3. However the NIOSH REL is based on a time-weighted average (TWA) over a 10-hour workday. Given these were task TWAs and samples were collected over continuous periods of grinding, they may overestimate exposures over an actual work day since some time would be spent performing tasks that would likely have lower, or no, silica exposures (setup, breaks, cleanup, etc.).
Static pressure, dust mass collection and grinding rates.
Static pressure was used as a surrogate for air flow as described earlier. Hood static pressure was measured periodically at a tap near the grinder more than 3 duct diameters from the air intake in the shroud. The static pressure, and thus air flow, was generally higher when the vacuum’s filter had recently been cleaned. The mean, median, and range of calculated flow rates are presented in Table A1 of the Appendix.
Based on the data we collected, the air-flow rate upstream from the Bosch grinder and Dust Director shroud ranged from 78 to 93 cubic feet per minute (cfm) with the DustControl vacuum. When the manufacturer’s filter cleaning procedure was followed the vacuum performed relatively well and flow could be maintained at slightly less than 90 cfm with cleaning. However, mean flow rates dropped substantially to 80 cfm after as little as 8 minutes of grinding without any filter cleaning. The flow rate returned to an average of 89 cfm when filters were cleaned correctly (without stopping air flow to the vacuum). Collingwood and Heitbrink (2007) found that the minimum exhaust flow rate for capture of silica and other particulate under ideal conditions is 21.25 cfm per inch of grinder blade diameter. This is equal to about 96 cfm when using a 4.5 inch diameter grinding blade. We set 106 cfm as the minimum desired flow rate for this study to allow a safety margin for potential decline in equipment performance and the possibility of inadequate maintenance, both of which may be likely after repeated use under actual work conditions. The DustControl vacuum provided slightly less than the minimum flow rate described by Collingwood and Heitbrink for a 4.5-inch blade and the peak flow rate fell with use.
The duration of vacuum bag use and mass of dust collected were recorded and are presented in Table A2 of the Appendix. The vacuum bags were changed and weighed after each trial utilizing the LEV system. A total of five bags were used to complete the five rounds of grinding. The DustControl vacuum captured 45 pounds of dust over 83 minutes of grinding for an average rate of dust collection of 0.54 pounds per minute. The rate of dust collection ranged from 0.47 to 0.63 pounds per minute. Based on these measurements, approximately 130 pounds of dust would likely be captured after just 4 hours of continuous grinding.
The rate of grinding a combination of vertical and horizontal joints while using the LEV system ranged from 2.3 to 3.3 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the use of the LEV system ranged from 2.6 to 3.4 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place ranged from 4.7 to 5.1 feet per minute. It’s important to note that: 1) the operator had limited experience using dust control systems and cut rates appeared to improve slightly over the 2-day period he used the tested equipment; and 2) the upper range of cut rates with the dust control system overlapped with the lowest cut rate with the original guard and without the LEV system in place indicating no statistical difference between cut rates. Given that grinding rates with and without use of this LEV system are only available for one operator and he had limited experience with the LEV system, these reported cut rates are in no way intended to represent the impact use of this LEV system is likely to have on productivity rates overall.
VI. Discussion
The objective of these trials was to evaluate the effectiveness of a tuckpointing LEV system for controlling respirable silica while grinding out mortar joints. The Dust Director shroud with the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced respirable silica concentrations when grinding with the Bosch grinder by approximately 99 percent. Despite being considered effective by our test criteria (greater than 50% reduction), it still resulted in task TWA exposures that exceeded the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 by 1.8 times. Depending on how much time is spent grinding over the course of a work day and on exposures while performing other tasks, the 8-hour TWA exposures may or may not exceed the REL with this system. Use of this system by workers with experience and training in proficient use will likely improve dust capture performance. Exposure reduction is greatly influenced by correct use of this system which includes grinding from right to left, making sure the shroud is held flush against the wall and that the tool travels at a pace that doesn’t exceed the ability of the system to capture dust as it’s generated. Deviation from any of these measures produces visible dust clouds which were observed during trials.
VII. Conclusions
With a 99 percent reduction in respirable silica exposure, the Dust Director shroud and DustControl 2900c vacuum with a Bosch Model 1775E grinder was effective in reducing silica exposures based on our criteria. Use of the tested dust control system may be effective in reducing silica exposure on the job to less than the NIOSH REL if used in combination with administrative controls such as work scheduling to reduce cutting times as needed. Training on correct use of the tested system is also essential. Personal air monitoring is necessary to verify control effectiveness on actual job sites and under “real-world” conditions. However, these results clearly demonstrate the availability of viable and effective engineering controls for tuckpointing operations associated with elevated silica exposure.
VIII. References
American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists. Threshold limit values for chemical substances (TLV®-CS). [2013]. ACGIH, Cincinnati, Ohio.
Bergdahl I.A,. Toren K., Eriksson K., et al. [2004]. Increased mortality in COPD among construction workers exposed to inorganic dust. European Respiratory Journal, 23: 402–06.
Blanc P.D. & Torén K. [2007]. Occupation in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and chronic bronchitis: an update [State of the Art Series. Occupational lung disease in high-and low-income countries, Edited by M. Chan-Yeung. Number 2 in the series]. The International Journal of Tuberculosis and Lung Disease, 11(3), 251-257.
Collingwood S. & Heitbrink W.A. [2007] 'Field Evaluation of an Engineering Control for Respirable Crystalline Silica Exposures During Mortar Removal'. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, 4:11, 875 – 887.
DHHS (NIOSH) Publication No. 2002-129 April 2002 http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/2002-129/
Echt A., Sieber W.K., Lefkowitz D., Meeker J., Susi P., Cardwell B., Heitbrink, W.A. In-depth survey of dust control technology for cutting concrete block and tuckpointing brick at The International Masonry Institute Bordentown Training Center, Bordentown, NJ. Cincinnati, OH: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Report. No. EPHB 282-13; 2007. http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ECTB-282-13.pdf
Heitbrink W., Bennett J. [2006]. A numerical and experimental investigation of crystalline silica exposure control during tuck pointing. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, Vol. 3, pp 366-378.
Lyons et al, [2007]. A breathless builder. Breathe, Vol. 3, no. 4, pp 386-390.
Mastrangelo G., Tartari M., Fedeli U., Fadda E., Saia B. [2003]. Ascertaining the risk of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease in relation to occupation using a case-control design. Occupational Medicine, 53: 165–172.
Meeker J., Cooper M., Lefrowitz D., Susi P. [2009]. Engineering control technologies to reduce occupational silica exposures in masonry cutting and tuckpointing. Public Health Reports, Supplement 1, Vol. 124, June.
Meeker J, Flynn M, Susi P, Cardwell, B [2004]. Performance evaluation of a masonry concrete vacuum. Unpublished Report.
Miller F. W., Alfredsson L., Costenbader K. H., Kamen D. L., Nelson L. M., Norris J. M., & De Roos A. J. [2012]. Epidemiology of environmental exposures and human autoimmune diseases: findings from a National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences Expert Panel workshop. Journal of autoimmunity. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3496812/
Occupational Safety and Health Administration U.S Department of Labor. Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction. [2009]. OSHA 3362-05.
Rappaport SM, Goldberg M, Susi P, Herrick RF [2003]. Excessive exposure to silica in the U.S. construction industry. Annals of Occupational Hygiene, Vol. 47, pp. 111-122.
IX. Appendices
| Measurement Conditions |
n | Mean Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Median
Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before filter cleaning | 5 | 80 | 81 | 78-81 |
| After filter cleaning following manufacturer directions | 9 | 89 | 90 | 84-93 |
| * Static pressure was measured in millibars and converted to inches of water gauge. Flow rates were calculated using the formula Q = Ce (A) 4005 (SP)1/2 where: Q = flow in cubic feet per minute (cfm), Ce = coefficient of entry, A = area of the duct where static pressure measurements were taken in square feet, and SP = static pressure in inches of water gauge. | ||||
| Tool/Control | Collection Period (min.) |
Dust Collection Rate (lb/min.) |
|---|---|---|
| Bosch grinder/Dust Director shroud & DustControl 2900c vacuum |
8 11 8 8 10 |
0.50 0.61 0.50 0.47 0.63 |
| Average | 0.54 |
[content_transformed:protected] =>
Executive Summary
This report describes the results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. It should also be noted that the NIOSH REL is based on exposures averaged over a ten hour work day and our results represent time weighted averages of the sample task duration periods.
Acronyms
ACGIH - American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists
CPWR - CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training
Ce - coefficient of entry
HEPA - high-efficiency particulate air
IUBAC - International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craftworkers
LEV - local exhaust ventilation
PACT - Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies
NIOSH - National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health
OEL - occupational exposure limit
OSHA - Occupational Safety and Health Administration
PAPR - powered air-purifying respirator
PEL - Permissible Exposure Limit
PVC - polyvinyl chloride
REL - Recommended Exposure Limit
RPM - revolutions per minute
TWA - time-weighted average
SP - static pressure
I. Introduction and Background
In 2010 CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training began a four-year project which seeks to identify and evaluate tuckpointing local exhaust ventilation (LEV) systems and disseminate information on their availability and effectiveness. A Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies (PACT) comprised of masonry contractors, representatives from unions, government, equipment manufacturers, and health and safety researcher was formed as part of this project. PACT members participated in identifying important characteristics for control technologies and this information was used to identify LEV systems for tuckpointing using that criteria. Contractor and labor members of the PACT selected specific tuckpointing LEV systems to be considered for evaluation. Each system consisted of a tuckpointing grinder, shroud, and vacuum. This report describes the second of four systems to be evaluated between 2012 the end of 2014, with and without LEV, in a controlled setting to determine effectiveness in silica exposure reduction. This report describes the methods and results of our evaluation of a system consisting of the DustControl 2900c vacuum with the ICS Dust Director shroud and a Bosch Model 1775E grinder.
Excessive exposure to respirable silica can result in silicosis or other silica-related diseases including pulmonary tuberculosis, lung cancer, silicoproteinosis (Lyons et al, 2007) and autoimmune disorders such as rheumatoid arthritis, sarcoidosis and scleroderma (Miller et al, 2012). Respirable silica is generally defined as particles less than 10 micrometers (μm) in aerodynamic diameter (ACGIH, 2013). Silicosis can lead to symptoms including shortness of breath, fatigue, chest pains, susceptibility to infection and possibly death. There is no cure for silicosis, however it is totally preventable. Construction workers exposed to dust, including silica, are also known to have higher rates of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD).
There are many sources of silica in construction that result in exposures of varying intensity among workers. Masonry restoration workers are among the most highly silica-exposed trades in construction. The process of grinding out deteriorated mortar joints between masonry units and replacing or repointing with fresh mortar (often referred to as tuckpointing) is a fundamental part of masonry restoration work. The removal of mortar with powered angle grinders generates enormous levels of dust. Between 2004 and 2006, NIOSH and CPWR evaluated silica exposures while grinding mortar in a controlled setting, at a local training center, where tasks, sample times and task variables were defined by the study design. These studies demonstrated that grinding mortar without controls can result in elevated respirable silica exposures. Meeker et al., (2009) reported exposures between 5 and 25.8 milligrams per cubic meter (mg/m3) in a controlled setting. This study also showed that LEV systems for tuckpointing grinders can reduce exposures to respirable silica by greater than 90 percent.II. Objectives
The objective of this evaluation was to assess the effectiveness of an LEV system for controlling exposure to silica during the grinding of mortar. The control technology was tested under controlled conditions, similar to those experienced by tuckpointers on actual job sites, using journeymen bricklayers experienced in tuckpointing and repeat, randomized trials with and without LEV. All other variables were held constant throughout so that the only variable was whether or not the tested control was used.
III. Description of Equipment Tested
A Bosch model 1775E grinder (Robert Bosch Tool Corporation, Prospect, IL) (Figures 1, 2 and 3) was fitted with a new 1/4-inch wide, 4½-inch diameter segmented diamond abrasive blade made by DeWalt (model #DW4740). The grinder weighs six and a half pounds, draws 8.5 amps and has a variable speed up to 11,000 revolutions per minute (RPMs). The DustControl 2900c vacuum (DustControl, Inc., Wilmington, NC) (Figure 3) was tested in combination with the Dust Director shroud (Industrial Contractors’ Supplies, Inc., Huntingdon, PA) (Figures 1 and 3) attached to the Bosch grinder.
Figure 1. Bosch grinder with Dust Director shroud
Figure 2. Bosch grinder without tuckpointing LEV system.
Figure 3: Bosch Grinder with LEV System
The vacuum is specified to weigh 31 pounds when empty and to provide a flow rate of 114 cubic feet of air per minute and a “static lift” or “vacuum suction pressure” of 84 inches of water. The vacuum is sold with a cyclonic pre-separator, to remove larger particles, a fine filter (rated 99.9 percent efficient) and a HEPA (high-efficiency particulate air) filter (rated to capture 99.97 percent of the particles with an aerodynamic diameter of 0.3 micrometers). The HEPA filter was removed based on the manufacturer’s recommendation due to the heavy dust loading associated with tuckpointing. CPWR sponsored research and contractor experience indicate that HEPA filters likely have an adverse effect on dust capture during tuckpointing because of extreme dust loading on filters. While the cyclone and the fine filter remove most of the dust, especially the large particles, before they reach the HEPA filter, the HEPA filter would still be subject to heavy loading, causing a substantial pressure drop and subsequent decrease in air flow rate. The relatively small increase in the efficiency of the filtration system while using the HEPA filter is expected to be quickly offset by a more significant decrease in capture efficiency as the air flow rate and ability to capture particles decreases.
Dust collects in relatively inexpensive, heavy-gauge plastic bags below and outside of the cyclone. The bags can be removed and replaced without opening the vacuum. Some vacuums are equipped with a light to indicate that the filters need to be cleaned or changed. The DC2900c features a “reverse air pulse cleaning system,” which removes accumulated dust from the filters without having to remove them from the vacuum. The system, as illustrated in Figure 4, requires the operator to disconnect the hose from the shroud, place it over an air stop so that air through the hose is cut off and pressure in the vacuum is maximized.
Figure 4. Procedure for "cleaning" of or dust removal from filters (source: http://dustcontrolusa.com/manuals/2800c.pdf)
The flap covering the port on the side of the vacuum is repeatedly flipped open to release built up pressure in strong pulses that dislodge dust from the filter.
The manufacturer indicates “the filter is generally cleaned once or twice daily during normal continuous operation.” The Dust Director shroud has a 2-inch diameter take-off that was connected to the antistatic, corrugated 1.5-inch diameter, 15-foot long vacuum hose supplied with the DustControl vacuum.
IV. Study Methods
This evaluation was conducted at the International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craft workers (IUBAC) Local 1 Philadelphia/Delaware Training Center in Philadelphia, PA on November 14 and 15, 2012. A single journeyman bricklayer, experienced in tuckpointing, used the grinder and LEV system being tested to remove mortar from joints wide enough to require two passes. The type S mortar had been allowed to cure for at least four weeks. The bricklayer either possessed or was provided with personal protective equipment including sturdy work boots, gloves, hearing protection and a powered air-purifying respirator (PAPR). The PAPR was a 3M GVP system with a bump cap, loose fitting face piece and a HEPA filter (3M, St Paul, MN).
The study was designed to include at least five rounds of sampling during mortar removal. Each round included a trial using the Bosch grinder with a Dust Director shroud and Dust Collector 2900c vacuum and a trial using the Bosch grinder with the factory-supplied guard and without a vacuum. The order of the two trials within each round was randomly selected to minimize bias that might be introduced due to variation associated with environmental factors, equipment operator, blade wear, vacuum performance over time and any other factors unrelated to LEV use. Tools were operated for approximately 16 minutes per trial with controls and for approximately 8 minutes when controls were not used. These times were selected based on the results of previous sampling efforts and estimates of the minimum sample time needed to achieve a limit of quantification low enough to accurately measure exposures down to or less than 0.05 mg/m3 – the NIOSH Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) for respirable silica. The bricklayer was required to take a 5 to 10 minute break in the middle of the 16-minute trials to reduce differences in fatigue, compared to the 8-minute trials. Personal air samples were collected in the breathing zone of the operator during each trial to measure respirable silica concentrations during grinding with and without LEV. The samples were collected using a GilAir-5 pump (Sensidyne, Inc., Clearwater, FL) to draw 4.2 liters of air per minute through a GK2.69 Respirable Cyclone (BGI Inc., Waltham, MA) with a pre-weighed, 37 mm diameter, 5-micron pore size polyvinyl chloride (PVC) filter positioned on the operator’s lapel.
The flow rates of the sampling pumps were calibrated at the beginning of each day using a DryCal DC-Lite Primary Flow Meter (Bios International Corporation, Butler, NJ). Flow rates were measured again near the middle and at the end of each day to ensure that sampling flow rates were maintained within 5% of pre-sampling flow rates throughout the day. Average flow rates were used to calculate sample air volumes. Samples were analyzed by R.J. Lee Group, Inc., (Monroeville, PA) using NIOSH Method 0600, to determine exposure to total mass of respirable dust. The same samples were also analyzed using X-Ray diffraction following NIOSH method 7500 to determine quartz, cristobalite and tridymite concentration in the respirable mass. Reported masses for these analytes were used with the sample air volumes to calculate airborne concentrations of total respirable dust, quartz, cristobalite and tridymite.
We used a reduction of greater than 50 percent in respirable silica exposure concentrations or a reduction to less than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 as our criteria for determining whether or not a control was considered efficacious. This is consistent with criteria used by NIOSH in conducting a similar study in 2004 described by Echt et al. (2007) and by CPWR in 2006 and described by Meeker et al. (2009). The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) and the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) publish additional occupational exposure limits (OELs) for silica which are listed in Table 1 with NIOSH RELs. OELs for silica are based on the respirable fraction of the aerosol, which consists of particles less than 10 micrometers in aerodynamic diameter.
| Organization or Agency | Form of Crystalline Silica | Occupational Exposure Limits (mg/m3) |
|---|---|---|
| NIOSHA | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 |
| OSHA - ConstructionB | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
PEL = 250 / (5 + % quartz) PEL = 250 / (5 + % cristobalite) PEL = 250 / (5 + % tridymite) |
| ACGIH | Crystalline Silica | TLV = 0.025 mg/m3 |
A NIOSH Publication No. 2005-151 indicates 10-hour time-weighted average during a 40-hr workweek B The PEL for silica in OSHA’s Safety and Health Regulations for Construction, 29 C.F.R. 1926.55(a), is an 8-hour time-weighted average (TWA) expressed in millions of particles per cubic foot (mppcf). However, the units mppcf can be converted to milligrams per cubic meter can by dividing mppcf by 10 (OSHA, 2009). The formula used by OSHA to determine the PEL for silica is dependent on the percentage of silica in each collected sample. The concentration of respirable dust measured is compared to the sample specific PEL to determine if the PEL has been exceeded. OSHA has proposed lowering the PEL to 0.05 mg/m3 of respirable silica as an 8 hour TWA. |
||
The flow of air in ventilation systems is governed by fundamental principles that describe the behavior of gases (in this case air). Pressure measurements taken within a ventilation system along with knowledge of hood (or shroud) entry losses can be used to calculate flow rates. Hood entry losses are dependent on the shape and configuration of a particular hood or shroud and described by the term “coefficient of entry (Ce)” which is the ratio of actual air flow through a hood and what the air flow would theoretically be if there were no hood entry losses. Given the coefficient of entry, static pressure measurements can be used to calculate air flow through a given hood. The coefficient of entry for the Dust Director shroud was previously determined by CPWR and used for calculating air flow based on static pressure measurements (Meeker et al., 2009). Static pressure, with the vacuum operating, was measured periodically throughout the evaluation to monitor the changes in air-flow rate following use and again after filter cleaning. The static pressure was measured at a port positioned more than 3 duct diameters downstream from the tool’s air intake using a UEi EM200 Electronic Manometer (Universal Enterprises, Inc., Beaverton, OR).
The dust in the vacuum bag was monitored and, per the manufacturer’s instructions, the bag was changed before the dust level was within 5 centimeters of the valve at the bottom of the vacuum. Each time a vacuum bag was removed, it was weighed to the nearest pound. The bag weights and corresponding grinding durations were used to calculate the average weight of dust collected per unit time. After each trial, cut lengths were measured on the wall to determine total linear feet of vertical (head) and horizontal (bed) joints per unit time.
A Haz-Dust III, Model HD-1003, Real-Time Aerosol Monitor (Environmental Devices Corporation, Plaistow, NH) was used to confirm clearance of dust between trials. The Haz-Dust monitor was positioned on the test wall near the operator at approximately breathing zone level and configured to measure respirable particulate concentration.
V. Results
Personal air monitoring
Five pairs of respirable dust samples were collected while grinding with and without the vacuum system. In addition, three respirable dust samples were collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place. One measurement collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard was shown to be a statistical outlier and was omitted from analysis. Personal air monitoring results for respirable silica and a comparison of average exposures relative to the NIOSH REL for silica (0.05 mg/m3) appears in Table 2. The mean respirable dust levels measured without LEV was 31.4 mg/m3. However, samples collected with LEV were below the limit of quantification (LOQ) which ranged from <1.29 to <1.46 mg/m3. Use of LEV resulted in a greater than 95% reduction in mean respirable dust levels using a mean value with use of LEV of <1.41 (n=5 samples with use of LEV and n=7 without use of LEV). The respirable dust samples collected during grinding without the LEV system contained an average of 24 percent silica. The mass of respirable dust in the samples collected with use of the LEV system was too low to determine the silica content.| Mean, mg/m3 (range) | Std. Dev. | Percent Reduction | Hazard RatioB | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bosch with Dust Director Shroud and DustControl 2900c Vacuum |
0.091 (<0.069 – 0.137) |
0.027 | 98.7 | 1.81 |
| Bosch with no Control | 7.23 (4.57 – 9.90) |
1.94 | NA | 145 |
A n = 5 samples for each tool/control combination and n = 7 samples without the use of the LEV system B Hazard Ratio = measured exposure / NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 |
||||
Average respirable silica and dust exposures, with and without the dust control system, appear as Figures 5 and 6, respectively.
Figure 5. Average respirable silica exposures with and without the Dustcontrol 2900c vacuum and Dust Director shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air - mg/m3)
Figure 6. Average respirable dust exposures with and without Dustcontrol 2900c Vacuum and Dust Director Shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air – mg/m3)
The mean respirable silica concentration measured during use of the control was significantly less than the concentration measured while using the same tool without controls (p<0.01). Grinding mortar with the Bosch angle grinder without dust controls resulted in an average exposure to respirable silica that was 145 times the NIOSH REL. Grinding with the Bosch angle grinder in combination with the Dust Director shroud and the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced the average concentration of respirable silica by 98.7 percent. With use of these controls, the concentration of respirable silica was 1.8 times greater than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3. However the NIOSH REL is based on a time-weighted average (TWA) over a 10-hour workday. Given these were task TWAs and samples were collected over continuous periods of grinding, they may overestimate exposures over an actual work day since some time would be spent performing tasks that would likely have lower, or no, silica exposures (setup, breaks, cleanup, etc.).
Static pressure, dust mass collection and grinding rates.
Static pressure was used as a surrogate for air flow as described earlier. Hood static pressure was measured periodically at a tap near the grinder more than 3 duct diameters from the air intake in the shroud. The static pressure, and thus air flow, was generally higher when the vacuum’s filter had recently been cleaned. The mean, median, and range of calculated flow rates are presented in Table A1 of the Appendix.
Based on the data we collected, the air-flow rate upstream from the Bosch grinder and Dust Director shroud ranged from 78 to 93 cubic feet per minute (cfm) with the DustControl vacuum. When the manufacturer’s filter cleaning procedure was followed the vacuum performed relatively well and flow could be maintained at slightly less than 90 cfm with cleaning. However, mean flow rates dropped substantially to 80 cfm after as little as 8 minutes of grinding without any filter cleaning. The flow rate returned to an average of 89 cfm when filters were cleaned correctly (without stopping air flow to the vacuum). Collingwood and Heitbrink (2007) found that the minimum exhaust flow rate for capture of silica and other particulate under ideal conditions is 21.25 cfm per inch of grinder blade diameter. This is equal to about 96 cfm when using a 4.5 inch diameter grinding blade. We set 106 cfm as the minimum desired flow rate for this study to allow a safety margin for potential decline in equipment performance and the possibility of inadequate maintenance, both of which may be likely after repeated use under actual work conditions. The DustControl vacuum provided slightly less than the minimum flow rate described by Collingwood and Heitbrink for a 4.5-inch blade and the peak flow rate fell with use.
The duration of vacuum bag use and mass of dust collected were recorded and are presented in Table A2 of the Appendix. The vacuum bags were changed and weighed after each trial utilizing the LEV system. A total of five bags were used to complete the five rounds of grinding. The DustControl vacuum captured 45 pounds of dust over 83 minutes of grinding for an average rate of dust collection of 0.54 pounds per minute. The rate of dust collection ranged from 0.47 to 0.63 pounds per minute. Based on these measurements, approximately 130 pounds of dust would likely be captured after just 4 hours of continuous grinding.
The rate of grinding a combination of vertical and horizontal joints while using the LEV system ranged from 2.3 to 3.3 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the use of the LEV system ranged from 2.6 to 3.4 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place ranged from 4.7 to 5.1 feet per minute. It’s important to note that: 1) the operator had limited experience using dust control systems and cut rates appeared to improve slightly over the 2-day period he used the tested equipment; and 2) the upper range of cut rates with the dust control system overlapped with the lowest cut rate with the original guard and without the LEV system in place indicating no statistical difference between cut rates. Given that grinding rates with and without use of this LEV system are only available for one operator and he had limited experience with the LEV system, these reported cut rates are in no way intended to represent the impact use of this LEV system is likely to have on productivity rates overall.
VI. Discussion
The objective of these trials was to evaluate the effectiveness of a tuckpointing LEV system for controlling respirable silica while grinding out mortar joints. The Dust Director shroud with the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced respirable silica concentrations when grinding with the Bosch grinder by approximately 99 percent. Despite being considered effective by our test criteria (greater than 50% reduction), it still resulted in task TWA exposures that exceeded the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 by 1.8 times. Depending on how much time is spent grinding over the course of a work day and on exposures while performing other tasks, the 8-hour TWA exposures may or may not exceed the REL with this system. Use of this system by workers with experience and training in proficient use will likely improve dust capture performance. Exposure reduction is greatly influenced by correct use of this system which includes grinding from right to left, making sure the shroud is held flush against the wall and that the tool travels at a pace that doesn’t exceed the ability of the system to capture dust as it’s generated. Deviation from any of these measures produces visible dust clouds which were observed during trials.
VII. Conclusions
With a 99 percent reduction in respirable silica exposure, the Dust Director shroud and DustControl 2900c vacuum with a Bosch Model 1775E grinder was effective in reducing silica exposures based on our criteria. Use of the tested dust control system may be effective in reducing silica exposure on the job to less than the NIOSH REL if used in combination with administrative controls such as work scheduling to reduce cutting times as needed. Training on correct use of the tested system is also essential. Personal air monitoring is necessary to verify control effectiveness on actual job sites and under “real-world” conditions. However, these results clearly demonstrate the availability of viable and effective engineering controls for tuckpointing operations associated with elevated silica exposure.
VIII. References
American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists. Threshold limit values for chemical substances (TLV®-CS). [2013]. ACGIH, Cincinnati, Ohio.
Bergdahl I.A,. Toren K., Eriksson K., et al. [2004]. Increased mortality in COPD among construction workers exposed to inorganic dust. European Respiratory Journal, 23: 402–06.
Blanc P.D. & Torén K. [2007]. Occupation in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and chronic bronchitis: an update [State of the Art Series. Occupational lung disease in high-and low-income countries, Edited by M. Chan-Yeung. Number 2 in the series]. The International Journal of Tuberculosis and Lung Disease, 11(3), 251-257.
Collingwood S. & Heitbrink W.A. [2007] 'Field Evaluation of an Engineering Control for Respirable Crystalline Silica Exposures During Mortar Removal'. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, 4:11, 875 – 887.
DHHS (NIOSH) Publication No. 2002-129 April 2002 http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/2002-129/
Echt A., Sieber W.K., Lefkowitz D., Meeker J., Susi P., Cardwell B., Heitbrink, W.A. In-depth survey of dust control technology for cutting concrete block and tuckpointing brick at The International Masonry Institute Bordentown Training Center, Bordentown, NJ. Cincinnati, OH: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Report. No. EPHB 282-13; 2007. http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ECTB-282-13.pdf
Heitbrink W., Bennett J. [2006]. A numerical and experimental investigation of crystalline silica exposure control during tuck pointing. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, Vol. 3, pp 366-378.
Lyons et al, [2007]. A breathless builder. Breathe, Vol. 3, no. 4, pp 386-390.
Mastrangelo G., Tartari M., Fedeli U., Fadda E., Saia B. [2003]. Ascertaining the risk of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease in relation to occupation using a case-control design. Occupational Medicine, 53: 165–172.
Meeker J., Cooper M., Lefrowitz D., Susi P. [2009]. Engineering control technologies to reduce occupational silica exposures in masonry cutting and tuckpointing. Public Health Reports, Supplement 1, Vol. 124, June.
Meeker J, Flynn M, Susi P, Cardwell, B [2004]. Performance evaluation of a masonry concrete vacuum. Unpublished Report.
Miller F. W., Alfredsson L., Costenbader K. H., Kamen D. L., Nelson L. M., Norris J. M., & De Roos A. J. [2012]. Epidemiology of environmental exposures and human autoimmune diseases: findings from a National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences Expert Panel workshop. Journal of autoimmunity. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3496812/
Occupational Safety and Health Administration U.S Department of Labor. Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction. [2009]. OSHA 3362-05.
Rappaport SM, Goldberg M, Susi P, Herrick RF [2003]. Excessive exposure to silica in the U.S. construction industry. Annals of Occupational Hygiene, Vol. 47, pp. 111-122.
IX. Appendices
| Measurement Conditions |
n | Mean Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Median
Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before filter cleaning | 5 | 80 | 81 | 78-81 |
| After filter cleaning following manufacturer directions | 9 | 89 | 90 | 84-93 |
| * Static pressure was measured in millibars and converted to inches of water gauge. Flow rates were calculated using the formula Q = Ce (A) 4005 (SP)1/2 where: Q = flow in cubic feet per minute (cfm), Ce = coefficient of entry, A = area of the duct where static pressure measurements were taken in square feet, and SP = static pressure in inches of water gauge. | ||||
| Tool/Control | Collection Period (min.) |
Dust Collection Rate (lb/min.) |
|---|---|---|
| Bosch grinder/Dust Director shroud & DustControl 2900c vacuum |
8 11 8 8 10 |
0.50 0.61 0.50 0.47 0.63 |
| Average | 0.54 |
[disclaimer:protected] => [disclaimer_transformed:protected] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [template] => record ) [_globalContext:PHPTAL_Context:private] => stdClass Object ( ) [_echoDeclarations:PHPTAL_Context:private] => [referer] => http://www.elcosh.org/document/3908/d001345/An%2BEvaluation%2Bof%2BSilica%2BExposure%2BControls%2Bfor%2BTuckpointing%253A%2BDustControl%2B2900c%2BVacuum%2Bwith%2Bthe%2BICS%2BDust%2BDirector%2BShroud%2Band%2BBosch%2BGrinder%2BModel%2B1775E%2BConducted%2BNovember%2B14-15%252C%2B2012.html [curr_module] => Record [styles] => Array ( ) [javascript] => Array ( [0] => jquery.min.js ) [metas] => Array ( [language] => en [robots] => index, follow ) [user] => [curr_url] => https://www.elcosh.org/index.php?module=Record&id=3908&type=document [base_url] => https://www.elcosh.org/index.php?module=Record [title] => eLCOSH : An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: DustControl 2900c Vacuum with the ICS Dust Director Shroud and Bosch Grinder Model 1775E Conducted November 14-15, 2012 [language] => en [search_query] => [module] => Record [new_records] => Array ( [0] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Fixed Ladder [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Fixed Ladders addresses the potential risks associated with using fixed ladders. The resource includes a brief case example,... [category] => Array ( [0] => 15 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 53 [5] => 55 [6] => 60 [7] => 64 [8] => 73 [9] => 76 [10] => 78 [11] => 80 [12] => 86 [13] => 87 [14] => 90 [15] => 92 [16] => 93 [17] => 94 [18] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Falls [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Concrete Polisher [11] => Electrical Worker [13] => HVAC [15] => Laborer [17] => PCC/Restoration [19] => Plumber/Pipefitter [21] => Roofer/Waterproofer [23] => Sheetmetal Worker [25] => Welder [27] => Commercial & Institutional [28] => Jobsites [29] => Industrial [31] => LEED/Green Construction [33] => Renovations [35] => Residential [37] => Toolbox Talks [38] => Documents [39] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4430/d001660/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BFixed%2BLadder.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [53] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 53 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Concrete Polisher [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [73] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 73 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => PCC/Restoration [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4430 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001660 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Fixed Ladder [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Fixed Ladders, Fall Prevention, Falls [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Fixed Ladders addresses the potential risks associated with using fixed ladders. The resource includes a brief case example, steps to prevent a related injury and questions for discussion. It includes an image that illustrates the hazard, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001257,d001254,d001255,d001256,d001258,d001262,d001279 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_completed:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/22/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [1] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Challenges Preventing Falling Objects [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Challenges Preventing Falling Objects addresses the hazards of being struck by falling objects on the job site. The resource... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 55 [5] => 64 [6] => 68 [7] => 71 [8] => 75 [9] => 78 [10] => 79 [11] => 82 [12] => 62 [13] => 86 [14] => 87 [15] => 88 [16] => 89 [17] => 91 [18] => 90 [19] => 92 [20] => 93 [21] => 94 [22] => 95 [23] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Electrical Worker [11] => Laborer [13] => Maintenance Worker [15] => Painter [17] => Plasterer [19] => Roofer/Waterproofer [21] => Scaffold Erector [23] => Stonemason [25] => Structural Ironworker [27] => Welder [29] => Commercial & Institutional [30] => Jobsites [31] => Demolition [33] => Disasters [35] => Heavy & Highway [37] => Industrial [39] => LEED/Green Construction [41] => Renovations [43] => Residential [45] => Underground [47] => Toolbox Talks [48] => Documents [49] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4431/d001661/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BChallenges%2BPreventing%2BFalling%2BObjects.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4431 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001661 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Challenges Preventing Falling Objects [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => dropped objects, falling objects, struck by incidents, struck by fatalities [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Challenges Preventing Falling Objects addresses the hazards of being struck by falling objects on the job site. The resource includes a brief example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates a group workers observing a scaffold free of debris during high winds, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001234,d001238,d001244,d001251,d001253,d001260,d001268,d001278 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_completed:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/22/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [2] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Tower Crane Safety [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Tower Crane Safety addresses the potential hazards of Tower Cranes and the importance of following procedure before and durin... [category] => Array ( [0] => 11 [1] => 12 [2] => 18 [3] => 70 [4] => 87 [5] => 88 [6] => 91 [7] => 90 [8] => 92 [9] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Cranes & Hoists [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Crushed/Struck By [6] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [9] => Operating Engineer [10] => Trades [11] => Commercial & Institutional [12] => Jobsites [13] => Demolition [15] => Heavy & Highway [17] => Industrial [19] => LEED/Green Construction [21] => Toolbox Talks [22] => Documents [23] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4427/d001657/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BTower%2BCrane%2BSafety.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [11] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 11 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Cranes & Hoists [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [18] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 18 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4427 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001657 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Tower Crane Safety [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Tower Crane, Crane, Stability, Tipping, Lift Zone Safety, Lift, Zone, Safety, Struck by [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Tower Crane Safety addresses the potential hazards of Tower Cranes and the importance of following procedure before and during Tower Crane operation. The resource includes a brief example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates a worker inspecting a Tower Crane before operation, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001234,d001238,d001250,d001251,d001253,d001258,d001262,d001273 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/19/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [3] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Work Zone Safety: Working Around Vehicles [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Working Around Vehicles in the Work Zone addresses methods to avoid being struck-by a vehicle on a construction site. The res... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 18 [2] => 52 [3] => 57 [4] => 70 [5] => 85 [6] => 87 [7] => 88 [8] => 89 [9] => 91 [10] => 90 [11] => 92 [12] => 93 [13] => 94 [14] => 95 [15] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [6] => Commercial Diver [7] => Trades [8] => Flagger [10] => Operating Engineer [12] => Truck Driver [14] => Commercial & Institutional [15] => Jobsites [16] => Demolition [18] => Disasters [20] => Heavy & Highway [22] => Industrial [24] => LEED/Green Construction [26] => Renovations [28] => Residential [30] => Underground [32] => Toolbox Talks [33] => Documents [34] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4428/d001658/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BWork%2BZone%2BSafety%253A%2BWorking%2BAround%2BVehicles.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [18] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 18 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [52] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 52 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Commercial Diver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [85] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 85 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Truck Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4428 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001658 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Daniela Caceres [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Work Zone Safety: Working Around Vehicles [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Struck, Struck by, Vehicle, Work Zone Safety, Truck, Operator, Driver, Mobile Equipment [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Working Around Vehicles in the Work Zone addresses methods to avoid being struck-by a vehicle on a construction site. The resource includes a case example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates the hazard, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001640 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/19/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [4] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Construction Dive -- DeWalt's Jobsite Pro headphones recalled for fire hazards [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => A recall notice by the United States Consumer Product Safety Commission affects over 300,000 DeWalt Jobsite Pro Headphones. The recall is a result of... [category] => Array ( [0] => 16 [1] => 44 [2] => 45 [3] => 46 [4] => 47 [5] => 48 [6] => 49 [7] => 50 [8] => 51 [9] => 52 [10] => 53 [11] => 54 [12] => 55 [13] => 56 [14] => 57 [15] => 58 [16] => 59 [17] => 60 [18] => 61 [19] => 64 [20] => 65 [21] => 66 [22] => 67 [23] => 68 [24] => 69 [25] => 70 [26] => 71 [27] => 72 [28] => 73 [29] => 74 [30] => 75 [31] => 76 [32] => 77 [33] => 63 [34] => 78 [35] => 79 [36] => 80 [37] => 81 [38] => 82 [39] => 62 [40] => 83 [41] => 84 [42] => 85 [43] => 86 [44] => 87 [45] => 88 [46] => 89 [47] => 91 [48] => 90 [49] => 92 [50] => 93 [51] => 94 [52] => 95 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Fire & Explosions [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Acoustical Ceiling Carpenter [4] => Trades [5] => Asbestos/Insulator [7] => Boilermaker [9] => Bricklayer [11] => Cabinetmaker [13] => Carpenter [15] => Carpet Layer [17] => Cement Mason [19] => Commercial Diver [21] => Concrete Polisher [23] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [25] => Electrical Worker [27] => Elevator Constructor [29] => Flagger [31] => Glazier [33] => Hazardous Waste Cleanup [35] => HVAC [37] => Interior Systems Carpenter [39] => Laborer [41] => Landscaper [43] => Lather [45] => Lead Abatement Worker [47] => Maintenance Worker [49] => Millwright [51] => Operating Engineer [53] => Painter [55] => Paper Hanger [57] => PCC/Restoration [59] => Pile Driver [61] => Plasterer [63] => Plumber/Pipefitter [65] => Refractory Worker [67] => Reinforcing Ironworker [69] => Roofer/Waterproofer [71] => Scaffold Erector [73] => Sheetmetal Worker [75] => Sprinkler Fitter [77] => Stonemason [79] => Structural Ironworker [81] => Terrazzo Worker [83] => Tile Setter [85] => Truck Driver [87] => Welder [89] => Commercial & Institutional [90] => Jobsites [91] => Demolition [93] => Disasters [95] => Heavy & Highway [97] => Industrial [99] => LEED/Green Construction [101] => Renovations [103] => Residential [105] => Underground ) [type] => [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4426/d001656/Construction%2BDive%2B--%2BDeWalt%2527s%2BJobsite%2BPro%2Bheadphones%2Brecalled%2Bfor%2Bfire%2Bhazards.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [16] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 16 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Fire & Explosions [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [44] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 44 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Acoustical Ceiling Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [45] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 45 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Asbestos/Insulator [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [46] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 46 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Boilermaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [48] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 48 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cabinetmaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [50] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 50 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpet Layer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [52] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 52 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Commercial Diver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [53] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 53 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Concrete Polisher [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [54] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 54 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [58] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 58 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Glazier [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [59] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 59 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Hazardous Waste Cleanup [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [65] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 65 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Landscaper [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [66] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 66 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Lather [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [67] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 67 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Lead Abatement Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [69] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 69 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Millwright [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [72] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 72 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Paper Hanger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [73] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 73 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => PCC/Restoration [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [77] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 77 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Refractory Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [81] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 81 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sprinkler Fitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [83] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 83 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Terrazzo Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [84] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 84 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Tile Setter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [85] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 85 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Truck Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4426 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001656 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Construction Dive -- DeWalt's Jobsite Pro headphones recalled for fire hazards [total_pages:protected] => 1 [billed_pages:protected] => 1 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => DeWalt, Fire Hazards, recall, headphones [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A recall notice by the United States Consumer Product Safety Commission affects over 300,000 DeWalt Jobsite Pro Headphones. The recall is a result of a malfunction that can cause earbuds to overheat while charging or during use, leading to fire and burn hazards. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => https://www.constructiondive.com/news/dewalts-jobsite-pro-headphones-recalled-for-fire-hazards/611248/?utm_source=Sailthru&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Issue:%202021-12-10%20Construction%20Dive%20Newsletter%20%5Bissue:38532%5D&utm_term=Construction%20Dive [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/13/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/13/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 12/13/21 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [new_images] => Array ( [0] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Morning Toolbox Talk [image] => /record/images/4003-p.jpg [blurb] => This photo is from an early morning toolbox talk on a construction job in Mclean, Virginia. It is being delivered in English and Spanish.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 20 [1] => 51 [2] => 57 [3] => 64 [4] => 70 [5] => 63 [6] => 78 [7] => 82 [8] => 62 [9] => 87 [10] => 88 [11] => 89 [12] => 91 [13] => 90 [14] => 93 [15] => 94 [16] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Safety Culture [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Cement Mason [4] => Trades [5] => Flagger [7] => Laborer [9] => Operating Engineer [11] => Reinforcing Ironworker [13] => Roofer/Waterproofer [15] => Stonemason [17] => Structural Ironworker [19] => Commercial & Institutional [20] => Jobsites [21] => Demolition [23] => Disasters [25] => Heavy & Highway [27] => Industrial [29] => Renovations [31] => Residential [33] => Images [34] => Media [35] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4003/i002691/Morning%2BToolbox%2BTalk.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4003 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002691 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Morning Toolbox Talk [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, Spanish, bilingual [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This photo is from an early morning toolbox talk on a construction job in Mclean, Virginia. It is being delivered in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001285,d001304,c000079 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [1] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox talk - crew view [image] => /record/images/4005-p.jpg [blurb] => Photo of crew listening to a toolbox safety talk before starting work.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 97 [1] => 20 [2] => 47 [3] => 49 [4] => 51 [5] => 55 [6] => 61 [7] => 64 [8] => 71 [9] => 75 [10] => 63 [11] => 79 [12] => 62 [13] => 87 [14] => 88 [15] => 91 [16] => 90 [17] => 93 [18] => 94 [19] => 95 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Images [1] => Media [2] => Media & Documents [3] => Safety Culture [4] => Work Environment [5] => Hazards [6] => Bricklayer [7] => Trades [8] => Carpenter [10] => Cement Mason [12] => Electrical Worker [14] => Interior Systems Carpenter [16] => Laborer [18] => Painter [20] => Plasterer [22] => Reinforcing Ironworker [24] => Scaffold Erector [26] => Structural Ironworker [28] => Commercial & Institutional [29] => Jobsites [30] => Demolition [32] => Heavy & Highway [34] => Industrial [36] => Renovations [38] => Residential [40] => Underground ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4005/i002692/Toolbox%2Btalk%2B-%2Bcrew%2Bview.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4005 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002692 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox talk - crew view [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, safety talk, Spanish [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Photo of crew listening to a toolbox safety talk before starting work. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002691,d001269, c000079, d001285 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [2] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox talk - long shot [image] => /record/images/4006-p.jpg [blurb] => This crew gathered every morning before starting work to discuss a new safety topic.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 20 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 55 [5] => 64 [6] => 68 [7] => 75 [8] => 76 [9] => 63 [10] => 78 [11] => 79 [12] => 82 [13] => 62 [14] => 87 [15] => 88 [16] => 91 [17] => 90 [18] => 93 [19] => 94 [20] => 95 [21] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Safety Culture [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Electrical Worker [11] => Laborer [13] => Maintenance Worker [15] => Plasterer [17] => Plumber/Pipefitter [19] => Reinforcing Ironworker [21] => Roofer/Waterproofer [23] => Scaffold Erector [25] => Stonemason [27] => Structural Ironworker [29] => Commercial & Institutional [30] => Jobsites [31] => Demolition [33] => Heavy & Highway [35] => Industrial [37] => Renovations [39] => Residential [41] => Underground [43] => Images [44] => Media [45] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4006/i002693/Toolbox%2Btalk%2B-%2Blong%2Bshot.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4006 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002693 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox talk - long shot [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, safety minute [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This crew gathered every morning before starting work to discuss a new safety topic. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002691,i002692,d001269,d000527 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [3] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Safety officer discussing ongoing project with marketing coordinator [image] => /record/images/4014-p.jpg [blurb] => The safety officer (left) points out the good safety practices on this project that reflect well on the firm and may influence future clients.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 97 [1] => 20 [2] => 46 [3] => 47 [4] => 49 [5] => 50 [6] => 51 [7] => 54 [8] => 55 [9] => 58 [10] => 60 [11] => 61 [12] => 64 [13] => 71 [14] => 75 [15] => 76 [16] => 63 [17] => 79 [18] => 80 [19] => 82 [20] => 62 [21] => 83 [22] => 87 [23] => 91 [24] => 90 [25] => 93 [26] => 94 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Images [1] => Media [2] => Media & Documents [3] => Safety Culture [4] => Work Environment [5] => Hazards [6] => Boilermaker [7] => Trades [8] => Bricklayer [10] => Carpenter [12] => Carpet Layer [14] => Cement Mason [16] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [18] => Electrical Worker [20] => Glazier [22] => HVAC [24] => Interior Systems Carpenter [26] => Laborer [28] => Painter [30] => Plasterer [32] => Plumber/Pipefitter [34] => Reinforcing Ironworker [36] => Scaffold Erector [38] => Sheetmetal Worker [40] => Stonemason [42] => Structural Ironworker [44] => Terrazzo Worker [46] => Commercial & Institutional [47] => Jobsites [48] => Heavy & Highway [50] => Industrial [52] => Renovations [54] => Residential ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4014/i002700/Safety%2Bofficer%2Bdiscussing%2Bongoing%2Bproject%2Bwith%2Bmarketing%2Bcoordinator.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [46] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 46 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Boilermaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [50] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 50 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpet Layer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [54] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 54 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [58] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 58 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Glazier [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [83] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 83 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Terrazzo Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4014 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002700 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Safety officer discussing ongoing project with marketing coordinator [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Latino, safety officer, safety culture [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The safety officer (left) points out the good safety practices on this project that reflect well on the firm and may influence future clients. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/index.php [more_like_this:protected] => d000989,d001351,d001362,d000652, d001101, d000931, d001395 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Hoar Construction, Photo by Neil Lippy [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 01/30/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [4] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Scaffolding at top of large column [image] => /record/images/3994-p.jpg [blurb] => This shot shows innovative guarding around the top of a large concrete column in the base of a high rise structure going up.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 15 [1] => 21 [2] => 47 [3] => 51 [4] => 63 [5] => 78 [6] => 79 [7] => 80 [8] => 62 [9] => 87 [10] => 97 [11] => 56 [12] => 64 [13] => 74 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Falls [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Scaffolds [6] => Bricklayer [7] => Trades [8] => Cement Mason [10] => Reinforcing Ironworker [12] => Roofer/Waterproofer [14] => Scaffold Erector [16] => Sheetmetal Worker [18] => Structural Ironworker [20] => Commercial & Institutional [21] => Jobsites [22] => Images [23] => Media [24] => Media & Documents [25] => Elevator Constructor [27] => Laborer [29] => Pile Driver ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/3994/i002689/Scaffolding%2Bat%2Btop%2Bof%2Blarge%2Bcolumn.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [21] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 21 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Scaffolds [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3994 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002689 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Scaffolding at top of large column [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Guardrail, railing, fall prevention, falls [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This shot shows innovative guarding around the top of a large concrete column in the base of a high rise structure going up. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/8/adjustable-tower-scaffold.html [more_like_this:protected] => c1002680,i002662,d000608,d001255 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Photo by Pam Susi [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2016 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_completed:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/01/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [5] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Construction bracing [image] => /record/images/3995-p.jpg [blurb] => This shows structural support that prevents collapses during construction.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 15 [2] => 21 [3] => 49 [4] => 51 [5] => 55 [6] => 56 [7] => 60 [8] => 64 [9] => 68 [10] => 74 [11] => 63 [12] => 78 [13] => 79 [14] => 80 [15] => 62 [16] => 87 [17] => 90 [18] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Falls [6] => Scaffolds [9] => Carpenter [10] => Trades [11] => Cement Mason [13] => Electrical Worker [15] => Elevator Constructor [17] => HVAC [19] => Laborer [21] => Maintenance Worker [23] => Pile Driver [25] => Reinforcing Ironworker [27] => Roofer/Waterproofer [29] => Scaffold Erector [31] => Sheetmetal Worker [33] => Structural Ironworker [35] => Commercial & Institutional [36] => Jobsites [37] => Industrial [39] => Images [40] => Media [41] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/3995/i002690/Construction%2Bbracing.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [21] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 21 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Scaffolds [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3995 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002690 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Construction bracing [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Bracing, support, scaffold [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This shows structural support that prevents collapses during construction. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/8/adjustable-tower-scaffold.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002660 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Photo by Pam Susi [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2016 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_completed:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/01/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [preview_mode] => [description] => The results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. [keywords] => tuckpointing, HEPA vacuum, dust control, LEV, local exhaust ventilation, silica [related_items] => Array ( [Research Reports] => Array ( [0] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1874 [old_id:protected] => 722 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000683 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Sharon Garber/COD [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Protecting Tuckpointing Workers from Silica Dust: Draft Recommendations for a Ventilated Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 12 [billed_pages:protected] => 12 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, vacuum, grinder, mortar, respirator, OSHA, NIOSH, exhaust, Heitbrink, tuckpointer, silica, masonry, dust, silicosis, LEV [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Describes draft recommendations for use of ventilated grinder to reduce dust during tuckpointing and describes field trials using these devices. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/hazard/67/chip-scrape-and-grind-surfaces-or-joints-silica.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001201,d000292,d000293,d000658 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2005 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/27/05 [date_completed:protected] => 04/26/05 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/20/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [1] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1940 [old_id:protected] => 909 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Workplace Solutions: Control of Hazardous Dust During Tuckpointing [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, silica, dust, tuckpoint, grinder, masonry restoration, mortar, vacuum [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d000819,d000820,d000730,d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 10/24/08 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/09 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [2] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3899 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001342 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: Hilti VC40-U Vacuum with Hilti DC-EX Dust Guard and Hilti Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 15 [billed_pages:protected] => 15 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP4 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => silica, tuckpointing, Hilti, local exhaust systems, LEV, shroud, quartz [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This report describes the results of an evaluation of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Hilti VC40-U vacuum, a Hilti DC-EX shroud, and a Hilti DAG-500 grinder. Randomized trials with and without use of the dust control system were conducted in a controlled setting. Removing mortar with the Hilti grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 220 times the National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05mg/m3. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 97 percent. However, exposures measured during the use of the dust control system still exceeded the NIOSH REL. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => December 1, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/05/14 [date_completed:protected] => 02/04/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/06/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [Handouts] => Array ( [0] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3656 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001198 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 24 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction While Doing Tuckpointing/Mortar Removal [total_pages:protected] => 2 [billed_pages:protected] => 2 [publication_number:protected] => DSG FS-3632 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Brick, block, tuckpointing, silica, local exhaust ventilation, LEV, masonry [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Tuckpointing creates some of the greatest exposures to silica in construction. This OSHA factsheet provides guidance on how to greatly reduce these exposures through the use of local exhaust ventilation. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863, d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => February 2013 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/04/13 [date_completed:protected] => 03/27/13 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [collections] => Array ( [3913] => ) [record] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => Array ( [867] => Author Object ( [id:protected] => 867 [organization_id:protected] => 0 [firstname:protected] => Michael [lastname:protected] => Cooper [address:protected] => [city:protected] => [province:protected] => [country:protected] => [postal_code:protected] => [department:protected] => [title:protected] => [phone:protected] => [fax:protected] => [email:protected] => [degree:protected] => [website:protected] => [about:protected] => [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => [date_completed:protected] => [date_billed:protected] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [481] => Author Object ( [id:protected] => 481 [organization_id:protected] => 0 [firstname:protected] => Pam [lastname:protected] => Susi [address:protected] => 8484 Georgia Avenue, Suite 1000 [city:protected] => Silver Spring [province:protected] => Maryland [country:protected] => USA [postal_code:protected] => 20910 [department:protected] => [title:protected] => [phone:protected] => 301-578-8500 ext.144 [fax:protected] => 301-578-8572 [email:protected] => plsusi@aol.com [degree:protected] => [website:protected] => http://www.cpwr.com [about:protected] => [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => 2003-10-02 [date_completed:protected] => 2003-10-06 [date_billed:protected] => 2003-11-03 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [organizations:protected] => Array ( [1] => Organization Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [elcosh_id:protected] => o000001 [user_id:protected] => 14 [province_id:protected] => 21 [country_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => CPWR - The Center for Construction Research and Training [address:protected] => Suite 1000, 8484 Georgia Ave [postal_code:protected] => 20910 [city:protected] => Silver Spring [department:protected] => [phone:protected] => 301-578-8500 [fax:protected] => 301-578-8572 [email:protected] => cpwrwebsite@cpwr.com [website:protected] => http://www.cpwr.com [filename:protected] => o000001.gif [about:protected] => CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training, developed, and continues to maintain/expand this website - The Electronic Library of Construction Occupational Safety and Health, www.elcosh.org. CPWR, formerly known as The Center to Protect Workers’ Rights, is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit research and training institution. Created by the Building and Construction Trades Department, AFL-CIO, CPWR serves as the research arm of the BCTD. Since the inception of its research agenda in 1990, CPWR has grown into a worldwide provider of safety and health information covering all aspects of the construction industry. CPWR launched eLCOSH in 2000, and the Spanish-language version of the site in 2001. CPWR also created, and continues to build, Construction Solutions - www.cpwrConstructionSolutions.org - a free, online database of construction hazards and ways to prevent, eliminate, or reduce them. [comments:protected] => [logo_available:protected] => T [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => 2000-08-18 [date_completed:protected] => 2000-08-30 [date_billed:protected] => 2000-09-05 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [collections:protected] => Array ( [3913] => ) [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => Array ( [1874] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1874 [old_id:protected] => 722 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000683 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Sharon Garber/COD [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Protecting Tuckpointing Workers from Silica Dust: Draft Recommendations for a Ventilated Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 12 [billed_pages:protected] => 12 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, vacuum, grinder, mortar, respirator, OSHA, NIOSH, exhaust, Heitbrink, tuckpointer, silica, masonry, dust, silicosis, LEV [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Describes draft recommendations for use of ventilated grinder to reduce dust during tuckpointing and describes field trials using these devices. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/hazard/67/chip-scrape-and-grind-surfaces-or-joints-silica.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001201,d000292,d000293,d000658 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2005 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/27/05 [date_completed:protected] => 04/26/05 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/20/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [1940] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1940 [old_id:protected] => 909 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Workplace Solutions: Control of Hazardous Dust During Tuckpointing [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, silica, dust, tuckpoint, grinder, masonry restoration, mortar, vacuum [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d000819,d000820,d000730,d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 10/24/08 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/09 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [2213] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 2213 [old_id:protected] => 1090 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => [language_id:protected] => 2 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Control del polvo peligroso que se genera durante los procesos de reparación de mortero [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => 2008-126 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => [comments:protected] => http://www.cdc.gov/spanish/niosh/docs/wp-solutions/2008-126_sp/ [summary:protected] => A Workplace Solutions de NIOSH que resume un estudio de NIOSH sobre los riesgos de exposición cuando se reparan las estructuras y los métodos para controlar el polvo. [A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust.] [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => D000819,D000820,D000730,d000819 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 01/07/10 [date_completed:protected] => 04/19/10 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 07/08/12 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [3656] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3656 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001198 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 24 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction While Doing Tuckpointing/Mortar Removal [total_pages:protected] => 2 [billed_pages:protected] => 2 [publication_number:protected] => DSG FS-3632 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Brick, block, tuckpointing, silica, local exhaust ventilation, LEV, masonry [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Tuckpointing creates some of the greatest exposures to silica in construction. This OSHA factsheet provides guidance on how to greatly reduce these exposures through the use of local exhaust ventilation. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863, d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => February 2013 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/04/13 [date_completed:protected] => 03/27/13 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [3899] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3899 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001342 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: Hilti VC40-U Vacuum with Hilti DC-EX Dust Guard and Hilti Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 15 [billed_pages:protected] => 15 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP4 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => silica, tuckpointing, Hilti, local exhaust systems, LEV, shroud, quartz [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This report describes the results of an evaluation of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Hilti VC40-U vacuum, a Hilti DC-EX shroud, and a Hilti DAG-500 grinder. Randomized trials with and without use of the dust control system were conducted in a controlled setting. Removing mortar with the Hilti grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 220 times the National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05mg/m3. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 97 percent. However, exposures measured during the use of the dust control system still exceeded the NIOSH REL. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => December 1, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/05/14 [date_completed:protected] => 02/04/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/06/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [content:protected] => [files:protected] => Array ( [559] => [560] => [546] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 546 [filename:protected] => 3.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:22 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [566] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 566 [filename:protected] => 4.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:23 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [720] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 720 [filename:protected] => 5.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [721] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 721 [filename:protected] => 6.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [722] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 722 [filename:protected] => 7.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [9765] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 9765 [filename:protected] => d001345.pdf [downloadable:protected] => T [timestamp:protected] => 2015-02-09 12:26:04 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3908 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001345 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: DustControl 2900c Vacuum with the ICS Dust Director Shroud and Bosch Grinder Model 1775E Conducted November 14-15, 2012 [total_pages:protected] => 13 [billed_pages:protected] => 13 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP2 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => tuckpointing, HEPA vacuum, dust control, LEV, local exhaust ventilation, silica [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => April 15, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 01/26/15 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/09/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [show_text] => [document_content] => ElcoshItemDocumentContent Object ( [id:protected] => 2934 [item_id:protected] => 3908 [type:protected] => main [title:protected] => [content:protected] =>
Executive Summary
This report describes the results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. It should also be noted that the NIOSH REL is based on exposures averaged over a ten hour work day and our results represent time weighted averages of the sample task duration periods.
Acronyms
ACGIH - American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists
CPWR - CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training
Ce - coefficient of entry
HEPA - high-efficiency particulate air
IUBAC - International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craftworkers
LEV - local exhaust ventilation
PACT - Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies
NIOSH - National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health
OEL - occupational exposure limit
OSHA - Occupational Safety and Health Administration
PAPR - powered air-purifying respirator
PEL - Permissible Exposure Limit
PVC - polyvinyl chloride
REL - Recommended Exposure Limit
RPM - revolutions per minute
TWA - time-weighted average
SP - static pressure
I. Introduction and Background
In 2010 CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training began a four-year project which seeks to identify and evaluate tuckpointing local exhaust ventilation (LEV) systems and disseminate information on their availability and effectiveness. A Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies (PACT) comprised of masonry contractors, representatives from unions, government, equipment manufacturers, and health and safety researcher was formed as part of this project. PACT members participated in identifying important characteristics for control technologies and this information was used to identify LEV systems for tuckpointing using that criteria. Contractor and labor members of the PACT selected specific tuckpointing LEV systems to be considered for evaluation. Each system consisted of a tuckpointing grinder, shroud, and vacuum. This report describes the second of four systems to be evaluated between 2012 the end of 2014, with and without LEV, in a controlled setting to determine effectiveness in silica exposure reduction. This report describes the methods and results of our evaluation of a system consisting of the DustControl 2900c vacuum with the ICS Dust Director shroud and a Bosch Model 1775E grinder.
Excessive exposure to respirable silica can result in silicosis or other silica-related diseases including pulmonary tuberculosis, lung cancer, silicoproteinosis (Lyons et al, 2007) and autoimmune disorders such as rheumatoid arthritis, sarcoidosis and scleroderma (Miller et al, 2012). Respirable silica is generally defined as particles less than 10 micrometers (μm) in aerodynamic diameter (ACGIH, 2013). Silicosis can lead to symptoms including shortness of breath, fatigue, chest pains, susceptibility to infection and possibly death. There is no cure for silicosis, however it is totally preventable. Construction workers exposed to dust, including silica, are also known to have higher rates of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD).
There are many sources of silica in construction that result in exposures of varying intensity among workers. Masonry restoration workers are among the most highly silica-exposed trades in construction. The process of grinding out deteriorated mortar joints between masonry units and replacing or repointing with fresh mortar (often referred to as tuckpointing) is a fundamental part of masonry restoration work. The removal of mortar with powered angle grinders generates enormous levels of dust. Between 2004 and 2006, NIOSH and CPWR evaluated silica exposures while grinding mortar in a controlled setting, at a local training center, where tasks, sample times and task variables were defined by the study design. These studies demonstrated that grinding mortar without controls can result in elevated respirable silica exposures. Meeker et al., (2009) reported exposures between 5 and 25.8 milligrams per cubic meter (mg/m3) in a controlled setting. This study also showed that LEV systems for tuckpointing grinders can reduce exposures to respirable silica by greater than 90 percent.II. Objectives
The objective of this evaluation was to assess the effectiveness of an LEV system for controlling exposure to silica during the grinding of mortar. The control technology was tested under controlled conditions, similar to those experienced by tuckpointers on actual job sites, using journeymen bricklayers experienced in tuckpointing and repeat, randomized trials with and without LEV. All other variables were held constant throughout so that the only variable was whether or not the tested control was used.
III. Description of Equipment Tested
A Bosch model 1775E grinder (Robert Bosch Tool Corporation, Prospect, IL) (Figures 1, 2 and 3) was fitted with a new 1/4-inch wide, 4½-inch diameter segmented diamond abrasive blade made by DeWalt (model #DW4740). The grinder weighs six and a half pounds, draws 8.5 amps and has a variable speed up to 11,000 revolutions per minute (RPMs). The DustControl 2900c vacuum (DustControl, Inc., Wilmington, NC) (Figure 3) was tested in combination with the Dust Director shroud (Industrial Contractors’ Supplies, Inc., Huntingdon, PA) (Figures 1 and 3) attached to the Bosch grinder.
Figure 1. Bosch grinder with Dust Director shroud
Figure 2. Bosch grinder without tuckpointing LEV system.
Figure 3: Bosch Grinder with LEV System
The vacuum is specified to weigh 31 pounds when empty and to provide a flow rate of 114 cubic feet of air per minute and a “static lift” or “vacuum suction pressure” of 84 inches of water. The vacuum is sold with a cyclonic pre-separator, to remove larger particles, a fine filter (rated 99.9 percent efficient) and a HEPA (high-efficiency particulate air) filter (rated to capture 99.97 percent of the particles with an aerodynamic diameter of 0.3 micrometers). The HEPA filter was removed based on the manufacturer’s recommendation due to the heavy dust loading associated with tuckpointing. CPWR sponsored research and contractor experience indicate that HEPA filters likely have an adverse effect on dust capture during tuckpointing because of extreme dust loading on filters. While the cyclone and the fine filter remove most of the dust, especially the large particles, before they reach the HEPA filter, the HEPA filter would still be subject to heavy loading, causing a substantial pressure drop and subsequent decrease in air flow rate. The relatively small increase in the efficiency of the filtration system while using the HEPA filter is expected to be quickly offset by a more significant decrease in capture efficiency as the air flow rate and ability to capture particles decreases.
Dust collects in relatively inexpensive, heavy-gauge plastic bags below and outside of the cyclone. The bags can be removed and replaced without opening the vacuum. Some vacuums are equipped with a light to indicate that the filters need to be cleaned or changed. The DC2900c features a “reverse air pulse cleaning system,” which removes accumulated dust from the filters without having to remove them from the vacuum. The system, as illustrated in Figure 4, requires the operator to disconnect the hose from the shroud, place it over an air stop so that air through the hose is cut off and pressure in the vacuum is maximized.
Figure 4. Procedure for "cleaning" of or dust removal from filters (source: http://dustcontrolusa.com/manuals/2800c.pdf)
The flap covering the port on the side of the vacuum is repeatedly flipped open to release built up pressure in strong pulses that dislodge dust from the filter.
The manufacturer indicates “the filter is generally cleaned once or twice daily during normal continuous operation.” The Dust Director shroud has a 2-inch diameter take-off that was connected to the antistatic, corrugated 1.5-inch diameter, 15-foot long vacuum hose supplied with the DustControl vacuum.
IV. Study Methods
This evaluation was conducted at the International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craft workers (IUBAC) Local 1 Philadelphia/Delaware Training Center in Philadelphia, PA on November 14 and 15, 2012. A single journeyman bricklayer, experienced in tuckpointing, used the grinder and LEV system being tested to remove mortar from joints wide enough to require two passes. The type S mortar had been allowed to cure for at least four weeks. The bricklayer either possessed or was provided with personal protective equipment including sturdy work boots, gloves, hearing protection and a powered air-purifying respirator (PAPR). The PAPR was a 3M GVP system with a bump cap, loose fitting face piece and a HEPA filter (3M, St Paul, MN).
The study was designed to include at least five rounds of sampling during mortar removal. Each round included a trial using the Bosch grinder with a Dust Director shroud and Dust Collector 2900c vacuum and a trial using the Bosch grinder with the factory-supplied guard and without a vacuum. The order of the two trials within each round was randomly selected to minimize bias that might be introduced due to variation associated with environmental factors, equipment operator, blade wear, vacuum performance over time and any other factors unrelated to LEV use. Tools were operated for approximately 16 minutes per trial with controls and for approximately 8 minutes when controls were not used. These times were selected based on the results of previous sampling efforts and estimates of the minimum sample time needed to achieve a limit of quantification low enough to accurately measure exposures down to or less than 0.05 mg/m3 – the NIOSH Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) for respirable silica. The bricklayer was required to take a 5 to 10 minute break in the middle of the 16-minute trials to reduce differences in fatigue, compared to the 8-minute trials. Personal air samples were collected in the breathing zone of the operator during each trial to measure respirable silica concentrations during grinding with and without LEV. The samples were collected using a GilAir-5 pump (Sensidyne, Inc., Clearwater, FL) to draw 4.2 liters of air per minute through a GK2.69 Respirable Cyclone (BGI Inc., Waltham, MA) with a pre-weighed, 37 mm diameter, 5-micron pore size polyvinyl chloride (PVC) filter positioned on the operator’s lapel.
The flow rates of the sampling pumps were calibrated at the beginning of each day using a DryCal DC-Lite Primary Flow Meter (Bios International Corporation, Butler, NJ). Flow rates were measured again near the middle and at the end of each day to ensure that sampling flow rates were maintained within 5% of pre-sampling flow rates throughout the day. Average flow rates were used to calculate sample air volumes. Samples were analyzed by R.J. Lee Group, Inc., (Monroeville, PA) using NIOSH Method 0600, to determine exposure to total mass of respirable dust. The same samples were also analyzed using X-Ray diffraction following NIOSH method 7500 to determine quartz, cristobalite and tridymite concentration in the respirable mass. Reported masses for these analytes were used with the sample air volumes to calculate airborne concentrations of total respirable dust, quartz, cristobalite and tridymite.
We used a reduction of greater than 50 percent in respirable silica exposure concentrations or a reduction to less than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 as our criteria for determining whether or not a control was considered efficacious. This is consistent with criteria used by NIOSH in conducting a similar study in 2004 described by Echt et al. (2007) and by CPWR in 2006 and described by Meeker et al. (2009). The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) and the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) publish additional occupational exposure limits (OELs) for silica which are listed in Table 1 with NIOSH RELs. OELs for silica are based on the respirable fraction of the aerosol, which consists of particles less than 10 micrometers in aerodynamic diameter.
| Organization or Agency | Form of Crystalline Silica | Occupational Exposure Limits (mg/m3) |
|---|---|---|
| NIOSHA | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 |
| OSHA - ConstructionB | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
PEL = 250 / (5 + % quartz) PEL = 250 / (5 + % cristobalite) PEL = 250 / (5 + % tridymite) |
| ACGIH | Crystalline Silica | TLV = 0.025 mg/m3 |
A NIOSH Publication No. 2005-151 indicates 10-hour time-weighted average during a 40-hr workweek B The PEL for silica in OSHA’s Safety and Health Regulations for Construction, 29 C.F.R. 1926.55(a), is an 8-hour time-weighted average (TWA) expressed in millions of particles per cubic foot (mppcf). However, the units mppcf can be converted to milligrams per cubic meter can by dividing mppcf by 10 (OSHA, 2009). The formula used by OSHA to determine the PEL for silica is dependent on the percentage of silica in each collected sample. The concentration of respirable dust measured is compared to the sample specific PEL to determine if the PEL has been exceeded. OSHA has proposed lowering the PEL to 0.05 mg/m3 of respirable silica as an 8 hour TWA. |
||
The flow of air in ventilation systems is governed by fundamental principles that describe the behavior of gases (in this case air). Pressure measurements taken within a ventilation system along with knowledge of hood (or shroud) entry losses can be used to calculate flow rates. Hood entry losses are dependent on the shape and configuration of a particular hood or shroud and described by the term “coefficient of entry (Ce)” which is the ratio of actual air flow through a hood and what the air flow would theoretically be if there were no hood entry losses. Given the coefficient of entry, static pressure measurements can be used to calculate air flow through a given hood. The coefficient of entry for the Dust Director shroud was previously determined by CPWR and used for calculating air flow based on static pressure measurements (Meeker et al., 2009). Static pressure, with the vacuum operating, was measured periodically throughout the evaluation to monitor the changes in air-flow rate following use and again after filter cleaning. The static pressure was measured at a port positioned more than 3 duct diameters downstream from the tool’s air intake using a UEi EM200 Electronic Manometer (Universal Enterprises, Inc., Beaverton, OR).
The dust in the vacuum bag was monitored and, per the manufacturer’s instructions, the bag was changed before the dust level was within 5 centimeters of the valve at the bottom of the vacuum. Each time a vacuum bag was removed, it was weighed to the nearest pound. The bag weights and corresponding grinding durations were used to calculate the average weight of dust collected per unit time. After each trial, cut lengths were measured on the wall to determine total linear feet of vertical (head) and horizontal (bed) joints per unit time.
A Haz-Dust III, Model HD-1003, Real-Time Aerosol Monitor (Environmental Devices Corporation, Plaistow, NH) was used to confirm clearance of dust between trials. The Haz-Dust monitor was positioned on the test wall near the operator at approximately breathing zone level and configured to measure respirable particulate concentration.
V. Results
Personal air monitoring
Five pairs of respirable dust samples were collected while grinding with and without the vacuum system. In addition, three respirable dust samples were collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place. One measurement collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard was shown to be a statistical outlier and was omitted from analysis. Personal air monitoring results for respirable silica and a comparison of average exposures relative to the NIOSH REL for silica (0.05 mg/m3) appears in Table 2. The mean respirable dust levels measured without LEV was 31.4 mg/m3. However, samples collected with LEV were below the limit of quantification (LOQ) which ranged from <1.29 to <1.46 mg/m3. Use of LEV resulted in a greater than 95% reduction in mean respirable dust levels using a mean value with use of LEV of <1.41 (n=5 samples with use of LEV and n=7 without use of LEV). The respirable dust samples collected during grinding without the LEV system contained an average of 24 percent silica. The mass of respirable dust in the samples collected with use of the LEV system was too low to determine the silica content.| Mean, mg/m3 (range) | Std. Dev. | Percent Reduction | Hazard RatioB | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bosch with Dust Director Shroud and DustControl 2900c Vacuum |
0.091 (<0.069 – 0.137) |
0.027 | 98.7 | 1.81 |
| Bosch with no Control | 7.23 (4.57 – 9.90) |
1.94 | NA | 145 |
A n = 5 samples for each tool/control combination and n = 7 samples without the use of the LEV system B Hazard Ratio = measured exposure / NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 |
||||
Average respirable silica and dust exposures, with and without the dust control system, appear as Figures 5 and 6, respectively.
Figure 5. Average respirable silica exposures with and without the Dustcontrol 2900c vacuum and Dust Director shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air - mg/m3)
Figure 6. Average respirable dust exposures with and without Dustcontrol 2900c Vacuum and Dust Director Shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air – mg/m3)
The mean respirable silica concentration measured during use of the control was significantly less than the concentration measured while using the same tool without controls (p<0.01). Grinding mortar with the Bosch angle grinder without dust controls resulted in an average exposure to respirable silica that was 145 times the NIOSH REL. Grinding with the Bosch angle grinder in combination with the Dust Director shroud and the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced the average concentration of respirable silica by 98.7 percent. With use of these controls, the concentration of respirable silica was 1.8 times greater than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3. However the NIOSH REL is based on a time-weighted average (TWA) over a 10-hour workday. Given these were task TWAs and samples were collected over continuous periods of grinding, they may overestimate exposures over an actual work day since some time would be spent performing tasks that would likely have lower, or no, silica exposures (setup, breaks, cleanup, etc.).
Static pressure, dust mass collection and grinding rates.
Static pressure was used as a surrogate for air flow as described earlier. Hood static pressure was measured periodically at a tap near the grinder more than 3 duct diameters from the air intake in the shroud. The static pressure, and thus air flow, was generally higher when the vacuum’s filter had recently been cleaned. The mean, median, and range of calculated flow rates are presented in Table A1 of the Appendix.
Based on the data we collected, the air-flow rate upstream from the Bosch grinder and Dust Director shroud ranged from 78 to 93 cubic feet per minute (cfm) with the DustControl vacuum. When the manufacturer’s filter cleaning procedure was followed the vacuum performed relatively well and flow could be maintained at slightly less than 90 cfm with cleaning. However, mean flow rates dropped substantially to 80 cfm after as little as 8 minutes of grinding without any filter cleaning. The flow rate returned to an average of 89 cfm when filters were cleaned correctly (without stopping air flow to the vacuum). Collingwood and Heitbrink (2007) found that the minimum exhaust flow rate for capture of silica and other particulate under ideal conditions is 21.25 cfm per inch of grinder blade diameter. This is equal to about 96 cfm when using a 4.5 inch diameter grinding blade. We set 106 cfm as the minimum desired flow rate for this study to allow a safety margin for potential decline in equipment performance and the possibility of inadequate maintenance, both of which may be likely after repeated use under actual work conditions. The DustControl vacuum provided slightly less than the minimum flow rate described by Collingwood and Heitbrink for a 4.5-inch blade and the peak flow rate fell with use.
The duration of vacuum bag use and mass of dust collected were recorded and are presented in Table A2 of the Appendix. The vacuum bags were changed and weighed after each trial utilizing the LEV system. A total of five bags were used to complete the five rounds of grinding. The DustControl vacuum captured 45 pounds of dust over 83 minutes of grinding for an average rate of dust collection of 0.54 pounds per minute. The rate of dust collection ranged from 0.47 to 0.63 pounds per minute. Based on these measurements, approximately 130 pounds of dust would likely be captured after just 4 hours of continuous grinding.
The rate of grinding a combination of vertical and horizontal joints while using the LEV system ranged from 2.3 to 3.3 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the use of the LEV system ranged from 2.6 to 3.4 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place ranged from 4.7 to 5.1 feet per minute. It’s important to note that: 1) the operator had limited experience using dust control systems and cut rates appeared to improve slightly over the 2-day period he used the tested equipment; and 2) the upper range of cut rates with the dust control system overlapped with the lowest cut rate with the original guard and without the LEV system in place indicating no statistical difference between cut rates. Given that grinding rates with and without use of this LEV system are only available for one operator and he had limited experience with the LEV system, these reported cut rates are in no way intended to represent the impact use of this LEV system is likely to have on productivity rates overall.
VI. Discussion
The objective of these trials was to evaluate the effectiveness of a tuckpointing LEV system for controlling respirable silica while grinding out mortar joints. The Dust Director shroud with the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced respirable silica concentrations when grinding with the Bosch grinder by approximately 99 percent. Despite being considered effective by our test criteria (greater than 50% reduction), it still resulted in task TWA exposures that exceeded the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 by 1.8 times. Depending on how much time is spent grinding over the course of a work day and on exposures while performing other tasks, the 8-hour TWA exposures may or may not exceed the REL with this system. Use of this system by workers with experience and training in proficient use will likely improve dust capture performance. Exposure reduction is greatly influenced by correct use of this system which includes grinding from right to left, making sure the shroud is held flush against the wall and that the tool travels at a pace that doesn’t exceed the ability of the system to capture dust as it’s generated. Deviation from any of these measures produces visible dust clouds which were observed during trials.
VII. Conclusions
With a 99 percent reduction in respirable silica exposure, the Dust Director shroud and DustControl 2900c vacuum with a Bosch Model 1775E grinder was effective in reducing silica exposures based on our criteria. Use of the tested dust control system may be effective in reducing silica exposure on the job to less than the NIOSH REL if used in combination with administrative controls such as work scheduling to reduce cutting times as needed. Training on correct use of the tested system is also essential. Personal air monitoring is necessary to verify control effectiveness on actual job sites and under “real-world” conditions. However, these results clearly demonstrate the availability of viable and effective engineering controls for tuckpointing operations associated with elevated silica exposure.
VIII. References
American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists. Threshold limit values for chemical substances (TLV®-CS). [2013]. ACGIH, Cincinnati, Ohio.
Bergdahl I.A,. Toren K., Eriksson K., et al. [2004]. Increased mortality in COPD among construction workers exposed to inorganic dust. European Respiratory Journal, 23: 402–06.
Blanc P.D. & Torén K. [2007]. Occupation in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and chronic bronchitis: an update [State of the Art Series. Occupational lung disease in high-and low-income countries, Edited by M. Chan-Yeung. Number 2 in the series]. The International Journal of Tuberculosis and Lung Disease, 11(3), 251-257.
Collingwood S. & Heitbrink W.A. [2007] 'Field Evaluation of an Engineering Control for Respirable Crystalline Silica Exposures During Mortar Removal'. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, 4:11, 875 – 887.
DHHS (NIOSH) Publication No. 2002-129 April 2002 http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/2002-129/
Echt A., Sieber W.K., Lefkowitz D., Meeker J., Susi P., Cardwell B., Heitbrink, W.A. In-depth survey of dust control technology for cutting concrete block and tuckpointing brick at The International Masonry Institute Bordentown Training Center, Bordentown, NJ. Cincinnati, OH: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Report. No. EPHB 282-13; 2007. http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ECTB-282-13.pdf
Heitbrink W., Bennett J. [2006]. A numerical and experimental investigation of crystalline silica exposure control during tuck pointing. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, Vol. 3, pp 366-378.
Lyons et al, [2007]. A breathless builder. Breathe, Vol. 3, no. 4, pp 386-390.
Mastrangelo G., Tartari M., Fedeli U., Fadda E., Saia B. [2003]. Ascertaining the risk of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease in relation to occupation using a case-control design. Occupational Medicine, 53: 165–172.
Meeker J., Cooper M., Lefrowitz D., Susi P. [2009]. Engineering control technologies to reduce occupational silica exposures in masonry cutting and tuckpointing. Public Health Reports, Supplement 1, Vol. 124, June.
Meeker J, Flynn M, Susi P, Cardwell, B [2004]. Performance evaluation of a masonry concrete vacuum. Unpublished Report.
Miller F. W., Alfredsson L., Costenbader K. H., Kamen D. L., Nelson L. M., Norris J. M., & De Roos A. J. [2012]. Epidemiology of environmental exposures and human autoimmune diseases: findings from a National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences Expert Panel workshop. Journal of autoimmunity. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3496812/
Occupational Safety and Health Administration U.S Department of Labor. Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction. [2009]. OSHA 3362-05.
Rappaport SM, Goldberg M, Susi P, Herrick RF [2003]. Excessive exposure to silica in the U.S. construction industry. Annals of Occupational Hygiene, Vol. 47, pp. 111-122.
IX. Appendices
| Measurement Conditions |
n | Mean Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Median
Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before filter cleaning | 5 | 80 | 81 | 78-81 |
| After filter cleaning following manufacturer directions | 9 | 89 | 90 | 84-93 |
| * Static pressure was measured in millibars and converted to inches of water gauge. Flow rates were calculated using the formula Q = Ce (A) 4005 (SP)1/2 where: Q = flow in cubic feet per minute (cfm), Ce = coefficient of entry, A = area of the duct where static pressure measurements were taken in square feet, and SP = static pressure in inches of water gauge. | ||||
| Tool/Control | Collection Period (min.) |
Dust Collection Rate (lb/min.) |
|---|---|---|
| Bosch grinder/Dust Director shroud & DustControl 2900c vacuum |
8 11 8 8 10 |
0.50 0.61 0.50 0.47 0.63 |
| Average | 0.54 |
[content_transformed:protected] =>
Executive Summary
This report describes the results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. It should also be noted that the NIOSH REL is based on exposures averaged over a ten hour work day and our results represent time weighted averages of the sample task duration periods.
Acronyms
ACGIH - American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists
CPWR - CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training
Ce - coefficient of entry
HEPA - high-efficiency particulate air
IUBAC - International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craftworkers
LEV - local exhaust ventilation
PACT - Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies
NIOSH - National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health
OEL - occupational exposure limit
OSHA - Occupational Safety and Health Administration
PAPR - powered air-purifying respirator
PEL - Permissible Exposure Limit
PVC - polyvinyl chloride
REL - Recommended Exposure Limit
RPM - revolutions per minute
TWA - time-weighted average
SP - static pressure
I. Introduction and Background
In 2010 CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training began a four-year project which seeks to identify and evaluate tuckpointing local exhaust ventilation (LEV) systems and disseminate information on their availability and effectiveness. A Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies (PACT) comprised of masonry contractors, representatives from unions, government, equipment manufacturers, and health and safety researcher was formed as part of this project. PACT members participated in identifying important characteristics for control technologies and this information was used to identify LEV systems for tuckpointing using that criteria. Contractor and labor members of the PACT selected specific tuckpointing LEV systems to be considered for evaluation. Each system consisted of a tuckpointing grinder, shroud, and vacuum. This report describes the second of four systems to be evaluated between 2012 the end of 2014, with and without LEV, in a controlled setting to determine effectiveness in silica exposure reduction. This report describes the methods and results of our evaluation of a system consisting of the DustControl 2900c vacuum with the ICS Dust Director shroud and a Bosch Model 1775E grinder.
Excessive exposure to respirable silica can result in silicosis or other silica-related diseases including pulmonary tuberculosis, lung cancer, silicoproteinosis (Lyons et al, 2007) and autoimmune disorders such as rheumatoid arthritis, sarcoidosis and scleroderma (Miller et al, 2012). Respirable silica is generally defined as particles less than 10 micrometers (μm) in aerodynamic diameter (ACGIH, 2013). Silicosis can lead to symptoms including shortness of breath, fatigue, chest pains, susceptibility to infection and possibly death. There is no cure for silicosis, however it is totally preventable. Construction workers exposed to dust, including silica, are also known to have higher rates of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD).
There are many sources of silica in construction that result in exposures of varying intensity among workers. Masonry restoration workers are among the most highly silica-exposed trades in construction. The process of grinding out deteriorated mortar joints between masonry units and replacing or repointing with fresh mortar (often referred to as tuckpointing) is a fundamental part of masonry restoration work. The removal of mortar with powered angle grinders generates enormous levels of dust. Between 2004 and 2006, NIOSH and CPWR evaluated silica exposures while grinding mortar in a controlled setting, at a local training center, where tasks, sample times and task variables were defined by the study design. These studies demonstrated that grinding mortar without controls can result in elevated respirable silica exposures. Meeker et al., (2009) reported exposures between 5 and 25.8 milligrams per cubic meter (mg/m3) in a controlled setting. This study also showed that LEV systems for tuckpointing grinders can reduce exposures to respirable silica by greater than 90 percent.II. Objectives
The objective of this evaluation was to assess the effectiveness of an LEV system for controlling exposure to silica during the grinding of mortar. The control technology was tested under controlled conditions, similar to those experienced by tuckpointers on actual job sites, using journeymen bricklayers experienced in tuckpointing and repeat, randomized trials with and without LEV. All other variables were held constant throughout so that the only variable was whether or not the tested control was used.
III. Description of Equipment Tested
A Bosch model 1775E grinder (Robert Bosch Tool Corporation, Prospect, IL) (Figures 1, 2 and 3) was fitted with a new 1/4-inch wide, 4½-inch diameter segmented diamond abrasive blade made by DeWalt (model #DW4740). The grinder weighs six and a half pounds, draws 8.5 amps and has a variable speed up to 11,000 revolutions per minute (RPMs). The DustControl 2900c vacuum (DustControl, Inc., Wilmington, NC) (Figure 3) was tested in combination with the Dust Director shroud (Industrial Contractors’ Supplies, Inc., Huntingdon, PA) (Figures 1 and 3) attached to the Bosch grinder.
Figure 1. Bosch grinder with Dust Director shroud
Figure 2. Bosch grinder without tuckpointing LEV system.
Figure 3: Bosch Grinder with LEV System
The vacuum is specified to weigh 31 pounds when empty and to provide a flow rate of 114 cubic feet of air per minute and a “static lift” or “vacuum suction pressure” of 84 inches of water. The vacuum is sold with a cyclonic pre-separator, to remove larger particles, a fine filter (rated 99.9 percent efficient) and a HEPA (high-efficiency particulate air) filter (rated to capture 99.97 percent of the particles with an aerodynamic diameter of 0.3 micrometers). The HEPA filter was removed based on the manufacturer’s recommendation due to the heavy dust loading associated with tuckpointing. CPWR sponsored research and contractor experience indicate that HEPA filters likely have an adverse effect on dust capture during tuckpointing because of extreme dust loading on filters. While the cyclone and the fine filter remove most of the dust, especially the large particles, before they reach the HEPA filter, the HEPA filter would still be subject to heavy loading, causing a substantial pressure drop and subsequent decrease in air flow rate. The relatively small increase in the efficiency of the filtration system while using the HEPA filter is expected to be quickly offset by a more significant decrease in capture efficiency as the air flow rate and ability to capture particles decreases.
Dust collects in relatively inexpensive, heavy-gauge plastic bags below and outside of the cyclone. The bags can be removed and replaced without opening the vacuum. Some vacuums are equipped with a light to indicate that the filters need to be cleaned or changed. The DC2900c features a “reverse air pulse cleaning system,” which removes accumulated dust from the filters without having to remove them from the vacuum. The system, as illustrated in Figure 4, requires the operator to disconnect the hose from the shroud, place it over an air stop so that air through the hose is cut off and pressure in the vacuum is maximized.
Figure 4. Procedure for "cleaning" of or dust removal from filters (source: http://dustcontrolusa.com/manuals/2800c.pdf)
The flap covering the port on the side of the vacuum is repeatedly flipped open to release built up pressure in strong pulses that dislodge dust from the filter.
The manufacturer indicates “the filter is generally cleaned once or twice daily during normal continuous operation.” The Dust Director shroud has a 2-inch diameter take-off that was connected to the antistatic, corrugated 1.5-inch diameter, 15-foot long vacuum hose supplied with the DustControl vacuum.
IV. Study Methods
This evaluation was conducted at the International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craft workers (IUBAC) Local 1 Philadelphia/Delaware Training Center in Philadelphia, PA on November 14 and 15, 2012. A single journeyman bricklayer, experienced in tuckpointing, used the grinder and LEV system being tested to remove mortar from joints wide enough to require two passes. The type S mortar had been allowed to cure for at least four weeks. The bricklayer either possessed or was provided with personal protective equipment including sturdy work boots, gloves, hearing protection and a powered air-purifying respirator (PAPR). The PAPR was a 3M GVP system with a bump cap, loose fitting face piece and a HEPA filter (3M, St Paul, MN).
The study was designed to include at least five rounds of sampling during mortar removal. Each round included a trial using the Bosch grinder with a Dust Director shroud and Dust Collector 2900c vacuum and a trial using the Bosch grinder with the factory-supplied guard and without a vacuum. The order of the two trials within each round was randomly selected to minimize bias that might be introduced due to variation associated with environmental factors, equipment operator, blade wear, vacuum performance over time and any other factors unrelated to LEV use. Tools were operated for approximately 16 minutes per trial with controls and for approximately 8 minutes when controls were not used. These times were selected based on the results of previous sampling efforts and estimates of the minimum sample time needed to achieve a limit of quantification low enough to accurately measure exposures down to or less than 0.05 mg/m3 – the NIOSH Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) for respirable silica. The bricklayer was required to take a 5 to 10 minute break in the middle of the 16-minute trials to reduce differences in fatigue, compared to the 8-minute trials. Personal air samples were collected in the breathing zone of the operator during each trial to measure respirable silica concentrations during grinding with and without LEV. The samples were collected using a GilAir-5 pump (Sensidyne, Inc., Clearwater, FL) to draw 4.2 liters of air per minute through a GK2.69 Respirable Cyclone (BGI Inc., Waltham, MA) with a pre-weighed, 37 mm diameter, 5-micron pore size polyvinyl chloride (PVC) filter positioned on the operator’s lapel.
The flow rates of the sampling pumps were calibrated at the beginning of each day using a DryCal DC-Lite Primary Flow Meter (Bios International Corporation, Butler, NJ). Flow rates were measured again near the middle and at the end of each day to ensure that sampling flow rates were maintained within 5% of pre-sampling flow rates throughout the day. Average flow rates were used to calculate sample air volumes. Samples were analyzed by R.J. Lee Group, Inc., (Monroeville, PA) using NIOSH Method 0600, to determine exposure to total mass of respirable dust. The same samples were also analyzed using X-Ray diffraction following NIOSH method 7500 to determine quartz, cristobalite and tridymite concentration in the respirable mass. Reported masses for these analytes were used with the sample air volumes to calculate airborne concentrations of total respirable dust, quartz, cristobalite and tridymite.
We used a reduction of greater than 50 percent in respirable silica exposure concentrations or a reduction to less than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 as our criteria for determining whether or not a control was considered efficacious. This is consistent with criteria used by NIOSH in conducting a similar study in 2004 described by Echt et al. (2007) and by CPWR in 2006 and described by Meeker et al. (2009). The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) and the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) publish additional occupational exposure limits (OELs) for silica which are listed in Table 1 with NIOSH RELs. OELs for silica are based on the respirable fraction of the aerosol, which consists of particles less than 10 micrometers in aerodynamic diameter.
| Organization or Agency | Form of Crystalline Silica | Occupational Exposure Limits (mg/m3) |
|---|---|---|
| NIOSHA | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 |
| OSHA - ConstructionB | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
PEL = 250 / (5 + % quartz) PEL = 250 / (5 + % cristobalite) PEL = 250 / (5 + % tridymite) |
| ACGIH | Crystalline Silica | TLV = 0.025 mg/m3 |
A NIOSH Publication No. 2005-151 indicates 10-hour time-weighted average during a 40-hr workweek B The PEL for silica in OSHA’s Safety and Health Regulations for Construction, 29 C.F.R. 1926.55(a), is an 8-hour time-weighted average (TWA) expressed in millions of particles per cubic foot (mppcf). However, the units mppcf can be converted to milligrams per cubic meter can by dividing mppcf by 10 (OSHA, 2009). The formula used by OSHA to determine the PEL for silica is dependent on the percentage of silica in each collected sample. The concentration of respirable dust measured is compared to the sample specific PEL to determine if the PEL has been exceeded. OSHA has proposed lowering the PEL to 0.05 mg/m3 of respirable silica as an 8 hour TWA. |
||
The flow of air in ventilation systems is governed by fundamental principles that describe the behavior of gases (in this case air). Pressure measurements taken within a ventilation system along with knowledge of hood (or shroud) entry losses can be used to calculate flow rates. Hood entry losses are dependent on the shape and configuration of a particular hood or shroud and described by the term “coefficient of entry (Ce)” which is the ratio of actual air flow through a hood and what the air flow would theoretically be if there were no hood entry losses. Given the coefficient of entry, static pressure measurements can be used to calculate air flow through a given hood. The coefficient of entry for the Dust Director shroud was previously determined by CPWR and used for calculating air flow based on static pressure measurements (Meeker et al., 2009). Static pressure, with the vacuum operating, was measured periodically throughout the evaluation to monitor the changes in air-flow rate following use and again after filter cleaning. The static pressure was measured at a port positioned more than 3 duct diameters downstream from the tool’s air intake using a UEi EM200 Electronic Manometer (Universal Enterprises, Inc., Beaverton, OR).
The dust in the vacuum bag was monitored and, per the manufacturer’s instructions, the bag was changed before the dust level was within 5 centimeters of the valve at the bottom of the vacuum. Each time a vacuum bag was removed, it was weighed to the nearest pound. The bag weights and corresponding grinding durations were used to calculate the average weight of dust collected per unit time. After each trial, cut lengths were measured on the wall to determine total linear feet of vertical (head) and horizontal (bed) joints per unit time.
A Haz-Dust III, Model HD-1003, Real-Time Aerosol Monitor (Environmental Devices Corporation, Plaistow, NH) was used to confirm clearance of dust between trials. The Haz-Dust monitor was positioned on the test wall near the operator at approximately breathing zone level and configured to measure respirable particulate concentration.
V. Results
Personal air monitoring
Five pairs of respirable dust samples were collected while grinding with and without the vacuum system. In addition, three respirable dust samples were collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place. One measurement collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard was shown to be a statistical outlier and was omitted from analysis. Personal air monitoring results for respirable silica and a comparison of average exposures relative to the NIOSH REL for silica (0.05 mg/m3) appears in Table 2. The mean respirable dust levels measured without LEV was 31.4 mg/m3. However, samples collected with LEV were below the limit of quantification (LOQ) which ranged from <1.29 to <1.46 mg/m3. Use of LEV resulted in a greater than 95% reduction in mean respirable dust levels using a mean value with use of LEV of <1.41 (n=5 samples with use of LEV and n=7 without use of LEV). The respirable dust samples collected during grinding without the LEV system contained an average of 24 percent silica. The mass of respirable dust in the samples collected with use of the LEV system was too low to determine the silica content.| Mean, mg/m3 (range) | Std. Dev. | Percent Reduction | Hazard RatioB | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bosch with Dust Director Shroud and DustControl 2900c Vacuum |
0.091 (<0.069 – 0.137) |
0.027 | 98.7 | 1.81 |
| Bosch with no Control | 7.23 (4.57 – 9.90) |
1.94 | NA | 145 |
A n = 5 samples for each tool/control combination and n = 7 samples without the use of the LEV system B Hazard Ratio = measured exposure / NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 |
||||
Average respirable silica and dust exposures, with and without the dust control system, appear as Figures 5 and 6, respectively.
Figure 5. Average respirable silica exposures with and without the Dustcontrol 2900c vacuum and Dust Director shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air - mg/m3)
Figure 6. Average respirable dust exposures with and without Dustcontrol 2900c Vacuum and Dust Director Shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air – mg/m3)
The mean respirable silica concentration measured during use of the control was significantly less than the concentration measured while using the same tool without controls (p<0.01). Grinding mortar with the Bosch angle grinder without dust controls resulted in an average exposure to respirable silica that was 145 times the NIOSH REL. Grinding with the Bosch angle grinder in combination with the Dust Director shroud and the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced the average concentration of respirable silica by 98.7 percent. With use of these controls, the concentration of respirable silica was 1.8 times greater than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3. However the NIOSH REL is based on a time-weighted average (TWA) over a 10-hour workday. Given these were task TWAs and samples were collected over continuous periods of grinding, they may overestimate exposures over an actual work day since some time would be spent performing tasks that would likely have lower, or no, silica exposures (setup, breaks, cleanup, etc.).
Static pressure, dust mass collection and grinding rates.
Static pressure was used as a surrogate for air flow as described earlier. Hood static pressure was measured periodically at a tap near the grinder more than 3 duct diameters from the air intake in the shroud. The static pressure, and thus air flow, was generally higher when the vacuum’s filter had recently been cleaned. The mean, median, and range of calculated flow rates are presented in Table A1 of the Appendix.
Based on the data we collected, the air-flow rate upstream from the Bosch grinder and Dust Director shroud ranged from 78 to 93 cubic feet per minute (cfm) with the DustControl vacuum. When the manufacturer’s filter cleaning procedure was followed the vacuum performed relatively well and flow could be maintained at slightly less than 90 cfm with cleaning. However, mean flow rates dropped substantially to 80 cfm after as little as 8 minutes of grinding without any filter cleaning. The flow rate returned to an average of 89 cfm when filters were cleaned correctly (without stopping air flow to the vacuum). Collingwood and Heitbrink (2007) found that the minimum exhaust flow rate for capture of silica and other particulate under ideal conditions is 21.25 cfm per inch of grinder blade diameter. This is equal to about 96 cfm when using a 4.5 inch diameter grinding blade. We set 106 cfm as the minimum desired flow rate for this study to allow a safety margin for potential decline in equipment performance and the possibility of inadequate maintenance, both of which may be likely after repeated use under actual work conditions. The DustControl vacuum provided slightly less than the minimum flow rate described by Collingwood and Heitbrink for a 4.5-inch blade and the peak flow rate fell with use.
The duration of vacuum bag use and mass of dust collected were recorded and are presented in Table A2 of the Appendix. The vacuum bags were changed and weighed after each trial utilizing the LEV system. A total of five bags were used to complete the five rounds of grinding. The DustControl vacuum captured 45 pounds of dust over 83 minutes of grinding for an average rate of dust collection of 0.54 pounds per minute. The rate of dust collection ranged from 0.47 to 0.63 pounds per minute. Based on these measurements, approximately 130 pounds of dust would likely be captured after just 4 hours of continuous grinding.
The rate of grinding a combination of vertical and horizontal joints while using the LEV system ranged from 2.3 to 3.3 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the use of the LEV system ranged from 2.6 to 3.4 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place ranged from 4.7 to 5.1 feet per minute. It’s important to note that: 1) the operator had limited experience using dust control systems and cut rates appeared to improve slightly over the 2-day period he used the tested equipment; and 2) the upper range of cut rates with the dust control system overlapped with the lowest cut rate with the original guard and without the LEV system in place indicating no statistical difference between cut rates. Given that grinding rates with and without use of this LEV system are only available for one operator and he had limited experience with the LEV system, these reported cut rates are in no way intended to represent the impact use of this LEV system is likely to have on productivity rates overall.
VI. Discussion
The objective of these trials was to evaluate the effectiveness of a tuckpointing LEV system for controlling respirable silica while grinding out mortar joints. The Dust Director shroud with the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced respirable silica concentrations when grinding with the Bosch grinder by approximately 99 percent. Despite being considered effective by our test criteria (greater than 50% reduction), it still resulted in task TWA exposures that exceeded the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 by 1.8 times. Depending on how much time is spent grinding over the course of a work day and on exposures while performing other tasks, the 8-hour TWA exposures may or may not exceed the REL with this system. Use of this system by workers with experience and training in proficient use will likely improve dust capture performance. Exposure reduction is greatly influenced by correct use of this system which includes grinding from right to left, making sure the shroud is held flush against the wall and that the tool travels at a pace that doesn’t exceed the ability of the system to capture dust as it’s generated. Deviation from any of these measures produces visible dust clouds which were observed during trials.
VII. Conclusions
With a 99 percent reduction in respirable silica exposure, the Dust Director shroud and DustControl 2900c vacuum with a Bosch Model 1775E grinder was effective in reducing silica exposures based on our criteria. Use of the tested dust control system may be effective in reducing silica exposure on the job to less than the NIOSH REL if used in combination with administrative controls such as work scheduling to reduce cutting times as needed. Training on correct use of the tested system is also essential. Personal air monitoring is necessary to verify control effectiveness on actual job sites and under “real-world” conditions. However, these results clearly demonstrate the availability of viable and effective engineering controls for tuckpointing operations associated with elevated silica exposure.
VIII. References
American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists. Threshold limit values for chemical substances (TLV®-CS). [2013]. ACGIH, Cincinnati, Ohio.
Bergdahl I.A,. Toren K., Eriksson K., et al. [2004]. Increased mortality in COPD among construction workers exposed to inorganic dust. European Respiratory Journal, 23: 402–06.
Blanc P.D. & Torén K. [2007]. Occupation in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and chronic bronchitis: an update [State of the Art Series. Occupational lung disease in high-and low-income countries, Edited by M. Chan-Yeung. Number 2 in the series]. The International Journal of Tuberculosis and Lung Disease, 11(3), 251-257.
Collingwood S. & Heitbrink W.A. [2007] 'Field Evaluation of an Engineering Control for Respirable Crystalline Silica Exposures During Mortar Removal'. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, 4:11, 875 – 887.
DHHS (NIOSH) Publication No. 2002-129 April 2002 http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/2002-129/
Echt A., Sieber W.K., Lefkowitz D., Meeker J., Susi P., Cardwell B., Heitbrink, W.A. In-depth survey of dust control technology for cutting concrete block and tuckpointing brick at The International Masonry Institute Bordentown Training Center, Bordentown, NJ. Cincinnati, OH: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Report. No. EPHB 282-13; 2007. http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ECTB-282-13.pdf
Heitbrink W., Bennett J. [2006]. A numerical and experimental investigation of crystalline silica exposure control during tuck pointing. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, Vol. 3, pp 366-378.
Lyons et al, [2007]. A breathless builder. Breathe, Vol. 3, no. 4, pp 386-390.
Mastrangelo G., Tartari M., Fedeli U., Fadda E., Saia B. [2003]. Ascertaining the risk of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease in relation to occupation using a case-control design. Occupational Medicine, 53: 165–172.
Meeker J., Cooper M., Lefrowitz D., Susi P. [2009]. Engineering control technologies to reduce occupational silica exposures in masonry cutting and tuckpointing. Public Health Reports, Supplement 1, Vol. 124, June.
Meeker J, Flynn M, Susi P, Cardwell, B [2004]. Performance evaluation of a masonry concrete vacuum. Unpublished Report.
Miller F. W., Alfredsson L., Costenbader K. H., Kamen D. L., Nelson L. M., Norris J. M., & De Roos A. J. [2012]. Epidemiology of environmental exposures and human autoimmune diseases: findings from a National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences Expert Panel workshop. Journal of autoimmunity. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3496812/
Occupational Safety and Health Administration U.S Department of Labor. Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction. [2009]. OSHA 3362-05.
Rappaport SM, Goldberg M, Susi P, Herrick RF [2003]. Excessive exposure to silica in the U.S. construction industry. Annals of Occupational Hygiene, Vol. 47, pp. 111-122.
IX. Appendices
| Measurement Conditions |
n | Mean Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Median
Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before filter cleaning | 5 | 80 | 81 | 78-81 |
| After filter cleaning following manufacturer directions | 9 | 89 | 90 | 84-93 |
| * Static pressure was measured in millibars and converted to inches of water gauge. Flow rates were calculated using the formula Q = Ce (A) 4005 (SP)1/2 where: Q = flow in cubic feet per minute (cfm), Ce = coefficient of entry, A = area of the duct where static pressure measurements were taken in square feet, and SP = static pressure in inches of water gauge. | ||||
| Tool/Control | Collection Period (min.) |
Dust Collection Rate (lb/min.) |
|---|---|---|
| Bosch grinder/Dust Director shroud & DustControl 2900c vacuum |
8 11 8 8 10 |
0.50 0.61 0.50 0.47 0.63 |
| Average | 0.54 |
[disclaimer:protected] => [disclaimer_transformed:protected] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [template] => record ) [_globalContext:PHPTAL_Context:private] => stdClass Object ( ) [_echoDeclarations:PHPTAL_Context:private] => [referer] => http://www.elcosh.org/document/3908/d001345/An%2BEvaluation%2Bof%2BSilica%2BExposure%2BControls%2Bfor%2BTuckpointing%253A%2BDustControl%2B2900c%2BVacuum%2Bwith%2Bthe%2BICS%2BDust%2BDirector%2BShroud%2Band%2BBosch%2BGrinder%2BModel%2B1775E%2BConducted%2BNovember%2B14-15%252C%2B2012.html [curr_module] => Record [styles] => Array ( ) [javascript] => Array ( [0] => jquery.min.js ) [metas] => Array ( [language] => en [robots] => index, follow ) [user] => [curr_url] => https://www.elcosh.org/index.php?module=Record&id=3908&type=document [base_url] => https://www.elcosh.org/index.php?module=Record [title] => eLCOSH : An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: DustControl 2900c Vacuum with the ICS Dust Director Shroud and Bosch Grinder Model 1775E Conducted November 14-15, 2012 [language] => en [search_query] => [module] => Record [new_records] => Array ( [0] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Fixed Ladder [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Fixed Ladders addresses the potential risks associated with using fixed ladders. The resource includes a brief case example,... [category] => Array ( [0] => 15 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 53 [5] => 55 [6] => 60 [7] => 64 [8] => 73 [9] => 76 [10] => 78 [11] => 80 [12] => 86 [13] => 87 [14] => 90 [15] => 92 [16] => 93 [17] => 94 [18] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Falls [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Concrete Polisher [11] => Electrical Worker [13] => HVAC [15] => Laborer [17] => PCC/Restoration [19] => Plumber/Pipefitter [21] => Roofer/Waterproofer [23] => Sheetmetal Worker [25] => Welder [27] => Commercial & Institutional [28] => Jobsites [29] => Industrial [31] => LEED/Green Construction [33] => Renovations [35] => Residential [37] => Toolbox Talks [38] => Documents [39] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4430/d001660/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BFixed%2BLadder.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [53] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 53 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Concrete Polisher [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [73] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 73 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => PCC/Restoration [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4430 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001660 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Fixed Ladder [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Fixed Ladders, Fall Prevention, Falls [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Fixed Ladders addresses the potential risks associated with using fixed ladders. The resource includes a brief case example, steps to prevent a related injury and questions for discussion. It includes an image that illustrates the hazard, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001257,d001254,d001255,d001256,d001258,d001262,d001279 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_completed:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/22/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [1] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Challenges Preventing Falling Objects [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Challenges Preventing Falling Objects addresses the hazards of being struck by falling objects on the job site. The resource... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 55 [5] => 64 [6] => 68 [7] => 71 [8] => 75 [9] => 78 [10] => 79 [11] => 82 [12] => 62 [13] => 86 [14] => 87 [15] => 88 [16] => 89 [17] => 91 [18] => 90 [19] => 92 [20] => 93 [21] => 94 [22] => 95 [23] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Electrical Worker [11] => Laborer [13] => Maintenance Worker [15] => Painter [17] => Plasterer [19] => Roofer/Waterproofer [21] => Scaffold Erector [23] => Stonemason [25] => Structural Ironworker [27] => Welder [29] => Commercial & Institutional [30] => Jobsites [31] => Demolition [33] => Disasters [35] => Heavy & Highway [37] => Industrial [39] => LEED/Green Construction [41] => Renovations [43] => Residential [45] => Underground [47] => Toolbox Talks [48] => Documents [49] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4431/d001661/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BChallenges%2BPreventing%2BFalling%2BObjects.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4431 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001661 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Challenges Preventing Falling Objects [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => dropped objects, falling objects, struck by incidents, struck by fatalities [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Challenges Preventing Falling Objects addresses the hazards of being struck by falling objects on the job site. The resource includes a brief example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates a group workers observing a scaffold free of debris during high winds, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001234,d001238,d001244,d001251,d001253,d001260,d001268,d001278 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_completed:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/22/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [2] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Tower Crane Safety [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Tower Crane Safety addresses the potential hazards of Tower Cranes and the importance of following procedure before and durin... [category] => Array ( [0] => 11 [1] => 12 [2] => 18 [3] => 70 [4] => 87 [5] => 88 [6] => 91 [7] => 90 [8] => 92 [9] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Cranes & Hoists [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Crushed/Struck By [6] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [9] => Operating Engineer [10] => Trades [11] => Commercial & Institutional [12] => Jobsites [13] => Demolition [15] => Heavy & Highway [17] => Industrial [19] => LEED/Green Construction [21] => Toolbox Talks [22] => Documents [23] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4427/d001657/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BTower%2BCrane%2BSafety.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [11] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 11 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Cranes & Hoists [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [18] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 18 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4427 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001657 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Tower Crane Safety [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Tower Crane, Crane, Stability, Tipping, Lift Zone Safety, Lift, Zone, Safety, Struck by [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Tower Crane Safety addresses the potential hazards of Tower Cranes and the importance of following procedure before and during Tower Crane operation. The resource includes a brief example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates a worker inspecting a Tower Crane before operation, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001234,d001238,d001250,d001251,d001253,d001258,d001262,d001273 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/19/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [3] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Work Zone Safety: Working Around Vehicles [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Working Around Vehicles in the Work Zone addresses methods to avoid being struck-by a vehicle on a construction site. The res... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 18 [2] => 52 [3] => 57 [4] => 70 [5] => 85 [6] => 87 [7] => 88 [8] => 89 [9] => 91 [10] => 90 [11] => 92 [12] => 93 [13] => 94 [14] => 95 [15] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [6] => Commercial Diver [7] => Trades [8] => Flagger [10] => Operating Engineer [12] => Truck Driver [14] => Commercial & Institutional [15] => Jobsites [16] => Demolition [18] => Disasters [20] => Heavy & Highway [22] => Industrial [24] => LEED/Green Construction [26] => Renovations [28] => Residential [30] => Underground [32] => Toolbox Talks [33] => Documents [34] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4428/d001658/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BWork%2BZone%2BSafety%253A%2BWorking%2BAround%2BVehicles.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [18] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 18 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [52] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 52 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Commercial Diver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [85] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 85 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Truck Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4428 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001658 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Daniela Caceres [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Work Zone Safety: Working Around Vehicles [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Struck, Struck by, Vehicle, Work Zone Safety, Truck, Operator, Driver, Mobile Equipment [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Working Around Vehicles in the Work Zone addresses methods to avoid being struck-by a vehicle on a construction site. The resource includes a case example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates the hazard, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001640 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/19/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [4] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Construction Dive -- DeWalt's Jobsite Pro headphones recalled for fire hazards [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => A recall notice by the United States Consumer Product Safety Commission affects over 300,000 DeWalt Jobsite Pro Headphones. The recall is a result of... [category] => Array ( [0] => 16 [1] => 44 [2] => 45 [3] => 46 [4] => 47 [5] => 48 [6] => 49 [7] => 50 [8] => 51 [9] => 52 [10] => 53 [11] => 54 [12] => 55 [13] => 56 [14] => 57 [15] => 58 [16] => 59 [17] => 60 [18] => 61 [19] => 64 [20] => 65 [21] => 66 [22] => 67 [23] => 68 [24] => 69 [25] => 70 [26] => 71 [27] => 72 [28] => 73 [29] => 74 [30] => 75 [31] => 76 [32] => 77 [33] => 63 [34] => 78 [35] => 79 [36] => 80 [37] => 81 [38] => 82 [39] => 62 [40] => 83 [41] => 84 [42] => 85 [43] => 86 [44] => 87 [45] => 88 [46] => 89 [47] => 91 [48] => 90 [49] => 92 [50] => 93 [51] => 94 [52] => 95 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Fire & Explosions [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Acoustical Ceiling Carpenter [4] => Trades [5] => Asbestos/Insulator [7] => Boilermaker [9] => Bricklayer [11] => Cabinetmaker [13] => Carpenter [15] => Carpet Layer [17] => Cement Mason [19] => Commercial Diver [21] => Concrete Polisher [23] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [25] => Electrical Worker [27] => Elevator Constructor [29] => Flagger [31] => Glazier [33] => Hazardous Waste Cleanup [35] => HVAC [37] => Interior Systems Carpenter [39] => Laborer [41] => Landscaper [43] => Lather [45] => Lead Abatement Worker [47] => Maintenance Worker [49] => Millwright [51] => Operating Engineer [53] => Painter [55] => Paper Hanger [57] => PCC/Restoration [59] => Pile Driver [61] => Plasterer [63] => Plumber/Pipefitter [65] => Refractory Worker [67] => Reinforcing Ironworker [69] => Roofer/Waterproofer [71] => Scaffold Erector [73] => Sheetmetal Worker [75] => Sprinkler Fitter [77] => Stonemason [79] => Structural Ironworker [81] => Terrazzo Worker [83] => Tile Setter [85] => Truck Driver [87] => Welder [89] => Commercial & Institutional [90] => Jobsites [91] => Demolition [93] => Disasters [95] => Heavy & Highway [97] => Industrial [99] => LEED/Green Construction [101] => Renovations [103] => Residential [105] => Underground ) [type] => [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4426/d001656/Construction%2BDive%2B--%2BDeWalt%2527s%2BJobsite%2BPro%2Bheadphones%2Brecalled%2Bfor%2Bfire%2Bhazards.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [16] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 16 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Fire & Explosions [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [44] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 44 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Acoustical Ceiling Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [45] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 45 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Asbestos/Insulator [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [46] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 46 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Boilermaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [48] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 48 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cabinetmaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [50] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 50 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpet Layer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [52] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 52 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Commercial Diver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [53] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 53 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Concrete Polisher [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [54] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 54 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [58] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 58 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Glazier [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [59] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 59 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Hazardous Waste Cleanup [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [65] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 65 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Landscaper [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [66] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 66 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Lather [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [67] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 67 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Lead Abatement Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [69] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 69 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Millwright [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [72] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 72 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Paper Hanger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [73] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 73 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => PCC/Restoration [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [77] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 77 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Refractory Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [81] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 81 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sprinkler Fitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [83] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 83 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Terrazzo Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [84] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 84 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Tile Setter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [85] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 85 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Truck Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4426 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001656 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Construction Dive -- DeWalt's Jobsite Pro headphones recalled for fire hazards [total_pages:protected] => 1 [billed_pages:protected] => 1 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => DeWalt, Fire Hazards, recall, headphones [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A recall notice by the United States Consumer Product Safety Commission affects over 300,000 DeWalt Jobsite Pro Headphones. The recall is a result of a malfunction that can cause earbuds to overheat while charging or during use, leading to fire and burn hazards. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => https://www.constructiondive.com/news/dewalts-jobsite-pro-headphones-recalled-for-fire-hazards/611248/?utm_source=Sailthru&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Issue:%202021-12-10%20Construction%20Dive%20Newsletter%20%5Bissue:38532%5D&utm_term=Construction%20Dive [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/13/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/13/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 12/13/21 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [new_images] => Array ( [0] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Morning Toolbox Talk [image] => /record/images/4003-p.jpg [blurb] => This photo is from an early morning toolbox talk on a construction job in Mclean, Virginia. It is being delivered in English and Spanish.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 20 [1] => 51 [2] => 57 [3] => 64 [4] => 70 [5] => 63 [6] => 78 [7] => 82 [8] => 62 [9] => 87 [10] => 88 [11] => 89 [12] => 91 [13] => 90 [14] => 93 [15] => 94 [16] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Safety Culture [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Cement Mason [4] => Trades [5] => Flagger [7] => Laborer [9] => Operating Engineer [11] => Reinforcing Ironworker [13] => Roofer/Waterproofer [15] => Stonemason [17] => Structural Ironworker [19] => Commercial & Institutional [20] => Jobsites [21] => Demolition [23] => Disasters [25] => Heavy & Highway [27] => Industrial [29] => Renovations [31] => Residential [33] => Images [34] => Media [35] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4003/i002691/Morning%2BToolbox%2BTalk.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4003 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002691 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Morning Toolbox Talk [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, Spanish, bilingual [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This photo is from an early morning toolbox talk on a construction job in Mclean, Virginia. It is being delivered in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001285,d001304,c000079 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [1] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox talk - crew view [image] => /record/images/4005-p.jpg [blurb] => Photo of crew listening to a toolbox safety talk before starting work.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 97 [1] => 20 [2] => 47 [3] => 49 [4] => 51 [5] => 55 [6] => 61 [7] => 64 [8] => 71 [9] => 75 [10] => 63 [11] => 79 [12] => 62 [13] => 87 [14] => 88 [15] => 91 [16] => 90 [17] => 93 [18] => 94 [19] => 95 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Images [1] => Media [2] => Media & Documents [3] => Safety Culture [4] => Work Environment [5] => Hazards [6] => Bricklayer [7] => Trades [8] => Carpenter [10] => Cement Mason [12] => Electrical Worker [14] => Interior Systems Carpenter [16] => Laborer [18] => Painter [20] => Plasterer [22] => Reinforcing Ironworker [24] => Scaffold Erector [26] => Structural Ironworker [28] => Commercial & Institutional [29] => Jobsites [30] => Demolition [32] => Heavy & Highway [34] => Industrial [36] => Renovations [38] => Residential [40] => Underground ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4005/i002692/Toolbox%2Btalk%2B-%2Bcrew%2Bview.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4005 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002692 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox talk - crew view [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, safety talk, Spanish [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Photo of crew listening to a toolbox safety talk before starting work. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002691,d001269, c000079, d001285 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [2] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox talk - long shot [image] => /record/images/4006-p.jpg [blurb] => This crew gathered every morning before starting work to discuss a new safety topic.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 20 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 55 [5] => 64 [6] => 68 [7] => 75 [8] => 76 [9] => 63 [10] => 78 [11] => 79 [12] => 82 [13] => 62 [14] => 87 [15] => 88 [16] => 91 [17] => 90 [18] => 93 [19] => 94 [20] => 95 [21] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Safety Culture [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Electrical Worker [11] => Laborer [13] => Maintenance Worker [15] => Plasterer [17] => Plumber/Pipefitter [19] => Reinforcing Ironworker [21] => Roofer/Waterproofer [23] => Scaffold Erector [25] => Stonemason [27] => Structural Ironworker [29] => Commercial & Institutional [30] => Jobsites [31] => Demolition [33] => Heavy & Highway [35] => Industrial [37] => Renovations [39] => Residential [41] => Underground [43] => Images [44] => Media [45] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4006/i002693/Toolbox%2Btalk%2B-%2Blong%2Bshot.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4006 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002693 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox talk - long shot [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, safety minute [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This crew gathered every morning before starting work to discuss a new safety topic. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002691,i002692,d001269,d000527 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [3] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Safety officer discussing ongoing project with marketing coordinator [image] => /record/images/4014-p.jpg [blurb] => The safety officer (left) points out the good safety practices on this project that reflect well on the firm and may influence future clients.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 97 [1] => 20 [2] => 46 [3] => 47 [4] => 49 [5] => 50 [6] => 51 [7] => 54 [8] => 55 [9] => 58 [10] => 60 [11] => 61 [12] => 64 [13] => 71 [14] => 75 [15] => 76 [16] => 63 [17] => 79 [18] => 80 [19] => 82 [20] => 62 [21] => 83 [22] => 87 [23] => 91 [24] => 90 [25] => 93 [26] => 94 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Images [1] => Media [2] => Media & Documents [3] => Safety Culture [4] => Work Environment [5] => Hazards [6] => Boilermaker [7] => Trades [8] => Bricklayer [10] => Carpenter [12] => Carpet Layer [14] => Cement Mason [16] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [18] => Electrical Worker [20] => Glazier [22] => HVAC [24] => Interior Systems Carpenter [26] => Laborer [28] => Painter [30] => Plasterer [32] => Plumber/Pipefitter [34] => Reinforcing Ironworker [36] => Scaffold Erector [38] => Sheetmetal Worker [40] => Stonemason [42] => Structural Ironworker [44] => Terrazzo Worker [46] => Commercial & Institutional [47] => Jobsites [48] => Heavy & Highway [50] => Industrial [52] => Renovations [54] => Residential ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4014/i002700/Safety%2Bofficer%2Bdiscussing%2Bongoing%2Bproject%2Bwith%2Bmarketing%2Bcoordinator.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [46] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 46 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Boilermaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [50] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 50 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpet Layer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [54] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 54 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [58] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 58 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Glazier [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [83] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 83 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Terrazzo Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4014 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002700 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Safety officer discussing ongoing project with marketing coordinator [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Latino, safety officer, safety culture [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The safety officer (left) points out the good safety practices on this project that reflect well on the firm and may influence future clients. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/index.php [more_like_this:protected] => d000989,d001351,d001362,d000652, d001101, d000931, d001395 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Hoar Construction, Photo by Neil Lippy [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 01/30/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [4] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Scaffolding at top of large column [image] => /record/images/3994-p.jpg [blurb] => This shot shows innovative guarding around the top of a large concrete column in the base of a high rise structure going up.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 15 [1] => 21 [2] => 47 [3] => 51 [4] => 63 [5] => 78 [6] => 79 [7] => 80 [8] => 62 [9] => 87 [10] => 97 [11] => 56 [12] => 64 [13] => 74 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Falls [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Scaffolds [6] => Bricklayer [7] => Trades [8] => Cement Mason [10] => Reinforcing Ironworker [12] => Roofer/Waterproofer [14] => Scaffold Erector [16] => Sheetmetal Worker [18] => Structural Ironworker [20] => Commercial & Institutional [21] => Jobsites [22] => Images [23] => Media [24] => Media & Documents [25] => Elevator Constructor [27] => Laborer [29] => Pile Driver ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/3994/i002689/Scaffolding%2Bat%2Btop%2Bof%2Blarge%2Bcolumn.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [21] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 21 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Scaffolds [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3994 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002689 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Scaffolding at top of large column [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Guardrail, railing, fall prevention, falls [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This shot shows innovative guarding around the top of a large concrete column in the base of a high rise structure going up. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/8/adjustable-tower-scaffold.html [more_like_this:protected] => c1002680,i002662,d000608,d001255 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Photo by Pam Susi [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2016 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_completed:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/01/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [5] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Construction bracing [image] => /record/images/3995-p.jpg [blurb] => This shows structural support that prevents collapses during construction.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 15 [2] => 21 [3] => 49 [4] => 51 [5] => 55 [6] => 56 [7] => 60 [8] => 64 [9] => 68 [10] => 74 [11] => 63 [12] => 78 [13] => 79 [14] => 80 [15] => 62 [16] => 87 [17] => 90 [18] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Falls [6] => Scaffolds [9] => Carpenter [10] => Trades [11] => Cement Mason [13] => Electrical Worker [15] => Elevator Constructor [17] => HVAC [19] => Laborer [21] => Maintenance Worker [23] => Pile Driver [25] => Reinforcing Ironworker [27] => Roofer/Waterproofer [29] => Scaffold Erector [31] => Sheetmetal Worker [33] => Structural Ironworker [35] => Commercial & Institutional [36] => Jobsites [37] => Industrial [39] => Images [40] => Media [41] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/3995/i002690/Construction%2Bbracing.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [21] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 21 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Scaffolds [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3995 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002690 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Construction bracing [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Bracing, support, scaffold [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This shows structural support that prevents collapses during construction. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/8/adjustable-tower-scaffold.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002660 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Photo by Pam Susi [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2016 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_completed:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/01/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [preview_mode] => [description] => The results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. [keywords] => tuckpointing, HEPA vacuum, dust control, LEV, local exhaust ventilation, silica [related_items] => Array ( [Research Reports] => Array ( [0] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1874 [old_id:protected] => 722 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000683 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Sharon Garber/COD [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Protecting Tuckpointing Workers from Silica Dust: Draft Recommendations for a Ventilated Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 12 [billed_pages:protected] => 12 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, vacuum, grinder, mortar, respirator, OSHA, NIOSH, exhaust, Heitbrink, tuckpointer, silica, masonry, dust, silicosis, LEV [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Describes draft recommendations for use of ventilated grinder to reduce dust during tuckpointing and describes field trials using these devices. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/hazard/67/chip-scrape-and-grind-surfaces-or-joints-silica.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001201,d000292,d000293,d000658 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2005 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/27/05 [date_completed:protected] => 04/26/05 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/20/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [1] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1940 [old_id:protected] => 909 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Workplace Solutions: Control of Hazardous Dust During Tuckpointing [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, silica, dust, tuckpoint, grinder, masonry restoration, mortar, vacuum [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d000819,d000820,d000730,d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 10/24/08 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/09 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [2] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3899 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001342 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: Hilti VC40-U Vacuum with Hilti DC-EX Dust Guard and Hilti Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 15 [billed_pages:protected] => 15 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP4 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => silica, tuckpointing, Hilti, local exhaust systems, LEV, shroud, quartz [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This report describes the results of an evaluation of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Hilti VC40-U vacuum, a Hilti DC-EX shroud, and a Hilti DAG-500 grinder. Randomized trials with and without use of the dust control system were conducted in a controlled setting. Removing mortar with the Hilti grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 220 times the National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05mg/m3. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 97 percent. However, exposures measured during the use of the dust control system still exceeded the NIOSH REL. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => December 1, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/05/14 [date_completed:protected] => 02/04/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/06/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [Handouts] => Array ( [0] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3656 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001198 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 24 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction While Doing Tuckpointing/Mortar Removal [total_pages:protected] => 2 [billed_pages:protected] => 2 [publication_number:protected] => DSG FS-3632 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Brick, block, tuckpointing, silica, local exhaust ventilation, LEV, masonry [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Tuckpointing creates some of the greatest exposures to silica in construction. This OSHA factsheet provides guidance on how to greatly reduce these exposures through the use of local exhaust ventilation. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863, d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => February 2013 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/04/13 [date_completed:protected] => 03/27/13 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [collections] => Array ( [3913] => ) [record] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => Array ( [867] => Author Object ( [id:protected] => 867 [organization_id:protected] => 0 [firstname:protected] => Michael [lastname:protected] => Cooper [address:protected] => [city:protected] => [province:protected] => [country:protected] => [postal_code:protected] => [department:protected] => [title:protected] => [phone:protected] => [fax:protected] => [email:protected] => [degree:protected] => [website:protected] => [about:protected] => [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => [date_completed:protected] => [date_billed:protected] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [481] => Author Object ( [id:protected] => 481 [organization_id:protected] => 0 [firstname:protected] => Pam [lastname:protected] => Susi [address:protected] => 8484 Georgia Avenue, Suite 1000 [city:protected] => Silver Spring [province:protected] => Maryland [country:protected] => USA [postal_code:protected] => 20910 [department:protected] => [title:protected] => [phone:protected] => 301-578-8500 ext.144 [fax:protected] => 301-578-8572 [email:protected] => plsusi@aol.com [degree:protected] => [website:protected] => http://www.cpwr.com [about:protected] => [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => 2003-10-02 [date_completed:protected] => 2003-10-06 [date_billed:protected] => 2003-11-03 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [organizations:protected] => Array ( [1] => Organization Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [elcosh_id:protected] => o000001 [user_id:protected] => 14 [province_id:protected] => 21 [country_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => CPWR - The Center for Construction Research and Training [address:protected] => Suite 1000, 8484 Georgia Ave [postal_code:protected] => 20910 [city:protected] => Silver Spring [department:protected] => [phone:protected] => 301-578-8500 [fax:protected] => 301-578-8572 [email:protected] => cpwrwebsite@cpwr.com [website:protected] => http://www.cpwr.com [filename:protected] => o000001.gif [about:protected] => CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training, developed, and continues to maintain/expand this website - The Electronic Library of Construction Occupational Safety and Health, www.elcosh.org. CPWR, formerly known as The Center to Protect Workers’ Rights, is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit research and training institution. Created by the Building and Construction Trades Department, AFL-CIO, CPWR serves as the research arm of the BCTD. Since the inception of its research agenda in 1990, CPWR has grown into a worldwide provider of safety and health information covering all aspects of the construction industry. CPWR launched eLCOSH in 2000, and the Spanish-language version of the site in 2001. CPWR also created, and continues to build, Construction Solutions - www.cpwrConstructionSolutions.org - a free, online database of construction hazards and ways to prevent, eliminate, or reduce them. [comments:protected] => [logo_available:protected] => T [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => 2000-08-18 [date_completed:protected] => 2000-08-30 [date_billed:protected] => 2000-09-05 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [collections:protected] => Array ( [3913] => ) [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => Array ( [1874] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1874 [old_id:protected] => 722 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000683 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Sharon Garber/COD [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Protecting Tuckpointing Workers from Silica Dust: Draft Recommendations for a Ventilated Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 12 [billed_pages:protected] => 12 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, vacuum, grinder, mortar, respirator, OSHA, NIOSH, exhaust, Heitbrink, tuckpointer, silica, masonry, dust, silicosis, LEV [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Describes draft recommendations for use of ventilated grinder to reduce dust during tuckpointing and describes field trials using these devices. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/hazard/67/chip-scrape-and-grind-surfaces-or-joints-silica.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001201,d000292,d000293,d000658 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2005 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/27/05 [date_completed:protected] => 04/26/05 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/20/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [1940] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1940 [old_id:protected] => 909 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Workplace Solutions: Control of Hazardous Dust During Tuckpointing [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, silica, dust, tuckpoint, grinder, masonry restoration, mortar, vacuum [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d000819,d000820,d000730,d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 10/24/08 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/09 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [2213] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 2213 [old_id:protected] => 1090 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => [language_id:protected] => 2 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Control del polvo peligroso que se genera durante los procesos de reparación de mortero [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => 2008-126 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => [comments:protected] => http://www.cdc.gov/spanish/niosh/docs/wp-solutions/2008-126_sp/ [summary:protected] => A Workplace Solutions de NIOSH que resume un estudio de NIOSH sobre los riesgos de exposición cuando se reparan las estructuras y los métodos para controlar el polvo. [A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust.] [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => D000819,D000820,D000730,d000819 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 01/07/10 [date_completed:protected] => 04/19/10 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 07/08/12 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [3656] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3656 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001198 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 24 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction While Doing Tuckpointing/Mortar Removal [total_pages:protected] => 2 [billed_pages:protected] => 2 [publication_number:protected] => DSG FS-3632 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Brick, block, tuckpointing, silica, local exhaust ventilation, LEV, masonry [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Tuckpointing creates some of the greatest exposures to silica in construction. This OSHA factsheet provides guidance on how to greatly reduce these exposures through the use of local exhaust ventilation. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863, d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => February 2013 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/04/13 [date_completed:protected] => 03/27/13 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [3899] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3899 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001342 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: Hilti VC40-U Vacuum with Hilti DC-EX Dust Guard and Hilti Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 15 [billed_pages:protected] => 15 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP4 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => silica, tuckpointing, Hilti, local exhaust systems, LEV, shroud, quartz [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This report describes the results of an evaluation of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Hilti VC40-U vacuum, a Hilti DC-EX shroud, and a Hilti DAG-500 grinder. Randomized trials with and without use of the dust control system were conducted in a controlled setting. Removing mortar with the Hilti grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 220 times the National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05mg/m3. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 97 percent. However, exposures measured during the use of the dust control system still exceeded the NIOSH REL. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => December 1, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/05/14 [date_completed:protected] => 02/04/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/06/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [content:protected] => [files:protected] => Array ( [559] => [560] => [546] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 546 [filename:protected] => 3.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:22 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [566] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 566 [filename:protected] => 4.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:23 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [720] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 720 [filename:protected] => 5.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [721] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 721 [filename:protected] => 6.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [722] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 722 [filename:protected] => 7.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [9765] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 9765 [filename:protected] => d001345.pdf [downloadable:protected] => T [timestamp:protected] => 2015-02-09 12:26:04 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3908 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001345 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: DustControl 2900c Vacuum with the ICS Dust Director Shroud and Bosch Grinder Model 1775E Conducted November 14-15, 2012 [total_pages:protected] => 13 [billed_pages:protected] => 13 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP2 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => tuckpointing, HEPA vacuum, dust control, LEV, local exhaust ventilation, silica [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => April 15, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 01/26/15 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/09/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [show_text] => [document_content] => ElcoshItemDocumentContent Object ( [id:protected] => 2934 [item_id:protected] => 3908 [type:protected] => main [title:protected] => [content:protected] =>
Executive Summary
This report describes the results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. It should also be noted that the NIOSH REL is based on exposures averaged over a ten hour work day and our results represent time weighted averages of the sample task duration periods.
Acronyms
ACGIH - American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists
CPWR - CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training
Ce - coefficient of entry
HEPA - high-efficiency particulate air
IUBAC - International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craftworkers
LEV - local exhaust ventilation
PACT - Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies
NIOSH - National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health
OEL - occupational exposure limit
OSHA - Occupational Safety and Health Administration
PAPR - powered air-purifying respirator
PEL - Permissible Exposure Limit
PVC - polyvinyl chloride
REL - Recommended Exposure Limit
RPM - revolutions per minute
TWA - time-weighted average
SP - static pressure
I. Introduction and Background
In 2010 CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training began a four-year project which seeks to identify and evaluate tuckpointing local exhaust ventilation (LEV) systems and disseminate information on their availability and effectiveness. A Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies (PACT) comprised of masonry contractors, representatives from unions, government, equipment manufacturers, and health and safety researcher was formed as part of this project. PACT members participated in identifying important characteristics for control technologies and this information was used to identify LEV systems for tuckpointing using that criteria. Contractor and labor members of the PACT selected specific tuckpointing LEV systems to be considered for evaluation. Each system consisted of a tuckpointing grinder, shroud, and vacuum. This report describes the second of four systems to be evaluated between 2012 the end of 2014, with and without LEV, in a controlled setting to determine effectiveness in silica exposure reduction. This report describes the methods and results of our evaluation of a system consisting of the DustControl 2900c vacuum with the ICS Dust Director shroud and a Bosch Model 1775E grinder.
Excessive exposure to respirable silica can result in silicosis or other silica-related diseases including pulmonary tuberculosis, lung cancer, silicoproteinosis (Lyons et al, 2007) and autoimmune disorders such as rheumatoid arthritis, sarcoidosis and scleroderma (Miller et al, 2012). Respirable silica is generally defined as particles less than 10 micrometers (μm) in aerodynamic diameter (ACGIH, 2013). Silicosis can lead to symptoms including shortness of breath, fatigue, chest pains, susceptibility to infection and possibly death. There is no cure for silicosis, however it is totally preventable. Construction workers exposed to dust, including silica, are also known to have higher rates of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD).
There are many sources of silica in construction that result in exposures of varying intensity among workers. Masonry restoration workers are among the most highly silica-exposed trades in construction. The process of grinding out deteriorated mortar joints between masonry units and replacing or repointing with fresh mortar (often referred to as tuckpointing) is a fundamental part of masonry restoration work. The removal of mortar with powered angle grinders generates enormous levels of dust. Between 2004 and 2006, NIOSH and CPWR evaluated silica exposures while grinding mortar in a controlled setting, at a local training center, where tasks, sample times and task variables were defined by the study design. These studies demonstrated that grinding mortar without controls can result in elevated respirable silica exposures. Meeker et al., (2009) reported exposures between 5 and 25.8 milligrams per cubic meter (mg/m3) in a controlled setting. This study also showed that LEV systems for tuckpointing grinders can reduce exposures to respirable silica by greater than 90 percent.II. Objectives
The objective of this evaluation was to assess the effectiveness of an LEV system for controlling exposure to silica during the grinding of mortar. The control technology was tested under controlled conditions, similar to those experienced by tuckpointers on actual job sites, using journeymen bricklayers experienced in tuckpointing and repeat, randomized trials with and without LEV. All other variables were held constant throughout so that the only variable was whether or not the tested control was used.
III. Description of Equipment Tested
A Bosch model 1775E grinder (Robert Bosch Tool Corporation, Prospect, IL) (Figures 1, 2 and 3) was fitted with a new 1/4-inch wide, 4½-inch diameter segmented diamond abrasive blade made by DeWalt (model #DW4740). The grinder weighs six and a half pounds, draws 8.5 amps and has a variable speed up to 11,000 revolutions per minute (RPMs). The DustControl 2900c vacuum (DustControl, Inc., Wilmington, NC) (Figure 3) was tested in combination with the Dust Director shroud (Industrial Contractors’ Supplies, Inc., Huntingdon, PA) (Figures 1 and 3) attached to the Bosch grinder.
Figure 1. Bosch grinder with Dust Director shroud
Figure 2. Bosch grinder without tuckpointing LEV system.
Figure 3: Bosch Grinder with LEV System
The vacuum is specified to weigh 31 pounds when empty and to provide a flow rate of 114 cubic feet of air per minute and a “static lift” or “vacuum suction pressure” of 84 inches of water. The vacuum is sold with a cyclonic pre-separator, to remove larger particles, a fine filter (rated 99.9 percent efficient) and a HEPA (high-efficiency particulate air) filter (rated to capture 99.97 percent of the particles with an aerodynamic diameter of 0.3 micrometers). The HEPA filter was removed based on the manufacturer’s recommendation due to the heavy dust loading associated with tuckpointing. CPWR sponsored research and contractor experience indicate that HEPA filters likely have an adverse effect on dust capture during tuckpointing because of extreme dust loading on filters. While the cyclone and the fine filter remove most of the dust, especially the large particles, before they reach the HEPA filter, the HEPA filter would still be subject to heavy loading, causing a substantial pressure drop and subsequent decrease in air flow rate. The relatively small increase in the efficiency of the filtration system while using the HEPA filter is expected to be quickly offset by a more significant decrease in capture efficiency as the air flow rate and ability to capture particles decreases.
Dust collects in relatively inexpensive, heavy-gauge plastic bags below and outside of the cyclone. The bags can be removed and replaced without opening the vacuum. Some vacuums are equipped with a light to indicate that the filters need to be cleaned or changed. The DC2900c features a “reverse air pulse cleaning system,” which removes accumulated dust from the filters without having to remove them from the vacuum. The system, as illustrated in Figure 4, requires the operator to disconnect the hose from the shroud, place it over an air stop so that air through the hose is cut off and pressure in the vacuum is maximized.
Figure 4. Procedure for "cleaning" of or dust removal from filters (source: http://dustcontrolusa.com/manuals/2800c.pdf)
The flap covering the port on the side of the vacuum is repeatedly flipped open to release built up pressure in strong pulses that dislodge dust from the filter.
The manufacturer indicates “the filter is generally cleaned once or twice daily during normal continuous operation.” The Dust Director shroud has a 2-inch diameter take-off that was connected to the antistatic, corrugated 1.5-inch diameter, 15-foot long vacuum hose supplied with the DustControl vacuum.
IV. Study Methods
This evaluation was conducted at the International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craft workers (IUBAC) Local 1 Philadelphia/Delaware Training Center in Philadelphia, PA on November 14 and 15, 2012. A single journeyman bricklayer, experienced in tuckpointing, used the grinder and LEV system being tested to remove mortar from joints wide enough to require two passes. The type S mortar had been allowed to cure for at least four weeks. The bricklayer either possessed or was provided with personal protective equipment including sturdy work boots, gloves, hearing protection and a powered air-purifying respirator (PAPR). The PAPR was a 3M GVP system with a bump cap, loose fitting face piece and a HEPA filter (3M, St Paul, MN).
The study was designed to include at least five rounds of sampling during mortar removal. Each round included a trial using the Bosch grinder with a Dust Director shroud and Dust Collector 2900c vacuum and a trial using the Bosch grinder with the factory-supplied guard and without a vacuum. The order of the two trials within each round was randomly selected to minimize bias that might be introduced due to variation associated with environmental factors, equipment operator, blade wear, vacuum performance over time and any other factors unrelated to LEV use. Tools were operated for approximately 16 minutes per trial with controls and for approximately 8 minutes when controls were not used. These times were selected based on the results of previous sampling efforts and estimates of the minimum sample time needed to achieve a limit of quantification low enough to accurately measure exposures down to or less than 0.05 mg/m3 – the NIOSH Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) for respirable silica. The bricklayer was required to take a 5 to 10 minute break in the middle of the 16-minute trials to reduce differences in fatigue, compared to the 8-minute trials. Personal air samples were collected in the breathing zone of the operator during each trial to measure respirable silica concentrations during grinding with and without LEV. The samples were collected using a GilAir-5 pump (Sensidyne, Inc., Clearwater, FL) to draw 4.2 liters of air per minute through a GK2.69 Respirable Cyclone (BGI Inc., Waltham, MA) with a pre-weighed, 37 mm diameter, 5-micron pore size polyvinyl chloride (PVC) filter positioned on the operator’s lapel.
The flow rates of the sampling pumps were calibrated at the beginning of each day using a DryCal DC-Lite Primary Flow Meter (Bios International Corporation, Butler, NJ). Flow rates were measured again near the middle and at the end of each day to ensure that sampling flow rates were maintained within 5% of pre-sampling flow rates throughout the day. Average flow rates were used to calculate sample air volumes. Samples were analyzed by R.J. Lee Group, Inc., (Monroeville, PA) using NIOSH Method 0600, to determine exposure to total mass of respirable dust. The same samples were also analyzed using X-Ray diffraction following NIOSH method 7500 to determine quartz, cristobalite and tridymite concentration in the respirable mass. Reported masses for these analytes were used with the sample air volumes to calculate airborne concentrations of total respirable dust, quartz, cristobalite and tridymite.
We used a reduction of greater than 50 percent in respirable silica exposure concentrations or a reduction to less than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 as our criteria for determining whether or not a control was considered efficacious. This is consistent with criteria used by NIOSH in conducting a similar study in 2004 described by Echt et al. (2007) and by CPWR in 2006 and described by Meeker et al. (2009). The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) and the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) publish additional occupational exposure limits (OELs) for silica which are listed in Table 1 with NIOSH RELs. OELs for silica are based on the respirable fraction of the aerosol, which consists of particles less than 10 micrometers in aerodynamic diameter.
| Organization or Agency | Form of Crystalline Silica | Occupational Exposure Limits (mg/m3) |
|---|---|---|
| NIOSHA | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 |
| OSHA - ConstructionB | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
PEL = 250 / (5 + % quartz) PEL = 250 / (5 + % cristobalite) PEL = 250 / (5 + % tridymite) |
| ACGIH | Crystalline Silica | TLV = 0.025 mg/m3 |
A NIOSH Publication No. 2005-151 indicates 10-hour time-weighted average during a 40-hr workweek B The PEL for silica in OSHA’s Safety and Health Regulations for Construction, 29 C.F.R. 1926.55(a), is an 8-hour time-weighted average (TWA) expressed in millions of particles per cubic foot (mppcf). However, the units mppcf can be converted to milligrams per cubic meter can by dividing mppcf by 10 (OSHA, 2009). The formula used by OSHA to determine the PEL for silica is dependent on the percentage of silica in each collected sample. The concentration of respirable dust measured is compared to the sample specific PEL to determine if the PEL has been exceeded. OSHA has proposed lowering the PEL to 0.05 mg/m3 of respirable silica as an 8 hour TWA. |
||
The flow of air in ventilation systems is governed by fundamental principles that describe the behavior of gases (in this case air). Pressure measurements taken within a ventilation system along with knowledge of hood (or shroud) entry losses can be used to calculate flow rates. Hood entry losses are dependent on the shape and configuration of a particular hood or shroud and described by the term “coefficient of entry (Ce)” which is the ratio of actual air flow through a hood and what the air flow would theoretically be if there were no hood entry losses. Given the coefficient of entry, static pressure measurements can be used to calculate air flow through a given hood. The coefficient of entry for the Dust Director shroud was previously determined by CPWR and used for calculating air flow based on static pressure measurements (Meeker et al., 2009). Static pressure, with the vacuum operating, was measured periodically throughout the evaluation to monitor the changes in air-flow rate following use and again after filter cleaning. The static pressure was measured at a port positioned more than 3 duct diameters downstream from the tool’s air intake using a UEi EM200 Electronic Manometer (Universal Enterprises, Inc., Beaverton, OR).
The dust in the vacuum bag was monitored and, per the manufacturer’s instructions, the bag was changed before the dust level was within 5 centimeters of the valve at the bottom of the vacuum. Each time a vacuum bag was removed, it was weighed to the nearest pound. The bag weights and corresponding grinding durations were used to calculate the average weight of dust collected per unit time. After each trial, cut lengths were measured on the wall to determine total linear feet of vertical (head) and horizontal (bed) joints per unit time.
A Haz-Dust III, Model HD-1003, Real-Time Aerosol Monitor (Environmental Devices Corporation, Plaistow, NH) was used to confirm clearance of dust between trials. The Haz-Dust monitor was positioned on the test wall near the operator at approximately breathing zone level and configured to measure respirable particulate concentration.
V. Results
Personal air monitoring
Five pairs of respirable dust samples were collected while grinding with and without the vacuum system. In addition, three respirable dust samples were collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place. One measurement collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard was shown to be a statistical outlier and was omitted from analysis. Personal air monitoring results for respirable silica and a comparison of average exposures relative to the NIOSH REL for silica (0.05 mg/m3) appears in Table 2. The mean respirable dust levels measured without LEV was 31.4 mg/m3. However, samples collected with LEV were below the limit of quantification (LOQ) which ranged from <1.29 to <1.46 mg/m3. Use of LEV resulted in a greater than 95% reduction in mean respirable dust levels using a mean value with use of LEV of <1.41 (n=5 samples with use of LEV and n=7 without use of LEV). The respirable dust samples collected during grinding without the LEV system contained an average of 24 percent silica. The mass of respirable dust in the samples collected with use of the LEV system was too low to determine the silica content.| Mean, mg/m3 (range) | Std. Dev. | Percent Reduction | Hazard RatioB | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bosch with Dust Director Shroud and DustControl 2900c Vacuum |
0.091 (<0.069 – 0.137) |
0.027 | 98.7 | 1.81 |
| Bosch with no Control | 7.23 (4.57 – 9.90) |
1.94 | NA | 145 |
A n = 5 samples for each tool/control combination and n = 7 samples without the use of the LEV system B Hazard Ratio = measured exposure / NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 |
||||
Average respirable silica and dust exposures, with and without the dust control system, appear as Figures 5 and 6, respectively.
Figure 5. Average respirable silica exposures with and without the Dustcontrol 2900c vacuum and Dust Director shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air - mg/m3)
Figure 6. Average respirable dust exposures with and without Dustcontrol 2900c Vacuum and Dust Director Shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air – mg/m3)
The mean respirable silica concentration measured during use of the control was significantly less than the concentration measured while using the same tool without controls (p<0.01). Grinding mortar with the Bosch angle grinder without dust controls resulted in an average exposure to respirable silica that was 145 times the NIOSH REL. Grinding with the Bosch angle grinder in combination with the Dust Director shroud and the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced the average concentration of respirable silica by 98.7 percent. With use of these controls, the concentration of respirable silica was 1.8 times greater than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3. However the NIOSH REL is based on a time-weighted average (TWA) over a 10-hour workday. Given these were task TWAs and samples were collected over continuous periods of grinding, they may overestimate exposures over an actual work day since some time would be spent performing tasks that would likely have lower, or no, silica exposures (setup, breaks, cleanup, etc.).
Static pressure, dust mass collection and grinding rates.
Static pressure was used as a surrogate for air flow as described earlier. Hood static pressure was measured periodically at a tap near the grinder more than 3 duct diameters from the air intake in the shroud. The static pressure, and thus air flow, was generally higher when the vacuum’s filter had recently been cleaned. The mean, median, and range of calculated flow rates are presented in Table A1 of the Appendix.
Based on the data we collected, the air-flow rate upstream from the Bosch grinder and Dust Director shroud ranged from 78 to 93 cubic feet per minute (cfm) with the DustControl vacuum. When the manufacturer’s filter cleaning procedure was followed the vacuum performed relatively well and flow could be maintained at slightly less than 90 cfm with cleaning. However, mean flow rates dropped substantially to 80 cfm after as little as 8 minutes of grinding without any filter cleaning. The flow rate returned to an average of 89 cfm when filters were cleaned correctly (without stopping air flow to the vacuum). Collingwood and Heitbrink (2007) found that the minimum exhaust flow rate for capture of silica and other particulate under ideal conditions is 21.25 cfm per inch of grinder blade diameter. This is equal to about 96 cfm when using a 4.5 inch diameter grinding blade. We set 106 cfm as the minimum desired flow rate for this study to allow a safety margin for potential decline in equipment performance and the possibility of inadequate maintenance, both of which may be likely after repeated use under actual work conditions. The DustControl vacuum provided slightly less than the minimum flow rate described by Collingwood and Heitbrink for a 4.5-inch blade and the peak flow rate fell with use.
The duration of vacuum bag use and mass of dust collected were recorded and are presented in Table A2 of the Appendix. The vacuum bags were changed and weighed after each trial utilizing the LEV system. A total of five bags were used to complete the five rounds of grinding. The DustControl vacuum captured 45 pounds of dust over 83 minutes of grinding for an average rate of dust collection of 0.54 pounds per minute. The rate of dust collection ranged from 0.47 to 0.63 pounds per minute. Based on these measurements, approximately 130 pounds of dust would likely be captured after just 4 hours of continuous grinding.
The rate of grinding a combination of vertical and horizontal joints while using the LEV system ranged from 2.3 to 3.3 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the use of the LEV system ranged from 2.6 to 3.4 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place ranged from 4.7 to 5.1 feet per minute. It’s important to note that: 1) the operator had limited experience using dust control systems and cut rates appeared to improve slightly over the 2-day period he used the tested equipment; and 2) the upper range of cut rates with the dust control system overlapped with the lowest cut rate with the original guard and without the LEV system in place indicating no statistical difference between cut rates. Given that grinding rates with and without use of this LEV system are only available for one operator and he had limited experience with the LEV system, these reported cut rates are in no way intended to represent the impact use of this LEV system is likely to have on productivity rates overall.
VI. Discussion
The objective of these trials was to evaluate the effectiveness of a tuckpointing LEV system for controlling respirable silica while grinding out mortar joints. The Dust Director shroud with the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced respirable silica concentrations when grinding with the Bosch grinder by approximately 99 percent. Despite being considered effective by our test criteria (greater than 50% reduction), it still resulted in task TWA exposures that exceeded the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 by 1.8 times. Depending on how much time is spent grinding over the course of a work day and on exposures while performing other tasks, the 8-hour TWA exposures may or may not exceed the REL with this system. Use of this system by workers with experience and training in proficient use will likely improve dust capture performance. Exposure reduction is greatly influenced by correct use of this system which includes grinding from right to left, making sure the shroud is held flush against the wall and that the tool travels at a pace that doesn’t exceed the ability of the system to capture dust as it’s generated. Deviation from any of these measures produces visible dust clouds which were observed during trials.
VII. Conclusions
With a 99 percent reduction in respirable silica exposure, the Dust Director shroud and DustControl 2900c vacuum with a Bosch Model 1775E grinder was effective in reducing silica exposures based on our criteria. Use of the tested dust control system may be effective in reducing silica exposure on the job to less than the NIOSH REL if used in combination with administrative controls such as work scheduling to reduce cutting times as needed. Training on correct use of the tested system is also essential. Personal air monitoring is necessary to verify control effectiveness on actual job sites and under “real-world” conditions. However, these results clearly demonstrate the availability of viable and effective engineering controls for tuckpointing operations associated with elevated silica exposure.
VIII. References
American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists. Threshold limit values for chemical substances (TLV®-CS). [2013]. ACGIH, Cincinnati, Ohio.
Bergdahl I.A,. Toren K., Eriksson K., et al. [2004]. Increased mortality in COPD among construction workers exposed to inorganic dust. European Respiratory Journal, 23: 402–06.
Blanc P.D. & Torén K. [2007]. Occupation in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and chronic bronchitis: an update [State of the Art Series. Occupational lung disease in high-and low-income countries, Edited by M. Chan-Yeung. Number 2 in the series]. The International Journal of Tuberculosis and Lung Disease, 11(3), 251-257.
Collingwood S. & Heitbrink W.A. [2007] 'Field Evaluation of an Engineering Control for Respirable Crystalline Silica Exposures During Mortar Removal'. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, 4:11, 875 – 887.
DHHS (NIOSH) Publication No. 2002-129 April 2002 http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/2002-129/
Echt A., Sieber W.K., Lefkowitz D., Meeker J., Susi P., Cardwell B., Heitbrink, W.A. In-depth survey of dust control technology for cutting concrete block and tuckpointing brick at The International Masonry Institute Bordentown Training Center, Bordentown, NJ. Cincinnati, OH: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Report. No. EPHB 282-13; 2007. http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ECTB-282-13.pdf
Heitbrink W., Bennett J. [2006]. A numerical and experimental investigation of crystalline silica exposure control during tuck pointing. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, Vol. 3, pp 366-378.
Lyons et al, [2007]. A breathless builder. Breathe, Vol. 3, no. 4, pp 386-390.
Mastrangelo G., Tartari M., Fedeli U., Fadda E., Saia B. [2003]. Ascertaining the risk of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease in relation to occupation using a case-control design. Occupational Medicine, 53: 165–172.
Meeker J., Cooper M., Lefrowitz D., Susi P. [2009]. Engineering control technologies to reduce occupational silica exposures in masonry cutting and tuckpointing. Public Health Reports, Supplement 1, Vol. 124, June.
Meeker J, Flynn M, Susi P, Cardwell, B [2004]. Performance evaluation of a masonry concrete vacuum. Unpublished Report.
Miller F. W., Alfredsson L., Costenbader K. H., Kamen D. L., Nelson L. M., Norris J. M., & De Roos A. J. [2012]. Epidemiology of environmental exposures and human autoimmune diseases: findings from a National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences Expert Panel workshop. Journal of autoimmunity. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3496812/
Occupational Safety and Health Administration U.S Department of Labor. Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction. [2009]. OSHA 3362-05.
Rappaport SM, Goldberg M, Susi P, Herrick RF [2003]. Excessive exposure to silica in the U.S. construction industry. Annals of Occupational Hygiene, Vol. 47, pp. 111-122.
IX. Appendices
| Measurement Conditions |
n | Mean Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Median
Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before filter cleaning | 5 | 80 | 81 | 78-81 |
| After filter cleaning following manufacturer directions | 9 | 89 | 90 | 84-93 |
| * Static pressure was measured in millibars and converted to inches of water gauge. Flow rates were calculated using the formula Q = Ce (A) 4005 (SP)1/2 where: Q = flow in cubic feet per minute (cfm), Ce = coefficient of entry, A = area of the duct where static pressure measurements were taken in square feet, and SP = static pressure in inches of water gauge. | ||||
| Tool/Control | Collection Period (min.) |
Dust Collection Rate (lb/min.) |
|---|---|---|
| Bosch grinder/Dust Director shroud & DustControl 2900c vacuum |
8 11 8 8 10 |
0.50 0.61 0.50 0.47 0.63 |
| Average | 0.54 |
[content_transformed:protected] =>
Executive Summary
This report describes the results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. It should also be noted that the NIOSH REL is based on exposures averaged over a ten hour work day and our results represent time weighted averages of the sample task duration periods.
Acronyms
ACGIH - American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists
CPWR - CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training
Ce - coefficient of entry
HEPA - high-efficiency particulate air
IUBAC - International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craftworkers
LEV - local exhaust ventilation
PACT - Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies
NIOSH - National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health
OEL - occupational exposure limit
OSHA - Occupational Safety and Health Administration
PAPR - powered air-purifying respirator
PEL - Permissible Exposure Limit
PVC - polyvinyl chloride
REL - Recommended Exposure Limit
RPM - revolutions per minute
TWA - time-weighted average
SP - static pressure
I. Introduction and Background
In 2010 CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training began a four-year project which seeks to identify and evaluate tuckpointing local exhaust ventilation (LEV) systems and disseminate information on their availability and effectiveness. A Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies (PACT) comprised of masonry contractors, representatives from unions, government, equipment manufacturers, and health and safety researcher was formed as part of this project. PACT members participated in identifying important characteristics for control technologies and this information was used to identify LEV systems for tuckpointing using that criteria. Contractor and labor members of the PACT selected specific tuckpointing LEV systems to be considered for evaluation. Each system consisted of a tuckpointing grinder, shroud, and vacuum. This report describes the second of four systems to be evaluated between 2012 the end of 2014, with and without LEV, in a controlled setting to determine effectiveness in silica exposure reduction. This report describes the methods and results of our evaluation of a system consisting of the DustControl 2900c vacuum with the ICS Dust Director shroud and a Bosch Model 1775E grinder.
Excessive exposure to respirable silica can result in silicosis or other silica-related diseases including pulmonary tuberculosis, lung cancer, silicoproteinosis (Lyons et al, 2007) and autoimmune disorders such as rheumatoid arthritis, sarcoidosis and scleroderma (Miller et al, 2012). Respirable silica is generally defined as particles less than 10 micrometers (μm) in aerodynamic diameter (ACGIH, 2013). Silicosis can lead to symptoms including shortness of breath, fatigue, chest pains, susceptibility to infection and possibly death. There is no cure for silicosis, however it is totally preventable. Construction workers exposed to dust, including silica, are also known to have higher rates of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD).
There are many sources of silica in construction that result in exposures of varying intensity among workers. Masonry restoration workers are among the most highly silica-exposed trades in construction. The process of grinding out deteriorated mortar joints between masonry units and replacing or repointing with fresh mortar (often referred to as tuckpointing) is a fundamental part of masonry restoration work. The removal of mortar with powered angle grinders generates enormous levels of dust. Between 2004 and 2006, NIOSH and CPWR evaluated silica exposures while grinding mortar in a controlled setting, at a local training center, where tasks, sample times and task variables were defined by the study design. These studies demonstrated that grinding mortar without controls can result in elevated respirable silica exposures. Meeker et al., (2009) reported exposures between 5 and 25.8 milligrams per cubic meter (mg/m3) in a controlled setting. This study also showed that LEV systems for tuckpointing grinders can reduce exposures to respirable silica by greater than 90 percent.II. Objectives
The objective of this evaluation was to assess the effectiveness of an LEV system for controlling exposure to silica during the grinding of mortar. The control technology was tested under controlled conditions, similar to those experienced by tuckpointers on actual job sites, using journeymen bricklayers experienced in tuckpointing and repeat, randomized trials with and without LEV. All other variables were held constant throughout so that the only variable was whether or not the tested control was used.
III. Description of Equipment Tested
A Bosch model 1775E grinder (Robert Bosch Tool Corporation, Prospect, IL) (Figures 1, 2 and 3) was fitted with a new 1/4-inch wide, 4½-inch diameter segmented diamond abrasive blade made by DeWalt (model #DW4740). The grinder weighs six and a half pounds, draws 8.5 amps and has a variable speed up to 11,000 revolutions per minute (RPMs). The DustControl 2900c vacuum (DustControl, Inc., Wilmington, NC) (Figure 3) was tested in combination with the Dust Director shroud (Industrial Contractors’ Supplies, Inc., Huntingdon, PA) (Figures 1 and 3) attached to the Bosch grinder.
Figure 1. Bosch grinder with Dust Director shroud
Figure 2. Bosch grinder without tuckpointing LEV system.
Figure 3: Bosch Grinder with LEV System
The vacuum is specified to weigh 31 pounds when empty and to provide a flow rate of 114 cubic feet of air per minute and a “static lift” or “vacuum suction pressure” of 84 inches of water. The vacuum is sold with a cyclonic pre-separator, to remove larger particles, a fine filter (rated 99.9 percent efficient) and a HEPA (high-efficiency particulate air) filter (rated to capture 99.97 percent of the particles with an aerodynamic diameter of 0.3 micrometers). The HEPA filter was removed based on the manufacturer’s recommendation due to the heavy dust loading associated with tuckpointing. CPWR sponsored research and contractor experience indicate that HEPA filters likely have an adverse effect on dust capture during tuckpointing because of extreme dust loading on filters. While the cyclone and the fine filter remove most of the dust, especially the large particles, before they reach the HEPA filter, the HEPA filter would still be subject to heavy loading, causing a substantial pressure drop and subsequent decrease in air flow rate. The relatively small increase in the efficiency of the filtration system while using the HEPA filter is expected to be quickly offset by a more significant decrease in capture efficiency as the air flow rate and ability to capture particles decreases.
Dust collects in relatively inexpensive, heavy-gauge plastic bags below and outside of the cyclone. The bags can be removed and replaced without opening the vacuum. Some vacuums are equipped with a light to indicate that the filters need to be cleaned or changed. The DC2900c features a “reverse air pulse cleaning system,” which removes accumulated dust from the filters without having to remove them from the vacuum. The system, as illustrated in Figure 4, requires the operator to disconnect the hose from the shroud, place it over an air stop so that air through the hose is cut off and pressure in the vacuum is maximized.
Figure 4. Procedure for "cleaning" of or dust removal from filters (source: http://dustcontrolusa.com/manuals/2800c.pdf)
The flap covering the port on the side of the vacuum is repeatedly flipped open to release built up pressure in strong pulses that dislodge dust from the filter.
The manufacturer indicates “the filter is generally cleaned once or twice daily during normal continuous operation.” The Dust Director shroud has a 2-inch diameter take-off that was connected to the antistatic, corrugated 1.5-inch diameter, 15-foot long vacuum hose supplied with the DustControl vacuum.
IV. Study Methods
This evaluation was conducted at the International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craft workers (IUBAC) Local 1 Philadelphia/Delaware Training Center in Philadelphia, PA on November 14 and 15, 2012. A single journeyman bricklayer, experienced in tuckpointing, used the grinder and LEV system being tested to remove mortar from joints wide enough to require two passes. The type S mortar had been allowed to cure for at least four weeks. The bricklayer either possessed or was provided with personal protective equipment including sturdy work boots, gloves, hearing protection and a powered air-purifying respirator (PAPR). The PAPR was a 3M GVP system with a bump cap, loose fitting face piece and a HEPA filter (3M, St Paul, MN).
The study was designed to include at least five rounds of sampling during mortar removal. Each round included a trial using the Bosch grinder with a Dust Director shroud and Dust Collector 2900c vacuum and a trial using the Bosch grinder with the factory-supplied guard and without a vacuum. The order of the two trials within each round was randomly selected to minimize bias that might be introduced due to variation associated with environmental factors, equipment operator, blade wear, vacuum performance over time and any other factors unrelated to LEV use. Tools were operated for approximately 16 minutes per trial with controls and for approximately 8 minutes when controls were not used. These times were selected based on the results of previous sampling efforts and estimates of the minimum sample time needed to achieve a limit of quantification low enough to accurately measure exposures down to or less than 0.05 mg/m3 – the NIOSH Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) for respirable silica. The bricklayer was required to take a 5 to 10 minute break in the middle of the 16-minute trials to reduce differences in fatigue, compared to the 8-minute trials. Personal air samples were collected in the breathing zone of the operator during each trial to measure respirable silica concentrations during grinding with and without LEV. The samples were collected using a GilAir-5 pump (Sensidyne, Inc., Clearwater, FL) to draw 4.2 liters of air per minute through a GK2.69 Respirable Cyclone (BGI Inc., Waltham, MA) with a pre-weighed, 37 mm diameter, 5-micron pore size polyvinyl chloride (PVC) filter positioned on the operator’s lapel.
The flow rates of the sampling pumps were calibrated at the beginning of each day using a DryCal DC-Lite Primary Flow Meter (Bios International Corporation, Butler, NJ). Flow rates were measured again near the middle and at the end of each day to ensure that sampling flow rates were maintained within 5% of pre-sampling flow rates throughout the day. Average flow rates were used to calculate sample air volumes. Samples were analyzed by R.J. Lee Group, Inc., (Monroeville, PA) using NIOSH Method 0600, to determine exposure to total mass of respirable dust. The same samples were also analyzed using X-Ray diffraction following NIOSH method 7500 to determine quartz, cristobalite and tridymite concentration in the respirable mass. Reported masses for these analytes were used with the sample air volumes to calculate airborne concentrations of total respirable dust, quartz, cristobalite and tridymite.
We used a reduction of greater than 50 percent in respirable silica exposure concentrations or a reduction to less than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 as our criteria for determining whether or not a control was considered efficacious. This is consistent with criteria used by NIOSH in conducting a similar study in 2004 described by Echt et al. (2007) and by CPWR in 2006 and described by Meeker et al. (2009). The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) and the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) publish additional occupational exposure limits (OELs) for silica which are listed in Table 1 with NIOSH RELs. OELs for silica are based on the respirable fraction of the aerosol, which consists of particles less than 10 micrometers in aerodynamic diameter.
| Organization or Agency | Form of Crystalline Silica | Occupational Exposure Limits (mg/m3) |
|---|---|---|
| NIOSHA | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 |
| OSHA - ConstructionB | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
PEL = 250 / (5 + % quartz) PEL = 250 / (5 + % cristobalite) PEL = 250 / (5 + % tridymite) |
| ACGIH | Crystalline Silica | TLV = 0.025 mg/m3 |
A NIOSH Publication No. 2005-151 indicates 10-hour time-weighted average during a 40-hr workweek B The PEL for silica in OSHA’s Safety and Health Regulations for Construction, 29 C.F.R. 1926.55(a), is an 8-hour time-weighted average (TWA) expressed in millions of particles per cubic foot (mppcf). However, the units mppcf can be converted to milligrams per cubic meter can by dividing mppcf by 10 (OSHA, 2009). The formula used by OSHA to determine the PEL for silica is dependent on the percentage of silica in each collected sample. The concentration of respirable dust measured is compared to the sample specific PEL to determine if the PEL has been exceeded. OSHA has proposed lowering the PEL to 0.05 mg/m3 of respirable silica as an 8 hour TWA. |
||
The flow of air in ventilation systems is governed by fundamental principles that describe the behavior of gases (in this case air). Pressure measurements taken within a ventilation system along with knowledge of hood (or shroud) entry losses can be used to calculate flow rates. Hood entry losses are dependent on the shape and configuration of a particular hood or shroud and described by the term “coefficient of entry (Ce)” which is the ratio of actual air flow through a hood and what the air flow would theoretically be if there were no hood entry losses. Given the coefficient of entry, static pressure measurements can be used to calculate air flow through a given hood. The coefficient of entry for the Dust Director shroud was previously determined by CPWR and used for calculating air flow based on static pressure measurements (Meeker et al., 2009). Static pressure, with the vacuum operating, was measured periodically throughout the evaluation to monitor the changes in air-flow rate following use and again after filter cleaning. The static pressure was measured at a port positioned more than 3 duct diameters downstream from the tool’s air intake using a UEi EM200 Electronic Manometer (Universal Enterprises, Inc., Beaverton, OR).
The dust in the vacuum bag was monitored and, per the manufacturer’s instructions, the bag was changed before the dust level was within 5 centimeters of the valve at the bottom of the vacuum. Each time a vacuum bag was removed, it was weighed to the nearest pound. The bag weights and corresponding grinding durations were used to calculate the average weight of dust collected per unit time. After each trial, cut lengths were measured on the wall to determine total linear feet of vertical (head) and horizontal (bed) joints per unit time.
A Haz-Dust III, Model HD-1003, Real-Time Aerosol Monitor (Environmental Devices Corporation, Plaistow, NH) was used to confirm clearance of dust between trials. The Haz-Dust monitor was positioned on the test wall near the operator at approximately breathing zone level and configured to measure respirable particulate concentration.
V. Results
Personal air monitoring
Five pairs of respirable dust samples were collected while grinding with and without the vacuum system. In addition, three respirable dust samples were collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place. One measurement collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard was shown to be a statistical outlier and was omitted from analysis. Personal air monitoring results for respirable silica and a comparison of average exposures relative to the NIOSH REL for silica (0.05 mg/m3) appears in Table 2. The mean respirable dust levels measured without LEV was 31.4 mg/m3. However, samples collected with LEV were below the limit of quantification (LOQ) which ranged from <1.29 to <1.46 mg/m3. Use of LEV resulted in a greater than 95% reduction in mean respirable dust levels using a mean value with use of LEV of <1.41 (n=5 samples with use of LEV and n=7 without use of LEV). The respirable dust samples collected during grinding without the LEV system contained an average of 24 percent silica. The mass of respirable dust in the samples collected with use of the LEV system was too low to determine the silica content.| Mean, mg/m3 (range) | Std. Dev. | Percent Reduction | Hazard RatioB | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bosch with Dust Director Shroud and DustControl 2900c Vacuum |
0.091 (<0.069 – 0.137) |
0.027 | 98.7 | 1.81 |
| Bosch with no Control | 7.23 (4.57 – 9.90) |
1.94 | NA | 145 |
A n = 5 samples for each tool/control combination and n = 7 samples without the use of the LEV system B Hazard Ratio = measured exposure / NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 |
||||
Average respirable silica and dust exposures, with and without the dust control system, appear as Figures 5 and 6, respectively.
Figure 5. Average respirable silica exposures with and without the Dustcontrol 2900c vacuum and Dust Director shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air - mg/m3)
Figure 6. Average respirable dust exposures with and without Dustcontrol 2900c Vacuum and Dust Director Shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air – mg/m3)
The mean respirable silica concentration measured during use of the control was significantly less than the concentration measured while using the same tool without controls (p<0.01). Grinding mortar with the Bosch angle grinder without dust controls resulted in an average exposure to respirable silica that was 145 times the NIOSH REL. Grinding with the Bosch angle grinder in combination with the Dust Director shroud and the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced the average concentration of respirable silica by 98.7 percent. With use of these controls, the concentration of respirable silica was 1.8 times greater than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3. However the NIOSH REL is based on a time-weighted average (TWA) over a 10-hour workday. Given these were task TWAs and samples were collected over continuous periods of grinding, they may overestimate exposures over an actual work day since some time would be spent performing tasks that would likely have lower, or no, silica exposures (setup, breaks, cleanup, etc.).
Static pressure, dust mass collection and grinding rates.
Static pressure was used as a surrogate for air flow as described earlier. Hood static pressure was measured periodically at a tap near the grinder more than 3 duct diameters from the air intake in the shroud. The static pressure, and thus air flow, was generally higher when the vacuum’s filter had recently been cleaned. The mean, median, and range of calculated flow rates are presented in Table A1 of the Appendix.
Based on the data we collected, the air-flow rate upstream from the Bosch grinder and Dust Director shroud ranged from 78 to 93 cubic feet per minute (cfm) with the DustControl vacuum. When the manufacturer’s filter cleaning procedure was followed the vacuum performed relatively well and flow could be maintained at slightly less than 90 cfm with cleaning. However, mean flow rates dropped substantially to 80 cfm after as little as 8 minutes of grinding without any filter cleaning. The flow rate returned to an average of 89 cfm when filters were cleaned correctly (without stopping air flow to the vacuum). Collingwood and Heitbrink (2007) found that the minimum exhaust flow rate for capture of silica and other particulate under ideal conditions is 21.25 cfm per inch of grinder blade diameter. This is equal to about 96 cfm when using a 4.5 inch diameter grinding blade. We set 106 cfm as the minimum desired flow rate for this study to allow a safety margin for potential decline in equipment performance and the possibility of inadequate maintenance, both of which may be likely after repeated use under actual work conditions. The DustControl vacuum provided slightly less than the minimum flow rate described by Collingwood and Heitbrink for a 4.5-inch blade and the peak flow rate fell with use.
The duration of vacuum bag use and mass of dust collected were recorded and are presented in Table A2 of the Appendix. The vacuum bags were changed and weighed after each trial utilizing the LEV system. A total of five bags were used to complete the five rounds of grinding. The DustControl vacuum captured 45 pounds of dust over 83 minutes of grinding for an average rate of dust collection of 0.54 pounds per minute. The rate of dust collection ranged from 0.47 to 0.63 pounds per minute. Based on these measurements, approximately 130 pounds of dust would likely be captured after just 4 hours of continuous grinding.
The rate of grinding a combination of vertical and horizontal joints while using the LEV system ranged from 2.3 to 3.3 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the use of the LEV system ranged from 2.6 to 3.4 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place ranged from 4.7 to 5.1 feet per minute. It’s important to note that: 1) the operator had limited experience using dust control systems and cut rates appeared to improve slightly over the 2-day period he used the tested equipment; and 2) the upper range of cut rates with the dust control system overlapped with the lowest cut rate with the original guard and without the LEV system in place indicating no statistical difference between cut rates. Given that grinding rates with and without use of this LEV system are only available for one operator and he had limited experience with the LEV system, these reported cut rates are in no way intended to represent the impact use of this LEV system is likely to have on productivity rates overall.
VI. Discussion
The objective of these trials was to evaluate the effectiveness of a tuckpointing LEV system for controlling respirable silica while grinding out mortar joints. The Dust Director shroud with the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced respirable silica concentrations when grinding with the Bosch grinder by approximately 99 percent. Despite being considered effective by our test criteria (greater than 50% reduction), it still resulted in task TWA exposures that exceeded the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 by 1.8 times. Depending on how much time is spent grinding over the course of a work day and on exposures while performing other tasks, the 8-hour TWA exposures may or may not exceed the REL with this system. Use of this system by workers with experience and training in proficient use will likely improve dust capture performance. Exposure reduction is greatly influenced by correct use of this system which includes grinding from right to left, making sure the shroud is held flush against the wall and that the tool travels at a pace that doesn’t exceed the ability of the system to capture dust as it’s generated. Deviation from any of these measures produces visible dust clouds which were observed during trials.
VII. Conclusions
With a 99 percent reduction in respirable silica exposure, the Dust Director shroud and DustControl 2900c vacuum with a Bosch Model 1775E grinder was effective in reducing silica exposures based on our criteria. Use of the tested dust control system may be effective in reducing silica exposure on the job to less than the NIOSH REL if used in combination with administrative controls such as work scheduling to reduce cutting times as needed. Training on correct use of the tested system is also essential. Personal air monitoring is necessary to verify control effectiveness on actual job sites and under “real-world” conditions. However, these results clearly demonstrate the availability of viable and effective engineering controls for tuckpointing operations associated with elevated silica exposure.
VIII. References
American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists. Threshold limit values for chemical substances (TLV®-CS). [2013]. ACGIH, Cincinnati, Ohio.
Bergdahl I.A,. Toren K., Eriksson K., et al. [2004]. Increased mortality in COPD among construction workers exposed to inorganic dust. European Respiratory Journal, 23: 402–06.
Blanc P.D. & Torén K. [2007]. Occupation in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and chronic bronchitis: an update [State of the Art Series. Occupational lung disease in high-and low-income countries, Edited by M. Chan-Yeung. Number 2 in the series]. The International Journal of Tuberculosis and Lung Disease, 11(3), 251-257.
Collingwood S. & Heitbrink W.A. [2007] 'Field Evaluation of an Engineering Control for Respirable Crystalline Silica Exposures During Mortar Removal'. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, 4:11, 875 – 887.
DHHS (NIOSH) Publication No. 2002-129 April 2002 http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/2002-129/
Echt A., Sieber W.K., Lefkowitz D., Meeker J., Susi P., Cardwell B., Heitbrink, W.A. In-depth survey of dust control technology for cutting concrete block and tuckpointing brick at The International Masonry Institute Bordentown Training Center, Bordentown, NJ. Cincinnati, OH: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Report. No. EPHB 282-13; 2007. http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ECTB-282-13.pdf
Heitbrink W., Bennett J. [2006]. A numerical and experimental investigation of crystalline silica exposure control during tuck pointing. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, Vol. 3, pp 366-378.
Lyons et al, [2007]. A breathless builder. Breathe, Vol. 3, no. 4, pp 386-390.
Mastrangelo G., Tartari M., Fedeli U., Fadda E., Saia B. [2003]. Ascertaining the risk of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease in relation to occupation using a case-control design. Occupational Medicine, 53: 165–172.
Meeker J., Cooper M., Lefrowitz D., Susi P. [2009]. Engineering control technologies to reduce occupational silica exposures in masonry cutting and tuckpointing. Public Health Reports, Supplement 1, Vol. 124, June.
Meeker J, Flynn M, Susi P, Cardwell, B [2004]. Performance evaluation of a masonry concrete vacuum. Unpublished Report.
Miller F. W., Alfredsson L., Costenbader K. H., Kamen D. L., Nelson L. M., Norris J. M., & De Roos A. J. [2012]. Epidemiology of environmental exposures and human autoimmune diseases: findings from a National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences Expert Panel workshop. Journal of autoimmunity. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3496812/
Occupational Safety and Health Administration U.S Department of Labor. Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction. [2009]. OSHA 3362-05.
Rappaport SM, Goldberg M, Susi P, Herrick RF [2003]. Excessive exposure to silica in the U.S. construction industry. Annals of Occupational Hygiene, Vol. 47, pp. 111-122.
IX. Appendices
| Measurement Conditions |
n | Mean Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Median
Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before filter cleaning | 5 | 80 | 81 | 78-81 |
| After filter cleaning following manufacturer directions | 9 | 89 | 90 | 84-93 |
| * Static pressure was measured in millibars and converted to inches of water gauge. Flow rates were calculated using the formula Q = Ce (A) 4005 (SP)1/2 where: Q = flow in cubic feet per minute (cfm), Ce = coefficient of entry, A = area of the duct where static pressure measurements were taken in square feet, and SP = static pressure in inches of water gauge. | ||||
| Tool/Control | Collection Period (min.) |
Dust Collection Rate (lb/min.) |
|---|---|---|
| Bosch grinder/Dust Director shroud & DustControl 2900c vacuum |
8 11 8 8 10 |
0.50 0.61 0.50 0.47 0.63 |
| Average | 0.54 |
[disclaimer:protected] => [disclaimer_transformed:protected] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [template] => record [collection] => ) [_file] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/templates/elcosh/record.html [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_encoding:protected] => UTF-8 [_outputMode:protected] => 11 [_forceReparse:protected] => [_phpCodeDestination:protected] => /tmp/ [_phpCodeExtension:protected] => php [_cacheLifetime:protected] => 30 [_cachePurgeFrequency:protected] => 30 [externalMacroTemplatesCache:PHPTAL:private] => Array ( [macros.html] => PHPTAL Object ( [_prefilters:protected] => Array ( ) [_prefilter:PHPTAL:private] => REMOVED: DO NOT USE [_postfilter:protected] => [_repositories:protected] => Array ( [0] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/templates/elcosh ) [_path:protected] => macros.html [_resolvers:protected] => Array ( ) [_source:protected] => PHPTAL_FileSource Object ( [_path:PHPTAL_FileSource:private] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/templates/elcosh/macros.html ) [_codeFile:protected] => /tmp/tpl_61515a6c_macros__EnKHR8AWVA3oW7OmomvoZw.php [_functionName:protected] => tpl_61515a6c_macros__EnKHR8AWVA3oW7OmomvoZw [_prepared:protected] => 1 [_triggers:protected] => Array ( ) [_translator:protected] => [_globalContext:protected] => stdClass Object ( ) [_context:protected] => PHPTAL_Context Object ( [_line] => [_file] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/templates/elcosh/record.html [repeat] => stdClass Object ( ) [_xmlDeclaration] => [_docType] => [_nothrow:PHPTAL_Context:private] => [_slots:PHPTAL_Context:private] => Array ( ) [_slotsStack:PHPTAL_Context:private] => Array ( [0] => Array ( ) [1] => Array ( ) ) [_parentContext:PHPTAL_Context:private] => PHPTAL_Context Object ( [_line] => [_file] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/templates/elcosh/record.html [repeat] => stdClass Object ( ) [_xmlDeclaration] => [_docType] => [_nothrow:PHPTAL_Context:private] => [_slots:PHPTAL_Context:private] => Array ( ) [_slotsStack:PHPTAL_Context:private] => Array ( [0] => Array ( ) [1] => Array ( ) ) [_parentContext:PHPTAL_Context:private] => [_globalContext:PHPTAL_Context:private] => stdClass Object ( ) [_echoDeclarations:PHPTAL_Context:private] => [referer] => http://www.elcosh.org/document/3908/d001345/An%2BEvaluation%2Bof%2BSilica%2BExposure%2BControls%2Bfor%2BTuckpointing%253A%2BDustControl%2B2900c%2BVacuum%2Bwith%2Bthe%2BICS%2BDust%2BDirector%2BShroud%2Band%2BBosch%2BGrinder%2BModel%2B1775E%2BConducted%2BNovember%2B14-15%252C%2B2012.html [curr_module] => Record [styles] => Array ( ) [javascript] => Array ( [0] => jquery.min.js ) [metas] => Array ( [language] => en [robots] => index, follow ) [user] => [curr_url] => https://www.elcosh.org/index.php?module=Record&id=3908&type=document [base_url] => https://www.elcosh.org/index.php?module=Record [title] => eLCOSH : An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: DustControl 2900c Vacuum with the ICS Dust Director Shroud and Bosch Grinder Model 1775E Conducted November 14-15, 2012 [language] => en [search_query] => [module] => Record [new_records] => Array ( [0] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Fixed Ladder [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Fixed Ladders addresses the potential risks associated with using fixed ladders. The resource includes a brief case example,... [category] => Array ( [0] => 15 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 53 [5] => 55 [6] => 60 [7] => 64 [8] => 73 [9] => 76 [10] => 78 [11] => 80 [12] => 86 [13] => 87 [14] => 90 [15] => 92 [16] => 93 [17] => 94 [18] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Falls [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Concrete Polisher [11] => Electrical Worker [13] => HVAC [15] => Laborer [17] => PCC/Restoration [19] => Plumber/Pipefitter [21] => Roofer/Waterproofer [23] => Sheetmetal Worker [25] => Welder [27] => Commercial & Institutional [28] => Jobsites [29] => Industrial [31] => LEED/Green Construction [33] => Renovations [35] => Residential [37] => Toolbox Talks [38] => Documents [39] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4430/d001660/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BFixed%2BLadder.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [53] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 53 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Concrete Polisher [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [73] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 73 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => PCC/Restoration [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4430 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001660 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Fixed Ladder [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Fixed Ladders, Fall Prevention, Falls [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Fixed Ladders addresses the potential risks associated with using fixed ladders. The resource includes a brief case example, steps to prevent a related injury and questions for discussion. It includes an image that illustrates the hazard, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001257,d001254,d001255,d001256,d001258,d001262,d001279 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_completed:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/22/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [1] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Challenges Preventing Falling Objects [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Challenges Preventing Falling Objects addresses the hazards of being struck by falling objects on the job site. The resource... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 55 [5] => 64 [6] => 68 [7] => 71 [8] => 75 [9] => 78 [10] => 79 [11] => 82 [12] => 62 [13] => 86 [14] => 87 [15] => 88 [16] => 89 [17] => 91 [18] => 90 [19] => 92 [20] => 93 [21] => 94 [22] => 95 [23] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Electrical Worker [11] => Laborer [13] => Maintenance Worker [15] => Painter [17] => Plasterer [19] => Roofer/Waterproofer [21] => Scaffold Erector [23] => Stonemason [25] => Structural Ironworker [27] => Welder [29] => Commercial & Institutional [30] => Jobsites [31] => Demolition [33] => Disasters [35] => Heavy & Highway [37] => Industrial [39] => LEED/Green Construction [41] => Renovations [43] => Residential [45] => Underground [47] => Toolbox Talks [48] => Documents [49] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4431/d001661/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BChallenges%2BPreventing%2BFalling%2BObjects.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4431 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001661 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Challenges Preventing Falling Objects [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => dropped objects, falling objects, struck by incidents, struck by fatalities [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Challenges Preventing Falling Objects addresses the hazards of being struck by falling objects on the job site. The resource includes a brief example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates a group workers observing a scaffold free of debris during high winds, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001234,d001238,d001244,d001251,d001253,d001260,d001268,d001278 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_completed:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/22/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [2] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Tower Crane Safety [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Tower Crane Safety addresses the potential hazards of Tower Cranes and the importance of following procedure before and durin... [category] => Array ( [0] => 11 [1] => 12 [2] => 18 [3] => 70 [4] => 87 [5] => 88 [6] => 91 [7] => 90 [8] => 92 [9] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Cranes & Hoists [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Crushed/Struck By [6] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [9] => Operating Engineer [10] => Trades [11] => Commercial & Institutional [12] => Jobsites [13] => Demolition [15] => Heavy & Highway [17] => Industrial [19] => LEED/Green Construction [21] => Toolbox Talks [22] => Documents [23] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4427/d001657/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BTower%2BCrane%2BSafety.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [11] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 11 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Cranes & Hoists [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [18] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 18 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4427 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001657 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Tower Crane Safety [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Tower Crane, Crane, Stability, Tipping, Lift Zone Safety, Lift, Zone, Safety, Struck by [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Tower Crane Safety addresses the potential hazards of Tower Cranes and the importance of following procedure before and during Tower Crane operation. The resource includes a brief example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates a worker inspecting a Tower Crane before operation, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001234,d001238,d001250,d001251,d001253,d001258,d001262,d001273 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/19/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [3] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Work Zone Safety: Working Around Vehicles [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Working Around Vehicles in the Work Zone addresses methods to avoid being struck-by a vehicle on a construction site. The res... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 18 [2] => 52 [3] => 57 [4] => 70 [5] => 85 [6] => 87 [7] => 88 [8] => 89 [9] => 91 [10] => 90 [11] => 92 [12] => 93 [13] => 94 [14] => 95 [15] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [6] => Commercial Diver [7] => Trades [8] => Flagger [10] => Operating Engineer [12] => Truck Driver [14] => Commercial & Institutional [15] => Jobsites [16] => Demolition [18] => Disasters [20] => Heavy & Highway [22] => Industrial [24] => LEED/Green Construction [26] => Renovations [28] => Residential [30] => Underground [32] => Toolbox Talks [33] => Documents [34] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4428/d001658/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BWork%2BZone%2BSafety%253A%2BWorking%2BAround%2BVehicles.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [18] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 18 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [52] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 52 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Commercial Diver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [85] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 85 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Truck Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4428 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001658 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Daniela Caceres [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Work Zone Safety: Working Around Vehicles [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Struck, Struck by, Vehicle, Work Zone Safety, Truck, Operator, Driver, Mobile Equipment [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Working Around Vehicles in the Work Zone addresses methods to avoid being struck-by a vehicle on a construction site. The resource includes a case example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates the hazard, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001640 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/19/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [4] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Construction Dive -- DeWalt's Jobsite Pro headphones recalled for fire hazards [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => A recall notice by the United States Consumer Product Safety Commission affects over 300,000 DeWalt Jobsite Pro Headphones. The recall is a result of... [category] => Array ( [0] => 16 [1] => 44 [2] => 45 [3] => 46 [4] => 47 [5] => 48 [6] => 49 [7] => 50 [8] => 51 [9] => 52 [10] => 53 [11] => 54 [12] => 55 [13] => 56 [14] => 57 [15] => 58 [16] => 59 [17] => 60 [18] => 61 [19] => 64 [20] => 65 [21] => 66 [22] => 67 [23] => 68 [24] => 69 [25] => 70 [26] => 71 [27] => 72 [28] => 73 [29] => 74 [30] => 75 [31] => 76 [32] => 77 [33] => 63 [34] => 78 [35] => 79 [36] => 80 [37] => 81 [38] => 82 [39] => 62 [40] => 83 [41] => 84 [42] => 85 [43] => 86 [44] => 87 [45] => 88 [46] => 89 [47] => 91 [48] => 90 [49] => 92 [50] => 93 [51] => 94 [52] => 95 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Fire & Explosions [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Acoustical Ceiling Carpenter [4] => Trades [5] => Asbestos/Insulator [7] => Boilermaker [9] => Bricklayer [11] => Cabinetmaker [13] => Carpenter [15] => Carpet Layer [17] => Cement Mason [19] => Commercial Diver [21] => Concrete Polisher [23] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [25] => Electrical Worker [27] => Elevator Constructor [29] => Flagger [31] => Glazier [33] => Hazardous Waste Cleanup [35] => HVAC [37] => Interior Systems Carpenter [39] => Laborer [41] => Landscaper [43] => Lather [45] => Lead Abatement Worker [47] => Maintenance Worker [49] => Millwright [51] => Operating Engineer [53] => Painter [55] => Paper Hanger [57] => PCC/Restoration [59] => Pile Driver [61] => Plasterer [63] => Plumber/Pipefitter [65] => Refractory Worker [67] => Reinforcing Ironworker [69] => Roofer/Waterproofer [71] => Scaffold Erector [73] => Sheetmetal Worker [75] => Sprinkler Fitter [77] => Stonemason [79] => Structural Ironworker [81] => Terrazzo Worker [83] => Tile Setter [85] => Truck Driver [87] => Welder [89] => Commercial & Institutional [90] => Jobsites [91] => Demolition [93] => Disasters [95] => Heavy & Highway [97] => Industrial [99] => LEED/Green Construction [101] => Renovations [103] => Residential [105] => Underground ) [type] => [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4426/d001656/Construction%2BDive%2B--%2BDeWalt%2527s%2BJobsite%2BPro%2Bheadphones%2Brecalled%2Bfor%2Bfire%2Bhazards.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [16] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 16 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Fire & Explosions [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [44] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 44 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Acoustical Ceiling Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [45] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 45 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Asbestos/Insulator [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [46] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 46 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Boilermaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [48] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 48 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cabinetmaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [50] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 50 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpet Layer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [52] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 52 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Commercial Diver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [53] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 53 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Concrete Polisher [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [54] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 54 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [58] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 58 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Glazier [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [59] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 59 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Hazardous Waste Cleanup [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [65] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 65 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Landscaper [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [66] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 66 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Lather [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [67] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 67 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Lead Abatement Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [69] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 69 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Millwright [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [72] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 72 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Paper Hanger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [73] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 73 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => PCC/Restoration [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [77] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 77 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Refractory Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [81] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 81 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sprinkler Fitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [83] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 83 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Terrazzo Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [84] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 84 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Tile Setter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [85] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 85 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Truck Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4426 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001656 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Construction Dive -- DeWalt's Jobsite Pro headphones recalled for fire hazards [total_pages:protected] => 1 [billed_pages:protected] => 1 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => DeWalt, Fire Hazards, recall, headphones [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A recall notice by the United States Consumer Product Safety Commission affects over 300,000 DeWalt Jobsite Pro Headphones. The recall is a result of a malfunction that can cause earbuds to overheat while charging or during use, leading to fire and burn hazards. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => https://www.constructiondive.com/news/dewalts-jobsite-pro-headphones-recalled-for-fire-hazards/611248/?utm_source=Sailthru&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Issue:%202021-12-10%20Construction%20Dive%20Newsletter%20%5Bissue:38532%5D&utm_term=Construction%20Dive [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/13/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/13/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 12/13/21 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [new_images] => Array ( [0] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Morning Toolbox Talk [image] => /record/images/4003-p.jpg [blurb] => This photo is from an early morning toolbox talk on a construction job in Mclean, Virginia. It is being delivered in English and Spanish.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 20 [1] => 51 [2] => 57 [3] => 64 [4] => 70 [5] => 63 [6] => 78 [7] => 82 [8] => 62 [9] => 87 [10] => 88 [11] => 89 [12] => 91 [13] => 90 [14] => 93 [15] => 94 [16] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Safety Culture [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Cement Mason [4] => Trades [5] => Flagger [7] => Laborer [9] => Operating Engineer [11] => Reinforcing Ironworker [13] => Roofer/Waterproofer [15] => Stonemason [17] => Structural Ironworker [19] => Commercial & Institutional [20] => Jobsites [21] => Demolition [23] => Disasters [25] => Heavy & Highway [27] => Industrial [29] => Renovations [31] => Residential [33] => Images [34] => Media [35] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4003/i002691/Morning%2BToolbox%2BTalk.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4003 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002691 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Morning Toolbox Talk [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, Spanish, bilingual [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This photo is from an early morning toolbox talk on a construction job in Mclean, Virginia. It is being delivered in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001285,d001304,c000079 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [1] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox talk - crew view [image] => /record/images/4005-p.jpg [blurb] => Photo of crew listening to a toolbox safety talk before starting work.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 97 [1] => 20 [2] => 47 [3] => 49 [4] => 51 [5] => 55 [6] => 61 [7] => 64 [8] => 71 [9] => 75 [10] => 63 [11] => 79 [12] => 62 [13] => 87 [14] => 88 [15] => 91 [16] => 90 [17] => 93 [18] => 94 [19] => 95 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Images [1] => Media [2] => Media & Documents [3] => Safety Culture [4] => Work Environment [5] => Hazards [6] => Bricklayer [7] => Trades [8] => Carpenter [10] => Cement Mason [12] => Electrical Worker [14] => Interior Systems Carpenter [16] => Laborer [18] => Painter [20] => Plasterer [22] => Reinforcing Ironworker [24] => Scaffold Erector [26] => Structural Ironworker [28] => Commercial & Institutional [29] => Jobsites [30] => Demolition [32] => Heavy & Highway [34] => Industrial [36] => Renovations [38] => Residential [40] => Underground ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4005/i002692/Toolbox%2Btalk%2B-%2Bcrew%2Bview.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4005 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002692 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox talk - crew view [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, safety talk, Spanish [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Photo of crew listening to a toolbox safety talk before starting work. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002691,d001269, c000079, d001285 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [2] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox talk - long shot [image] => /record/images/4006-p.jpg [blurb] => This crew gathered every morning before starting work to discuss a new safety topic.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 20 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 55 [5] => 64 [6] => 68 [7] => 75 [8] => 76 [9] => 63 [10] => 78 [11] => 79 [12] => 82 [13] => 62 [14] => 87 [15] => 88 [16] => 91 [17] => 90 [18] => 93 [19] => 94 [20] => 95 [21] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Safety Culture [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Electrical Worker [11] => Laborer [13] => Maintenance Worker [15] => Plasterer [17] => Plumber/Pipefitter [19] => Reinforcing Ironworker [21] => Roofer/Waterproofer [23] => Scaffold Erector [25] => Stonemason [27] => Structural Ironworker [29] => Commercial & Institutional [30] => Jobsites [31] => Demolition [33] => Heavy & Highway [35] => Industrial [37] => Renovations [39] => Residential [41] => Underground [43] => Images [44] => Media [45] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4006/i002693/Toolbox%2Btalk%2B-%2Blong%2Bshot.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4006 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002693 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox talk - long shot [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, safety minute [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This crew gathered every morning before starting work to discuss a new safety topic. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002691,i002692,d001269,d000527 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [3] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Safety officer discussing ongoing project with marketing coordinator [image] => /record/images/4014-p.jpg [blurb] => The safety officer (left) points out the good safety practices on this project that reflect well on the firm and may influence future clients.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 97 [1] => 20 [2] => 46 [3] => 47 [4] => 49 [5] => 50 [6] => 51 [7] => 54 [8] => 55 [9] => 58 [10] => 60 [11] => 61 [12] => 64 [13] => 71 [14] => 75 [15] => 76 [16] => 63 [17] => 79 [18] => 80 [19] => 82 [20] => 62 [21] => 83 [22] => 87 [23] => 91 [24] => 90 [25] => 93 [26] => 94 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Images [1] => Media [2] => Media & Documents [3] => Safety Culture [4] => Work Environment [5] => Hazards [6] => Boilermaker [7] => Trades [8] => Bricklayer [10] => Carpenter [12] => Carpet Layer [14] => Cement Mason [16] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [18] => Electrical Worker [20] => Glazier [22] => HVAC [24] => Interior Systems Carpenter [26] => Laborer [28] => Painter [30] => Plasterer [32] => Plumber/Pipefitter [34] => Reinforcing Ironworker [36] => Scaffold Erector [38] => Sheetmetal Worker [40] => Stonemason [42] => Structural Ironworker [44] => Terrazzo Worker [46] => Commercial & Institutional [47] => Jobsites [48] => Heavy & Highway [50] => Industrial [52] => Renovations [54] => Residential ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4014/i002700/Safety%2Bofficer%2Bdiscussing%2Bongoing%2Bproject%2Bwith%2Bmarketing%2Bcoordinator.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [46] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 46 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Boilermaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [50] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 50 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpet Layer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [54] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 54 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [58] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 58 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Glazier [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [83] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 83 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Terrazzo Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4014 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002700 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Safety officer discussing ongoing project with marketing coordinator [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Latino, safety officer, safety culture [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The safety officer (left) points out the good safety practices on this project that reflect well on the firm and may influence future clients. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/index.php [more_like_this:protected] => d000989,d001351,d001362,d000652, d001101, d000931, d001395 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Hoar Construction, Photo by Neil Lippy [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 01/30/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [4] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Scaffolding at top of large column [image] => /record/images/3994-p.jpg [blurb] => This shot shows innovative guarding around the top of a large concrete column in the base of a high rise structure going up.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 15 [1] => 21 [2] => 47 [3] => 51 [4] => 63 [5] => 78 [6] => 79 [7] => 80 [8] => 62 [9] => 87 [10] => 97 [11] => 56 [12] => 64 [13] => 74 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Falls [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Scaffolds [6] => Bricklayer [7] => Trades [8] => Cement Mason [10] => Reinforcing Ironworker [12] => Roofer/Waterproofer [14] => Scaffold Erector [16] => Sheetmetal Worker [18] => Structural Ironworker [20] => Commercial & Institutional [21] => Jobsites [22] => Images [23] => Media [24] => Media & Documents [25] => Elevator Constructor [27] => Laborer [29] => Pile Driver ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/3994/i002689/Scaffolding%2Bat%2Btop%2Bof%2Blarge%2Bcolumn.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [21] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 21 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Scaffolds [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3994 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002689 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Scaffolding at top of large column [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Guardrail, railing, fall prevention, falls [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This shot shows innovative guarding around the top of a large concrete column in the base of a high rise structure going up. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/8/adjustable-tower-scaffold.html [more_like_this:protected] => c1002680,i002662,d000608,d001255 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Photo by Pam Susi [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2016 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_completed:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/01/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [5] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Construction bracing [image] => /record/images/3995-p.jpg [blurb] => This shows structural support that prevents collapses during construction.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 15 [2] => 21 [3] => 49 [4] => 51 [5] => 55 [6] => 56 [7] => 60 [8] => 64 [9] => 68 [10] => 74 [11] => 63 [12] => 78 [13] => 79 [14] => 80 [15] => 62 [16] => 87 [17] => 90 [18] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Falls [6] => Scaffolds [9] => Carpenter [10] => Trades [11] => Cement Mason [13] => Electrical Worker [15] => Elevator Constructor [17] => HVAC [19] => Laborer [21] => Maintenance Worker [23] => Pile Driver [25] => Reinforcing Ironworker [27] => Roofer/Waterproofer [29] => Scaffold Erector [31] => Sheetmetal Worker [33] => Structural Ironworker [35] => Commercial & Institutional [36] => Jobsites [37] => Industrial [39] => Images [40] => Media [41] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/3995/i002690/Construction%2Bbracing.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [21] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 21 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Scaffolds [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3995 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002690 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Construction bracing [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Bracing, support, scaffold [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This shows structural support that prevents collapses during construction. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/8/adjustable-tower-scaffold.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002660 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Photo by Pam Susi [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2016 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_completed:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/01/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [preview_mode] => [description] => The results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. [keywords] => tuckpointing, HEPA vacuum, dust control, LEV, local exhaust ventilation, silica [related_items] => Array ( [Research Reports] => Array ( [0] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1874 [old_id:protected] => 722 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000683 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Sharon Garber/COD [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Protecting Tuckpointing Workers from Silica Dust: Draft Recommendations for a Ventilated Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 12 [billed_pages:protected] => 12 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, vacuum, grinder, mortar, respirator, OSHA, NIOSH, exhaust, Heitbrink, tuckpointer, silica, masonry, dust, silicosis, LEV [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Describes draft recommendations for use of ventilated grinder to reduce dust during tuckpointing and describes field trials using these devices. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/hazard/67/chip-scrape-and-grind-surfaces-or-joints-silica.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001201,d000292,d000293,d000658 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2005 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/27/05 [date_completed:protected] => 04/26/05 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/20/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [1] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1940 [old_id:protected] => 909 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Workplace Solutions: Control of Hazardous Dust During Tuckpointing [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, silica, dust, tuckpoint, grinder, masonry restoration, mortar, vacuum [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d000819,d000820,d000730,d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 10/24/08 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/09 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [2] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3899 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001342 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: Hilti VC40-U Vacuum with Hilti DC-EX Dust Guard and Hilti Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 15 [billed_pages:protected] => 15 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP4 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => silica, tuckpointing, Hilti, local exhaust systems, LEV, shroud, quartz [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This report describes the results of an evaluation of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Hilti VC40-U vacuum, a Hilti DC-EX shroud, and a Hilti DAG-500 grinder. Randomized trials with and without use of the dust control system were conducted in a controlled setting. Removing mortar with the Hilti grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 220 times the National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05mg/m3. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 97 percent. However, exposures measured during the use of the dust control system still exceeded the NIOSH REL. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => December 1, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/05/14 [date_completed:protected] => 02/04/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/06/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [Handouts] => Array ( [0] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3656 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001198 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 24 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction While Doing Tuckpointing/Mortar Removal [total_pages:protected] => 2 [billed_pages:protected] => 2 [publication_number:protected] => DSG FS-3632 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Brick, block, tuckpointing, silica, local exhaust ventilation, LEV, masonry [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Tuckpointing creates some of the greatest exposures to silica in construction. This OSHA factsheet provides guidance on how to greatly reduce these exposures through the use of local exhaust ventilation. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863, d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => February 2013 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/04/13 [date_completed:protected] => 03/27/13 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [collections] => Array ( [3913] => ) [record] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => Array ( [867] => Author Object ( [id:protected] => 867 [organization_id:protected] => 0 [firstname:protected] => Michael [lastname:protected] => Cooper [address:protected] => [city:protected] => [province:protected] => [country:protected] => [postal_code:protected] => [department:protected] => [title:protected] => [phone:protected] => [fax:protected] => [email:protected] => [degree:protected] => [website:protected] => [about:protected] => [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => [date_completed:protected] => [date_billed:protected] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [481] => Author Object ( [id:protected] => 481 [organization_id:protected] => 0 [firstname:protected] => Pam [lastname:protected] => Susi [address:protected] => 8484 Georgia Avenue, Suite 1000 [city:protected] => Silver Spring [province:protected] => Maryland [country:protected] => USA [postal_code:protected] => 20910 [department:protected] => [title:protected] => [phone:protected] => 301-578-8500 ext.144 [fax:protected] => 301-578-8572 [email:protected] => plsusi@aol.com [degree:protected] => [website:protected] => http://www.cpwr.com [about:protected] => [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => 2003-10-02 [date_completed:protected] => 2003-10-06 [date_billed:protected] => 2003-11-03 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [organizations:protected] => Array ( [1] => Organization Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [elcosh_id:protected] => o000001 [user_id:protected] => 14 [province_id:protected] => 21 [country_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => CPWR - The Center for Construction Research and Training [address:protected] => Suite 1000, 8484 Georgia Ave [postal_code:protected] => 20910 [city:protected] => Silver Spring [department:protected] => [phone:protected] => 301-578-8500 [fax:protected] => 301-578-8572 [email:protected] => cpwrwebsite@cpwr.com [website:protected] => http://www.cpwr.com [filename:protected] => o000001.gif [about:protected] => CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training, developed, and continues to maintain/expand this website - The Electronic Library of Construction Occupational Safety and Health, www.elcosh.org. CPWR, formerly known as The Center to Protect Workers’ Rights, is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit research and training institution. Created by the Building and Construction Trades Department, AFL-CIO, CPWR serves as the research arm of the BCTD. Since the inception of its research agenda in 1990, CPWR has grown into a worldwide provider of safety and health information covering all aspects of the construction industry. CPWR launched eLCOSH in 2000, and the Spanish-language version of the site in 2001. CPWR also created, and continues to build, Construction Solutions - www.cpwrConstructionSolutions.org - a free, online database of construction hazards and ways to prevent, eliminate, or reduce them. [comments:protected] => [logo_available:protected] => T [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => 2000-08-18 [date_completed:protected] => 2000-08-30 [date_billed:protected] => 2000-09-05 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [collections:protected] => Array ( [3913] => ) [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => Array ( [1874] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1874 [old_id:protected] => 722 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000683 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Sharon Garber/COD [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Protecting Tuckpointing Workers from Silica Dust: Draft Recommendations for a Ventilated Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 12 [billed_pages:protected] => 12 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, vacuum, grinder, mortar, respirator, OSHA, NIOSH, exhaust, Heitbrink, tuckpointer, silica, masonry, dust, silicosis, LEV [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Describes draft recommendations for use of ventilated grinder to reduce dust during tuckpointing and describes field trials using these devices. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/hazard/67/chip-scrape-and-grind-surfaces-or-joints-silica.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001201,d000292,d000293,d000658 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2005 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/27/05 [date_completed:protected] => 04/26/05 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/20/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [1940] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1940 [old_id:protected] => 909 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Workplace Solutions: Control of Hazardous Dust During Tuckpointing [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, silica, dust, tuckpoint, grinder, masonry restoration, mortar, vacuum [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d000819,d000820,d000730,d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 10/24/08 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/09 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [2213] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 2213 [old_id:protected] => 1090 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => [language_id:protected] => 2 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Control del polvo peligroso que se genera durante los procesos de reparación de mortero [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => 2008-126 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => [comments:protected] => http://www.cdc.gov/spanish/niosh/docs/wp-solutions/2008-126_sp/ [summary:protected] => A Workplace Solutions de NIOSH que resume un estudio de NIOSH sobre los riesgos de exposición cuando se reparan las estructuras y los métodos para controlar el polvo. [A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust.] [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => D000819,D000820,D000730,d000819 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 01/07/10 [date_completed:protected] => 04/19/10 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 07/08/12 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [3656] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3656 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001198 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 24 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction While Doing Tuckpointing/Mortar Removal [total_pages:protected] => 2 [billed_pages:protected] => 2 [publication_number:protected] => DSG FS-3632 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Brick, block, tuckpointing, silica, local exhaust ventilation, LEV, masonry [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Tuckpointing creates some of the greatest exposures to silica in construction. This OSHA factsheet provides guidance on how to greatly reduce these exposures through the use of local exhaust ventilation. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863, d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => February 2013 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/04/13 [date_completed:protected] => 03/27/13 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [3899] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3899 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001342 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: Hilti VC40-U Vacuum with Hilti DC-EX Dust Guard and Hilti Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 15 [billed_pages:protected] => 15 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP4 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => silica, tuckpointing, Hilti, local exhaust systems, LEV, shroud, quartz [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This report describes the results of an evaluation of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Hilti VC40-U vacuum, a Hilti DC-EX shroud, and a Hilti DAG-500 grinder. Randomized trials with and without use of the dust control system were conducted in a controlled setting. Removing mortar with the Hilti grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 220 times the National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05mg/m3. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 97 percent. However, exposures measured during the use of the dust control system still exceeded the NIOSH REL. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => December 1, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/05/14 [date_completed:protected] => 02/04/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/06/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [content:protected] => [files:protected] => Array ( [559] => [560] => [546] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 546 [filename:protected] => 3.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:22 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [566] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 566 [filename:protected] => 4.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:23 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [720] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 720 [filename:protected] => 5.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [721] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 721 [filename:protected] => 6.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [722] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 722 [filename:protected] => 7.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [9765] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 9765 [filename:protected] => d001345.pdf [downloadable:protected] => T [timestamp:protected] => 2015-02-09 12:26:04 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3908 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001345 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: DustControl 2900c Vacuum with the ICS Dust Director Shroud and Bosch Grinder Model 1775E Conducted November 14-15, 2012 [total_pages:protected] => 13 [billed_pages:protected] => 13 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP2 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => tuckpointing, HEPA vacuum, dust control, LEV, local exhaust ventilation, silica [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => April 15, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 01/26/15 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/09/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [show_text] => [document_content] => ElcoshItemDocumentContent Object ( [id:protected] => 2934 [item_id:protected] => 3908 [type:protected] => main [title:protected] => [content:protected] =>
Executive Summary
This report describes the results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. It should also be noted that the NIOSH REL is based on exposures averaged over a ten hour work day and our results represent time weighted averages of the sample task duration periods.
Acronyms
ACGIH - American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists
CPWR - CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training
Ce - coefficient of entry
HEPA - high-efficiency particulate air
IUBAC - International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craftworkers
LEV - local exhaust ventilation
PACT - Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies
NIOSH - National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health
OEL - occupational exposure limit
OSHA - Occupational Safety and Health Administration
PAPR - powered air-purifying respirator
PEL - Permissible Exposure Limit
PVC - polyvinyl chloride
REL - Recommended Exposure Limit
RPM - revolutions per minute
TWA - time-weighted average
SP - static pressure
I. Introduction and Background
In 2010 CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training began a four-year project which seeks to identify and evaluate tuckpointing local exhaust ventilation (LEV) systems and disseminate information on their availability and effectiveness. A Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies (PACT) comprised of masonry contractors, representatives from unions, government, equipment manufacturers, and health and safety researcher was formed as part of this project. PACT members participated in identifying important characteristics for control technologies and this information was used to identify LEV systems for tuckpointing using that criteria. Contractor and labor members of the PACT selected specific tuckpointing LEV systems to be considered for evaluation. Each system consisted of a tuckpointing grinder, shroud, and vacuum. This report describes the second of four systems to be evaluated between 2012 the end of 2014, with and without LEV, in a controlled setting to determine effectiveness in silica exposure reduction. This report describes the methods and results of our evaluation of a system consisting of the DustControl 2900c vacuum with the ICS Dust Director shroud and a Bosch Model 1775E grinder.
Excessive exposure to respirable silica can result in silicosis or other silica-related diseases including pulmonary tuberculosis, lung cancer, silicoproteinosis (Lyons et al, 2007) and autoimmune disorders such as rheumatoid arthritis, sarcoidosis and scleroderma (Miller et al, 2012). Respirable silica is generally defined as particles less than 10 micrometers (μm) in aerodynamic diameter (ACGIH, 2013). Silicosis can lead to symptoms including shortness of breath, fatigue, chest pains, susceptibility to infection and possibly death. There is no cure for silicosis, however it is totally preventable. Construction workers exposed to dust, including silica, are also known to have higher rates of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD).
There are many sources of silica in construction that result in exposures of varying intensity among workers. Masonry restoration workers are among the most highly silica-exposed trades in construction. The process of grinding out deteriorated mortar joints between masonry units and replacing or repointing with fresh mortar (often referred to as tuckpointing) is a fundamental part of masonry restoration work. The removal of mortar with powered angle grinders generates enormous levels of dust. Between 2004 and 2006, NIOSH and CPWR evaluated silica exposures while grinding mortar in a controlled setting, at a local training center, where tasks, sample times and task variables were defined by the study design. These studies demonstrated that grinding mortar without controls can result in elevated respirable silica exposures. Meeker et al., (2009) reported exposures between 5 and 25.8 milligrams per cubic meter (mg/m3) in a controlled setting. This study also showed that LEV systems for tuckpointing grinders can reduce exposures to respirable silica by greater than 90 percent.II. Objectives
The objective of this evaluation was to assess the effectiveness of an LEV system for controlling exposure to silica during the grinding of mortar. The control technology was tested under controlled conditions, similar to those experienced by tuckpointers on actual job sites, using journeymen bricklayers experienced in tuckpointing and repeat, randomized trials with and without LEV. All other variables were held constant throughout so that the only variable was whether or not the tested control was used.
III. Description of Equipment Tested
A Bosch model 1775E grinder (Robert Bosch Tool Corporation, Prospect, IL) (Figures 1, 2 and 3) was fitted with a new 1/4-inch wide, 4½-inch diameter segmented diamond abrasive blade made by DeWalt (model #DW4740). The grinder weighs six and a half pounds, draws 8.5 amps and has a variable speed up to 11,000 revolutions per minute (RPMs). The DustControl 2900c vacuum (DustControl, Inc., Wilmington, NC) (Figure 3) was tested in combination with the Dust Director shroud (Industrial Contractors’ Supplies, Inc., Huntingdon, PA) (Figures 1 and 3) attached to the Bosch grinder.
Figure 1. Bosch grinder with Dust Director shroud
Figure 2. Bosch grinder without tuckpointing LEV system.
Figure 3: Bosch Grinder with LEV System
The vacuum is specified to weigh 31 pounds when empty and to provide a flow rate of 114 cubic feet of air per minute and a “static lift” or “vacuum suction pressure” of 84 inches of water. The vacuum is sold with a cyclonic pre-separator, to remove larger particles, a fine filter (rated 99.9 percent efficient) and a HEPA (high-efficiency particulate air) filter (rated to capture 99.97 percent of the particles with an aerodynamic diameter of 0.3 micrometers). The HEPA filter was removed based on the manufacturer’s recommendation due to the heavy dust loading associated with tuckpointing. CPWR sponsored research and contractor experience indicate that HEPA filters likely have an adverse effect on dust capture during tuckpointing because of extreme dust loading on filters. While the cyclone and the fine filter remove most of the dust, especially the large particles, before they reach the HEPA filter, the HEPA filter would still be subject to heavy loading, causing a substantial pressure drop and subsequent decrease in air flow rate. The relatively small increase in the efficiency of the filtration system while using the HEPA filter is expected to be quickly offset by a more significant decrease in capture efficiency as the air flow rate and ability to capture particles decreases.
Dust collects in relatively inexpensive, heavy-gauge plastic bags below and outside of the cyclone. The bags can be removed and replaced without opening the vacuum. Some vacuums are equipped with a light to indicate that the filters need to be cleaned or changed. The DC2900c features a “reverse air pulse cleaning system,” which removes accumulated dust from the filters without having to remove them from the vacuum. The system, as illustrated in Figure 4, requires the operator to disconnect the hose from the shroud, place it over an air stop so that air through the hose is cut off and pressure in the vacuum is maximized.
Figure 4. Procedure for "cleaning" of or dust removal from filters (source: http://dustcontrolusa.com/manuals/2800c.pdf)
The flap covering the port on the side of the vacuum is repeatedly flipped open to release built up pressure in strong pulses that dislodge dust from the filter.
The manufacturer indicates “the filter is generally cleaned once or twice daily during normal continuous operation.” The Dust Director shroud has a 2-inch diameter take-off that was connected to the antistatic, corrugated 1.5-inch diameter, 15-foot long vacuum hose supplied with the DustControl vacuum.
IV. Study Methods
This evaluation was conducted at the International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craft workers (IUBAC) Local 1 Philadelphia/Delaware Training Center in Philadelphia, PA on November 14 and 15, 2012. A single journeyman bricklayer, experienced in tuckpointing, used the grinder and LEV system being tested to remove mortar from joints wide enough to require two passes. The type S mortar had been allowed to cure for at least four weeks. The bricklayer either possessed or was provided with personal protective equipment including sturdy work boots, gloves, hearing protection and a powered air-purifying respirator (PAPR). The PAPR was a 3M GVP system with a bump cap, loose fitting face piece and a HEPA filter (3M, St Paul, MN).
The study was designed to include at least five rounds of sampling during mortar removal. Each round included a trial using the Bosch grinder with a Dust Director shroud and Dust Collector 2900c vacuum and a trial using the Bosch grinder with the factory-supplied guard and without a vacuum. The order of the two trials within each round was randomly selected to minimize bias that might be introduced due to variation associated with environmental factors, equipment operator, blade wear, vacuum performance over time and any other factors unrelated to LEV use. Tools were operated for approximately 16 minutes per trial with controls and for approximately 8 minutes when controls were not used. These times were selected based on the results of previous sampling efforts and estimates of the minimum sample time needed to achieve a limit of quantification low enough to accurately measure exposures down to or less than 0.05 mg/m3 – the NIOSH Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) for respirable silica. The bricklayer was required to take a 5 to 10 minute break in the middle of the 16-minute trials to reduce differences in fatigue, compared to the 8-minute trials. Personal air samples were collected in the breathing zone of the operator during each trial to measure respirable silica concentrations during grinding with and without LEV. The samples were collected using a GilAir-5 pump (Sensidyne, Inc., Clearwater, FL) to draw 4.2 liters of air per minute through a GK2.69 Respirable Cyclone (BGI Inc., Waltham, MA) with a pre-weighed, 37 mm diameter, 5-micron pore size polyvinyl chloride (PVC) filter positioned on the operator’s lapel.
The flow rates of the sampling pumps were calibrated at the beginning of each day using a DryCal DC-Lite Primary Flow Meter (Bios International Corporation, Butler, NJ). Flow rates were measured again near the middle and at the end of each day to ensure that sampling flow rates were maintained within 5% of pre-sampling flow rates throughout the day. Average flow rates were used to calculate sample air volumes. Samples were analyzed by R.J. Lee Group, Inc., (Monroeville, PA) using NIOSH Method 0600, to determine exposure to total mass of respirable dust. The same samples were also analyzed using X-Ray diffraction following NIOSH method 7500 to determine quartz, cristobalite and tridymite concentration in the respirable mass. Reported masses for these analytes were used with the sample air volumes to calculate airborne concentrations of total respirable dust, quartz, cristobalite and tridymite.
We used a reduction of greater than 50 percent in respirable silica exposure concentrations or a reduction to less than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 as our criteria for determining whether or not a control was considered efficacious. This is consistent with criteria used by NIOSH in conducting a similar study in 2004 described by Echt et al. (2007) and by CPWR in 2006 and described by Meeker et al. (2009). The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) and the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) publish additional occupational exposure limits (OELs) for silica which are listed in Table 1 with NIOSH RELs. OELs for silica are based on the respirable fraction of the aerosol, which consists of particles less than 10 micrometers in aerodynamic diameter.
| Organization or Agency | Form of Crystalline Silica | Occupational Exposure Limits (mg/m3) |
|---|---|---|
| NIOSHA | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 |
| OSHA - ConstructionB | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
PEL = 250 / (5 + % quartz) PEL = 250 / (5 + % cristobalite) PEL = 250 / (5 + % tridymite) |
| ACGIH | Crystalline Silica | TLV = 0.025 mg/m3 |
A NIOSH Publication No. 2005-151 indicates 10-hour time-weighted average during a 40-hr workweek B The PEL for silica in OSHA’s Safety and Health Regulations for Construction, 29 C.F.R. 1926.55(a), is an 8-hour time-weighted average (TWA) expressed in millions of particles per cubic foot (mppcf). However, the units mppcf can be converted to milligrams per cubic meter can by dividing mppcf by 10 (OSHA, 2009). The formula used by OSHA to determine the PEL for silica is dependent on the percentage of silica in each collected sample. The concentration of respirable dust measured is compared to the sample specific PEL to determine if the PEL has been exceeded. OSHA has proposed lowering the PEL to 0.05 mg/m3 of respirable silica as an 8 hour TWA. |
||
The flow of air in ventilation systems is governed by fundamental principles that describe the behavior of gases (in this case air). Pressure measurements taken within a ventilation system along with knowledge of hood (or shroud) entry losses can be used to calculate flow rates. Hood entry losses are dependent on the shape and configuration of a particular hood or shroud and described by the term “coefficient of entry (Ce)” which is the ratio of actual air flow through a hood and what the air flow would theoretically be if there were no hood entry losses. Given the coefficient of entry, static pressure measurements can be used to calculate air flow through a given hood. The coefficient of entry for the Dust Director shroud was previously determined by CPWR and used for calculating air flow based on static pressure measurements (Meeker et al., 2009). Static pressure, with the vacuum operating, was measured periodically throughout the evaluation to monitor the changes in air-flow rate following use and again after filter cleaning. The static pressure was measured at a port positioned more than 3 duct diameters downstream from the tool’s air intake using a UEi EM200 Electronic Manometer (Universal Enterprises, Inc., Beaverton, OR).
The dust in the vacuum bag was monitored and, per the manufacturer’s instructions, the bag was changed before the dust level was within 5 centimeters of the valve at the bottom of the vacuum. Each time a vacuum bag was removed, it was weighed to the nearest pound. The bag weights and corresponding grinding durations were used to calculate the average weight of dust collected per unit time. After each trial, cut lengths were measured on the wall to determine total linear feet of vertical (head) and horizontal (bed) joints per unit time.
A Haz-Dust III, Model HD-1003, Real-Time Aerosol Monitor (Environmental Devices Corporation, Plaistow, NH) was used to confirm clearance of dust between trials. The Haz-Dust monitor was positioned on the test wall near the operator at approximately breathing zone level and configured to measure respirable particulate concentration.
V. Results
Personal air monitoring
Five pairs of respirable dust samples were collected while grinding with and without the vacuum system. In addition, three respirable dust samples were collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place. One measurement collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard was shown to be a statistical outlier and was omitted from analysis. Personal air monitoring results for respirable silica and a comparison of average exposures relative to the NIOSH REL for silica (0.05 mg/m3) appears in Table 2. The mean respirable dust levels measured without LEV was 31.4 mg/m3. However, samples collected with LEV were below the limit of quantification (LOQ) which ranged from <1.29 to <1.46 mg/m3. Use of LEV resulted in a greater than 95% reduction in mean respirable dust levels using a mean value with use of LEV of <1.41 (n=5 samples with use of LEV and n=7 without use of LEV). The respirable dust samples collected during grinding without the LEV system contained an average of 24 percent silica. The mass of respirable dust in the samples collected with use of the LEV system was too low to determine the silica content.| Mean, mg/m3 (range) | Std. Dev. | Percent Reduction | Hazard RatioB | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bosch with Dust Director Shroud and DustControl 2900c Vacuum |
0.091 (<0.069 – 0.137) |
0.027 | 98.7 | 1.81 |
| Bosch with no Control | 7.23 (4.57 – 9.90) |
1.94 | NA | 145 |
A n = 5 samples for each tool/control combination and n = 7 samples without the use of the LEV system B Hazard Ratio = measured exposure / NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 |
||||
Average respirable silica and dust exposures, with and without the dust control system, appear as Figures 5 and 6, respectively.
Figure 5. Average respirable silica exposures with and without the Dustcontrol 2900c vacuum and Dust Director shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air - mg/m3)
Figure 6. Average respirable dust exposures with and without Dustcontrol 2900c Vacuum and Dust Director Shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air – mg/m3)
The mean respirable silica concentration measured during use of the control was significantly less than the concentration measured while using the same tool without controls (p<0.01). Grinding mortar with the Bosch angle grinder without dust controls resulted in an average exposure to respirable silica that was 145 times the NIOSH REL. Grinding with the Bosch angle grinder in combination with the Dust Director shroud and the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced the average concentration of respirable silica by 98.7 percent. With use of these controls, the concentration of respirable silica was 1.8 times greater than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3. However the NIOSH REL is based on a time-weighted average (TWA) over a 10-hour workday. Given these were task TWAs and samples were collected over continuous periods of grinding, they may overestimate exposures over an actual work day since some time would be spent performing tasks that would likely have lower, or no, silica exposures (setup, breaks, cleanup, etc.).
Static pressure, dust mass collection and grinding rates.
Static pressure was used as a surrogate for air flow as described earlier. Hood static pressure was measured periodically at a tap near the grinder more than 3 duct diameters from the air intake in the shroud. The static pressure, and thus air flow, was generally higher when the vacuum’s filter had recently been cleaned. The mean, median, and range of calculated flow rates are presented in Table A1 of the Appendix.
Based on the data we collected, the air-flow rate upstream from the Bosch grinder and Dust Director shroud ranged from 78 to 93 cubic feet per minute (cfm) with the DustControl vacuum. When the manufacturer’s filter cleaning procedure was followed the vacuum performed relatively well and flow could be maintained at slightly less than 90 cfm with cleaning. However, mean flow rates dropped substantially to 80 cfm after as little as 8 minutes of grinding without any filter cleaning. The flow rate returned to an average of 89 cfm when filters were cleaned correctly (without stopping air flow to the vacuum). Collingwood and Heitbrink (2007) found that the minimum exhaust flow rate for capture of silica and other particulate under ideal conditions is 21.25 cfm per inch of grinder blade diameter. This is equal to about 96 cfm when using a 4.5 inch diameter grinding blade. We set 106 cfm as the minimum desired flow rate for this study to allow a safety margin for potential decline in equipment performance and the possibility of inadequate maintenance, both of which may be likely after repeated use under actual work conditions. The DustControl vacuum provided slightly less than the minimum flow rate described by Collingwood and Heitbrink for a 4.5-inch blade and the peak flow rate fell with use.
The duration of vacuum bag use and mass of dust collected were recorded and are presented in Table A2 of the Appendix. The vacuum bags were changed and weighed after each trial utilizing the LEV system. A total of five bags were used to complete the five rounds of grinding. The DustControl vacuum captured 45 pounds of dust over 83 minutes of grinding for an average rate of dust collection of 0.54 pounds per minute. The rate of dust collection ranged from 0.47 to 0.63 pounds per minute. Based on these measurements, approximately 130 pounds of dust would likely be captured after just 4 hours of continuous grinding.
The rate of grinding a combination of vertical and horizontal joints while using the LEV system ranged from 2.3 to 3.3 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the use of the LEV system ranged from 2.6 to 3.4 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place ranged from 4.7 to 5.1 feet per minute. It’s important to note that: 1) the operator had limited experience using dust control systems and cut rates appeared to improve slightly over the 2-day period he used the tested equipment; and 2) the upper range of cut rates with the dust control system overlapped with the lowest cut rate with the original guard and without the LEV system in place indicating no statistical difference between cut rates. Given that grinding rates with and without use of this LEV system are only available for one operator and he had limited experience with the LEV system, these reported cut rates are in no way intended to represent the impact use of this LEV system is likely to have on productivity rates overall.
VI. Discussion
The objective of these trials was to evaluate the effectiveness of a tuckpointing LEV system for controlling respirable silica while grinding out mortar joints. The Dust Director shroud with the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced respirable silica concentrations when grinding with the Bosch grinder by approximately 99 percent. Despite being considered effective by our test criteria (greater than 50% reduction), it still resulted in task TWA exposures that exceeded the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 by 1.8 times. Depending on how much time is spent grinding over the course of a work day and on exposures while performing other tasks, the 8-hour TWA exposures may or may not exceed the REL with this system. Use of this system by workers with experience and training in proficient use will likely improve dust capture performance. Exposure reduction is greatly influenced by correct use of this system which includes grinding from right to left, making sure the shroud is held flush against the wall and that the tool travels at a pace that doesn’t exceed the ability of the system to capture dust as it’s generated. Deviation from any of these measures produces visible dust clouds which were observed during trials.
VII. Conclusions
With a 99 percent reduction in respirable silica exposure, the Dust Director shroud and DustControl 2900c vacuum with a Bosch Model 1775E grinder was effective in reducing silica exposures based on our criteria. Use of the tested dust control system may be effective in reducing silica exposure on the job to less than the NIOSH REL if used in combination with administrative controls such as work scheduling to reduce cutting times as needed. Training on correct use of the tested system is also essential. Personal air monitoring is necessary to verify control effectiveness on actual job sites and under “real-world” conditions. However, these results clearly demonstrate the availability of viable and effective engineering controls for tuckpointing operations associated with elevated silica exposure.
VIII. References
American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists. Threshold limit values for chemical substances (TLV®-CS). [2013]. ACGIH, Cincinnati, Ohio.
Bergdahl I.A,. Toren K., Eriksson K., et al. [2004]. Increased mortality in COPD among construction workers exposed to inorganic dust. European Respiratory Journal, 23: 402–06.
Blanc P.D. & Torén K. [2007]. Occupation in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and chronic bronchitis: an update [State of the Art Series. Occupational lung disease in high-and low-income countries, Edited by M. Chan-Yeung. Number 2 in the series]. The International Journal of Tuberculosis and Lung Disease, 11(3), 251-257.
Collingwood S. & Heitbrink W.A. [2007] 'Field Evaluation of an Engineering Control for Respirable Crystalline Silica Exposures During Mortar Removal'. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, 4:11, 875 – 887.
DHHS (NIOSH) Publication No. 2002-129 April 2002 http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/2002-129/
Echt A., Sieber W.K., Lefkowitz D., Meeker J., Susi P., Cardwell B., Heitbrink, W.A. In-depth survey of dust control technology for cutting concrete block and tuckpointing brick at The International Masonry Institute Bordentown Training Center, Bordentown, NJ. Cincinnati, OH: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Report. No. EPHB 282-13; 2007. http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ECTB-282-13.pdf
Heitbrink W., Bennett J. [2006]. A numerical and experimental investigation of crystalline silica exposure control during tuck pointing. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, Vol. 3, pp 366-378.
Lyons et al, [2007]. A breathless builder. Breathe, Vol. 3, no. 4, pp 386-390.
Mastrangelo G., Tartari M., Fedeli U., Fadda E., Saia B. [2003]. Ascertaining the risk of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease in relation to occupation using a case-control design. Occupational Medicine, 53: 165–172.
Meeker J., Cooper M., Lefrowitz D., Susi P. [2009]. Engineering control technologies to reduce occupational silica exposures in masonry cutting and tuckpointing. Public Health Reports, Supplement 1, Vol. 124, June.
Meeker J, Flynn M, Susi P, Cardwell, B [2004]. Performance evaluation of a masonry concrete vacuum. Unpublished Report.
Miller F. W., Alfredsson L., Costenbader K. H., Kamen D. L., Nelson L. M., Norris J. M., & De Roos A. J. [2012]. Epidemiology of environmental exposures and human autoimmune diseases: findings from a National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences Expert Panel workshop. Journal of autoimmunity. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3496812/
Occupational Safety and Health Administration U.S Department of Labor. Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction. [2009]. OSHA 3362-05.
Rappaport SM, Goldberg M, Susi P, Herrick RF [2003]. Excessive exposure to silica in the U.S. construction industry. Annals of Occupational Hygiene, Vol. 47, pp. 111-122.
IX. Appendices
| Measurement Conditions |
n | Mean Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Median
Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before filter cleaning | 5 | 80 | 81 | 78-81 |
| After filter cleaning following manufacturer directions | 9 | 89 | 90 | 84-93 |
| * Static pressure was measured in millibars and converted to inches of water gauge. Flow rates were calculated using the formula Q = Ce (A) 4005 (SP)1/2 where: Q = flow in cubic feet per minute (cfm), Ce = coefficient of entry, A = area of the duct where static pressure measurements were taken in square feet, and SP = static pressure in inches of water gauge. | ||||
| Tool/Control | Collection Period (min.) |
Dust Collection Rate (lb/min.) |
|---|---|---|
| Bosch grinder/Dust Director shroud & DustControl 2900c vacuum |
8 11 8 8 10 |
0.50 0.61 0.50 0.47 0.63 |
| Average | 0.54 |
[content_transformed:protected] =>
Executive Summary
This report describes the results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. It should also be noted that the NIOSH REL is based on exposures averaged over a ten hour work day and our results represent time weighted averages of the sample task duration periods.
Acronyms
ACGIH - American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists
CPWR - CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training
Ce - coefficient of entry
HEPA - high-efficiency particulate air
IUBAC - International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craftworkers
LEV - local exhaust ventilation
PACT - Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies
NIOSH - National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health
OEL - occupational exposure limit
OSHA - Occupational Safety and Health Administration
PAPR - powered air-purifying respirator
PEL - Permissible Exposure Limit
PVC - polyvinyl chloride
REL - Recommended Exposure Limit
RPM - revolutions per minute
TWA - time-weighted average
SP - static pressure
I. Introduction and Background
In 2010 CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training began a four-year project which seeks to identify and evaluate tuckpointing local exhaust ventilation (LEV) systems and disseminate information on their availability and effectiveness. A Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies (PACT) comprised of masonry contractors, representatives from unions, government, equipment manufacturers, and health and safety researcher was formed as part of this project. PACT members participated in identifying important characteristics for control technologies and this information was used to identify LEV systems for tuckpointing using that criteria. Contractor and labor members of the PACT selected specific tuckpointing LEV systems to be considered for evaluation. Each system consisted of a tuckpointing grinder, shroud, and vacuum. This report describes the second of four systems to be evaluated between 2012 the end of 2014, with and without LEV, in a controlled setting to determine effectiveness in silica exposure reduction. This report describes the methods and results of our evaluation of a system consisting of the DustControl 2900c vacuum with the ICS Dust Director shroud and a Bosch Model 1775E grinder.
Excessive exposure to respirable silica can result in silicosis or other silica-related diseases including pulmonary tuberculosis, lung cancer, silicoproteinosis (Lyons et al, 2007) and autoimmune disorders such as rheumatoid arthritis, sarcoidosis and scleroderma (Miller et al, 2012). Respirable silica is generally defined as particles less than 10 micrometers (μm) in aerodynamic diameter (ACGIH, 2013). Silicosis can lead to symptoms including shortness of breath, fatigue, chest pains, susceptibility to infection and possibly death. There is no cure for silicosis, however it is totally preventable. Construction workers exposed to dust, including silica, are also known to have higher rates of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD).
There are many sources of silica in construction that result in exposures of varying intensity among workers. Masonry restoration workers are among the most highly silica-exposed trades in construction. The process of grinding out deteriorated mortar joints between masonry units and replacing or repointing with fresh mortar (often referred to as tuckpointing) is a fundamental part of masonry restoration work. The removal of mortar with powered angle grinders generates enormous levels of dust. Between 2004 and 2006, NIOSH and CPWR evaluated silica exposures while grinding mortar in a controlled setting, at a local training center, where tasks, sample times and task variables were defined by the study design. These studies demonstrated that grinding mortar without controls can result in elevated respirable silica exposures. Meeker et al., (2009) reported exposures between 5 and 25.8 milligrams per cubic meter (mg/m3) in a controlled setting. This study also showed that LEV systems for tuckpointing grinders can reduce exposures to respirable silica by greater than 90 percent.II. Objectives
The objective of this evaluation was to assess the effectiveness of an LEV system for controlling exposure to silica during the grinding of mortar. The control technology was tested under controlled conditions, similar to those experienced by tuckpointers on actual job sites, using journeymen bricklayers experienced in tuckpointing and repeat, randomized trials with and without LEV. All other variables were held constant throughout so that the only variable was whether or not the tested control was used.
III. Description of Equipment Tested
A Bosch model 1775E grinder (Robert Bosch Tool Corporation, Prospect, IL) (Figures 1, 2 and 3) was fitted with a new 1/4-inch wide, 4½-inch diameter segmented diamond abrasive blade made by DeWalt (model #DW4740). The grinder weighs six and a half pounds, draws 8.5 amps and has a variable speed up to 11,000 revolutions per minute (RPMs). The DustControl 2900c vacuum (DustControl, Inc., Wilmington, NC) (Figure 3) was tested in combination with the Dust Director shroud (Industrial Contractors’ Supplies, Inc., Huntingdon, PA) (Figures 1 and 3) attached to the Bosch grinder.
Figure 1. Bosch grinder with Dust Director shroud
Figure 2. Bosch grinder without tuckpointing LEV system.
Figure 3: Bosch Grinder with LEV System
The vacuum is specified to weigh 31 pounds when empty and to provide a flow rate of 114 cubic feet of air per minute and a “static lift” or “vacuum suction pressure” of 84 inches of water. The vacuum is sold with a cyclonic pre-separator, to remove larger particles, a fine filter (rated 99.9 percent efficient) and a HEPA (high-efficiency particulate air) filter (rated to capture 99.97 percent of the particles with an aerodynamic diameter of 0.3 micrometers). The HEPA filter was removed based on the manufacturer’s recommendation due to the heavy dust loading associated with tuckpointing. CPWR sponsored research and contractor experience indicate that HEPA filters likely have an adverse effect on dust capture during tuckpointing because of extreme dust loading on filters. While the cyclone and the fine filter remove most of the dust, especially the large particles, before they reach the HEPA filter, the HEPA filter would still be subject to heavy loading, causing a substantial pressure drop and subsequent decrease in air flow rate. The relatively small increase in the efficiency of the filtration system while using the HEPA filter is expected to be quickly offset by a more significant decrease in capture efficiency as the air flow rate and ability to capture particles decreases.
Dust collects in relatively inexpensive, heavy-gauge plastic bags below and outside of the cyclone. The bags can be removed and replaced without opening the vacuum. Some vacuums are equipped with a light to indicate that the filters need to be cleaned or changed. The DC2900c features a “reverse air pulse cleaning system,” which removes accumulated dust from the filters without having to remove them from the vacuum. The system, as illustrated in Figure 4, requires the operator to disconnect the hose from the shroud, place it over an air stop so that air through the hose is cut off and pressure in the vacuum is maximized.
Figure 4. Procedure for "cleaning" of or dust removal from filters (source: http://dustcontrolusa.com/manuals/2800c.pdf)
The flap covering the port on the side of the vacuum is repeatedly flipped open to release built up pressure in strong pulses that dislodge dust from the filter.
The manufacturer indicates “the filter is generally cleaned once or twice daily during normal continuous operation.” The Dust Director shroud has a 2-inch diameter take-off that was connected to the antistatic, corrugated 1.5-inch diameter, 15-foot long vacuum hose supplied with the DustControl vacuum.
IV. Study Methods
This evaluation was conducted at the International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craft workers (IUBAC) Local 1 Philadelphia/Delaware Training Center in Philadelphia, PA on November 14 and 15, 2012. A single journeyman bricklayer, experienced in tuckpointing, used the grinder and LEV system being tested to remove mortar from joints wide enough to require two passes. The type S mortar had been allowed to cure for at least four weeks. The bricklayer either possessed or was provided with personal protective equipment including sturdy work boots, gloves, hearing protection and a powered air-purifying respirator (PAPR). The PAPR was a 3M GVP system with a bump cap, loose fitting face piece and a HEPA filter (3M, St Paul, MN).
The study was designed to include at least five rounds of sampling during mortar removal. Each round included a trial using the Bosch grinder with a Dust Director shroud and Dust Collector 2900c vacuum and a trial using the Bosch grinder with the factory-supplied guard and without a vacuum. The order of the two trials within each round was randomly selected to minimize bias that might be introduced due to variation associated with environmental factors, equipment operator, blade wear, vacuum performance over time and any other factors unrelated to LEV use. Tools were operated for approximately 16 minutes per trial with controls and for approximately 8 minutes when controls were not used. These times were selected based on the results of previous sampling efforts and estimates of the minimum sample time needed to achieve a limit of quantification low enough to accurately measure exposures down to or less than 0.05 mg/m3 – the NIOSH Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) for respirable silica. The bricklayer was required to take a 5 to 10 minute break in the middle of the 16-minute trials to reduce differences in fatigue, compared to the 8-minute trials. Personal air samples were collected in the breathing zone of the operator during each trial to measure respirable silica concentrations during grinding with and without LEV. The samples were collected using a GilAir-5 pump (Sensidyne, Inc., Clearwater, FL) to draw 4.2 liters of air per minute through a GK2.69 Respirable Cyclone (BGI Inc., Waltham, MA) with a pre-weighed, 37 mm diameter, 5-micron pore size polyvinyl chloride (PVC) filter positioned on the operator’s lapel.
The flow rates of the sampling pumps were calibrated at the beginning of each day using a DryCal DC-Lite Primary Flow Meter (Bios International Corporation, Butler, NJ). Flow rates were measured again near the middle and at the end of each day to ensure that sampling flow rates were maintained within 5% of pre-sampling flow rates throughout the day. Average flow rates were used to calculate sample air volumes. Samples were analyzed by R.J. Lee Group, Inc., (Monroeville, PA) using NIOSH Method 0600, to determine exposure to total mass of respirable dust. The same samples were also analyzed using X-Ray diffraction following NIOSH method 7500 to determine quartz, cristobalite and tridymite concentration in the respirable mass. Reported masses for these analytes were used with the sample air volumes to calculate airborne concentrations of total respirable dust, quartz, cristobalite and tridymite.
We used a reduction of greater than 50 percent in respirable silica exposure concentrations or a reduction to less than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 as our criteria for determining whether or not a control was considered efficacious. This is consistent with criteria used by NIOSH in conducting a similar study in 2004 described by Echt et al. (2007) and by CPWR in 2006 and described by Meeker et al. (2009). The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) and the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) publish additional occupational exposure limits (OELs) for silica which are listed in Table 1 with NIOSH RELs. OELs for silica are based on the respirable fraction of the aerosol, which consists of particles less than 10 micrometers in aerodynamic diameter.
| Organization or Agency | Form of Crystalline Silica | Occupational Exposure Limits (mg/m3) |
|---|---|---|
| NIOSHA | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 |
| OSHA - ConstructionB | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
PEL = 250 / (5 + % quartz) PEL = 250 / (5 + % cristobalite) PEL = 250 / (5 + % tridymite) |
| ACGIH | Crystalline Silica | TLV = 0.025 mg/m3 |
A NIOSH Publication No. 2005-151 indicates 10-hour time-weighted average during a 40-hr workweek B The PEL for silica in OSHA’s Safety and Health Regulations for Construction, 29 C.F.R. 1926.55(a), is an 8-hour time-weighted average (TWA) expressed in millions of particles per cubic foot (mppcf). However, the units mppcf can be converted to milligrams per cubic meter can by dividing mppcf by 10 (OSHA, 2009). The formula used by OSHA to determine the PEL for silica is dependent on the percentage of silica in each collected sample. The concentration of respirable dust measured is compared to the sample specific PEL to determine if the PEL has been exceeded. OSHA has proposed lowering the PEL to 0.05 mg/m3 of respirable silica as an 8 hour TWA. |
||
The flow of air in ventilation systems is governed by fundamental principles that describe the behavior of gases (in this case air). Pressure measurements taken within a ventilation system along with knowledge of hood (or shroud) entry losses can be used to calculate flow rates. Hood entry losses are dependent on the shape and configuration of a particular hood or shroud and described by the term “coefficient of entry (Ce)” which is the ratio of actual air flow through a hood and what the air flow would theoretically be if there were no hood entry losses. Given the coefficient of entry, static pressure measurements can be used to calculate air flow through a given hood. The coefficient of entry for the Dust Director shroud was previously determined by CPWR and used for calculating air flow based on static pressure measurements (Meeker et al., 2009). Static pressure, with the vacuum operating, was measured periodically throughout the evaluation to monitor the changes in air-flow rate following use and again after filter cleaning. The static pressure was measured at a port positioned more than 3 duct diameters downstream from the tool’s air intake using a UEi EM200 Electronic Manometer (Universal Enterprises, Inc., Beaverton, OR).
The dust in the vacuum bag was monitored and, per the manufacturer’s instructions, the bag was changed before the dust level was within 5 centimeters of the valve at the bottom of the vacuum. Each time a vacuum bag was removed, it was weighed to the nearest pound. The bag weights and corresponding grinding durations were used to calculate the average weight of dust collected per unit time. After each trial, cut lengths were measured on the wall to determine total linear feet of vertical (head) and horizontal (bed) joints per unit time.
A Haz-Dust III, Model HD-1003, Real-Time Aerosol Monitor (Environmental Devices Corporation, Plaistow, NH) was used to confirm clearance of dust between trials. The Haz-Dust monitor was positioned on the test wall near the operator at approximately breathing zone level and configured to measure respirable particulate concentration.
V. Results
Personal air monitoring
Five pairs of respirable dust samples were collected while grinding with and without the vacuum system. In addition, three respirable dust samples were collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place. One measurement collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard was shown to be a statistical outlier and was omitted from analysis. Personal air monitoring results for respirable silica and a comparison of average exposures relative to the NIOSH REL for silica (0.05 mg/m3) appears in Table 2. The mean respirable dust levels measured without LEV was 31.4 mg/m3. However, samples collected with LEV were below the limit of quantification (LOQ) which ranged from <1.29 to <1.46 mg/m3. Use of LEV resulted in a greater than 95% reduction in mean respirable dust levels using a mean value with use of LEV of <1.41 (n=5 samples with use of LEV and n=7 without use of LEV). The respirable dust samples collected during grinding without the LEV system contained an average of 24 percent silica. The mass of respirable dust in the samples collected with use of the LEV system was too low to determine the silica content.| Mean, mg/m3 (range) | Std. Dev. | Percent Reduction | Hazard RatioB | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bosch with Dust Director Shroud and DustControl 2900c Vacuum |
0.091 (<0.069 – 0.137) |
0.027 | 98.7 | 1.81 |
| Bosch with no Control | 7.23 (4.57 – 9.90) |
1.94 | NA | 145 |
A n = 5 samples for each tool/control combination and n = 7 samples without the use of the LEV system B Hazard Ratio = measured exposure / NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 |
||||
Average respirable silica and dust exposures, with and without the dust control system, appear as Figures 5 and 6, respectively.
Figure 5. Average respirable silica exposures with and without the Dustcontrol 2900c vacuum and Dust Director shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air - mg/m3)
Figure 6. Average respirable dust exposures with and without Dustcontrol 2900c Vacuum and Dust Director Shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air – mg/m3)
The mean respirable silica concentration measured during use of the control was significantly less than the concentration measured while using the same tool without controls (p<0.01). Grinding mortar with the Bosch angle grinder without dust controls resulted in an average exposure to respirable silica that was 145 times the NIOSH REL. Grinding with the Bosch angle grinder in combination with the Dust Director shroud and the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced the average concentration of respirable silica by 98.7 percent. With use of these controls, the concentration of respirable silica was 1.8 times greater than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3. However the NIOSH REL is based on a time-weighted average (TWA) over a 10-hour workday. Given these were task TWAs and samples were collected over continuous periods of grinding, they may overestimate exposures over an actual work day since some time would be spent performing tasks that would likely have lower, or no, silica exposures (setup, breaks, cleanup, etc.).
Static pressure, dust mass collection and grinding rates.
Static pressure was used as a surrogate for air flow as described earlier. Hood static pressure was measured periodically at a tap near the grinder more than 3 duct diameters from the air intake in the shroud. The static pressure, and thus air flow, was generally higher when the vacuum’s filter had recently been cleaned. The mean, median, and range of calculated flow rates are presented in Table A1 of the Appendix.
Based on the data we collected, the air-flow rate upstream from the Bosch grinder and Dust Director shroud ranged from 78 to 93 cubic feet per minute (cfm) with the DustControl vacuum. When the manufacturer’s filter cleaning procedure was followed the vacuum performed relatively well and flow could be maintained at slightly less than 90 cfm with cleaning. However, mean flow rates dropped substantially to 80 cfm after as little as 8 minutes of grinding without any filter cleaning. The flow rate returned to an average of 89 cfm when filters were cleaned correctly (without stopping air flow to the vacuum). Collingwood and Heitbrink (2007) found that the minimum exhaust flow rate for capture of silica and other particulate under ideal conditions is 21.25 cfm per inch of grinder blade diameter. This is equal to about 96 cfm when using a 4.5 inch diameter grinding blade. We set 106 cfm as the minimum desired flow rate for this study to allow a safety margin for potential decline in equipment performance and the possibility of inadequate maintenance, both of which may be likely after repeated use under actual work conditions. The DustControl vacuum provided slightly less than the minimum flow rate described by Collingwood and Heitbrink for a 4.5-inch blade and the peak flow rate fell with use.
The duration of vacuum bag use and mass of dust collected were recorded and are presented in Table A2 of the Appendix. The vacuum bags were changed and weighed after each trial utilizing the LEV system. A total of five bags were used to complete the five rounds of grinding. The DustControl vacuum captured 45 pounds of dust over 83 minutes of grinding for an average rate of dust collection of 0.54 pounds per minute. The rate of dust collection ranged from 0.47 to 0.63 pounds per minute. Based on these measurements, approximately 130 pounds of dust would likely be captured after just 4 hours of continuous grinding.
The rate of grinding a combination of vertical and horizontal joints while using the LEV system ranged from 2.3 to 3.3 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the use of the LEV system ranged from 2.6 to 3.4 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place ranged from 4.7 to 5.1 feet per minute. It’s important to note that: 1) the operator had limited experience using dust control systems and cut rates appeared to improve slightly over the 2-day period he used the tested equipment; and 2) the upper range of cut rates with the dust control system overlapped with the lowest cut rate with the original guard and without the LEV system in place indicating no statistical difference between cut rates. Given that grinding rates with and without use of this LEV system are only available for one operator and he had limited experience with the LEV system, these reported cut rates are in no way intended to represent the impact use of this LEV system is likely to have on productivity rates overall.
VI. Discussion
The objective of these trials was to evaluate the effectiveness of a tuckpointing LEV system for controlling respirable silica while grinding out mortar joints. The Dust Director shroud with the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced respirable silica concentrations when grinding with the Bosch grinder by approximately 99 percent. Despite being considered effective by our test criteria (greater than 50% reduction), it still resulted in task TWA exposures that exceeded the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 by 1.8 times. Depending on how much time is spent grinding over the course of a work day and on exposures while performing other tasks, the 8-hour TWA exposures may or may not exceed the REL with this system. Use of this system by workers with experience and training in proficient use will likely improve dust capture performance. Exposure reduction is greatly influenced by correct use of this system which includes grinding from right to left, making sure the shroud is held flush against the wall and that the tool travels at a pace that doesn’t exceed the ability of the system to capture dust as it’s generated. Deviation from any of these measures produces visible dust clouds which were observed during trials.
VII. Conclusions
With a 99 percent reduction in respirable silica exposure, the Dust Director shroud and DustControl 2900c vacuum with a Bosch Model 1775E grinder was effective in reducing silica exposures based on our criteria. Use of the tested dust control system may be effective in reducing silica exposure on the job to less than the NIOSH REL if used in combination with administrative controls such as work scheduling to reduce cutting times as needed. Training on correct use of the tested system is also essential. Personal air monitoring is necessary to verify control effectiveness on actual job sites and under “real-world” conditions. However, these results clearly demonstrate the availability of viable and effective engineering controls for tuckpointing operations associated with elevated silica exposure.
VIII. References
American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists. Threshold limit values for chemical substances (TLV®-CS). [2013]. ACGIH, Cincinnati, Ohio.
Bergdahl I.A,. Toren K., Eriksson K., et al. [2004]. Increased mortality in COPD among construction workers exposed to inorganic dust. European Respiratory Journal, 23: 402–06.
Blanc P.D. & Torén K. [2007]. Occupation in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and chronic bronchitis: an update [State of the Art Series. Occupational lung disease in high-and low-income countries, Edited by M. Chan-Yeung. Number 2 in the series]. The International Journal of Tuberculosis and Lung Disease, 11(3), 251-257.
Collingwood S. & Heitbrink W.A. [2007] 'Field Evaluation of an Engineering Control for Respirable Crystalline Silica Exposures During Mortar Removal'. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, 4:11, 875 – 887.
DHHS (NIOSH) Publication No. 2002-129 April 2002 http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/2002-129/
Echt A., Sieber W.K., Lefkowitz D., Meeker J., Susi P., Cardwell B., Heitbrink, W.A. In-depth survey of dust control technology for cutting concrete block and tuckpointing brick at The International Masonry Institute Bordentown Training Center, Bordentown, NJ. Cincinnati, OH: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Report. No. EPHB 282-13; 2007. http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ECTB-282-13.pdf
Heitbrink W., Bennett J. [2006]. A numerical and experimental investigation of crystalline silica exposure control during tuck pointing. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, Vol. 3, pp 366-378.
Lyons et al, [2007]. A breathless builder. Breathe, Vol. 3, no. 4, pp 386-390.
Mastrangelo G., Tartari M., Fedeli U., Fadda E., Saia B. [2003]. Ascertaining the risk of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease in relation to occupation using a case-control design. Occupational Medicine, 53: 165–172.
Meeker J., Cooper M., Lefrowitz D., Susi P. [2009]. Engineering control technologies to reduce occupational silica exposures in masonry cutting and tuckpointing. Public Health Reports, Supplement 1, Vol. 124, June.
Meeker J, Flynn M, Susi P, Cardwell, B [2004]. Performance evaluation of a masonry concrete vacuum. Unpublished Report.
Miller F. W., Alfredsson L., Costenbader K. H., Kamen D. L., Nelson L. M., Norris J. M., & De Roos A. J. [2012]. Epidemiology of environmental exposures and human autoimmune diseases: findings from a National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences Expert Panel workshop. Journal of autoimmunity. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3496812/
Occupational Safety and Health Administration U.S Department of Labor. Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction. [2009]. OSHA 3362-05.
Rappaport SM, Goldberg M, Susi P, Herrick RF [2003]. Excessive exposure to silica in the U.S. construction industry. Annals of Occupational Hygiene, Vol. 47, pp. 111-122.
IX. Appendices
| Measurement Conditions |
n | Mean Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Median
Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before filter cleaning | 5 | 80 | 81 | 78-81 |
| After filter cleaning following manufacturer directions | 9 | 89 | 90 | 84-93 |
| * Static pressure was measured in millibars and converted to inches of water gauge. Flow rates were calculated using the formula Q = Ce (A) 4005 (SP)1/2 where: Q = flow in cubic feet per minute (cfm), Ce = coefficient of entry, A = area of the duct where static pressure measurements were taken in square feet, and SP = static pressure in inches of water gauge. | ||||
| Tool/Control | Collection Period (min.) |
Dust Collection Rate (lb/min.) |
|---|---|---|
| Bosch grinder/Dust Director shroud & DustControl 2900c vacuum |
8 11 8 8 10 |
0.50 0.61 0.50 0.47 0.63 |
| Average | 0.54 |
[disclaimer:protected] => [disclaimer_transformed:protected] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [template] => record ) [_globalContext:PHPTAL_Context:private] => stdClass Object ( ) [_echoDeclarations:PHPTAL_Context:private] => [referer] => http://www.elcosh.org/document/3908/d001345/An%2BEvaluation%2Bof%2BSilica%2BExposure%2BControls%2Bfor%2BTuckpointing%253A%2BDustControl%2B2900c%2BVacuum%2Bwith%2Bthe%2BICS%2BDust%2BDirector%2BShroud%2Band%2BBosch%2BGrinder%2BModel%2B1775E%2BConducted%2BNovember%2B14-15%252C%2B2012.html [curr_module] => Record [styles] => Array ( ) [javascript] => Array ( [0] => jquery.min.js ) [metas] => Array ( [language] => en [robots] => index, follow ) [user] => [curr_url] => https://www.elcosh.org/index.php?module=Record&id=3908&type=document [base_url] => https://www.elcosh.org/index.php?module=Record [title] => eLCOSH : An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: DustControl 2900c Vacuum with the ICS Dust Director Shroud and Bosch Grinder Model 1775E Conducted November 14-15, 2012 [language] => en [search_query] => [module] => Record [new_records] => Array ( [0] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Fixed Ladder [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Fixed Ladders addresses the potential risks associated with using fixed ladders. The resource includes a brief case example,... [category] => Array ( [0] => 15 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 53 [5] => 55 [6] => 60 [7] => 64 [8] => 73 [9] => 76 [10] => 78 [11] => 80 [12] => 86 [13] => 87 [14] => 90 [15] => 92 [16] => 93 [17] => 94 [18] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Falls [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Concrete Polisher [11] => Electrical Worker [13] => HVAC [15] => Laborer [17] => PCC/Restoration [19] => Plumber/Pipefitter [21] => Roofer/Waterproofer [23] => Sheetmetal Worker [25] => Welder [27] => Commercial & Institutional [28] => Jobsites [29] => Industrial [31] => LEED/Green Construction [33] => Renovations [35] => Residential [37] => Toolbox Talks [38] => Documents [39] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4430/d001660/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BFixed%2BLadder.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [53] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 53 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Concrete Polisher [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [73] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 73 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => PCC/Restoration [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4430 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001660 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Fixed Ladder [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Fixed Ladders, Fall Prevention, Falls [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Fixed Ladders addresses the potential risks associated with using fixed ladders. The resource includes a brief case example, steps to prevent a related injury and questions for discussion. It includes an image that illustrates the hazard, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001257,d001254,d001255,d001256,d001258,d001262,d001279 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_completed:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/22/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [1] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Challenges Preventing Falling Objects [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Challenges Preventing Falling Objects addresses the hazards of being struck by falling objects on the job site. The resource... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 55 [5] => 64 [6] => 68 [7] => 71 [8] => 75 [9] => 78 [10] => 79 [11] => 82 [12] => 62 [13] => 86 [14] => 87 [15] => 88 [16] => 89 [17] => 91 [18] => 90 [19] => 92 [20] => 93 [21] => 94 [22] => 95 [23] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Electrical Worker [11] => Laborer [13] => Maintenance Worker [15] => Painter [17] => Plasterer [19] => Roofer/Waterproofer [21] => Scaffold Erector [23] => Stonemason [25] => Structural Ironworker [27] => Welder [29] => Commercial & Institutional [30] => Jobsites [31] => Demolition [33] => Disasters [35] => Heavy & Highway [37] => Industrial [39] => LEED/Green Construction [41] => Renovations [43] => Residential [45] => Underground [47] => Toolbox Talks [48] => Documents [49] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4431/d001661/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BChallenges%2BPreventing%2BFalling%2BObjects.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4431 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001661 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Challenges Preventing Falling Objects [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => dropped objects, falling objects, struck by incidents, struck by fatalities [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Challenges Preventing Falling Objects addresses the hazards of being struck by falling objects on the job site. The resource includes a brief example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates a group workers observing a scaffold free of debris during high winds, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001234,d001238,d001244,d001251,d001253,d001260,d001268,d001278 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_completed:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/22/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [2] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Tower Crane Safety [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Tower Crane Safety addresses the potential hazards of Tower Cranes and the importance of following procedure before and durin... [category] => Array ( [0] => 11 [1] => 12 [2] => 18 [3] => 70 [4] => 87 [5] => 88 [6] => 91 [7] => 90 [8] => 92 [9] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Cranes & Hoists [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Crushed/Struck By [6] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [9] => Operating Engineer [10] => Trades [11] => Commercial & Institutional [12] => Jobsites [13] => Demolition [15] => Heavy & Highway [17] => Industrial [19] => LEED/Green Construction [21] => Toolbox Talks [22] => Documents [23] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4427/d001657/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BTower%2BCrane%2BSafety.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [11] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 11 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Cranes & Hoists [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [18] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 18 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4427 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001657 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Tower Crane Safety [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Tower Crane, Crane, Stability, Tipping, Lift Zone Safety, Lift, Zone, Safety, Struck by [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Tower Crane Safety addresses the potential hazards of Tower Cranes and the importance of following procedure before and during Tower Crane operation. The resource includes a brief example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates a worker inspecting a Tower Crane before operation, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001234,d001238,d001250,d001251,d001253,d001258,d001262,d001273 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/19/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [3] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Work Zone Safety: Working Around Vehicles [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Working Around Vehicles in the Work Zone addresses methods to avoid being struck-by a vehicle on a construction site. The res... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 18 [2] => 52 [3] => 57 [4] => 70 [5] => 85 [6] => 87 [7] => 88 [8] => 89 [9] => 91 [10] => 90 [11] => 92 [12] => 93 [13] => 94 [14] => 95 [15] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [6] => Commercial Diver [7] => Trades [8] => Flagger [10] => Operating Engineer [12] => Truck Driver [14] => Commercial & Institutional [15] => Jobsites [16] => Demolition [18] => Disasters [20] => Heavy & Highway [22] => Industrial [24] => LEED/Green Construction [26] => Renovations [28] => Residential [30] => Underground [32] => Toolbox Talks [33] => Documents [34] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4428/d001658/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BWork%2BZone%2BSafety%253A%2BWorking%2BAround%2BVehicles.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [18] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 18 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [52] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 52 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Commercial Diver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [85] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 85 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Truck Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4428 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001658 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Daniela Caceres [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Work Zone Safety: Working Around Vehicles [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Struck, Struck by, Vehicle, Work Zone Safety, Truck, Operator, Driver, Mobile Equipment [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Working Around Vehicles in the Work Zone addresses methods to avoid being struck-by a vehicle on a construction site. The resource includes a case example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates the hazard, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001640 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/19/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [4] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Construction Dive -- DeWalt's Jobsite Pro headphones recalled for fire hazards [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => A recall notice by the United States Consumer Product Safety Commission affects over 300,000 DeWalt Jobsite Pro Headphones. The recall is a result of... [category] => Array ( [0] => 16 [1] => 44 [2] => 45 [3] => 46 [4] => 47 [5] => 48 [6] => 49 [7] => 50 [8] => 51 [9] => 52 [10] => 53 [11] => 54 [12] => 55 [13] => 56 [14] => 57 [15] => 58 [16] => 59 [17] => 60 [18] => 61 [19] => 64 [20] => 65 [21] => 66 [22] => 67 [23] => 68 [24] => 69 [25] => 70 [26] => 71 [27] => 72 [28] => 73 [29] => 74 [30] => 75 [31] => 76 [32] => 77 [33] => 63 [34] => 78 [35] => 79 [36] => 80 [37] => 81 [38] => 82 [39] => 62 [40] => 83 [41] => 84 [42] => 85 [43] => 86 [44] => 87 [45] => 88 [46] => 89 [47] => 91 [48] => 90 [49] => 92 [50] => 93 [51] => 94 [52] => 95 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Fire & Explosions [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Acoustical Ceiling Carpenter [4] => Trades [5] => Asbestos/Insulator [7] => Boilermaker [9] => Bricklayer [11] => Cabinetmaker [13] => Carpenter [15] => Carpet Layer [17] => Cement Mason [19] => Commercial Diver [21] => Concrete Polisher [23] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [25] => Electrical Worker [27] => Elevator Constructor [29] => Flagger [31] => Glazier [33] => Hazardous Waste Cleanup [35] => HVAC [37] => Interior Systems Carpenter [39] => Laborer [41] => Landscaper [43] => Lather [45] => Lead Abatement Worker [47] => Maintenance Worker [49] => Millwright [51] => Operating Engineer [53] => Painter [55] => Paper Hanger [57] => PCC/Restoration [59] => Pile Driver [61] => Plasterer [63] => Plumber/Pipefitter [65] => Refractory Worker [67] => Reinforcing Ironworker [69] => Roofer/Waterproofer [71] => Scaffold Erector [73] => Sheetmetal Worker [75] => Sprinkler Fitter [77] => Stonemason [79] => Structural Ironworker [81] => Terrazzo Worker [83] => Tile Setter [85] => Truck Driver [87] => Welder [89] => Commercial & Institutional [90] => Jobsites [91] => Demolition [93] => Disasters [95] => Heavy & Highway [97] => Industrial [99] => LEED/Green Construction [101] => Renovations [103] => Residential [105] => Underground ) [type] => [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4426/d001656/Construction%2BDive%2B--%2BDeWalt%2527s%2BJobsite%2BPro%2Bheadphones%2Brecalled%2Bfor%2Bfire%2Bhazards.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [16] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 16 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Fire & Explosions [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [44] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 44 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Acoustical Ceiling Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [45] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 45 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Asbestos/Insulator [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [46] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 46 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Boilermaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [48] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 48 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cabinetmaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [50] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 50 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpet Layer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [52] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 52 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Commercial Diver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [53] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 53 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Concrete Polisher [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [54] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 54 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [58] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 58 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Glazier [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [59] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 59 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Hazardous Waste Cleanup [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [65] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 65 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Landscaper [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [66] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 66 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Lather [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [67] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 67 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Lead Abatement Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [69] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 69 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Millwright [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [72] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 72 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Paper Hanger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [73] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 73 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => PCC/Restoration [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [77] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 77 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Refractory Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [81] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 81 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sprinkler Fitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [83] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 83 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Terrazzo Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [84] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 84 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Tile Setter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [85] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 85 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Truck Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4426 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001656 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Construction Dive -- DeWalt's Jobsite Pro headphones recalled for fire hazards [total_pages:protected] => 1 [billed_pages:protected] => 1 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => DeWalt, Fire Hazards, recall, headphones [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A recall notice by the United States Consumer Product Safety Commission affects over 300,000 DeWalt Jobsite Pro Headphones. The recall is a result of a malfunction that can cause earbuds to overheat while charging or during use, leading to fire and burn hazards. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => https://www.constructiondive.com/news/dewalts-jobsite-pro-headphones-recalled-for-fire-hazards/611248/?utm_source=Sailthru&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Issue:%202021-12-10%20Construction%20Dive%20Newsletter%20%5Bissue:38532%5D&utm_term=Construction%20Dive [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/13/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/13/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 12/13/21 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [new_images] => Array ( [0] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Morning Toolbox Talk [image] => /record/images/4003-p.jpg [blurb] => This photo is from an early morning toolbox talk on a construction job in Mclean, Virginia. It is being delivered in English and Spanish.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 20 [1] => 51 [2] => 57 [3] => 64 [4] => 70 [5] => 63 [6] => 78 [7] => 82 [8] => 62 [9] => 87 [10] => 88 [11] => 89 [12] => 91 [13] => 90 [14] => 93 [15] => 94 [16] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Safety Culture [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Cement Mason [4] => Trades [5] => Flagger [7] => Laborer [9] => Operating Engineer [11] => Reinforcing Ironworker [13] => Roofer/Waterproofer [15] => Stonemason [17] => Structural Ironworker [19] => Commercial & Institutional [20] => Jobsites [21] => Demolition [23] => Disasters [25] => Heavy & Highway [27] => Industrial [29] => Renovations [31] => Residential [33] => Images [34] => Media [35] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4003/i002691/Morning%2BToolbox%2BTalk.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4003 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002691 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Morning Toolbox Talk [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, Spanish, bilingual [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This photo is from an early morning toolbox talk on a construction job in Mclean, Virginia. It is being delivered in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001285,d001304,c000079 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [1] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox talk - crew view [image] => /record/images/4005-p.jpg [blurb] => Photo of crew listening to a toolbox safety talk before starting work.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 97 [1] => 20 [2] => 47 [3] => 49 [4] => 51 [5] => 55 [6] => 61 [7] => 64 [8] => 71 [9] => 75 [10] => 63 [11] => 79 [12] => 62 [13] => 87 [14] => 88 [15] => 91 [16] => 90 [17] => 93 [18] => 94 [19] => 95 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Images [1] => Media [2] => Media & Documents [3] => Safety Culture [4] => Work Environment [5] => Hazards [6] => Bricklayer [7] => Trades [8] => Carpenter [10] => Cement Mason [12] => Electrical Worker [14] => Interior Systems Carpenter [16] => Laborer [18] => Painter [20] => Plasterer [22] => Reinforcing Ironworker [24] => Scaffold Erector [26] => Structural Ironworker [28] => Commercial & Institutional [29] => Jobsites [30] => Demolition [32] => Heavy & Highway [34] => Industrial [36] => Renovations [38] => Residential [40] => Underground ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4005/i002692/Toolbox%2Btalk%2B-%2Bcrew%2Bview.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4005 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002692 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox talk - crew view [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, safety talk, Spanish [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Photo of crew listening to a toolbox safety talk before starting work. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002691,d001269, c000079, d001285 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [2] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox talk - long shot [image] => /record/images/4006-p.jpg [blurb] => This crew gathered every morning before starting work to discuss a new safety topic.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 20 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 55 [5] => 64 [6] => 68 [7] => 75 [8] => 76 [9] => 63 [10] => 78 [11] => 79 [12] => 82 [13] => 62 [14] => 87 [15] => 88 [16] => 91 [17] => 90 [18] => 93 [19] => 94 [20] => 95 [21] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Safety Culture [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Electrical Worker [11] => Laborer [13] => Maintenance Worker [15] => Plasterer [17] => Plumber/Pipefitter [19] => Reinforcing Ironworker [21] => Roofer/Waterproofer [23] => Scaffold Erector [25] => Stonemason [27] => Structural Ironworker [29] => Commercial & Institutional [30] => Jobsites [31] => Demolition [33] => Heavy & Highway [35] => Industrial [37] => Renovations [39] => Residential [41] => Underground [43] => Images [44] => Media [45] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4006/i002693/Toolbox%2Btalk%2B-%2Blong%2Bshot.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4006 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002693 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox talk - long shot [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, safety minute [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This crew gathered every morning before starting work to discuss a new safety topic. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002691,i002692,d001269,d000527 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [3] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Safety officer discussing ongoing project with marketing coordinator [image] => /record/images/4014-p.jpg [blurb] => The safety officer (left) points out the good safety practices on this project that reflect well on the firm and may influence future clients.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 97 [1] => 20 [2] => 46 [3] => 47 [4] => 49 [5] => 50 [6] => 51 [7] => 54 [8] => 55 [9] => 58 [10] => 60 [11] => 61 [12] => 64 [13] => 71 [14] => 75 [15] => 76 [16] => 63 [17] => 79 [18] => 80 [19] => 82 [20] => 62 [21] => 83 [22] => 87 [23] => 91 [24] => 90 [25] => 93 [26] => 94 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Images [1] => Media [2] => Media & Documents [3] => Safety Culture [4] => Work Environment [5] => Hazards [6] => Boilermaker [7] => Trades [8] => Bricklayer [10] => Carpenter [12] => Carpet Layer [14] => Cement Mason [16] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [18] => Electrical Worker [20] => Glazier [22] => HVAC [24] => Interior Systems Carpenter [26] => Laborer [28] => Painter [30] => Plasterer [32] => Plumber/Pipefitter [34] => Reinforcing Ironworker [36] => Scaffold Erector [38] => Sheetmetal Worker [40] => Stonemason [42] => Structural Ironworker [44] => Terrazzo Worker [46] => Commercial & Institutional [47] => Jobsites [48] => Heavy & Highway [50] => Industrial [52] => Renovations [54] => Residential ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4014/i002700/Safety%2Bofficer%2Bdiscussing%2Bongoing%2Bproject%2Bwith%2Bmarketing%2Bcoordinator.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [46] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 46 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Boilermaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [50] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 50 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpet Layer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [54] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 54 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [58] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 58 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Glazier [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [83] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 83 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Terrazzo Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4014 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002700 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Safety officer discussing ongoing project with marketing coordinator [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Latino, safety officer, safety culture [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The safety officer (left) points out the good safety practices on this project that reflect well on the firm and may influence future clients. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/index.php [more_like_this:protected] => d000989,d001351,d001362,d000652, d001101, d000931, d001395 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Hoar Construction, Photo by Neil Lippy [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 01/30/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [4] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Scaffolding at top of large column [image] => /record/images/3994-p.jpg [blurb] => This shot shows innovative guarding around the top of a large concrete column in the base of a high rise structure going up.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 15 [1] => 21 [2] => 47 [3] => 51 [4] => 63 [5] => 78 [6] => 79 [7] => 80 [8] => 62 [9] => 87 [10] => 97 [11] => 56 [12] => 64 [13] => 74 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Falls [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Scaffolds [6] => Bricklayer [7] => Trades [8] => Cement Mason [10] => Reinforcing Ironworker [12] => Roofer/Waterproofer [14] => Scaffold Erector [16] => Sheetmetal Worker [18] => Structural Ironworker [20] => Commercial & Institutional [21] => Jobsites [22] => Images [23] => Media [24] => Media & Documents [25] => Elevator Constructor [27] => Laborer [29] => Pile Driver ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/3994/i002689/Scaffolding%2Bat%2Btop%2Bof%2Blarge%2Bcolumn.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [21] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 21 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Scaffolds [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3994 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002689 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Scaffolding at top of large column [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Guardrail, railing, fall prevention, falls [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This shot shows innovative guarding around the top of a large concrete column in the base of a high rise structure going up. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/8/adjustable-tower-scaffold.html [more_like_this:protected] => c1002680,i002662,d000608,d001255 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Photo by Pam Susi [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2016 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_completed:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/01/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [5] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Construction bracing [image] => /record/images/3995-p.jpg [blurb] => This shows structural support that prevents collapses during construction.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 15 [2] => 21 [3] => 49 [4] => 51 [5] => 55 [6] => 56 [7] => 60 [8] => 64 [9] => 68 [10] => 74 [11] => 63 [12] => 78 [13] => 79 [14] => 80 [15] => 62 [16] => 87 [17] => 90 [18] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Falls [6] => Scaffolds [9] => Carpenter [10] => Trades [11] => Cement Mason [13] => Electrical Worker [15] => Elevator Constructor [17] => HVAC [19] => Laborer [21] => Maintenance Worker [23] => Pile Driver [25] => Reinforcing Ironworker [27] => Roofer/Waterproofer [29] => Scaffold Erector [31] => Sheetmetal Worker [33] => Structural Ironworker [35] => Commercial & Institutional [36] => Jobsites [37] => Industrial [39] => Images [40] => Media [41] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/3995/i002690/Construction%2Bbracing.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [21] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 21 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Scaffolds [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3995 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002690 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Construction bracing [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Bracing, support, scaffold [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This shows structural support that prevents collapses during construction. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/8/adjustable-tower-scaffold.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002660 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Photo by Pam Susi [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2016 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_completed:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/01/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [preview_mode] => [description] => The results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. [keywords] => tuckpointing, HEPA vacuum, dust control, LEV, local exhaust ventilation, silica [related_items] => Array ( [Research Reports] => Array ( [0] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1874 [old_id:protected] => 722 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000683 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Sharon Garber/COD [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Protecting Tuckpointing Workers from Silica Dust: Draft Recommendations for a Ventilated Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 12 [billed_pages:protected] => 12 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, vacuum, grinder, mortar, respirator, OSHA, NIOSH, exhaust, Heitbrink, tuckpointer, silica, masonry, dust, silicosis, LEV [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Describes draft recommendations for use of ventilated grinder to reduce dust during tuckpointing and describes field trials using these devices. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/hazard/67/chip-scrape-and-grind-surfaces-or-joints-silica.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001201,d000292,d000293,d000658 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2005 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/27/05 [date_completed:protected] => 04/26/05 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/20/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [1] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1940 [old_id:protected] => 909 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Workplace Solutions: Control of Hazardous Dust During Tuckpointing [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, silica, dust, tuckpoint, grinder, masonry restoration, mortar, vacuum [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d000819,d000820,d000730,d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 10/24/08 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/09 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [2] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3899 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001342 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: Hilti VC40-U Vacuum with Hilti DC-EX Dust Guard and Hilti Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 15 [billed_pages:protected] => 15 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP4 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => silica, tuckpointing, Hilti, local exhaust systems, LEV, shroud, quartz [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This report describes the results of an evaluation of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Hilti VC40-U vacuum, a Hilti DC-EX shroud, and a Hilti DAG-500 grinder. Randomized trials with and without use of the dust control system were conducted in a controlled setting. Removing mortar with the Hilti grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 220 times the National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05mg/m3. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 97 percent. However, exposures measured during the use of the dust control system still exceeded the NIOSH REL. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => December 1, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/05/14 [date_completed:protected] => 02/04/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/06/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [Handouts] => Array ( [0] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3656 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001198 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 24 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction While Doing Tuckpointing/Mortar Removal [total_pages:protected] => 2 [billed_pages:protected] => 2 [publication_number:protected] => DSG FS-3632 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Brick, block, tuckpointing, silica, local exhaust ventilation, LEV, masonry [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Tuckpointing creates some of the greatest exposures to silica in construction. This OSHA factsheet provides guidance on how to greatly reduce these exposures through the use of local exhaust ventilation. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863, d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => February 2013 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/04/13 [date_completed:protected] => 03/27/13 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [collections] => Array ( [3913] => ) [record] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => Array ( [867] => Author Object ( [id:protected] => 867 [organization_id:protected] => 0 [firstname:protected] => Michael [lastname:protected] => Cooper [address:protected] => [city:protected] => [province:protected] => [country:protected] => [postal_code:protected] => [department:protected] => [title:protected] => [phone:protected] => [fax:protected] => [email:protected] => [degree:protected] => [website:protected] => [about:protected] => [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => [date_completed:protected] => [date_billed:protected] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [481] => Author Object ( [id:protected] => 481 [organization_id:protected] => 0 [firstname:protected] => Pam [lastname:protected] => Susi [address:protected] => 8484 Georgia Avenue, Suite 1000 [city:protected] => Silver Spring [province:protected] => Maryland [country:protected] => USA [postal_code:protected] => 20910 [department:protected] => [title:protected] => [phone:protected] => 301-578-8500 ext.144 [fax:protected] => 301-578-8572 [email:protected] => plsusi@aol.com [degree:protected] => [website:protected] => http://www.cpwr.com [about:protected] => [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => 2003-10-02 [date_completed:protected] => 2003-10-06 [date_billed:protected] => 2003-11-03 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [organizations:protected] => Array ( [1] => Organization Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [elcosh_id:protected] => o000001 [user_id:protected] => 14 [province_id:protected] => 21 [country_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => CPWR - The Center for Construction Research and Training [address:protected] => Suite 1000, 8484 Georgia Ave [postal_code:protected] => 20910 [city:protected] => Silver Spring [department:protected] => [phone:protected] => 301-578-8500 [fax:protected] => 301-578-8572 [email:protected] => cpwrwebsite@cpwr.com [website:protected] => http://www.cpwr.com [filename:protected] => o000001.gif [about:protected] => CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training, developed, and continues to maintain/expand this website - The Electronic Library of Construction Occupational Safety and Health, www.elcosh.org. CPWR, formerly known as The Center to Protect Workers’ Rights, is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit research and training institution. Created by the Building and Construction Trades Department, AFL-CIO, CPWR serves as the research arm of the BCTD. Since the inception of its research agenda in 1990, CPWR has grown into a worldwide provider of safety and health information covering all aspects of the construction industry. CPWR launched eLCOSH in 2000, and the Spanish-language version of the site in 2001. CPWR also created, and continues to build, Construction Solutions - www.cpwrConstructionSolutions.org - a free, online database of construction hazards and ways to prevent, eliminate, or reduce them. [comments:protected] => [logo_available:protected] => T [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => 2000-08-18 [date_completed:protected] => 2000-08-30 [date_billed:protected] => 2000-09-05 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [collections:protected] => Array ( [3913] => ) [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => Array ( [1874] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1874 [old_id:protected] => 722 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000683 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Sharon Garber/COD [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Protecting Tuckpointing Workers from Silica Dust: Draft Recommendations for a Ventilated Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 12 [billed_pages:protected] => 12 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, vacuum, grinder, mortar, respirator, OSHA, NIOSH, exhaust, Heitbrink, tuckpointer, silica, masonry, dust, silicosis, LEV [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Describes draft recommendations for use of ventilated grinder to reduce dust during tuckpointing and describes field trials using these devices. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/hazard/67/chip-scrape-and-grind-surfaces-or-joints-silica.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001201,d000292,d000293,d000658 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2005 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/27/05 [date_completed:protected] => 04/26/05 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/20/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [1940] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1940 [old_id:protected] => 909 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Workplace Solutions: Control of Hazardous Dust During Tuckpointing [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, silica, dust, tuckpoint, grinder, masonry restoration, mortar, vacuum [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d000819,d000820,d000730,d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 10/24/08 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/09 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [2213] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 2213 [old_id:protected] => 1090 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => [language_id:protected] => 2 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Control del polvo peligroso que se genera durante los procesos de reparación de mortero [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => 2008-126 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => [comments:protected] => http://www.cdc.gov/spanish/niosh/docs/wp-solutions/2008-126_sp/ [summary:protected] => A Workplace Solutions de NIOSH que resume un estudio de NIOSH sobre los riesgos de exposición cuando se reparan las estructuras y los métodos para controlar el polvo. [A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust.] [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => D000819,D000820,D000730,d000819 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 01/07/10 [date_completed:protected] => 04/19/10 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 07/08/12 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [3656] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3656 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001198 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 24 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction While Doing Tuckpointing/Mortar Removal [total_pages:protected] => 2 [billed_pages:protected] => 2 [publication_number:protected] => DSG FS-3632 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Brick, block, tuckpointing, silica, local exhaust ventilation, LEV, masonry [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Tuckpointing creates some of the greatest exposures to silica in construction. This OSHA factsheet provides guidance on how to greatly reduce these exposures through the use of local exhaust ventilation. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863, d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => February 2013 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/04/13 [date_completed:protected] => 03/27/13 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [3899] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3899 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001342 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: Hilti VC40-U Vacuum with Hilti DC-EX Dust Guard and Hilti Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 15 [billed_pages:protected] => 15 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP4 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => silica, tuckpointing, Hilti, local exhaust systems, LEV, shroud, quartz [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This report describes the results of an evaluation of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Hilti VC40-U vacuum, a Hilti DC-EX shroud, and a Hilti DAG-500 grinder. Randomized trials with and without use of the dust control system were conducted in a controlled setting. Removing mortar with the Hilti grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 220 times the National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05mg/m3. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 97 percent. However, exposures measured during the use of the dust control system still exceeded the NIOSH REL. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => December 1, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/05/14 [date_completed:protected] => 02/04/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/06/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [content:protected] => [files:protected] => Array ( [559] => [560] => [546] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 546 [filename:protected] => 3.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:22 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [566] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 566 [filename:protected] => 4.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:23 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [720] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 720 [filename:protected] => 5.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [721] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 721 [filename:protected] => 6.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [722] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 722 [filename:protected] => 7.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [9765] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 9765 [filename:protected] => d001345.pdf [downloadable:protected] => T [timestamp:protected] => 2015-02-09 12:26:04 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3908 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001345 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: DustControl 2900c Vacuum with the ICS Dust Director Shroud and Bosch Grinder Model 1775E Conducted November 14-15, 2012 [total_pages:protected] => 13 [billed_pages:protected] => 13 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP2 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => tuckpointing, HEPA vacuum, dust control, LEV, local exhaust ventilation, silica [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => April 15, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 01/26/15 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/09/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [show_text] => [document_content] => ElcoshItemDocumentContent Object ( [id:protected] => 2934 [item_id:protected] => 3908 [type:protected] => main [title:protected] => [content:protected] =>
Executive Summary
This report describes the results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. It should also be noted that the NIOSH REL is based on exposures averaged over a ten hour work day and our results represent time weighted averages of the sample task duration periods.
Acronyms
ACGIH - American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists
CPWR - CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training
Ce - coefficient of entry
HEPA - high-efficiency particulate air
IUBAC - International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craftworkers
LEV - local exhaust ventilation
PACT - Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies
NIOSH - National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health
OEL - occupational exposure limit
OSHA - Occupational Safety and Health Administration
PAPR - powered air-purifying respirator
PEL - Permissible Exposure Limit
PVC - polyvinyl chloride
REL - Recommended Exposure Limit
RPM - revolutions per minute
TWA - time-weighted average
SP - static pressure
I. Introduction and Background
In 2010 CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training began a four-year project which seeks to identify and evaluate tuckpointing local exhaust ventilation (LEV) systems and disseminate information on their availability and effectiveness. A Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies (PACT) comprised of masonry contractors, representatives from unions, government, equipment manufacturers, and health and safety researcher was formed as part of this project. PACT members participated in identifying important characteristics for control technologies and this information was used to identify LEV systems for tuckpointing using that criteria. Contractor and labor members of the PACT selected specific tuckpointing LEV systems to be considered for evaluation. Each system consisted of a tuckpointing grinder, shroud, and vacuum. This report describes the second of four systems to be evaluated between 2012 the end of 2014, with and without LEV, in a controlled setting to determine effectiveness in silica exposure reduction. This report describes the methods and results of our evaluation of a system consisting of the DustControl 2900c vacuum with the ICS Dust Director shroud and a Bosch Model 1775E grinder.
Excessive exposure to respirable silica can result in silicosis or other silica-related diseases including pulmonary tuberculosis, lung cancer, silicoproteinosis (Lyons et al, 2007) and autoimmune disorders such as rheumatoid arthritis, sarcoidosis and scleroderma (Miller et al, 2012). Respirable silica is generally defined as particles less than 10 micrometers (μm) in aerodynamic diameter (ACGIH, 2013). Silicosis can lead to symptoms including shortness of breath, fatigue, chest pains, susceptibility to infection and possibly death. There is no cure for silicosis, however it is totally preventable. Construction workers exposed to dust, including silica, are also known to have higher rates of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD).
There are many sources of silica in construction that result in exposures of varying intensity among workers. Masonry restoration workers are among the most highly silica-exposed trades in construction. The process of grinding out deteriorated mortar joints between masonry units and replacing or repointing with fresh mortar (often referred to as tuckpointing) is a fundamental part of masonry restoration work. The removal of mortar with powered angle grinders generates enormous levels of dust. Between 2004 and 2006, NIOSH and CPWR evaluated silica exposures while grinding mortar in a controlled setting, at a local training center, where tasks, sample times and task variables were defined by the study design. These studies demonstrated that grinding mortar without controls can result in elevated respirable silica exposures. Meeker et al., (2009) reported exposures between 5 and 25.8 milligrams per cubic meter (mg/m3) in a controlled setting. This study also showed that LEV systems for tuckpointing grinders can reduce exposures to respirable silica by greater than 90 percent.II. Objectives
The objective of this evaluation was to assess the effectiveness of an LEV system for controlling exposure to silica during the grinding of mortar. The control technology was tested under controlled conditions, similar to those experienced by tuckpointers on actual job sites, using journeymen bricklayers experienced in tuckpointing and repeat, randomized trials with and without LEV. All other variables were held constant throughout so that the only variable was whether or not the tested control was used.
III. Description of Equipment Tested
A Bosch model 1775E grinder (Robert Bosch Tool Corporation, Prospect, IL) (Figures 1, 2 and 3) was fitted with a new 1/4-inch wide, 4½-inch diameter segmented diamond abrasive blade made by DeWalt (model #DW4740). The grinder weighs six and a half pounds, draws 8.5 amps and has a variable speed up to 11,000 revolutions per minute (RPMs). The DustControl 2900c vacuum (DustControl, Inc., Wilmington, NC) (Figure 3) was tested in combination with the Dust Director shroud (Industrial Contractors’ Supplies, Inc., Huntingdon, PA) (Figures 1 and 3) attached to the Bosch grinder.
Figure 1. Bosch grinder with Dust Director shroud
Figure 2. Bosch grinder without tuckpointing LEV system.
Figure 3: Bosch Grinder with LEV System
The vacuum is specified to weigh 31 pounds when empty and to provide a flow rate of 114 cubic feet of air per minute and a “static lift” or “vacuum suction pressure” of 84 inches of water. The vacuum is sold with a cyclonic pre-separator, to remove larger particles, a fine filter (rated 99.9 percent efficient) and a HEPA (high-efficiency particulate air) filter (rated to capture 99.97 percent of the particles with an aerodynamic diameter of 0.3 micrometers). The HEPA filter was removed based on the manufacturer’s recommendation due to the heavy dust loading associated with tuckpointing. CPWR sponsored research and contractor experience indicate that HEPA filters likely have an adverse effect on dust capture during tuckpointing because of extreme dust loading on filters. While the cyclone and the fine filter remove most of the dust, especially the large particles, before they reach the HEPA filter, the HEPA filter would still be subject to heavy loading, causing a substantial pressure drop and subsequent decrease in air flow rate. The relatively small increase in the efficiency of the filtration system while using the HEPA filter is expected to be quickly offset by a more significant decrease in capture efficiency as the air flow rate and ability to capture particles decreases.
Dust collects in relatively inexpensive, heavy-gauge plastic bags below and outside of the cyclone. The bags can be removed and replaced without opening the vacuum. Some vacuums are equipped with a light to indicate that the filters need to be cleaned or changed. The DC2900c features a “reverse air pulse cleaning system,” which removes accumulated dust from the filters without having to remove them from the vacuum. The system, as illustrated in Figure 4, requires the operator to disconnect the hose from the shroud, place it over an air stop so that air through the hose is cut off and pressure in the vacuum is maximized.
Figure 4. Procedure for "cleaning" of or dust removal from filters (source: http://dustcontrolusa.com/manuals/2800c.pdf)
The flap covering the port on the side of the vacuum is repeatedly flipped open to release built up pressure in strong pulses that dislodge dust from the filter.
The manufacturer indicates “the filter is generally cleaned once or twice daily during normal continuous operation.” The Dust Director shroud has a 2-inch diameter take-off that was connected to the antistatic, corrugated 1.5-inch diameter, 15-foot long vacuum hose supplied with the DustControl vacuum.
IV. Study Methods
This evaluation was conducted at the International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craft workers (IUBAC) Local 1 Philadelphia/Delaware Training Center in Philadelphia, PA on November 14 and 15, 2012. A single journeyman bricklayer, experienced in tuckpointing, used the grinder and LEV system being tested to remove mortar from joints wide enough to require two passes. The type S mortar had been allowed to cure for at least four weeks. The bricklayer either possessed or was provided with personal protective equipment including sturdy work boots, gloves, hearing protection and a powered air-purifying respirator (PAPR). The PAPR was a 3M GVP system with a bump cap, loose fitting face piece and a HEPA filter (3M, St Paul, MN).
The study was designed to include at least five rounds of sampling during mortar removal. Each round included a trial using the Bosch grinder with a Dust Director shroud and Dust Collector 2900c vacuum and a trial using the Bosch grinder with the factory-supplied guard and without a vacuum. The order of the two trials within each round was randomly selected to minimize bias that might be introduced due to variation associated with environmental factors, equipment operator, blade wear, vacuum performance over time and any other factors unrelated to LEV use. Tools were operated for approximately 16 minutes per trial with controls and for approximately 8 minutes when controls were not used. These times were selected based on the results of previous sampling efforts and estimates of the minimum sample time needed to achieve a limit of quantification low enough to accurately measure exposures down to or less than 0.05 mg/m3 – the NIOSH Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) for respirable silica. The bricklayer was required to take a 5 to 10 minute break in the middle of the 16-minute trials to reduce differences in fatigue, compared to the 8-minute trials. Personal air samples were collected in the breathing zone of the operator during each trial to measure respirable silica concentrations during grinding with and without LEV. The samples were collected using a GilAir-5 pump (Sensidyne, Inc., Clearwater, FL) to draw 4.2 liters of air per minute through a GK2.69 Respirable Cyclone (BGI Inc., Waltham, MA) with a pre-weighed, 37 mm diameter, 5-micron pore size polyvinyl chloride (PVC) filter positioned on the operator’s lapel.
The flow rates of the sampling pumps were calibrated at the beginning of each day using a DryCal DC-Lite Primary Flow Meter (Bios International Corporation, Butler, NJ). Flow rates were measured again near the middle and at the end of each day to ensure that sampling flow rates were maintained within 5% of pre-sampling flow rates throughout the day. Average flow rates were used to calculate sample air volumes. Samples were analyzed by R.J. Lee Group, Inc., (Monroeville, PA) using NIOSH Method 0600, to determine exposure to total mass of respirable dust. The same samples were also analyzed using X-Ray diffraction following NIOSH method 7500 to determine quartz, cristobalite and tridymite concentration in the respirable mass. Reported masses for these analytes were used with the sample air volumes to calculate airborne concentrations of total respirable dust, quartz, cristobalite and tridymite.
We used a reduction of greater than 50 percent in respirable silica exposure concentrations or a reduction to less than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 as our criteria for determining whether or not a control was considered efficacious. This is consistent with criteria used by NIOSH in conducting a similar study in 2004 described by Echt et al. (2007) and by CPWR in 2006 and described by Meeker et al. (2009). The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) and the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) publish additional occupational exposure limits (OELs) for silica which are listed in Table 1 with NIOSH RELs. OELs for silica are based on the respirable fraction of the aerosol, which consists of particles less than 10 micrometers in aerodynamic diameter.
| Organization or Agency | Form of Crystalline Silica | Occupational Exposure Limits (mg/m3) |
|---|---|---|
| NIOSHA | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 |
| OSHA - ConstructionB | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
PEL = 250 / (5 + % quartz) PEL = 250 / (5 + % cristobalite) PEL = 250 / (5 + % tridymite) |
| ACGIH | Crystalline Silica | TLV = 0.025 mg/m3 |
A NIOSH Publication No. 2005-151 indicates 10-hour time-weighted average during a 40-hr workweek B The PEL for silica in OSHA’s Safety and Health Regulations for Construction, 29 C.F.R. 1926.55(a), is an 8-hour time-weighted average (TWA) expressed in millions of particles per cubic foot (mppcf). However, the units mppcf can be converted to milligrams per cubic meter can by dividing mppcf by 10 (OSHA, 2009). The formula used by OSHA to determine the PEL for silica is dependent on the percentage of silica in each collected sample. The concentration of respirable dust measured is compared to the sample specific PEL to determine if the PEL has been exceeded. OSHA has proposed lowering the PEL to 0.05 mg/m3 of respirable silica as an 8 hour TWA. |
||
The flow of air in ventilation systems is governed by fundamental principles that describe the behavior of gases (in this case air). Pressure measurements taken within a ventilation system along with knowledge of hood (or shroud) entry losses can be used to calculate flow rates. Hood entry losses are dependent on the shape and configuration of a particular hood or shroud and described by the term “coefficient of entry (Ce)” which is the ratio of actual air flow through a hood and what the air flow would theoretically be if there were no hood entry losses. Given the coefficient of entry, static pressure measurements can be used to calculate air flow through a given hood. The coefficient of entry for the Dust Director shroud was previously determined by CPWR and used for calculating air flow based on static pressure measurements (Meeker et al., 2009). Static pressure, with the vacuum operating, was measured periodically throughout the evaluation to monitor the changes in air-flow rate following use and again after filter cleaning. The static pressure was measured at a port positioned more than 3 duct diameters downstream from the tool’s air intake using a UEi EM200 Electronic Manometer (Universal Enterprises, Inc., Beaverton, OR).
The dust in the vacuum bag was monitored and, per the manufacturer’s instructions, the bag was changed before the dust level was within 5 centimeters of the valve at the bottom of the vacuum. Each time a vacuum bag was removed, it was weighed to the nearest pound. The bag weights and corresponding grinding durations were used to calculate the average weight of dust collected per unit time. After each trial, cut lengths were measured on the wall to determine total linear feet of vertical (head) and horizontal (bed) joints per unit time.
A Haz-Dust III, Model HD-1003, Real-Time Aerosol Monitor (Environmental Devices Corporation, Plaistow, NH) was used to confirm clearance of dust between trials. The Haz-Dust monitor was positioned on the test wall near the operator at approximately breathing zone level and configured to measure respirable particulate concentration.
V. Results
Personal air monitoring
Five pairs of respirable dust samples were collected while grinding with and without the vacuum system. In addition, three respirable dust samples were collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place. One measurement collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard was shown to be a statistical outlier and was omitted from analysis. Personal air monitoring results for respirable silica and a comparison of average exposures relative to the NIOSH REL for silica (0.05 mg/m3) appears in Table 2. The mean respirable dust levels measured without LEV was 31.4 mg/m3. However, samples collected with LEV were below the limit of quantification (LOQ) which ranged from <1.29 to <1.46 mg/m3. Use of LEV resulted in a greater than 95% reduction in mean respirable dust levels using a mean value with use of LEV of <1.41 (n=5 samples with use of LEV and n=7 without use of LEV). The respirable dust samples collected during grinding without the LEV system contained an average of 24 percent silica. The mass of respirable dust in the samples collected with use of the LEV system was too low to determine the silica content.| Mean, mg/m3 (range) | Std. Dev. | Percent Reduction | Hazard RatioB | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bosch with Dust Director Shroud and DustControl 2900c Vacuum |
0.091 (<0.069 – 0.137) |
0.027 | 98.7 | 1.81 |
| Bosch with no Control | 7.23 (4.57 – 9.90) |
1.94 | NA | 145 |
A n = 5 samples for each tool/control combination and n = 7 samples without the use of the LEV system B Hazard Ratio = measured exposure / NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 |
||||
Average respirable silica and dust exposures, with and without the dust control system, appear as Figures 5 and 6, respectively.
Figure 5. Average respirable silica exposures with and without the Dustcontrol 2900c vacuum and Dust Director shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air - mg/m3)
Figure 6. Average respirable dust exposures with and without Dustcontrol 2900c Vacuum and Dust Director Shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air – mg/m3)
The mean respirable silica concentration measured during use of the control was significantly less than the concentration measured while using the same tool without controls (p<0.01). Grinding mortar with the Bosch angle grinder without dust controls resulted in an average exposure to respirable silica that was 145 times the NIOSH REL. Grinding with the Bosch angle grinder in combination with the Dust Director shroud and the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced the average concentration of respirable silica by 98.7 percent. With use of these controls, the concentration of respirable silica was 1.8 times greater than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3. However the NIOSH REL is based on a time-weighted average (TWA) over a 10-hour workday. Given these were task TWAs and samples were collected over continuous periods of grinding, they may overestimate exposures over an actual work day since some time would be spent performing tasks that would likely have lower, or no, silica exposures (setup, breaks, cleanup, etc.).
Static pressure, dust mass collection and grinding rates.
Static pressure was used as a surrogate for air flow as described earlier. Hood static pressure was measured periodically at a tap near the grinder more than 3 duct diameters from the air intake in the shroud. The static pressure, and thus air flow, was generally higher when the vacuum’s filter had recently been cleaned. The mean, median, and range of calculated flow rates are presented in Table A1 of the Appendix.
Based on the data we collected, the air-flow rate upstream from the Bosch grinder and Dust Director shroud ranged from 78 to 93 cubic feet per minute (cfm) with the DustControl vacuum. When the manufacturer’s filter cleaning procedure was followed the vacuum performed relatively well and flow could be maintained at slightly less than 90 cfm with cleaning. However, mean flow rates dropped substantially to 80 cfm after as little as 8 minutes of grinding without any filter cleaning. The flow rate returned to an average of 89 cfm when filters were cleaned correctly (without stopping air flow to the vacuum). Collingwood and Heitbrink (2007) found that the minimum exhaust flow rate for capture of silica and other particulate under ideal conditions is 21.25 cfm per inch of grinder blade diameter. This is equal to about 96 cfm when using a 4.5 inch diameter grinding blade. We set 106 cfm as the minimum desired flow rate for this study to allow a safety margin for potential decline in equipment performance and the possibility of inadequate maintenance, both of which may be likely after repeated use under actual work conditions. The DustControl vacuum provided slightly less than the minimum flow rate described by Collingwood and Heitbrink for a 4.5-inch blade and the peak flow rate fell with use.
The duration of vacuum bag use and mass of dust collected were recorded and are presented in Table A2 of the Appendix. The vacuum bags were changed and weighed after each trial utilizing the LEV system. A total of five bags were used to complete the five rounds of grinding. The DustControl vacuum captured 45 pounds of dust over 83 minutes of grinding for an average rate of dust collection of 0.54 pounds per minute. The rate of dust collection ranged from 0.47 to 0.63 pounds per minute. Based on these measurements, approximately 130 pounds of dust would likely be captured after just 4 hours of continuous grinding.
The rate of grinding a combination of vertical and horizontal joints while using the LEV system ranged from 2.3 to 3.3 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the use of the LEV system ranged from 2.6 to 3.4 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place ranged from 4.7 to 5.1 feet per minute. It’s important to note that: 1) the operator had limited experience using dust control systems and cut rates appeared to improve slightly over the 2-day period he used the tested equipment; and 2) the upper range of cut rates with the dust control system overlapped with the lowest cut rate with the original guard and without the LEV system in place indicating no statistical difference between cut rates. Given that grinding rates with and without use of this LEV system are only available for one operator and he had limited experience with the LEV system, these reported cut rates are in no way intended to represent the impact use of this LEV system is likely to have on productivity rates overall.
VI. Discussion
The objective of these trials was to evaluate the effectiveness of a tuckpointing LEV system for controlling respirable silica while grinding out mortar joints. The Dust Director shroud with the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced respirable silica concentrations when grinding with the Bosch grinder by approximately 99 percent. Despite being considered effective by our test criteria (greater than 50% reduction), it still resulted in task TWA exposures that exceeded the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 by 1.8 times. Depending on how much time is spent grinding over the course of a work day and on exposures while performing other tasks, the 8-hour TWA exposures may or may not exceed the REL with this system. Use of this system by workers with experience and training in proficient use will likely improve dust capture performance. Exposure reduction is greatly influenced by correct use of this system which includes grinding from right to left, making sure the shroud is held flush against the wall and that the tool travels at a pace that doesn’t exceed the ability of the system to capture dust as it’s generated. Deviation from any of these measures produces visible dust clouds which were observed during trials.
VII. Conclusions
With a 99 percent reduction in respirable silica exposure, the Dust Director shroud and DustControl 2900c vacuum with a Bosch Model 1775E grinder was effective in reducing silica exposures based on our criteria. Use of the tested dust control system may be effective in reducing silica exposure on the job to less than the NIOSH REL if used in combination with administrative controls such as work scheduling to reduce cutting times as needed. Training on correct use of the tested system is also essential. Personal air monitoring is necessary to verify control effectiveness on actual job sites and under “real-world” conditions. However, these results clearly demonstrate the availability of viable and effective engineering controls for tuckpointing operations associated with elevated silica exposure.
VIII. References
American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists. Threshold limit values for chemical substances (TLV®-CS). [2013]. ACGIH, Cincinnati, Ohio.
Bergdahl I.A,. Toren K., Eriksson K., et al. [2004]. Increased mortality in COPD among construction workers exposed to inorganic dust. European Respiratory Journal, 23: 402–06.
Blanc P.D. & Torén K. [2007]. Occupation in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and chronic bronchitis: an update [State of the Art Series. Occupational lung disease in high-and low-income countries, Edited by M. Chan-Yeung. Number 2 in the series]. The International Journal of Tuberculosis and Lung Disease, 11(3), 251-257.
Collingwood S. & Heitbrink W.A. [2007] 'Field Evaluation of an Engineering Control for Respirable Crystalline Silica Exposures During Mortar Removal'. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, 4:11, 875 – 887.
DHHS (NIOSH) Publication No. 2002-129 April 2002 http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/2002-129/
Echt A., Sieber W.K., Lefkowitz D., Meeker J., Susi P., Cardwell B., Heitbrink, W.A. In-depth survey of dust control technology for cutting concrete block and tuckpointing brick at The International Masonry Institute Bordentown Training Center, Bordentown, NJ. Cincinnati, OH: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Report. No. EPHB 282-13; 2007. http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ECTB-282-13.pdf
Heitbrink W., Bennett J. [2006]. A numerical and experimental investigation of crystalline silica exposure control during tuck pointing. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, Vol. 3, pp 366-378.
Lyons et al, [2007]. A breathless builder. Breathe, Vol. 3, no. 4, pp 386-390.
Mastrangelo G., Tartari M., Fedeli U., Fadda E., Saia B. [2003]. Ascertaining the risk of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease in relation to occupation using a case-control design. Occupational Medicine, 53: 165–172.
Meeker J., Cooper M., Lefrowitz D., Susi P. [2009]. Engineering control technologies to reduce occupational silica exposures in masonry cutting and tuckpointing. Public Health Reports, Supplement 1, Vol. 124, June.
Meeker J, Flynn M, Susi P, Cardwell, B [2004]. Performance evaluation of a masonry concrete vacuum. Unpublished Report.
Miller F. W., Alfredsson L., Costenbader K. H., Kamen D. L., Nelson L. M., Norris J. M., & De Roos A. J. [2012]. Epidemiology of environmental exposures and human autoimmune diseases: findings from a National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences Expert Panel workshop. Journal of autoimmunity. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3496812/
Occupational Safety and Health Administration U.S Department of Labor. Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction. [2009]. OSHA 3362-05.
Rappaport SM, Goldberg M, Susi P, Herrick RF [2003]. Excessive exposure to silica in the U.S. construction industry. Annals of Occupational Hygiene, Vol. 47, pp. 111-122.
IX. Appendices
| Measurement Conditions |
n | Mean Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Median
Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before filter cleaning | 5 | 80 | 81 | 78-81 |
| After filter cleaning following manufacturer directions | 9 | 89 | 90 | 84-93 |
| * Static pressure was measured in millibars and converted to inches of water gauge. Flow rates were calculated using the formula Q = Ce (A) 4005 (SP)1/2 where: Q = flow in cubic feet per minute (cfm), Ce = coefficient of entry, A = area of the duct where static pressure measurements were taken in square feet, and SP = static pressure in inches of water gauge. | ||||
| Tool/Control | Collection Period (min.) |
Dust Collection Rate (lb/min.) |
|---|---|---|
| Bosch grinder/Dust Director shroud & DustControl 2900c vacuum |
8 11 8 8 10 |
0.50 0.61 0.50 0.47 0.63 |
| Average | 0.54 |
[content_transformed:protected] =>
Executive Summary
This report describes the results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. It should also be noted that the NIOSH REL is based on exposures averaged over a ten hour work day and our results represent time weighted averages of the sample task duration periods.
Acronyms
ACGIH - American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists
CPWR - CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training
Ce - coefficient of entry
HEPA - high-efficiency particulate air
IUBAC - International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craftworkers
LEV - local exhaust ventilation
PACT - Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies
NIOSH - National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health
OEL - occupational exposure limit
OSHA - Occupational Safety and Health Administration
PAPR - powered air-purifying respirator
PEL - Permissible Exposure Limit
PVC - polyvinyl chloride
REL - Recommended Exposure Limit
RPM - revolutions per minute
TWA - time-weighted average
SP - static pressure
I. Introduction and Background
In 2010 CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training began a four-year project which seeks to identify and evaluate tuckpointing local exhaust ventilation (LEV) systems and disseminate information on their availability and effectiveness. A Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies (PACT) comprised of masonry contractors, representatives from unions, government, equipment manufacturers, and health and safety researcher was formed as part of this project. PACT members participated in identifying important characteristics for control technologies and this information was used to identify LEV systems for tuckpointing using that criteria. Contractor and labor members of the PACT selected specific tuckpointing LEV systems to be considered for evaluation. Each system consisted of a tuckpointing grinder, shroud, and vacuum. This report describes the second of four systems to be evaluated between 2012 the end of 2014, with and without LEV, in a controlled setting to determine effectiveness in silica exposure reduction. This report describes the methods and results of our evaluation of a system consisting of the DustControl 2900c vacuum with the ICS Dust Director shroud and a Bosch Model 1775E grinder.
Excessive exposure to respirable silica can result in silicosis or other silica-related diseases including pulmonary tuberculosis, lung cancer, silicoproteinosis (Lyons et al, 2007) and autoimmune disorders such as rheumatoid arthritis, sarcoidosis and scleroderma (Miller et al, 2012). Respirable silica is generally defined as particles less than 10 micrometers (μm) in aerodynamic diameter (ACGIH, 2013). Silicosis can lead to symptoms including shortness of breath, fatigue, chest pains, susceptibility to infection and possibly death. There is no cure for silicosis, however it is totally preventable. Construction workers exposed to dust, including silica, are also known to have higher rates of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD).
There are many sources of silica in construction that result in exposures of varying intensity among workers. Masonry restoration workers are among the most highly silica-exposed trades in construction. The process of grinding out deteriorated mortar joints between masonry units and replacing or repointing with fresh mortar (often referred to as tuckpointing) is a fundamental part of masonry restoration work. The removal of mortar with powered angle grinders generates enormous levels of dust. Between 2004 and 2006, NIOSH and CPWR evaluated silica exposures while grinding mortar in a controlled setting, at a local training center, where tasks, sample times and task variables were defined by the study design. These studies demonstrated that grinding mortar without controls can result in elevated respirable silica exposures. Meeker et al., (2009) reported exposures between 5 and 25.8 milligrams per cubic meter (mg/m3) in a controlled setting. This study also showed that LEV systems for tuckpointing grinders can reduce exposures to respirable silica by greater than 90 percent.II. Objectives
The objective of this evaluation was to assess the effectiveness of an LEV system for controlling exposure to silica during the grinding of mortar. The control technology was tested under controlled conditions, similar to those experienced by tuckpointers on actual job sites, using journeymen bricklayers experienced in tuckpointing and repeat, randomized trials with and without LEV. All other variables were held constant throughout so that the only variable was whether or not the tested control was used.
III. Description of Equipment Tested
A Bosch model 1775E grinder (Robert Bosch Tool Corporation, Prospect, IL) (Figures 1, 2 and 3) was fitted with a new 1/4-inch wide, 4½-inch diameter segmented diamond abrasive blade made by DeWalt (model #DW4740). The grinder weighs six and a half pounds, draws 8.5 amps and has a variable speed up to 11,000 revolutions per minute (RPMs). The DustControl 2900c vacuum (DustControl, Inc., Wilmington, NC) (Figure 3) was tested in combination with the Dust Director shroud (Industrial Contractors’ Supplies, Inc., Huntingdon, PA) (Figures 1 and 3) attached to the Bosch grinder.
Figure 1. Bosch grinder with Dust Director shroud
Figure 2. Bosch grinder without tuckpointing LEV system.
Figure 3: Bosch Grinder with LEV System
The vacuum is specified to weigh 31 pounds when empty and to provide a flow rate of 114 cubic feet of air per minute and a “static lift” or “vacuum suction pressure” of 84 inches of water. The vacuum is sold with a cyclonic pre-separator, to remove larger particles, a fine filter (rated 99.9 percent efficient) and a HEPA (high-efficiency particulate air) filter (rated to capture 99.97 percent of the particles with an aerodynamic diameter of 0.3 micrometers). The HEPA filter was removed based on the manufacturer’s recommendation due to the heavy dust loading associated with tuckpointing. CPWR sponsored research and contractor experience indicate that HEPA filters likely have an adverse effect on dust capture during tuckpointing because of extreme dust loading on filters. While the cyclone and the fine filter remove most of the dust, especially the large particles, before they reach the HEPA filter, the HEPA filter would still be subject to heavy loading, causing a substantial pressure drop and subsequent decrease in air flow rate. The relatively small increase in the efficiency of the filtration system while using the HEPA filter is expected to be quickly offset by a more significant decrease in capture efficiency as the air flow rate and ability to capture particles decreases.
Dust collects in relatively inexpensive, heavy-gauge plastic bags below and outside of the cyclone. The bags can be removed and replaced without opening the vacuum. Some vacuums are equipped with a light to indicate that the filters need to be cleaned or changed. The DC2900c features a “reverse air pulse cleaning system,” which removes accumulated dust from the filters without having to remove them from the vacuum. The system, as illustrated in Figure 4, requires the operator to disconnect the hose from the shroud, place it over an air stop so that air through the hose is cut off and pressure in the vacuum is maximized.
Figure 4. Procedure for "cleaning" of or dust removal from filters (source: http://dustcontrolusa.com/manuals/2800c.pdf)
The flap covering the port on the side of the vacuum is repeatedly flipped open to release built up pressure in strong pulses that dislodge dust from the filter.
The manufacturer indicates “the filter is generally cleaned once or twice daily during normal continuous operation.” The Dust Director shroud has a 2-inch diameter take-off that was connected to the antistatic, corrugated 1.5-inch diameter, 15-foot long vacuum hose supplied with the DustControl vacuum.
IV. Study Methods
This evaluation was conducted at the International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craft workers (IUBAC) Local 1 Philadelphia/Delaware Training Center in Philadelphia, PA on November 14 and 15, 2012. A single journeyman bricklayer, experienced in tuckpointing, used the grinder and LEV system being tested to remove mortar from joints wide enough to require two passes. The type S mortar had been allowed to cure for at least four weeks. The bricklayer either possessed or was provided with personal protective equipment including sturdy work boots, gloves, hearing protection and a powered air-purifying respirator (PAPR). The PAPR was a 3M GVP system with a bump cap, loose fitting face piece and a HEPA filter (3M, St Paul, MN).
The study was designed to include at least five rounds of sampling during mortar removal. Each round included a trial using the Bosch grinder with a Dust Director shroud and Dust Collector 2900c vacuum and a trial using the Bosch grinder with the factory-supplied guard and without a vacuum. The order of the two trials within each round was randomly selected to minimize bias that might be introduced due to variation associated with environmental factors, equipment operator, blade wear, vacuum performance over time and any other factors unrelated to LEV use. Tools were operated for approximately 16 minutes per trial with controls and for approximately 8 minutes when controls were not used. These times were selected based on the results of previous sampling efforts and estimates of the minimum sample time needed to achieve a limit of quantification low enough to accurately measure exposures down to or less than 0.05 mg/m3 – the NIOSH Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) for respirable silica. The bricklayer was required to take a 5 to 10 minute break in the middle of the 16-minute trials to reduce differences in fatigue, compared to the 8-minute trials. Personal air samples were collected in the breathing zone of the operator during each trial to measure respirable silica concentrations during grinding with and without LEV. The samples were collected using a GilAir-5 pump (Sensidyne, Inc., Clearwater, FL) to draw 4.2 liters of air per minute through a GK2.69 Respirable Cyclone (BGI Inc., Waltham, MA) with a pre-weighed, 37 mm diameter, 5-micron pore size polyvinyl chloride (PVC) filter positioned on the operator’s lapel.
The flow rates of the sampling pumps were calibrated at the beginning of each day using a DryCal DC-Lite Primary Flow Meter (Bios International Corporation, Butler, NJ). Flow rates were measured again near the middle and at the end of each day to ensure that sampling flow rates were maintained within 5% of pre-sampling flow rates throughout the day. Average flow rates were used to calculate sample air volumes. Samples were analyzed by R.J. Lee Group, Inc., (Monroeville, PA) using NIOSH Method 0600, to determine exposure to total mass of respirable dust. The same samples were also analyzed using X-Ray diffraction following NIOSH method 7500 to determine quartz, cristobalite and tridymite concentration in the respirable mass. Reported masses for these analytes were used with the sample air volumes to calculate airborne concentrations of total respirable dust, quartz, cristobalite and tridymite.
We used a reduction of greater than 50 percent in respirable silica exposure concentrations or a reduction to less than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 as our criteria for determining whether or not a control was considered efficacious. This is consistent with criteria used by NIOSH in conducting a similar study in 2004 described by Echt et al. (2007) and by CPWR in 2006 and described by Meeker et al. (2009). The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) and the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) publish additional occupational exposure limits (OELs) for silica which are listed in Table 1 with NIOSH RELs. OELs for silica are based on the respirable fraction of the aerosol, which consists of particles less than 10 micrometers in aerodynamic diameter.
| Organization or Agency | Form of Crystalline Silica | Occupational Exposure Limits (mg/m3) |
|---|---|---|
| NIOSHA | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 |
| OSHA - ConstructionB | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
PEL = 250 / (5 + % quartz) PEL = 250 / (5 + % cristobalite) PEL = 250 / (5 + % tridymite) |
| ACGIH | Crystalline Silica | TLV = 0.025 mg/m3 |
A NIOSH Publication No. 2005-151 indicates 10-hour time-weighted average during a 40-hr workweek B The PEL for silica in OSHA’s Safety and Health Regulations for Construction, 29 C.F.R. 1926.55(a), is an 8-hour time-weighted average (TWA) expressed in millions of particles per cubic foot (mppcf). However, the units mppcf can be converted to milligrams per cubic meter can by dividing mppcf by 10 (OSHA, 2009). The formula used by OSHA to determine the PEL for silica is dependent on the percentage of silica in each collected sample. The concentration of respirable dust measured is compared to the sample specific PEL to determine if the PEL has been exceeded. OSHA has proposed lowering the PEL to 0.05 mg/m3 of respirable silica as an 8 hour TWA. |
||
The flow of air in ventilation systems is governed by fundamental principles that describe the behavior of gases (in this case air). Pressure measurements taken within a ventilation system along with knowledge of hood (or shroud) entry losses can be used to calculate flow rates. Hood entry losses are dependent on the shape and configuration of a particular hood or shroud and described by the term “coefficient of entry (Ce)” which is the ratio of actual air flow through a hood and what the air flow would theoretically be if there were no hood entry losses. Given the coefficient of entry, static pressure measurements can be used to calculate air flow through a given hood. The coefficient of entry for the Dust Director shroud was previously determined by CPWR and used for calculating air flow based on static pressure measurements (Meeker et al., 2009). Static pressure, with the vacuum operating, was measured periodically throughout the evaluation to monitor the changes in air-flow rate following use and again after filter cleaning. The static pressure was measured at a port positioned more than 3 duct diameters downstream from the tool’s air intake using a UEi EM200 Electronic Manometer (Universal Enterprises, Inc., Beaverton, OR).
The dust in the vacuum bag was monitored and, per the manufacturer’s instructions, the bag was changed before the dust level was within 5 centimeters of the valve at the bottom of the vacuum. Each time a vacuum bag was removed, it was weighed to the nearest pound. The bag weights and corresponding grinding durations were used to calculate the average weight of dust collected per unit time. After each trial, cut lengths were measured on the wall to determine total linear feet of vertical (head) and horizontal (bed) joints per unit time.
A Haz-Dust III, Model HD-1003, Real-Time Aerosol Monitor (Environmental Devices Corporation, Plaistow, NH) was used to confirm clearance of dust between trials. The Haz-Dust monitor was positioned on the test wall near the operator at approximately breathing zone level and configured to measure respirable particulate concentration.
V. Results
Personal air monitoring
Five pairs of respirable dust samples were collected while grinding with and without the vacuum system. In addition, three respirable dust samples were collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place. One measurement collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard was shown to be a statistical outlier and was omitted from analysis. Personal air monitoring results for respirable silica and a comparison of average exposures relative to the NIOSH REL for silica (0.05 mg/m3) appears in Table 2. The mean respirable dust levels measured without LEV was 31.4 mg/m3. However, samples collected with LEV were below the limit of quantification (LOQ) which ranged from <1.29 to <1.46 mg/m3. Use of LEV resulted in a greater than 95% reduction in mean respirable dust levels using a mean value with use of LEV of <1.41 (n=5 samples with use of LEV and n=7 without use of LEV). The respirable dust samples collected during grinding without the LEV system contained an average of 24 percent silica. The mass of respirable dust in the samples collected with use of the LEV system was too low to determine the silica content.| Mean, mg/m3 (range) | Std. Dev. | Percent Reduction | Hazard RatioB | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bosch with Dust Director Shroud and DustControl 2900c Vacuum |
0.091 (<0.069 – 0.137) |
0.027 | 98.7 | 1.81 |
| Bosch with no Control | 7.23 (4.57 – 9.90) |
1.94 | NA | 145 |
A n = 5 samples for each tool/control combination and n = 7 samples without the use of the LEV system B Hazard Ratio = measured exposure / NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 |
||||
Average respirable silica and dust exposures, with and without the dust control system, appear as Figures 5 and 6, respectively.
Figure 5. Average respirable silica exposures with and without the Dustcontrol 2900c vacuum and Dust Director shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air - mg/m3)
Figure 6. Average respirable dust exposures with and without Dustcontrol 2900c Vacuum and Dust Director Shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air – mg/m3)
The mean respirable silica concentration measured during use of the control was significantly less than the concentration measured while using the same tool without controls (p<0.01). Grinding mortar with the Bosch angle grinder without dust controls resulted in an average exposure to respirable silica that was 145 times the NIOSH REL. Grinding with the Bosch angle grinder in combination with the Dust Director shroud and the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced the average concentration of respirable silica by 98.7 percent. With use of these controls, the concentration of respirable silica was 1.8 times greater than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3. However the NIOSH REL is based on a time-weighted average (TWA) over a 10-hour workday. Given these were task TWAs and samples were collected over continuous periods of grinding, they may overestimate exposures over an actual work day since some time would be spent performing tasks that would likely have lower, or no, silica exposures (setup, breaks, cleanup, etc.).
Static pressure, dust mass collection and grinding rates.
Static pressure was used as a surrogate for air flow as described earlier. Hood static pressure was measured periodically at a tap near the grinder more than 3 duct diameters from the air intake in the shroud. The static pressure, and thus air flow, was generally higher when the vacuum’s filter had recently been cleaned. The mean, median, and range of calculated flow rates are presented in Table A1 of the Appendix.
Based on the data we collected, the air-flow rate upstream from the Bosch grinder and Dust Director shroud ranged from 78 to 93 cubic feet per minute (cfm) with the DustControl vacuum. When the manufacturer’s filter cleaning procedure was followed the vacuum performed relatively well and flow could be maintained at slightly less than 90 cfm with cleaning. However, mean flow rates dropped substantially to 80 cfm after as little as 8 minutes of grinding without any filter cleaning. The flow rate returned to an average of 89 cfm when filters were cleaned correctly (without stopping air flow to the vacuum). Collingwood and Heitbrink (2007) found that the minimum exhaust flow rate for capture of silica and other particulate under ideal conditions is 21.25 cfm per inch of grinder blade diameter. This is equal to about 96 cfm when using a 4.5 inch diameter grinding blade. We set 106 cfm as the minimum desired flow rate for this study to allow a safety margin for potential decline in equipment performance and the possibility of inadequate maintenance, both of which may be likely after repeated use under actual work conditions. The DustControl vacuum provided slightly less than the minimum flow rate described by Collingwood and Heitbrink for a 4.5-inch blade and the peak flow rate fell with use.
The duration of vacuum bag use and mass of dust collected were recorded and are presented in Table A2 of the Appendix. The vacuum bags were changed and weighed after each trial utilizing the LEV system. A total of five bags were used to complete the five rounds of grinding. The DustControl vacuum captured 45 pounds of dust over 83 minutes of grinding for an average rate of dust collection of 0.54 pounds per minute. The rate of dust collection ranged from 0.47 to 0.63 pounds per minute. Based on these measurements, approximately 130 pounds of dust would likely be captured after just 4 hours of continuous grinding.
The rate of grinding a combination of vertical and horizontal joints while using the LEV system ranged from 2.3 to 3.3 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the use of the LEV system ranged from 2.6 to 3.4 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place ranged from 4.7 to 5.1 feet per minute. It’s important to note that: 1) the operator had limited experience using dust control systems and cut rates appeared to improve slightly over the 2-day period he used the tested equipment; and 2) the upper range of cut rates with the dust control system overlapped with the lowest cut rate with the original guard and without the LEV system in place indicating no statistical difference between cut rates. Given that grinding rates with and without use of this LEV system are only available for one operator and he had limited experience with the LEV system, these reported cut rates are in no way intended to represent the impact use of this LEV system is likely to have on productivity rates overall.
VI. Discussion
The objective of these trials was to evaluate the effectiveness of a tuckpointing LEV system for controlling respirable silica while grinding out mortar joints. The Dust Director shroud with the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced respirable silica concentrations when grinding with the Bosch grinder by approximately 99 percent. Despite being considered effective by our test criteria (greater than 50% reduction), it still resulted in task TWA exposures that exceeded the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 by 1.8 times. Depending on how much time is spent grinding over the course of a work day and on exposures while performing other tasks, the 8-hour TWA exposures may or may not exceed the REL with this system. Use of this system by workers with experience and training in proficient use will likely improve dust capture performance. Exposure reduction is greatly influenced by correct use of this system which includes grinding from right to left, making sure the shroud is held flush against the wall and that the tool travels at a pace that doesn’t exceed the ability of the system to capture dust as it’s generated. Deviation from any of these measures produces visible dust clouds which were observed during trials.
VII. Conclusions
With a 99 percent reduction in respirable silica exposure, the Dust Director shroud and DustControl 2900c vacuum with a Bosch Model 1775E grinder was effective in reducing silica exposures based on our criteria. Use of the tested dust control system may be effective in reducing silica exposure on the job to less than the NIOSH REL if used in combination with administrative controls such as work scheduling to reduce cutting times as needed. Training on correct use of the tested system is also essential. Personal air monitoring is necessary to verify control effectiveness on actual job sites and under “real-world” conditions. However, these results clearly demonstrate the availability of viable and effective engineering controls for tuckpointing operations associated with elevated silica exposure.
VIII. References
American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists. Threshold limit values for chemical substances (TLV®-CS). [2013]. ACGIH, Cincinnati, Ohio.
Bergdahl I.A,. Toren K., Eriksson K., et al. [2004]. Increased mortality in COPD among construction workers exposed to inorganic dust. European Respiratory Journal, 23: 402–06.
Blanc P.D. & Torén K. [2007]. Occupation in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and chronic bronchitis: an update [State of the Art Series. Occupational lung disease in high-and low-income countries, Edited by M. Chan-Yeung. Number 2 in the series]. The International Journal of Tuberculosis and Lung Disease, 11(3), 251-257.
Collingwood S. & Heitbrink W.A. [2007] 'Field Evaluation of an Engineering Control for Respirable Crystalline Silica Exposures During Mortar Removal'. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, 4:11, 875 – 887.
DHHS (NIOSH) Publication No. 2002-129 April 2002 http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/2002-129/
Echt A., Sieber W.K., Lefkowitz D., Meeker J., Susi P., Cardwell B., Heitbrink, W.A. In-depth survey of dust control technology for cutting concrete block and tuckpointing brick at The International Masonry Institute Bordentown Training Center, Bordentown, NJ. Cincinnati, OH: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Report. No. EPHB 282-13; 2007. http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ECTB-282-13.pdf
Heitbrink W., Bennett J. [2006]. A numerical and experimental investigation of crystalline silica exposure control during tuck pointing. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, Vol. 3, pp 366-378.
Lyons et al, [2007]. A breathless builder. Breathe, Vol. 3, no. 4, pp 386-390.
Mastrangelo G., Tartari M., Fedeli U., Fadda E., Saia B. [2003]. Ascertaining the risk of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease in relation to occupation using a case-control design. Occupational Medicine, 53: 165–172.
Meeker J., Cooper M., Lefrowitz D., Susi P. [2009]. Engineering control technologies to reduce occupational silica exposures in masonry cutting and tuckpointing. Public Health Reports, Supplement 1, Vol. 124, June.
Meeker J, Flynn M, Susi P, Cardwell, B [2004]. Performance evaluation of a masonry concrete vacuum. Unpublished Report.
Miller F. W., Alfredsson L., Costenbader K. H., Kamen D. L., Nelson L. M., Norris J. M., & De Roos A. J. [2012]. Epidemiology of environmental exposures and human autoimmune diseases: findings from a National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences Expert Panel workshop. Journal of autoimmunity. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3496812/
Occupational Safety and Health Administration U.S Department of Labor. Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction. [2009]. OSHA 3362-05.
Rappaport SM, Goldberg M, Susi P, Herrick RF [2003]. Excessive exposure to silica in the U.S. construction industry. Annals of Occupational Hygiene, Vol. 47, pp. 111-122.
IX. Appendices
| Measurement Conditions |
n | Mean Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Median
Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before filter cleaning | 5 | 80 | 81 | 78-81 |
| After filter cleaning following manufacturer directions | 9 | 89 | 90 | 84-93 |
| * Static pressure was measured in millibars and converted to inches of water gauge. Flow rates were calculated using the formula Q = Ce (A) 4005 (SP)1/2 where: Q = flow in cubic feet per minute (cfm), Ce = coefficient of entry, A = area of the duct where static pressure measurements were taken in square feet, and SP = static pressure in inches of water gauge. | ||||
| Tool/Control | Collection Period (min.) |
Dust Collection Rate (lb/min.) |
|---|---|---|
| Bosch grinder/Dust Director shroud & DustControl 2900c vacuum |
8 11 8 8 10 |
0.50 0.61 0.50 0.47 0.63 |
| Average | 0.54 |
[disclaimer:protected] => [disclaimer_transformed:protected] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [template] => record ) [_file] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/templates/elcosh/macros.html [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_encoding:protected] => UTF-8 [_outputMode:protected] => 11 [_forceReparse:protected] => [_phpCodeDestination:protected] => /tmp/ [_phpCodeExtension:protected] => php [_cacheLifetime:protected] => 30 [_cachePurgeFrequency:protected] => 30 [externalMacroTemplatesCache:PHPTAL:private] => Array ( ) ) [record_macros.html] => PHPTAL Object ( [_prefilters:protected] => Array ( ) [_prefilter:PHPTAL:private] => REMOVED: DO NOT USE [_postfilter:protected] => [_repositories:protected] => Array ( [0] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/templates/elcosh ) [_path:protected] => record_macros.html [_resolvers:protected] => Array ( ) [_source:protected] => PHPTAL_FileSource Object ( [_path:PHPTAL_FileSource:private] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/templates/elcosh/record_macros.html ) [_codeFile:protected] => /tmp/tpl_61515a6c_record_macros__gMFg5NvPLybiFfYjAv9Aag.php [_functionName:protected] => tpl_61515a6c_record_macros__gMFg5NvPLybiFfYjAv9Aag [_prepared:protected] => 1 [_triggers:protected] => Array ( ) [_translator:protected] => [_globalContext:protected] => stdClass Object ( ) [_context:protected] => PHPTAL_Context Object ( [_line] => [_file] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/templates/elcosh/record.html [repeat] => stdClass Object ( ) [_xmlDeclaration] => [_docType] => [_nothrow:PHPTAL_Context:private] => [_slots:PHPTAL_Context:private] => Array ( ) [_slotsStack:PHPTAL_Context:private] => Array ( [0] => Array ( ) [1] => Array ( ) ) [_parentContext:PHPTAL_Context:private] => PHPTAL_Context Object ( [_line] => [_file] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/templates/elcosh/record.html [repeat] => stdClass Object ( ) [_xmlDeclaration] => [_docType] => [_nothrow:PHPTAL_Context:private] => [_slots:PHPTAL_Context:private] => Array ( ) [_slotsStack:PHPTAL_Context:private] => Array ( [0] => Array ( ) [1] => Array ( ) ) [_parentContext:PHPTAL_Context:private] => [_globalContext:PHPTAL_Context:private] => stdClass Object ( ) [_echoDeclarations:PHPTAL_Context:private] => [referer] => http://www.elcosh.org/document/3908/d001345/An%2BEvaluation%2Bof%2BSilica%2BExposure%2BControls%2Bfor%2BTuckpointing%253A%2BDustControl%2B2900c%2BVacuum%2Bwith%2Bthe%2BICS%2BDust%2BDirector%2BShroud%2Band%2BBosch%2BGrinder%2BModel%2B1775E%2BConducted%2BNovember%2B14-15%252C%2B2012.html [curr_module] => Record [styles] => Array ( ) [javascript] => Array ( [0] => jquery.min.js ) [metas] => Array ( [language] => en [robots] => index, follow ) [user] => [curr_url] => https://www.elcosh.org/index.php?module=Record&id=3908&type=document [base_url] => https://www.elcosh.org/index.php?module=Record [title] => eLCOSH : An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: DustControl 2900c Vacuum with the ICS Dust Director Shroud and Bosch Grinder Model 1775E Conducted November 14-15, 2012 [language] => en [search_query] => [module] => Record [new_records] => Array ( [0] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Fixed Ladder [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Fixed Ladders addresses the potential risks associated with using fixed ladders. The resource includes a brief case example,... [category] => Array ( [0] => 15 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 53 [5] => 55 [6] => 60 [7] => 64 [8] => 73 [9] => 76 [10] => 78 [11] => 80 [12] => 86 [13] => 87 [14] => 90 [15] => 92 [16] => 93 [17] => 94 [18] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Falls [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Concrete Polisher [11] => Electrical Worker [13] => HVAC [15] => Laborer [17] => PCC/Restoration [19] => Plumber/Pipefitter [21] => Roofer/Waterproofer [23] => Sheetmetal Worker [25] => Welder [27] => Commercial & Institutional [28] => Jobsites [29] => Industrial [31] => LEED/Green Construction [33] => Renovations [35] => Residential [37] => Toolbox Talks [38] => Documents [39] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4430/d001660/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BFixed%2BLadder.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [53] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 53 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Concrete Polisher [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [73] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 73 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => PCC/Restoration [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4430 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001660 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Fixed Ladder [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Fixed Ladders, Fall Prevention, Falls [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Fixed Ladders addresses the potential risks associated with using fixed ladders. The resource includes a brief case example, steps to prevent a related injury and questions for discussion. It includes an image that illustrates the hazard, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001257,d001254,d001255,d001256,d001258,d001262,d001279 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_completed:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/22/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [1] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Challenges Preventing Falling Objects [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Challenges Preventing Falling Objects addresses the hazards of being struck by falling objects on the job site. The resource... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 55 [5] => 64 [6] => 68 [7] => 71 [8] => 75 [9] => 78 [10] => 79 [11] => 82 [12] => 62 [13] => 86 [14] => 87 [15] => 88 [16] => 89 [17] => 91 [18] => 90 [19] => 92 [20] => 93 [21] => 94 [22] => 95 [23] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Electrical Worker [11] => Laborer [13] => Maintenance Worker [15] => Painter [17] => Plasterer [19] => Roofer/Waterproofer [21] => Scaffold Erector [23] => Stonemason [25] => Structural Ironworker [27] => Welder [29] => Commercial & Institutional [30] => Jobsites [31] => Demolition [33] => Disasters [35] => Heavy & Highway [37] => Industrial [39] => LEED/Green Construction [41] => Renovations [43] => Residential [45] => Underground [47] => Toolbox Talks [48] => Documents [49] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4431/d001661/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BChallenges%2BPreventing%2BFalling%2BObjects.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4431 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001661 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Challenges Preventing Falling Objects [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => dropped objects, falling objects, struck by incidents, struck by fatalities [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Challenges Preventing Falling Objects addresses the hazards of being struck by falling objects on the job site. The resource includes a brief example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates a group workers observing a scaffold free of debris during high winds, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001234,d001238,d001244,d001251,d001253,d001260,d001268,d001278 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_completed:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/22/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [2] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Tower Crane Safety [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Tower Crane Safety addresses the potential hazards of Tower Cranes and the importance of following procedure before and durin... [category] => Array ( [0] => 11 [1] => 12 [2] => 18 [3] => 70 [4] => 87 [5] => 88 [6] => 91 [7] => 90 [8] => 92 [9] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Cranes & Hoists [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Crushed/Struck By [6] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [9] => Operating Engineer [10] => Trades [11] => Commercial & Institutional [12] => Jobsites [13] => Demolition [15] => Heavy & Highway [17] => Industrial [19] => LEED/Green Construction [21] => Toolbox Talks [22] => Documents [23] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4427/d001657/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BTower%2BCrane%2BSafety.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [11] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 11 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Cranes & Hoists [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [18] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 18 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4427 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001657 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Tower Crane Safety [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Tower Crane, Crane, Stability, Tipping, Lift Zone Safety, Lift, Zone, Safety, Struck by [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Tower Crane Safety addresses the potential hazards of Tower Cranes and the importance of following procedure before and during Tower Crane operation. The resource includes a brief example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates a worker inspecting a Tower Crane before operation, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001234,d001238,d001250,d001251,d001253,d001258,d001262,d001273 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/19/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [3] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Work Zone Safety: Working Around Vehicles [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Working Around Vehicles in the Work Zone addresses methods to avoid being struck-by a vehicle on a construction site. The res... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 18 [2] => 52 [3] => 57 [4] => 70 [5] => 85 [6] => 87 [7] => 88 [8] => 89 [9] => 91 [10] => 90 [11] => 92 [12] => 93 [13] => 94 [14] => 95 [15] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [6] => Commercial Diver [7] => Trades [8] => Flagger [10] => Operating Engineer [12] => Truck Driver [14] => Commercial & Institutional [15] => Jobsites [16] => Demolition [18] => Disasters [20] => Heavy & Highway [22] => Industrial [24] => LEED/Green Construction [26] => Renovations [28] => Residential [30] => Underground [32] => Toolbox Talks [33] => Documents [34] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4428/d001658/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BWork%2BZone%2BSafety%253A%2BWorking%2BAround%2BVehicles.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [18] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 18 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [52] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 52 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Commercial Diver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [85] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 85 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Truck Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4428 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001658 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Daniela Caceres [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Work Zone Safety: Working Around Vehicles [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Struck, Struck by, Vehicle, Work Zone Safety, Truck, Operator, Driver, Mobile Equipment [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Working Around Vehicles in the Work Zone addresses methods to avoid being struck-by a vehicle on a construction site. The resource includes a case example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates the hazard, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001640 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/19/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [4] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Construction Dive -- DeWalt's Jobsite Pro headphones recalled for fire hazards [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => A recall notice by the United States Consumer Product Safety Commission affects over 300,000 DeWalt Jobsite Pro Headphones. The recall is a result of... [category] => Array ( [0] => 16 [1] => 44 [2] => 45 [3] => 46 [4] => 47 [5] => 48 [6] => 49 [7] => 50 [8] => 51 [9] => 52 [10] => 53 [11] => 54 [12] => 55 [13] => 56 [14] => 57 [15] => 58 [16] => 59 [17] => 60 [18] => 61 [19] => 64 [20] => 65 [21] => 66 [22] => 67 [23] => 68 [24] => 69 [25] => 70 [26] => 71 [27] => 72 [28] => 73 [29] => 74 [30] => 75 [31] => 76 [32] => 77 [33] => 63 [34] => 78 [35] => 79 [36] => 80 [37] => 81 [38] => 82 [39] => 62 [40] => 83 [41] => 84 [42] => 85 [43] => 86 [44] => 87 [45] => 88 [46] => 89 [47] => 91 [48] => 90 [49] => 92 [50] => 93 [51] => 94 [52] => 95 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Fire & Explosions [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Acoustical Ceiling Carpenter [4] => Trades [5] => Asbestos/Insulator [7] => Boilermaker [9] => Bricklayer [11] => Cabinetmaker [13] => Carpenter [15] => Carpet Layer [17] => Cement Mason [19] => Commercial Diver [21] => Concrete Polisher [23] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [25] => Electrical Worker [27] => Elevator Constructor [29] => Flagger [31] => Glazier [33] => Hazardous Waste Cleanup [35] => HVAC [37] => Interior Systems Carpenter [39] => Laborer [41] => Landscaper [43] => Lather [45] => Lead Abatement Worker [47] => Maintenance Worker [49] => Millwright [51] => Operating Engineer [53] => Painter [55] => Paper Hanger [57] => PCC/Restoration [59] => Pile Driver [61] => Plasterer [63] => Plumber/Pipefitter [65] => Refractory Worker [67] => Reinforcing Ironworker [69] => Roofer/Waterproofer [71] => Scaffold Erector [73] => Sheetmetal Worker [75] => Sprinkler Fitter [77] => Stonemason [79] => Structural Ironworker [81] => Terrazzo Worker [83] => Tile Setter [85] => Truck Driver [87] => Welder [89] => Commercial & Institutional [90] => Jobsites [91] => Demolition [93] => Disasters [95] => Heavy & Highway [97] => Industrial [99] => LEED/Green Construction [101] => Renovations [103] => Residential [105] => Underground ) [type] => [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4426/d001656/Construction%2BDive%2B--%2BDeWalt%2527s%2BJobsite%2BPro%2Bheadphones%2Brecalled%2Bfor%2Bfire%2Bhazards.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [16] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 16 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Fire & Explosions [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [44] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 44 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Acoustical Ceiling Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [45] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 45 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Asbestos/Insulator [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [46] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 46 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Boilermaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [48] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 48 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cabinetmaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [50] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 50 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpet Layer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [52] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 52 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Commercial Diver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [53] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 53 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Concrete Polisher [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [54] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 54 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [58] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 58 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Glazier [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [59] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 59 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Hazardous Waste Cleanup [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [65] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 65 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Landscaper [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [66] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 66 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Lather [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [67] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 67 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Lead Abatement Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [69] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 69 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Millwright [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [72] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 72 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Paper Hanger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [73] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 73 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => PCC/Restoration [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [77] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 77 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Refractory Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [81] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 81 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sprinkler Fitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [83] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 83 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Terrazzo Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [84] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 84 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Tile Setter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [85] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 85 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Truck Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4426 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001656 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Construction Dive -- DeWalt's Jobsite Pro headphones recalled for fire hazards [total_pages:protected] => 1 [billed_pages:protected] => 1 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => DeWalt, Fire Hazards, recall, headphones [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A recall notice by the United States Consumer Product Safety Commission affects over 300,000 DeWalt Jobsite Pro Headphones. The recall is a result of a malfunction that can cause earbuds to overheat while charging or during use, leading to fire and burn hazards. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => https://www.constructiondive.com/news/dewalts-jobsite-pro-headphones-recalled-for-fire-hazards/611248/?utm_source=Sailthru&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Issue:%202021-12-10%20Construction%20Dive%20Newsletter%20%5Bissue:38532%5D&utm_term=Construction%20Dive [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/13/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/13/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 12/13/21 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [new_images] => Array ( [0] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Morning Toolbox Talk [image] => /record/images/4003-p.jpg [blurb] => This photo is from an early morning toolbox talk on a construction job in Mclean, Virginia. It is being delivered in English and Spanish.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 20 [1] => 51 [2] => 57 [3] => 64 [4] => 70 [5] => 63 [6] => 78 [7] => 82 [8] => 62 [9] => 87 [10] => 88 [11] => 89 [12] => 91 [13] => 90 [14] => 93 [15] => 94 [16] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Safety Culture [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Cement Mason [4] => Trades [5] => Flagger [7] => Laborer [9] => Operating Engineer [11] => Reinforcing Ironworker [13] => Roofer/Waterproofer [15] => Stonemason [17] => Structural Ironworker [19] => Commercial & Institutional [20] => Jobsites [21] => Demolition [23] => Disasters [25] => Heavy & Highway [27] => Industrial [29] => Renovations [31] => Residential [33] => Images [34] => Media [35] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4003/i002691/Morning%2BToolbox%2BTalk.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4003 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002691 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Morning Toolbox Talk [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, Spanish, bilingual [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This photo is from an early morning toolbox talk on a construction job in Mclean, Virginia. It is being delivered in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001285,d001304,c000079 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [1] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox talk - crew view [image] => /record/images/4005-p.jpg [blurb] => Photo of crew listening to a toolbox safety talk before starting work.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 97 [1] => 20 [2] => 47 [3] => 49 [4] => 51 [5] => 55 [6] => 61 [7] => 64 [8] => 71 [9] => 75 [10] => 63 [11] => 79 [12] => 62 [13] => 87 [14] => 88 [15] => 91 [16] => 90 [17] => 93 [18] => 94 [19] => 95 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Images [1] => Media [2] => Media & Documents [3] => Safety Culture [4] => Work Environment [5] => Hazards [6] => Bricklayer [7] => Trades [8] => Carpenter [10] => Cement Mason [12] => Electrical Worker [14] => Interior Systems Carpenter [16] => Laborer [18] => Painter [20] => Plasterer [22] => Reinforcing Ironworker [24] => Scaffold Erector [26] => Structural Ironworker [28] => Commercial & Institutional [29] => Jobsites [30] => Demolition [32] => Heavy & Highway [34] => Industrial [36] => Renovations [38] => Residential [40] => Underground ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4005/i002692/Toolbox%2Btalk%2B-%2Bcrew%2Bview.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4005 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002692 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox talk - crew view [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, safety talk, Spanish [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Photo of crew listening to a toolbox safety talk before starting work. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002691,d001269, c000079, d001285 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [2] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox talk - long shot [image] => /record/images/4006-p.jpg [blurb] => This crew gathered every morning before starting work to discuss a new safety topic.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 20 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 55 [5] => 64 [6] => 68 [7] => 75 [8] => 76 [9] => 63 [10] => 78 [11] => 79 [12] => 82 [13] => 62 [14] => 87 [15] => 88 [16] => 91 [17] => 90 [18] => 93 [19] => 94 [20] => 95 [21] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Safety Culture [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Electrical Worker [11] => Laborer [13] => Maintenance Worker [15] => Plasterer [17] => Plumber/Pipefitter [19] => Reinforcing Ironworker [21] => Roofer/Waterproofer [23] => Scaffold Erector [25] => Stonemason [27] => Structural Ironworker [29] => Commercial & Institutional [30] => Jobsites [31] => Demolition [33] => Heavy & Highway [35] => Industrial [37] => Renovations [39] => Residential [41] => Underground [43] => Images [44] => Media [45] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4006/i002693/Toolbox%2Btalk%2B-%2Blong%2Bshot.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4006 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002693 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox talk - long shot [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, safety minute [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This crew gathered every morning before starting work to discuss a new safety topic. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002691,i002692,d001269,d000527 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [3] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Safety officer discussing ongoing project with marketing coordinator [image] => /record/images/4014-p.jpg [blurb] => The safety officer (left) points out the good safety practices on this project that reflect well on the firm and may influence future clients.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 97 [1] => 20 [2] => 46 [3] => 47 [4] => 49 [5] => 50 [6] => 51 [7] => 54 [8] => 55 [9] => 58 [10] => 60 [11] => 61 [12] => 64 [13] => 71 [14] => 75 [15] => 76 [16] => 63 [17] => 79 [18] => 80 [19] => 82 [20] => 62 [21] => 83 [22] => 87 [23] => 91 [24] => 90 [25] => 93 [26] => 94 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Images [1] => Media [2] => Media & Documents [3] => Safety Culture [4] => Work Environment [5] => Hazards [6] => Boilermaker [7] => Trades [8] => Bricklayer [10] => Carpenter [12] => Carpet Layer [14] => Cement Mason [16] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [18] => Electrical Worker [20] => Glazier [22] => HVAC [24] => Interior Systems Carpenter [26] => Laborer [28] => Painter [30] => Plasterer [32] => Plumber/Pipefitter [34] => Reinforcing Ironworker [36] => Scaffold Erector [38] => Sheetmetal Worker [40] => Stonemason [42] => Structural Ironworker [44] => Terrazzo Worker [46] => Commercial & Institutional [47] => Jobsites [48] => Heavy & Highway [50] => Industrial [52] => Renovations [54] => Residential ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4014/i002700/Safety%2Bofficer%2Bdiscussing%2Bongoing%2Bproject%2Bwith%2Bmarketing%2Bcoordinator.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [46] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 46 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Boilermaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [50] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 50 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpet Layer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [54] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 54 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [58] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 58 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Glazier [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [83] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 83 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Terrazzo Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4014 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002700 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Safety officer discussing ongoing project with marketing coordinator [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Latino, safety officer, safety culture [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The safety officer (left) points out the good safety practices on this project that reflect well on the firm and may influence future clients. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/index.php [more_like_this:protected] => d000989,d001351,d001362,d000652, d001101, d000931, d001395 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Hoar Construction, Photo by Neil Lippy [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 01/30/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [4] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Scaffolding at top of large column [image] => /record/images/3994-p.jpg [blurb] => This shot shows innovative guarding around the top of a large concrete column in the base of a high rise structure going up.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 15 [1] => 21 [2] => 47 [3] => 51 [4] => 63 [5] => 78 [6] => 79 [7] => 80 [8] => 62 [9] => 87 [10] => 97 [11] => 56 [12] => 64 [13] => 74 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Falls [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Scaffolds [6] => Bricklayer [7] => Trades [8] => Cement Mason [10] => Reinforcing Ironworker [12] => Roofer/Waterproofer [14] => Scaffold Erector [16] => Sheetmetal Worker [18] => Structural Ironworker [20] => Commercial & Institutional [21] => Jobsites [22] => Images [23] => Media [24] => Media & Documents [25] => Elevator Constructor [27] => Laborer [29] => Pile Driver ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/3994/i002689/Scaffolding%2Bat%2Btop%2Bof%2Blarge%2Bcolumn.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [21] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 21 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Scaffolds [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3994 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002689 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Scaffolding at top of large column [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Guardrail, railing, fall prevention, falls [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This shot shows innovative guarding around the top of a large concrete column in the base of a high rise structure going up. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/8/adjustable-tower-scaffold.html [more_like_this:protected] => c1002680,i002662,d000608,d001255 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Photo by Pam Susi [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2016 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_completed:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/01/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [5] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Construction bracing [image] => /record/images/3995-p.jpg [blurb] => This shows structural support that prevents collapses during construction.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 15 [2] => 21 [3] => 49 [4] => 51 [5] => 55 [6] => 56 [7] => 60 [8] => 64 [9] => 68 [10] => 74 [11] => 63 [12] => 78 [13] => 79 [14] => 80 [15] => 62 [16] => 87 [17] => 90 [18] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Falls [6] => Scaffolds [9] => Carpenter [10] => Trades [11] => Cement Mason [13] => Electrical Worker [15] => Elevator Constructor [17] => HVAC [19] => Laborer [21] => Maintenance Worker [23] => Pile Driver [25] => Reinforcing Ironworker [27] => Roofer/Waterproofer [29] => Scaffold Erector [31] => Sheetmetal Worker [33] => Structural Ironworker [35] => Commercial & Institutional [36] => Jobsites [37] => Industrial [39] => Images [40] => Media [41] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/3995/i002690/Construction%2Bbracing.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [21] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 21 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Scaffolds [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3995 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002690 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Construction bracing [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Bracing, support, scaffold [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This shows structural support that prevents collapses during construction. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/8/adjustable-tower-scaffold.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002660 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Photo by Pam Susi [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2016 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_completed:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/01/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [preview_mode] => [description] => The results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. [keywords] => tuckpointing, HEPA vacuum, dust control, LEV, local exhaust ventilation, silica [related_items] => Array ( [Research Reports] => Array ( [0] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1874 [old_id:protected] => 722 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000683 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Sharon Garber/COD [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Protecting Tuckpointing Workers from Silica Dust: Draft Recommendations for a Ventilated Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 12 [billed_pages:protected] => 12 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, vacuum, grinder, mortar, respirator, OSHA, NIOSH, exhaust, Heitbrink, tuckpointer, silica, masonry, dust, silicosis, LEV [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Describes draft recommendations for use of ventilated grinder to reduce dust during tuckpointing and describes field trials using these devices. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/hazard/67/chip-scrape-and-grind-surfaces-or-joints-silica.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001201,d000292,d000293,d000658 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2005 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/27/05 [date_completed:protected] => 04/26/05 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/20/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [1] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1940 [old_id:protected] => 909 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Workplace Solutions: Control of Hazardous Dust During Tuckpointing [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, silica, dust, tuckpoint, grinder, masonry restoration, mortar, vacuum [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d000819,d000820,d000730,d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 10/24/08 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/09 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [2] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3899 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001342 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: Hilti VC40-U Vacuum with Hilti DC-EX Dust Guard and Hilti Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 15 [billed_pages:protected] => 15 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP4 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => silica, tuckpointing, Hilti, local exhaust systems, LEV, shroud, quartz [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This report describes the results of an evaluation of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Hilti VC40-U vacuum, a Hilti DC-EX shroud, and a Hilti DAG-500 grinder. Randomized trials with and without use of the dust control system were conducted in a controlled setting. Removing mortar with the Hilti grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 220 times the National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05mg/m3. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 97 percent. However, exposures measured during the use of the dust control system still exceeded the NIOSH REL. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => December 1, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/05/14 [date_completed:protected] => 02/04/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/06/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [Handouts] => Array ( [0] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3656 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001198 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 24 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction While Doing Tuckpointing/Mortar Removal [total_pages:protected] => 2 [billed_pages:protected] => 2 [publication_number:protected] => DSG FS-3632 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Brick, block, tuckpointing, silica, local exhaust ventilation, LEV, masonry [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Tuckpointing creates some of the greatest exposures to silica in construction. This OSHA factsheet provides guidance on how to greatly reduce these exposures through the use of local exhaust ventilation. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863, d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => February 2013 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/04/13 [date_completed:protected] => 03/27/13 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [collections] => Array ( [3913] => ) [record] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => Array ( [867] => Author Object ( [id:protected] => 867 [organization_id:protected] => 0 [firstname:protected] => Michael [lastname:protected] => Cooper [address:protected] => [city:protected] => [province:protected] => [country:protected] => [postal_code:protected] => [department:protected] => [title:protected] => [phone:protected] => [fax:protected] => [email:protected] => [degree:protected] => [website:protected] => [about:protected] => [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => [date_completed:protected] => [date_billed:protected] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [481] => Author Object ( [id:protected] => 481 [organization_id:protected] => 0 [firstname:protected] => Pam [lastname:protected] => Susi [address:protected] => 8484 Georgia Avenue, Suite 1000 [city:protected] => Silver Spring [province:protected] => Maryland [country:protected] => USA [postal_code:protected] => 20910 [department:protected] => [title:protected] => [phone:protected] => 301-578-8500 ext.144 [fax:protected] => 301-578-8572 [email:protected] => plsusi@aol.com [degree:protected] => [website:protected] => http://www.cpwr.com [about:protected] => [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => 2003-10-02 [date_completed:protected] => 2003-10-06 [date_billed:protected] => 2003-11-03 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [organizations:protected] => Array ( [1] => Organization Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [elcosh_id:protected] => o000001 [user_id:protected] => 14 [province_id:protected] => 21 [country_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => CPWR - The Center for Construction Research and Training [address:protected] => Suite 1000, 8484 Georgia Ave [postal_code:protected] => 20910 [city:protected] => Silver Spring [department:protected] => [phone:protected] => 301-578-8500 [fax:protected] => 301-578-8572 [email:protected] => cpwrwebsite@cpwr.com [website:protected] => http://www.cpwr.com [filename:protected] => o000001.gif [about:protected] => CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training, developed, and continues to maintain/expand this website - The Electronic Library of Construction Occupational Safety and Health, www.elcosh.org. CPWR, formerly known as The Center to Protect Workers’ Rights, is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit research and training institution. Created by the Building and Construction Trades Department, AFL-CIO, CPWR serves as the research arm of the BCTD. Since the inception of its research agenda in 1990, CPWR has grown into a worldwide provider of safety and health information covering all aspects of the construction industry. CPWR launched eLCOSH in 2000, and the Spanish-language version of the site in 2001. CPWR also created, and continues to build, Construction Solutions - www.cpwrConstructionSolutions.org - a free, online database of construction hazards and ways to prevent, eliminate, or reduce them. [comments:protected] => [logo_available:protected] => T [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => 2000-08-18 [date_completed:protected] => 2000-08-30 [date_billed:protected] => 2000-09-05 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [collections:protected] => Array ( [3913] => ) [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => Array ( [1874] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1874 [old_id:protected] => 722 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000683 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Sharon Garber/COD [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Protecting Tuckpointing Workers from Silica Dust: Draft Recommendations for a Ventilated Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 12 [billed_pages:protected] => 12 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, vacuum, grinder, mortar, respirator, OSHA, NIOSH, exhaust, Heitbrink, tuckpointer, silica, masonry, dust, silicosis, LEV [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Describes draft recommendations for use of ventilated grinder to reduce dust during tuckpointing and describes field trials using these devices. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/hazard/67/chip-scrape-and-grind-surfaces-or-joints-silica.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001201,d000292,d000293,d000658 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2005 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/27/05 [date_completed:protected] => 04/26/05 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/20/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [1940] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1940 [old_id:protected] => 909 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Workplace Solutions: Control of Hazardous Dust During Tuckpointing [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, silica, dust, tuckpoint, grinder, masonry restoration, mortar, vacuum [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d000819,d000820,d000730,d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 10/24/08 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/09 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [2213] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 2213 [old_id:protected] => 1090 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => [language_id:protected] => 2 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Control del polvo peligroso que se genera durante los procesos de reparación de mortero [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => 2008-126 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => [comments:protected] => http://www.cdc.gov/spanish/niosh/docs/wp-solutions/2008-126_sp/ [summary:protected] => A Workplace Solutions de NIOSH que resume un estudio de NIOSH sobre los riesgos de exposición cuando se reparan las estructuras y los métodos para controlar el polvo. [A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust.] [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => D000819,D000820,D000730,d000819 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 01/07/10 [date_completed:protected] => 04/19/10 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 07/08/12 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [3656] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3656 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001198 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 24 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction While Doing Tuckpointing/Mortar Removal [total_pages:protected] => 2 [billed_pages:protected] => 2 [publication_number:protected] => DSG FS-3632 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Brick, block, tuckpointing, silica, local exhaust ventilation, LEV, masonry [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Tuckpointing creates some of the greatest exposures to silica in construction. This OSHA factsheet provides guidance on how to greatly reduce these exposures through the use of local exhaust ventilation. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863, d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => February 2013 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/04/13 [date_completed:protected] => 03/27/13 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [3899] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3899 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001342 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: Hilti VC40-U Vacuum with Hilti DC-EX Dust Guard and Hilti Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 15 [billed_pages:protected] => 15 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP4 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => silica, tuckpointing, Hilti, local exhaust systems, LEV, shroud, quartz [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This report describes the results of an evaluation of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Hilti VC40-U vacuum, a Hilti DC-EX shroud, and a Hilti DAG-500 grinder. Randomized trials with and without use of the dust control system were conducted in a controlled setting. Removing mortar with the Hilti grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 220 times the National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05mg/m3. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 97 percent. However, exposures measured during the use of the dust control system still exceeded the NIOSH REL. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => December 1, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/05/14 [date_completed:protected] => 02/04/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/06/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [content:protected] => [files:protected] => Array ( [559] => [560] => [546] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 546 [filename:protected] => 3.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:22 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [566] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 566 [filename:protected] => 4.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:23 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [720] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 720 [filename:protected] => 5.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [721] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 721 [filename:protected] => 6.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [722] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 722 [filename:protected] => 7.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [9765] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 9765 [filename:protected] => d001345.pdf [downloadable:protected] => T [timestamp:protected] => 2015-02-09 12:26:04 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3908 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001345 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: DustControl 2900c Vacuum with the ICS Dust Director Shroud and Bosch Grinder Model 1775E Conducted November 14-15, 2012 [total_pages:protected] => 13 [billed_pages:protected] => 13 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP2 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => tuckpointing, HEPA vacuum, dust control, LEV, local exhaust ventilation, silica [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => April 15, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 01/26/15 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/09/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [show_text] => [document_content] => ElcoshItemDocumentContent Object ( [id:protected] => 2934 [item_id:protected] => 3908 [type:protected] => main [title:protected] => [content:protected] =>
Executive Summary
This report describes the results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. It should also be noted that the NIOSH REL is based on exposures averaged over a ten hour work day and our results represent time weighted averages of the sample task duration periods.
Acronyms
ACGIH - American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists
CPWR - CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training
Ce - coefficient of entry
HEPA - high-efficiency particulate air
IUBAC - International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craftworkers
LEV - local exhaust ventilation
PACT - Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies
NIOSH - National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health
OEL - occupational exposure limit
OSHA - Occupational Safety and Health Administration
PAPR - powered air-purifying respirator
PEL - Permissible Exposure Limit
PVC - polyvinyl chloride
REL - Recommended Exposure Limit
RPM - revolutions per minute
TWA - time-weighted average
SP - static pressure
I. Introduction and Background
In 2010 CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training began a four-year project which seeks to identify and evaluate tuckpointing local exhaust ventilation (LEV) systems and disseminate information on their availability and effectiveness. A Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies (PACT) comprised of masonry contractors, representatives from unions, government, equipment manufacturers, and health and safety researcher was formed as part of this project. PACT members participated in identifying important characteristics for control technologies and this information was used to identify LEV systems for tuckpointing using that criteria. Contractor and labor members of the PACT selected specific tuckpointing LEV systems to be considered for evaluation. Each system consisted of a tuckpointing grinder, shroud, and vacuum. This report describes the second of four systems to be evaluated between 2012 the end of 2014, with and without LEV, in a controlled setting to determine effectiveness in silica exposure reduction. This report describes the methods and results of our evaluation of a system consisting of the DustControl 2900c vacuum with the ICS Dust Director shroud and a Bosch Model 1775E grinder.
Excessive exposure to respirable silica can result in silicosis or other silica-related diseases including pulmonary tuberculosis, lung cancer, silicoproteinosis (Lyons et al, 2007) and autoimmune disorders such as rheumatoid arthritis, sarcoidosis and scleroderma (Miller et al, 2012). Respirable silica is generally defined as particles less than 10 micrometers (μm) in aerodynamic diameter (ACGIH, 2013). Silicosis can lead to symptoms including shortness of breath, fatigue, chest pains, susceptibility to infection and possibly death. There is no cure for silicosis, however it is totally preventable. Construction workers exposed to dust, including silica, are also known to have higher rates of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD).
There are many sources of silica in construction that result in exposures of varying intensity among workers. Masonry restoration workers are among the most highly silica-exposed trades in construction. The process of grinding out deteriorated mortar joints between masonry units and replacing or repointing with fresh mortar (often referred to as tuckpointing) is a fundamental part of masonry restoration work. The removal of mortar with powered angle grinders generates enormous levels of dust. Between 2004 and 2006, NIOSH and CPWR evaluated silica exposures while grinding mortar in a controlled setting, at a local training center, where tasks, sample times and task variables were defined by the study design. These studies demonstrated that grinding mortar without controls can result in elevated respirable silica exposures. Meeker et al., (2009) reported exposures between 5 and 25.8 milligrams per cubic meter (mg/m3) in a controlled setting. This study also showed that LEV systems for tuckpointing grinders can reduce exposures to respirable silica by greater than 90 percent.II. Objectives
The objective of this evaluation was to assess the effectiveness of an LEV system for controlling exposure to silica during the grinding of mortar. The control technology was tested under controlled conditions, similar to those experienced by tuckpointers on actual job sites, using journeymen bricklayers experienced in tuckpointing and repeat, randomized trials with and without LEV. All other variables were held constant throughout so that the only variable was whether or not the tested control was used.
III. Description of Equipment Tested
A Bosch model 1775E grinder (Robert Bosch Tool Corporation, Prospect, IL) (Figures 1, 2 and 3) was fitted with a new 1/4-inch wide, 4½-inch diameter segmented diamond abrasive blade made by DeWalt (model #DW4740). The grinder weighs six and a half pounds, draws 8.5 amps and has a variable speed up to 11,000 revolutions per minute (RPMs). The DustControl 2900c vacuum (DustControl, Inc., Wilmington, NC) (Figure 3) was tested in combination with the Dust Director shroud (Industrial Contractors’ Supplies, Inc., Huntingdon, PA) (Figures 1 and 3) attached to the Bosch grinder.
Figure 1. Bosch grinder with Dust Director shroud
Figure 2. Bosch grinder without tuckpointing LEV system.
Figure 3: Bosch Grinder with LEV System
The vacuum is specified to weigh 31 pounds when empty and to provide a flow rate of 114 cubic feet of air per minute and a “static lift” or “vacuum suction pressure” of 84 inches of water. The vacuum is sold with a cyclonic pre-separator, to remove larger particles, a fine filter (rated 99.9 percent efficient) and a HEPA (high-efficiency particulate air) filter (rated to capture 99.97 percent of the particles with an aerodynamic diameter of 0.3 micrometers). The HEPA filter was removed based on the manufacturer’s recommendation due to the heavy dust loading associated with tuckpointing. CPWR sponsored research and contractor experience indicate that HEPA filters likely have an adverse effect on dust capture during tuckpointing because of extreme dust loading on filters. While the cyclone and the fine filter remove most of the dust, especially the large particles, before they reach the HEPA filter, the HEPA filter would still be subject to heavy loading, causing a substantial pressure drop and subsequent decrease in air flow rate. The relatively small increase in the efficiency of the filtration system while using the HEPA filter is expected to be quickly offset by a more significant decrease in capture efficiency as the air flow rate and ability to capture particles decreases.
Dust collects in relatively inexpensive, heavy-gauge plastic bags below and outside of the cyclone. The bags can be removed and replaced without opening the vacuum. Some vacuums are equipped with a light to indicate that the filters need to be cleaned or changed. The DC2900c features a “reverse air pulse cleaning system,” which removes accumulated dust from the filters without having to remove them from the vacuum. The system, as illustrated in Figure 4, requires the operator to disconnect the hose from the shroud, place it over an air stop so that air through the hose is cut off and pressure in the vacuum is maximized.
Figure 4. Procedure for "cleaning" of or dust removal from filters (source: http://dustcontrolusa.com/manuals/2800c.pdf)
The flap covering the port on the side of the vacuum is repeatedly flipped open to release built up pressure in strong pulses that dislodge dust from the filter.
The manufacturer indicates “the filter is generally cleaned once or twice daily during normal continuous operation.” The Dust Director shroud has a 2-inch diameter take-off that was connected to the antistatic, corrugated 1.5-inch diameter, 15-foot long vacuum hose supplied with the DustControl vacuum.
IV. Study Methods
This evaluation was conducted at the International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craft workers (IUBAC) Local 1 Philadelphia/Delaware Training Center in Philadelphia, PA on November 14 and 15, 2012. A single journeyman bricklayer, experienced in tuckpointing, used the grinder and LEV system being tested to remove mortar from joints wide enough to require two passes. The type S mortar had been allowed to cure for at least four weeks. The bricklayer either possessed or was provided with personal protective equipment including sturdy work boots, gloves, hearing protection and a powered air-purifying respirator (PAPR). The PAPR was a 3M GVP system with a bump cap, loose fitting face piece and a HEPA filter (3M, St Paul, MN).
The study was designed to include at least five rounds of sampling during mortar removal. Each round included a trial using the Bosch grinder with a Dust Director shroud and Dust Collector 2900c vacuum and a trial using the Bosch grinder with the factory-supplied guard and without a vacuum. The order of the two trials within each round was randomly selected to minimize bias that might be introduced due to variation associated with environmental factors, equipment operator, blade wear, vacuum performance over time and any other factors unrelated to LEV use. Tools were operated for approximately 16 minutes per trial with controls and for approximately 8 minutes when controls were not used. These times were selected based on the results of previous sampling efforts and estimates of the minimum sample time needed to achieve a limit of quantification low enough to accurately measure exposures down to or less than 0.05 mg/m3 – the NIOSH Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) for respirable silica. The bricklayer was required to take a 5 to 10 minute break in the middle of the 16-minute trials to reduce differences in fatigue, compared to the 8-minute trials. Personal air samples were collected in the breathing zone of the operator during each trial to measure respirable silica concentrations during grinding with and without LEV. The samples were collected using a GilAir-5 pump (Sensidyne, Inc., Clearwater, FL) to draw 4.2 liters of air per minute through a GK2.69 Respirable Cyclone (BGI Inc., Waltham, MA) with a pre-weighed, 37 mm diameter, 5-micron pore size polyvinyl chloride (PVC) filter positioned on the operator’s lapel.
The flow rates of the sampling pumps were calibrated at the beginning of each day using a DryCal DC-Lite Primary Flow Meter (Bios International Corporation, Butler, NJ). Flow rates were measured again near the middle and at the end of each day to ensure that sampling flow rates were maintained within 5% of pre-sampling flow rates throughout the day. Average flow rates were used to calculate sample air volumes. Samples were analyzed by R.J. Lee Group, Inc., (Monroeville, PA) using NIOSH Method 0600, to determine exposure to total mass of respirable dust. The same samples were also analyzed using X-Ray diffraction following NIOSH method 7500 to determine quartz, cristobalite and tridymite concentration in the respirable mass. Reported masses for these analytes were used with the sample air volumes to calculate airborne concentrations of total respirable dust, quartz, cristobalite and tridymite.
We used a reduction of greater than 50 percent in respirable silica exposure concentrations or a reduction to less than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 as our criteria for determining whether or not a control was considered efficacious. This is consistent with criteria used by NIOSH in conducting a similar study in 2004 described by Echt et al. (2007) and by CPWR in 2006 and described by Meeker et al. (2009). The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) and the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) publish additional occupational exposure limits (OELs) for silica which are listed in Table 1 with NIOSH RELs. OELs for silica are based on the respirable fraction of the aerosol, which consists of particles less than 10 micrometers in aerodynamic diameter.
| Organization or Agency | Form of Crystalline Silica | Occupational Exposure Limits (mg/m3) |
|---|---|---|
| NIOSHA | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 |
| OSHA - ConstructionB | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
PEL = 250 / (5 + % quartz) PEL = 250 / (5 + % cristobalite) PEL = 250 / (5 + % tridymite) |
| ACGIH | Crystalline Silica | TLV = 0.025 mg/m3 |
A NIOSH Publication No. 2005-151 indicates 10-hour time-weighted average during a 40-hr workweek B The PEL for silica in OSHA’s Safety and Health Regulations for Construction, 29 C.F.R. 1926.55(a), is an 8-hour time-weighted average (TWA) expressed in millions of particles per cubic foot (mppcf). However, the units mppcf can be converted to milligrams per cubic meter can by dividing mppcf by 10 (OSHA, 2009). The formula used by OSHA to determine the PEL for silica is dependent on the percentage of silica in each collected sample. The concentration of respirable dust measured is compared to the sample specific PEL to determine if the PEL has been exceeded. OSHA has proposed lowering the PEL to 0.05 mg/m3 of respirable silica as an 8 hour TWA. |
||
The flow of air in ventilation systems is governed by fundamental principles that describe the behavior of gases (in this case air). Pressure measurements taken within a ventilation system along with knowledge of hood (or shroud) entry losses can be used to calculate flow rates. Hood entry losses are dependent on the shape and configuration of a particular hood or shroud and described by the term “coefficient of entry (Ce)” which is the ratio of actual air flow through a hood and what the air flow would theoretically be if there were no hood entry losses. Given the coefficient of entry, static pressure measurements can be used to calculate air flow through a given hood. The coefficient of entry for the Dust Director shroud was previously determined by CPWR and used for calculating air flow based on static pressure measurements (Meeker et al., 2009). Static pressure, with the vacuum operating, was measured periodically throughout the evaluation to monitor the changes in air-flow rate following use and again after filter cleaning. The static pressure was measured at a port positioned more than 3 duct diameters downstream from the tool’s air intake using a UEi EM200 Electronic Manometer (Universal Enterprises, Inc., Beaverton, OR).
The dust in the vacuum bag was monitored and, per the manufacturer’s instructions, the bag was changed before the dust level was within 5 centimeters of the valve at the bottom of the vacuum. Each time a vacuum bag was removed, it was weighed to the nearest pound. The bag weights and corresponding grinding durations were used to calculate the average weight of dust collected per unit time. After each trial, cut lengths were measured on the wall to determine total linear feet of vertical (head) and horizontal (bed) joints per unit time.
A Haz-Dust III, Model HD-1003, Real-Time Aerosol Monitor (Environmental Devices Corporation, Plaistow, NH) was used to confirm clearance of dust between trials. The Haz-Dust monitor was positioned on the test wall near the operator at approximately breathing zone level and configured to measure respirable particulate concentration.
V. Results
Personal air monitoring
Five pairs of respirable dust samples were collected while grinding with and without the vacuum system. In addition, three respirable dust samples were collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place. One measurement collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard was shown to be a statistical outlier and was omitted from analysis. Personal air monitoring results for respirable silica and a comparison of average exposures relative to the NIOSH REL for silica (0.05 mg/m3) appears in Table 2. The mean respirable dust levels measured without LEV was 31.4 mg/m3. However, samples collected with LEV were below the limit of quantification (LOQ) which ranged from <1.29 to <1.46 mg/m3. Use of LEV resulted in a greater than 95% reduction in mean respirable dust levels using a mean value with use of LEV of <1.41 (n=5 samples with use of LEV and n=7 without use of LEV). The respirable dust samples collected during grinding without the LEV system contained an average of 24 percent silica. The mass of respirable dust in the samples collected with use of the LEV system was too low to determine the silica content.| Mean, mg/m3 (range) | Std. Dev. | Percent Reduction | Hazard RatioB | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bosch with Dust Director Shroud and DustControl 2900c Vacuum |
0.091 (<0.069 – 0.137) |
0.027 | 98.7 | 1.81 |
| Bosch with no Control | 7.23 (4.57 – 9.90) |
1.94 | NA | 145 |
A n = 5 samples for each tool/control combination and n = 7 samples without the use of the LEV system B Hazard Ratio = measured exposure / NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 |
||||
Average respirable silica and dust exposures, with and without the dust control system, appear as Figures 5 and 6, respectively.
Figure 5. Average respirable silica exposures with and without the Dustcontrol 2900c vacuum and Dust Director shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air - mg/m3)
Figure 6. Average respirable dust exposures with and without Dustcontrol 2900c Vacuum and Dust Director Shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air – mg/m3)
The mean respirable silica concentration measured during use of the control was significantly less than the concentration measured while using the same tool without controls (p<0.01). Grinding mortar with the Bosch angle grinder without dust controls resulted in an average exposure to respirable silica that was 145 times the NIOSH REL. Grinding with the Bosch angle grinder in combination with the Dust Director shroud and the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced the average concentration of respirable silica by 98.7 percent. With use of these controls, the concentration of respirable silica was 1.8 times greater than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3. However the NIOSH REL is based on a time-weighted average (TWA) over a 10-hour workday. Given these were task TWAs and samples were collected over continuous periods of grinding, they may overestimate exposures over an actual work day since some time would be spent performing tasks that would likely have lower, or no, silica exposures (setup, breaks, cleanup, etc.).
Static pressure, dust mass collection and grinding rates.
Static pressure was used as a surrogate for air flow as described earlier. Hood static pressure was measured periodically at a tap near the grinder more than 3 duct diameters from the air intake in the shroud. The static pressure, and thus air flow, was generally higher when the vacuum’s filter had recently been cleaned. The mean, median, and range of calculated flow rates are presented in Table A1 of the Appendix.
Based on the data we collected, the air-flow rate upstream from the Bosch grinder and Dust Director shroud ranged from 78 to 93 cubic feet per minute (cfm) with the DustControl vacuum. When the manufacturer’s filter cleaning procedure was followed the vacuum performed relatively well and flow could be maintained at slightly less than 90 cfm with cleaning. However, mean flow rates dropped substantially to 80 cfm after as little as 8 minutes of grinding without any filter cleaning. The flow rate returned to an average of 89 cfm when filters were cleaned correctly (without stopping air flow to the vacuum). Collingwood and Heitbrink (2007) found that the minimum exhaust flow rate for capture of silica and other particulate under ideal conditions is 21.25 cfm per inch of grinder blade diameter. This is equal to about 96 cfm when using a 4.5 inch diameter grinding blade. We set 106 cfm as the minimum desired flow rate for this study to allow a safety margin for potential decline in equipment performance and the possibility of inadequate maintenance, both of which may be likely after repeated use under actual work conditions. The DustControl vacuum provided slightly less than the minimum flow rate described by Collingwood and Heitbrink for a 4.5-inch blade and the peak flow rate fell with use.
The duration of vacuum bag use and mass of dust collected were recorded and are presented in Table A2 of the Appendix. The vacuum bags were changed and weighed after each trial utilizing the LEV system. A total of five bags were used to complete the five rounds of grinding. The DustControl vacuum captured 45 pounds of dust over 83 minutes of grinding for an average rate of dust collection of 0.54 pounds per minute. The rate of dust collection ranged from 0.47 to 0.63 pounds per minute. Based on these measurements, approximately 130 pounds of dust would likely be captured after just 4 hours of continuous grinding.
The rate of grinding a combination of vertical and horizontal joints while using the LEV system ranged from 2.3 to 3.3 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the use of the LEV system ranged from 2.6 to 3.4 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place ranged from 4.7 to 5.1 feet per minute. It’s important to note that: 1) the operator had limited experience using dust control systems and cut rates appeared to improve slightly over the 2-day period he used the tested equipment; and 2) the upper range of cut rates with the dust control system overlapped with the lowest cut rate with the original guard and without the LEV system in place indicating no statistical difference between cut rates. Given that grinding rates with and without use of this LEV system are only available for one operator and he had limited experience with the LEV system, these reported cut rates are in no way intended to represent the impact use of this LEV system is likely to have on productivity rates overall.
VI. Discussion
The objective of these trials was to evaluate the effectiveness of a tuckpointing LEV system for controlling respirable silica while grinding out mortar joints. The Dust Director shroud with the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced respirable silica concentrations when grinding with the Bosch grinder by approximately 99 percent. Despite being considered effective by our test criteria (greater than 50% reduction), it still resulted in task TWA exposures that exceeded the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 by 1.8 times. Depending on how much time is spent grinding over the course of a work day and on exposures while performing other tasks, the 8-hour TWA exposures may or may not exceed the REL with this system. Use of this system by workers with experience and training in proficient use will likely improve dust capture performance. Exposure reduction is greatly influenced by correct use of this system which includes grinding from right to left, making sure the shroud is held flush against the wall and that the tool travels at a pace that doesn’t exceed the ability of the system to capture dust as it’s generated. Deviation from any of these measures produces visible dust clouds which were observed during trials.
VII. Conclusions
With a 99 percent reduction in respirable silica exposure, the Dust Director shroud and DustControl 2900c vacuum with a Bosch Model 1775E grinder was effective in reducing silica exposures based on our criteria. Use of the tested dust control system may be effective in reducing silica exposure on the job to less than the NIOSH REL if used in combination with administrative controls such as work scheduling to reduce cutting times as needed. Training on correct use of the tested system is also essential. Personal air monitoring is necessary to verify control effectiveness on actual job sites and under “real-world” conditions. However, these results clearly demonstrate the availability of viable and effective engineering controls for tuckpointing operations associated with elevated silica exposure.
VIII. References
American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists. Threshold limit values for chemical substances (TLV®-CS). [2013]. ACGIH, Cincinnati, Ohio.
Bergdahl I.A,. Toren K., Eriksson K., et al. [2004]. Increased mortality in COPD among construction workers exposed to inorganic dust. European Respiratory Journal, 23: 402–06.
Blanc P.D. & Torén K. [2007]. Occupation in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and chronic bronchitis: an update [State of the Art Series. Occupational lung disease in high-and low-income countries, Edited by M. Chan-Yeung. Number 2 in the series]. The International Journal of Tuberculosis and Lung Disease, 11(3), 251-257.
Collingwood S. & Heitbrink W.A. [2007] 'Field Evaluation of an Engineering Control for Respirable Crystalline Silica Exposures During Mortar Removal'. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, 4:11, 875 – 887.
DHHS (NIOSH) Publication No. 2002-129 April 2002 http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/2002-129/
Echt A., Sieber W.K., Lefkowitz D., Meeker J., Susi P., Cardwell B., Heitbrink, W.A. In-depth survey of dust control technology for cutting concrete block and tuckpointing brick at The International Masonry Institute Bordentown Training Center, Bordentown, NJ. Cincinnati, OH: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Report. No. EPHB 282-13; 2007. http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ECTB-282-13.pdf
Heitbrink W., Bennett J. [2006]. A numerical and experimental investigation of crystalline silica exposure control during tuck pointing. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, Vol. 3, pp 366-378.
Lyons et al, [2007]. A breathless builder. Breathe, Vol. 3, no. 4, pp 386-390.
Mastrangelo G., Tartari M., Fedeli U., Fadda E., Saia B. [2003]. Ascertaining the risk of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease in relation to occupation using a case-control design. Occupational Medicine, 53: 165–172.
Meeker J., Cooper M., Lefrowitz D., Susi P. [2009]. Engineering control technologies to reduce occupational silica exposures in masonry cutting and tuckpointing. Public Health Reports, Supplement 1, Vol. 124, June.
Meeker J, Flynn M, Susi P, Cardwell, B [2004]. Performance evaluation of a masonry concrete vacuum. Unpublished Report.
Miller F. W., Alfredsson L., Costenbader K. H., Kamen D. L., Nelson L. M., Norris J. M., & De Roos A. J. [2012]. Epidemiology of environmental exposures and human autoimmune diseases: findings from a National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences Expert Panel workshop. Journal of autoimmunity. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3496812/
Occupational Safety and Health Administration U.S Department of Labor. Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction. [2009]. OSHA 3362-05.
Rappaport SM, Goldberg M, Susi P, Herrick RF [2003]. Excessive exposure to silica in the U.S. construction industry. Annals of Occupational Hygiene, Vol. 47, pp. 111-122.
IX. Appendices
| Measurement Conditions |
n | Mean Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Median
Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before filter cleaning | 5 | 80 | 81 | 78-81 |
| After filter cleaning following manufacturer directions | 9 | 89 | 90 | 84-93 |
| * Static pressure was measured in millibars and converted to inches of water gauge. Flow rates were calculated using the formula Q = Ce (A) 4005 (SP)1/2 where: Q = flow in cubic feet per minute (cfm), Ce = coefficient of entry, A = area of the duct where static pressure measurements were taken in square feet, and SP = static pressure in inches of water gauge. | ||||
| Tool/Control | Collection Period (min.) |
Dust Collection Rate (lb/min.) |
|---|---|---|
| Bosch grinder/Dust Director shroud & DustControl 2900c vacuum |
8 11 8 8 10 |
0.50 0.61 0.50 0.47 0.63 |
| Average | 0.54 |
[content_transformed:protected] =>
Executive Summary
This report describes the results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. It should also be noted that the NIOSH REL is based on exposures averaged over a ten hour work day and our results represent time weighted averages of the sample task duration periods.
Acronyms
ACGIH - American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists
CPWR - CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training
Ce - coefficient of entry
HEPA - high-efficiency particulate air
IUBAC - International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craftworkers
LEV - local exhaust ventilation
PACT - Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies
NIOSH - National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health
OEL - occupational exposure limit
OSHA - Occupational Safety and Health Administration
PAPR - powered air-purifying respirator
PEL - Permissible Exposure Limit
PVC - polyvinyl chloride
REL - Recommended Exposure Limit
RPM - revolutions per minute
TWA - time-weighted average
SP - static pressure
I. Introduction and Background
In 2010 CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training began a four-year project which seeks to identify and evaluate tuckpointing local exhaust ventilation (LEV) systems and disseminate information on their availability and effectiveness. A Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies (PACT) comprised of masonry contractors, representatives from unions, government, equipment manufacturers, and health and safety researcher was formed as part of this project. PACT members participated in identifying important characteristics for control technologies and this information was used to identify LEV systems for tuckpointing using that criteria. Contractor and labor members of the PACT selected specific tuckpointing LEV systems to be considered for evaluation. Each system consisted of a tuckpointing grinder, shroud, and vacuum. This report describes the second of four systems to be evaluated between 2012 the end of 2014, with and without LEV, in a controlled setting to determine effectiveness in silica exposure reduction. This report describes the methods and results of our evaluation of a system consisting of the DustControl 2900c vacuum with the ICS Dust Director shroud and a Bosch Model 1775E grinder.
Excessive exposure to respirable silica can result in silicosis or other silica-related diseases including pulmonary tuberculosis, lung cancer, silicoproteinosis (Lyons et al, 2007) and autoimmune disorders such as rheumatoid arthritis, sarcoidosis and scleroderma (Miller et al, 2012). Respirable silica is generally defined as particles less than 10 micrometers (μm) in aerodynamic diameter (ACGIH, 2013). Silicosis can lead to symptoms including shortness of breath, fatigue, chest pains, susceptibility to infection and possibly death. There is no cure for silicosis, however it is totally preventable. Construction workers exposed to dust, including silica, are also known to have higher rates of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD).
There are many sources of silica in construction that result in exposures of varying intensity among workers. Masonry restoration workers are among the most highly silica-exposed trades in construction. The process of grinding out deteriorated mortar joints between masonry units and replacing or repointing with fresh mortar (often referred to as tuckpointing) is a fundamental part of masonry restoration work. The removal of mortar with powered angle grinders generates enormous levels of dust. Between 2004 and 2006, NIOSH and CPWR evaluated silica exposures while grinding mortar in a controlled setting, at a local training center, where tasks, sample times and task variables were defined by the study design. These studies demonstrated that grinding mortar without controls can result in elevated respirable silica exposures. Meeker et al., (2009) reported exposures between 5 and 25.8 milligrams per cubic meter (mg/m3) in a controlled setting. This study also showed that LEV systems for tuckpointing grinders can reduce exposures to respirable silica by greater than 90 percent.II. Objectives
The objective of this evaluation was to assess the effectiveness of an LEV system for controlling exposure to silica during the grinding of mortar. The control technology was tested under controlled conditions, similar to those experienced by tuckpointers on actual job sites, using journeymen bricklayers experienced in tuckpointing and repeat, randomized trials with and without LEV. All other variables were held constant throughout so that the only variable was whether or not the tested control was used.
III. Description of Equipment Tested
A Bosch model 1775E grinder (Robert Bosch Tool Corporation, Prospect, IL) (Figures 1, 2 and 3) was fitted with a new 1/4-inch wide, 4½-inch diameter segmented diamond abrasive blade made by DeWalt (model #DW4740). The grinder weighs six and a half pounds, draws 8.5 amps and has a variable speed up to 11,000 revolutions per minute (RPMs). The DustControl 2900c vacuum (DustControl, Inc., Wilmington, NC) (Figure 3) was tested in combination with the Dust Director shroud (Industrial Contractors’ Supplies, Inc., Huntingdon, PA) (Figures 1 and 3) attached to the Bosch grinder.
Figure 1. Bosch grinder with Dust Director shroud
Figure 2. Bosch grinder without tuckpointing LEV system.
Figure 3: Bosch Grinder with LEV System
The vacuum is specified to weigh 31 pounds when empty and to provide a flow rate of 114 cubic feet of air per minute and a “static lift” or “vacuum suction pressure” of 84 inches of water. The vacuum is sold with a cyclonic pre-separator, to remove larger particles, a fine filter (rated 99.9 percent efficient) and a HEPA (high-efficiency particulate air) filter (rated to capture 99.97 percent of the particles with an aerodynamic diameter of 0.3 micrometers). The HEPA filter was removed based on the manufacturer’s recommendation due to the heavy dust loading associated with tuckpointing. CPWR sponsored research and contractor experience indicate that HEPA filters likely have an adverse effect on dust capture during tuckpointing because of extreme dust loading on filters. While the cyclone and the fine filter remove most of the dust, especially the large particles, before they reach the HEPA filter, the HEPA filter would still be subject to heavy loading, causing a substantial pressure drop and subsequent decrease in air flow rate. The relatively small increase in the efficiency of the filtration system while using the HEPA filter is expected to be quickly offset by a more significant decrease in capture efficiency as the air flow rate and ability to capture particles decreases.
Dust collects in relatively inexpensive, heavy-gauge plastic bags below and outside of the cyclone. The bags can be removed and replaced without opening the vacuum. Some vacuums are equipped with a light to indicate that the filters need to be cleaned or changed. The DC2900c features a “reverse air pulse cleaning system,” which removes accumulated dust from the filters without having to remove them from the vacuum. The system, as illustrated in Figure 4, requires the operator to disconnect the hose from the shroud, place it over an air stop so that air through the hose is cut off and pressure in the vacuum is maximized.
Figure 4. Procedure for "cleaning" of or dust removal from filters (source: http://dustcontrolusa.com/manuals/2800c.pdf)
The flap covering the port on the side of the vacuum is repeatedly flipped open to release built up pressure in strong pulses that dislodge dust from the filter.
The manufacturer indicates “the filter is generally cleaned once or twice daily during normal continuous operation.” The Dust Director shroud has a 2-inch diameter take-off that was connected to the antistatic, corrugated 1.5-inch diameter, 15-foot long vacuum hose supplied with the DustControl vacuum.
IV. Study Methods
This evaluation was conducted at the International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craft workers (IUBAC) Local 1 Philadelphia/Delaware Training Center in Philadelphia, PA on November 14 and 15, 2012. A single journeyman bricklayer, experienced in tuckpointing, used the grinder and LEV system being tested to remove mortar from joints wide enough to require two passes. The type S mortar had been allowed to cure for at least four weeks. The bricklayer either possessed or was provided with personal protective equipment including sturdy work boots, gloves, hearing protection and a powered air-purifying respirator (PAPR). The PAPR was a 3M GVP system with a bump cap, loose fitting face piece and a HEPA filter (3M, St Paul, MN).
The study was designed to include at least five rounds of sampling during mortar removal. Each round included a trial using the Bosch grinder with a Dust Director shroud and Dust Collector 2900c vacuum and a trial using the Bosch grinder with the factory-supplied guard and without a vacuum. The order of the two trials within each round was randomly selected to minimize bias that might be introduced due to variation associated with environmental factors, equipment operator, blade wear, vacuum performance over time and any other factors unrelated to LEV use. Tools were operated for approximately 16 minutes per trial with controls and for approximately 8 minutes when controls were not used. These times were selected based on the results of previous sampling efforts and estimates of the minimum sample time needed to achieve a limit of quantification low enough to accurately measure exposures down to or less than 0.05 mg/m3 – the NIOSH Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) for respirable silica. The bricklayer was required to take a 5 to 10 minute break in the middle of the 16-minute trials to reduce differences in fatigue, compared to the 8-minute trials. Personal air samples were collected in the breathing zone of the operator during each trial to measure respirable silica concentrations during grinding with and without LEV. The samples were collected using a GilAir-5 pump (Sensidyne, Inc., Clearwater, FL) to draw 4.2 liters of air per minute through a GK2.69 Respirable Cyclone (BGI Inc., Waltham, MA) with a pre-weighed, 37 mm diameter, 5-micron pore size polyvinyl chloride (PVC) filter positioned on the operator’s lapel.
The flow rates of the sampling pumps were calibrated at the beginning of each day using a DryCal DC-Lite Primary Flow Meter (Bios International Corporation, Butler, NJ). Flow rates were measured again near the middle and at the end of each day to ensure that sampling flow rates were maintained within 5% of pre-sampling flow rates throughout the day. Average flow rates were used to calculate sample air volumes. Samples were analyzed by R.J. Lee Group, Inc., (Monroeville, PA) using NIOSH Method 0600, to determine exposure to total mass of respirable dust. The same samples were also analyzed using X-Ray diffraction following NIOSH method 7500 to determine quartz, cristobalite and tridymite concentration in the respirable mass. Reported masses for these analytes were used with the sample air volumes to calculate airborne concentrations of total respirable dust, quartz, cristobalite and tridymite.
We used a reduction of greater than 50 percent in respirable silica exposure concentrations or a reduction to less than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 as our criteria for determining whether or not a control was considered efficacious. This is consistent with criteria used by NIOSH in conducting a similar study in 2004 described by Echt et al. (2007) and by CPWR in 2006 and described by Meeker et al. (2009). The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) and the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) publish additional occupational exposure limits (OELs) for silica which are listed in Table 1 with NIOSH RELs. OELs for silica are based on the respirable fraction of the aerosol, which consists of particles less than 10 micrometers in aerodynamic diameter.
| Organization or Agency | Form of Crystalline Silica | Occupational Exposure Limits (mg/m3) |
|---|---|---|
| NIOSHA | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 |
| OSHA - ConstructionB | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
PEL = 250 / (5 + % quartz) PEL = 250 / (5 + % cristobalite) PEL = 250 / (5 + % tridymite) |
| ACGIH | Crystalline Silica | TLV = 0.025 mg/m3 |
A NIOSH Publication No. 2005-151 indicates 10-hour time-weighted average during a 40-hr workweek B The PEL for silica in OSHA’s Safety and Health Regulations for Construction, 29 C.F.R. 1926.55(a), is an 8-hour time-weighted average (TWA) expressed in millions of particles per cubic foot (mppcf). However, the units mppcf can be converted to milligrams per cubic meter can by dividing mppcf by 10 (OSHA, 2009). The formula used by OSHA to determine the PEL for silica is dependent on the percentage of silica in each collected sample. The concentration of respirable dust measured is compared to the sample specific PEL to determine if the PEL has been exceeded. OSHA has proposed lowering the PEL to 0.05 mg/m3 of respirable silica as an 8 hour TWA. |
||
The flow of air in ventilation systems is governed by fundamental principles that describe the behavior of gases (in this case air). Pressure measurements taken within a ventilation system along with knowledge of hood (or shroud) entry losses can be used to calculate flow rates. Hood entry losses are dependent on the shape and configuration of a particular hood or shroud and described by the term “coefficient of entry (Ce)” which is the ratio of actual air flow through a hood and what the air flow would theoretically be if there were no hood entry losses. Given the coefficient of entry, static pressure measurements can be used to calculate air flow through a given hood. The coefficient of entry for the Dust Director shroud was previously determined by CPWR and used for calculating air flow based on static pressure measurements (Meeker et al., 2009). Static pressure, with the vacuum operating, was measured periodically throughout the evaluation to monitor the changes in air-flow rate following use and again after filter cleaning. The static pressure was measured at a port positioned more than 3 duct diameters downstream from the tool’s air intake using a UEi EM200 Electronic Manometer (Universal Enterprises, Inc., Beaverton, OR).
The dust in the vacuum bag was monitored and, per the manufacturer’s instructions, the bag was changed before the dust level was within 5 centimeters of the valve at the bottom of the vacuum. Each time a vacuum bag was removed, it was weighed to the nearest pound. The bag weights and corresponding grinding durations were used to calculate the average weight of dust collected per unit time. After each trial, cut lengths were measured on the wall to determine total linear feet of vertical (head) and horizontal (bed) joints per unit time.
A Haz-Dust III, Model HD-1003, Real-Time Aerosol Monitor (Environmental Devices Corporation, Plaistow, NH) was used to confirm clearance of dust between trials. The Haz-Dust monitor was positioned on the test wall near the operator at approximately breathing zone level and configured to measure respirable particulate concentration.
V. Results
Personal air monitoring
Five pairs of respirable dust samples were collected while grinding with and without the vacuum system. In addition, three respirable dust samples were collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place. One measurement collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard was shown to be a statistical outlier and was omitted from analysis. Personal air monitoring results for respirable silica and a comparison of average exposures relative to the NIOSH REL for silica (0.05 mg/m3) appears in Table 2. The mean respirable dust levels measured without LEV was 31.4 mg/m3. However, samples collected with LEV were below the limit of quantification (LOQ) which ranged from <1.29 to <1.46 mg/m3. Use of LEV resulted in a greater than 95% reduction in mean respirable dust levels using a mean value with use of LEV of <1.41 (n=5 samples with use of LEV and n=7 without use of LEV). The respirable dust samples collected during grinding without the LEV system contained an average of 24 percent silica. The mass of respirable dust in the samples collected with use of the LEV system was too low to determine the silica content.| Mean, mg/m3 (range) | Std. Dev. | Percent Reduction | Hazard RatioB | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bosch with Dust Director Shroud and DustControl 2900c Vacuum |
0.091 (<0.069 – 0.137) |
0.027 | 98.7 | 1.81 |
| Bosch with no Control | 7.23 (4.57 – 9.90) |
1.94 | NA | 145 |
A n = 5 samples for each tool/control combination and n = 7 samples without the use of the LEV system B Hazard Ratio = measured exposure / NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 |
||||
Average respirable silica and dust exposures, with and without the dust control system, appear as Figures 5 and 6, respectively.
Figure 5. Average respirable silica exposures with and without the Dustcontrol 2900c vacuum and Dust Director shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air - mg/m3)
Figure 6. Average respirable dust exposures with and without Dustcontrol 2900c Vacuum and Dust Director Shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air – mg/m3)
The mean respirable silica concentration measured during use of the control was significantly less than the concentration measured while using the same tool without controls (p<0.01). Grinding mortar with the Bosch angle grinder without dust controls resulted in an average exposure to respirable silica that was 145 times the NIOSH REL. Grinding with the Bosch angle grinder in combination with the Dust Director shroud and the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced the average concentration of respirable silica by 98.7 percent. With use of these controls, the concentration of respirable silica was 1.8 times greater than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3. However the NIOSH REL is based on a time-weighted average (TWA) over a 10-hour workday. Given these were task TWAs and samples were collected over continuous periods of grinding, they may overestimate exposures over an actual work day since some time would be spent performing tasks that would likely have lower, or no, silica exposures (setup, breaks, cleanup, etc.).
Static pressure, dust mass collection and grinding rates.
Static pressure was used as a surrogate for air flow as described earlier. Hood static pressure was measured periodically at a tap near the grinder more than 3 duct diameters from the air intake in the shroud. The static pressure, and thus air flow, was generally higher when the vacuum’s filter had recently been cleaned. The mean, median, and range of calculated flow rates are presented in Table A1 of the Appendix.
Based on the data we collected, the air-flow rate upstream from the Bosch grinder and Dust Director shroud ranged from 78 to 93 cubic feet per minute (cfm) with the DustControl vacuum. When the manufacturer’s filter cleaning procedure was followed the vacuum performed relatively well and flow could be maintained at slightly less than 90 cfm with cleaning. However, mean flow rates dropped substantially to 80 cfm after as little as 8 minutes of grinding without any filter cleaning. The flow rate returned to an average of 89 cfm when filters were cleaned correctly (without stopping air flow to the vacuum). Collingwood and Heitbrink (2007) found that the minimum exhaust flow rate for capture of silica and other particulate under ideal conditions is 21.25 cfm per inch of grinder blade diameter. This is equal to about 96 cfm when using a 4.5 inch diameter grinding blade. We set 106 cfm as the minimum desired flow rate for this study to allow a safety margin for potential decline in equipment performance and the possibility of inadequate maintenance, both of which may be likely after repeated use under actual work conditions. The DustControl vacuum provided slightly less than the minimum flow rate described by Collingwood and Heitbrink for a 4.5-inch blade and the peak flow rate fell with use.
The duration of vacuum bag use and mass of dust collected were recorded and are presented in Table A2 of the Appendix. The vacuum bags were changed and weighed after each trial utilizing the LEV system. A total of five bags were used to complete the five rounds of grinding. The DustControl vacuum captured 45 pounds of dust over 83 minutes of grinding for an average rate of dust collection of 0.54 pounds per minute. The rate of dust collection ranged from 0.47 to 0.63 pounds per minute. Based on these measurements, approximately 130 pounds of dust would likely be captured after just 4 hours of continuous grinding.
The rate of grinding a combination of vertical and horizontal joints while using the LEV system ranged from 2.3 to 3.3 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the use of the LEV system ranged from 2.6 to 3.4 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place ranged from 4.7 to 5.1 feet per minute. It’s important to note that: 1) the operator had limited experience using dust control systems and cut rates appeared to improve slightly over the 2-day period he used the tested equipment; and 2) the upper range of cut rates with the dust control system overlapped with the lowest cut rate with the original guard and without the LEV system in place indicating no statistical difference between cut rates. Given that grinding rates with and without use of this LEV system are only available for one operator and he had limited experience with the LEV system, these reported cut rates are in no way intended to represent the impact use of this LEV system is likely to have on productivity rates overall.
VI. Discussion
The objective of these trials was to evaluate the effectiveness of a tuckpointing LEV system for controlling respirable silica while grinding out mortar joints. The Dust Director shroud with the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced respirable silica concentrations when grinding with the Bosch grinder by approximately 99 percent. Despite being considered effective by our test criteria (greater than 50% reduction), it still resulted in task TWA exposures that exceeded the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 by 1.8 times. Depending on how much time is spent grinding over the course of a work day and on exposures while performing other tasks, the 8-hour TWA exposures may or may not exceed the REL with this system. Use of this system by workers with experience and training in proficient use will likely improve dust capture performance. Exposure reduction is greatly influenced by correct use of this system which includes grinding from right to left, making sure the shroud is held flush against the wall and that the tool travels at a pace that doesn’t exceed the ability of the system to capture dust as it’s generated. Deviation from any of these measures produces visible dust clouds which were observed during trials.
VII. Conclusions
With a 99 percent reduction in respirable silica exposure, the Dust Director shroud and DustControl 2900c vacuum with a Bosch Model 1775E grinder was effective in reducing silica exposures based on our criteria. Use of the tested dust control system may be effective in reducing silica exposure on the job to less than the NIOSH REL if used in combination with administrative controls such as work scheduling to reduce cutting times as needed. Training on correct use of the tested system is also essential. Personal air monitoring is necessary to verify control effectiveness on actual job sites and under “real-world” conditions. However, these results clearly demonstrate the availability of viable and effective engineering controls for tuckpointing operations associated with elevated silica exposure.
VIII. References
American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists. Threshold limit values for chemical substances (TLV®-CS). [2013]. ACGIH, Cincinnati, Ohio.
Bergdahl I.A,. Toren K., Eriksson K., et al. [2004]. Increased mortality in COPD among construction workers exposed to inorganic dust. European Respiratory Journal, 23: 402–06.
Blanc P.D. & Torén K. [2007]. Occupation in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and chronic bronchitis: an update [State of the Art Series. Occupational lung disease in high-and low-income countries, Edited by M. Chan-Yeung. Number 2 in the series]. The International Journal of Tuberculosis and Lung Disease, 11(3), 251-257.
Collingwood S. & Heitbrink W.A. [2007] 'Field Evaluation of an Engineering Control for Respirable Crystalline Silica Exposures During Mortar Removal'. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, 4:11, 875 – 887.
DHHS (NIOSH) Publication No. 2002-129 April 2002 http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/2002-129/
Echt A., Sieber W.K., Lefkowitz D., Meeker J., Susi P., Cardwell B., Heitbrink, W.A. In-depth survey of dust control technology for cutting concrete block and tuckpointing brick at The International Masonry Institute Bordentown Training Center, Bordentown, NJ. Cincinnati, OH: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Report. No. EPHB 282-13; 2007. http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ECTB-282-13.pdf
Heitbrink W., Bennett J. [2006]. A numerical and experimental investigation of crystalline silica exposure control during tuck pointing. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, Vol. 3, pp 366-378.
Lyons et al, [2007]. A breathless builder. Breathe, Vol. 3, no. 4, pp 386-390.
Mastrangelo G., Tartari M., Fedeli U., Fadda E., Saia B. [2003]. Ascertaining the risk of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease in relation to occupation using a case-control design. Occupational Medicine, 53: 165–172.
Meeker J., Cooper M., Lefrowitz D., Susi P. [2009]. Engineering control technologies to reduce occupational silica exposures in masonry cutting and tuckpointing. Public Health Reports, Supplement 1, Vol. 124, June.
Meeker J, Flynn M, Susi P, Cardwell, B [2004]. Performance evaluation of a masonry concrete vacuum. Unpublished Report.
Miller F. W., Alfredsson L., Costenbader K. H., Kamen D. L., Nelson L. M., Norris J. M., & De Roos A. J. [2012]. Epidemiology of environmental exposures and human autoimmune diseases: findings from a National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences Expert Panel workshop. Journal of autoimmunity. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3496812/
Occupational Safety and Health Administration U.S Department of Labor. Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction. [2009]. OSHA 3362-05.
Rappaport SM, Goldberg M, Susi P, Herrick RF [2003]. Excessive exposure to silica in the U.S. construction industry. Annals of Occupational Hygiene, Vol. 47, pp. 111-122.
IX. Appendices
| Measurement Conditions |
n | Mean Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Median
Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before filter cleaning | 5 | 80 | 81 | 78-81 |
| After filter cleaning following manufacturer directions | 9 | 89 | 90 | 84-93 |
| * Static pressure was measured in millibars and converted to inches of water gauge. Flow rates were calculated using the formula Q = Ce (A) 4005 (SP)1/2 where: Q = flow in cubic feet per minute (cfm), Ce = coefficient of entry, A = area of the duct where static pressure measurements were taken in square feet, and SP = static pressure in inches of water gauge. | ||||
| Tool/Control | Collection Period (min.) |
Dust Collection Rate (lb/min.) |
|---|---|---|
| Bosch grinder/Dust Director shroud & DustControl 2900c vacuum |
8 11 8 8 10 |
0.50 0.61 0.50 0.47 0.63 |
| Average | 0.54 |
[disclaimer:protected] => [disclaimer_transformed:protected] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [template] => record ) [_globalContext:PHPTAL_Context:private] => stdClass Object ( ) [_echoDeclarations:PHPTAL_Context:private] => [referer] => http://www.elcosh.org/document/3908/d001345/An%2BEvaluation%2Bof%2BSilica%2BExposure%2BControls%2Bfor%2BTuckpointing%253A%2BDustControl%2B2900c%2BVacuum%2Bwith%2Bthe%2BICS%2BDust%2BDirector%2BShroud%2Band%2BBosch%2BGrinder%2BModel%2B1775E%2BConducted%2BNovember%2B14-15%252C%2B2012.html [curr_module] => Record [styles] => Array ( ) [javascript] => Array ( [0] => jquery.min.js ) [metas] => Array ( [language] => en [robots] => index, follow ) [user] => [curr_url] => https://www.elcosh.org/index.php?module=Record&id=3908&type=document [base_url] => https://www.elcosh.org/index.php?module=Record [title] => eLCOSH : An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: DustControl 2900c Vacuum with the ICS Dust Director Shroud and Bosch Grinder Model 1775E Conducted November 14-15, 2012 [language] => en [search_query] => [module] => Record [new_records] => Array ( [0] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Fixed Ladder [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Fixed Ladders addresses the potential risks associated with using fixed ladders. The resource includes a brief case example,... [category] => Array ( [0] => 15 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 53 [5] => 55 [6] => 60 [7] => 64 [8] => 73 [9] => 76 [10] => 78 [11] => 80 [12] => 86 [13] => 87 [14] => 90 [15] => 92 [16] => 93 [17] => 94 [18] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Falls [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Concrete Polisher [11] => Electrical Worker [13] => HVAC [15] => Laborer [17] => PCC/Restoration [19] => Plumber/Pipefitter [21] => Roofer/Waterproofer [23] => Sheetmetal Worker [25] => Welder [27] => Commercial & Institutional [28] => Jobsites [29] => Industrial [31] => LEED/Green Construction [33] => Renovations [35] => Residential [37] => Toolbox Talks [38] => Documents [39] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4430/d001660/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BFixed%2BLadder.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [53] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 53 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Concrete Polisher [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [73] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 73 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => PCC/Restoration [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4430 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001660 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Fixed Ladder [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Fixed Ladders, Fall Prevention, Falls [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Fixed Ladders addresses the potential risks associated with using fixed ladders. The resource includes a brief case example, steps to prevent a related injury and questions for discussion. It includes an image that illustrates the hazard, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001257,d001254,d001255,d001256,d001258,d001262,d001279 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_completed:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/22/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [1] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Challenges Preventing Falling Objects [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Challenges Preventing Falling Objects addresses the hazards of being struck by falling objects on the job site. The resource... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 55 [5] => 64 [6] => 68 [7] => 71 [8] => 75 [9] => 78 [10] => 79 [11] => 82 [12] => 62 [13] => 86 [14] => 87 [15] => 88 [16] => 89 [17] => 91 [18] => 90 [19] => 92 [20] => 93 [21] => 94 [22] => 95 [23] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Electrical Worker [11] => Laborer [13] => Maintenance Worker [15] => Painter [17] => Plasterer [19] => Roofer/Waterproofer [21] => Scaffold Erector [23] => Stonemason [25] => Structural Ironworker [27] => Welder [29] => Commercial & Institutional [30] => Jobsites [31] => Demolition [33] => Disasters [35] => Heavy & Highway [37] => Industrial [39] => LEED/Green Construction [41] => Renovations [43] => Residential [45] => Underground [47] => Toolbox Talks [48] => Documents [49] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4431/d001661/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BChallenges%2BPreventing%2BFalling%2BObjects.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4431 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001661 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Challenges Preventing Falling Objects [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => dropped objects, falling objects, struck by incidents, struck by fatalities [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Challenges Preventing Falling Objects addresses the hazards of being struck by falling objects on the job site. The resource includes a brief example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates a group workers observing a scaffold free of debris during high winds, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001234,d001238,d001244,d001251,d001253,d001260,d001268,d001278 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_completed:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/22/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [2] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Tower Crane Safety [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Tower Crane Safety addresses the potential hazards of Tower Cranes and the importance of following procedure before and durin... [category] => Array ( [0] => 11 [1] => 12 [2] => 18 [3] => 70 [4] => 87 [5] => 88 [6] => 91 [7] => 90 [8] => 92 [9] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Cranes & Hoists [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Crushed/Struck By [6] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [9] => Operating Engineer [10] => Trades [11] => Commercial & Institutional [12] => Jobsites [13] => Demolition [15] => Heavy & Highway [17] => Industrial [19] => LEED/Green Construction [21] => Toolbox Talks [22] => Documents [23] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4427/d001657/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BTower%2BCrane%2BSafety.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [11] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 11 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Cranes & Hoists [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [18] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 18 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4427 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001657 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Tower Crane Safety [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Tower Crane, Crane, Stability, Tipping, Lift Zone Safety, Lift, Zone, Safety, Struck by [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Tower Crane Safety addresses the potential hazards of Tower Cranes and the importance of following procedure before and during Tower Crane operation. The resource includes a brief example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates a worker inspecting a Tower Crane before operation, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001234,d001238,d001250,d001251,d001253,d001258,d001262,d001273 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/19/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [3] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Work Zone Safety: Working Around Vehicles [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Working Around Vehicles in the Work Zone addresses methods to avoid being struck-by a vehicle on a construction site. The res... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 18 [2] => 52 [3] => 57 [4] => 70 [5] => 85 [6] => 87 [7] => 88 [8] => 89 [9] => 91 [10] => 90 [11] => 92 [12] => 93 [13] => 94 [14] => 95 [15] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [6] => Commercial Diver [7] => Trades [8] => Flagger [10] => Operating Engineer [12] => Truck Driver [14] => Commercial & Institutional [15] => Jobsites [16] => Demolition [18] => Disasters [20] => Heavy & Highway [22] => Industrial [24] => LEED/Green Construction [26] => Renovations [28] => Residential [30] => Underground [32] => Toolbox Talks [33] => Documents [34] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4428/d001658/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BWork%2BZone%2BSafety%253A%2BWorking%2BAround%2BVehicles.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [18] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 18 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [52] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 52 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Commercial Diver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [85] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 85 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Truck Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4428 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001658 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Daniela Caceres [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Work Zone Safety: Working Around Vehicles [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Struck, Struck by, Vehicle, Work Zone Safety, Truck, Operator, Driver, Mobile Equipment [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Working Around Vehicles in the Work Zone addresses methods to avoid being struck-by a vehicle on a construction site. The resource includes a case example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates the hazard, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001640 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/19/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [4] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Construction Dive -- DeWalt's Jobsite Pro headphones recalled for fire hazards [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => A recall notice by the United States Consumer Product Safety Commission affects over 300,000 DeWalt Jobsite Pro Headphones. The recall is a result of... [category] => Array ( [0] => 16 [1] => 44 [2] => 45 [3] => 46 [4] => 47 [5] => 48 [6] => 49 [7] => 50 [8] => 51 [9] => 52 [10] => 53 [11] => 54 [12] => 55 [13] => 56 [14] => 57 [15] => 58 [16] => 59 [17] => 60 [18] => 61 [19] => 64 [20] => 65 [21] => 66 [22] => 67 [23] => 68 [24] => 69 [25] => 70 [26] => 71 [27] => 72 [28] => 73 [29] => 74 [30] => 75 [31] => 76 [32] => 77 [33] => 63 [34] => 78 [35] => 79 [36] => 80 [37] => 81 [38] => 82 [39] => 62 [40] => 83 [41] => 84 [42] => 85 [43] => 86 [44] => 87 [45] => 88 [46] => 89 [47] => 91 [48] => 90 [49] => 92 [50] => 93 [51] => 94 [52] => 95 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Fire & Explosions [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Acoustical Ceiling Carpenter [4] => Trades [5] => Asbestos/Insulator [7] => Boilermaker [9] => Bricklayer [11] => Cabinetmaker [13] => Carpenter [15] => Carpet Layer [17] => Cement Mason [19] => Commercial Diver [21] => Concrete Polisher [23] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [25] => Electrical Worker [27] => Elevator Constructor [29] => Flagger [31] => Glazier [33] => Hazardous Waste Cleanup [35] => HVAC [37] => Interior Systems Carpenter [39] => Laborer [41] => Landscaper [43] => Lather [45] => Lead Abatement Worker [47] => Maintenance Worker [49] => Millwright [51] => Operating Engineer [53] => Painter [55] => Paper Hanger [57] => PCC/Restoration [59] => Pile Driver [61] => Plasterer [63] => Plumber/Pipefitter [65] => Refractory Worker [67] => Reinforcing Ironworker [69] => Roofer/Waterproofer [71] => Scaffold Erector [73] => Sheetmetal Worker [75] => Sprinkler Fitter [77] => Stonemason [79] => Structural Ironworker [81] => Terrazzo Worker [83] => Tile Setter [85] => Truck Driver [87] => Welder [89] => Commercial & Institutional [90] => Jobsites [91] => Demolition [93] => Disasters [95] => Heavy & Highway [97] => Industrial [99] => LEED/Green Construction [101] => Renovations [103] => Residential [105] => Underground ) [type] => [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4426/d001656/Construction%2BDive%2B--%2BDeWalt%2527s%2BJobsite%2BPro%2Bheadphones%2Brecalled%2Bfor%2Bfire%2Bhazards.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [16] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 16 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Fire & Explosions [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [44] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 44 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Acoustical Ceiling Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [45] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 45 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Asbestos/Insulator [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [46] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 46 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Boilermaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [48] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 48 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cabinetmaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [50] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 50 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpet Layer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [52] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 52 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Commercial Diver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [53] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 53 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Concrete Polisher [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [54] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 54 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [58] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 58 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Glazier [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [59] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 59 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Hazardous Waste Cleanup [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [65] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 65 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Landscaper [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [66] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 66 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Lather [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [67] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 67 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Lead Abatement Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [69] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 69 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Millwright [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [72] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 72 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Paper Hanger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [73] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 73 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => PCC/Restoration [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [77] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 77 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Refractory Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [81] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 81 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sprinkler Fitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [83] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 83 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Terrazzo Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [84] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 84 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Tile Setter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [85] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 85 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Truck Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4426 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001656 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Construction Dive -- DeWalt's Jobsite Pro headphones recalled for fire hazards [total_pages:protected] => 1 [billed_pages:protected] => 1 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => DeWalt, Fire Hazards, recall, headphones [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A recall notice by the United States Consumer Product Safety Commission affects over 300,000 DeWalt Jobsite Pro Headphones. The recall is a result of a malfunction that can cause earbuds to overheat while charging or during use, leading to fire and burn hazards. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => https://www.constructiondive.com/news/dewalts-jobsite-pro-headphones-recalled-for-fire-hazards/611248/?utm_source=Sailthru&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Issue:%202021-12-10%20Construction%20Dive%20Newsletter%20%5Bissue:38532%5D&utm_term=Construction%20Dive [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/13/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/13/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 12/13/21 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [new_images] => Array ( [0] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Morning Toolbox Talk [image] => /record/images/4003-p.jpg [blurb] => This photo is from an early morning toolbox talk on a construction job in Mclean, Virginia. It is being delivered in English and Spanish.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 20 [1] => 51 [2] => 57 [3] => 64 [4] => 70 [5] => 63 [6] => 78 [7] => 82 [8] => 62 [9] => 87 [10] => 88 [11] => 89 [12] => 91 [13] => 90 [14] => 93 [15] => 94 [16] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Safety Culture [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Cement Mason [4] => Trades [5] => Flagger [7] => Laborer [9] => Operating Engineer [11] => Reinforcing Ironworker [13] => Roofer/Waterproofer [15] => Stonemason [17] => Structural Ironworker [19] => Commercial & Institutional [20] => Jobsites [21] => Demolition [23] => Disasters [25] => Heavy & Highway [27] => Industrial [29] => Renovations [31] => Residential [33] => Images [34] => Media [35] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4003/i002691/Morning%2BToolbox%2BTalk.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4003 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002691 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Morning Toolbox Talk [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, Spanish, bilingual [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This photo is from an early morning toolbox talk on a construction job in Mclean, Virginia. It is being delivered in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001285,d001304,c000079 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [1] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox talk - crew view [image] => /record/images/4005-p.jpg [blurb] => Photo of crew listening to a toolbox safety talk before starting work.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 97 [1] => 20 [2] => 47 [3] => 49 [4] => 51 [5] => 55 [6] => 61 [7] => 64 [8] => 71 [9] => 75 [10] => 63 [11] => 79 [12] => 62 [13] => 87 [14] => 88 [15] => 91 [16] => 90 [17] => 93 [18] => 94 [19] => 95 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Images [1] => Media [2] => Media & Documents [3] => Safety Culture [4] => Work Environment [5] => Hazards [6] => Bricklayer [7] => Trades [8] => Carpenter [10] => Cement Mason [12] => Electrical Worker [14] => Interior Systems Carpenter [16] => Laborer [18] => Painter [20] => Plasterer [22] => Reinforcing Ironworker [24] => Scaffold Erector [26] => Structural Ironworker [28] => Commercial & Institutional [29] => Jobsites [30] => Demolition [32] => Heavy & Highway [34] => Industrial [36] => Renovations [38] => Residential [40] => Underground ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4005/i002692/Toolbox%2Btalk%2B-%2Bcrew%2Bview.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4005 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002692 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox talk - crew view [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, safety talk, Spanish [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Photo of crew listening to a toolbox safety talk before starting work. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002691,d001269, c000079, d001285 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [2] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox talk - long shot [image] => /record/images/4006-p.jpg [blurb] => This crew gathered every morning before starting work to discuss a new safety topic.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 20 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 55 [5] => 64 [6] => 68 [7] => 75 [8] => 76 [9] => 63 [10] => 78 [11] => 79 [12] => 82 [13] => 62 [14] => 87 [15] => 88 [16] => 91 [17] => 90 [18] => 93 [19] => 94 [20] => 95 [21] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Safety Culture [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Electrical Worker [11] => Laborer [13] => Maintenance Worker [15] => Plasterer [17] => Plumber/Pipefitter [19] => Reinforcing Ironworker [21] => Roofer/Waterproofer [23] => Scaffold Erector [25] => Stonemason [27] => Structural Ironworker [29] => Commercial & Institutional [30] => Jobsites [31] => Demolition [33] => Heavy & Highway [35] => Industrial [37] => Renovations [39] => Residential [41] => Underground [43] => Images [44] => Media [45] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4006/i002693/Toolbox%2Btalk%2B-%2Blong%2Bshot.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4006 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002693 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox talk - long shot [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, safety minute [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This crew gathered every morning before starting work to discuss a new safety topic. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002691,i002692,d001269,d000527 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [3] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Safety officer discussing ongoing project with marketing coordinator [image] => /record/images/4014-p.jpg [blurb] => The safety officer (left) points out the good safety practices on this project that reflect well on the firm and may influence future clients.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 97 [1] => 20 [2] => 46 [3] => 47 [4] => 49 [5] => 50 [6] => 51 [7] => 54 [8] => 55 [9] => 58 [10] => 60 [11] => 61 [12] => 64 [13] => 71 [14] => 75 [15] => 76 [16] => 63 [17] => 79 [18] => 80 [19] => 82 [20] => 62 [21] => 83 [22] => 87 [23] => 91 [24] => 90 [25] => 93 [26] => 94 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Images [1] => Media [2] => Media & Documents [3] => Safety Culture [4] => Work Environment [5] => Hazards [6] => Boilermaker [7] => Trades [8] => Bricklayer [10] => Carpenter [12] => Carpet Layer [14] => Cement Mason [16] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [18] => Electrical Worker [20] => Glazier [22] => HVAC [24] => Interior Systems Carpenter [26] => Laborer [28] => Painter [30] => Plasterer [32] => Plumber/Pipefitter [34] => Reinforcing Ironworker [36] => Scaffold Erector [38] => Sheetmetal Worker [40] => Stonemason [42] => Structural Ironworker [44] => Terrazzo Worker [46] => Commercial & Institutional [47] => Jobsites [48] => Heavy & Highway [50] => Industrial [52] => Renovations [54] => Residential ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4014/i002700/Safety%2Bofficer%2Bdiscussing%2Bongoing%2Bproject%2Bwith%2Bmarketing%2Bcoordinator.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [46] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 46 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Boilermaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [50] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 50 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpet Layer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [54] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 54 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [58] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 58 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Glazier [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [83] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 83 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Terrazzo Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4014 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002700 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Safety officer discussing ongoing project with marketing coordinator [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Latino, safety officer, safety culture [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The safety officer (left) points out the good safety practices on this project that reflect well on the firm and may influence future clients. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/index.php [more_like_this:protected] => d000989,d001351,d001362,d000652, d001101, d000931, d001395 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Hoar Construction, Photo by Neil Lippy [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 01/30/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [4] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Scaffolding at top of large column [image] => /record/images/3994-p.jpg [blurb] => This shot shows innovative guarding around the top of a large concrete column in the base of a high rise structure going up.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 15 [1] => 21 [2] => 47 [3] => 51 [4] => 63 [5] => 78 [6] => 79 [7] => 80 [8] => 62 [9] => 87 [10] => 97 [11] => 56 [12] => 64 [13] => 74 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Falls [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Scaffolds [6] => Bricklayer [7] => Trades [8] => Cement Mason [10] => Reinforcing Ironworker [12] => Roofer/Waterproofer [14] => Scaffold Erector [16] => Sheetmetal Worker [18] => Structural Ironworker [20] => Commercial & Institutional [21] => Jobsites [22] => Images [23] => Media [24] => Media & Documents [25] => Elevator Constructor [27] => Laborer [29] => Pile Driver ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/3994/i002689/Scaffolding%2Bat%2Btop%2Bof%2Blarge%2Bcolumn.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [21] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 21 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Scaffolds [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3994 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002689 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Scaffolding at top of large column [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Guardrail, railing, fall prevention, falls [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This shot shows innovative guarding around the top of a large concrete column in the base of a high rise structure going up. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/8/adjustable-tower-scaffold.html [more_like_this:protected] => c1002680,i002662,d000608,d001255 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Photo by Pam Susi [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2016 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_completed:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/01/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [5] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Construction bracing [image] => /record/images/3995-p.jpg [blurb] => This shows structural support that prevents collapses during construction.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 15 [2] => 21 [3] => 49 [4] => 51 [5] => 55 [6] => 56 [7] => 60 [8] => 64 [9] => 68 [10] => 74 [11] => 63 [12] => 78 [13] => 79 [14] => 80 [15] => 62 [16] => 87 [17] => 90 [18] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Falls [6] => Scaffolds [9] => Carpenter [10] => Trades [11] => Cement Mason [13] => Electrical Worker [15] => Elevator Constructor [17] => HVAC [19] => Laborer [21] => Maintenance Worker [23] => Pile Driver [25] => Reinforcing Ironworker [27] => Roofer/Waterproofer [29] => Scaffold Erector [31] => Sheetmetal Worker [33] => Structural Ironworker [35] => Commercial & Institutional [36] => Jobsites [37] => Industrial [39] => Images [40] => Media [41] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/3995/i002690/Construction%2Bbracing.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [21] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 21 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Scaffolds [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3995 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002690 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Construction bracing [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Bracing, support, scaffold [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This shows structural support that prevents collapses during construction. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/8/adjustable-tower-scaffold.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002660 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Photo by Pam Susi [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2016 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_completed:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/01/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [preview_mode] => [description] => The results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. [keywords] => tuckpointing, HEPA vacuum, dust control, LEV, local exhaust ventilation, silica [related_items] => Array ( [Research Reports] => Array ( [0] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1874 [old_id:protected] => 722 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000683 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Sharon Garber/COD [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Protecting Tuckpointing Workers from Silica Dust: Draft Recommendations for a Ventilated Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 12 [billed_pages:protected] => 12 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, vacuum, grinder, mortar, respirator, OSHA, NIOSH, exhaust, Heitbrink, tuckpointer, silica, masonry, dust, silicosis, LEV [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Describes draft recommendations for use of ventilated grinder to reduce dust during tuckpointing and describes field trials using these devices. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/hazard/67/chip-scrape-and-grind-surfaces-or-joints-silica.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001201,d000292,d000293,d000658 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2005 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/27/05 [date_completed:protected] => 04/26/05 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/20/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [1] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1940 [old_id:protected] => 909 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Workplace Solutions: Control of Hazardous Dust During Tuckpointing [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, silica, dust, tuckpoint, grinder, masonry restoration, mortar, vacuum [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d000819,d000820,d000730,d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 10/24/08 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/09 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [2] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3899 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001342 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: Hilti VC40-U Vacuum with Hilti DC-EX Dust Guard and Hilti Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 15 [billed_pages:protected] => 15 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP4 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => silica, tuckpointing, Hilti, local exhaust systems, LEV, shroud, quartz [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This report describes the results of an evaluation of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Hilti VC40-U vacuum, a Hilti DC-EX shroud, and a Hilti DAG-500 grinder. Randomized trials with and without use of the dust control system were conducted in a controlled setting. Removing mortar with the Hilti grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 220 times the National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05mg/m3. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 97 percent. However, exposures measured during the use of the dust control system still exceeded the NIOSH REL. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => December 1, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/05/14 [date_completed:protected] => 02/04/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/06/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [Handouts] => Array ( [0] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3656 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001198 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 24 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction While Doing Tuckpointing/Mortar Removal [total_pages:protected] => 2 [billed_pages:protected] => 2 [publication_number:protected] => DSG FS-3632 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Brick, block, tuckpointing, silica, local exhaust ventilation, LEV, masonry [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Tuckpointing creates some of the greatest exposures to silica in construction. This OSHA factsheet provides guidance on how to greatly reduce these exposures through the use of local exhaust ventilation. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863, d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => February 2013 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/04/13 [date_completed:protected] => 03/27/13 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [collections] => Array ( [3913] => ) [record] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => Array ( [867] => Author Object ( [id:protected] => 867 [organization_id:protected] => 0 [firstname:protected] => Michael [lastname:protected] => Cooper [address:protected] => [city:protected] => [province:protected] => [country:protected] => [postal_code:protected] => [department:protected] => [title:protected] => [phone:protected] => [fax:protected] => [email:protected] => [degree:protected] => [website:protected] => [about:protected] => [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => [date_completed:protected] => [date_billed:protected] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [481] => Author Object ( [id:protected] => 481 [organization_id:protected] => 0 [firstname:protected] => Pam [lastname:protected] => Susi [address:protected] => 8484 Georgia Avenue, Suite 1000 [city:protected] => Silver Spring [province:protected] => Maryland [country:protected] => USA [postal_code:protected] => 20910 [department:protected] => [title:protected] => [phone:protected] => 301-578-8500 ext.144 [fax:protected] => 301-578-8572 [email:protected] => plsusi@aol.com [degree:protected] => [website:protected] => http://www.cpwr.com [about:protected] => [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => 2003-10-02 [date_completed:protected] => 2003-10-06 [date_billed:protected] => 2003-11-03 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [organizations:protected] => Array ( [1] => Organization Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [elcosh_id:protected] => o000001 [user_id:protected] => 14 [province_id:protected] => 21 [country_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => CPWR - The Center for Construction Research and Training [address:protected] => Suite 1000, 8484 Georgia Ave [postal_code:protected] => 20910 [city:protected] => Silver Spring [department:protected] => [phone:protected] => 301-578-8500 [fax:protected] => 301-578-8572 [email:protected] => cpwrwebsite@cpwr.com [website:protected] => http://www.cpwr.com [filename:protected] => o000001.gif [about:protected] => CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training, developed, and continues to maintain/expand this website - The Electronic Library of Construction Occupational Safety and Health, www.elcosh.org. CPWR, formerly known as The Center to Protect Workers’ Rights, is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit research and training institution. Created by the Building and Construction Trades Department, AFL-CIO, CPWR serves as the research arm of the BCTD. Since the inception of its research agenda in 1990, CPWR has grown into a worldwide provider of safety and health information covering all aspects of the construction industry. CPWR launched eLCOSH in 2000, and the Spanish-language version of the site in 2001. CPWR also created, and continues to build, Construction Solutions - www.cpwrConstructionSolutions.org - a free, online database of construction hazards and ways to prevent, eliminate, or reduce them. [comments:protected] => [logo_available:protected] => T [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => 2000-08-18 [date_completed:protected] => 2000-08-30 [date_billed:protected] => 2000-09-05 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [collections:protected] => Array ( [3913] => ) [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => Array ( [1874] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1874 [old_id:protected] => 722 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000683 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Sharon Garber/COD [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Protecting Tuckpointing Workers from Silica Dust: Draft Recommendations for a Ventilated Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 12 [billed_pages:protected] => 12 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, vacuum, grinder, mortar, respirator, OSHA, NIOSH, exhaust, Heitbrink, tuckpointer, silica, masonry, dust, silicosis, LEV [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Describes draft recommendations for use of ventilated grinder to reduce dust during tuckpointing and describes field trials using these devices. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/hazard/67/chip-scrape-and-grind-surfaces-or-joints-silica.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001201,d000292,d000293,d000658 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2005 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/27/05 [date_completed:protected] => 04/26/05 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/20/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [1940] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1940 [old_id:protected] => 909 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Workplace Solutions: Control of Hazardous Dust During Tuckpointing [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, silica, dust, tuckpoint, grinder, masonry restoration, mortar, vacuum [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d000819,d000820,d000730,d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 10/24/08 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/09 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [2213] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 2213 [old_id:protected] => 1090 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => [language_id:protected] => 2 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Control del polvo peligroso que se genera durante los procesos de reparación de mortero [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => 2008-126 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => [comments:protected] => http://www.cdc.gov/spanish/niosh/docs/wp-solutions/2008-126_sp/ [summary:protected] => A Workplace Solutions de NIOSH que resume un estudio de NIOSH sobre los riesgos de exposición cuando se reparan las estructuras y los métodos para controlar el polvo. [A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust.] [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => D000819,D000820,D000730,d000819 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 01/07/10 [date_completed:protected] => 04/19/10 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 07/08/12 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [3656] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3656 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001198 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 24 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction While Doing Tuckpointing/Mortar Removal [total_pages:protected] => 2 [billed_pages:protected] => 2 [publication_number:protected] => DSG FS-3632 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Brick, block, tuckpointing, silica, local exhaust ventilation, LEV, masonry [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Tuckpointing creates some of the greatest exposures to silica in construction. This OSHA factsheet provides guidance on how to greatly reduce these exposures through the use of local exhaust ventilation. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863, d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => February 2013 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/04/13 [date_completed:protected] => 03/27/13 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [3899] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3899 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001342 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: Hilti VC40-U Vacuum with Hilti DC-EX Dust Guard and Hilti Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 15 [billed_pages:protected] => 15 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP4 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => silica, tuckpointing, Hilti, local exhaust systems, LEV, shroud, quartz [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This report describes the results of an evaluation of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Hilti VC40-U vacuum, a Hilti DC-EX shroud, and a Hilti DAG-500 grinder. Randomized trials with and without use of the dust control system were conducted in a controlled setting. Removing mortar with the Hilti grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 220 times the National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05mg/m3. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 97 percent. However, exposures measured during the use of the dust control system still exceeded the NIOSH REL. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => December 1, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/05/14 [date_completed:protected] => 02/04/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/06/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [content:protected] => [files:protected] => Array ( [559] => [560] => [546] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 546 [filename:protected] => 3.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:22 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [566] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 566 [filename:protected] => 4.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:23 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [720] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 720 [filename:protected] => 5.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [721] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 721 [filename:protected] => 6.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [722] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 722 [filename:protected] => 7.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [9765] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 9765 [filename:protected] => d001345.pdf [downloadable:protected] => T [timestamp:protected] => 2015-02-09 12:26:04 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3908 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001345 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: DustControl 2900c Vacuum with the ICS Dust Director Shroud and Bosch Grinder Model 1775E Conducted November 14-15, 2012 [total_pages:protected] => 13 [billed_pages:protected] => 13 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP2 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => tuckpointing, HEPA vacuum, dust control, LEV, local exhaust ventilation, silica [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => April 15, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 01/26/15 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/09/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [show_text] => [document_content] => ElcoshItemDocumentContent Object ( [id:protected] => 2934 [item_id:protected] => 3908 [type:protected] => main [title:protected] => [content:protected] =>
Executive Summary
This report describes the results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. It should also be noted that the NIOSH REL is based on exposures averaged over a ten hour work day and our results represent time weighted averages of the sample task duration periods.
Acronyms
ACGIH - American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists
CPWR - CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training
Ce - coefficient of entry
HEPA - high-efficiency particulate air
IUBAC - International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craftworkers
LEV - local exhaust ventilation
PACT - Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies
NIOSH - National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health
OEL - occupational exposure limit
OSHA - Occupational Safety and Health Administration
PAPR - powered air-purifying respirator
PEL - Permissible Exposure Limit
PVC - polyvinyl chloride
REL - Recommended Exposure Limit
RPM - revolutions per minute
TWA - time-weighted average
SP - static pressure
I. Introduction and Background
In 2010 CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training began a four-year project which seeks to identify and evaluate tuckpointing local exhaust ventilation (LEV) systems and disseminate information on their availability and effectiveness. A Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies (PACT) comprised of masonry contractors, representatives from unions, government, equipment manufacturers, and health and safety researcher was formed as part of this project. PACT members participated in identifying important characteristics for control technologies and this information was used to identify LEV systems for tuckpointing using that criteria. Contractor and labor members of the PACT selected specific tuckpointing LEV systems to be considered for evaluation. Each system consisted of a tuckpointing grinder, shroud, and vacuum. This report describes the second of four systems to be evaluated between 2012 the end of 2014, with and without LEV, in a controlled setting to determine effectiveness in silica exposure reduction. This report describes the methods and results of our evaluation of a system consisting of the DustControl 2900c vacuum with the ICS Dust Director shroud and a Bosch Model 1775E grinder.
Excessive exposure to respirable silica can result in silicosis or other silica-related diseases including pulmonary tuberculosis, lung cancer, silicoproteinosis (Lyons et al, 2007) and autoimmune disorders such as rheumatoid arthritis, sarcoidosis and scleroderma (Miller et al, 2012). Respirable silica is generally defined as particles less than 10 micrometers (μm) in aerodynamic diameter (ACGIH, 2013). Silicosis can lead to symptoms including shortness of breath, fatigue, chest pains, susceptibility to infection and possibly death. There is no cure for silicosis, however it is totally preventable. Construction workers exposed to dust, including silica, are also known to have higher rates of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD).
There are many sources of silica in construction that result in exposures of varying intensity among workers. Masonry restoration workers are among the most highly silica-exposed trades in construction. The process of grinding out deteriorated mortar joints between masonry units and replacing or repointing with fresh mortar (often referred to as tuckpointing) is a fundamental part of masonry restoration work. The removal of mortar with powered angle grinders generates enormous levels of dust. Between 2004 and 2006, NIOSH and CPWR evaluated silica exposures while grinding mortar in a controlled setting, at a local training center, where tasks, sample times and task variables were defined by the study design. These studies demonstrated that grinding mortar without controls can result in elevated respirable silica exposures. Meeker et al., (2009) reported exposures between 5 and 25.8 milligrams per cubic meter (mg/m3) in a controlled setting. This study also showed that LEV systems for tuckpointing grinders can reduce exposures to respirable silica by greater than 90 percent.II. Objectives
The objective of this evaluation was to assess the effectiveness of an LEV system for controlling exposure to silica during the grinding of mortar. The control technology was tested under controlled conditions, similar to those experienced by tuckpointers on actual job sites, using journeymen bricklayers experienced in tuckpointing and repeat, randomized trials with and without LEV. All other variables were held constant throughout so that the only variable was whether or not the tested control was used.
III. Description of Equipment Tested
A Bosch model 1775E grinder (Robert Bosch Tool Corporation, Prospect, IL) (Figures 1, 2 and 3) was fitted with a new 1/4-inch wide, 4½-inch diameter segmented diamond abrasive blade made by DeWalt (model #DW4740). The grinder weighs six and a half pounds, draws 8.5 amps and has a variable speed up to 11,000 revolutions per minute (RPMs). The DustControl 2900c vacuum (DustControl, Inc., Wilmington, NC) (Figure 3) was tested in combination with the Dust Director shroud (Industrial Contractors’ Supplies, Inc., Huntingdon, PA) (Figures 1 and 3) attached to the Bosch grinder.
Figure 1. Bosch grinder with Dust Director shroud
Figure 2. Bosch grinder without tuckpointing LEV system.
Figure 3: Bosch Grinder with LEV System
The vacuum is specified to weigh 31 pounds when empty and to provide a flow rate of 114 cubic feet of air per minute and a “static lift” or “vacuum suction pressure” of 84 inches of water. The vacuum is sold with a cyclonic pre-separator, to remove larger particles, a fine filter (rated 99.9 percent efficient) and a HEPA (high-efficiency particulate air) filter (rated to capture 99.97 percent of the particles with an aerodynamic diameter of 0.3 micrometers). The HEPA filter was removed based on the manufacturer’s recommendation due to the heavy dust loading associated with tuckpointing. CPWR sponsored research and contractor experience indicate that HEPA filters likely have an adverse effect on dust capture during tuckpointing because of extreme dust loading on filters. While the cyclone and the fine filter remove most of the dust, especially the large particles, before they reach the HEPA filter, the HEPA filter would still be subject to heavy loading, causing a substantial pressure drop and subsequent decrease in air flow rate. The relatively small increase in the efficiency of the filtration system while using the HEPA filter is expected to be quickly offset by a more significant decrease in capture efficiency as the air flow rate and ability to capture particles decreases.
Dust collects in relatively inexpensive, heavy-gauge plastic bags below and outside of the cyclone. The bags can be removed and replaced without opening the vacuum. Some vacuums are equipped with a light to indicate that the filters need to be cleaned or changed. The DC2900c features a “reverse air pulse cleaning system,” which removes accumulated dust from the filters without having to remove them from the vacuum. The system, as illustrated in Figure 4, requires the operator to disconnect the hose from the shroud, place it over an air stop so that air through the hose is cut off and pressure in the vacuum is maximized.
Figure 4. Procedure for "cleaning" of or dust removal from filters (source: http://dustcontrolusa.com/manuals/2800c.pdf)
The flap covering the port on the side of the vacuum is repeatedly flipped open to release built up pressure in strong pulses that dislodge dust from the filter.
The manufacturer indicates “the filter is generally cleaned once or twice daily during normal continuous operation.” The Dust Director shroud has a 2-inch diameter take-off that was connected to the antistatic, corrugated 1.5-inch diameter, 15-foot long vacuum hose supplied with the DustControl vacuum.
IV. Study Methods
This evaluation was conducted at the International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craft workers (IUBAC) Local 1 Philadelphia/Delaware Training Center in Philadelphia, PA on November 14 and 15, 2012. A single journeyman bricklayer, experienced in tuckpointing, used the grinder and LEV system being tested to remove mortar from joints wide enough to require two passes. The type S mortar had been allowed to cure for at least four weeks. The bricklayer either possessed or was provided with personal protective equipment including sturdy work boots, gloves, hearing protection and a powered air-purifying respirator (PAPR). The PAPR was a 3M GVP system with a bump cap, loose fitting face piece and a HEPA filter (3M, St Paul, MN).
The study was designed to include at least five rounds of sampling during mortar removal. Each round included a trial using the Bosch grinder with a Dust Director shroud and Dust Collector 2900c vacuum and a trial using the Bosch grinder with the factory-supplied guard and without a vacuum. The order of the two trials within each round was randomly selected to minimize bias that might be introduced due to variation associated with environmental factors, equipment operator, blade wear, vacuum performance over time and any other factors unrelated to LEV use. Tools were operated for approximately 16 minutes per trial with controls and for approximately 8 minutes when controls were not used. These times were selected based on the results of previous sampling efforts and estimates of the minimum sample time needed to achieve a limit of quantification low enough to accurately measure exposures down to or less than 0.05 mg/m3 – the NIOSH Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) for respirable silica. The bricklayer was required to take a 5 to 10 minute break in the middle of the 16-minute trials to reduce differences in fatigue, compared to the 8-minute trials. Personal air samples were collected in the breathing zone of the operator during each trial to measure respirable silica concentrations during grinding with and without LEV. The samples were collected using a GilAir-5 pump (Sensidyne, Inc., Clearwater, FL) to draw 4.2 liters of air per minute through a GK2.69 Respirable Cyclone (BGI Inc., Waltham, MA) with a pre-weighed, 37 mm diameter, 5-micron pore size polyvinyl chloride (PVC) filter positioned on the operator’s lapel.
The flow rates of the sampling pumps were calibrated at the beginning of each day using a DryCal DC-Lite Primary Flow Meter (Bios International Corporation, Butler, NJ). Flow rates were measured again near the middle and at the end of each day to ensure that sampling flow rates were maintained within 5% of pre-sampling flow rates throughout the day. Average flow rates were used to calculate sample air volumes. Samples were analyzed by R.J. Lee Group, Inc., (Monroeville, PA) using NIOSH Method 0600, to determine exposure to total mass of respirable dust. The same samples were also analyzed using X-Ray diffraction following NIOSH method 7500 to determine quartz, cristobalite and tridymite concentration in the respirable mass. Reported masses for these analytes were used with the sample air volumes to calculate airborne concentrations of total respirable dust, quartz, cristobalite and tridymite.
We used a reduction of greater than 50 percent in respirable silica exposure concentrations or a reduction to less than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 as our criteria for determining whether or not a control was considered efficacious. This is consistent with criteria used by NIOSH in conducting a similar study in 2004 described by Echt et al. (2007) and by CPWR in 2006 and described by Meeker et al. (2009). The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) and the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) publish additional occupational exposure limits (OELs) for silica which are listed in Table 1 with NIOSH RELs. OELs for silica are based on the respirable fraction of the aerosol, which consists of particles less than 10 micrometers in aerodynamic diameter.
| Organization or Agency | Form of Crystalline Silica | Occupational Exposure Limits (mg/m3) |
|---|---|---|
| NIOSHA | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 |
| OSHA - ConstructionB | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
PEL = 250 / (5 + % quartz) PEL = 250 / (5 + % cristobalite) PEL = 250 / (5 + % tridymite) |
| ACGIH | Crystalline Silica | TLV = 0.025 mg/m3 |
A NIOSH Publication No. 2005-151 indicates 10-hour time-weighted average during a 40-hr workweek B The PEL for silica in OSHA’s Safety and Health Regulations for Construction, 29 C.F.R. 1926.55(a), is an 8-hour time-weighted average (TWA) expressed in millions of particles per cubic foot (mppcf). However, the units mppcf can be converted to milligrams per cubic meter can by dividing mppcf by 10 (OSHA, 2009). The formula used by OSHA to determine the PEL for silica is dependent on the percentage of silica in each collected sample. The concentration of respirable dust measured is compared to the sample specific PEL to determine if the PEL has been exceeded. OSHA has proposed lowering the PEL to 0.05 mg/m3 of respirable silica as an 8 hour TWA. |
||
The flow of air in ventilation systems is governed by fundamental principles that describe the behavior of gases (in this case air). Pressure measurements taken within a ventilation system along with knowledge of hood (or shroud) entry losses can be used to calculate flow rates. Hood entry losses are dependent on the shape and configuration of a particular hood or shroud and described by the term “coefficient of entry (Ce)” which is the ratio of actual air flow through a hood and what the air flow would theoretically be if there were no hood entry losses. Given the coefficient of entry, static pressure measurements can be used to calculate air flow through a given hood. The coefficient of entry for the Dust Director shroud was previously determined by CPWR and used for calculating air flow based on static pressure measurements (Meeker et al., 2009). Static pressure, with the vacuum operating, was measured periodically throughout the evaluation to monitor the changes in air-flow rate following use and again after filter cleaning. The static pressure was measured at a port positioned more than 3 duct diameters downstream from the tool’s air intake using a UEi EM200 Electronic Manometer (Universal Enterprises, Inc., Beaverton, OR).
The dust in the vacuum bag was monitored and, per the manufacturer’s instructions, the bag was changed before the dust level was within 5 centimeters of the valve at the bottom of the vacuum. Each time a vacuum bag was removed, it was weighed to the nearest pound. The bag weights and corresponding grinding durations were used to calculate the average weight of dust collected per unit time. After each trial, cut lengths were measured on the wall to determine total linear feet of vertical (head) and horizontal (bed) joints per unit time.
A Haz-Dust III, Model HD-1003, Real-Time Aerosol Monitor (Environmental Devices Corporation, Plaistow, NH) was used to confirm clearance of dust between trials. The Haz-Dust monitor was positioned on the test wall near the operator at approximately breathing zone level and configured to measure respirable particulate concentration.
V. Results
Personal air monitoring
Five pairs of respirable dust samples were collected while grinding with and without the vacuum system. In addition, three respirable dust samples were collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place. One measurement collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard was shown to be a statistical outlier and was omitted from analysis. Personal air monitoring results for respirable silica and a comparison of average exposures relative to the NIOSH REL for silica (0.05 mg/m3) appears in Table 2. The mean respirable dust levels measured without LEV was 31.4 mg/m3. However, samples collected with LEV were below the limit of quantification (LOQ) which ranged from <1.29 to <1.46 mg/m3. Use of LEV resulted in a greater than 95% reduction in mean respirable dust levels using a mean value with use of LEV of <1.41 (n=5 samples with use of LEV and n=7 without use of LEV). The respirable dust samples collected during grinding without the LEV system contained an average of 24 percent silica. The mass of respirable dust in the samples collected with use of the LEV system was too low to determine the silica content.| Mean, mg/m3 (range) | Std. Dev. | Percent Reduction | Hazard RatioB | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bosch with Dust Director Shroud and DustControl 2900c Vacuum |
0.091 (<0.069 – 0.137) |
0.027 | 98.7 | 1.81 |
| Bosch with no Control | 7.23 (4.57 – 9.90) |
1.94 | NA | 145 |
A n = 5 samples for each tool/control combination and n = 7 samples without the use of the LEV system B Hazard Ratio = measured exposure / NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 |
||||
Average respirable silica and dust exposures, with and without the dust control system, appear as Figures 5 and 6, respectively.
Figure 5. Average respirable silica exposures with and without the Dustcontrol 2900c vacuum and Dust Director shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air - mg/m3)
Figure 6. Average respirable dust exposures with and without Dustcontrol 2900c Vacuum and Dust Director Shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air – mg/m3)
The mean respirable silica concentration measured during use of the control was significantly less than the concentration measured while using the same tool without controls (p<0.01). Grinding mortar with the Bosch angle grinder without dust controls resulted in an average exposure to respirable silica that was 145 times the NIOSH REL. Grinding with the Bosch angle grinder in combination with the Dust Director shroud and the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced the average concentration of respirable silica by 98.7 percent. With use of these controls, the concentration of respirable silica was 1.8 times greater than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3. However the NIOSH REL is based on a time-weighted average (TWA) over a 10-hour workday. Given these were task TWAs and samples were collected over continuous periods of grinding, they may overestimate exposures over an actual work day since some time would be spent performing tasks that would likely have lower, or no, silica exposures (setup, breaks, cleanup, etc.).
Static pressure, dust mass collection and grinding rates.
Static pressure was used as a surrogate for air flow as described earlier. Hood static pressure was measured periodically at a tap near the grinder more than 3 duct diameters from the air intake in the shroud. The static pressure, and thus air flow, was generally higher when the vacuum’s filter had recently been cleaned. The mean, median, and range of calculated flow rates are presented in Table A1 of the Appendix.
Based on the data we collected, the air-flow rate upstream from the Bosch grinder and Dust Director shroud ranged from 78 to 93 cubic feet per minute (cfm) with the DustControl vacuum. When the manufacturer’s filter cleaning procedure was followed the vacuum performed relatively well and flow could be maintained at slightly less than 90 cfm with cleaning. However, mean flow rates dropped substantially to 80 cfm after as little as 8 minutes of grinding without any filter cleaning. The flow rate returned to an average of 89 cfm when filters were cleaned correctly (without stopping air flow to the vacuum). Collingwood and Heitbrink (2007) found that the minimum exhaust flow rate for capture of silica and other particulate under ideal conditions is 21.25 cfm per inch of grinder blade diameter. This is equal to about 96 cfm when using a 4.5 inch diameter grinding blade. We set 106 cfm as the minimum desired flow rate for this study to allow a safety margin for potential decline in equipment performance and the possibility of inadequate maintenance, both of which may be likely after repeated use under actual work conditions. The DustControl vacuum provided slightly less than the minimum flow rate described by Collingwood and Heitbrink for a 4.5-inch blade and the peak flow rate fell with use.
The duration of vacuum bag use and mass of dust collected were recorded and are presented in Table A2 of the Appendix. The vacuum bags were changed and weighed after each trial utilizing the LEV system. A total of five bags were used to complete the five rounds of grinding. The DustControl vacuum captured 45 pounds of dust over 83 minutes of grinding for an average rate of dust collection of 0.54 pounds per minute. The rate of dust collection ranged from 0.47 to 0.63 pounds per minute. Based on these measurements, approximately 130 pounds of dust would likely be captured after just 4 hours of continuous grinding.
The rate of grinding a combination of vertical and horizontal joints while using the LEV system ranged from 2.3 to 3.3 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the use of the LEV system ranged from 2.6 to 3.4 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place ranged from 4.7 to 5.1 feet per minute. It’s important to note that: 1) the operator had limited experience using dust control systems and cut rates appeared to improve slightly over the 2-day period he used the tested equipment; and 2) the upper range of cut rates with the dust control system overlapped with the lowest cut rate with the original guard and without the LEV system in place indicating no statistical difference between cut rates. Given that grinding rates with and without use of this LEV system are only available for one operator and he had limited experience with the LEV system, these reported cut rates are in no way intended to represent the impact use of this LEV system is likely to have on productivity rates overall.
VI. Discussion
The objective of these trials was to evaluate the effectiveness of a tuckpointing LEV system for controlling respirable silica while grinding out mortar joints. The Dust Director shroud with the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced respirable silica concentrations when grinding with the Bosch grinder by approximately 99 percent. Despite being considered effective by our test criteria (greater than 50% reduction), it still resulted in task TWA exposures that exceeded the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 by 1.8 times. Depending on how much time is spent grinding over the course of a work day and on exposures while performing other tasks, the 8-hour TWA exposures may or may not exceed the REL with this system. Use of this system by workers with experience and training in proficient use will likely improve dust capture performance. Exposure reduction is greatly influenced by correct use of this system which includes grinding from right to left, making sure the shroud is held flush against the wall and that the tool travels at a pace that doesn’t exceed the ability of the system to capture dust as it’s generated. Deviation from any of these measures produces visible dust clouds which were observed during trials.
VII. Conclusions
With a 99 percent reduction in respirable silica exposure, the Dust Director shroud and DustControl 2900c vacuum with a Bosch Model 1775E grinder was effective in reducing silica exposures based on our criteria. Use of the tested dust control system may be effective in reducing silica exposure on the job to less than the NIOSH REL if used in combination with administrative controls such as work scheduling to reduce cutting times as needed. Training on correct use of the tested system is also essential. Personal air monitoring is necessary to verify control effectiveness on actual job sites and under “real-world” conditions. However, these results clearly demonstrate the availability of viable and effective engineering controls for tuckpointing operations associated with elevated silica exposure.
VIII. References
American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists. Threshold limit values for chemical substances (TLV®-CS). [2013]. ACGIH, Cincinnati, Ohio.
Bergdahl I.A,. Toren K., Eriksson K., et al. [2004]. Increased mortality in COPD among construction workers exposed to inorganic dust. European Respiratory Journal, 23: 402–06.
Blanc P.D. & Torén K. [2007]. Occupation in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and chronic bronchitis: an update [State of the Art Series. Occupational lung disease in high-and low-income countries, Edited by M. Chan-Yeung. Number 2 in the series]. The International Journal of Tuberculosis and Lung Disease, 11(3), 251-257.
Collingwood S. & Heitbrink W.A. [2007] 'Field Evaluation of an Engineering Control for Respirable Crystalline Silica Exposures During Mortar Removal'. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, 4:11, 875 – 887.
DHHS (NIOSH) Publication No. 2002-129 April 2002 http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/2002-129/
Echt A., Sieber W.K., Lefkowitz D., Meeker J., Susi P., Cardwell B., Heitbrink, W.A. In-depth survey of dust control technology for cutting concrete block and tuckpointing brick at The International Masonry Institute Bordentown Training Center, Bordentown, NJ. Cincinnati, OH: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Report. No. EPHB 282-13; 2007. http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ECTB-282-13.pdf
Heitbrink W., Bennett J. [2006]. A numerical and experimental investigation of crystalline silica exposure control during tuck pointing. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, Vol. 3, pp 366-378.
Lyons et al, [2007]. A breathless builder. Breathe, Vol. 3, no. 4, pp 386-390.
Mastrangelo G., Tartari M., Fedeli U., Fadda E., Saia B. [2003]. Ascertaining the risk of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease in relation to occupation using a case-control design. Occupational Medicine, 53: 165–172.
Meeker J., Cooper M., Lefrowitz D., Susi P. [2009]. Engineering control technologies to reduce occupational silica exposures in masonry cutting and tuckpointing. Public Health Reports, Supplement 1, Vol. 124, June.
Meeker J, Flynn M, Susi P, Cardwell, B [2004]. Performance evaluation of a masonry concrete vacuum. Unpublished Report.
Miller F. W., Alfredsson L., Costenbader K. H., Kamen D. L., Nelson L. M., Norris J. M., & De Roos A. J. [2012]. Epidemiology of environmental exposures and human autoimmune diseases: findings from a National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences Expert Panel workshop. Journal of autoimmunity. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3496812/
Occupational Safety and Health Administration U.S Department of Labor. Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction. [2009]. OSHA 3362-05.
Rappaport SM, Goldberg M, Susi P, Herrick RF [2003]. Excessive exposure to silica in the U.S. construction industry. Annals of Occupational Hygiene, Vol. 47, pp. 111-122.
IX. Appendices
| Measurement Conditions |
n | Mean Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Median
Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before filter cleaning | 5 | 80 | 81 | 78-81 |
| After filter cleaning following manufacturer directions | 9 | 89 | 90 | 84-93 |
| * Static pressure was measured in millibars and converted to inches of water gauge. Flow rates were calculated using the formula Q = Ce (A) 4005 (SP)1/2 where: Q = flow in cubic feet per minute (cfm), Ce = coefficient of entry, A = area of the duct where static pressure measurements were taken in square feet, and SP = static pressure in inches of water gauge. | ||||
| Tool/Control | Collection Period (min.) |
Dust Collection Rate (lb/min.) |
|---|---|---|
| Bosch grinder/Dust Director shroud & DustControl 2900c vacuum |
8 11 8 8 10 |
0.50 0.61 0.50 0.47 0.63 |
| Average | 0.54 |
[content_transformed:protected] =>
Executive Summary
This report describes the results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. It should also be noted that the NIOSH REL is based on exposures averaged over a ten hour work day and our results represent time weighted averages of the sample task duration periods.
Acronyms
ACGIH - American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists
CPWR - CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training
Ce - coefficient of entry
HEPA - high-efficiency particulate air
IUBAC - International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craftworkers
LEV - local exhaust ventilation
PACT - Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies
NIOSH - National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health
OEL - occupational exposure limit
OSHA - Occupational Safety and Health Administration
PAPR - powered air-purifying respirator
PEL - Permissible Exposure Limit
PVC - polyvinyl chloride
REL - Recommended Exposure Limit
RPM - revolutions per minute
TWA - time-weighted average
SP - static pressure
I. Introduction and Background
In 2010 CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training began a four-year project which seeks to identify and evaluate tuckpointing local exhaust ventilation (LEV) systems and disseminate information on their availability and effectiveness. A Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies (PACT) comprised of masonry contractors, representatives from unions, government, equipment manufacturers, and health and safety researcher was formed as part of this project. PACT members participated in identifying important characteristics for control technologies and this information was used to identify LEV systems for tuckpointing using that criteria. Contractor and labor members of the PACT selected specific tuckpointing LEV systems to be considered for evaluation. Each system consisted of a tuckpointing grinder, shroud, and vacuum. This report describes the second of four systems to be evaluated between 2012 the end of 2014, with and without LEV, in a controlled setting to determine effectiveness in silica exposure reduction. This report describes the methods and results of our evaluation of a system consisting of the DustControl 2900c vacuum with the ICS Dust Director shroud and a Bosch Model 1775E grinder.
Excessive exposure to respirable silica can result in silicosis or other silica-related diseases including pulmonary tuberculosis, lung cancer, silicoproteinosis (Lyons et al, 2007) and autoimmune disorders such as rheumatoid arthritis, sarcoidosis and scleroderma (Miller et al, 2012). Respirable silica is generally defined as particles less than 10 micrometers (μm) in aerodynamic diameter (ACGIH, 2013). Silicosis can lead to symptoms including shortness of breath, fatigue, chest pains, susceptibility to infection and possibly death. There is no cure for silicosis, however it is totally preventable. Construction workers exposed to dust, including silica, are also known to have higher rates of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD).
There are many sources of silica in construction that result in exposures of varying intensity among workers. Masonry restoration workers are among the most highly silica-exposed trades in construction. The process of grinding out deteriorated mortar joints between masonry units and replacing or repointing with fresh mortar (often referred to as tuckpointing) is a fundamental part of masonry restoration work. The removal of mortar with powered angle grinders generates enormous levels of dust. Between 2004 and 2006, NIOSH and CPWR evaluated silica exposures while grinding mortar in a controlled setting, at a local training center, where tasks, sample times and task variables were defined by the study design. These studies demonstrated that grinding mortar without controls can result in elevated respirable silica exposures. Meeker et al., (2009) reported exposures between 5 and 25.8 milligrams per cubic meter (mg/m3) in a controlled setting. This study also showed that LEV systems for tuckpointing grinders can reduce exposures to respirable silica by greater than 90 percent.II. Objectives
The objective of this evaluation was to assess the effectiveness of an LEV system for controlling exposure to silica during the grinding of mortar. The control technology was tested under controlled conditions, similar to those experienced by tuckpointers on actual job sites, using journeymen bricklayers experienced in tuckpointing and repeat, randomized trials with and without LEV. All other variables were held constant throughout so that the only variable was whether or not the tested control was used.
III. Description of Equipment Tested
A Bosch model 1775E grinder (Robert Bosch Tool Corporation, Prospect, IL) (Figures 1, 2 and 3) was fitted with a new 1/4-inch wide, 4½-inch diameter segmented diamond abrasive blade made by DeWalt (model #DW4740). The grinder weighs six and a half pounds, draws 8.5 amps and has a variable speed up to 11,000 revolutions per minute (RPMs). The DustControl 2900c vacuum (DustControl, Inc., Wilmington, NC) (Figure 3) was tested in combination with the Dust Director shroud (Industrial Contractors’ Supplies, Inc., Huntingdon, PA) (Figures 1 and 3) attached to the Bosch grinder.
Figure 1. Bosch grinder with Dust Director shroud
Figure 2. Bosch grinder without tuckpointing LEV system.
Figure 3: Bosch Grinder with LEV System
The vacuum is specified to weigh 31 pounds when empty and to provide a flow rate of 114 cubic feet of air per minute and a “static lift” or “vacuum suction pressure” of 84 inches of water. The vacuum is sold with a cyclonic pre-separator, to remove larger particles, a fine filter (rated 99.9 percent efficient) and a HEPA (high-efficiency particulate air) filter (rated to capture 99.97 percent of the particles with an aerodynamic diameter of 0.3 micrometers). The HEPA filter was removed based on the manufacturer’s recommendation due to the heavy dust loading associated with tuckpointing. CPWR sponsored research and contractor experience indicate that HEPA filters likely have an adverse effect on dust capture during tuckpointing because of extreme dust loading on filters. While the cyclone and the fine filter remove most of the dust, especially the large particles, before they reach the HEPA filter, the HEPA filter would still be subject to heavy loading, causing a substantial pressure drop and subsequent decrease in air flow rate. The relatively small increase in the efficiency of the filtration system while using the HEPA filter is expected to be quickly offset by a more significant decrease in capture efficiency as the air flow rate and ability to capture particles decreases.
Dust collects in relatively inexpensive, heavy-gauge plastic bags below and outside of the cyclone. The bags can be removed and replaced without opening the vacuum. Some vacuums are equipped with a light to indicate that the filters need to be cleaned or changed. The DC2900c features a “reverse air pulse cleaning system,” which removes accumulated dust from the filters without having to remove them from the vacuum. The system, as illustrated in Figure 4, requires the operator to disconnect the hose from the shroud, place it over an air stop so that air through the hose is cut off and pressure in the vacuum is maximized.
Figure 4. Procedure for "cleaning" of or dust removal from filters (source: http://dustcontrolusa.com/manuals/2800c.pdf)
The flap covering the port on the side of the vacuum is repeatedly flipped open to release built up pressure in strong pulses that dislodge dust from the filter.
The manufacturer indicates “the filter is generally cleaned once or twice daily during normal continuous operation.” The Dust Director shroud has a 2-inch diameter take-off that was connected to the antistatic, corrugated 1.5-inch diameter, 15-foot long vacuum hose supplied with the DustControl vacuum.
IV. Study Methods
This evaluation was conducted at the International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craft workers (IUBAC) Local 1 Philadelphia/Delaware Training Center in Philadelphia, PA on November 14 and 15, 2012. A single journeyman bricklayer, experienced in tuckpointing, used the grinder and LEV system being tested to remove mortar from joints wide enough to require two passes. The type S mortar had been allowed to cure for at least four weeks. The bricklayer either possessed or was provided with personal protective equipment including sturdy work boots, gloves, hearing protection and a powered air-purifying respirator (PAPR). The PAPR was a 3M GVP system with a bump cap, loose fitting face piece and a HEPA filter (3M, St Paul, MN).
The study was designed to include at least five rounds of sampling during mortar removal. Each round included a trial using the Bosch grinder with a Dust Director shroud and Dust Collector 2900c vacuum and a trial using the Bosch grinder with the factory-supplied guard and without a vacuum. The order of the two trials within each round was randomly selected to minimize bias that might be introduced due to variation associated with environmental factors, equipment operator, blade wear, vacuum performance over time and any other factors unrelated to LEV use. Tools were operated for approximately 16 minutes per trial with controls and for approximately 8 minutes when controls were not used. These times were selected based on the results of previous sampling efforts and estimates of the minimum sample time needed to achieve a limit of quantification low enough to accurately measure exposures down to or less than 0.05 mg/m3 – the NIOSH Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) for respirable silica. The bricklayer was required to take a 5 to 10 minute break in the middle of the 16-minute trials to reduce differences in fatigue, compared to the 8-minute trials. Personal air samples were collected in the breathing zone of the operator during each trial to measure respirable silica concentrations during grinding with and without LEV. The samples were collected using a GilAir-5 pump (Sensidyne, Inc., Clearwater, FL) to draw 4.2 liters of air per minute through a GK2.69 Respirable Cyclone (BGI Inc., Waltham, MA) with a pre-weighed, 37 mm diameter, 5-micron pore size polyvinyl chloride (PVC) filter positioned on the operator’s lapel.
The flow rates of the sampling pumps were calibrated at the beginning of each day using a DryCal DC-Lite Primary Flow Meter (Bios International Corporation, Butler, NJ). Flow rates were measured again near the middle and at the end of each day to ensure that sampling flow rates were maintained within 5% of pre-sampling flow rates throughout the day. Average flow rates were used to calculate sample air volumes. Samples were analyzed by R.J. Lee Group, Inc., (Monroeville, PA) using NIOSH Method 0600, to determine exposure to total mass of respirable dust. The same samples were also analyzed using X-Ray diffraction following NIOSH method 7500 to determine quartz, cristobalite and tridymite concentration in the respirable mass. Reported masses for these analytes were used with the sample air volumes to calculate airborne concentrations of total respirable dust, quartz, cristobalite and tridymite.
We used a reduction of greater than 50 percent in respirable silica exposure concentrations or a reduction to less than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 as our criteria for determining whether or not a control was considered efficacious. This is consistent with criteria used by NIOSH in conducting a similar study in 2004 described by Echt et al. (2007) and by CPWR in 2006 and described by Meeker et al. (2009). The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) and the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) publish additional occupational exposure limits (OELs) for silica which are listed in Table 1 with NIOSH RELs. OELs for silica are based on the respirable fraction of the aerosol, which consists of particles less than 10 micrometers in aerodynamic diameter.
| Organization or Agency | Form of Crystalline Silica | Occupational Exposure Limits (mg/m3) |
|---|---|---|
| NIOSHA | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 |
| OSHA - ConstructionB | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
PEL = 250 / (5 + % quartz) PEL = 250 / (5 + % cristobalite) PEL = 250 / (5 + % tridymite) |
| ACGIH | Crystalline Silica | TLV = 0.025 mg/m3 |
A NIOSH Publication No. 2005-151 indicates 10-hour time-weighted average during a 40-hr workweek B The PEL for silica in OSHA’s Safety and Health Regulations for Construction, 29 C.F.R. 1926.55(a), is an 8-hour time-weighted average (TWA) expressed in millions of particles per cubic foot (mppcf). However, the units mppcf can be converted to milligrams per cubic meter can by dividing mppcf by 10 (OSHA, 2009). The formula used by OSHA to determine the PEL for silica is dependent on the percentage of silica in each collected sample. The concentration of respirable dust measured is compared to the sample specific PEL to determine if the PEL has been exceeded. OSHA has proposed lowering the PEL to 0.05 mg/m3 of respirable silica as an 8 hour TWA. |
||
The flow of air in ventilation systems is governed by fundamental principles that describe the behavior of gases (in this case air). Pressure measurements taken within a ventilation system along with knowledge of hood (or shroud) entry losses can be used to calculate flow rates. Hood entry losses are dependent on the shape and configuration of a particular hood or shroud and described by the term “coefficient of entry (Ce)” which is the ratio of actual air flow through a hood and what the air flow would theoretically be if there were no hood entry losses. Given the coefficient of entry, static pressure measurements can be used to calculate air flow through a given hood. The coefficient of entry for the Dust Director shroud was previously determined by CPWR and used for calculating air flow based on static pressure measurements (Meeker et al., 2009). Static pressure, with the vacuum operating, was measured periodically throughout the evaluation to monitor the changes in air-flow rate following use and again after filter cleaning. The static pressure was measured at a port positioned more than 3 duct diameters downstream from the tool’s air intake using a UEi EM200 Electronic Manometer (Universal Enterprises, Inc., Beaverton, OR).
The dust in the vacuum bag was monitored and, per the manufacturer’s instructions, the bag was changed before the dust level was within 5 centimeters of the valve at the bottom of the vacuum. Each time a vacuum bag was removed, it was weighed to the nearest pound. The bag weights and corresponding grinding durations were used to calculate the average weight of dust collected per unit time. After each trial, cut lengths were measured on the wall to determine total linear feet of vertical (head) and horizontal (bed) joints per unit time.
A Haz-Dust III, Model HD-1003, Real-Time Aerosol Monitor (Environmental Devices Corporation, Plaistow, NH) was used to confirm clearance of dust between trials. The Haz-Dust monitor was positioned on the test wall near the operator at approximately breathing zone level and configured to measure respirable particulate concentration.
V. Results
Personal air monitoring
Five pairs of respirable dust samples were collected while grinding with and without the vacuum system. In addition, three respirable dust samples were collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place. One measurement collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard was shown to be a statistical outlier and was omitted from analysis. Personal air monitoring results for respirable silica and a comparison of average exposures relative to the NIOSH REL for silica (0.05 mg/m3) appears in Table 2. The mean respirable dust levels measured without LEV was 31.4 mg/m3. However, samples collected with LEV were below the limit of quantification (LOQ) which ranged from <1.29 to <1.46 mg/m3. Use of LEV resulted in a greater than 95% reduction in mean respirable dust levels using a mean value with use of LEV of <1.41 (n=5 samples with use of LEV and n=7 without use of LEV). The respirable dust samples collected during grinding without the LEV system contained an average of 24 percent silica. The mass of respirable dust in the samples collected with use of the LEV system was too low to determine the silica content.| Mean, mg/m3 (range) | Std. Dev. | Percent Reduction | Hazard RatioB | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bosch with Dust Director Shroud and DustControl 2900c Vacuum |
0.091 (<0.069 – 0.137) |
0.027 | 98.7 | 1.81 |
| Bosch with no Control | 7.23 (4.57 – 9.90) |
1.94 | NA | 145 |
A n = 5 samples for each tool/control combination and n = 7 samples without the use of the LEV system B Hazard Ratio = measured exposure / NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 |
||||
Average respirable silica and dust exposures, with and without the dust control system, appear as Figures 5 and 6, respectively.
Figure 5. Average respirable silica exposures with and without the Dustcontrol 2900c vacuum and Dust Director shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air - mg/m3)
Figure 6. Average respirable dust exposures with and without Dustcontrol 2900c Vacuum and Dust Director Shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air – mg/m3)
The mean respirable silica concentration measured during use of the control was significantly less than the concentration measured while using the same tool without controls (p<0.01). Grinding mortar with the Bosch angle grinder without dust controls resulted in an average exposure to respirable silica that was 145 times the NIOSH REL. Grinding with the Bosch angle grinder in combination with the Dust Director shroud and the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced the average concentration of respirable silica by 98.7 percent. With use of these controls, the concentration of respirable silica was 1.8 times greater than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3. However the NIOSH REL is based on a time-weighted average (TWA) over a 10-hour workday. Given these were task TWAs and samples were collected over continuous periods of grinding, they may overestimate exposures over an actual work day since some time would be spent performing tasks that would likely have lower, or no, silica exposures (setup, breaks, cleanup, etc.).
Static pressure, dust mass collection and grinding rates.
Static pressure was used as a surrogate for air flow as described earlier. Hood static pressure was measured periodically at a tap near the grinder more than 3 duct diameters from the air intake in the shroud. The static pressure, and thus air flow, was generally higher when the vacuum’s filter had recently been cleaned. The mean, median, and range of calculated flow rates are presented in Table A1 of the Appendix.
Based on the data we collected, the air-flow rate upstream from the Bosch grinder and Dust Director shroud ranged from 78 to 93 cubic feet per minute (cfm) with the DustControl vacuum. When the manufacturer’s filter cleaning procedure was followed the vacuum performed relatively well and flow could be maintained at slightly less than 90 cfm with cleaning. However, mean flow rates dropped substantially to 80 cfm after as little as 8 minutes of grinding without any filter cleaning. The flow rate returned to an average of 89 cfm when filters were cleaned correctly (without stopping air flow to the vacuum). Collingwood and Heitbrink (2007) found that the minimum exhaust flow rate for capture of silica and other particulate under ideal conditions is 21.25 cfm per inch of grinder blade diameter. This is equal to about 96 cfm when using a 4.5 inch diameter grinding blade. We set 106 cfm as the minimum desired flow rate for this study to allow a safety margin for potential decline in equipment performance and the possibility of inadequate maintenance, both of which may be likely after repeated use under actual work conditions. The DustControl vacuum provided slightly less than the minimum flow rate described by Collingwood and Heitbrink for a 4.5-inch blade and the peak flow rate fell with use.
The duration of vacuum bag use and mass of dust collected were recorded and are presented in Table A2 of the Appendix. The vacuum bags were changed and weighed after each trial utilizing the LEV system. A total of five bags were used to complete the five rounds of grinding. The DustControl vacuum captured 45 pounds of dust over 83 minutes of grinding for an average rate of dust collection of 0.54 pounds per minute. The rate of dust collection ranged from 0.47 to 0.63 pounds per minute. Based on these measurements, approximately 130 pounds of dust would likely be captured after just 4 hours of continuous grinding.
The rate of grinding a combination of vertical and horizontal joints while using the LEV system ranged from 2.3 to 3.3 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the use of the LEV system ranged from 2.6 to 3.4 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place ranged from 4.7 to 5.1 feet per minute. It’s important to note that: 1) the operator had limited experience using dust control systems and cut rates appeared to improve slightly over the 2-day period he used the tested equipment; and 2) the upper range of cut rates with the dust control system overlapped with the lowest cut rate with the original guard and without the LEV system in place indicating no statistical difference between cut rates. Given that grinding rates with and without use of this LEV system are only available for one operator and he had limited experience with the LEV system, these reported cut rates are in no way intended to represent the impact use of this LEV system is likely to have on productivity rates overall.
VI. Discussion
The objective of these trials was to evaluate the effectiveness of a tuckpointing LEV system for controlling respirable silica while grinding out mortar joints. The Dust Director shroud with the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced respirable silica concentrations when grinding with the Bosch grinder by approximately 99 percent. Despite being considered effective by our test criteria (greater than 50% reduction), it still resulted in task TWA exposures that exceeded the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 by 1.8 times. Depending on how much time is spent grinding over the course of a work day and on exposures while performing other tasks, the 8-hour TWA exposures may or may not exceed the REL with this system. Use of this system by workers with experience and training in proficient use will likely improve dust capture performance. Exposure reduction is greatly influenced by correct use of this system which includes grinding from right to left, making sure the shroud is held flush against the wall and that the tool travels at a pace that doesn’t exceed the ability of the system to capture dust as it’s generated. Deviation from any of these measures produces visible dust clouds which were observed during trials.
VII. Conclusions
With a 99 percent reduction in respirable silica exposure, the Dust Director shroud and DustControl 2900c vacuum with a Bosch Model 1775E grinder was effective in reducing silica exposures based on our criteria. Use of the tested dust control system may be effective in reducing silica exposure on the job to less than the NIOSH REL if used in combination with administrative controls such as work scheduling to reduce cutting times as needed. Training on correct use of the tested system is also essential. Personal air monitoring is necessary to verify control effectiveness on actual job sites and under “real-world” conditions. However, these results clearly demonstrate the availability of viable and effective engineering controls for tuckpointing operations associated with elevated silica exposure.
VIII. References
American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists. Threshold limit values for chemical substances (TLV®-CS). [2013]. ACGIH, Cincinnati, Ohio.
Bergdahl I.A,. Toren K., Eriksson K., et al. [2004]. Increased mortality in COPD among construction workers exposed to inorganic dust. European Respiratory Journal, 23: 402–06.
Blanc P.D. & Torén K. [2007]. Occupation in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and chronic bronchitis: an update [State of the Art Series. Occupational lung disease in high-and low-income countries, Edited by M. Chan-Yeung. Number 2 in the series]. The International Journal of Tuberculosis and Lung Disease, 11(3), 251-257.
Collingwood S. & Heitbrink W.A. [2007] 'Field Evaluation of an Engineering Control for Respirable Crystalline Silica Exposures During Mortar Removal'. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, 4:11, 875 – 887.
DHHS (NIOSH) Publication No. 2002-129 April 2002 http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/2002-129/
Echt A., Sieber W.K., Lefkowitz D., Meeker J., Susi P., Cardwell B., Heitbrink, W.A. In-depth survey of dust control technology for cutting concrete block and tuckpointing brick at The International Masonry Institute Bordentown Training Center, Bordentown, NJ. Cincinnati, OH: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Report. No. EPHB 282-13; 2007. http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ECTB-282-13.pdf
Heitbrink W., Bennett J. [2006]. A numerical and experimental investigation of crystalline silica exposure control during tuck pointing. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, Vol. 3, pp 366-378.
Lyons et al, [2007]. A breathless builder. Breathe, Vol. 3, no. 4, pp 386-390.
Mastrangelo G., Tartari M., Fedeli U., Fadda E., Saia B. [2003]. Ascertaining the risk of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease in relation to occupation using a case-control design. Occupational Medicine, 53: 165–172.
Meeker J., Cooper M., Lefrowitz D., Susi P. [2009]. Engineering control technologies to reduce occupational silica exposures in masonry cutting and tuckpointing. Public Health Reports, Supplement 1, Vol. 124, June.
Meeker J, Flynn M, Susi P, Cardwell, B [2004]. Performance evaluation of a masonry concrete vacuum. Unpublished Report.
Miller F. W., Alfredsson L., Costenbader K. H., Kamen D. L., Nelson L. M., Norris J. M., & De Roos A. J. [2012]. Epidemiology of environmental exposures and human autoimmune diseases: findings from a National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences Expert Panel workshop. Journal of autoimmunity. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3496812/
Occupational Safety and Health Administration U.S Department of Labor. Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction. [2009]. OSHA 3362-05.
Rappaport SM, Goldberg M, Susi P, Herrick RF [2003]. Excessive exposure to silica in the U.S. construction industry. Annals of Occupational Hygiene, Vol. 47, pp. 111-122.
IX. Appendices
| Measurement Conditions |
n | Mean Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Median
Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before filter cleaning | 5 | 80 | 81 | 78-81 |
| After filter cleaning following manufacturer directions | 9 | 89 | 90 | 84-93 |
| * Static pressure was measured in millibars and converted to inches of water gauge. Flow rates were calculated using the formula Q = Ce (A) 4005 (SP)1/2 where: Q = flow in cubic feet per minute (cfm), Ce = coefficient of entry, A = area of the duct where static pressure measurements were taken in square feet, and SP = static pressure in inches of water gauge. | ||||
| Tool/Control | Collection Period (min.) |
Dust Collection Rate (lb/min.) |
|---|---|---|
| Bosch grinder/Dust Director shroud & DustControl 2900c vacuum |
8 11 8 8 10 |
0.50 0.61 0.50 0.47 0.63 |
| Average | 0.54 |
[disclaimer:protected] => [disclaimer_transformed:protected] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [template] => record ) [_file] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/templates/elcosh/record_macros.html [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_encoding:protected] => UTF-8 [_outputMode:protected] => 11 [_forceReparse:protected] => [_phpCodeDestination:protected] => /tmp/ [_phpCodeExtension:protected] => php [_cacheLifetime:protected] => 30 [_cachePurgeFrequency:protected] => 30 [externalMacroTemplatesCache:PHPTAL:private] => Array ( ) ) ) ) ) ) [3] => Array ( [file] => /tmp/tpl_61515a6c_record__uvBJJSo8xT_sgOY5gjP7ug.php [line] => 44 [function] => _executeMacroOfTemplate [class] => PHPTAL [type] => -> [args] => Array ( [0] => record_macros.html/collections [1] => PHPTAL Object ( [_prefilters:protected] => Array ( ) [_prefilter:PHPTAL:private] => REMOVED: DO NOT USE [_postfilter:protected] => [_repositories:protected] => Array ( ) [_path:protected] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/templates/elcosh/record.html [_resolvers:protected] => Array ( ) [_source:protected] => PHPTAL_FileSource Object ( [_path:PHPTAL_FileSource:private] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/templates/elcosh/record.html ) [_codeFile:protected] => /tmp/tpl_61515a6c_record__uvBJJSo8xT_sgOY5gjP7ug.php [_functionName:protected] => tpl_61515a6c_record__uvBJJSo8xT_sgOY5gjP7ug [_prepared:protected] => 1 [_triggers:protected] => Array ( ) [_translator:protected] => [_globalContext:protected] => stdClass Object ( ) [_context:protected] => PHPTAL_Context Object ( [_line] => [_file] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/templates/elcosh/record.html [repeat] => stdClass Object ( ) [_xmlDeclaration] => [_docType] => [_nothrow:PHPTAL_Context:private] => [_slots:PHPTAL_Context:private] => Array ( ) [_slotsStack:PHPTAL_Context:private] => Array ( [0] => Array ( ) [1] => Array ( ) ) [_parentContext:PHPTAL_Context:private] => [_globalContext:PHPTAL_Context:private] => stdClass Object ( ) [_echoDeclarations:PHPTAL_Context:private] => [referer] => http://www.elcosh.org/document/3908/d001345/An%2BEvaluation%2Bof%2BSilica%2BExposure%2BControls%2Bfor%2BTuckpointing%253A%2BDustControl%2B2900c%2BVacuum%2Bwith%2Bthe%2BICS%2BDust%2BDirector%2BShroud%2Band%2BBosch%2BGrinder%2BModel%2B1775E%2BConducted%2BNovember%2B14-15%252C%2B2012.html [curr_module] => Record [styles] => Array ( ) [javascript] => Array ( [0] => jquery.min.js ) [metas] => Array ( [language] => en [robots] => index, follow ) [user] => [curr_url] => https://www.elcosh.org/index.php?module=Record&id=3908&type=document [base_url] => https://www.elcosh.org/index.php?module=Record [title] => eLCOSH : An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: DustControl 2900c Vacuum with the ICS Dust Director Shroud and Bosch Grinder Model 1775E Conducted November 14-15, 2012 [language] => en [search_query] => [module] => Record [new_records] => Array ( [0] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Fixed Ladder [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Fixed Ladders addresses the potential risks associated with using fixed ladders. The resource includes a brief case example,... [category] => Array ( [0] => 15 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 53 [5] => 55 [6] => 60 [7] => 64 [8] => 73 [9] => 76 [10] => 78 [11] => 80 [12] => 86 [13] => 87 [14] => 90 [15] => 92 [16] => 93 [17] => 94 [18] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Falls [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Concrete Polisher [11] => Electrical Worker [13] => HVAC [15] => Laborer [17] => PCC/Restoration [19] => Plumber/Pipefitter [21] => Roofer/Waterproofer [23] => Sheetmetal Worker [25] => Welder [27] => Commercial & Institutional [28] => Jobsites [29] => Industrial [31] => LEED/Green Construction [33] => Renovations [35] => Residential [37] => Toolbox Talks [38] => Documents [39] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4430/d001660/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BFixed%2BLadder.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [53] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 53 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Concrete Polisher [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [73] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 73 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => PCC/Restoration [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4430 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001660 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Fixed Ladder [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Fixed Ladders, Fall Prevention, Falls [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Fixed Ladders addresses the potential risks associated with using fixed ladders. The resource includes a brief case example, steps to prevent a related injury and questions for discussion. It includes an image that illustrates the hazard, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001257,d001254,d001255,d001256,d001258,d001262,d001279 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_completed:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/22/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [1] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Challenges Preventing Falling Objects [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Challenges Preventing Falling Objects addresses the hazards of being struck by falling objects on the job site. The resource... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 55 [5] => 64 [6] => 68 [7] => 71 [8] => 75 [9] => 78 [10] => 79 [11] => 82 [12] => 62 [13] => 86 [14] => 87 [15] => 88 [16] => 89 [17] => 91 [18] => 90 [19] => 92 [20] => 93 [21] => 94 [22] => 95 [23] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Electrical Worker [11] => Laborer [13] => Maintenance Worker [15] => Painter [17] => Plasterer [19] => Roofer/Waterproofer [21] => Scaffold Erector [23] => Stonemason [25] => Structural Ironworker [27] => Welder [29] => Commercial & Institutional [30] => Jobsites [31] => Demolition [33] => Disasters [35] => Heavy & Highway [37] => Industrial [39] => LEED/Green Construction [41] => Renovations [43] => Residential [45] => Underground [47] => Toolbox Talks [48] => Documents [49] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4431/d001661/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BChallenges%2BPreventing%2BFalling%2BObjects.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4431 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001661 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Challenges Preventing Falling Objects [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => dropped objects, falling objects, struck by incidents, struck by fatalities [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Challenges Preventing Falling Objects addresses the hazards of being struck by falling objects on the job site. The resource includes a brief example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates a group workers observing a scaffold free of debris during high winds, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001234,d001238,d001244,d001251,d001253,d001260,d001268,d001278 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_completed:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/22/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [2] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Tower Crane Safety [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Tower Crane Safety addresses the potential hazards of Tower Cranes and the importance of following procedure before and durin... [category] => Array ( [0] => 11 [1] => 12 [2] => 18 [3] => 70 [4] => 87 [5] => 88 [6] => 91 [7] => 90 [8] => 92 [9] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Cranes & Hoists [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Crushed/Struck By [6] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [9] => Operating Engineer [10] => Trades [11] => Commercial & Institutional [12] => Jobsites [13] => Demolition [15] => Heavy & Highway [17] => Industrial [19] => LEED/Green Construction [21] => Toolbox Talks [22] => Documents [23] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4427/d001657/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BTower%2BCrane%2BSafety.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [11] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 11 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Cranes & Hoists [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [18] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 18 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4427 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001657 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Tower Crane Safety [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Tower Crane, Crane, Stability, Tipping, Lift Zone Safety, Lift, Zone, Safety, Struck by [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Tower Crane Safety addresses the potential hazards of Tower Cranes and the importance of following procedure before and during Tower Crane operation. The resource includes a brief example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates a worker inspecting a Tower Crane before operation, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001234,d001238,d001250,d001251,d001253,d001258,d001262,d001273 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/19/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [3] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Work Zone Safety: Working Around Vehicles [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Working Around Vehicles in the Work Zone addresses methods to avoid being struck-by a vehicle on a construction site. The res... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 18 [2] => 52 [3] => 57 [4] => 70 [5] => 85 [6] => 87 [7] => 88 [8] => 89 [9] => 91 [10] => 90 [11] => 92 [12] => 93 [13] => 94 [14] => 95 [15] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [6] => Commercial Diver [7] => Trades [8] => Flagger [10] => Operating Engineer [12] => Truck Driver [14] => Commercial & Institutional [15] => Jobsites [16] => Demolition [18] => Disasters [20] => Heavy & Highway [22] => Industrial [24] => LEED/Green Construction [26] => Renovations [28] => Residential [30] => Underground [32] => Toolbox Talks [33] => Documents [34] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4428/d001658/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BWork%2BZone%2BSafety%253A%2BWorking%2BAround%2BVehicles.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [18] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 18 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [52] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 52 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Commercial Diver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [85] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 85 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Truck Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4428 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001658 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Daniela Caceres [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Work Zone Safety: Working Around Vehicles [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Struck, Struck by, Vehicle, Work Zone Safety, Truck, Operator, Driver, Mobile Equipment [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Working Around Vehicles in the Work Zone addresses methods to avoid being struck-by a vehicle on a construction site. The resource includes a case example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates the hazard, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001640 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/19/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [4] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Construction Dive -- DeWalt's Jobsite Pro headphones recalled for fire hazards [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => A recall notice by the United States Consumer Product Safety Commission affects over 300,000 DeWalt Jobsite Pro Headphones. The recall is a result of... [category] => Array ( [0] => 16 [1] => 44 [2] => 45 [3] => 46 [4] => 47 [5] => 48 [6] => 49 [7] => 50 [8] => 51 [9] => 52 [10] => 53 [11] => 54 [12] => 55 [13] => 56 [14] => 57 [15] => 58 [16] => 59 [17] => 60 [18] => 61 [19] => 64 [20] => 65 [21] => 66 [22] => 67 [23] => 68 [24] => 69 [25] => 70 [26] => 71 [27] => 72 [28] => 73 [29] => 74 [30] => 75 [31] => 76 [32] => 77 [33] => 63 [34] => 78 [35] => 79 [36] => 80 [37] => 81 [38] => 82 [39] => 62 [40] => 83 [41] => 84 [42] => 85 [43] => 86 [44] => 87 [45] => 88 [46] => 89 [47] => 91 [48] => 90 [49] => 92 [50] => 93 [51] => 94 [52] => 95 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Fire & Explosions [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Acoustical Ceiling Carpenter [4] => Trades [5] => Asbestos/Insulator [7] => Boilermaker [9] => Bricklayer [11] => Cabinetmaker [13] => Carpenter [15] => Carpet Layer [17] => Cement Mason [19] => Commercial Diver [21] => Concrete Polisher [23] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [25] => Electrical Worker [27] => Elevator Constructor [29] => Flagger [31] => Glazier [33] => Hazardous Waste Cleanup [35] => HVAC [37] => Interior Systems Carpenter [39] => Laborer [41] => Landscaper [43] => Lather [45] => Lead Abatement Worker [47] => Maintenance Worker [49] => Millwright [51] => Operating Engineer [53] => Painter [55] => Paper Hanger [57] => PCC/Restoration [59] => Pile Driver [61] => Plasterer [63] => Plumber/Pipefitter [65] => Refractory Worker [67] => Reinforcing Ironworker [69] => Roofer/Waterproofer [71] => Scaffold Erector [73] => Sheetmetal Worker [75] => Sprinkler Fitter [77] => Stonemason [79] => Structural Ironworker [81] => Terrazzo Worker [83] => Tile Setter [85] => Truck Driver [87] => Welder [89] => Commercial & Institutional [90] => Jobsites [91] => Demolition [93] => Disasters [95] => Heavy & Highway [97] => Industrial [99] => LEED/Green Construction [101] => Renovations [103] => Residential [105] => Underground ) [type] => [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4426/d001656/Construction%2BDive%2B--%2BDeWalt%2527s%2BJobsite%2BPro%2Bheadphones%2Brecalled%2Bfor%2Bfire%2Bhazards.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [16] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 16 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Fire & Explosions [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [44] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 44 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Acoustical Ceiling Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [45] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 45 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Asbestos/Insulator [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [46] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 46 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Boilermaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [48] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 48 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cabinetmaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [50] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 50 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpet Layer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [52] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 52 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Commercial Diver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [53] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 53 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Concrete Polisher [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [54] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 54 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [58] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 58 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Glazier [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [59] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 59 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Hazardous Waste Cleanup [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [65] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 65 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Landscaper [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [66] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 66 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Lather [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [67] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 67 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Lead Abatement Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [69] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 69 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Millwright [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [72] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 72 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Paper Hanger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [73] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 73 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => PCC/Restoration [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [77] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 77 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Refractory Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [81] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 81 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sprinkler Fitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [83] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 83 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Terrazzo Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [84] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 84 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Tile Setter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [85] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 85 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Truck Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4426 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001656 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Construction Dive -- DeWalt's Jobsite Pro headphones recalled for fire hazards [total_pages:protected] => 1 [billed_pages:protected] => 1 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => DeWalt, Fire Hazards, recall, headphones [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A recall notice by the United States Consumer Product Safety Commission affects over 300,000 DeWalt Jobsite Pro Headphones. The recall is a result of a malfunction that can cause earbuds to overheat while charging or during use, leading to fire and burn hazards. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => https://www.constructiondive.com/news/dewalts-jobsite-pro-headphones-recalled-for-fire-hazards/611248/?utm_source=Sailthru&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Issue:%202021-12-10%20Construction%20Dive%20Newsletter%20%5Bissue:38532%5D&utm_term=Construction%20Dive [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/13/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/13/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 12/13/21 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [new_images] => Array ( [0] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Morning Toolbox Talk [image] => /record/images/4003-p.jpg [blurb] => This photo is from an early morning toolbox talk on a construction job in Mclean, Virginia. It is being delivered in English and Spanish.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 20 [1] => 51 [2] => 57 [3] => 64 [4] => 70 [5] => 63 [6] => 78 [7] => 82 [8] => 62 [9] => 87 [10] => 88 [11] => 89 [12] => 91 [13] => 90 [14] => 93 [15] => 94 [16] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Safety Culture [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Cement Mason [4] => Trades [5] => Flagger [7] => Laborer [9] => Operating Engineer [11] => Reinforcing Ironworker [13] => Roofer/Waterproofer [15] => Stonemason [17] => Structural Ironworker [19] => Commercial & Institutional [20] => Jobsites [21] => Demolition [23] => Disasters [25] => Heavy & Highway [27] => Industrial [29] => Renovations [31] => Residential [33] => Images [34] => Media [35] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4003/i002691/Morning%2BToolbox%2BTalk.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4003 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002691 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Morning Toolbox Talk [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, Spanish, bilingual [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This photo is from an early morning toolbox talk on a construction job in Mclean, Virginia. It is being delivered in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001285,d001304,c000079 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [1] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox talk - crew view [image] => /record/images/4005-p.jpg [blurb] => Photo of crew listening to a toolbox safety talk before starting work.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 97 [1] => 20 [2] => 47 [3] => 49 [4] => 51 [5] => 55 [6] => 61 [7] => 64 [8] => 71 [9] => 75 [10] => 63 [11] => 79 [12] => 62 [13] => 87 [14] => 88 [15] => 91 [16] => 90 [17] => 93 [18] => 94 [19] => 95 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Images [1] => Media [2] => Media & Documents [3] => Safety Culture [4] => Work Environment [5] => Hazards [6] => Bricklayer [7] => Trades [8] => Carpenter [10] => Cement Mason [12] => Electrical Worker [14] => Interior Systems Carpenter [16] => Laborer [18] => Painter [20] => Plasterer [22] => Reinforcing Ironworker [24] => Scaffold Erector [26] => Structural Ironworker [28] => Commercial & Institutional [29] => Jobsites [30] => Demolition [32] => Heavy & Highway [34] => Industrial [36] => Renovations [38] => Residential [40] => Underground ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4005/i002692/Toolbox%2Btalk%2B-%2Bcrew%2Bview.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4005 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002692 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox talk - crew view [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, safety talk, Spanish [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Photo of crew listening to a toolbox safety talk before starting work. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002691,d001269, c000079, d001285 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [2] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox talk - long shot [image] => /record/images/4006-p.jpg [blurb] => This crew gathered every morning before starting work to discuss a new safety topic.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 20 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 55 [5] => 64 [6] => 68 [7] => 75 [8] => 76 [9] => 63 [10] => 78 [11] => 79 [12] => 82 [13] => 62 [14] => 87 [15] => 88 [16] => 91 [17] => 90 [18] => 93 [19] => 94 [20] => 95 [21] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Safety Culture [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Electrical Worker [11] => Laborer [13] => Maintenance Worker [15] => Plasterer [17] => Plumber/Pipefitter [19] => Reinforcing Ironworker [21] => Roofer/Waterproofer [23] => Scaffold Erector [25] => Stonemason [27] => Structural Ironworker [29] => Commercial & Institutional [30] => Jobsites [31] => Demolition [33] => Heavy & Highway [35] => Industrial [37] => Renovations [39] => Residential [41] => Underground [43] => Images [44] => Media [45] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4006/i002693/Toolbox%2Btalk%2B-%2Blong%2Bshot.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4006 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002693 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox talk - long shot [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, safety minute [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This crew gathered every morning before starting work to discuss a new safety topic. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002691,i002692,d001269,d000527 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [3] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Safety officer discussing ongoing project with marketing coordinator [image] => /record/images/4014-p.jpg [blurb] => The safety officer (left) points out the good safety practices on this project that reflect well on the firm and may influence future clients.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 97 [1] => 20 [2] => 46 [3] => 47 [4] => 49 [5] => 50 [6] => 51 [7] => 54 [8] => 55 [9] => 58 [10] => 60 [11] => 61 [12] => 64 [13] => 71 [14] => 75 [15] => 76 [16] => 63 [17] => 79 [18] => 80 [19] => 82 [20] => 62 [21] => 83 [22] => 87 [23] => 91 [24] => 90 [25] => 93 [26] => 94 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Images [1] => Media [2] => Media & Documents [3] => Safety Culture [4] => Work Environment [5] => Hazards [6] => Boilermaker [7] => Trades [8] => Bricklayer [10] => Carpenter [12] => Carpet Layer [14] => Cement Mason [16] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [18] => Electrical Worker [20] => Glazier [22] => HVAC [24] => Interior Systems Carpenter [26] => Laborer [28] => Painter [30] => Plasterer [32] => Plumber/Pipefitter [34] => Reinforcing Ironworker [36] => Scaffold Erector [38] => Sheetmetal Worker [40] => Stonemason [42] => Structural Ironworker [44] => Terrazzo Worker [46] => Commercial & Institutional [47] => Jobsites [48] => Heavy & Highway [50] => Industrial [52] => Renovations [54] => Residential ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4014/i002700/Safety%2Bofficer%2Bdiscussing%2Bongoing%2Bproject%2Bwith%2Bmarketing%2Bcoordinator.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [46] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 46 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Boilermaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [50] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 50 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpet Layer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [54] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 54 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [58] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 58 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Glazier [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [83] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 83 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Terrazzo Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4014 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002700 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Safety officer discussing ongoing project with marketing coordinator [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Latino, safety officer, safety culture [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The safety officer (left) points out the good safety practices on this project that reflect well on the firm and may influence future clients. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/index.php [more_like_this:protected] => d000989,d001351,d001362,d000652, d001101, d000931, d001395 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Hoar Construction, Photo by Neil Lippy [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 01/30/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [4] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Scaffolding at top of large column [image] => /record/images/3994-p.jpg [blurb] => This shot shows innovative guarding around the top of a large concrete column in the base of a high rise structure going up.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 15 [1] => 21 [2] => 47 [3] => 51 [4] => 63 [5] => 78 [6] => 79 [7] => 80 [8] => 62 [9] => 87 [10] => 97 [11] => 56 [12] => 64 [13] => 74 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Falls [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Scaffolds [6] => Bricklayer [7] => Trades [8] => Cement Mason [10] => Reinforcing Ironworker [12] => Roofer/Waterproofer [14] => Scaffold Erector [16] => Sheetmetal Worker [18] => Structural Ironworker [20] => Commercial & Institutional [21] => Jobsites [22] => Images [23] => Media [24] => Media & Documents [25] => Elevator Constructor [27] => Laborer [29] => Pile Driver ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/3994/i002689/Scaffolding%2Bat%2Btop%2Bof%2Blarge%2Bcolumn.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [21] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 21 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Scaffolds [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3994 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002689 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Scaffolding at top of large column [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Guardrail, railing, fall prevention, falls [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This shot shows innovative guarding around the top of a large concrete column in the base of a high rise structure going up. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/8/adjustable-tower-scaffold.html [more_like_this:protected] => c1002680,i002662,d000608,d001255 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Photo by Pam Susi [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2016 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_completed:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/01/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [5] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Construction bracing [image] => /record/images/3995-p.jpg [blurb] => This shows structural support that prevents collapses during construction.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 15 [2] => 21 [3] => 49 [4] => 51 [5] => 55 [6] => 56 [7] => 60 [8] => 64 [9] => 68 [10] => 74 [11] => 63 [12] => 78 [13] => 79 [14] => 80 [15] => 62 [16] => 87 [17] => 90 [18] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Falls [6] => Scaffolds [9] => Carpenter [10] => Trades [11] => Cement Mason [13] => Electrical Worker [15] => Elevator Constructor [17] => HVAC [19] => Laborer [21] => Maintenance Worker [23] => Pile Driver [25] => Reinforcing Ironworker [27] => Roofer/Waterproofer [29] => Scaffold Erector [31] => Sheetmetal Worker [33] => Structural Ironworker [35] => Commercial & Institutional [36] => Jobsites [37] => Industrial [39] => Images [40] => Media [41] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/3995/i002690/Construction%2Bbracing.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [21] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 21 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Scaffolds [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3995 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002690 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Construction bracing [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Bracing, support, scaffold [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This shows structural support that prevents collapses during construction. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/8/adjustable-tower-scaffold.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002660 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Photo by Pam Susi [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2016 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_completed:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/01/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [preview_mode] => [description] => The results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. [keywords] => tuckpointing, HEPA vacuum, dust control, LEV, local exhaust ventilation, silica [related_items] => Array ( [Research Reports] => Array ( [0] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1874 [old_id:protected] => 722 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000683 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Sharon Garber/COD [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Protecting Tuckpointing Workers from Silica Dust: Draft Recommendations for a Ventilated Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 12 [billed_pages:protected] => 12 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, vacuum, grinder, mortar, respirator, OSHA, NIOSH, exhaust, Heitbrink, tuckpointer, silica, masonry, dust, silicosis, LEV [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Describes draft recommendations for use of ventilated grinder to reduce dust during tuckpointing and describes field trials using these devices. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/hazard/67/chip-scrape-and-grind-surfaces-or-joints-silica.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001201,d000292,d000293,d000658 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2005 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/27/05 [date_completed:protected] => 04/26/05 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/20/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [1] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1940 [old_id:protected] => 909 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Workplace Solutions: Control of Hazardous Dust During Tuckpointing [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, silica, dust, tuckpoint, grinder, masonry restoration, mortar, vacuum [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d000819,d000820,d000730,d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 10/24/08 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/09 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [2] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3899 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001342 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: Hilti VC40-U Vacuum with Hilti DC-EX Dust Guard and Hilti Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 15 [billed_pages:protected] => 15 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP4 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => silica, tuckpointing, Hilti, local exhaust systems, LEV, shroud, quartz [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This report describes the results of an evaluation of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Hilti VC40-U vacuum, a Hilti DC-EX shroud, and a Hilti DAG-500 grinder. Randomized trials with and without use of the dust control system were conducted in a controlled setting. Removing mortar with the Hilti grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 220 times the National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05mg/m3. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 97 percent. However, exposures measured during the use of the dust control system still exceeded the NIOSH REL. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => December 1, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/05/14 [date_completed:protected] => 02/04/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/06/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [Handouts] => Array ( [0] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3656 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001198 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 24 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction While Doing Tuckpointing/Mortar Removal [total_pages:protected] => 2 [billed_pages:protected] => 2 [publication_number:protected] => DSG FS-3632 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Brick, block, tuckpointing, silica, local exhaust ventilation, LEV, masonry [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Tuckpointing creates some of the greatest exposures to silica in construction. This OSHA factsheet provides guidance on how to greatly reduce these exposures through the use of local exhaust ventilation. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863, d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => February 2013 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/04/13 [date_completed:protected] => 03/27/13 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [collections] => Array ( [3913] => ) [record] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => Array ( [867] => Author Object ( [id:protected] => 867 [organization_id:protected] => 0 [firstname:protected] => Michael [lastname:protected] => Cooper [address:protected] => [city:protected] => [province:protected] => [country:protected] => [postal_code:protected] => [department:protected] => [title:protected] => [phone:protected] => [fax:protected] => [email:protected] => [degree:protected] => [website:protected] => [about:protected] => [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => [date_completed:protected] => [date_billed:protected] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [481] => Author Object ( [id:protected] => 481 [organization_id:protected] => 0 [firstname:protected] => Pam [lastname:protected] => Susi [address:protected] => 8484 Georgia Avenue, Suite 1000 [city:protected] => Silver Spring [province:protected] => Maryland [country:protected] => USA [postal_code:protected] => 20910 [department:protected] => [title:protected] => [phone:protected] => 301-578-8500 ext.144 [fax:protected] => 301-578-8572 [email:protected] => plsusi@aol.com [degree:protected] => [website:protected] => http://www.cpwr.com [about:protected] => [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => 2003-10-02 [date_completed:protected] => 2003-10-06 [date_billed:protected] => 2003-11-03 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [organizations:protected] => Array ( [1] => Organization Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [elcosh_id:protected] => o000001 [user_id:protected] => 14 [province_id:protected] => 21 [country_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => CPWR - The Center for Construction Research and Training [address:protected] => Suite 1000, 8484 Georgia Ave [postal_code:protected] => 20910 [city:protected] => Silver Spring [department:protected] => [phone:protected] => 301-578-8500 [fax:protected] => 301-578-8572 [email:protected] => cpwrwebsite@cpwr.com [website:protected] => http://www.cpwr.com [filename:protected] => o000001.gif [about:protected] => CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training, developed, and continues to maintain/expand this website - The Electronic Library of Construction Occupational Safety and Health, www.elcosh.org. CPWR, formerly known as The Center to Protect Workers’ Rights, is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit research and training institution. Created by the Building and Construction Trades Department, AFL-CIO, CPWR serves as the research arm of the BCTD. Since the inception of its research agenda in 1990, CPWR has grown into a worldwide provider of safety and health information covering all aspects of the construction industry. CPWR launched eLCOSH in 2000, and the Spanish-language version of the site in 2001. CPWR also created, and continues to build, Construction Solutions - www.cpwrConstructionSolutions.org - a free, online database of construction hazards and ways to prevent, eliminate, or reduce them. [comments:protected] => [logo_available:protected] => T [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => 2000-08-18 [date_completed:protected] => 2000-08-30 [date_billed:protected] => 2000-09-05 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [collections:protected] => Array ( [3913] => ) [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => Array ( [1874] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1874 [old_id:protected] => 722 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000683 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Sharon Garber/COD [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Protecting Tuckpointing Workers from Silica Dust: Draft Recommendations for a Ventilated Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 12 [billed_pages:protected] => 12 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, vacuum, grinder, mortar, respirator, OSHA, NIOSH, exhaust, Heitbrink, tuckpointer, silica, masonry, dust, silicosis, LEV [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Describes draft recommendations for use of ventilated grinder to reduce dust during tuckpointing and describes field trials using these devices. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/hazard/67/chip-scrape-and-grind-surfaces-or-joints-silica.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001201,d000292,d000293,d000658 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2005 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/27/05 [date_completed:protected] => 04/26/05 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/20/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [1940] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1940 [old_id:protected] => 909 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Workplace Solutions: Control of Hazardous Dust During Tuckpointing [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, silica, dust, tuckpoint, grinder, masonry restoration, mortar, vacuum [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d000819,d000820,d000730,d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 10/24/08 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/09 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [2213] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 2213 [old_id:protected] => 1090 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => [language_id:protected] => 2 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Control del polvo peligroso que se genera durante los procesos de reparación de mortero [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => 2008-126 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => [comments:protected] => http://www.cdc.gov/spanish/niosh/docs/wp-solutions/2008-126_sp/ [summary:protected] => A Workplace Solutions de NIOSH que resume un estudio de NIOSH sobre los riesgos de exposición cuando se reparan las estructuras y los métodos para controlar el polvo. [A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust.] [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => D000819,D000820,D000730,d000819 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 01/07/10 [date_completed:protected] => 04/19/10 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 07/08/12 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [3656] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3656 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001198 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 24 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction While Doing Tuckpointing/Mortar Removal [total_pages:protected] => 2 [billed_pages:protected] => 2 [publication_number:protected] => DSG FS-3632 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Brick, block, tuckpointing, silica, local exhaust ventilation, LEV, masonry [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Tuckpointing creates some of the greatest exposures to silica in construction. This OSHA factsheet provides guidance on how to greatly reduce these exposures through the use of local exhaust ventilation. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863, d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => February 2013 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/04/13 [date_completed:protected] => 03/27/13 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [3899] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3899 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001342 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: Hilti VC40-U Vacuum with Hilti DC-EX Dust Guard and Hilti Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 15 [billed_pages:protected] => 15 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP4 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => silica, tuckpointing, Hilti, local exhaust systems, LEV, shroud, quartz [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This report describes the results of an evaluation of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Hilti VC40-U vacuum, a Hilti DC-EX shroud, and a Hilti DAG-500 grinder. Randomized trials with and without use of the dust control system were conducted in a controlled setting. Removing mortar with the Hilti grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 220 times the National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05mg/m3. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 97 percent. However, exposures measured during the use of the dust control system still exceeded the NIOSH REL. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => December 1, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/05/14 [date_completed:protected] => 02/04/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/06/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [content:protected] => [files:protected] => Array ( [559] => [560] => [546] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 546 [filename:protected] => 3.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:22 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [566] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 566 [filename:protected] => 4.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:23 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [720] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 720 [filename:protected] => 5.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [721] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 721 [filename:protected] => 6.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [722] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 722 [filename:protected] => 7.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [9765] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 9765 [filename:protected] => d001345.pdf [downloadable:protected] => T [timestamp:protected] => 2015-02-09 12:26:04 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3908 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001345 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: DustControl 2900c Vacuum with the ICS Dust Director Shroud and Bosch Grinder Model 1775E Conducted November 14-15, 2012 [total_pages:protected] => 13 [billed_pages:protected] => 13 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP2 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => tuckpointing, HEPA vacuum, dust control, LEV, local exhaust ventilation, silica [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => April 15, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 01/26/15 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/09/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [show_text] => [document_content] => ElcoshItemDocumentContent Object ( [id:protected] => 2934 [item_id:protected] => 3908 [type:protected] => main [title:protected] => [content:protected] =>
Executive Summary
This report describes the results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. It should also be noted that the NIOSH REL is based on exposures averaged over a ten hour work day and our results represent time weighted averages of the sample task duration periods.
Acronyms
ACGIH - American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists
CPWR - CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training
Ce - coefficient of entry
HEPA - high-efficiency particulate air
IUBAC - International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craftworkers
LEV - local exhaust ventilation
PACT - Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies
NIOSH - National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health
OEL - occupational exposure limit
OSHA - Occupational Safety and Health Administration
PAPR - powered air-purifying respirator
PEL - Permissible Exposure Limit
PVC - polyvinyl chloride
REL - Recommended Exposure Limit
RPM - revolutions per minute
TWA - time-weighted average
SP - static pressure
I. Introduction and Background
In 2010 CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training began a four-year project which seeks to identify and evaluate tuckpointing local exhaust ventilation (LEV) systems and disseminate information on their availability and effectiveness. A Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies (PACT) comprised of masonry contractors, representatives from unions, government, equipment manufacturers, and health and safety researcher was formed as part of this project. PACT members participated in identifying important characteristics for control technologies and this information was used to identify LEV systems for tuckpointing using that criteria. Contractor and labor members of the PACT selected specific tuckpointing LEV systems to be considered for evaluation. Each system consisted of a tuckpointing grinder, shroud, and vacuum. This report describes the second of four systems to be evaluated between 2012 the end of 2014, with and without LEV, in a controlled setting to determine effectiveness in silica exposure reduction. This report describes the methods and results of our evaluation of a system consisting of the DustControl 2900c vacuum with the ICS Dust Director shroud and a Bosch Model 1775E grinder.
Excessive exposure to respirable silica can result in silicosis or other silica-related diseases including pulmonary tuberculosis, lung cancer, silicoproteinosis (Lyons et al, 2007) and autoimmune disorders such as rheumatoid arthritis, sarcoidosis and scleroderma (Miller et al, 2012). Respirable silica is generally defined as particles less than 10 micrometers (μm) in aerodynamic diameter (ACGIH, 2013). Silicosis can lead to symptoms including shortness of breath, fatigue, chest pains, susceptibility to infection and possibly death. There is no cure for silicosis, however it is totally preventable. Construction workers exposed to dust, including silica, are also known to have higher rates of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD).
There are many sources of silica in construction that result in exposures of varying intensity among workers. Masonry restoration workers are among the most highly silica-exposed trades in construction. The process of grinding out deteriorated mortar joints between masonry units and replacing or repointing with fresh mortar (often referred to as tuckpointing) is a fundamental part of masonry restoration work. The removal of mortar with powered angle grinders generates enormous levels of dust. Between 2004 and 2006, NIOSH and CPWR evaluated silica exposures while grinding mortar in a controlled setting, at a local training center, where tasks, sample times and task variables were defined by the study design. These studies demonstrated that grinding mortar without controls can result in elevated respirable silica exposures. Meeker et al., (2009) reported exposures between 5 and 25.8 milligrams per cubic meter (mg/m3) in a controlled setting. This study also showed that LEV systems for tuckpointing grinders can reduce exposures to respirable silica by greater than 90 percent.II. Objectives
The objective of this evaluation was to assess the effectiveness of an LEV system for controlling exposure to silica during the grinding of mortar. The control technology was tested under controlled conditions, similar to those experienced by tuckpointers on actual job sites, using journeymen bricklayers experienced in tuckpointing and repeat, randomized trials with and without LEV. All other variables were held constant throughout so that the only variable was whether or not the tested control was used.
III. Description of Equipment Tested
A Bosch model 1775E grinder (Robert Bosch Tool Corporation, Prospect, IL) (Figures 1, 2 and 3) was fitted with a new 1/4-inch wide, 4½-inch diameter segmented diamond abrasive blade made by DeWalt (model #DW4740). The grinder weighs six and a half pounds, draws 8.5 amps and has a variable speed up to 11,000 revolutions per minute (RPMs). The DustControl 2900c vacuum (DustControl, Inc., Wilmington, NC) (Figure 3) was tested in combination with the Dust Director shroud (Industrial Contractors’ Supplies, Inc., Huntingdon, PA) (Figures 1 and 3) attached to the Bosch grinder.
Figure 1. Bosch grinder with Dust Director shroud
Figure 2. Bosch grinder without tuckpointing LEV system.
Figure 3: Bosch Grinder with LEV System
The vacuum is specified to weigh 31 pounds when empty and to provide a flow rate of 114 cubic feet of air per minute and a “static lift” or “vacuum suction pressure” of 84 inches of water. The vacuum is sold with a cyclonic pre-separator, to remove larger particles, a fine filter (rated 99.9 percent efficient) and a HEPA (high-efficiency particulate air) filter (rated to capture 99.97 percent of the particles with an aerodynamic diameter of 0.3 micrometers). The HEPA filter was removed based on the manufacturer’s recommendation due to the heavy dust loading associated with tuckpointing. CPWR sponsored research and contractor experience indicate that HEPA filters likely have an adverse effect on dust capture during tuckpointing because of extreme dust loading on filters. While the cyclone and the fine filter remove most of the dust, especially the large particles, before they reach the HEPA filter, the HEPA filter would still be subject to heavy loading, causing a substantial pressure drop and subsequent decrease in air flow rate. The relatively small increase in the efficiency of the filtration system while using the HEPA filter is expected to be quickly offset by a more significant decrease in capture efficiency as the air flow rate and ability to capture particles decreases.
Dust collects in relatively inexpensive, heavy-gauge plastic bags below and outside of the cyclone. The bags can be removed and replaced without opening the vacuum. Some vacuums are equipped with a light to indicate that the filters need to be cleaned or changed. The DC2900c features a “reverse air pulse cleaning system,” which removes accumulated dust from the filters without having to remove them from the vacuum. The system, as illustrated in Figure 4, requires the operator to disconnect the hose from the shroud, place it over an air stop so that air through the hose is cut off and pressure in the vacuum is maximized.
Figure 4. Procedure for "cleaning" of or dust removal from filters (source: http://dustcontrolusa.com/manuals/2800c.pdf)
The flap covering the port on the side of the vacuum is repeatedly flipped open to release built up pressure in strong pulses that dislodge dust from the filter.
The manufacturer indicates “the filter is generally cleaned once or twice daily during normal continuous operation.” The Dust Director shroud has a 2-inch diameter take-off that was connected to the antistatic, corrugated 1.5-inch diameter, 15-foot long vacuum hose supplied with the DustControl vacuum.
IV. Study Methods
This evaluation was conducted at the International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craft workers (IUBAC) Local 1 Philadelphia/Delaware Training Center in Philadelphia, PA on November 14 and 15, 2012. A single journeyman bricklayer, experienced in tuckpointing, used the grinder and LEV system being tested to remove mortar from joints wide enough to require two passes. The type S mortar had been allowed to cure for at least four weeks. The bricklayer either possessed or was provided with personal protective equipment including sturdy work boots, gloves, hearing protection and a powered air-purifying respirator (PAPR). The PAPR was a 3M GVP system with a bump cap, loose fitting face piece and a HEPA filter (3M, St Paul, MN).
The study was designed to include at least five rounds of sampling during mortar removal. Each round included a trial using the Bosch grinder with a Dust Director shroud and Dust Collector 2900c vacuum and a trial using the Bosch grinder with the factory-supplied guard and without a vacuum. The order of the two trials within each round was randomly selected to minimize bias that might be introduced due to variation associated with environmental factors, equipment operator, blade wear, vacuum performance over time and any other factors unrelated to LEV use. Tools were operated for approximately 16 minutes per trial with controls and for approximately 8 minutes when controls were not used. These times were selected based on the results of previous sampling efforts and estimates of the minimum sample time needed to achieve a limit of quantification low enough to accurately measure exposures down to or less than 0.05 mg/m3 – the NIOSH Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) for respirable silica. The bricklayer was required to take a 5 to 10 minute break in the middle of the 16-minute trials to reduce differences in fatigue, compared to the 8-minute trials. Personal air samples were collected in the breathing zone of the operator during each trial to measure respirable silica concentrations during grinding with and without LEV. The samples were collected using a GilAir-5 pump (Sensidyne, Inc., Clearwater, FL) to draw 4.2 liters of air per minute through a GK2.69 Respirable Cyclone (BGI Inc., Waltham, MA) with a pre-weighed, 37 mm diameter, 5-micron pore size polyvinyl chloride (PVC) filter positioned on the operator’s lapel.
The flow rates of the sampling pumps were calibrated at the beginning of each day using a DryCal DC-Lite Primary Flow Meter (Bios International Corporation, Butler, NJ). Flow rates were measured again near the middle and at the end of each day to ensure that sampling flow rates were maintained within 5% of pre-sampling flow rates throughout the day. Average flow rates were used to calculate sample air volumes. Samples were analyzed by R.J. Lee Group, Inc., (Monroeville, PA) using NIOSH Method 0600, to determine exposure to total mass of respirable dust. The same samples were also analyzed using X-Ray diffraction following NIOSH method 7500 to determine quartz, cristobalite and tridymite concentration in the respirable mass. Reported masses for these analytes were used with the sample air volumes to calculate airborne concentrations of total respirable dust, quartz, cristobalite and tridymite.
We used a reduction of greater than 50 percent in respirable silica exposure concentrations or a reduction to less than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 as our criteria for determining whether or not a control was considered efficacious. This is consistent with criteria used by NIOSH in conducting a similar study in 2004 described by Echt et al. (2007) and by CPWR in 2006 and described by Meeker et al. (2009). The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) and the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) publish additional occupational exposure limits (OELs) for silica which are listed in Table 1 with NIOSH RELs. OELs for silica are based on the respirable fraction of the aerosol, which consists of particles less than 10 micrometers in aerodynamic diameter.
| Organization or Agency | Form of Crystalline Silica | Occupational Exposure Limits (mg/m3) |
|---|---|---|
| NIOSHA | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 |
| OSHA - ConstructionB | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
PEL = 250 / (5 + % quartz) PEL = 250 / (5 + % cristobalite) PEL = 250 / (5 + % tridymite) |
| ACGIH | Crystalline Silica | TLV = 0.025 mg/m3 |
A NIOSH Publication No. 2005-151 indicates 10-hour time-weighted average during a 40-hr workweek B The PEL for silica in OSHA’s Safety and Health Regulations for Construction, 29 C.F.R. 1926.55(a), is an 8-hour time-weighted average (TWA) expressed in millions of particles per cubic foot (mppcf). However, the units mppcf can be converted to milligrams per cubic meter can by dividing mppcf by 10 (OSHA, 2009). The formula used by OSHA to determine the PEL for silica is dependent on the percentage of silica in each collected sample. The concentration of respirable dust measured is compared to the sample specific PEL to determine if the PEL has been exceeded. OSHA has proposed lowering the PEL to 0.05 mg/m3 of respirable silica as an 8 hour TWA. |
||
The flow of air in ventilation systems is governed by fundamental principles that describe the behavior of gases (in this case air). Pressure measurements taken within a ventilation system along with knowledge of hood (or shroud) entry losses can be used to calculate flow rates. Hood entry losses are dependent on the shape and configuration of a particular hood or shroud and described by the term “coefficient of entry (Ce)” which is the ratio of actual air flow through a hood and what the air flow would theoretically be if there were no hood entry losses. Given the coefficient of entry, static pressure measurements can be used to calculate air flow through a given hood. The coefficient of entry for the Dust Director shroud was previously determined by CPWR and used for calculating air flow based on static pressure measurements (Meeker et al., 2009). Static pressure, with the vacuum operating, was measured periodically throughout the evaluation to monitor the changes in air-flow rate following use and again after filter cleaning. The static pressure was measured at a port positioned more than 3 duct diameters downstream from the tool’s air intake using a UEi EM200 Electronic Manometer (Universal Enterprises, Inc., Beaverton, OR).
The dust in the vacuum bag was monitored and, per the manufacturer’s instructions, the bag was changed before the dust level was within 5 centimeters of the valve at the bottom of the vacuum. Each time a vacuum bag was removed, it was weighed to the nearest pound. The bag weights and corresponding grinding durations were used to calculate the average weight of dust collected per unit time. After each trial, cut lengths were measured on the wall to determine total linear feet of vertical (head) and horizontal (bed) joints per unit time.
A Haz-Dust III, Model HD-1003, Real-Time Aerosol Monitor (Environmental Devices Corporation, Plaistow, NH) was used to confirm clearance of dust between trials. The Haz-Dust monitor was positioned on the test wall near the operator at approximately breathing zone level and configured to measure respirable particulate concentration.
V. Results
Personal air monitoring
Five pairs of respirable dust samples were collected while grinding with and without the vacuum system. In addition, three respirable dust samples were collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place. One measurement collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard was shown to be a statistical outlier and was omitted from analysis. Personal air monitoring results for respirable silica and a comparison of average exposures relative to the NIOSH REL for silica (0.05 mg/m3) appears in Table 2. The mean respirable dust levels measured without LEV was 31.4 mg/m3. However, samples collected with LEV were below the limit of quantification (LOQ) which ranged from <1.29 to <1.46 mg/m3. Use of LEV resulted in a greater than 95% reduction in mean respirable dust levels using a mean value with use of LEV of <1.41 (n=5 samples with use of LEV and n=7 without use of LEV). The respirable dust samples collected during grinding without the LEV system contained an average of 24 percent silica. The mass of respirable dust in the samples collected with use of the LEV system was too low to determine the silica content.| Mean, mg/m3 (range) | Std. Dev. | Percent Reduction | Hazard RatioB | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bosch with Dust Director Shroud and DustControl 2900c Vacuum |
0.091 (<0.069 – 0.137) |
0.027 | 98.7 | 1.81 |
| Bosch with no Control | 7.23 (4.57 – 9.90) |
1.94 | NA | 145 |
A n = 5 samples for each tool/control combination and n = 7 samples without the use of the LEV system B Hazard Ratio = measured exposure / NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 |
||||
Average respirable silica and dust exposures, with and without the dust control system, appear as Figures 5 and 6, respectively.
Figure 5. Average respirable silica exposures with and without the Dustcontrol 2900c vacuum and Dust Director shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air - mg/m3)
Figure 6. Average respirable dust exposures with and without Dustcontrol 2900c Vacuum and Dust Director Shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air – mg/m3)
The mean respirable silica concentration measured during use of the control was significantly less than the concentration measured while using the same tool without controls (p<0.01). Grinding mortar with the Bosch angle grinder without dust controls resulted in an average exposure to respirable silica that was 145 times the NIOSH REL. Grinding with the Bosch angle grinder in combination with the Dust Director shroud and the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced the average concentration of respirable silica by 98.7 percent. With use of these controls, the concentration of respirable silica was 1.8 times greater than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3. However the NIOSH REL is based on a time-weighted average (TWA) over a 10-hour workday. Given these were task TWAs and samples were collected over continuous periods of grinding, they may overestimate exposures over an actual work day since some time would be spent performing tasks that would likely have lower, or no, silica exposures (setup, breaks, cleanup, etc.).
Static pressure, dust mass collection and grinding rates.
Static pressure was used as a surrogate for air flow as described earlier. Hood static pressure was measured periodically at a tap near the grinder more than 3 duct diameters from the air intake in the shroud. The static pressure, and thus air flow, was generally higher when the vacuum’s filter had recently been cleaned. The mean, median, and range of calculated flow rates are presented in Table A1 of the Appendix.
Based on the data we collected, the air-flow rate upstream from the Bosch grinder and Dust Director shroud ranged from 78 to 93 cubic feet per minute (cfm) with the DustControl vacuum. When the manufacturer’s filter cleaning procedure was followed the vacuum performed relatively well and flow could be maintained at slightly less than 90 cfm with cleaning. However, mean flow rates dropped substantially to 80 cfm after as little as 8 minutes of grinding without any filter cleaning. The flow rate returned to an average of 89 cfm when filters were cleaned correctly (without stopping air flow to the vacuum). Collingwood and Heitbrink (2007) found that the minimum exhaust flow rate for capture of silica and other particulate under ideal conditions is 21.25 cfm per inch of grinder blade diameter. This is equal to about 96 cfm when using a 4.5 inch diameter grinding blade. We set 106 cfm as the minimum desired flow rate for this study to allow a safety margin for potential decline in equipment performance and the possibility of inadequate maintenance, both of which may be likely after repeated use under actual work conditions. The DustControl vacuum provided slightly less than the minimum flow rate described by Collingwood and Heitbrink for a 4.5-inch blade and the peak flow rate fell with use.
The duration of vacuum bag use and mass of dust collected were recorded and are presented in Table A2 of the Appendix. The vacuum bags were changed and weighed after each trial utilizing the LEV system. A total of five bags were used to complete the five rounds of grinding. The DustControl vacuum captured 45 pounds of dust over 83 minutes of grinding for an average rate of dust collection of 0.54 pounds per minute. The rate of dust collection ranged from 0.47 to 0.63 pounds per minute. Based on these measurements, approximately 130 pounds of dust would likely be captured after just 4 hours of continuous grinding.
The rate of grinding a combination of vertical and horizontal joints while using the LEV system ranged from 2.3 to 3.3 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the use of the LEV system ranged from 2.6 to 3.4 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place ranged from 4.7 to 5.1 feet per minute. It’s important to note that: 1) the operator had limited experience using dust control systems and cut rates appeared to improve slightly over the 2-day period he used the tested equipment; and 2) the upper range of cut rates with the dust control system overlapped with the lowest cut rate with the original guard and without the LEV system in place indicating no statistical difference between cut rates. Given that grinding rates with and without use of this LEV system are only available for one operator and he had limited experience with the LEV system, these reported cut rates are in no way intended to represent the impact use of this LEV system is likely to have on productivity rates overall.
VI. Discussion
The objective of these trials was to evaluate the effectiveness of a tuckpointing LEV system for controlling respirable silica while grinding out mortar joints. The Dust Director shroud with the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced respirable silica concentrations when grinding with the Bosch grinder by approximately 99 percent. Despite being considered effective by our test criteria (greater than 50% reduction), it still resulted in task TWA exposures that exceeded the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 by 1.8 times. Depending on how much time is spent grinding over the course of a work day and on exposures while performing other tasks, the 8-hour TWA exposures may or may not exceed the REL with this system. Use of this system by workers with experience and training in proficient use will likely improve dust capture performance. Exposure reduction is greatly influenced by correct use of this system which includes grinding from right to left, making sure the shroud is held flush against the wall and that the tool travels at a pace that doesn’t exceed the ability of the system to capture dust as it’s generated. Deviation from any of these measures produces visible dust clouds which were observed during trials.
VII. Conclusions
With a 99 percent reduction in respirable silica exposure, the Dust Director shroud and DustControl 2900c vacuum with a Bosch Model 1775E grinder was effective in reducing silica exposures based on our criteria. Use of the tested dust control system may be effective in reducing silica exposure on the job to less than the NIOSH REL if used in combination with administrative controls such as work scheduling to reduce cutting times as needed. Training on correct use of the tested system is also essential. Personal air monitoring is necessary to verify control effectiveness on actual job sites and under “real-world” conditions. However, these results clearly demonstrate the availability of viable and effective engineering controls for tuckpointing operations associated with elevated silica exposure.
VIII. References
American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists. Threshold limit values for chemical substances (TLV®-CS). [2013]. ACGIH, Cincinnati, Ohio.
Bergdahl I.A,. Toren K., Eriksson K., et al. [2004]. Increased mortality in COPD among construction workers exposed to inorganic dust. European Respiratory Journal, 23: 402–06.
Blanc P.D. & Torén K. [2007]. Occupation in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and chronic bronchitis: an update [State of the Art Series. Occupational lung disease in high-and low-income countries, Edited by M. Chan-Yeung. Number 2 in the series]. The International Journal of Tuberculosis and Lung Disease, 11(3), 251-257.
Collingwood S. & Heitbrink W.A. [2007] 'Field Evaluation of an Engineering Control for Respirable Crystalline Silica Exposures During Mortar Removal'. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, 4:11, 875 – 887.
DHHS (NIOSH) Publication No. 2002-129 April 2002 http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/2002-129/
Echt A., Sieber W.K., Lefkowitz D., Meeker J., Susi P., Cardwell B., Heitbrink, W.A. In-depth survey of dust control technology for cutting concrete block and tuckpointing brick at The International Masonry Institute Bordentown Training Center, Bordentown, NJ. Cincinnati, OH: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Report. No. EPHB 282-13; 2007. http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ECTB-282-13.pdf
Heitbrink W., Bennett J. [2006]. A numerical and experimental investigation of crystalline silica exposure control during tuck pointing. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, Vol. 3, pp 366-378.
Lyons et al, [2007]. A breathless builder. Breathe, Vol. 3, no. 4, pp 386-390.
Mastrangelo G., Tartari M., Fedeli U., Fadda E., Saia B. [2003]. Ascertaining the risk of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease in relation to occupation using a case-control design. Occupational Medicine, 53: 165–172.
Meeker J., Cooper M., Lefrowitz D., Susi P. [2009]. Engineering control technologies to reduce occupational silica exposures in masonry cutting and tuckpointing. Public Health Reports, Supplement 1, Vol. 124, June.
Meeker J, Flynn M, Susi P, Cardwell, B [2004]. Performance evaluation of a masonry concrete vacuum. Unpublished Report.
Miller F. W., Alfredsson L., Costenbader K. H., Kamen D. L., Nelson L. M., Norris J. M., & De Roos A. J. [2012]. Epidemiology of environmental exposures and human autoimmune diseases: findings from a National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences Expert Panel workshop. Journal of autoimmunity. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3496812/
Occupational Safety and Health Administration U.S Department of Labor. Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction. [2009]. OSHA 3362-05.
Rappaport SM, Goldberg M, Susi P, Herrick RF [2003]. Excessive exposure to silica in the U.S. construction industry. Annals of Occupational Hygiene, Vol. 47, pp. 111-122.
IX. Appendices
| Measurement Conditions |
n | Mean Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Median
Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before filter cleaning | 5 | 80 | 81 | 78-81 |
| After filter cleaning following manufacturer directions | 9 | 89 | 90 | 84-93 |
| * Static pressure was measured in millibars and converted to inches of water gauge. Flow rates were calculated using the formula Q = Ce (A) 4005 (SP)1/2 where: Q = flow in cubic feet per minute (cfm), Ce = coefficient of entry, A = area of the duct where static pressure measurements were taken in square feet, and SP = static pressure in inches of water gauge. | ||||
| Tool/Control | Collection Period (min.) |
Dust Collection Rate (lb/min.) |
|---|---|---|
| Bosch grinder/Dust Director shroud & DustControl 2900c vacuum |
8 11 8 8 10 |
0.50 0.61 0.50 0.47 0.63 |
| Average | 0.54 |
[content_transformed:protected] =>
Executive Summary
This report describes the results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. It should also be noted that the NIOSH REL is based on exposures averaged over a ten hour work day and our results represent time weighted averages of the sample task duration periods.
Acronyms
ACGIH - American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists
CPWR - CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training
Ce - coefficient of entry
HEPA - high-efficiency particulate air
IUBAC - International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craftworkers
LEV - local exhaust ventilation
PACT - Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies
NIOSH - National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health
OEL - occupational exposure limit
OSHA - Occupational Safety and Health Administration
PAPR - powered air-purifying respirator
PEL - Permissible Exposure Limit
PVC - polyvinyl chloride
REL - Recommended Exposure Limit
RPM - revolutions per minute
TWA - time-weighted average
SP - static pressure
I. Introduction and Background
In 2010 CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training began a four-year project which seeks to identify and evaluate tuckpointing local exhaust ventilation (LEV) systems and disseminate information on their availability and effectiveness. A Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies (PACT) comprised of masonry contractors, representatives from unions, government, equipment manufacturers, and health and safety researcher was formed as part of this project. PACT members participated in identifying important characteristics for control technologies and this information was used to identify LEV systems for tuckpointing using that criteria. Contractor and labor members of the PACT selected specific tuckpointing LEV systems to be considered for evaluation. Each system consisted of a tuckpointing grinder, shroud, and vacuum. This report describes the second of four systems to be evaluated between 2012 the end of 2014, with and without LEV, in a controlled setting to determine effectiveness in silica exposure reduction. This report describes the methods and results of our evaluation of a system consisting of the DustControl 2900c vacuum with the ICS Dust Director shroud and a Bosch Model 1775E grinder.
Excessive exposure to respirable silica can result in silicosis or other silica-related diseases including pulmonary tuberculosis, lung cancer, silicoproteinosis (Lyons et al, 2007) and autoimmune disorders such as rheumatoid arthritis, sarcoidosis and scleroderma (Miller et al, 2012). Respirable silica is generally defined as particles less than 10 micrometers (μm) in aerodynamic diameter (ACGIH, 2013). Silicosis can lead to symptoms including shortness of breath, fatigue, chest pains, susceptibility to infection and possibly death. There is no cure for silicosis, however it is totally preventable. Construction workers exposed to dust, including silica, are also known to have higher rates of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD).
There are many sources of silica in construction that result in exposures of varying intensity among workers. Masonry restoration workers are among the most highly silica-exposed trades in construction. The process of grinding out deteriorated mortar joints between masonry units and replacing or repointing with fresh mortar (often referred to as tuckpointing) is a fundamental part of masonry restoration work. The removal of mortar with powered angle grinders generates enormous levels of dust. Between 2004 and 2006, NIOSH and CPWR evaluated silica exposures while grinding mortar in a controlled setting, at a local training center, where tasks, sample times and task variables were defined by the study design. These studies demonstrated that grinding mortar without controls can result in elevated respirable silica exposures. Meeker et al., (2009) reported exposures between 5 and 25.8 milligrams per cubic meter (mg/m3) in a controlled setting. This study also showed that LEV systems for tuckpointing grinders can reduce exposures to respirable silica by greater than 90 percent.II. Objectives
The objective of this evaluation was to assess the effectiveness of an LEV system for controlling exposure to silica during the grinding of mortar. The control technology was tested under controlled conditions, similar to those experienced by tuckpointers on actual job sites, using journeymen bricklayers experienced in tuckpointing and repeat, randomized trials with and without LEV. All other variables were held constant throughout so that the only variable was whether or not the tested control was used.
III. Description of Equipment Tested
A Bosch model 1775E grinder (Robert Bosch Tool Corporation, Prospect, IL) (Figures 1, 2 and 3) was fitted with a new 1/4-inch wide, 4½-inch diameter segmented diamond abrasive blade made by DeWalt (model #DW4740). The grinder weighs six and a half pounds, draws 8.5 amps and has a variable speed up to 11,000 revolutions per minute (RPMs). The DustControl 2900c vacuum (DustControl, Inc., Wilmington, NC) (Figure 3) was tested in combination with the Dust Director shroud (Industrial Contractors’ Supplies, Inc., Huntingdon, PA) (Figures 1 and 3) attached to the Bosch grinder.
Figure 1. Bosch grinder with Dust Director shroud
Figure 2. Bosch grinder without tuckpointing LEV system.
Figure 3: Bosch Grinder with LEV System
The vacuum is specified to weigh 31 pounds when empty and to provide a flow rate of 114 cubic feet of air per minute and a “static lift” or “vacuum suction pressure” of 84 inches of water. The vacuum is sold with a cyclonic pre-separator, to remove larger particles, a fine filter (rated 99.9 percent efficient) and a HEPA (high-efficiency particulate air) filter (rated to capture 99.97 percent of the particles with an aerodynamic diameter of 0.3 micrometers). The HEPA filter was removed based on the manufacturer’s recommendation due to the heavy dust loading associated with tuckpointing. CPWR sponsored research and contractor experience indicate that HEPA filters likely have an adverse effect on dust capture during tuckpointing because of extreme dust loading on filters. While the cyclone and the fine filter remove most of the dust, especially the large particles, before they reach the HEPA filter, the HEPA filter would still be subject to heavy loading, causing a substantial pressure drop and subsequent decrease in air flow rate. The relatively small increase in the efficiency of the filtration system while using the HEPA filter is expected to be quickly offset by a more significant decrease in capture efficiency as the air flow rate and ability to capture particles decreases.
Dust collects in relatively inexpensive, heavy-gauge plastic bags below and outside of the cyclone. The bags can be removed and replaced without opening the vacuum. Some vacuums are equipped with a light to indicate that the filters need to be cleaned or changed. The DC2900c features a “reverse air pulse cleaning system,” which removes accumulated dust from the filters without having to remove them from the vacuum. The system, as illustrated in Figure 4, requires the operator to disconnect the hose from the shroud, place it over an air stop so that air through the hose is cut off and pressure in the vacuum is maximized.
Figure 4. Procedure for "cleaning" of or dust removal from filters (source: http://dustcontrolusa.com/manuals/2800c.pdf)
The flap covering the port on the side of the vacuum is repeatedly flipped open to release built up pressure in strong pulses that dislodge dust from the filter.
The manufacturer indicates “the filter is generally cleaned once or twice daily during normal continuous operation.” The Dust Director shroud has a 2-inch diameter take-off that was connected to the antistatic, corrugated 1.5-inch diameter, 15-foot long vacuum hose supplied with the DustControl vacuum.
IV. Study Methods
This evaluation was conducted at the International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craft workers (IUBAC) Local 1 Philadelphia/Delaware Training Center in Philadelphia, PA on November 14 and 15, 2012. A single journeyman bricklayer, experienced in tuckpointing, used the grinder and LEV system being tested to remove mortar from joints wide enough to require two passes. The type S mortar had been allowed to cure for at least four weeks. The bricklayer either possessed or was provided with personal protective equipment including sturdy work boots, gloves, hearing protection and a powered air-purifying respirator (PAPR). The PAPR was a 3M GVP system with a bump cap, loose fitting face piece and a HEPA filter (3M, St Paul, MN).
The study was designed to include at least five rounds of sampling during mortar removal. Each round included a trial using the Bosch grinder with a Dust Director shroud and Dust Collector 2900c vacuum and a trial using the Bosch grinder with the factory-supplied guard and without a vacuum. The order of the two trials within each round was randomly selected to minimize bias that might be introduced due to variation associated with environmental factors, equipment operator, blade wear, vacuum performance over time and any other factors unrelated to LEV use. Tools were operated for approximately 16 minutes per trial with controls and for approximately 8 minutes when controls were not used. These times were selected based on the results of previous sampling efforts and estimates of the minimum sample time needed to achieve a limit of quantification low enough to accurately measure exposures down to or less than 0.05 mg/m3 – the NIOSH Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) for respirable silica. The bricklayer was required to take a 5 to 10 minute break in the middle of the 16-minute trials to reduce differences in fatigue, compared to the 8-minute trials. Personal air samples were collected in the breathing zone of the operator during each trial to measure respirable silica concentrations during grinding with and without LEV. The samples were collected using a GilAir-5 pump (Sensidyne, Inc., Clearwater, FL) to draw 4.2 liters of air per minute through a GK2.69 Respirable Cyclone (BGI Inc., Waltham, MA) with a pre-weighed, 37 mm diameter, 5-micron pore size polyvinyl chloride (PVC) filter positioned on the operator’s lapel.
The flow rates of the sampling pumps were calibrated at the beginning of each day using a DryCal DC-Lite Primary Flow Meter (Bios International Corporation, Butler, NJ). Flow rates were measured again near the middle and at the end of each day to ensure that sampling flow rates were maintained within 5% of pre-sampling flow rates throughout the day. Average flow rates were used to calculate sample air volumes. Samples were analyzed by R.J. Lee Group, Inc., (Monroeville, PA) using NIOSH Method 0600, to determine exposure to total mass of respirable dust. The same samples were also analyzed using X-Ray diffraction following NIOSH method 7500 to determine quartz, cristobalite and tridymite concentration in the respirable mass. Reported masses for these analytes were used with the sample air volumes to calculate airborne concentrations of total respirable dust, quartz, cristobalite and tridymite.
We used a reduction of greater than 50 percent in respirable silica exposure concentrations or a reduction to less than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 as our criteria for determining whether or not a control was considered efficacious. This is consistent with criteria used by NIOSH in conducting a similar study in 2004 described by Echt et al. (2007) and by CPWR in 2006 and described by Meeker et al. (2009). The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) and the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) publish additional occupational exposure limits (OELs) for silica which are listed in Table 1 with NIOSH RELs. OELs for silica are based on the respirable fraction of the aerosol, which consists of particles less than 10 micrometers in aerodynamic diameter.
| Organization or Agency | Form of Crystalline Silica | Occupational Exposure Limits (mg/m3) |
|---|---|---|
| NIOSHA | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 |
| OSHA - ConstructionB | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
PEL = 250 / (5 + % quartz) PEL = 250 / (5 + % cristobalite) PEL = 250 / (5 + % tridymite) |
| ACGIH | Crystalline Silica | TLV = 0.025 mg/m3 |
A NIOSH Publication No. 2005-151 indicates 10-hour time-weighted average during a 40-hr workweek B The PEL for silica in OSHA’s Safety and Health Regulations for Construction, 29 C.F.R. 1926.55(a), is an 8-hour time-weighted average (TWA) expressed in millions of particles per cubic foot (mppcf). However, the units mppcf can be converted to milligrams per cubic meter can by dividing mppcf by 10 (OSHA, 2009). The formula used by OSHA to determine the PEL for silica is dependent on the percentage of silica in each collected sample. The concentration of respirable dust measured is compared to the sample specific PEL to determine if the PEL has been exceeded. OSHA has proposed lowering the PEL to 0.05 mg/m3 of respirable silica as an 8 hour TWA. |
||
The flow of air in ventilation systems is governed by fundamental principles that describe the behavior of gases (in this case air). Pressure measurements taken within a ventilation system along with knowledge of hood (or shroud) entry losses can be used to calculate flow rates. Hood entry losses are dependent on the shape and configuration of a particular hood or shroud and described by the term “coefficient of entry (Ce)” which is the ratio of actual air flow through a hood and what the air flow would theoretically be if there were no hood entry losses. Given the coefficient of entry, static pressure measurements can be used to calculate air flow through a given hood. The coefficient of entry for the Dust Director shroud was previously determined by CPWR and used for calculating air flow based on static pressure measurements (Meeker et al., 2009). Static pressure, with the vacuum operating, was measured periodically throughout the evaluation to monitor the changes in air-flow rate following use and again after filter cleaning. The static pressure was measured at a port positioned more than 3 duct diameters downstream from the tool’s air intake using a UEi EM200 Electronic Manometer (Universal Enterprises, Inc., Beaverton, OR).
The dust in the vacuum bag was monitored and, per the manufacturer’s instructions, the bag was changed before the dust level was within 5 centimeters of the valve at the bottom of the vacuum. Each time a vacuum bag was removed, it was weighed to the nearest pound. The bag weights and corresponding grinding durations were used to calculate the average weight of dust collected per unit time. After each trial, cut lengths were measured on the wall to determine total linear feet of vertical (head) and horizontal (bed) joints per unit time.
A Haz-Dust III, Model HD-1003, Real-Time Aerosol Monitor (Environmental Devices Corporation, Plaistow, NH) was used to confirm clearance of dust between trials. The Haz-Dust monitor was positioned on the test wall near the operator at approximately breathing zone level and configured to measure respirable particulate concentration.
V. Results
Personal air monitoring
Five pairs of respirable dust samples were collected while grinding with and without the vacuum system. In addition, three respirable dust samples were collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place. One measurement collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard was shown to be a statistical outlier and was omitted from analysis. Personal air monitoring results for respirable silica and a comparison of average exposures relative to the NIOSH REL for silica (0.05 mg/m3) appears in Table 2. The mean respirable dust levels measured without LEV was 31.4 mg/m3. However, samples collected with LEV were below the limit of quantification (LOQ) which ranged from <1.29 to <1.46 mg/m3. Use of LEV resulted in a greater than 95% reduction in mean respirable dust levels using a mean value with use of LEV of <1.41 (n=5 samples with use of LEV and n=7 without use of LEV). The respirable dust samples collected during grinding without the LEV system contained an average of 24 percent silica. The mass of respirable dust in the samples collected with use of the LEV system was too low to determine the silica content.| Mean, mg/m3 (range) | Std. Dev. | Percent Reduction | Hazard RatioB | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bosch with Dust Director Shroud and DustControl 2900c Vacuum |
0.091 (<0.069 – 0.137) |
0.027 | 98.7 | 1.81 |
| Bosch with no Control | 7.23 (4.57 – 9.90) |
1.94 | NA | 145 |
A n = 5 samples for each tool/control combination and n = 7 samples without the use of the LEV system B Hazard Ratio = measured exposure / NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 |
||||
Average respirable silica and dust exposures, with and without the dust control system, appear as Figures 5 and 6, respectively.
Figure 5. Average respirable silica exposures with and without the Dustcontrol 2900c vacuum and Dust Director shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air - mg/m3)
Figure 6. Average respirable dust exposures with and without Dustcontrol 2900c Vacuum and Dust Director Shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air – mg/m3)
The mean respirable silica concentration measured during use of the control was significantly less than the concentration measured while using the same tool without controls (p<0.01). Grinding mortar with the Bosch angle grinder without dust controls resulted in an average exposure to respirable silica that was 145 times the NIOSH REL. Grinding with the Bosch angle grinder in combination with the Dust Director shroud and the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced the average concentration of respirable silica by 98.7 percent. With use of these controls, the concentration of respirable silica was 1.8 times greater than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3. However the NIOSH REL is based on a time-weighted average (TWA) over a 10-hour workday. Given these were task TWAs and samples were collected over continuous periods of grinding, they may overestimate exposures over an actual work day since some time would be spent performing tasks that would likely have lower, or no, silica exposures (setup, breaks, cleanup, etc.).
Static pressure, dust mass collection and grinding rates.
Static pressure was used as a surrogate for air flow as described earlier. Hood static pressure was measured periodically at a tap near the grinder more than 3 duct diameters from the air intake in the shroud. The static pressure, and thus air flow, was generally higher when the vacuum’s filter had recently been cleaned. The mean, median, and range of calculated flow rates are presented in Table A1 of the Appendix.
Based on the data we collected, the air-flow rate upstream from the Bosch grinder and Dust Director shroud ranged from 78 to 93 cubic feet per minute (cfm) with the DustControl vacuum. When the manufacturer’s filter cleaning procedure was followed the vacuum performed relatively well and flow could be maintained at slightly less than 90 cfm with cleaning. However, mean flow rates dropped substantially to 80 cfm after as little as 8 minutes of grinding without any filter cleaning. The flow rate returned to an average of 89 cfm when filters were cleaned correctly (without stopping air flow to the vacuum). Collingwood and Heitbrink (2007) found that the minimum exhaust flow rate for capture of silica and other particulate under ideal conditions is 21.25 cfm per inch of grinder blade diameter. This is equal to about 96 cfm when using a 4.5 inch diameter grinding blade. We set 106 cfm as the minimum desired flow rate for this study to allow a safety margin for potential decline in equipment performance and the possibility of inadequate maintenance, both of which may be likely after repeated use under actual work conditions. The DustControl vacuum provided slightly less than the minimum flow rate described by Collingwood and Heitbrink for a 4.5-inch blade and the peak flow rate fell with use.
The duration of vacuum bag use and mass of dust collected were recorded and are presented in Table A2 of the Appendix. The vacuum bags were changed and weighed after each trial utilizing the LEV system. A total of five bags were used to complete the five rounds of grinding. The DustControl vacuum captured 45 pounds of dust over 83 minutes of grinding for an average rate of dust collection of 0.54 pounds per minute. The rate of dust collection ranged from 0.47 to 0.63 pounds per minute. Based on these measurements, approximately 130 pounds of dust would likely be captured after just 4 hours of continuous grinding.
The rate of grinding a combination of vertical and horizontal joints while using the LEV system ranged from 2.3 to 3.3 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the use of the LEV system ranged from 2.6 to 3.4 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place ranged from 4.7 to 5.1 feet per minute. It’s important to note that: 1) the operator had limited experience using dust control systems and cut rates appeared to improve slightly over the 2-day period he used the tested equipment; and 2) the upper range of cut rates with the dust control system overlapped with the lowest cut rate with the original guard and without the LEV system in place indicating no statistical difference between cut rates. Given that grinding rates with and without use of this LEV system are only available for one operator and he had limited experience with the LEV system, these reported cut rates are in no way intended to represent the impact use of this LEV system is likely to have on productivity rates overall.
VI. Discussion
The objective of these trials was to evaluate the effectiveness of a tuckpointing LEV system for controlling respirable silica while grinding out mortar joints. The Dust Director shroud with the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced respirable silica concentrations when grinding with the Bosch grinder by approximately 99 percent. Despite being considered effective by our test criteria (greater than 50% reduction), it still resulted in task TWA exposures that exceeded the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 by 1.8 times. Depending on how much time is spent grinding over the course of a work day and on exposures while performing other tasks, the 8-hour TWA exposures may or may not exceed the REL with this system. Use of this system by workers with experience and training in proficient use will likely improve dust capture performance. Exposure reduction is greatly influenced by correct use of this system which includes grinding from right to left, making sure the shroud is held flush against the wall and that the tool travels at a pace that doesn’t exceed the ability of the system to capture dust as it’s generated. Deviation from any of these measures produces visible dust clouds which were observed during trials.
VII. Conclusions
With a 99 percent reduction in respirable silica exposure, the Dust Director shroud and DustControl 2900c vacuum with a Bosch Model 1775E grinder was effective in reducing silica exposures based on our criteria. Use of the tested dust control system may be effective in reducing silica exposure on the job to less than the NIOSH REL if used in combination with administrative controls such as work scheduling to reduce cutting times as needed. Training on correct use of the tested system is also essential. Personal air monitoring is necessary to verify control effectiveness on actual job sites and under “real-world” conditions. However, these results clearly demonstrate the availability of viable and effective engineering controls for tuckpointing operations associated with elevated silica exposure.
VIII. References
American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists. Threshold limit values for chemical substances (TLV®-CS). [2013]. ACGIH, Cincinnati, Ohio.
Bergdahl I.A,. Toren K., Eriksson K., et al. [2004]. Increased mortality in COPD among construction workers exposed to inorganic dust. European Respiratory Journal, 23: 402–06.
Blanc P.D. & Torén K. [2007]. Occupation in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and chronic bronchitis: an update [State of the Art Series. Occupational lung disease in high-and low-income countries, Edited by M. Chan-Yeung. Number 2 in the series]. The International Journal of Tuberculosis and Lung Disease, 11(3), 251-257.
Collingwood S. & Heitbrink W.A. [2007] 'Field Evaluation of an Engineering Control for Respirable Crystalline Silica Exposures During Mortar Removal'. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, 4:11, 875 – 887.
DHHS (NIOSH) Publication No. 2002-129 April 2002 http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/2002-129/
Echt A., Sieber W.K., Lefkowitz D., Meeker J., Susi P., Cardwell B., Heitbrink, W.A. In-depth survey of dust control technology for cutting concrete block and tuckpointing brick at The International Masonry Institute Bordentown Training Center, Bordentown, NJ. Cincinnati, OH: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Report. No. EPHB 282-13; 2007. http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ECTB-282-13.pdf
Heitbrink W., Bennett J. [2006]. A numerical and experimental investigation of crystalline silica exposure control during tuck pointing. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, Vol. 3, pp 366-378.
Lyons et al, [2007]. A breathless builder. Breathe, Vol. 3, no. 4, pp 386-390.
Mastrangelo G., Tartari M., Fedeli U., Fadda E., Saia B. [2003]. Ascertaining the risk of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease in relation to occupation using a case-control design. Occupational Medicine, 53: 165–172.
Meeker J., Cooper M., Lefrowitz D., Susi P. [2009]. Engineering control technologies to reduce occupational silica exposures in masonry cutting and tuckpointing. Public Health Reports, Supplement 1, Vol. 124, June.
Meeker J, Flynn M, Susi P, Cardwell, B [2004]. Performance evaluation of a masonry concrete vacuum. Unpublished Report.
Miller F. W., Alfredsson L., Costenbader K. H., Kamen D. L., Nelson L. M., Norris J. M., & De Roos A. J. [2012]. Epidemiology of environmental exposures and human autoimmune diseases: findings from a National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences Expert Panel workshop. Journal of autoimmunity. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3496812/
Occupational Safety and Health Administration U.S Department of Labor. Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction. [2009]. OSHA 3362-05.
Rappaport SM, Goldberg M, Susi P, Herrick RF [2003]. Excessive exposure to silica in the U.S. construction industry. Annals of Occupational Hygiene, Vol. 47, pp. 111-122.
IX. Appendices
| Measurement Conditions |
n | Mean Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Median
Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before filter cleaning | 5 | 80 | 81 | 78-81 |
| After filter cleaning following manufacturer directions | 9 | 89 | 90 | 84-93 |
| * Static pressure was measured in millibars and converted to inches of water gauge. Flow rates were calculated using the formula Q = Ce (A) 4005 (SP)1/2 where: Q = flow in cubic feet per minute (cfm), Ce = coefficient of entry, A = area of the duct where static pressure measurements were taken in square feet, and SP = static pressure in inches of water gauge. | ||||
| Tool/Control | Collection Period (min.) |
Dust Collection Rate (lb/min.) |
|---|---|---|
| Bosch grinder/Dust Director shroud & DustControl 2900c vacuum |
8 11 8 8 10 |
0.50 0.61 0.50 0.47 0.63 |
| Average | 0.54 |
[disclaimer:protected] => [disclaimer_transformed:protected] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [template] => record ) [_file] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/templates/elcosh/record.html [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_encoding:protected] => UTF-8 [_outputMode:protected] => 11 [_forceReparse:protected] => [_phpCodeDestination:protected] => /tmp/ [_phpCodeExtension:protected] => php [_cacheLifetime:protected] => 30 [_cachePurgeFrequency:protected] => 30 [externalMacroTemplatesCache:PHPTAL:private] => Array ( [macros.html] => PHPTAL Object ( [_prefilters:protected] => Array ( ) [_prefilter:PHPTAL:private] => REMOVED: DO NOT USE [_postfilter:protected] => [_repositories:protected] => Array ( [0] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/templates/elcosh ) [_path:protected] => macros.html [_resolvers:protected] => Array ( ) [_source:protected] => PHPTAL_FileSource Object ( [_path:PHPTAL_FileSource:private] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/templates/elcosh/macros.html ) [_codeFile:protected] => /tmp/tpl_61515a6c_macros__EnKHR8AWVA3oW7OmomvoZw.php [_functionName:protected] => tpl_61515a6c_macros__EnKHR8AWVA3oW7OmomvoZw [_prepared:protected] => 1 [_triggers:protected] => Array ( ) [_translator:protected] => [_globalContext:protected] => stdClass Object ( ) [_context:protected] => PHPTAL_Context Object ( [_line] => [_file] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/templates/elcosh/record.html [repeat] => stdClass Object ( ) [_xmlDeclaration] => [_docType] => [_nothrow:PHPTAL_Context:private] => [_slots:PHPTAL_Context:private] => Array ( ) [_slotsStack:PHPTAL_Context:private] => Array ( [0] => Array ( ) [1] => Array ( ) ) [_parentContext:PHPTAL_Context:private] => PHPTAL_Context Object ( [_line] => [_file] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/templates/elcosh/record.html [repeat] => stdClass Object ( ) [_xmlDeclaration] => [_docType] => [_nothrow:PHPTAL_Context:private] => [_slots:PHPTAL_Context:private] => Array ( ) [_slotsStack:PHPTAL_Context:private] => Array ( [0] => Array ( ) [1] => Array ( ) ) [_parentContext:PHPTAL_Context:private] => [_globalContext:PHPTAL_Context:private] => stdClass Object ( ) [_echoDeclarations:PHPTAL_Context:private] => [referer] => http://www.elcosh.org/document/3908/d001345/An%2BEvaluation%2Bof%2BSilica%2BExposure%2BControls%2Bfor%2BTuckpointing%253A%2BDustControl%2B2900c%2BVacuum%2Bwith%2Bthe%2BICS%2BDust%2BDirector%2BShroud%2Band%2BBosch%2BGrinder%2BModel%2B1775E%2BConducted%2BNovember%2B14-15%252C%2B2012.html [curr_module] => Record [styles] => Array ( ) [javascript] => Array ( [0] => jquery.min.js ) [metas] => Array ( [language] => en [robots] => index, follow ) [user] => [curr_url] => https://www.elcosh.org/index.php?module=Record&id=3908&type=document [base_url] => https://www.elcosh.org/index.php?module=Record [title] => eLCOSH : An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: DustControl 2900c Vacuum with the ICS Dust Director Shroud and Bosch Grinder Model 1775E Conducted November 14-15, 2012 [language] => en [search_query] => [module] => Record [new_records] => Array ( [0] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Fixed Ladder [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Fixed Ladders addresses the potential risks associated with using fixed ladders. The resource includes a brief case example,... [category] => Array ( [0] => 15 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 53 [5] => 55 [6] => 60 [7] => 64 [8] => 73 [9] => 76 [10] => 78 [11] => 80 [12] => 86 [13] => 87 [14] => 90 [15] => 92 [16] => 93 [17] => 94 [18] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Falls [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Concrete Polisher [11] => Electrical Worker [13] => HVAC [15] => Laborer [17] => PCC/Restoration [19] => Plumber/Pipefitter [21] => Roofer/Waterproofer [23] => Sheetmetal Worker [25] => Welder [27] => Commercial & Institutional [28] => Jobsites [29] => Industrial [31] => LEED/Green Construction [33] => Renovations [35] => Residential [37] => Toolbox Talks [38] => Documents [39] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4430/d001660/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BFixed%2BLadder.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [53] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 53 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Concrete Polisher [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [73] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 73 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => PCC/Restoration [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4430 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001660 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Fixed Ladder [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Fixed Ladders, Fall Prevention, Falls [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Fixed Ladders addresses the potential risks associated with using fixed ladders. The resource includes a brief case example, steps to prevent a related injury and questions for discussion. It includes an image that illustrates the hazard, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001257,d001254,d001255,d001256,d001258,d001262,d001279 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_completed:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/22/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [1] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Challenges Preventing Falling Objects [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Challenges Preventing Falling Objects addresses the hazards of being struck by falling objects on the job site. The resource... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 55 [5] => 64 [6] => 68 [7] => 71 [8] => 75 [9] => 78 [10] => 79 [11] => 82 [12] => 62 [13] => 86 [14] => 87 [15] => 88 [16] => 89 [17] => 91 [18] => 90 [19] => 92 [20] => 93 [21] => 94 [22] => 95 [23] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Electrical Worker [11] => Laborer [13] => Maintenance Worker [15] => Painter [17] => Plasterer [19] => Roofer/Waterproofer [21] => Scaffold Erector [23] => Stonemason [25] => Structural Ironworker [27] => Welder [29] => Commercial & Institutional [30] => Jobsites [31] => Demolition [33] => Disasters [35] => Heavy & Highway [37] => Industrial [39] => LEED/Green Construction [41] => Renovations [43] => Residential [45] => Underground [47] => Toolbox Talks [48] => Documents [49] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4431/d001661/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BChallenges%2BPreventing%2BFalling%2BObjects.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4431 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001661 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Challenges Preventing Falling Objects [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => dropped objects, falling objects, struck by incidents, struck by fatalities [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Challenges Preventing Falling Objects addresses the hazards of being struck by falling objects on the job site. The resource includes a brief example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates a group workers observing a scaffold free of debris during high winds, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001234,d001238,d001244,d001251,d001253,d001260,d001268,d001278 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_completed:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/22/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [2] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Tower Crane Safety [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Tower Crane Safety addresses the potential hazards of Tower Cranes and the importance of following procedure before and durin... [category] => Array ( [0] => 11 [1] => 12 [2] => 18 [3] => 70 [4] => 87 [5] => 88 [6] => 91 [7] => 90 [8] => 92 [9] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Cranes & Hoists [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Crushed/Struck By [6] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [9] => Operating Engineer [10] => Trades [11] => Commercial & Institutional [12] => Jobsites [13] => Demolition [15] => Heavy & Highway [17] => Industrial [19] => LEED/Green Construction [21] => Toolbox Talks [22] => Documents [23] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4427/d001657/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BTower%2BCrane%2BSafety.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [11] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 11 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Cranes & Hoists [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [18] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 18 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4427 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001657 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Tower Crane Safety [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Tower Crane, Crane, Stability, Tipping, Lift Zone Safety, Lift, Zone, Safety, Struck by [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Tower Crane Safety addresses the potential hazards of Tower Cranes and the importance of following procedure before and during Tower Crane operation. The resource includes a brief example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates a worker inspecting a Tower Crane before operation, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001234,d001238,d001250,d001251,d001253,d001258,d001262,d001273 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/19/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [3] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Work Zone Safety: Working Around Vehicles [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Working Around Vehicles in the Work Zone addresses methods to avoid being struck-by a vehicle on a construction site. The res... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 18 [2] => 52 [3] => 57 [4] => 70 [5] => 85 [6] => 87 [7] => 88 [8] => 89 [9] => 91 [10] => 90 [11] => 92 [12] => 93 [13] => 94 [14] => 95 [15] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [6] => Commercial Diver [7] => Trades [8] => Flagger [10] => Operating Engineer [12] => Truck Driver [14] => Commercial & Institutional [15] => Jobsites [16] => Demolition [18] => Disasters [20] => Heavy & Highway [22] => Industrial [24] => LEED/Green Construction [26] => Renovations [28] => Residential [30] => Underground [32] => Toolbox Talks [33] => Documents [34] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4428/d001658/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BWork%2BZone%2BSafety%253A%2BWorking%2BAround%2BVehicles.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [18] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 18 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [52] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 52 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Commercial Diver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [85] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 85 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Truck Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4428 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001658 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Daniela Caceres [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Work Zone Safety: Working Around Vehicles [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Struck, Struck by, Vehicle, Work Zone Safety, Truck, Operator, Driver, Mobile Equipment [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Working Around Vehicles in the Work Zone addresses methods to avoid being struck-by a vehicle on a construction site. The resource includes a case example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates the hazard, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001640 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/19/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [4] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Construction Dive -- DeWalt's Jobsite Pro headphones recalled for fire hazards [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => A recall notice by the United States Consumer Product Safety Commission affects over 300,000 DeWalt Jobsite Pro Headphones. The recall is a result of... [category] => Array ( [0] => 16 [1] => 44 [2] => 45 [3] => 46 [4] => 47 [5] => 48 [6] => 49 [7] => 50 [8] => 51 [9] => 52 [10] => 53 [11] => 54 [12] => 55 [13] => 56 [14] => 57 [15] => 58 [16] => 59 [17] => 60 [18] => 61 [19] => 64 [20] => 65 [21] => 66 [22] => 67 [23] => 68 [24] => 69 [25] => 70 [26] => 71 [27] => 72 [28] => 73 [29] => 74 [30] => 75 [31] => 76 [32] => 77 [33] => 63 [34] => 78 [35] => 79 [36] => 80 [37] => 81 [38] => 82 [39] => 62 [40] => 83 [41] => 84 [42] => 85 [43] => 86 [44] => 87 [45] => 88 [46] => 89 [47] => 91 [48] => 90 [49] => 92 [50] => 93 [51] => 94 [52] => 95 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Fire & Explosions [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Acoustical Ceiling Carpenter [4] => Trades [5] => Asbestos/Insulator [7] => Boilermaker [9] => Bricklayer [11] => Cabinetmaker [13] => Carpenter [15] => Carpet Layer [17] => Cement Mason [19] => Commercial Diver [21] => Concrete Polisher [23] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [25] => Electrical Worker [27] => Elevator Constructor [29] => Flagger [31] => Glazier [33] => Hazardous Waste Cleanup [35] => HVAC [37] => Interior Systems Carpenter [39] => Laborer [41] => Landscaper [43] => Lather [45] => Lead Abatement Worker [47] => Maintenance Worker [49] => Millwright [51] => Operating Engineer [53] => Painter [55] => Paper Hanger [57] => PCC/Restoration [59] => Pile Driver [61] => Plasterer [63] => Plumber/Pipefitter [65] => Refractory Worker [67] => Reinforcing Ironworker [69] => Roofer/Waterproofer [71] => Scaffold Erector [73] => Sheetmetal Worker [75] => Sprinkler Fitter [77] => Stonemason [79] => Structural Ironworker [81] => Terrazzo Worker [83] => Tile Setter [85] => Truck Driver [87] => Welder [89] => Commercial & Institutional [90] => Jobsites [91] => Demolition [93] => Disasters [95] => Heavy & Highway [97] => Industrial [99] => LEED/Green Construction [101] => Renovations [103] => Residential [105] => Underground ) [type] => [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4426/d001656/Construction%2BDive%2B--%2BDeWalt%2527s%2BJobsite%2BPro%2Bheadphones%2Brecalled%2Bfor%2Bfire%2Bhazards.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [16] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 16 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Fire & Explosions [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [44] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 44 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Acoustical Ceiling Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [45] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 45 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Asbestos/Insulator [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [46] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 46 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Boilermaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [48] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 48 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cabinetmaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [50] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 50 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpet Layer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [52] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 52 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Commercial Diver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [53] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 53 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Concrete Polisher [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [54] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 54 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [58] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 58 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Glazier [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [59] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 59 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Hazardous Waste Cleanup [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [65] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 65 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Landscaper [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [66] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 66 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Lather [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [67] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 67 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Lead Abatement Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [69] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 69 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Millwright [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [72] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 72 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Paper Hanger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [73] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 73 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => PCC/Restoration [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [77] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 77 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Refractory Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [81] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 81 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sprinkler Fitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [83] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 83 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Terrazzo Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [84] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 84 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Tile Setter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [85] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 85 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Truck Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4426 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001656 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Construction Dive -- DeWalt's Jobsite Pro headphones recalled for fire hazards [total_pages:protected] => 1 [billed_pages:protected] => 1 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => DeWalt, Fire Hazards, recall, headphones [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A recall notice by the United States Consumer Product Safety Commission affects over 300,000 DeWalt Jobsite Pro Headphones. The recall is a result of a malfunction that can cause earbuds to overheat while charging or during use, leading to fire and burn hazards. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => https://www.constructiondive.com/news/dewalts-jobsite-pro-headphones-recalled-for-fire-hazards/611248/?utm_source=Sailthru&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Issue:%202021-12-10%20Construction%20Dive%20Newsletter%20%5Bissue:38532%5D&utm_term=Construction%20Dive [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/13/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/13/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 12/13/21 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [new_images] => Array ( [0] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Morning Toolbox Talk [image] => /record/images/4003-p.jpg [blurb] => This photo is from an early morning toolbox talk on a construction job in Mclean, Virginia. It is being delivered in English and Spanish.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 20 [1] => 51 [2] => 57 [3] => 64 [4] => 70 [5] => 63 [6] => 78 [7] => 82 [8] => 62 [9] => 87 [10] => 88 [11] => 89 [12] => 91 [13] => 90 [14] => 93 [15] => 94 [16] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Safety Culture [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Cement Mason [4] => Trades [5] => Flagger [7] => Laborer [9] => Operating Engineer [11] => Reinforcing Ironworker [13] => Roofer/Waterproofer [15] => Stonemason [17] => Structural Ironworker [19] => Commercial & Institutional [20] => Jobsites [21] => Demolition [23] => Disasters [25] => Heavy & Highway [27] => Industrial [29] => Renovations [31] => Residential [33] => Images [34] => Media [35] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4003/i002691/Morning%2BToolbox%2BTalk.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4003 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002691 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Morning Toolbox Talk [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, Spanish, bilingual [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This photo is from an early morning toolbox talk on a construction job in Mclean, Virginia. It is being delivered in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001285,d001304,c000079 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [1] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox talk - crew view [image] => /record/images/4005-p.jpg [blurb] => Photo of crew listening to a toolbox safety talk before starting work.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 97 [1] => 20 [2] => 47 [3] => 49 [4] => 51 [5] => 55 [6] => 61 [7] => 64 [8] => 71 [9] => 75 [10] => 63 [11] => 79 [12] => 62 [13] => 87 [14] => 88 [15] => 91 [16] => 90 [17] => 93 [18] => 94 [19] => 95 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Images [1] => Media [2] => Media & Documents [3] => Safety Culture [4] => Work Environment [5] => Hazards [6] => Bricklayer [7] => Trades [8] => Carpenter [10] => Cement Mason [12] => Electrical Worker [14] => Interior Systems Carpenter [16] => Laborer [18] => Painter [20] => Plasterer [22] => Reinforcing Ironworker [24] => Scaffold Erector [26] => Structural Ironworker [28] => Commercial & Institutional [29] => Jobsites [30] => Demolition [32] => Heavy & Highway [34] => Industrial [36] => Renovations [38] => Residential [40] => Underground ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4005/i002692/Toolbox%2Btalk%2B-%2Bcrew%2Bview.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4005 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002692 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox talk - crew view [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, safety talk, Spanish [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Photo of crew listening to a toolbox safety talk before starting work. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002691,d001269, c000079, d001285 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [2] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox talk - long shot [image] => /record/images/4006-p.jpg [blurb] => This crew gathered every morning before starting work to discuss a new safety topic.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 20 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 55 [5] => 64 [6] => 68 [7] => 75 [8] => 76 [9] => 63 [10] => 78 [11] => 79 [12] => 82 [13] => 62 [14] => 87 [15] => 88 [16] => 91 [17] => 90 [18] => 93 [19] => 94 [20] => 95 [21] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Safety Culture [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Electrical Worker [11] => Laborer [13] => Maintenance Worker [15] => Plasterer [17] => Plumber/Pipefitter [19] => Reinforcing Ironworker [21] => Roofer/Waterproofer [23] => Scaffold Erector [25] => Stonemason [27] => Structural Ironworker [29] => Commercial & Institutional [30] => Jobsites [31] => Demolition [33] => Heavy & Highway [35] => Industrial [37] => Renovations [39] => Residential [41] => Underground [43] => Images [44] => Media [45] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4006/i002693/Toolbox%2Btalk%2B-%2Blong%2Bshot.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4006 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002693 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox talk - long shot [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, safety minute [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This crew gathered every morning before starting work to discuss a new safety topic. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002691,i002692,d001269,d000527 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [3] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Safety officer discussing ongoing project with marketing coordinator [image] => /record/images/4014-p.jpg [blurb] => The safety officer (left) points out the good safety practices on this project that reflect well on the firm and may influence future clients.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 97 [1] => 20 [2] => 46 [3] => 47 [4] => 49 [5] => 50 [6] => 51 [7] => 54 [8] => 55 [9] => 58 [10] => 60 [11] => 61 [12] => 64 [13] => 71 [14] => 75 [15] => 76 [16] => 63 [17] => 79 [18] => 80 [19] => 82 [20] => 62 [21] => 83 [22] => 87 [23] => 91 [24] => 90 [25] => 93 [26] => 94 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Images [1] => Media [2] => Media & Documents [3] => Safety Culture [4] => Work Environment [5] => Hazards [6] => Boilermaker [7] => Trades [8] => Bricklayer [10] => Carpenter [12] => Carpet Layer [14] => Cement Mason [16] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [18] => Electrical Worker [20] => Glazier [22] => HVAC [24] => Interior Systems Carpenter [26] => Laborer [28] => Painter [30] => Plasterer [32] => Plumber/Pipefitter [34] => Reinforcing Ironworker [36] => Scaffold Erector [38] => Sheetmetal Worker [40] => Stonemason [42] => Structural Ironworker [44] => Terrazzo Worker [46] => Commercial & Institutional [47] => Jobsites [48] => Heavy & Highway [50] => Industrial [52] => Renovations [54] => Residential ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4014/i002700/Safety%2Bofficer%2Bdiscussing%2Bongoing%2Bproject%2Bwith%2Bmarketing%2Bcoordinator.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [46] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 46 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Boilermaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [50] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 50 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpet Layer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [54] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 54 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [58] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 58 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Glazier [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [83] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 83 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Terrazzo Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4014 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002700 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Safety officer discussing ongoing project with marketing coordinator [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Latino, safety officer, safety culture [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The safety officer (left) points out the good safety practices on this project that reflect well on the firm and may influence future clients. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/index.php [more_like_this:protected] => d000989,d001351,d001362,d000652, d001101, d000931, d001395 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Hoar Construction, Photo by Neil Lippy [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 01/30/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [4] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Scaffolding at top of large column [image] => /record/images/3994-p.jpg [blurb] => This shot shows innovative guarding around the top of a large concrete column in the base of a high rise structure going up.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 15 [1] => 21 [2] => 47 [3] => 51 [4] => 63 [5] => 78 [6] => 79 [7] => 80 [8] => 62 [9] => 87 [10] => 97 [11] => 56 [12] => 64 [13] => 74 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Falls [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Scaffolds [6] => Bricklayer [7] => Trades [8] => Cement Mason [10] => Reinforcing Ironworker [12] => Roofer/Waterproofer [14] => Scaffold Erector [16] => Sheetmetal Worker [18] => Structural Ironworker [20] => Commercial & Institutional [21] => Jobsites [22] => Images [23] => Media [24] => Media & Documents [25] => Elevator Constructor [27] => Laborer [29] => Pile Driver ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/3994/i002689/Scaffolding%2Bat%2Btop%2Bof%2Blarge%2Bcolumn.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [21] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 21 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Scaffolds [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3994 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002689 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Scaffolding at top of large column [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Guardrail, railing, fall prevention, falls [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This shot shows innovative guarding around the top of a large concrete column in the base of a high rise structure going up. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/8/adjustable-tower-scaffold.html [more_like_this:protected] => c1002680,i002662,d000608,d001255 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Photo by Pam Susi [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2016 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_completed:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/01/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [5] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Construction bracing [image] => /record/images/3995-p.jpg [blurb] => This shows structural support that prevents collapses during construction.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 15 [2] => 21 [3] => 49 [4] => 51 [5] => 55 [6] => 56 [7] => 60 [8] => 64 [9] => 68 [10] => 74 [11] => 63 [12] => 78 [13] => 79 [14] => 80 [15] => 62 [16] => 87 [17] => 90 [18] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Falls [6] => Scaffolds [9] => Carpenter [10] => Trades [11] => Cement Mason [13] => Electrical Worker [15] => Elevator Constructor [17] => HVAC [19] => Laborer [21] => Maintenance Worker [23] => Pile Driver [25] => Reinforcing Ironworker [27] => Roofer/Waterproofer [29] => Scaffold Erector [31] => Sheetmetal Worker [33] => Structural Ironworker [35] => Commercial & Institutional [36] => Jobsites [37] => Industrial [39] => Images [40] => Media [41] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/3995/i002690/Construction%2Bbracing.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [21] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 21 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Scaffolds [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3995 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002690 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Construction bracing [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Bracing, support, scaffold [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This shows structural support that prevents collapses during construction. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/8/adjustable-tower-scaffold.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002660 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Photo by Pam Susi [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2016 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_completed:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/01/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [preview_mode] => [description] => The results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. [keywords] => tuckpointing, HEPA vacuum, dust control, LEV, local exhaust ventilation, silica [related_items] => Array ( [Research Reports] => Array ( [0] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1874 [old_id:protected] => 722 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000683 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Sharon Garber/COD [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Protecting Tuckpointing Workers from Silica Dust: Draft Recommendations for a Ventilated Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 12 [billed_pages:protected] => 12 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, vacuum, grinder, mortar, respirator, OSHA, NIOSH, exhaust, Heitbrink, tuckpointer, silica, masonry, dust, silicosis, LEV [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Describes draft recommendations for use of ventilated grinder to reduce dust during tuckpointing and describes field trials using these devices. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/hazard/67/chip-scrape-and-grind-surfaces-or-joints-silica.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001201,d000292,d000293,d000658 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2005 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/27/05 [date_completed:protected] => 04/26/05 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/20/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [1] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1940 [old_id:protected] => 909 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Workplace Solutions: Control of Hazardous Dust During Tuckpointing [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, silica, dust, tuckpoint, grinder, masonry restoration, mortar, vacuum [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d000819,d000820,d000730,d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 10/24/08 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/09 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [2] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3899 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001342 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: Hilti VC40-U Vacuum with Hilti DC-EX Dust Guard and Hilti Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 15 [billed_pages:protected] => 15 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP4 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => silica, tuckpointing, Hilti, local exhaust systems, LEV, shroud, quartz [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This report describes the results of an evaluation of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Hilti VC40-U vacuum, a Hilti DC-EX shroud, and a Hilti DAG-500 grinder. Randomized trials with and without use of the dust control system were conducted in a controlled setting. Removing mortar with the Hilti grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 220 times the National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05mg/m3. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 97 percent. However, exposures measured during the use of the dust control system still exceeded the NIOSH REL. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => December 1, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/05/14 [date_completed:protected] => 02/04/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/06/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [Handouts] => Array ( [0] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3656 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001198 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 24 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction While Doing Tuckpointing/Mortar Removal [total_pages:protected] => 2 [billed_pages:protected] => 2 [publication_number:protected] => DSG FS-3632 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Brick, block, tuckpointing, silica, local exhaust ventilation, LEV, masonry [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Tuckpointing creates some of the greatest exposures to silica in construction. This OSHA factsheet provides guidance on how to greatly reduce these exposures through the use of local exhaust ventilation. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863, d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => February 2013 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/04/13 [date_completed:protected] => 03/27/13 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [collections] => Array ( [3913] => ) [record] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => Array ( [867] => Author Object ( [id:protected] => 867 [organization_id:protected] => 0 [firstname:protected] => Michael [lastname:protected] => Cooper [address:protected] => [city:protected] => [province:protected] => [country:protected] => [postal_code:protected] => [department:protected] => [title:protected] => [phone:protected] => [fax:protected] => [email:protected] => [degree:protected] => [website:protected] => [about:protected] => [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => [date_completed:protected] => [date_billed:protected] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [481] => Author Object ( [id:protected] => 481 [organization_id:protected] => 0 [firstname:protected] => Pam [lastname:protected] => Susi [address:protected] => 8484 Georgia Avenue, Suite 1000 [city:protected] => Silver Spring [province:protected] => Maryland [country:protected] => USA [postal_code:protected] => 20910 [department:protected] => [title:protected] => [phone:protected] => 301-578-8500 ext.144 [fax:protected] => 301-578-8572 [email:protected] => plsusi@aol.com [degree:protected] => [website:protected] => http://www.cpwr.com [about:protected] => [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => 2003-10-02 [date_completed:protected] => 2003-10-06 [date_billed:protected] => 2003-11-03 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [organizations:protected] => Array ( [1] => Organization Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [elcosh_id:protected] => o000001 [user_id:protected] => 14 [province_id:protected] => 21 [country_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => CPWR - The Center for Construction Research and Training [address:protected] => Suite 1000, 8484 Georgia Ave [postal_code:protected] => 20910 [city:protected] => Silver Spring [department:protected] => [phone:protected] => 301-578-8500 [fax:protected] => 301-578-8572 [email:protected] => cpwrwebsite@cpwr.com [website:protected] => http://www.cpwr.com [filename:protected] => o000001.gif [about:protected] => CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training, developed, and continues to maintain/expand this website - The Electronic Library of Construction Occupational Safety and Health, www.elcosh.org. CPWR, formerly known as The Center to Protect Workers’ Rights, is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit research and training institution. Created by the Building and Construction Trades Department, AFL-CIO, CPWR serves as the research arm of the BCTD. Since the inception of its research agenda in 1990, CPWR has grown into a worldwide provider of safety and health information covering all aspects of the construction industry. CPWR launched eLCOSH in 2000, and the Spanish-language version of the site in 2001. CPWR also created, and continues to build, Construction Solutions - www.cpwrConstructionSolutions.org - a free, online database of construction hazards and ways to prevent, eliminate, or reduce them. [comments:protected] => [logo_available:protected] => T [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => 2000-08-18 [date_completed:protected] => 2000-08-30 [date_billed:protected] => 2000-09-05 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [collections:protected] => Array ( [3913] => ) [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => Array ( [1874] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1874 [old_id:protected] => 722 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000683 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Sharon Garber/COD [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Protecting Tuckpointing Workers from Silica Dust: Draft Recommendations for a Ventilated Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 12 [billed_pages:protected] => 12 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, vacuum, grinder, mortar, respirator, OSHA, NIOSH, exhaust, Heitbrink, tuckpointer, silica, masonry, dust, silicosis, LEV [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Describes draft recommendations for use of ventilated grinder to reduce dust during tuckpointing and describes field trials using these devices. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/hazard/67/chip-scrape-and-grind-surfaces-or-joints-silica.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001201,d000292,d000293,d000658 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2005 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/27/05 [date_completed:protected] => 04/26/05 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/20/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [1940] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1940 [old_id:protected] => 909 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Workplace Solutions: Control of Hazardous Dust During Tuckpointing [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, silica, dust, tuckpoint, grinder, masonry restoration, mortar, vacuum [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d000819,d000820,d000730,d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 10/24/08 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/09 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [2213] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 2213 [old_id:protected] => 1090 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => [language_id:protected] => 2 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Control del polvo peligroso que se genera durante los procesos de reparación de mortero [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => 2008-126 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => [comments:protected] => http://www.cdc.gov/spanish/niosh/docs/wp-solutions/2008-126_sp/ [summary:protected] => A Workplace Solutions de NIOSH que resume un estudio de NIOSH sobre los riesgos de exposición cuando se reparan las estructuras y los métodos para controlar el polvo. [A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust.] [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => D000819,D000820,D000730,d000819 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 01/07/10 [date_completed:protected] => 04/19/10 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 07/08/12 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [3656] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3656 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001198 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 24 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction While Doing Tuckpointing/Mortar Removal [total_pages:protected] => 2 [billed_pages:protected] => 2 [publication_number:protected] => DSG FS-3632 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Brick, block, tuckpointing, silica, local exhaust ventilation, LEV, masonry [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Tuckpointing creates some of the greatest exposures to silica in construction. This OSHA factsheet provides guidance on how to greatly reduce these exposures through the use of local exhaust ventilation. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863, d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => February 2013 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/04/13 [date_completed:protected] => 03/27/13 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [3899] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3899 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001342 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: Hilti VC40-U Vacuum with Hilti DC-EX Dust Guard and Hilti Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 15 [billed_pages:protected] => 15 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP4 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => silica, tuckpointing, Hilti, local exhaust systems, LEV, shroud, quartz [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This report describes the results of an evaluation of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Hilti VC40-U vacuum, a Hilti DC-EX shroud, and a Hilti DAG-500 grinder. Randomized trials with and without use of the dust control system were conducted in a controlled setting. Removing mortar with the Hilti grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 220 times the National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05mg/m3. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 97 percent. However, exposures measured during the use of the dust control system still exceeded the NIOSH REL. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => December 1, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/05/14 [date_completed:protected] => 02/04/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/06/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [content:protected] => [files:protected] => Array ( [559] => [560] => [546] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 546 [filename:protected] => 3.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:22 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [566] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 566 [filename:protected] => 4.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:23 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [720] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 720 [filename:protected] => 5.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [721] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 721 [filename:protected] => 6.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [722] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 722 [filename:protected] => 7.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [9765] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 9765 [filename:protected] => d001345.pdf [downloadable:protected] => T [timestamp:protected] => 2015-02-09 12:26:04 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3908 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001345 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: DustControl 2900c Vacuum with the ICS Dust Director Shroud and Bosch Grinder Model 1775E Conducted November 14-15, 2012 [total_pages:protected] => 13 [billed_pages:protected] => 13 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP2 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => tuckpointing, HEPA vacuum, dust control, LEV, local exhaust ventilation, silica [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => April 15, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 01/26/15 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/09/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [show_text] => [document_content] => ElcoshItemDocumentContent Object ( [id:protected] => 2934 [item_id:protected] => 3908 [type:protected] => main [title:protected] => [content:protected] =>
Executive Summary
This report describes the results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. It should also be noted that the NIOSH REL is based on exposures averaged over a ten hour work day and our results represent time weighted averages of the sample task duration periods.
Acronyms
ACGIH - American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists
CPWR - CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training
Ce - coefficient of entry
HEPA - high-efficiency particulate air
IUBAC - International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craftworkers
LEV - local exhaust ventilation
PACT - Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies
NIOSH - National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health
OEL - occupational exposure limit
OSHA - Occupational Safety and Health Administration
PAPR - powered air-purifying respirator
PEL - Permissible Exposure Limit
PVC - polyvinyl chloride
REL - Recommended Exposure Limit
RPM - revolutions per minute
TWA - time-weighted average
SP - static pressure
I. Introduction and Background
In 2010 CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training began a four-year project which seeks to identify and evaluate tuckpointing local exhaust ventilation (LEV) systems and disseminate information on their availability and effectiveness. A Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies (PACT) comprised of masonry contractors, representatives from unions, government, equipment manufacturers, and health and safety researcher was formed as part of this project. PACT members participated in identifying important characteristics for control technologies and this information was used to identify LEV systems for tuckpointing using that criteria. Contractor and labor members of the PACT selected specific tuckpointing LEV systems to be considered for evaluation. Each system consisted of a tuckpointing grinder, shroud, and vacuum. This report describes the second of four systems to be evaluated between 2012 the end of 2014, with and without LEV, in a controlled setting to determine effectiveness in silica exposure reduction. This report describes the methods and results of our evaluation of a system consisting of the DustControl 2900c vacuum with the ICS Dust Director shroud and a Bosch Model 1775E grinder.
Excessive exposure to respirable silica can result in silicosis or other silica-related diseases including pulmonary tuberculosis, lung cancer, silicoproteinosis (Lyons et al, 2007) and autoimmune disorders such as rheumatoid arthritis, sarcoidosis and scleroderma (Miller et al, 2012). Respirable silica is generally defined as particles less than 10 micrometers (μm) in aerodynamic diameter (ACGIH, 2013). Silicosis can lead to symptoms including shortness of breath, fatigue, chest pains, susceptibility to infection and possibly death. There is no cure for silicosis, however it is totally preventable. Construction workers exposed to dust, including silica, are also known to have higher rates of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD).
There are many sources of silica in construction that result in exposures of varying intensity among workers. Masonry restoration workers are among the most highly silica-exposed trades in construction. The process of grinding out deteriorated mortar joints between masonry units and replacing or repointing with fresh mortar (often referred to as tuckpointing) is a fundamental part of masonry restoration work. The removal of mortar with powered angle grinders generates enormous levels of dust. Between 2004 and 2006, NIOSH and CPWR evaluated silica exposures while grinding mortar in a controlled setting, at a local training center, where tasks, sample times and task variables were defined by the study design. These studies demonstrated that grinding mortar without controls can result in elevated respirable silica exposures. Meeker et al., (2009) reported exposures between 5 and 25.8 milligrams per cubic meter (mg/m3) in a controlled setting. This study also showed that LEV systems for tuckpointing grinders can reduce exposures to respirable silica by greater than 90 percent.II. Objectives
The objective of this evaluation was to assess the effectiveness of an LEV system for controlling exposure to silica during the grinding of mortar. The control technology was tested under controlled conditions, similar to those experienced by tuckpointers on actual job sites, using journeymen bricklayers experienced in tuckpointing and repeat, randomized trials with and without LEV. All other variables were held constant throughout so that the only variable was whether or not the tested control was used.
III. Description of Equipment Tested
A Bosch model 1775E grinder (Robert Bosch Tool Corporation, Prospect, IL) (Figures 1, 2 and 3) was fitted with a new 1/4-inch wide, 4½-inch diameter segmented diamond abrasive blade made by DeWalt (model #DW4740). The grinder weighs six and a half pounds, draws 8.5 amps and has a variable speed up to 11,000 revolutions per minute (RPMs). The DustControl 2900c vacuum (DustControl, Inc., Wilmington, NC) (Figure 3) was tested in combination with the Dust Director shroud (Industrial Contractors’ Supplies, Inc., Huntingdon, PA) (Figures 1 and 3) attached to the Bosch grinder.
Figure 1. Bosch grinder with Dust Director shroud
Figure 2. Bosch grinder without tuckpointing LEV system.
Figure 3: Bosch Grinder with LEV System
The vacuum is specified to weigh 31 pounds when empty and to provide a flow rate of 114 cubic feet of air per minute and a “static lift” or “vacuum suction pressure” of 84 inches of water. The vacuum is sold with a cyclonic pre-separator, to remove larger particles, a fine filter (rated 99.9 percent efficient) and a HEPA (high-efficiency particulate air) filter (rated to capture 99.97 percent of the particles with an aerodynamic diameter of 0.3 micrometers). The HEPA filter was removed based on the manufacturer’s recommendation due to the heavy dust loading associated with tuckpointing. CPWR sponsored research and contractor experience indicate that HEPA filters likely have an adverse effect on dust capture during tuckpointing because of extreme dust loading on filters. While the cyclone and the fine filter remove most of the dust, especially the large particles, before they reach the HEPA filter, the HEPA filter would still be subject to heavy loading, causing a substantial pressure drop and subsequent decrease in air flow rate. The relatively small increase in the efficiency of the filtration system while using the HEPA filter is expected to be quickly offset by a more significant decrease in capture efficiency as the air flow rate and ability to capture particles decreases.
Dust collects in relatively inexpensive, heavy-gauge plastic bags below and outside of the cyclone. The bags can be removed and replaced without opening the vacuum. Some vacuums are equipped with a light to indicate that the filters need to be cleaned or changed. The DC2900c features a “reverse air pulse cleaning system,” which removes accumulated dust from the filters without having to remove them from the vacuum. The system, as illustrated in Figure 4, requires the operator to disconnect the hose from the shroud, place it over an air stop so that air through the hose is cut off and pressure in the vacuum is maximized.
Figure 4. Procedure for "cleaning" of or dust removal from filters (source: http://dustcontrolusa.com/manuals/2800c.pdf)
The flap covering the port on the side of the vacuum is repeatedly flipped open to release built up pressure in strong pulses that dislodge dust from the filter.
The manufacturer indicates “the filter is generally cleaned once or twice daily during normal continuous operation.” The Dust Director shroud has a 2-inch diameter take-off that was connected to the antistatic, corrugated 1.5-inch diameter, 15-foot long vacuum hose supplied with the DustControl vacuum.
IV. Study Methods
This evaluation was conducted at the International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craft workers (IUBAC) Local 1 Philadelphia/Delaware Training Center in Philadelphia, PA on November 14 and 15, 2012. A single journeyman bricklayer, experienced in tuckpointing, used the grinder and LEV system being tested to remove mortar from joints wide enough to require two passes. The type S mortar had been allowed to cure for at least four weeks. The bricklayer either possessed or was provided with personal protective equipment including sturdy work boots, gloves, hearing protection and a powered air-purifying respirator (PAPR). The PAPR was a 3M GVP system with a bump cap, loose fitting face piece and a HEPA filter (3M, St Paul, MN).
The study was designed to include at least five rounds of sampling during mortar removal. Each round included a trial using the Bosch grinder with a Dust Director shroud and Dust Collector 2900c vacuum and a trial using the Bosch grinder with the factory-supplied guard and without a vacuum. The order of the two trials within each round was randomly selected to minimize bias that might be introduced due to variation associated with environmental factors, equipment operator, blade wear, vacuum performance over time and any other factors unrelated to LEV use. Tools were operated for approximately 16 minutes per trial with controls and for approximately 8 minutes when controls were not used. These times were selected based on the results of previous sampling efforts and estimates of the minimum sample time needed to achieve a limit of quantification low enough to accurately measure exposures down to or less than 0.05 mg/m3 – the NIOSH Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) for respirable silica. The bricklayer was required to take a 5 to 10 minute break in the middle of the 16-minute trials to reduce differences in fatigue, compared to the 8-minute trials. Personal air samples were collected in the breathing zone of the operator during each trial to measure respirable silica concentrations during grinding with and without LEV. The samples were collected using a GilAir-5 pump (Sensidyne, Inc., Clearwater, FL) to draw 4.2 liters of air per minute through a GK2.69 Respirable Cyclone (BGI Inc., Waltham, MA) with a pre-weighed, 37 mm diameter, 5-micron pore size polyvinyl chloride (PVC) filter positioned on the operator’s lapel.
The flow rates of the sampling pumps were calibrated at the beginning of each day using a DryCal DC-Lite Primary Flow Meter (Bios International Corporation, Butler, NJ). Flow rates were measured again near the middle and at the end of each day to ensure that sampling flow rates were maintained within 5% of pre-sampling flow rates throughout the day. Average flow rates were used to calculate sample air volumes. Samples were analyzed by R.J. Lee Group, Inc., (Monroeville, PA) using NIOSH Method 0600, to determine exposure to total mass of respirable dust. The same samples were also analyzed using X-Ray diffraction following NIOSH method 7500 to determine quartz, cristobalite and tridymite concentration in the respirable mass. Reported masses for these analytes were used with the sample air volumes to calculate airborne concentrations of total respirable dust, quartz, cristobalite and tridymite.
We used a reduction of greater than 50 percent in respirable silica exposure concentrations or a reduction to less than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 as our criteria for determining whether or not a control was considered efficacious. This is consistent with criteria used by NIOSH in conducting a similar study in 2004 described by Echt et al. (2007) and by CPWR in 2006 and described by Meeker et al. (2009). The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) and the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) publish additional occupational exposure limits (OELs) for silica which are listed in Table 1 with NIOSH RELs. OELs for silica are based on the respirable fraction of the aerosol, which consists of particles less than 10 micrometers in aerodynamic diameter.
| Organization or Agency | Form of Crystalline Silica | Occupational Exposure Limits (mg/m3) |
|---|---|---|
| NIOSHA | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 |
| OSHA - ConstructionB | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
PEL = 250 / (5 + % quartz) PEL = 250 / (5 + % cristobalite) PEL = 250 / (5 + % tridymite) |
| ACGIH | Crystalline Silica | TLV = 0.025 mg/m3 |
A NIOSH Publication No. 2005-151 indicates 10-hour time-weighted average during a 40-hr workweek B The PEL for silica in OSHA’s Safety and Health Regulations for Construction, 29 C.F.R. 1926.55(a), is an 8-hour time-weighted average (TWA) expressed in millions of particles per cubic foot (mppcf). However, the units mppcf can be converted to milligrams per cubic meter can by dividing mppcf by 10 (OSHA, 2009). The formula used by OSHA to determine the PEL for silica is dependent on the percentage of silica in each collected sample. The concentration of respirable dust measured is compared to the sample specific PEL to determine if the PEL has been exceeded. OSHA has proposed lowering the PEL to 0.05 mg/m3 of respirable silica as an 8 hour TWA. |
||
The flow of air in ventilation systems is governed by fundamental principles that describe the behavior of gases (in this case air). Pressure measurements taken within a ventilation system along with knowledge of hood (or shroud) entry losses can be used to calculate flow rates. Hood entry losses are dependent on the shape and configuration of a particular hood or shroud and described by the term “coefficient of entry (Ce)” which is the ratio of actual air flow through a hood and what the air flow would theoretically be if there were no hood entry losses. Given the coefficient of entry, static pressure measurements can be used to calculate air flow through a given hood. The coefficient of entry for the Dust Director shroud was previously determined by CPWR and used for calculating air flow based on static pressure measurements (Meeker et al., 2009). Static pressure, with the vacuum operating, was measured periodically throughout the evaluation to monitor the changes in air-flow rate following use and again after filter cleaning. The static pressure was measured at a port positioned more than 3 duct diameters downstream from the tool’s air intake using a UEi EM200 Electronic Manometer (Universal Enterprises, Inc., Beaverton, OR).
The dust in the vacuum bag was monitored and, per the manufacturer’s instructions, the bag was changed before the dust level was within 5 centimeters of the valve at the bottom of the vacuum. Each time a vacuum bag was removed, it was weighed to the nearest pound. The bag weights and corresponding grinding durations were used to calculate the average weight of dust collected per unit time. After each trial, cut lengths were measured on the wall to determine total linear feet of vertical (head) and horizontal (bed) joints per unit time.
A Haz-Dust III, Model HD-1003, Real-Time Aerosol Monitor (Environmental Devices Corporation, Plaistow, NH) was used to confirm clearance of dust between trials. The Haz-Dust monitor was positioned on the test wall near the operator at approximately breathing zone level and configured to measure respirable particulate concentration.
V. Results
Personal air monitoring
Five pairs of respirable dust samples were collected while grinding with and without the vacuum system. In addition, three respirable dust samples were collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place. One measurement collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard was shown to be a statistical outlier and was omitted from analysis. Personal air monitoring results for respirable silica and a comparison of average exposures relative to the NIOSH REL for silica (0.05 mg/m3) appears in Table 2. The mean respirable dust levels measured without LEV was 31.4 mg/m3. However, samples collected with LEV were below the limit of quantification (LOQ) which ranged from <1.29 to <1.46 mg/m3. Use of LEV resulted in a greater than 95% reduction in mean respirable dust levels using a mean value with use of LEV of <1.41 (n=5 samples with use of LEV and n=7 without use of LEV). The respirable dust samples collected during grinding without the LEV system contained an average of 24 percent silica. The mass of respirable dust in the samples collected with use of the LEV system was too low to determine the silica content.| Mean, mg/m3 (range) | Std. Dev. | Percent Reduction | Hazard RatioB | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bosch with Dust Director Shroud and DustControl 2900c Vacuum |
0.091 (<0.069 – 0.137) |
0.027 | 98.7 | 1.81 |
| Bosch with no Control | 7.23 (4.57 – 9.90) |
1.94 | NA | 145 |
A n = 5 samples for each tool/control combination and n = 7 samples without the use of the LEV system B Hazard Ratio = measured exposure / NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 |
||||
Average respirable silica and dust exposures, with and without the dust control system, appear as Figures 5 and 6, respectively.
Figure 5. Average respirable silica exposures with and without the Dustcontrol 2900c vacuum and Dust Director shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air - mg/m3)
Figure 6. Average respirable dust exposures with and without Dustcontrol 2900c Vacuum and Dust Director Shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air – mg/m3)
The mean respirable silica concentration measured during use of the control was significantly less than the concentration measured while using the same tool without controls (p<0.01). Grinding mortar with the Bosch angle grinder without dust controls resulted in an average exposure to respirable silica that was 145 times the NIOSH REL. Grinding with the Bosch angle grinder in combination with the Dust Director shroud and the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced the average concentration of respirable silica by 98.7 percent. With use of these controls, the concentration of respirable silica was 1.8 times greater than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3. However the NIOSH REL is based on a time-weighted average (TWA) over a 10-hour workday. Given these were task TWAs and samples were collected over continuous periods of grinding, they may overestimate exposures over an actual work day since some time would be spent performing tasks that would likely have lower, or no, silica exposures (setup, breaks, cleanup, etc.).
Static pressure, dust mass collection and grinding rates.
Static pressure was used as a surrogate for air flow as described earlier. Hood static pressure was measured periodically at a tap near the grinder more than 3 duct diameters from the air intake in the shroud. The static pressure, and thus air flow, was generally higher when the vacuum’s filter had recently been cleaned. The mean, median, and range of calculated flow rates are presented in Table A1 of the Appendix.
Based on the data we collected, the air-flow rate upstream from the Bosch grinder and Dust Director shroud ranged from 78 to 93 cubic feet per minute (cfm) with the DustControl vacuum. When the manufacturer’s filter cleaning procedure was followed the vacuum performed relatively well and flow could be maintained at slightly less than 90 cfm with cleaning. However, mean flow rates dropped substantially to 80 cfm after as little as 8 minutes of grinding without any filter cleaning. The flow rate returned to an average of 89 cfm when filters were cleaned correctly (without stopping air flow to the vacuum). Collingwood and Heitbrink (2007) found that the minimum exhaust flow rate for capture of silica and other particulate under ideal conditions is 21.25 cfm per inch of grinder blade diameter. This is equal to about 96 cfm when using a 4.5 inch diameter grinding blade. We set 106 cfm as the minimum desired flow rate for this study to allow a safety margin for potential decline in equipment performance and the possibility of inadequate maintenance, both of which may be likely after repeated use under actual work conditions. The DustControl vacuum provided slightly less than the minimum flow rate described by Collingwood and Heitbrink for a 4.5-inch blade and the peak flow rate fell with use.
The duration of vacuum bag use and mass of dust collected were recorded and are presented in Table A2 of the Appendix. The vacuum bags were changed and weighed after each trial utilizing the LEV system. A total of five bags were used to complete the five rounds of grinding. The DustControl vacuum captured 45 pounds of dust over 83 minutes of grinding for an average rate of dust collection of 0.54 pounds per minute. The rate of dust collection ranged from 0.47 to 0.63 pounds per minute. Based on these measurements, approximately 130 pounds of dust would likely be captured after just 4 hours of continuous grinding.
The rate of grinding a combination of vertical and horizontal joints while using the LEV system ranged from 2.3 to 3.3 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the use of the LEV system ranged from 2.6 to 3.4 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place ranged from 4.7 to 5.1 feet per minute. It’s important to note that: 1) the operator had limited experience using dust control systems and cut rates appeared to improve slightly over the 2-day period he used the tested equipment; and 2) the upper range of cut rates with the dust control system overlapped with the lowest cut rate with the original guard and without the LEV system in place indicating no statistical difference between cut rates. Given that grinding rates with and without use of this LEV system are only available for one operator and he had limited experience with the LEV system, these reported cut rates are in no way intended to represent the impact use of this LEV system is likely to have on productivity rates overall.
VI. Discussion
The objective of these trials was to evaluate the effectiveness of a tuckpointing LEV system for controlling respirable silica while grinding out mortar joints. The Dust Director shroud with the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced respirable silica concentrations when grinding with the Bosch grinder by approximately 99 percent. Despite being considered effective by our test criteria (greater than 50% reduction), it still resulted in task TWA exposures that exceeded the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 by 1.8 times. Depending on how much time is spent grinding over the course of a work day and on exposures while performing other tasks, the 8-hour TWA exposures may or may not exceed the REL with this system. Use of this system by workers with experience and training in proficient use will likely improve dust capture performance. Exposure reduction is greatly influenced by correct use of this system which includes grinding from right to left, making sure the shroud is held flush against the wall and that the tool travels at a pace that doesn’t exceed the ability of the system to capture dust as it’s generated. Deviation from any of these measures produces visible dust clouds which were observed during trials.
VII. Conclusions
With a 99 percent reduction in respirable silica exposure, the Dust Director shroud and DustControl 2900c vacuum with a Bosch Model 1775E grinder was effective in reducing silica exposures based on our criteria. Use of the tested dust control system may be effective in reducing silica exposure on the job to less than the NIOSH REL if used in combination with administrative controls such as work scheduling to reduce cutting times as needed. Training on correct use of the tested system is also essential. Personal air monitoring is necessary to verify control effectiveness on actual job sites and under “real-world” conditions. However, these results clearly demonstrate the availability of viable and effective engineering controls for tuckpointing operations associated with elevated silica exposure.
VIII. References
American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists. Threshold limit values for chemical substances (TLV®-CS). [2013]. ACGIH, Cincinnati, Ohio.
Bergdahl I.A,. Toren K., Eriksson K., et al. [2004]. Increased mortality in COPD among construction workers exposed to inorganic dust. European Respiratory Journal, 23: 402–06.
Blanc P.D. & Torén K. [2007]. Occupation in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and chronic bronchitis: an update [State of the Art Series. Occupational lung disease in high-and low-income countries, Edited by M. Chan-Yeung. Number 2 in the series]. The International Journal of Tuberculosis and Lung Disease, 11(3), 251-257.
Collingwood S. & Heitbrink W.A. [2007] 'Field Evaluation of an Engineering Control for Respirable Crystalline Silica Exposures During Mortar Removal'. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, 4:11, 875 – 887.
DHHS (NIOSH) Publication No. 2002-129 April 2002 http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/2002-129/
Echt A., Sieber W.K., Lefkowitz D., Meeker J., Susi P., Cardwell B., Heitbrink, W.A. In-depth survey of dust control technology for cutting concrete block and tuckpointing brick at The International Masonry Institute Bordentown Training Center, Bordentown, NJ. Cincinnati, OH: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Report. No. EPHB 282-13; 2007. http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ECTB-282-13.pdf
Heitbrink W., Bennett J. [2006]. A numerical and experimental investigation of crystalline silica exposure control during tuck pointing. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, Vol. 3, pp 366-378.
Lyons et al, [2007]. A breathless builder. Breathe, Vol. 3, no. 4, pp 386-390.
Mastrangelo G., Tartari M., Fedeli U., Fadda E., Saia B. [2003]. Ascertaining the risk of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease in relation to occupation using a case-control design. Occupational Medicine, 53: 165–172.
Meeker J., Cooper M., Lefrowitz D., Susi P. [2009]. Engineering control technologies to reduce occupational silica exposures in masonry cutting and tuckpointing. Public Health Reports, Supplement 1, Vol. 124, June.
Meeker J, Flynn M, Susi P, Cardwell, B [2004]. Performance evaluation of a masonry concrete vacuum. Unpublished Report.
Miller F. W., Alfredsson L., Costenbader K. H., Kamen D. L., Nelson L. M., Norris J. M., & De Roos A. J. [2012]. Epidemiology of environmental exposures and human autoimmune diseases: findings from a National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences Expert Panel workshop. Journal of autoimmunity. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3496812/
Occupational Safety and Health Administration U.S Department of Labor. Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction. [2009]. OSHA 3362-05.
Rappaport SM, Goldberg M, Susi P, Herrick RF [2003]. Excessive exposure to silica in the U.S. construction industry. Annals of Occupational Hygiene, Vol. 47, pp. 111-122.
IX. Appendices
| Measurement Conditions |
n | Mean Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Median
Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before filter cleaning | 5 | 80 | 81 | 78-81 |
| After filter cleaning following manufacturer directions | 9 | 89 | 90 | 84-93 |
| * Static pressure was measured in millibars and converted to inches of water gauge. Flow rates were calculated using the formula Q = Ce (A) 4005 (SP)1/2 where: Q = flow in cubic feet per minute (cfm), Ce = coefficient of entry, A = area of the duct where static pressure measurements were taken in square feet, and SP = static pressure in inches of water gauge. | ||||
| Tool/Control | Collection Period (min.) |
Dust Collection Rate (lb/min.) |
|---|---|---|
| Bosch grinder/Dust Director shroud & DustControl 2900c vacuum |
8 11 8 8 10 |
0.50 0.61 0.50 0.47 0.63 |
| Average | 0.54 |
[content_transformed:protected] =>
Executive Summary
This report describes the results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. It should also be noted that the NIOSH REL is based on exposures averaged over a ten hour work day and our results represent time weighted averages of the sample task duration periods.
Acronyms
ACGIH - American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists
CPWR - CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training
Ce - coefficient of entry
HEPA - high-efficiency particulate air
IUBAC - International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craftworkers
LEV - local exhaust ventilation
PACT - Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies
NIOSH - National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health
OEL - occupational exposure limit
OSHA - Occupational Safety and Health Administration
PAPR - powered air-purifying respirator
PEL - Permissible Exposure Limit
PVC - polyvinyl chloride
REL - Recommended Exposure Limit
RPM - revolutions per minute
TWA - time-weighted average
SP - static pressure
I. Introduction and Background
In 2010 CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training began a four-year project which seeks to identify and evaluate tuckpointing local exhaust ventilation (LEV) systems and disseminate information on their availability and effectiveness. A Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies (PACT) comprised of masonry contractors, representatives from unions, government, equipment manufacturers, and health and safety researcher was formed as part of this project. PACT members participated in identifying important characteristics for control technologies and this information was used to identify LEV systems for tuckpointing using that criteria. Contractor and labor members of the PACT selected specific tuckpointing LEV systems to be considered for evaluation. Each system consisted of a tuckpointing grinder, shroud, and vacuum. This report describes the second of four systems to be evaluated between 2012 the end of 2014, with and without LEV, in a controlled setting to determine effectiveness in silica exposure reduction. This report describes the methods and results of our evaluation of a system consisting of the DustControl 2900c vacuum with the ICS Dust Director shroud and a Bosch Model 1775E grinder.
Excessive exposure to respirable silica can result in silicosis or other silica-related diseases including pulmonary tuberculosis, lung cancer, silicoproteinosis (Lyons et al, 2007) and autoimmune disorders such as rheumatoid arthritis, sarcoidosis and scleroderma (Miller et al, 2012). Respirable silica is generally defined as particles less than 10 micrometers (μm) in aerodynamic diameter (ACGIH, 2013). Silicosis can lead to symptoms including shortness of breath, fatigue, chest pains, susceptibility to infection and possibly death. There is no cure for silicosis, however it is totally preventable. Construction workers exposed to dust, including silica, are also known to have higher rates of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD).
There are many sources of silica in construction that result in exposures of varying intensity among workers. Masonry restoration workers are among the most highly silica-exposed trades in construction. The process of grinding out deteriorated mortar joints between masonry units and replacing or repointing with fresh mortar (often referred to as tuckpointing) is a fundamental part of masonry restoration work. The removal of mortar with powered angle grinders generates enormous levels of dust. Between 2004 and 2006, NIOSH and CPWR evaluated silica exposures while grinding mortar in a controlled setting, at a local training center, where tasks, sample times and task variables were defined by the study design. These studies demonstrated that grinding mortar without controls can result in elevated respirable silica exposures. Meeker et al., (2009) reported exposures between 5 and 25.8 milligrams per cubic meter (mg/m3) in a controlled setting. This study also showed that LEV systems for tuckpointing grinders can reduce exposures to respirable silica by greater than 90 percent.II. Objectives
The objective of this evaluation was to assess the effectiveness of an LEV system for controlling exposure to silica during the grinding of mortar. The control technology was tested under controlled conditions, similar to those experienced by tuckpointers on actual job sites, using journeymen bricklayers experienced in tuckpointing and repeat, randomized trials with and without LEV. All other variables were held constant throughout so that the only variable was whether or not the tested control was used.
III. Description of Equipment Tested
A Bosch model 1775E grinder (Robert Bosch Tool Corporation, Prospect, IL) (Figures 1, 2 and 3) was fitted with a new 1/4-inch wide, 4½-inch diameter segmented diamond abrasive blade made by DeWalt (model #DW4740). The grinder weighs six and a half pounds, draws 8.5 amps and has a variable speed up to 11,000 revolutions per minute (RPMs). The DustControl 2900c vacuum (DustControl, Inc., Wilmington, NC) (Figure 3) was tested in combination with the Dust Director shroud (Industrial Contractors’ Supplies, Inc., Huntingdon, PA) (Figures 1 and 3) attached to the Bosch grinder.
Figure 1. Bosch grinder with Dust Director shroud
Figure 2. Bosch grinder without tuckpointing LEV system.
Figure 3: Bosch Grinder with LEV System
The vacuum is specified to weigh 31 pounds when empty and to provide a flow rate of 114 cubic feet of air per minute and a “static lift” or “vacuum suction pressure” of 84 inches of water. The vacuum is sold with a cyclonic pre-separator, to remove larger particles, a fine filter (rated 99.9 percent efficient) and a HEPA (high-efficiency particulate air) filter (rated to capture 99.97 percent of the particles with an aerodynamic diameter of 0.3 micrometers). The HEPA filter was removed based on the manufacturer’s recommendation due to the heavy dust loading associated with tuckpointing. CPWR sponsored research and contractor experience indicate that HEPA filters likely have an adverse effect on dust capture during tuckpointing because of extreme dust loading on filters. While the cyclone and the fine filter remove most of the dust, especially the large particles, before they reach the HEPA filter, the HEPA filter would still be subject to heavy loading, causing a substantial pressure drop and subsequent decrease in air flow rate. The relatively small increase in the efficiency of the filtration system while using the HEPA filter is expected to be quickly offset by a more significant decrease in capture efficiency as the air flow rate and ability to capture particles decreases.
Dust collects in relatively inexpensive, heavy-gauge plastic bags below and outside of the cyclone. The bags can be removed and replaced without opening the vacuum. Some vacuums are equipped with a light to indicate that the filters need to be cleaned or changed. The DC2900c features a “reverse air pulse cleaning system,” which removes accumulated dust from the filters without having to remove them from the vacuum. The system, as illustrated in Figure 4, requires the operator to disconnect the hose from the shroud, place it over an air stop so that air through the hose is cut off and pressure in the vacuum is maximized.
Figure 4. Procedure for "cleaning" of or dust removal from filters (source: http://dustcontrolusa.com/manuals/2800c.pdf)
The flap covering the port on the side of the vacuum is repeatedly flipped open to release built up pressure in strong pulses that dislodge dust from the filter.
The manufacturer indicates “the filter is generally cleaned once or twice daily during normal continuous operation.” The Dust Director shroud has a 2-inch diameter take-off that was connected to the antistatic, corrugated 1.5-inch diameter, 15-foot long vacuum hose supplied with the DustControl vacuum.
IV. Study Methods
This evaluation was conducted at the International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craft workers (IUBAC) Local 1 Philadelphia/Delaware Training Center in Philadelphia, PA on November 14 and 15, 2012. A single journeyman bricklayer, experienced in tuckpointing, used the grinder and LEV system being tested to remove mortar from joints wide enough to require two passes. The type S mortar had been allowed to cure for at least four weeks. The bricklayer either possessed or was provided with personal protective equipment including sturdy work boots, gloves, hearing protection and a powered air-purifying respirator (PAPR). The PAPR was a 3M GVP system with a bump cap, loose fitting face piece and a HEPA filter (3M, St Paul, MN).
The study was designed to include at least five rounds of sampling during mortar removal. Each round included a trial using the Bosch grinder with a Dust Director shroud and Dust Collector 2900c vacuum and a trial using the Bosch grinder with the factory-supplied guard and without a vacuum. The order of the two trials within each round was randomly selected to minimize bias that might be introduced due to variation associated with environmental factors, equipment operator, blade wear, vacuum performance over time and any other factors unrelated to LEV use. Tools were operated for approximately 16 minutes per trial with controls and for approximately 8 minutes when controls were not used. These times were selected based on the results of previous sampling efforts and estimates of the minimum sample time needed to achieve a limit of quantification low enough to accurately measure exposures down to or less than 0.05 mg/m3 – the NIOSH Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) for respirable silica. The bricklayer was required to take a 5 to 10 minute break in the middle of the 16-minute trials to reduce differences in fatigue, compared to the 8-minute trials. Personal air samples were collected in the breathing zone of the operator during each trial to measure respirable silica concentrations during grinding with and without LEV. The samples were collected using a GilAir-5 pump (Sensidyne, Inc., Clearwater, FL) to draw 4.2 liters of air per minute through a GK2.69 Respirable Cyclone (BGI Inc., Waltham, MA) with a pre-weighed, 37 mm diameter, 5-micron pore size polyvinyl chloride (PVC) filter positioned on the operator’s lapel.
The flow rates of the sampling pumps were calibrated at the beginning of each day using a DryCal DC-Lite Primary Flow Meter (Bios International Corporation, Butler, NJ). Flow rates were measured again near the middle and at the end of each day to ensure that sampling flow rates were maintained within 5% of pre-sampling flow rates throughout the day. Average flow rates were used to calculate sample air volumes. Samples were analyzed by R.J. Lee Group, Inc., (Monroeville, PA) using NIOSH Method 0600, to determine exposure to total mass of respirable dust. The same samples were also analyzed using X-Ray diffraction following NIOSH method 7500 to determine quartz, cristobalite and tridymite concentration in the respirable mass. Reported masses for these analytes were used with the sample air volumes to calculate airborne concentrations of total respirable dust, quartz, cristobalite and tridymite.
We used a reduction of greater than 50 percent in respirable silica exposure concentrations or a reduction to less than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 as our criteria for determining whether or not a control was considered efficacious. This is consistent with criteria used by NIOSH in conducting a similar study in 2004 described by Echt et al. (2007) and by CPWR in 2006 and described by Meeker et al. (2009). The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) and the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) publish additional occupational exposure limits (OELs) for silica which are listed in Table 1 with NIOSH RELs. OELs for silica are based on the respirable fraction of the aerosol, which consists of particles less than 10 micrometers in aerodynamic diameter.
| Organization or Agency | Form of Crystalline Silica | Occupational Exposure Limits (mg/m3) |
|---|---|---|
| NIOSHA | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 |
| OSHA - ConstructionB | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
PEL = 250 / (5 + % quartz) PEL = 250 / (5 + % cristobalite) PEL = 250 / (5 + % tridymite) |
| ACGIH | Crystalline Silica | TLV = 0.025 mg/m3 |
A NIOSH Publication No. 2005-151 indicates 10-hour time-weighted average during a 40-hr workweek B The PEL for silica in OSHA’s Safety and Health Regulations for Construction, 29 C.F.R. 1926.55(a), is an 8-hour time-weighted average (TWA) expressed in millions of particles per cubic foot (mppcf). However, the units mppcf can be converted to milligrams per cubic meter can by dividing mppcf by 10 (OSHA, 2009). The formula used by OSHA to determine the PEL for silica is dependent on the percentage of silica in each collected sample. The concentration of respirable dust measured is compared to the sample specific PEL to determine if the PEL has been exceeded. OSHA has proposed lowering the PEL to 0.05 mg/m3 of respirable silica as an 8 hour TWA. |
||
The flow of air in ventilation systems is governed by fundamental principles that describe the behavior of gases (in this case air). Pressure measurements taken within a ventilation system along with knowledge of hood (or shroud) entry losses can be used to calculate flow rates. Hood entry losses are dependent on the shape and configuration of a particular hood or shroud and described by the term “coefficient of entry (Ce)” which is the ratio of actual air flow through a hood and what the air flow would theoretically be if there were no hood entry losses. Given the coefficient of entry, static pressure measurements can be used to calculate air flow through a given hood. The coefficient of entry for the Dust Director shroud was previously determined by CPWR and used for calculating air flow based on static pressure measurements (Meeker et al., 2009). Static pressure, with the vacuum operating, was measured periodically throughout the evaluation to monitor the changes in air-flow rate following use and again after filter cleaning. The static pressure was measured at a port positioned more than 3 duct diameters downstream from the tool’s air intake using a UEi EM200 Electronic Manometer (Universal Enterprises, Inc., Beaverton, OR).
The dust in the vacuum bag was monitored and, per the manufacturer’s instructions, the bag was changed before the dust level was within 5 centimeters of the valve at the bottom of the vacuum. Each time a vacuum bag was removed, it was weighed to the nearest pound. The bag weights and corresponding grinding durations were used to calculate the average weight of dust collected per unit time. After each trial, cut lengths were measured on the wall to determine total linear feet of vertical (head) and horizontal (bed) joints per unit time.
A Haz-Dust III, Model HD-1003, Real-Time Aerosol Monitor (Environmental Devices Corporation, Plaistow, NH) was used to confirm clearance of dust between trials. The Haz-Dust monitor was positioned on the test wall near the operator at approximately breathing zone level and configured to measure respirable particulate concentration.
V. Results
Personal air monitoring
Five pairs of respirable dust samples were collected while grinding with and without the vacuum system. In addition, three respirable dust samples were collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place. One measurement collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard was shown to be a statistical outlier and was omitted from analysis. Personal air monitoring results for respirable silica and a comparison of average exposures relative to the NIOSH REL for silica (0.05 mg/m3) appears in Table 2. The mean respirable dust levels measured without LEV was 31.4 mg/m3. However, samples collected with LEV were below the limit of quantification (LOQ) which ranged from <1.29 to <1.46 mg/m3. Use of LEV resulted in a greater than 95% reduction in mean respirable dust levels using a mean value with use of LEV of <1.41 (n=5 samples with use of LEV and n=7 without use of LEV). The respirable dust samples collected during grinding without the LEV system contained an average of 24 percent silica. The mass of respirable dust in the samples collected with use of the LEV system was too low to determine the silica content.| Mean, mg/m3 (range) | Std. Dev. | Percent Reduction | Hazard RatioB | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bosch with Dust Director Shroud and DustControl 2900c Vacuum |
0.091 (<0.069 – 0.137) |
0.027 | 98.7 | 1.81 |
| Bosch with no Control | 7.23 (4.57 – 9.90) |
1.94 | NA | 145 |
A n = 5 samples for each tool/control combination and n = 7 samples without the use of the LEV system B Hazard Ratio = measured exposure / NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 |
||||
Average respirable silica and dust exposures, with and without the dust control system, appear as Figures 5 and 6, respectively.
Figure 5. Average respirable silica exposures with and without the Dustcontrol 2900c vacuum and Dust Director shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air - mg/m3)
Figure 6. Average respirable dust exposures with and without Dustcontrol 2900c Vacuum and Dust Director Shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air – mg/m3)
The mean respirable silica concentration measured during use of the control was significantly less than the concentration measured while using the same tool without controls (p<0.01). Grinding mortar with the Bosch angle grinder without dust controls resulted in an average exposure to respirable silica that was 145 times the NIOSH REL. Grinding with the Bosch angle grinder in combination with the Dust Director shroud and the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced the average concentration of respirable silica by 98.7 percent. With use of these controls, the concentration of respirable silica was 1.8 times greater than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3. However the NIOSH REL is based on a time-weighted average (TWA) over a 10-hour workday. Given these were task TWAs and samples were collected over continuous periods of grinding, they may overestimate exposures over an actual work day since some time would be spent performing tasks that would likely have lower, or no, silica exposures (setup, breaks, cleanup, etc.).
Static pressure, dust mass collection and grinding rates.
Static pressure was used as a surrogate for air flow as described earlier. Hood static pressure was measured periodically at a tap near the grinder more than 3 duct diameters from the air intake in the shroud. The static pressure, and thus air flow, was generally higher when the vacuum’s filter had recently been cleaned. The mean, median, and range of calculated flow rates are presented in Table A1 of the Appendix.
Based on the data we collected, the air-flow rate upstream from the Bosch grinder and Dust Director shroud ranged from 78 to 93 cubic feet per minute (cfm) with the DustControl vacuum. When the manufacturer’s filter cleaning procedure was followed the vacuum performed relatively well and flow could be maintained at slightly less than 90 cfm with cleaning. However, mean flow rates dropped substantially to 80 cfm after as little as 8 minutes of grinding without any filter cleaning. The flow rate returned to an average of 89 cfm when filters were cleaned correctly (without stopping air flow to the vacuum). Collingwood and Heitbrink (2007) found that the minimum exhaust flow rate for capture of silica and other particulate under ideal conditions is 21.25 cfm per inch of grinder blade diameter. This is equal to about 96 cfm when using a 4.5 inch diameter grinding blade. We set 106 cfm as the minimum desired flow rate for this study to allow a safety margin for potential decline in equipment performance and the possibility of inadequate maintenance, both of which may be likely after repeated use under actual work conditions. The DustControl vacuum provided slightly less than the minimum flow rate described by Collingwood and Heitbrink for a 4.5-inch blade and the peak flow rate fell with use.
The duration of vacuum bag use and mass of dust collected were recorded and are presented in Table A2 of the Appendix. The vacuum bags were changed and weighed after each trial utilizing the LEV system. A total of five bags were used to complete the five rounds of grinding. The DustControl vacuum captured 45 pounds of dust over 83 minutes of grinding for an average rate of dust collection of 0.54 pounds per minute. The rate of dust collection ranged from 0.47 to 0.63 pounds per minute. Based on these measurements, approximately 130 pounds of dust would likely be captured after just 4 hours of continuous grinding.
The rate of grinding a combination of vertical and horizontal joints while using the LEV system ranged from 2.3 to 3.3 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the use of the LEV system ranged from 2.6 to 3.4 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place ranged from 4.7 to 5.1 feet per minute. It’s important to note that: 1) the operator had limited experience using dust control systems and cut rates appeared to improve slightly over the 2-day period he used the tested equipment; and 2) the upper range of cut rates with the dust control system overlapped with the lowest cut rate with the original guard and without the LEV system in place indicating no statistical difference between cut rates. Given that grinding rates with and without use of this LEV system are only available for one operator and he had limited experience with the LEV system, these reported cut rates are in no way intended to represent the impact use of this LEV system is likely to have on productivity rates overall.
VI. Discussion
The objective of these trials was to evaluate the effectiveness of a tuckpointing LEV system for controlling respirable silica while grinding out mortar joints. The Dust Director shroud with the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced respirable silica concentrations when grinding with the Bosch grinder by approximately 99 percent. Despite being considered effective by our test criteria (greater than 50% reduction), it still resulted in task TWA exposures that exceeded the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 by 1.8 times. Depending on how much time is spent grinding over the course of a work day and on exposures while performing other tasks, the 8-hour TWA exposures may or may not exceed the REL with this system. Use of this system by workers with experience and training in proficient use will likely improve dust capture performance. Exposure reduction is greatly influenced by correct use of this system which includes grinding from right to left, making sure the shroud is held flush against the wall and that the tool travels at a pace that doesn’t exceed the ability of the system to capture dust as it’s generated. Deviation from any of these measures produces visible dust clouds which were observed during trials.
VII. Conclusions
With a 99 percent reduction in respirable silica exposure, the Dust Director shroud and DustControl 2900c vacuum with a Bosch Model 1775E grinder was effective in reducing silica exposures based on our criteria. Use of the tested dust control system may be effective in reducing silica exposure on the job to less than the NIOSH REL if used in combination with administrative controls such as work scheduling to reduce cutting times as needed. Training on correct use of the tested system is also essential. Personal air monitoring is necessary to verify control effectiveness on actual job sites and under “real-world” conditions. However, these results clearly demonstrate the availability of viable and effective engineering controls for tuckpointing operations associated with elevated silica exposure.
VIII. References
American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists. Threshold limit values for chemical substances (TLV®-CS). [2013]. ACGIH, Cincinnati, Ohio.
Bergdahl I.A,. Toren K., Eriksson K., et al. [2004]. Increased mortality in COPD among construction workers exposed to inorganic dust. European Respiratory Journal, 23: 402–06.
Blanc P.D. & Torén K. [2007]. Occupation in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and chronic bronchitis: an update [State of the Art Series. Occupational lung disease in high-and low-income countries, Edited by M. Chan-Yeung. Number 2 in the series]. The International Journal of Tuberculosis and Lung Disease, 11(3), 251-257.
Collingwood S. & Heitbrink W.A. [2007] 'Field Evaluation of an Engineering Control for Respirable Crystalline Silica Exposures During Mortar Removal'. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, 4:11, 875 – 887.
DHHS (NIOSH) Publication No. 2002-129 April 2002 http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/2002-129/
Echt A., Sieber W.K., Lefkowitz D., Meeker J., Susi P., Cardwell B., Heitbrink, W.A. In-depth survey of dust control technology for cutting concrete block and tuckpointing brick at The International Masonry Institute Bordentown Training Center, Bordentown, NJ. Cincinnati, OH: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Report. No. EPHB 282-13; 2007. http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ECTB-282-13.pdf
Heitbrink W., Bennett J. [2006]. A numerical and experimental investigation of crystalline silica exposure control during tuck pointing. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, Vol. 3, pp 366-378.
Lyons et al, [2007]. A breathless builder. Breathe, Vol. 3, no. 4, pp 386-390.
Mastrangelo G., Tartari M., Fedeli U., Fadda E., Saia B. [2003]. Ascertaining the risk of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease in relation to occupation using a case-control design. Occupational Medicine, 53: 165–172.
Meeker J., Cooper M., Lefrowitz D., Susi P. [2009]. Engineering control technologies to reduce occupational silica exposures in masonry cutting and tuckpointing. Public Health Reports, Supplement 1, Vol. 124, June.
Meeker J, Flynn M, Susi P, Cardwell, B [2004]. Performance evaluation of a masonry concrete vacuum. Unpublished Report.
Miller F. W., Alfredsson L., Costenbader K. H., Kamen D. L., Nelson L. M., Norris J. M., & De Roos A. J. [2012]. Epidemiology of environmental exposures and human autoimmune diseases: findings from a National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences Expert Panel workshop. Journal of autoimmunity. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3496812/
Occupational Safety and Health Administration U.S Department of Labor. Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction. [2009]. OSHA 3362-05.
Rappaport SM, Goldberg M, Susi P, Herrick RF [2003]. Excessive exposure to silica in the U.S. construction industry. Annals of Occupational Hygiene, Vol. 47, pp. 111-122.
IX. Appendices
| Measurement Conditions |
n | Mean Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Median
Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before filter cleaning | 5 | 80 | 81 | 78-81 |
| After filter cleaning following manufacturer directions | 9 | 89 | 90 | 84-93 |
| * Static pressure was measured in millibars and converted to inches of water gauge. Flow rates were calculated using the formula Q = Ce (A) 4005 (SP)1/2 where: Q = flow in cubic feet per minute (cfm), Ce = coefficient of entry, A = area of the duct where static pressure measurements were taken in square feet, and SP = static pressure in inches of water gauge. | ||||
| Tool/Control | Collection Period (min.) |
Dust Collection Rate (lb/min.) |
|---|---|---|
| Bosch grinder/Dust Director shroud & DustControl 2900c vacuum |
8 11 8 8 10 |
0.50 0.61 0.50 0.47 0.63 |
| Average | 0.54 |
[disclaimer:protected] => [disclaimer_transformed:protected] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [template] => record ) [_globalContext:PHPTAL_Context:private] => stdClass Object ( ) [_echoDeclarations:PHPTAL_Context:private] => [referer] => http://www.elcosh.org/document/3908/d001345/An%2BEvaluation%2Bof%2BSilica%2BExposure%2BControls%2Bfor%2BTuckpointing%253A%2BDustControl%2B2900c%2BVacuum%2Bwith%2Bthe%2BICS%2BDust%2BDirector%2BShroud%2Band%2BBosch%2BGrinder%2BModel%2B1775E%2BConducted%2BNovember%2B14-15%252C%2B2012.html [curr_module] => Record [styles] => Array ( ) [javascript] => Array ( [0] => jquery.min.js ) [metas] => Array ( [language] => en [robots] => index, follow ) [user] => [curr_url] => https://www.elcosh.org/index.php?module=Record&id=3908&type=document [base_url] => https://www.elcosh.org/index.php?module=Record [title] => eLCOSH : An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: DustControl 2900c Vacuum with the ICS Dust Director Shroud and Bosch Grinder Model 1775E Conducted November 14-15, 2012 [language] => en [search_query] => [module] => Record [new_records] => Array ( [0] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Fixed Ladder [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Fixed Ladders addresses the potential risks associated with using fixed ladders. The resource includes a brief case example,... [category] => Array ( [0] => 15 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 53 [5] => 55 [6] => 60 [7] => 64 [8] => 73 [9] => 76 [10] => 78 [11] => 80 [12] => 86 [13] => 87 [14] => 90 [15] => 92 [16] => 93 [17] => 94 [18] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Falls [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Concrete Polisher [11] => Electrical Worker [13] => HVAC [15] => Laborer [17] => PCC/Restoration [19] => Plumber/Pipefitter [21] => Roofer/Waterproofer [23] => Sheetmetal Worker [25] => Welder [27] => Commercial & Institutional [28] => Jobsites [29] => Industrial [31] => LEED/Green Construction [33] => Renovations [35] => Residential [37] => Toolbox Talks [38] => Documents [39] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4430/d001660/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BFixed%2BLadder.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [53] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 53 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Concrete Polisher [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [73] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 73 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => PCC/Restoration [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4430 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001660 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Fixed Ladder [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Fixed Ladders, Fall Prevention, Falls [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Fixed Ladders addresses the potential risks associated with using fixed ladders. The resource includes a brief case example, steps to prevent a related injury and questions for discussion. It includes an image that illustrates the hazard, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001257,d001254,d001255,d001256,d001258,d001262,d001279 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_completed:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/22/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [1] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Challenges Preventing Falling Objects [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Challenges Preventing Falling Objects addresses the hazards of being struck by falling objects on the job site. The resource... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 55 [5] => 64 [6] => 68 [7] => 71 [8] => 75 [9] => 78 [10] => 79 [11] => 82 [12] => 62 [13] => 86 [14] => 87 [15] => 88 [16] => 89 [17] => 91 [18] => 90 [19] => 92 [20] => 93 [21] => 94 [22] => 95 [23] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Electrical Worker [11] => Laborer [13] => Maintenance Worker [15] => Painter [17] => Plasterer [19] => Roofer/Waterproofer [21] => Scaffold Erector [23] => Stonemason [25] => Structural Ironworker [27] => Welder [29] => Commercial & Institutional [30] => Jobsites [31] => Demolition [33] => Disasters [35] => Heavy & Highway [37] => Industrial [39] => LEED/Green Construction [41] => Renovations [43] => Residential [45] => Underground [47] => Toolbox Talks [48] => Documents [49] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4431/d001661/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BChallenges%2BPreventing%2BFalling%2BObjects.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4431 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001661 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Challenges Preventing Falling Objects [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => dropped objects, falling objects, struck by incidents, struck by fatalities [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Challenges Preventing Falling Objects addresses the hazards of being struck by falling objects on the job site. The resource includes a brief example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates a group workers observing a scaffold free of debris during high winds, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001234,d001238,d001244,d001251,d001253,d001260,d001268,d001278 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_completed:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/22/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [2] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Tower Crane Safety [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Tower Crane Safety addresses the potential hazards of Tower Cranes and the importance of following procedure before and durin... [category] => Array ( [0] => 11 [1] => 12 [2] => 18 [3] => 70 [4] => 87 [5] => 88 [6] => 91 [7] => 90 [8] => 92 [9] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Cranes & Hoists [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Crushed/Struck By [6] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [9] => Operating Engineer [10] => Trades [11] => Commercial & Institutional [12] => Jobsites [13] => Demolition [15] => Heavy & Highway [17] => Industrial [19] => LEED/Green Construction [21] => Toolbox Talks [22] => Documents [23] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4427/d001657/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BTower%2BCrane%2BSafety.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [11] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 11 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Cranes & Hoists [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [18] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 18 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4427 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001657 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Tower Crane Safety [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Tower Crane, Crane, Stability, Tipping, Lift Zone Safety, Lift, Zone, Safety, Struck by [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Tower Crane Safety addresses the potential hazards of Tower Cranes and the importance of following procedure before and during Tower Crane operation. The resource includes a brief example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates a worker inspecting a Tower Crane before operation, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001234,d001238,d001250,d001251,d001253,d001258,d001262,d001273 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/19/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [3] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Work Zone Safety: Working Around Vehicles [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Working Around Vehicles in the Work Zone addresses methods to avoid being struck-by a vehicle on a construction site. The res... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 18 [2] => 52 [3] => 57 [4] => 70 [5] => 85 [6] => 87 [7] => 88 [8] => 89 [9] => 91 [10] => 90 [11] => 92 [12] => 93 [13] => 94 [14] => 95 [15] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [6] => Commercial Diver [7] => Trades [8] => Flagger [10] => Operating Engineer [12] => Truck Driver [14] => Commercial & Institutional [15] => Jobsites [16] => Demolition [18] => Disasters [20] => Heavy & Highway [22] => Industrial [24] => LEED/Green Construction [26] => Renovations [28] => Residential [30] => Underground [32] => Toolbox Talks [33] => Documents [34] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4428/d001658/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BWork%2BZone%2BSafety%253A%2BWorking%2BAround%2BVehicles.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [18] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 18 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [52] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 52 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Commercial Diver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [85] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 85 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Truck Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4428 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001658 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Daniela Caceres [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Work Zone Safety: Working Around Vehicles [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Struck, Struck by, Vehicle, Work Zone Safety, Truck, Operator, Driver, Mobile Equipment [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Working Around Vehicles in the Work Zone addresses methods to avoid being struck-by a vehicle on a construction site. The resource includes a case example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates the hazard, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001640 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/19/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [4] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Construction Dive -- DeWalt's Jobsite Pro headphones recalled for fire hazards [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => A recall notice by the United States Consumer Product Safety Commission affects over 300,000 DeWalt Jobsite Pro Headphones. The recall is a result of... [category] => Array ( [0] => 16 [1] => 44 [2] => 45 [3] => 46 [4] => 47 [5] => 48 [6] => 49 [7] => 50 [8] => 51 [9] => 52 [10] => 53 [11] => 54 [12] => 55 [13] => 56 [14] => 57 [15] => 58 [16] => 59 [17] => 60 [18] => 61 [19] => 64 [20] => 65 [21] => 66 [22] => 67 [23] => 68 [24] => 69 [25] => 70 [26] => 71 [27] => 72 [28] => 73 [29] => 74 [30] => 75 [31] => 76 [32] => 77 [33] => 63 [34] => 78 [35] => 79 [36] => 80 [37] => 81 [38] => 82 [39] => 62 [40] => 83 [41] => 84 [42] => 85 [43] => 86 [44] => 87 [45] => 88 [46] => 89 [47] => 91 [48] => 90 [49] => 92 [50] => 93 [51] => 94 [52] => 95 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Fire & Explosions [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Acoustical Ceiling Carpenter [4] => Trades [5] => Asbestos/Insulator [7] => Boilermaker [9] => Bricklayer [11] => Cabinetmaker [13] => Carpenter [15] => Carpet Layer [17] => Cement Mason [19] => Commercial Diver [21] => Concrete Polisher [23] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [25] => Electrical Worker [27] => Elevator Constructor [29] => Flagger [31] => Glazier [33] => Hazardous Waste Cleanup [35] => HVAC [37] => Interior Systems Carpenter [39] => Laborer [41] => Landscaper [43] => Lather [45] => Lead Abatement Worker [47] => Maintenance Worker [49] => Millwright [51] => Operating Engineer [53] => Painter [55] => Paper Hanger [57] => PCC/Restoration [59] => Pile Driver [61] => Plasterer [63] => Plumber/Pipefitter [65] => Refractory Worker [67] => Reinforcing Ironworker [69] => Roofer/Waterproofer [71] => Scaffold Erector [73] => Sheetmetal Worker [75] => Sprinkler Fitter [77] => Stonemason [79] => Structural Ironworker [81] => Terrazzo Worker [83] => Tile Setter [85] => Truck Driver [87] => Welder [89] => Commercial & Institutional [90] => Jobsites [91] => Demolition [93] => Disasters [95] => Heavy & Highway [97] => Industrial [99] => LEED/Green Construction [101] => Renovations [103] => Residential [105] => Underground ) [type] => [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4426/d001656/Construction%2BDive%2B--%2BDeWalt%2527s%2BJobsite%2BPro%2Bheadphones%2Brecalled%2Bfor%2Bfire%2Bhazards.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [16] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 16 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Fire & Explosions [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [44] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 44 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Acoustical Ceiling Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [45] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 45 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Asbestos/Insulator [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [46] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 46 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Boilermaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [48] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 48 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cabinetmaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [50] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 50 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpet Layer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [52] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 52 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Commercial Diver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [53] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 53 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Concrete Polisher [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [54] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 54 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [58] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 58 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Glazier [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [59] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 59 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Hazardous Waste Cleanup [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [65] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 65 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Landscaper [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [66] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 66 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Lather [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [67] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 67 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Lead Abatement Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [69] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 69 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Millwright [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [72] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 72 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Paper Hanger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [73] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 73 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => PCC/Restoration [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [77] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 77 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Refractory Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [81] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 81 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sprinkler Fitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [83] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 83 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Terrazzo Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [84] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 84 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Tile Setter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [85] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 85 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Truck Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4426 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001656 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Construction Dive -- DeWalt's Jobsite Pro headphones recalled for fire hazards [total_pages:protected] => 1 [billed_pages:protected] => 1 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => DeWalt, Fire Hazards, recall, headphones [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A recall notice by the United States Consumer Product Safety Commission affects over 300,000 DeWalt Jobsite Pro Headphones. The recall is a result of a malfunction that can cause earbuds to overheat while charging or during use, leading to fire and burn hazards. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => https://www.constructiondive.com/news/dewalts-jobsite-pro-headphones-recalled-for-fire-hazards/611248/?utm_source=Sailthru&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Issue:%202021-12-10%20Construction%20Dive%20Newsletter%20%5Bissue:38532%5D&utm_term=Construction%20Dive [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/13/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/13/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 12/13/21 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [new_images] => Array ( [0] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Morning Toolbox Talk [image] => /record/images/4003-p.jpg [blurb] => This photo is from an early morning toolbox talk on a construction job in Mclean, Virginia. It is being delivered in English and Spanish.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 20 [1] => 51 [2] => 57 [3] => 64 [4] => 70 [5] => 63 [6] => 78 [7] => 82 [8] => 62 [9] => 87 [10] => 88 [11] => 89 [12] => 91 [13] => 90 [14] => 93 [15] => 94 [16] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Safety Culture [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Cement Mason [4] => Trades [5] => Flagger [7] => Laborer [9] => Operating Engineer [11] => Reinforcing Ironworker [13] => Roofer/Waterproofer [15] => Stonemason [17] => Structural Ironworker [19] => Commercial & Institutional [20] => Jobsites [21] => Demolition [23] => Disasters [25] => Heavy & Highway [27] => Industrial [29] => Renovations [31] => Residential [33] => Images [34] => Media [35] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4003/i002691/Morning%2BToolbox%2BTalk.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4003 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002691 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Morning Toolbox Talk [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, Spanish, bilingual [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This photo is from an early morning toolbox talk on a construction job in Mclean, Virginia. It is being delivered in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001285,d001304,c000079 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [1] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox talk - crew view [image] => /record/images/4005-p.jpg [blurb] => Photo of crew listening to a toolbox safety talk before starting work.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 97 [1] => 20 [2] => 47 [3] => 49 [4] => 51 [5] => 55 [6] => 61 [7] => 64 [8] => 71 [9] => 75 [10] => 63 [11] => 79 [12] => 62 [13] => 87 [14] => 88 [15] => 91 [16] => 90 [17] => 93 [18] => 94 [19] => 95 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Images [1] => Media [2] => Media & Documents [3] => Safety Culture [4] => Work Environment [5] => Hazards [6] => Bricklayer [7] => Trades [8] => Carpenter [10] => Cement Mason [12] => Electrical Worker [14] => Interior Systems Carpenter [16] => Laborer [18] => Painter [20] => Plasterer [22] => Reinforcing Ironworker [24] => Scaffold Erector [26] => Structural Ironworker [28] => Commercial & Institutional [29] => Jobsites [30] => Demolition [32] => Heavy & Highway [34] => Industrial [36] => Renovations [38] => Residential [40] => Underground ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4005/i002692/Toolbox%2Btalk%2B-%2Bcrew%2Bview.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4005 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002692 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox talk - crew view [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, safety talk, Spanish [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Photo of crew listening to a toolbox safety talk before starting work. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002691,d001269, c000079, d001285 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [2] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox talk - long shot [image] => /record/images/4006-p.jpg [blurb] => This crew gathered every morning before starting work to discuss a new safety topic.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 20 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 55 [5] => 64 [6] => 68 [7] => 75 [8] => 76 [9] => 63 [10] => 78 [11] => 79 [12] => 82 [13] => 62 [14] => 87 [15] => 88 [16] => 91 [17] => 90 [18] => 93 [19] => 94 [20] => 95 [21] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Safety Culture [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Electrical Worker [11] => Laborer [13] => Maintenance Worker [15] => Plasterer [17] => Plumber/Pipefitter [19] => Reinforcing Ironworker [21] => Roofer/Waterproofer [23] => Scaffold Erector [25] => Stonemason [27] => Structural Ironworker [29] => Commercial & Institutional [30] => Jobsites [31] => Demolition [33] => Heavy & Highway [35] => Industrial [37] => Renovations [39] => Residential [41] => Underground [43] => Images [44] => Media [45] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4006/i002693/Toolbox%2Btalk%2B-%2Blong%2Bshot.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4006 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002693 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox talk - long shot [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, safety minute [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This crew gathered every morning before starting work to discuss a new safety topic. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002691,i002692,d001269,d000527 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [3] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Safety officer discussing ongoing project with marketing coordinator [image] => /record/images/4014-p.jpg [blurb] => The safety officer (left) points out the good safety practices on this project that reflect well on the firm and may influence future clients.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 97 [1] => 20 [2] => 46 [3] => 47 [4] => 49 [5] => 50 [6] => 51 [7] => 54 [8] => 55 [9] => 58 [10] => 60 [11] => 61 [12] => 64 [13] => 71 [14] => 75 [15] => 76 [16] => 63 [17] => 79 [18] => 80 [19] => 82 [20] => 62 [21] => 83 [22] => 87 [23] => 91 [24] => 90 [25] => 93 [26] => 94 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Images [1] => Media [2] => Media & Documents [3] => Safety Culture [4] => Work Environment [5] => Hazards [6] => Boilermaker [7] => Trades [8] => Bricklayer [10] => Carpenter [12] => Carpet Layer [14] => Cement Mason [16] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [18] => Electrical Worker [20] => Glazier [22] => HVAC [24] => Interior Systems Carpenter [26] => Laborer [28] => Painter [30] => Plasterer [32] => Plumber/Pipefitter [34] => Reinforcing Ironworker [36] => Scaffold Erector [38] => Sheetmetal Worker [40] => Stonemason [42] => Structural Ironworker [44] => Terrazzo Worker [46] => Commercial & Institutional [47] => Jobsites [48] => Heavy & Highway [50] => Industrial [52] => Renovations [54] => Residential ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4014/i002700/Safety%2Bofficer%2Bdiscussing%2Bongoing%2Bproject%2Bwith%2Bmarketing%2Bcoordinator.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [46] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 46 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Boilermaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [50] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 50 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpet Layer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [54] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 54 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [58] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 58 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Glazier [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [83] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 83 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Terrazzo Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4014 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002700 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Safety officer discussing ongoing project with marketing coordinator [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Latino, safety officer, safety culture [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The safety officer (left) points out the good safety practices on this project that reflect well on the firm and may influence future clients. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/index.php [more_like_this:protected] => d000989,d001351,d001362,d000652, d001101, d000931, d001395 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Hoar Construction, Photo by Neil Lippy [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 01/30/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [4] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Scaffolding at top of large column [image] => /record/images/3994-p.jpg [blurb] => This shot shows innovative guarding around the top of a large concrete column in the base of a high rise structure going up.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 15 [1] => 21 [2] => 47 [3] => 51 [4] => 63 [5] => 78 [6] => 79 [7] => 80 [8] => 62 [9] => 87 [10] => 97 [11] => 56 [12] => 64 [13] => 74 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Falls [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Scaffolds [6] => Bricklayer [7] => Trades [8] => Cement Mason [10] => Reinforcing Ironworker [12] => Roofer/Waterproofer [14] => Scaffold Erector [16] => Sheetmetal Worker [18] => Structural Ironworker [20] => Commercial & Institutional [21] => Jobsites [22] => Images [23] => Media [24] => Media & Documents [25] => Elevator Constructor [27] => Laborer [29] => Pile Driver ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/3994/i002689/Scaffolding%2Bat%2Btop%2Bof%2Blarge%2Bcolumn.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [21] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 21 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Scaffolds [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3994 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002689 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Scaffolding at top of large column [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Guardrail, railing, fall prevention, falls [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This shot shows innovative guarding around the top of a large concrete column in the base of a high rise structure going up. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/8/adjustable-tower-scaffold.html [more_like_this:protected] => c1002680,i002662,d000608,d001255 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Photo by Pam Susi [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2016 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_completed:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/01/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [5] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Construction bracing [image] => /record/images/3995-p.jpg [blurb] => This shows structural support that prevents collapses during construction.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 15 [2] => 21 [3] => 49 [4] => 51 [5] => 55 [6] => 56 [7] => 60 [8] => 64 [9] => 68 [10] => 74 [11] => 63 [12] => 78 [13] => 79 [14] => 80 [15] => 62 [16] => 87 [17] => 90 [18] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Falls [6] => Scaffolds [9] => Carpenter [10] => Trades [11] => Cement Mason [13] => Electrical Worker [15] => Elevator Constructor [17] => HVAC [19] => Laborer [21] => Maintenance Worker [23] => Pile Driver [25] => Reinforcing Ironworker [27] => Roofer/Waterproofer [29] => Scaffold Erector [31] => Sheetmetal Worker [33] => Structural Ironworker [35] => Commercial & Institutional [36] => Jobsites [37] => Industrial [39] => Images [40] => Media [41] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/3995/i002690/Construction%2Bbracing.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [21] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 21 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Scaffolds [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3995 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002690 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Construction bracing [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Bracing, support, scaffold [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This shows structural support that prevents collapses during construction. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/8/adjustable-tower-scaffold.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002660 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Photo by Pam Susi [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2016 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_completed:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/01/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [preview_mode] => [description] => The results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. [keywords] => tuckpointing, HEPA vacuum, dust control, LEV, local exhaust ventilation, silica [related_items] => Array ( [Research Reports] => Array ( [0] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1874 [old_id:protected] => 722 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000683 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Sharon Garber/COD [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Protecting Tuckpointing Workers from Silica Dust: Draft Recommendations for a Ventilated Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 12 [billed_pages:protected] => 12 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, vacuum, grinder, mortar, respirator, OSHA, NIOSH, exhaust, Heitbrink, tuckpointer, silica, masonry, dust, silicosis, LEV [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Describes draft recommendations for use of ventilated grinder to reduce dust during tuckpointing and describes field trials using these devices. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/hazard/67/chip-scrape-and-grind-surfaces-or-joints-silica.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001201,d000292,d000293,d000658 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2005 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/27/05 [date_completed:protected] => 04/26/05 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/20/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [1] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1940 [old_id:protected] => 909 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Workplace Solutions: Control of Hazardous Dust During Tuckpointing [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, silica, dust, tuckpoint, grinder, masonry restoration, mortar, vacuum [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d000819,d000820,d000730,d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 10/24/08 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/09 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [2] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3899 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001342 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: Hilti VC40-U Vacuum with Hilti DC-EX Dust Guard and Hilti Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 15 [billed_pages:protected] => 15 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP4 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => silica, tuckpointing, Hilti, local exhaust systems, LEV, shroud, quartz [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This report describes the results of an evaluation of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Hilti VC40-U vacuum, a Hilti DC-EX shroud, and a Hilti DAG-500 grinder. Randomized trials with and without use of the dust control system were conducted in a controlled setting. Removing mortar with the Hilti grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 220 times the National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05mg/m3. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 97 percent. However, exposures measured during the use of the dust control system still exceeded the NIOSH REL. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => December 1, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/05/14 [date_completed:protected] => 02/04/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/06/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [Handouts] => Array ( [0] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3656 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001198 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 24 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction While Doing Tuckpointing/Mortar Removal [total_pages:protected] => 2 [billed_pages:protected] => 2 [publication_number:protected] => DSG FS-3632 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Brick, block, tuckpointing, silica, local exhaust ventilation, LEV, masonry [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Tuckpointing creates some of the greatest exposures to silica in construction. This OSHA factsheet provides guidance on how to greatly reduce these exposures through the use of local exhaust ventilation. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863, d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => February 2013 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/04/13 [date_completed:protected] => 03/27/13 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [collections] => Array ( [3913] => ) [record] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => Array ( [867] => Author Object ( [id:protected] => 867 [organization_id:protected] => 0 [firstname:protected] => Michael [lastname:protected] => Cooper [address:protected] => [city:protected] => [province:protected] => [country:protected] => [postal_code:protected] => [department:protected] => [title:protected] => [phone:protected] => [fax:protected] => [email:protected] => [degree:protected] => [website:protected] => [about:protected] => [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => [date_completed:protected] => [date_billed:protected] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [481] => Author Object ( [id:protected] => 481 [organization_id:protected] => 0 [firstname:protected] => Pam [lastname:protected] => Susi [address:protected] => 8484 Georgia Avenue, Suite 1000 [city:protected] => Silver Spring [province:protected] => Maryland [country:protected] => USA [postal_code:protected] => 20910 [department:protected] => [title:protected] => [phone:protected] => 301-578-8500 ext.144 [fax:protected] => 301-578-8572 [email:protected] => plsusi@aol.com [degree:protected] => [website:protected] => http://www.cpwr.com [about:protected] => [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => 2003-10-02 [date_completed:protected] => 2003-10-06 [date_billed:protected] => 2003-11-03 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [organizations:protected] => Array ( [1] => Organization Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [elcosh_id:protected] => o000001 [user_id:protected] => 14 [province_id:protected] => 21 [country_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => CPWR - The Center for Construction Research and Training [address:protected] => Suite 1000, 8484 Georgia Ave [postal_code:protected] => 20910 [city:protected] => Silver Spring [department:protected] => [phone:protected] => 301-578-8500 [fax:protected] => 301-578-8572 [email:protected] => cpwrwebsite@cpwr.com [website:protected] => http://www.cpwr.com [filename:protected] => o000001.gif [about:protected] => CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training, developed, and continues to maintain/expand this website - The Electronic Library of Construction Occupational Safety and Health, www.elcosh.org. CPWR, formerly known as The Center to Protect Workers’ Rights, is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit research and training institution. Created by the Building and Construction Trades Department, AFL-CIO, CPWR serves as the research arm of the BCTD. Since the inception of its research agenda in 1990, CPWR has grown into a worldwide provider of safety and health information covering all aspects of the construction industry. CPWR launched eLCOSH in 2000, and the Spanish-language version of the site in 2001. CPWR also created, and continues to build, Construction Solutions - www.cpwrConstructionSolutions.org - a free, online database of construction hazards and ways to prevent, eliminate, or reduce them. [comments:protected] => [logo_available:protected] => T [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => 2000-08-18 [date_completed:protected] => 2000-08-30 [date_billed:protected] => 2000-09-05 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [collections:protected] => Array ( [3913] => ) [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => Array ( [1874] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1874 [old_id:protected] => 722 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000683 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Sharon Garber/COD [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Protecting Tuckpointing Workers from Silica Dust: Draft Recommendations for a Ventilated Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 12 [billed_pages:protected] => 12 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, vacuum, grinder, mortar, respirator, OSHA, NIOSH, exhaust, Heitbrink, tuckpointer, silica, masonry, dust, silicosis, LEV [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Describes draft recommendations for use of ventilated grinder to reduce dust during tuckpointing and describes field trials using these devices. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/hazard/67/chip-scrape-and-grind-surfaces-or-joints-silica.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001201,d000292,d000293,d000658 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2005 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/27/05 [date_completed:protected] => 04/26/05 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/20/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [1940] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1940 [old_id:protected] => 909 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Workplace Solutions: Control of Hazardous Dust During Tuckpointing [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, silica, dust, tuckpoint, grinder, masonry restoration, mortar, vacuum [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d000819,d000820,d000730,d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 10/24/08 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/09 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [2213] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 2213 [old_id:protected] => 1090 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => [language_id:protected] => 2 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Control del polvo peligroso que se genera durante los procesos de reparación de mortero [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => 2008-126 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => [comments:protected] => http://www.cdc.gov/spanish/niosh/docs/wp-solutions/2008-126_sp/ [summary:protected] => A Workplace Solutions de NIOSH que resume un estudio de NIOSH sobre los riesgos de exposición cuando se reparan las estructuras y los métodos para controlar el polvo. [A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust.] [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => D000819,D000820,D000730,d000819 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 01/07/10 [date_completed:protected] => 04/19/10 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 07/08/12 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [3656] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3656 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001198 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 24 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction While Doing Tuckpointing/Mortar Removal [total_pages:protected] => 2 [billed_pages:protected] => 2 [publication_number:protected] => DSG FS-3632 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Brick, block, tuckpointing, silica, local exhaust ventilation, LEV, masonry [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Tuckpointing creates some of the greatest exposures to silica in construction. This OSHA factsheet provides guidance on how to greatly reduce these exposures through the use of local exhaust ventilation. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863, d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => February 2013 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/04/13 [date_completed:protected] => 03/27/13 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [3899] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3899 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001342 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: Hilti VC40-U Vacuum with Hilti DC-EX Dust Guard and Hilti Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 15 [billed_pages:protected] => 15 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP4 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => silica, tuckpointing, Hilti, local exhaust systems, LEV, shroud, quartz [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This report describes the results of an evaluation of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Hilti VC40-U vacuum, a Hilti DC-EX shroud, and a Hilti DAG-500 grinder. Randomized trials with and without use of the dust control system were conducted in a controlled setting. Removing mortar with the Hilti grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 220 times the National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05mg/m3. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 97 percent. However, exposures measured during the use of the dust control system still exceeded the NIOSH REL. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => December 1, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/05/14 [date_completed:protected] => 02/04/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/06/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [content:protected] => [files:protected] => Array ( [559] => [560] => [546] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 546 [filename:protected] => 3.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:22 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [566] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 566 [filename:protected] => 4.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:23 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [720] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 720 [filename:protected] => 5.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [721] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 721 [filename:protected] => 6.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [722] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 722 [filename:protected] => 7.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [9765] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 9765 [filename:protected] => d001345.pdf [downloadable:protected] => T [timestamp:protected] => 2015-02-09 12:26:04 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3908 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001345 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: DustControl 2900c Vacuum with the ICS Dust Director Shroud and Bosch Grinder Model 1775E Conducted November 14-15, 2012 [total_pages:protected] => 13 [billed_pages:protected] => 13 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP2 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => tuckpointing, HEPA vacuum, dust control, LEV, local exhaust ventilation, silica [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => April 15, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 01/26/15 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/09/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [show_text] => [document_content] => ElcoshItemDocumentContent Object ( [id:protected] => 2934 [item_id:protected] => 3908 [type:protected] => main [title:protected] => [content:protected] =>
Executive Summary
This report describes the results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. It should also be noted that the NIOSH REL is based on exposures averaged over a ten hour work day and our results represent time weighted averages of the sample task duration periods.
Acronyms
ACGIH - American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists
CPWR - CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training
Ce - coefficient of entry
HEPA - high-efficiency particulate air
IUBAC - International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craftworkers
LEV - local exhaust ventilation
PACT - Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies
NIOSH - National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health
OEL - occupational exposure limit
OSHA - Occupational Safety and Health Administration
PAPR - powered air-purifying respirator
PEL - Permissible Exposure Limit
PVC - polyvinyl chloride
REL - Recommended Exposure Limit
RPM - revolutions per minute
TWA - time-weighted average
SP - static pressure
I. Introduction and Background
In 2010 CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training began a four-year project which seeks to identify and evaluate tuckpointing local exhaust ventilation (LEV) systems and disseminate information on their availability and effectiveness. A Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies (PACT) comprised of masonry contractors, representatives from unions, government, equipment manufacturers, and health and safety researcher was formed as part of this project. PACT members participated in identifying important characteristics for control technologies and this information was used to identify LEV systems for tuckpointing using that criteria. Contractor and labor members of the PACT selected specific tuckpointing LEV systems to be considered for evaluation. Each system consisted of a tuckpointing grinder, shroud, and vacuum. This report describes the second of four systems to be evaluated between 2012 the end of 2014, with and without LEV, in a controlled setting to determine effectiveness in silica exposure reduction. This report describes the methods and results of our evaluation of a system consisting of the DustControl 2900c vacuum with the ICS Dust Director shroud and a Bosch Model 1775E grinder.
Excessive exposure to respirable silica can result in silicosis or other silica-related diseases including pulmonary tuberculosis, lung cancer, silicoproteinosis (Lyons et al, 2007) and autoimmune disorders such as rheumatoid arthritis, sarcoidosis and scleroderma (Miller et al, 2012). Respirable silica is generally defined as particles less than 10 micrometers (μm) in aerodynamic diameter (ACGIH, 2013). Silicosis can lead to symptoms including shortness of breath, fatigue, chest pains, susceptibility to infection and possibly death. There is no cure for silicosis, however it is totally preventable. Construction workers exposed to dust, including silica, are also known to have higher rates of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD).
There are many sources of silica in construction that result in exposures of varying intensity among workers. Masonry restoration workers are among the most highly silica-exposed trades in construction. The process of grinding out deteriorated mortar joints between masonry units and replacing or repointing with fresh mortar (often referred to as tuckpointing) is a fundamental part of masonry restoration work. The removal of mortar with powered angle grinders generates enormous levels of dust. Between 2004 and 2006, NIOSH and CPWR evaluated silica exposures while grinding mortar in a controlled setting, at a local training center, where tasks, sample times and task variables were defined by the study design. These studies demonstrated that grinding mortar without controls can result in elevated respirable silica exposures. Meeker et al., (2009) reported exposures between 5 and 25.8 milligrams per cubic meter (mg/m3) in a controlled setting. This study also showed that LEV systems for tuckpointing grinders can reduce exposures to respirable silica by greater than 90 percent.II. Objectives
The objective of this evaluation was to assess the effectiveness of an LEV system for controlling exposure to silica during the grinding of mortar. The control technology was tested under controlled conditions, similar to those experienced by tuckpointers on actual job sites, using journeymen bricklayers experienced in tuckpointing and repeat, randomized trials with and without LEV. All other variables were held constant throughout so that the only variable was whether or not the tested control was used.
III. Description of Equipment Tested
A Bosch model 1775E grinder (Robert Bosch Tool Corporation, Prospect, IL) (Figures 1, 2 and 3) was fitted with a new 1/4-inch wide, 4½-inch diameter segmented diamond abrasive blade made by DeWalt (model #DW4740). The grinder weighs six and a half pounds, draws 8.5 amps and has a variable speed up to 11,000 revolutions per minute (RPMs). The DustControl 2900c vacuum (DustControl, Inc., Wilmington, NC) (Figure 3) was tested in combination with the Dust Director shroud (Industrial Contractors’ Supplies, Inc., Huntingdon, PA) (Figures 1 and 3) attached to the Bosch grinder.
Figure 1. Bosch grinder with Dust Director shroud
Figure 2. Bosch grinder without tuckpointing LEV system.
Figure 3: Bosch Grinder with LEV System
The vacuum is specified to weigh 31 pounds when empty and to provide a flow rate of 114 cubic feet of air per minute and a “static lift” or “vacuum suction pressure” of 84 inches of water. The vacuum is sold with a cyclonic pre-separator, to remove larger particles, a fine filter (rated 99.9 percent efficient) and a HEPA (high-efficiency particulate air) filter (rated to capture 99.97 percent of the particles with an aerodynamic diameter of 0.3 micrometers). The HEPA filter was removed based on the manufacturer’s recommendation due to the heavy dust loading associated with tuckpointing. CPWR sponsored research and contractor experience indicate that HEPA filters likely have an adverse effect on dust capture during tuckpointing because of extreme dust loading on filters. While the cyclone and the fine filter remove most of the dust, especially the large particles, before they reach the HEPA filter, the HEPA filter would still be subject to heavy loading, causing a substantial pressure drop and subsequent decrease in air flow rate. The relatively small increase in the efficiency of the filtration system while using the HEPA filter is expected to be quickly offset by a more significant decrease in capture efficiency as the air flow rate and ability to capture particles decreases.
Dust collects in relatively inexpensive, heavy-gauge plastic bags below and outside of the cyclone. The bags can be removed and replaced without opening the vacuum. Some vacuums are equipped with a light to indicate that the filters need to be cleaned or changed. The DC2900c features a “reverse air pulse cleaning system,” which removes accumulated dust from the filters without having to remove them from the vacuum. The system, as illustrated in Figure 4, requires the operator to disconnect the hose from the shroud, place it over an air stop so that air through the hose is cut off and pressure in the vacuum is maximized.
Figure 4. Procedure for "cleaning" of or dust removal from filters (source: http://dustcontrolusa.com/manuals/2800c.pdf)
The flap covering the port on the side of the vacuum is repeatedly flipped open to release built up pressure in strong pulses that dislodge dust from the filter.
The manufacturer indicates “the filter is generally cleaned once or twice daily during normal continuous operation.” The Dust Director shroud has a 2-inch diameter take-off that was connected to the antistatic, corrugated 1.5-inch diameter, 15-foot long vacuum hose supplied with the DustControl vacuum.
IV. Study Methods
This evaluation was conducted at the International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craft workers (IUBAC) Local 1 Philadelphia/Delaware Training Center in Philadelphia, PA on November 14 and 15, 2012. A single journeyman bricklayer, experienced in tuckpointing, used the grinder and LEV system being tested to remove mortar from joints wide enough to require two passes. The type S mortar had been allowed to cure for at least four weeks. The bricklayer either possessed or was provided with personal protective equipment including sturdy work boots, gloves, hearing protection and a powered air-purifying respirator (PAPR). The PAPR was a 3M GVP system with a bump cap, loose fitting face piece and a HEPA filter (3M, St Paul, MN).
The study was designed to include at least five rounds of sampling during mortar removal. Each round included a trial using the Bosch grinder with a Dust Director shroud and Dust Collector 2900c vacuum and a trial using the Bosch grinder with the factory-supplied guard and without a vacuum. The order of the two trials within each round was randomly selected to minimize bias that might be introduced due to variation associated with environmental factors, equipment operator, blade wear, vacuum performance over time and any other factors unrelated to LEV use. Tools were operated for approximately 16 minutes per trial with controls and for approximately 8 minutes when controls were not used. These times were selected based on the results of previous sampling efforts and estimates of the minimum sample time needed to achieve a limit of quantification low enough to accurately measure exposures down to or less than 0.05 mg/m3 – the NIOSH Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) for respirable silica. The bricklayer was required to take a 5 to 10 minute break in the middle of the 16-minute trials to reduce differences in fatigue, compared to the 8-minute trials. Personal air samples were collected in the breathing zone of the operator during each trial to measure respirable silica concentrations during grinding with and without LEV. The samples were collected using a GilAir-5 pump (Sensidyne, Inc., Clearwater, FL) to draw 4.2 liters of air per minute through a GK2.69 Respirable Cyclone (BGI Inc., Waltham, MA) with a pre-weighed, 37 mm diameter, 5-micron pore size polyvinyl chloride (PVC) filter positioned on the operator’s lapel.
The flow rates of the sampling pumps were calibrated at the beginning of each day using a DryCal DC-Lite Primary Flow Meter (Bios International Corporation, Butler, NJ). Flow rates were measured again near the middle and at the end of each day to ensure that sampling flow rates were maintained within 5% of pre-sampling flow rates throughout the day. Average flow rates were used to calculate sample air volumes. Samples were analyzed by R.J. Lee Group, Inc., (Monroeville, PA) using NIOSH Method 0600, to determine exposure to total mass of respirable dust. The same samples were also analyzed using X-Ray diffraction following NIOSH method 7500 to determine quartz, cristobalite and tridymite concentration in the respirable mass. Reported masses for these analytes were used with the sample air volumes to calculate airborne concentrations of total respirable dust, quartz, cristobalite and tridymite.
We used a reduction of greater than 50 percent in respirable silica exposure concentrations or a reduction to less than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 as our criteria for determining whether or not a control was considered efficacious. This is consistent with criteria used by NIOSH in conducting a similar study in 2004 described by Echt et al. (2007) and by CPWR in 2006 and described by Meeker et al. (2009). The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) and the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) publish additional occupational exposure limits (OELs) for silica which are listed in Table 1 with NIOSH RELs. OELs for silica are based on the respirable fraction of the aerosol, which consists of particles less than 10 micrometers in aerodynamic diameter.
| Organization or Agency | Form of Crystalline Silica | Occupational Exposure Limits (mg/m3) |
|---|---|---|
| NIOSHA | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 |
| OSHA - ConstructionB | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
PEL = 250 / (5 + % quartz) PEL = 250 / (5 + % cristobalite) PEL = 250 / (5 + % tridymite) |
| ACGIH | Crystalline Silica | TLV = 0.025 mg/m3 |
A NIOSH Publication No. 2005-151 indicates 10-hour time-weighted average during a 40-hr workweek B The PEL for silica in OSHA’s Safety and Health Regulations for Construction, 29 C.F.R. 1926.55(a), is an 8-hour time-weighted average (TWA) expressed in millions of particles per cubic foot (mppcf). However, the units mppcf can be converted to milligrams per cubic meter can by dividing mppcf by 10 (OSHA, 2009). The formula used by OSHA to determine the PEL for silica is dependent on the percentage of silica in each collected sample. The concentration of respirable dust measured is compared to the sample specific PEL to determine if the PEL has been exceeded. OSHA has proposed lowering the PEL to 0.05 mg/m3 of respirable silica as an 8 hour TWA. |
||
The flow of air in ventilation systems is governed by fundamental principles that describe the behavior of gases (in this case air). Pressure measurements taken within a ventilation system along with knowledge of hood (or shroud) entry losses can be used to calculate flow rates. Hood entry losses are dependent on the shape and configuration of a particular hood or shroud and described by the term “coefficient of entry (Ce)” which is the ratio of actual air flow through a hood and what the air flow would theoretically be if there were no hood entry losses. Given the coefficient of entry, static pressure measurements can be used to calculate air flow through a given hood. The coefficient of entry for the Dust Director shroud was previously determined by CPWR and used for calculating air flow based on static pressure measurements (Meeker et al., 2009). Static pressure, with the vacuum operating, was measured periodically throughout the evaluation to monitor the changes in air-flow rate following use and again after filter cleaning. The static pressure was measured at a port positioned more than 3 duct diameters downstream from the tool’s air intake using a UEi EM200 Electronic Manometer (Universal Enterprises, Inc., Beaverton, OR).
The dust in the vacuum bag was monitored and, per the manufacturer’s instructions, the bag was changed before the dust level was within 5 centimeters of the valve at the bottom of the vacuum. Each time a vacuum bag was removed, it was weighed to the nearest pound. The bag weights and corresponding grinding durations were used to calculate the average weight of dust collected per unit time. After each trial, cut lengths were measured on the wall to determine total linear feet of vertical (head) and horizontal (bed) joints per unit time.
A Haz-Dust III, Model HD-1003, Real-Time Aerosol Monitor (Environmental Devices Corporation, Plaistow, NH) was used to confirm clearance of dust between trials. The Haz-Dust monitor was positioned on the test wall near the operator at approximately breathing zone level and configured to measure respirable particulate concentration.
V. Results
Personal air monitoring
Five pairs of respirable dust samples were collected while grinding with and without the vacuum system. In addition, three respirable dust samples were collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place. One measurement collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard was shown to be a statistical outlier and was omitted from analysis. Personal air monitoring results for respirable silica and a comparison of average exposures relative to the NIOSH REL for silica (0.05 mg/m3) appears in Table 2. The mean respirable dust levels measured without LEV was 31.4 mg/m3. However, samples collected with LEV were below the limit of quantification (LOQ) which ranged from <1.29 to <1.46 mg/m3. Use of LEV resulted in a greater than 95% reduction in mean respirable dust levels using a mean value with use of LEV of <1.41 (n=5 samples with use of LEV and n=7 without use of LEV). The respirable dust samples collected during grinding without the LEV system contained an average of 24 percent silica. The mass of respirable dust in the samples collected with use of the LEV system was too low to determine the silica content.| Mean, mg/m3 (range) | Std. Dev. | Percent Reduction | Hazard RatioB | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bosch with Dust Director Shroud and DustControl 2900c Vacuum |
0.091 (<0.069 – 0.137) |
0.027 | 98.7 | 1.81 |
| Bosch with no Control | 7.23 (4.57 – 9.90) |
1.94 | NA | 145 |
A n = 5 samples for each tool/control combination and n = 7 samples without the use of the LEV system B Hazard Ratio = measured exposure / NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 |
||||
Average respirable silica and dust exposures, with and without the dust control system, appear as Figures 5 and 6, respectively.
Figure 5. Average respirable silica exposures with and without the Dustcontrol 2900c vacuum and Dust Director shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air - mg/m3)
Figure 6. Average respirable dust exposures with and without Dustcontrol 2900c Vacuum and Dust Director Shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air – mg/m3)
The mean respirable silica concentration measured during use of the control was significantly less than the concentration measured while using the same tool without controls (p<0.01). Grinding mortar with the Bosch angle grinder without dust controls resulted in an average exposure to respirable silica that was 145 times the NIOSH REL. Grinding with the Bosch angle grinder in combination with the Dust Director shroud and the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced the average concentration of respirable silica by 98.7 percent. With use of these controls, the concentration of respirable silica was 1.8 times greater than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3. However the NIOSH REL is based on a time-weighted average (TWA) over a 10-hour workday. Given these were task TWAs and samples were collected over continuous periods of grinding, they may overestimate exposures over an actual work day since some time would be spent performing tasks that would likely have lower, or no, silica exposures (setup, breaks, cleanup, etc.).
Static pressure, dust mass collection and grinding rates.
Static pressure was used as a surrogate for air flow as described earlier. Hood static pressure was measured periodically at a tap near the grinder more than 3 duct diameters from the air intake in the shroud. The static pressure, and thus air flow, was generally higher when the vacuum’s filter had recently been cleaned. The mean, median, and range of calculated flow rates are presented in Table A1 of the Appendix.
Based on the data we collected, the air-flow rate upstream from the Bosch grinder and Dust Director shroud ranged from 78 to 93 cubic feet per minute (cfm) with the DustControl vacuum. When the manufacturer’s filter cleaning procedure was followed the vacuum performed relatively well and flow could be maintained at slightly less than 90 cfm with cleaning. However, mean flow rates dropped substantially to 80 cfm after as little as 8 minutes of grinding without any filter cleaning. The flow rate returned to an average of 89 cfm when filters were cleaned correctly (without stopping air flow to the vacuum). Collingwood and Heitbrink (2007) found that the minimum exhaust flow rate for capture of silica and other particulate under ideal conditions is 21.25 cfm per inch of grinder blade diameter. This is equal to about 96 cfm when using a 4.5 inch diameter grinding blade. We set 106 cfm as the minimum desired flow rate for this study to allow a safety margin for potential decline in equipment performance and the possibility of inadequate maintenance, both of which may be likely after repeated use under actual work conditions. The DustControl vacuum provided slightly less than the minimum flow rate described by Collingwood and Heitbrink for a 4.5-inch blade and the peak flow rate fell with use.
The duration of vacuum bag use and mass of dust collected were recorded and are presented in Table A2 of the Appendix. The vacuum bags were changed and weighed after each trial utilizing the LEV system. A total of five bags were used to complete the five rounds of grinding. The DustControl vacuum captured 45 pounds of dust over 83 minutes of grinding for an average rate of dust collection of 0.54 pounds per minute. The rate of dust collection ranged from 0.47 to 0.63 pounds per minute. Based on these measurements, approximately 130 pounds of dust would likely be captured after just 4 hours of continuous grinding.
The rate of grinding a combination of vertical and horizontal joints while using the LEV system ranged from 2.3 to 3.3 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the use of the LEV system ranged from 2.6 to 3.4 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place ranged from 4.7 to 5.1 feet per minute. It’s important to note that: 1) the operator had limited experience using dust control systems and cut rates appeared to improve slightly over the 2-day period he used the tested equipment; and 2) the upper range of cut rates with the dust control system overlapped with the lowest cut rate with the original guard and without the LEV system in place indicating no statistical difference between cut rates. Given that grinding rates with and without use of this LEV system are only available for one operator and he had limited experience with the LEV system, these reported cut rates are in no way intended to represent the impact use of this LEV system is likely to have on productivity rates overall.
VI. Discussion
The objective of these trials was to evaluate the effectiveness of a tuckpointing LEV system for controlling respirable silica while grinding out mortar joints. The Dust Director shroud with the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced respirable silica concentrations when grinding with the Bosch grinder by approximately 99 percent. Despite being considered effective by our test criteria (greater than 50% reduction), it still resulted in task TWA exposures that exceeded the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 by 1.8 times. Depending on how much time is spent grinding over the course of a work day and on exposures while performing other tasks, the 8-hour TWA exposures may or may not exceed the REL with this system. Use of this system by workers with experience and training in proficient use will likely improve dust capture performance. Exposure reduction is greatly influenced by correct use of this system which includes grinding from right to left, making sure the shroud is held flush against the wall and that the tool travels at a pace that doesn’t exceed the ability of the system to capture dust as it’s generated. Deviation from any of these measures produces visible dust clouds which were observed during trials.
VII. Conclusions
With a 99 percent reduction in respirable silica exposure, the Dust Director shroud and DustControl 2900c vacuum with a Bosch Model 1775E grinder was effective in reducing silica exposures based on our criteria. Use of the tested dust control system may be effective in reducing silica exposure on the job to less than the NIOSH REL if used in combination with administrative controls such as work scheduling to reduce cutting times as needed. Training on correct use of the tested system is also essential. Personal air monitoring is necessary to verify control effectiveness on actual job sites and under “real-world” conditions. However, these results clearly demonstrate the availability of viable and effective engineering controls for tuckpointing operations associated with elevated silica exposure.
VIII. References
American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists. Threshold limit values for chemical substances (TLV®-CS). [2013]. ACGIH, Cincinnati, Ohio.
Bergdahl I.A,. Toren K., Eriksson K., et al. [2004]. Increased mortality in COPD among construction workers exposed to inorganic dust. European Respiratory Journal, 23: 402–06.
Blanc P.D. & Torén K. [2007]. Occupation in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and chronic bronchitis: an update [State of the Art Series. Occupational lung disease in high-and low-income countries, Edited by M. Chan-Yeung. Number 2 in the series]. The International Journal of Tuberculosis and Lung Disease, 11(3), 251-257.
Collingwood S. & Heitbrink W.A. [2007] 'Field Evaluation of an Engineering Control for Respirable Crystalline Silica Exposures During Mortar Removal'. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, 4:11, 875 – 887.
DHHS (NIOSH) Publication No. 2002-129 April 2002 http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/2002-129/
Echt A., Sieber W.K., Lefkowitz D., Meeker J., Susi P., Cardwell B., Heitbrink, W.A. In-depth survey of dust control technology for cutting concrete block and tuckpointing brick at The International Masonry Institute Bordentown Training Center, Bordentown, NJ. Cincinnati, OH: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Report. No. EPHB 282-13; 2007. http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ECTB-282-13.pdf
Heitbrink W., Bennett J. [2006]. A numerical and experimental investigation of crystalline silica exposure control during tuck pointing. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, Vol. 3, pp 366-378.
Lyons et al, [2007]. A breathless builder. Breathe, Vol. 3, no. 4, pp 386-390.
Mastrangelo G., Tartari M., Fedeli U., Fadda E., Saia B. [2003]. Ascertaining the risk of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease in relation to occupation using a case-control design. Occupational Medicine, 53: 165–172.
Meeker J., Cooper M., Lefrowitz D., Susi P. [2009]. Engineering control technologies to reduce occupational silica exposures in masonry cutting and tuckpointing. Public Health Reports, Supplement 1, Vol. 124, June.
Meeker J, Flynn M, Susi P, Cardwell, B [2004]. Performance evaluation of a masonry concrete vacuum. Unpublished Report.
Miller F. W., Alfredsson L., Costenbader K. H., Kamen D. L., Nelson L. M., Norris J. M., & De Roos A. J. [2012]. Epidemiology of environmental exposures and human autoimmune diseases: findings from a National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences Expert Panel workshop. Journal of autoimmunity. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3496812/
Occupational Safety and Health Administration U.S Department of Labor. Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction. [2009]. OSHA 3362-05.
Rappaport SM, Goldberg M, Susi P, Herrick RF [2003]. Excessive exposure to silica in the U.S. construction industry. Annals of Occupational Hygiene, Vol. 47, pp. 111-122.
IX. Appendices
| Measurement Conditions |
n | Mean Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Median
Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before filter cleaning | 5 | 80 | 81 | 78-81 |
| After filter cleaning following manufacturer directions | 9 | 89 | 90 | 84-93 |
| * Static pressure was measured in millibars and converted to inches of water gauge. Flow rates were calculated using the formula Q = Ce (A) 4005 (SP)1/2 where: Q = flow in cubic feet per minute (cfm), Ce = coefficient of entry, A = area of the duct where static pressure measurements were taken in square feet, and SP = static pressure in inches of water gauge. | ||||
| Tool/Control | Collection Period (min.) |
Dust Collection Rate (lb/min.) |
|---|---|---|
| Bosch grinder/Dust Director shroud & DustControl 2900c vacuum |
8 11 8 8 10 |
0.50 0.61 0.50 0.47 0.63 |
| Average | 0.54 |
[content_transformed:protected] =>
Executive Summary
This report describes the results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. It should also be noted that the NIOSH REL is based on exposures averaged over a ten hour work day and our results represent time weighted averages of the sample task duration periods.
Acronyms
ACGIH - American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists
CPWR - CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training
Ce - coefficient of entry
HEPA - high-efficiency particulate air
IUBAC - International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craftworkers
LEV - local exhaust ventilation
PACT - Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies
NIOSH - National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health
OEL - occupational exposure limit
OSHA - Occupational Safety and Health Administration
PAPR - powered air-purifying respirator
PEL - Permissible Exposure Limit
PVC - polyvinyl chloride
REL - Recommended Exposure Limit
RPM - revolutions per minute
TWA - time-weighted average
SP - static pressure
I. Introduction and Background
In 2010 CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training began a four-year project which seeks to identify and evaluate tuckpointing local exhaust ventilation (LEV) systems and disseminate information on their availability and effectiveness. A Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies (PACT) comprised of masonry contractors, representatives from unions, government, equipment manufacturers, and health and safety researcher was formed as part of this project. PACT members participated in identifying important characteristics for control technologies and this information was used to identify LEV systems for tuckpointing using that criteria. Contractor and labor members of the PACT selected specific tuckpointing LEV systems to be considered for evaluation. Each system consisted of a tuckpointing grinder, shroud, and vacuum. This report describes the second of four systems to be evaluated between 2012 the end of 2014, with and without LEV, in a controlled setting to determine effectiveness in silica exposure reduction. This report describes the methods and results of our evaluation of a system consisting of the DustControl 2900c vacuum with the ICS Dust Director shroud and a Bosch Model 1775E grinder.
Excessive exposure to respirable silica can result in silicosis or other silica-related diseases including pulmonary tuberculosis, lung cancer, silicoproteinosis (Lyons et al, 2007) and autoimmune disorders such as rheumatoid arthritis, sarcoidosis and scleroderma (Miller et al, 2012). Respirable silica is generally defined as particles less than 10 micrometers (μm) in aerodynamic diameter (ACGIH, 2013). Silicosis can lead to symptoms including shortness of breath, fatigue, chest pains, susceptibility to infection and possibly death. There is no cure for silicosis, however it is totally preventable. Construction workers exposed to dust, including silica, are also known to have higher rates of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD).
There are many sources of silica in construction that result in exposures of varying intensity among workers. Masonry restoration workers are among the most highly silica-exposed trades in construction. The process of grinding out deteriorated mortar joints between masonry units and replacing or repointing with fresh mortar (often referred to as tuckpointing) is a fundamental part of masonry restoration work. The removal of mortar with powered angle grinders generates enormous levels of dust. Between 2004 and 2006, NIOSH and CPWR evaluated silica exposures while grinding mortar in a controlled setting, at a local training center, where tasks, sample times and task variables were defined by the study design. These studies demonstrated that grinding mortar without controls can result in elevated respirable silica exposures. Meeker et al., (2009) reported exposures between 5 and 25.8 milligrams per cubic meter (mg/m3) in a controlled setting. This study also showed that LEV systems for tuckpointing grinders can reduce exposures to respirable silica by greater than 90 percent.II. Objectives
The objective of this evaluation was to assess the effectiveness of an LEV system for controlling exposure to silica during the grinding of mortar. The control technology was tested under controlled conditions, similar to those experienced by tuckpointers on actual job sites, using journeymen bricklayers experienced in tuckpointing and repeat, randomized trials with and without LEV. All other variables were held constant throughout so that the only variable was whether or not the tested control was used.
III. Description of Equipment Tested
A Bosch model 1775E grinder (Robert Bosch Tool Corporation, Prospect, IL) (Figures 1, 2 and 3) was fitted with a new 1/4-inch wide, 4½-inch diameter segmented diamond abrasive blade made by DeWalt (model #DW4740). The grinder weighs six and a half pounds, draws 8.5 amps and has a variable speed up to 11,000 revolutions per minute (RPMs). The DustControl 2900c vacuum (DustControl, Inc., Wilmington, NC) (Figure 3) was tested in combination with the Dust Director shroud (Industrial Contractors’ Supplies, Inc., Huntingdon, PA) (Figures 1 and 3) attached to the Bosch grinder.
Figure 1. Bosch grinder with Dust Director shroud
Figure 2. Bosch grinder without tuckpointing LEV system.
Figure 3: Bosch Grinder with LEV System
The vacuum is specified to weigh 31 pounds when empty and to provide a flow rate of 114 cubic feet of air per minute and a “static lift” or “vacuum suction pressure” of 84 inches of water. The vacuum is sold with a cyclonic pre-separator, to remove larger particles, a fine filter (rated 99.9 percent efficient) and a HEPA (high-efficiency particulate air) filter (rated to capture 99.97 percent of the particles with an aerodynamic diameter of 0.3 micrometers). The HEPA filter was removed based on the manufacturer’s recommendation due to the heavy dust loading associated with tuckpointing. CPWR sponsored research and contractor experience indicate that HEPA filters likely have an adverse effect on dust capture during tuckpointing because of extreme dust loading on filters. While the cyclone and the fine filter remove most of the dust, especially the large particles, before they reach the HEPA filter, the HEPA filter would still be subject to heavy loading, causing a substantial pressure drop and subsequent decrease in air flow rate. The relatively small increase in the efficiency of the filtration system while using the HEPA filter is expected to be quickly offset by a more significant decrease in capture efficiency as the air flow rate and ability to capture particles decreases.
Dust collects in relatively inexpensive, heavy-gauge plastic bags below and outside of the cyclone. The bags can be removed and replaced without opening the vacuum. Some vacuums are equipped with a light to indicate that the filters need to be cleaned or changed. The DC2900c features a “reverse air pulse cleaning system,” which removes accumulated dust from the filters without having to remove them from the vacuum. The system, as illustrated in Figure 4, requires the operator to disconnect the hose from the shroud, place it over an air stop so that air through the hose is cut off and pressure in the vacuum is maximized.
Figure 4. Procedure for "cleaning" of or dust removal from filters (source: http://dustcontrolusa.com/manuals/2800c.pdf)
The flap covering the port on the side of the vacuum is repeatedly flipped open to release built up pressure in strong pulses that dislodge dust from the filter.
The manufacturer indicates “the filter is generally cleaned once or twice daily during normal continuous operation.” The Dust Director shroud has a 2-inch diameter take-off that was connected to the antistatic, corrugated 1.5-inch diameter, 15-foot long vacuum hose supplied with the DustControl vacuum.
IV. Study Methods
This evaluation was conducted at the International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craft workers (IUBAC) Local 1 Philadelphia/Delaware Training Center in Philadelphia, PA on November 14 and 15, 2012. A single journeyman bricklayer, experienced in tuckpointing, used the grinder and LEV system being tested to remove mortar from joints wide enough to require two passes. The type S mortar had been allowed to cure for at least four weeks. The bricklayer either possessed or was provided with personal protective equipment including sturdy work boots, gloves, hearing protection and a powered air-purifying respirator (PAPR). The PAPR was a 3M GVP system with a bump cap, loose fitting face piece and a HEPA filter (3M, St Paul, MN).
The study was designed to include at least five rounds of sampling during mortar removal. Each round included a trial using the Bosch grinder with a Dust Director shroud and Dust Collector 2900c vacuum and a trial using the Bosch grinder with the factory-supplied guard and without a vacuum. The order of the two trials within each round was randomly selected to minimize bias that might be introduced due to variation associated with environmental factors, equipment operator, blade wear, vacuum performance over time and any other factors unrelated to LEV use. Tools were operated for approximately 16 minutes per trial with controls and for approximately 8 minutes when controls were not used. These times were selected based on the results of previous sampling efforts and estimates of the minimum sample time needed to achieve a limit of quantification low enough to accurately measure exposures down to or less than 0.05 mg/m3 – the NIOSH Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) for respirable silica. The bricklayer was required to take a 5 to 10 minute break in the middle of the 16-minute trials to reduce differences in fatigue, compared to the 8-minute trials. Personal air samples were collected in the breathing zone of the operator during each trial to measure respirable silica concentrations during grinding with and without LEV. The samples were collected using a GilAir-5 pump (Sensidyne, Inc., Clearwater, FL) to draw 4.2 liters of air per minute through a GK2.69 Respirable Cyclone (BGI Inc., Waltham, MA) with a pre-weighed, 37 mm diameter, 5-micron pore size polyvinyl chloride (PVC) filter positioned on the operator’s lapel.
The flow rates of the sampling pumps were calibrated at the beginning of each day using a DryCal DC-Lite Primary Flow Meter (Bios International Corporation, Butler, NJ). Flow rates were measured again near the middle and at the end of each day to ensure that sampling flow rates were maintained within 5% of pre-sampling flow rates throughout the day. Average flow rates were used to calculate sample air volumes. Samples were analyzed by R.J. Lee Group, Inc., (Monroeville, PA) using NIOSH Method 0600, to determine exposure to total mass of respirable dust. The same samples were also analyzed using X-Ray diffraction following NIOSH method 7500 to determine quartz, cristobalite and tridymite concentration in the respirable mass. Reported masses for these analytes were used with the sample air volumes to calculate airborne concentrations of total respirable dust, quartz, cristobalite and tridymite.
We used a reduction of greater than 50 percent in respirable silica exposure concentrations or a reduction to less than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 as our criteria for determining whether or not a control was considered efficacious. This is consistent with criteria used by NIOSH in conducting a similar study in 2004 described by Echt et al. (2007) and by CPWR in 2006 and described by Meeker et al. (2009). The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) and the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) publish additional occupational exposure limits (OELs) for silica which are listed in Table 1 with NIOSH RELs. OELs for silica are based on the respirable fraction of the aerosol, which consists of particles less than 10 micrometers in aerodynamic diameter.
| Organization or Agency | Form of Crystalline Silica | Occupational Exposure Limits (mg/m3) |
|---|---|---|
| NIOSHA | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 |
| OSHA - ConstructionB | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
PEL = 250 / (5 + % quartz) PEL = 250 / (5 + % cristobalite) PEL = 250 / (5 + % tridymite) |
| ACGIH | Crystalline Silica | TLV = 0.025 mg/m3 |
A NIOSH Publication No. 2005-151 indicates 10-hour time-weighted average during a 40-hr workweek B The PEL for silica in OSHA’s Safety and Health Regulations for Construction, 29 C.F.R. 1926.55(a), is an 8-hour time-weighted average (TWA) expressed in millions of particles per cubic foot (mppcf). However, the units mppcf can be converted to milligrams per cubic meter can by dividing mppcf by 10 (OSHA, 2009). The formula used by OSHA to determine the PEL for silica is dependent on the percentage of silica in each collected sample. The concentration of respirable dust measured is compared to the sample specific PEL to determine if the PEL has been exceeded. OSHA has proposed lowering the PEL to 0.05 mg/m3 of respirable silica as an 8 hour TWA. |
||
The flow of air in ventilation systems is governed by fundamental principles that describe the behavior of gases (in this case air). Pressure measurements taken within a ventilation system along with knowledge of hood (or shroud) entry losses can be used to calculate flow rates. Hood entry losses are dependent on the shape and configuration of a particular hood or shroud and described by the term “coefficient of entry (Ce)” which is the ratio of actual air flow through a hood and what the air flow would theoretically be if there were no hood entry losses. Given the coefficient of entry, static pressure measurements can be used to calculate air flow through a given hood. The coefficient of entry for the Dust Director shroud was previously determined by CPWR and used for calculating air flow based on static pressure measurements (Meeker et al., 2009). Static pressure, with the vacuum operating, was measured periodically throughout the evaluation to monitor the changes in air-flow rate following use and again after filter cleaning. The static pressure was measured at a port positioned more than 3 duct diameters downstream from the tool’s air intake using a UEi EM200 Electronic Manometer (Universal Enterprises, Inc., Beaverton, OR).
The dust in the vacuum bag was monitored and, per the manufacturer’s instructions, the bag was changed before the dust level was within 5 centimeters of the valve at the bottom of the vacuum. Each time a vacuum bag was removed, it was weighed to the nearest pound. The bag weights and corresponding grinding durations were used to calculate the average weight of dust collected per unit time. After each trial, cut lengths were measured on the wall to determine total linear feet of vertical (head) and horizontal (bed) joints per unit time.
A Haz-Dust III, Model HD-1003, Real-Time Aerosol Monitor (Environmental Devices Corporation, Plaistow, NH) was used to confirm clearance of dust between trials. The Haz-Dust monitor was positioned on the test wall near the operator at approximately breathing zone level and configured to measure respirable particulate concentration.
V. Results
Personal air monitoring
Five pairs of respirable dust samples were collected while grinding with and without the vacuum system. In addition, three respirable dust samples were collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place. One measurement collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard was shown to be a statistical outlier and was omitted from analysis. Personal air monitoring results for respirable silica and a comparison of average exposures relative to the NIOSH REL for silica (0.05 mg/m3) appears in Table 2. The mean respirable dust levels measured without LEV was 31.4 mg/m3. However, samples collected with LEV were below the limit of quantification (LOQ) which ranged from <1.29 to <1.46 mg/m3. Use of LEV resulted in a greater than 95% reduction in mean respirable dust levels using a mean value with use of LEV of <1.41 (n=5 samples with use of LEV and n=7 without use of LEV). The respirable dust samples collected during grinding without the LEV system contained an average of 24 percent silica. The mass of respirable dust in the samples collected with use of the LEV system was too low to determine the silica content.| Mean, mg/m3 (range) | Std. Dev. | Percent Reduction | Hazard RatioB | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bosch with Dust Director Shroud and DustControl 2900c Vacuum |
0.091 (<0.069 – 0.137) |
0.027 | 98.7 | 1.81 |
| Bosch with no Control | 7.23 (4.57 – 9.90) |
1.94 | NA | 145 |
A n = 5 samples for each tool/control combination and n = 7 samples without the use of the LEV system B Hazard Ratio = measured exposure / NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 |
||||
Average respirable silica and dust exposures, with and without the dust control system, appear as Figures 5 and 6, respectively.
Figure 5. Average respirable silica exposures with and without the Dustcontrol 2900c vacuum and Dust Director shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air - mg/m3)
Figure 6. Average respirable dust exposures with and without Dustcontrol 2900c Vacuum and Dust Director Shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air – mg/m3)
The mean respirable silica concentration measured during use of the control was significantly less than the concentration measured while using the same tool without controls (p<0.01). Grinding mortar with the Bosch angle grinder without dust controls resulted in an average exposure to respirable silica that was 145 times the NIOSH REL. Grinding with the Bosch angle grinder in combination with the Dust Director shroud and the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced the average concentration of respirable silica by 98.7 percent. With use of these controls, the concentration of respirable silica was 1.8 times greater than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3. However the NIOSH REL is based on a time-weighted average (TWA) over a 10-hour workday. Given these were task TWAs and samples were collected over continuous periods of grinding, they may overestimate exposures over an actual work day since some time would be spent performing tasks that would likely have lower, or no, silica exposures (setup, breaks, cleanup, etc.).
Static pressure, dust mass collection and grinding rates.
Static pressure was used as a surrogate for air flow as described earlier. Hood static pressure was measured periodically at a tap near the grinder more than 3 duct diameters from the air intake in the shroud. The static pressure, and thus air flow, was generally higher when the vacuum’s filter had recently been cleaned. The mean, median, and range of calculated flow rates are presented in Table A1 of the Appendix.
Based on the data we collected, the air-flow rate upstream from the Bosch grinder and Dust Director shroud ranged from 78 to 93 cubic feet per minute (cfm) with the DustControl vacuum. When the manufacturer’s filter cleaning procedure was followed the vacuum performed relatively well and flow could be maintained at slightly less than 90 cfm with cleaning. However, mean flow rates dropped substantially to 80 cfm after as little as 8 minutes of grinding without any filter cleaning. The flow rate returned to an average of 89 cfm when filters were cleaned correctly (without stopping air flow to the vacuum). Collingwood and Heitbrink (2007) found that the minimum exhaust flow rate for capture of silica and other particulate under ideal conditions is 21.25 cfm per inch of grinder blade diameter. This is equal to about 96 cfm when using a 4.5 inch diameter grinding blade. We set 106 cfm as the minimum desired flow rate for this study to allow a safety margin for potential decline in equipment performance and the possibility of inadequate maintenance, both of which may be likely after repeated use under actual work conditions. The DustControl vacuum provided slightly less than the minimum flow rate described by Collingwood and Heitbrink for a 4.5-inch blade and the peak flow rate fell with use.
The duration of vacuum bag use and mass of dust collected were recorded and are presented in Table A2 of the Appendix. The vacuum bags were changed and weighed after each trial utilizing the LEV system. A total of five bags were used to complete the five rounds of grinding. The DustControl vacuum captured 45 pounds of dust over 83 minutes of grinding for an average rate of dust collection of 0.54 pounds per minute. The rate of dust collection ranged from 0.47 to 0.63 pounds per minute. Based on these measurements, approximately 130 pounds of dust would likely be captured after just 4 hours of continuous grinding.
The rate of grinding a combination of vertical and horizontal joints while using the LEV system ranged from 2.3 to 3.3 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the use of the LEV system ranged from 2.6 to 3.4 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place ranged from 4.7 to 5.1 feet per minute. It’s important to note that: 1) the operator had limited experience using dust control systems and cut rates appeared to improve slightly over the 2-day period he used the tested equipment; and 2) the upper range of cut rates with the dust control system overlapped with the lowest cut rate with the original guard and without the LEV system in place indicating no statistical difference between cut rates. Given that grinding rates with and without use of this LEV system are only available for one operator and he had limited experience with the LEV system, these reported cut rates are in no way intended to represent the impact use of this LEV system is likely to have on productivity rates overall.
VI. Discussion
The objective of these trials was to evaluate the effectiveness of a tuckpointing LEV system for controlling respirable silica while grinding out mortar joints. The Dust Director shroud with the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced respirable silica concentrations when grinding with the Bosch grinder by approximately 99 percent. Despite being considered effective by our test criteria (greater than 50% reduction), it still resulted in task TWA exposures that exceeded the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 by 1.8 times. Depending on how much time is spent grinding over the course of a work day and on exposures while performing other tasks, the 8-hour TWA exposures may or may not exceed the REL with this system. Use of this system by workers with experience and training in proficient use will likely improve dust capture performance. Exposure reduction is greatly influenced by correct use of this system which includes grinding from right to left, making sure the shroud is held flush against the wall and that the tool travels at a pace that doesn’t exceed the ability of the system to capture dust as it’s generated. Deviation from any of these measures produces visible dust clouds which were observed during trials.
VII. Conclusions
With a 99 percent reduction in respirable silica exposure, the Dust Director shroud and DustControl 2900c vacuum with a Bosch Model 1775E grinder was effective in reducing silica exposures based on our criteria. Use of the tested dust control system may be effective in reducing silica exposure on the job to less than the NIOSH REL if used in combination with administrative controls such as work scheduling to reduce cutting times as needed. Training on correct use of the tested system is also essential. Personal air monitoring is necessary to verify control effectiveness on actual job sites and under “real-world” conditions. However, these results clearly demonstrate the availability of viable and effective engineering controls for tuckpointing operations associated with elevated silica exposure.
VIII. References
American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists. Threshold limit values for chemical substances (TLV®-CS). [2013]. ACGIH, Cincinnati, Ohio.
Bergdahl I.A,. Toren K., Eriksson K., et al. [2004]. Increased mortality in COPD among construction workers exposed to inorganic dust. European Respiratory Journal, 23: 402–06.
Blanc P.D. & Torén K. [2007]. Occupation in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and chronic bronchitis: an update [State of the Art Series. Occupational lung disease in high-and low-income countries, Edited by M. Chan-Yeung. Number 2 in the series]. The International Journal of Tuberculosis and Lung Disease, 11(3), 251-257.
Collingwood S. & Heitbrink W.A. [2007] 'Field Evaluation of an Engineering Control for Respirable Crystalline Silica Exposures During Mortar Removal'. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, 4:11, 875 – 887.
DHHS (NIOSH) Publication No. 2002-129 April 2002 http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/2002-129/
Echt A., Sieber W.K., Lefkowitz D., Meeker J., Susi P., Cardwell B., Heitbrink, W.A. In-depth survey of dust control technology for cutting concrete block and tuckpointing brick at The International Masonry Institute Bordentown Training Center, Bordentown, NJ. Cincinnati, OH: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Report. No. EPHB 282-13; 2007. http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ECTB-282-13.pdf
Heitbrink W., Bennett J. [2006]. A numerical and experimental investigation of crystalline silica exposure control during tuck pointing. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, Vol. 3, pp 366-378.
Lyons et al, [2007]. A breathless builder. Breathe, Vol. 3, no. 4, pp 386-390.
Mastrangelo G., Tartari M., Fedeli U., Fadda E., Saia B. [2003]. Ascertaining the risk of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease in relation to occupation using a case-control design. Occupational Medicine, 53: 165–172.
Meeker J., Cooper M., Lefrowitz D., Susi P. [2009]. Engineering control technologies to reduce occupational silica exposures in masonry cutting and tuckpointing. Public Health Reports, Supplement 1, Vol. 124, June.
Meeker J, Flynn M, Susi P, Cardwell, B [2004]. Performance evaluation of a masonry concrete vacuum. Unpublished Report.
Miller F. W., Alfredsson L., Costenbader K. H., Kamen D. L., Nelson L. M., Norris J. M., & De Roos A. J. [2012]. Epidemiology of environmental exposures and human autoimmune diseases: findings from a National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences Expert Panel workshop. Journal of autoimmunity. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3496812/
Occupational Safety and Health Administration U.S Department of Labor. Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction. [2009]. OSHA 3362-05.
Rappaport SM, Goldberg M, Susi P, Herrick RF [2003]. Excessive exposure to silica in the U.S. construction industry. Annals of Occupational Hygiene, Vol. 47, pp. 111-122.
IX. Appendices
| Measurement Conditions |
n | Mean Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Median
Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before filter cleaning | 5 | 80 | 81 | 78-81 |
| After filter cleaning following manufacturer directions | 9 | 89 | 90 | 84-93 |
| * Static pressure was measured in millibars and converted to inches of water gauge. Flow rates were calculated using the formula Q = Ce (A) 4005 (SP)1/2 where: Q = flow in cubic feet per minute (cfm), Ce = coefficient of entry, A = area of the duct where static pressure measurements were taken in square feet, and SP = static pressure in inches of water gauge. | ||||
| Tool/Control | Collection Period (min.) |
Dust Collection Rate (lb/min.) |
|---|---|---|
| Bosch grinder/Dust Director shroud & DustControl 2900c vacuum |
8 11 8 8 10 |
0.50 0.61 0.50 0.47 0.63 |
| Average | 0.54 |
[disclaimer:protected] => [disclaimer_transformed:protected] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [template] => record ) [_file] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/templates/elcosh/macros.html [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_encoding:protected] => UTF-8 [_outputMode:protected] => 11 [_forceReparse:protected] => [_phpCodeDestination:protected] => /tmp/ [_phpCodeExtension:protected] => php [_cacheLifetime:protected] => 30 [_cachePurgeFrequency:protected] => 30 [externalMacroTemplatesCache:PHPTAL:private] => Array ( ) ) [record_macros.html] => PHPTAL Object ( [_prefilters:protected] => Array ( ) [_prefilter:PHPTAL:private] => REMOVED: DO NOT USE [_postfilter:protected] => [_repositories:protected] => Array ( [0] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/templates/elcosh ) [_path:protected] => record_macros.html [_resolvers:protected] => Array ( ) [_source:protected] => PHPTAL_FileSource Object ( [_path:PHPTAL_FileSource:private] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/templates/elcosh/record_macros.html ) [_codeFile:protected] => /tmp/tpl_61515a6c_record_macros__gMFg5NvPLybiFfYjAv9Aag.php [_functionName:protected] => tpl_61515a6c_record_macros__gMFg5NvPLybiFfYjAv9Aag [_prepared:protected] => 1 [_triggers:protected] => Array ( ) [_translator:protected] => [_globalContext:protected] => stdClass Object ( ) [_context:protected] => PHPTAL_Context Object ( [_line] => [_file] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/templates/elcosh/record.html [repeat] => stdClass Object ( ) [_xmlDeclaration] => [_docType] => [_nothrow:PHPTAL_Context:private] => [_slots:PHPTAL_Context:private] => Array ( ) [_slotsStack:PHPTAL_Context:private] => Array ( [0] => Array ( ) [1] => Array ( ) ) [_parentContext:PHPTAL_Context:private] => PHPTAL_Context Object ( [_line] => [_file] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/templates/elcosh/record.html [repeat] => stdClass Object ( ) [_xmlDeclaration] => [_docType] => [_nothrow:PHPTAL_Context:private] => [_slots:PHPTAL_Context:private] => Array ( ) [_slotsStack:PHPTAL_Context:private] => Array ( [0] => Array ( ) [1] => Array ( ) ) [_parentContext:PHPTAL_Context:private] => [_globalContext:PHPTAL_Context:private] => stdClass Object ( ) [_echoDeclarations:PHPTAL_Context:private] => [referer] => http://www.elcosh.org/document/3908/d001345/An%2BEvaluation%2Bof%2BSilica%2BExposure%2BControls%2Bfor%2BTuckpointing%253A%2BDustControl%2B2900c%2BVacuum%2Bwith%2Bthe%2BICS%2BDust%2BDirector%2BShroud%2Band%2BBosch%2BGrinder%2BModel%2B1775E%2BConducted%2BNovember%2B14-15%252C%2B2012.html [curr_module] => Record [styles] => Array ( ) [javascript] => Array ( [0] => jquery.min.js ) [metas] => Array ( [language] => en [robots] => index, follow ) [user] => [curr_url] => https://www.elcosh.org/index.php?module=Record&id=3908&type=document [base_url] => https://www.elcosh.org/index.php?module=Record [title] => eLCOSH : An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: DustControl 2900c Vacuum with the ICS Dust Director Shroud and Bosch Grinder Model 1775E Conducted November 14-15, 2012 [language] => en [search_query] => [module] => Record [new_records] => Array ( [0] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Fixed Ladder [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Fixed Ladders addresses the potential risks associated with using fixed ladders. The resource includes a brief case example,... [category] => Array ( [0] => 15 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 53 [5] => 55 [6] => 60 [7] => 64 [8] => 73 [9] => 76 [10] => 78 [11] => 80 [12] => 86 [13] => 87 [14] => 90 [15] => 92 [16] => 93 [17] => 94 [18] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Falls [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Concrete Polisher [11] => Electrical Worker [13] => HVAC [15] => Laborer [17] => PCC/Restoration [19] => Plumber/Pipefitter [21] => Roofer/Waterproofer [23] => Sheetmetal Worker [25] => Welder [27] => Commercial & Institutional [28] => Jobsites [29] => Industrial [31] => LEED/Green Construction [33] => Renovations [35] => Residential [37] => Toolbox Talks [38] => Documents [39] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4430/d001660/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BFixed%2BLadder.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [53] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 53 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Concrete Polisher [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [73] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 73 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => PCC/Restoration [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4430 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001660 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Fixed Ladder [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Fixed Ladders, Fall Prevention, Falls [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Fixed Ladders addresses the potential risks associated with using fixed ladders. The resource includes a brief case example, steps to prevent a related injury and questions for discussion. It includes an image that illustrates the hazard, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001257,d001254,d001255,d001256,d001258,d001262,d001279 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_completed:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/22/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [1] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Challenges Preventing Falling Objects [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Challenges Preventing Falling Objects addresses the hazards of being struck by falling objects on the job site. The resource... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 55 [5] => 64 [6] => 68 [7] => 71 [8] => 75 [9] => 78 [10] => 79 [11] => 82 [12] => 62 [13] => 86 [14] => 87 [15] => 88 [16] => 89 [17] => 91 [18] => 90 [19] => 92 [20] => 93 [21] => 94 [22] => 95 [23] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Electrical Worker [11] => Laborer [13] => Maintenance Worker [15] => Painter [17] => Plasterer [19] => Roofer/Waterproofer [21] => Scaffold Erector [23] => Stonemason [25] => Structural Ironworker [27] => Welder [29] => Commercial & Institutional [30] => Jobsites [31] => Demolition [33] => Disasters [35] => Heavy & Highway [37] => Industrial [39] => LEED/Green Construction [41] => Renovations [43] => Residential [45] => Underground [47] => Toolbox Talks [48] => Documents [49] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4431/d001661/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BChallenges%2BPreventing%2BFalling%2BObjects.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4431 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001661 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Challenges Preventing Falling Objects [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => dropped objects, falling objects, struck by incidents, struck by fatalities [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Challenges Preventing Falling Objects addresses the hazards of being struck by falling objects on the job site. The resource includes a brief example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates a group workers observing a scaffold free of debris during high winds, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001234,d001238,d001244,d001251,d001253,d001260,d001268,d001278 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_completed:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/22/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [2] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Tower Crane Safety [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Tower Crane Safety addresses the potential hazards of Tower Cranes and the importance of following procedure before and durin... [category] => Array ( [0] => 11 [1] => 12 [2] => 18 [3] => 70 [4] => 87 [5] => 88 [6] => 91 [7] => 90 [8] => 92 [9] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Cranes & Hoists [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Crushed/Struck By [6] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [9] => Operating Engineer [10] => Trades [11] => Commercial & Institutional [12] => Jobsites [13] => Demolition [15] => Heavy & Highway [17] => Industrial [19] => LEED/Green Construction [21] => Toolbox Talks [22] => Documents [23] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4427/d001657/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BTower%2BCrane%2BSafety.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [11] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 11 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Cranes & Hoists [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [18] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 18 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4427 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001657 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Tower Crane Safety [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Tower Crane, Crane, Stability, Tipping, Lift Zone Safety, Lift, Zone, Safety, Struck by [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Tower Crane Safety addresses the potential hazards of Tower Cranes and the importance of following procedure before and during Tower Crane operation. The resource includes a brief example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates a worker inspecting a Tower Crane before operation, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001234,d001238,d001250,d001251,d001253,d001258,d001262,d001273 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/19/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [3] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Work Zone Safety: Working Around Vehicles [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Working Around Vehicles in the Work Zone addresses methods to avoid being struck-by a vehicle on a construction site. The res... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 18 [2] => 52 [3] => 57 [4] => 70 [5] => 85 [6] => 87 [7] => 88 [8] => 89 [9] => 91 [10] => 90 [11] => 92 [12] => 93 [13] => 94 [14] => 95 [15] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [6] => Commercial Diver [7] => Trades [8] => Flagger [10] => Operating Engineer [12] => Truck Driver [14] => Commercial & Institutional [15] => Jobsites [16] => Demolition [18] => Disasters [20] => Heavy & Highway [22] => Industrial [24] => LEED/Green Construction [26] => Renovations [28] => Residential [30] => Underground [32] => Toolbox Talks [33] => Documents [34] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4428/d001658/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BWork%2BZone%2BSafety%253A%2BWorking%2BAround%2BVehicles.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [18] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 18 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [52] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 52 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Commercial Diver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [85] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 85 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Truck Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4428 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001658 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Daniela Caceres [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Work Zone Safety: Working Around Vehicles [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Struck, Struck by, Vehicle, Work Zone Safety, Truck, Operator, Driver, Mobile Equipment [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Working Around Vehicles in the Work Zone addresses methods to avoid being struck-by a vehicle on a construction site. The resource includes a case example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates the hazard, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001640 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/19/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [4] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Construction Dive -- DeWalt's Jobsite Pro headphones recalled for fire hazards [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => A recall notice by the United States Consumer Product Safety Commission affects over 300,000 DeWalt Jobsite Pro Headphones. The recall is a result of... [category] => Array ( [0] => 16 [1] => 44 [2] => 45 [3] => 46 [4] => 47 [5] => 48 [6] => 49 [7] => 50 [8] => 51 [9] => 52 [10] => 53 [11] => 54 [12] => 55 [13] => 56 [14] => 57 [15] => 58 [16] => 59 [17] => 60 [18] => 61 [19] => 64 [20] => 65 [21] => 66 [22] => 67 [23] => 68 [24] => 69 [25] => 70 [26] => 71 [27] => 72 [28] => 73 [29] => 74 [30] => 75 [31] => 76 [32] => 77 [33] => 63 [34] => 78 [35] => 79 [36] => 80 [37] => 81 [38] => 82 [39] => 62 [40] => 83 [41] => 84 [42] => 85 [43] => 86 [44] => 87 [45] => 88 [46] => 89 [47] => 91 [48] => 90 [49] => 92 [50] => 93 [51] => 94 [52] => 95 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Fire & Explosions [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Acoustical Ceiling Carpenter [4] => Trades [5] => Asbestos/Insulator [7] => Boilermaker [9] => Bricklayer [11] => Cabinetmaker [13] => Carpenter [15] => Carpet Layer [17] => Cement Mason [19] => Commercial Diver [21] => Concrete Polisher [23] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [25] => Electrical Worker [27] => Elevator Constructor [29] => Flagger [31] => Glazier [33] => Hazardous Waste Cleanup [35] => HVAC [37] => Interior Systems Carpenter [39] => Laborer [41] => Landscaper [43] => Lather [45] => Lead Abatement Worker [47] => Maintenance Worker [49] => Millwright [51] => Operating Engineer [53] => Painter [55] => Paper Hanger [57] => PCC/Restoration [59] => Pile Driver [61] => Plasterer [63] => Plumber/Pipefitter [65] => Refractory Worker [67] => Reinforcing Ironworker [69] => Roofer/Waterproofer [71] => Scaffold Erector [73] => Sheetmetal Worker [75] => Sprinkler Fitter [77] => Stonemason [79] => Structural Ironworker [81] => Terrazzo Worker [83] => Tile Setter [85] => Truck Driver [87] => Welder [89] => Commercial & Institutional [90] => Jobsites [91] => Demolition [93] => Disasters [95] => Heavy & Highway [97] => Industrial [99] => LEED/Green Construction [101] => Renovations [103] => Residential [105] => Underground ) [type] => [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4426/d001656/Construction%2BDive%2B--%2BDeWalt%2527s%2BJobsite%2BPro%2Bheadphones%2Brecalled%2Bfor%2Bfire%2Bhazards.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [16] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 16 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Fire & Explosions [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [44] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 44 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Acoustical Ceiling Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [45] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 45 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Asbestos/Insulator [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [46] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 46 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Boilermaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [48] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 48 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cabinetmaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [50] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 50 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpet Layer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [52] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 52 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Commercial Diver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [53] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 53 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Concrete Polisher [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [54] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 54 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [58] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 58 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Glazier [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [59] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 59 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Hazardous Waste Cleanup [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [65] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 65 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Landscaper [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [66] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 66 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Lather [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [67] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 67 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Lead Abatement Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [69] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 69 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Millwright [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [72] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 72 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Paper Hanger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [73] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 73 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => PCC/Restoration [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [77] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 77 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Refractory Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [81] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 81 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sprinkler Fitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [83] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 83 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Terrazzo Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [84] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 84 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Tile Setter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [85] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 85 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Truck Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4426 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001656 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Construction Dive -- DeWalt's Jobsite Pro headphones recalled for fire hazards [total_pages:protected] => 1 [billed_pages:protected] => 1 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => DeWalt, Fire Hazards, recall, headphones [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A recall notice by the United States Consumer Product Safety Commission affects over 300,000 DeWalt Jobsite Pro Headphones. The recall is a result of a malfunction that can cause earbuds to overheat while charging or during use, leading to fire and burn hazards. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => https://www.constructiondive.com/news/dewalts-jobsite-pro-headphones-recalled-for-fire-hazards/611248/?utm_source=Sailthru&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Issue:%202021-12-10%20Construction%20Dive%20Newsletter%20%5Bissue:38532%5D&utm_term=Construction%20Dive [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/13/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/13/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 12/13/21 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [new_images] => Array ( [0] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Morning Toolbox Talk [image] => /record/images/4003-p.jpg [blurb] => This photo is from an early morning toolbox talk on a construction job in Mclean, Virginia. It is being delivered in English and Spanish.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 20 [1] => 51 [2] => 57 [3] => 64 [4] => 70 [5] => 63 [6] => 78 [7] => 82 [8] => 62 [9] => 87 [10] => 88 [11] => 89 [12] => 91 [13] => 90 [14] => 93 [15] => 94 [16] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Safety Culture [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Cement Mason [4] => Trades [5] => Flagger [7] => Laborer [9] => Operating Engineer [11] => Reinforcing Ironworker [13] => Roofer/Waterproofer [15] => Stonemason [17] => Structural Ironworker [19] => Commercial & Institutional [20] => Jobsites [21] => Demolition [23] => Disasters [25] => Heavy & Highway [27] => Industrial [29] => Renovations [31] => Residential [33] => Images [34] => Media [35] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4003/i002691/Morning%2BToolbox%2BTalk.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4003 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002691 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Morning Toolbox Talk [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, Spanish, bilingual [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This photo is from an early morning toolbox talk on a construction job in Mclean, Virginia. It is being delivered in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001285,d001304,c000079 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [1] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox talk - crew view [image] => /record/images/4005-p.jpg [blurb] => Photo of crew listening to a toolbox safety talk before starting work.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 97 [1] => 20 [2] => 47 [3] => 49 [4] => 51 [5] => 55 [6] => 61 [7] => 64 [8] => 71 [9] => 75 [10] => 63 [11] => 79 [12] => 62 [13] => 87 [14] => 88 [15] => 91 [16] => 90 [17] => 93 [18] => 94 [19] => 95 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Images [1] => Media [2] => Media & Documents [3] => Safety Culture [4] => Work Environment [5] => Hazards [6] => Bricklayer [7] => Trades [8] => Carpenter [10] => Cement Mason [12] => Electrical Worker [14] => Interior Systems Carpenter [16] => Laborer [18] => Painter [20] => Plasterer [22] => Reinforcing Ironworker [24] => Scaffold Erector [26] => Structural Ironworker [28] => Commercial & Institutional [29] => Jobsites [30] => Demolition [32] => Heavy & Highway [34] => Industrial [36] => Renovations [38] => Residential [40] => Underground ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4005/i002692/Toolbox%2Btalk%2B-%2Bcrew%2Bview.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4005 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002692 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox talk - crew view [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, safety talk, Spanish [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Photo of crew listening to a toolbox safety talk before starting work. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002691,d001269, c000079, d001285 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [2] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox talk - long shot [image] => /record/images/4006-p.jpg [blurb] => This crew gathered every morning before starting work to discuss a new safety topic.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 20 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 55 [5] => 64 [6] => 68 [7] => 75 [8] => 76 [9] => 63 [10] => 78 [11] => 79 [12] => 82 [13] => 62 [14] => 87 [15] => 88 [16] => 91 [17] => 90 [18] => 93 [19] => 94 [20] => 95 [21] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Safety Culture [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Electrical Worker [11] => Laborer [13] => Maintenance Worker [15] => Plasterer [17] => Plumber/Pipefitter [19] => Reinforcing Ironworker [21] => Roofer/Waterproofer [23] => Scaffold Erector [25] => Stonemason [27] => Structural Ironworker [29] => Commercial & Institutional [30] => Jobsites [31] => Demolition [33] => Heavy & Highway [35] => Industrial [37] => Renovations [39] => Residential [41] => Underground [43] => Images [44] => Media [45] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4006/i002693/Toolbox%2Btalk%2B-%2Blong%2Bshot.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4006 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002693 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox talk - long shot [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, safety minute [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This crew gathered every morning before starting work to discuss a new safety topic. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002691,i002692,d001269,d000527 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [3] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Safety officer discussing ongoing project with marketing coordinator [image] => /record/images/4014-p.jpg [blurb] => The safety officer (left) points out the good safety practices on this project that reflect well on the firm and may influence future clients.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 97 [1] => 20 [2] => 46 [3] => 47 [4] => 49 [5] => 50 [6] => 51 [7] => 54 [8] => 55 [9] => 58 [10] => 60 [11] => 61 [12] => 64 [13] => 71 [14] => 75 [15] => 76 [16] => 63 [17] => 79 [18] => 80 [19] => 82 [20] => 62 [21] => 83 [22] => 87 [23] => 91 [24] => 90 [25] => 93 [26] => 94 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Images [1] => Media [2] => Media & Documents [3] => Safety Culture [4] => Work Environment [5] => Hazards [6] => Boilermaker [7] => Trades [8] => Bricklayer [10] => Carpenter [12] => Carpet Layer [14] => Cement Mason [16] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [18] => Electrical Worker [20] => Glazier [22] => HVAC [24] => Interior Systems Carpenter [26] => Laborer [28] => Painter [30] => Plasterer [32] => Plumber/Pipefitter [34] => Reinforcing Ironworker [36] => Scaffold Erector [38] => Sheetmetal Worker [40] => Stonemason [42] => Structural Ironworker [44] => Terrazzo Worker [46] => Commercial & Institutional [47] => Jobsites [48] => Heavy & Highway [50] => Industrial [52] => Renovations [54] => Residential ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4014/i002700/Safety%2Bofficer%2Bdiscussing%2Bongoing%2Bproject%2Bwith%2Bmarketing%2Bcoordinator.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [46] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 46 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Boilermaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [50] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 50 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpet Layer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [54] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 54 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [58] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 58 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Glazier [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [83] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 83 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Terrazzo Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4014 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002700 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Safety officer discussing ongoing project with marketing coordinator [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Latino, safety officer, safety culture [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The safety officer (left) points out the good safety practices on this project that reflect well on the firm and may influence future clients. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/index.php [more_like_this:protected] => d000989,d001351,d001362,d000652, d001101, d000931, d001395 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Hoar Construction, Photo by Neil Lippy [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 01/30/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [4] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Scaffolding at top of large column [image] => /record/images/3994-p.jpg [blurb] => This shot shows innovative guarding around the top of a large concrete column in the base of a high rise structure going up.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 15 [1] => 21 [2] => 47 [3] => 51 [4] => 63 [5] => 78 [6] => 79 [7] => 80 [8] => 62 [9] => 87 [10] => 97 [11] => 56 [12] => 64 [13] => 74 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Falls [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Scaffolds [6] => Bricklayer [7] => Trades [8] => Cement Mason [10] => Reinforcing Ironworker [12] => Roofer/Waterproofer [14] => Scaffold Erector [16] => Sheetmetal Worker [18] => Structural Ironworker [20] => Commercial & Institutional [21] => Jobsites [22] => Images [23] => Media [24] => Media & Documents [25] => Elevator Constructor [27] => Laborer [29] => Pile Driver ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/3994/i002689/Scaffolding%2Bat%2Btop%2Bof%2Blarge%2Bcolumn.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [21] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 21 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Scaffolds [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3994 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002689 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Scaffolding at top of large column [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Guardrail, railing, fall prevention, falls [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This shot shows innovative guarding around the top of a large concrete column in the base of a high rise structure going up. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/8/adjustable-tower-scaffold.html [more_like_this:protected] => c1002680,i002662,d000608,d001255 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Photo by Pam Susi [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2016 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_completed:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/01/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [5] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Construction bracing [image] => /record/images/3995-p.jpg [blurb] => This shows structural support that prevents collapses during construction.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 15 [2] => 21 [3] => 49 [4] => 51 [5] => 55 [6] => 56 [7] => 60 [8] => 64 [9] => 68 [10] => 74 [11] => 63 [12] => 78 [13] => 79 [14] => 80 [15] => 62 [16] => 87 [17] => 90 [18] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Falls [6] => Scaffolds [9] => Carpenter [10] => Trades [11] => Cement Mason [13] => Electrical Worker [15] => Elevator Constructor [17] => HVAC [19] => Laborer [21] => Maintenance Worker [23] => Pile Driver [25] => Reinforcing Ironworker [27] => Roofer/Waterproofer [29] => Scaffold Erector [31] => Sheetmetal Worker [33] => Structural Ironworker [35] => Commercial & Institutional [36] => Jobsites [37] => Industrial [39] => Images [40] => Media [41] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/3995/i002690/Construction%2Bbracing.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [21] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 21 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Scaffolds [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3995 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002690 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Construction bracing [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Bracing, support, scaffold [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This shows structural support that prevents collapses during construction. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/8/adjustable-tower-scaffold.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002660 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Photo by Pam Susi [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2016 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_completed:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/01/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [preview_mode] => [description] => The results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. [keywords] => tuckpointing, HEPA vacuum, dust control, LEV, local exhaust ventilation, silica [related_items] => Array ( [Research Reports] => Array ( [0] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1874 [old_id:protected] => 722 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000683 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Sharon Garber/COD [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Protecting Tuckpointing Workers from Silica Dust: Draft Recommendations for a Ventilated Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 12 [billed_pages:protected] => 12 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, vacuum, grinder, mortar, respirator, OSHA, NIOSH, exhaust, Heitbrink, tuckpointer, silica, masonry, dust, silicosis, LEV [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Describes draft recommendations for use of ventilated grinder to reduce dust during tuckpointing and describes field trials using these devices. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/hazard/67/chip-scrape-and-grind-surfaces-or-joints-silica.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001201,d000292,d000293,d000658 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2005 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/27/05 [date_completed:protected] => 04/26/05 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/20/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [1] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1940 [old_id:protected] => 909 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Workplace Solutions: Control of Hazardous Dust During Tuckpointing [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, silica, dust, tuckpoint, grinder, masonry restoration, mortar, vacuum [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d000819,d000820,d000730,d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 10/24/08 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/09 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [2] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3899 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001342 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: Hilti VC40-U Vacuum with Hilti DC-EX Dust Guard and Hilti Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 15 [billed_pages:protected] => 15 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP4 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => silica, tuckpointing, Hilti, local exhaust systems, LEV, shroud, quartz [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This report describes the results of an evaluation of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Hilti VC40-U vacuum, a Hilti DC-EX shroud, and a Hilti DAG-500 grinder. Randomized trials with and without use of the dust control system were conducted in a controlled setting. Removing mortar with the Hilti grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 220 times the National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05mg/m3. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 97 percent. However, exposures measured during the use of the dust control system still exceeded the NIOSH REL. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => December 1, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/05/14 [date_completed:protected] => 02/04/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/06/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [Handouts] => Array ( [0] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3656 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001198 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 24 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction While Doing Tuckpointing/Mortar Removal [total_pages:protected] => 2 [billed_pages:protected] => 2 [publication_number:protected] => DSG FS-3632 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Brick, block, tuckpointing, silica, local exhaust ventilation, LEV, masonry [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Tuckpointing creates some of the greatest exposures to silica in construction. This OSHA factsheet provides guidance on how to greatly reduce these exposures through the use of local exhaust ventilation. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863, d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => February 2013 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/04/13 [date_completed:protected] => 03/27/13 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [collections] => Array ( [3913] => ) [record] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => Array ( [867] => Author Object ( [id:protected] => 867 [organization_id:protected] => 0 [firstname:protected] => Michael [lastname:protected] => Cooper [address:protected] => [city:protected] => [province:protected] => [country:protected] => [postal_code:protected] => [department:protected] => [title:protected] => [phone:protected] => [fax:protected] => [email:protected] => [degree:protected] => [website:protected] => [about:protected] => [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => [date_completed:protected] => [date_billed:protected] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [481] => Author Object ( [id:protected] => 481 [organization_id:protected] => 0 [firstname:protected] => Pam [lastname:protected] => Susi [address:protected] => 8484 Georgia Avenue, Suite 1000 [city:protected] => Silver Spring [province:protected] => Maryland [country:protected] => USA [postal_code:protected] => 20910 [department:protected] => [title:protected] => [phone:protected] => 301-578-8500 ext.144 [fax:protected] => 301-578-8572 [email:protected] => plsusi@aol.com [degree:protected] => [website:protected] => http://www.cpwr.com [about:protected] => [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => 2003-10-02 [date_completed:protected] => 2003-10-06 [date_billed:protected] => 2003-11-03 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [organizations:protected] => Array ( [1] => Organization Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [elcosh_id:protected] => o000001 [user_id:protected] => 14 [province_id:protected] => 21 [country_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => CPWR - The Center for Construction Research and Training [address:protected] => Suite 1000, 8484 Georgia Ave [postal_code:protected] => 20910 [city:protected] => Silver Spring [department:protected] => [phone:protected] => 301-578-8500 [fax:protected] => 301-578-8572 [email:protected] => cpwrwebsite@cpwr.com [website:protected] => http://www.cpwr.com [filename:protected] => o000001.gif [about:protected] => CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training, developed, and continues to maintain/expand this website - The Electronic Library of Construction Occupational Safety and Health, www.elcosh.org. CPWR, formerly known as The Center to Protect Workers’ Rights, is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit research and training institution. Created by the Building and Construction Trades Department, AFL-CIO, CPWR serves as the research arm of the BCTD. Since the inception of its research agenda in 1990, CPWR has grown into a worldwide provider of safety and health information covering all aspects of the construction industry. CPWR launched eLCOSH in 2000, and the Spanish-language version of the site in 2001. CPWR also created, and continues to build, Construction Solutions - www.cpwrConstructionSolutions.org - a free, online database of construction hazards and ways to prevent, eliminate, or reduce them. [comments:protected] => [logo_available:protected] => T [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => 2000-08-18 [date_completed:protected] => 2000-08-30 [date_billed:protected] => 2000-09-05 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [collections:protected] => Array ( [3913] => ) [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => Array ( [1874] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1874 [old_id:protected] => 722 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000683 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Sharon Garber/COD [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Protecting Tuckpointing Workers from Silica Dust: Draft Recommendations for a Ventilated Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 12 [billed_pages:protected] => 12 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, vacuum, grinder, mortar, respirator, OSHA, NIOSH, exhaust, Heitbrink, tuckpointer, silica, masonry, dust, silicosis, LEV [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Describes draft recommendations for use of ventilated grinder to reduce dust during tuckpointing and describes field trials using these devices. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/hazard/67/chip-scrape-and-grind-surfaces-or-joints-silica.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001201,d000292,d000293,d000658 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2005 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/27/05 [date_completed:protected] => 04/26/05 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/20/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [1940] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1940 [old_id:protected] => 909 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Workplace Solutions: Control of Hazardous Dust During Tuckpointing [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, silica, dust, tuckpoint, grinder, masonry restoration, mortar, vacuum [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d000819,d000820,d000730,d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 10/24/08 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/09 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [2213] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 2213 [old_id:protected] => 1090 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => [language_id:protected] => 2 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Control del polvo peligroso que se genera durante los procesos de reparación de mortero [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => 2008-126 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => [comments:protected] => http://www.cdc.gov/spanish/niosh/docs/wp-solutions/2008-126_sp/ [summary:protected] => A Workplace Solutions de NIOSH que resume un estudio de NIOSH sobre los riesgos de exposición cuando se reparan las estructuras y los métodos para controlar el polvo. [A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust.] [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => D000819,D000820,D000730,d000819 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 01/07/10 [date_completed:protected] => 04/19/10 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 07/08/12 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [3656] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3656 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001198 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 24 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction While Doing Tuckpointing/Mortar Removal [total_pages:protected] => 2 [billed_pages:protected] => 2 [publication_number:protected] => DSG FS-3632 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Brick, block, tuckpointing, silica, local exhaust ventilation, LEV, masonry [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Tuckpointing creates some of the greatest exposures to silica in construction. This OSHA factsheet provides guidance on how to greatly reduce these exposures through the use of local exhaust ventilation. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863, d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => February 2013 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/04/13 [date_completed:protected] => 03/27/13 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [3899] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3899 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001342 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: Hilti VC40-U Vacuum with Hilti DC-EX Dust Guard and Hilti Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 15 [billed_pages:protected] => 15 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP4 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => silica, tuckpointing, Hilti, local exhaust systems, LEV, shroud, quartz [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This report describes the results of an evaluation of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Hilti VC40-U vacuum, a Hilti DC-EX shroud, and a Hilti DAG-500 grinder. Randomized trials with and without use of the dust control system were conducted in a controlled setting. Removing mortar with the Hilti grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 220 times the National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05mg/m3. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 97 percent. However, exposures measured during the use of the dust control system still exceeded the NIOSH REL. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => December 1, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/05/14 [date_completed:protected] => 02/04/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/06/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [content:protected] => [files:protected] => Array ( [559] => [560] => [546] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 546 [filename:protected] => 3.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:22 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [566] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 566 [filename:protected] => 4.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:23 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [720] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 720 [filename:protected] => 5.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [721] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 721 [filename:protected] => 6.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [722] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 722 [filename:protected] => 7.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [9765] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 9765 [filename:protected] => d001345.pdf [downloadable:protected] => T [timestamp:protected] => 2015-02-09 12:26:04 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3908 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001345 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: DustControl 2900c Vacuum with the ICS Dust Director Shroud and Bosch Grinder Model 1775E Conducted November 14-15, 2012 [total_pages:protected] => 13 [billed_pages:protected] => 13 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP2 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => tuckpointing, HEPA vacuum, dust control, LEV, local exhaust ventilation, silica [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => April 15, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 01/26/15 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/09/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [show_text] => [document_content] => ElcoshItemDocumentContent Object ( [id:protected] => 2934 [item_id:protected] => 3908 [type:protected] => main [title:protected] => [content:protected] =>
Executive Summary
This report describes the results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. It should also be noted that the NIOSH REL is based on exposures averaged over a ten hour work day and our results represent time weighted averages of the sample task duration periods.
Acronyms
ACGIH - American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists
CPWR - CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training
Ce - coefficient of entry
HEPA - high-efficiency particulate air
IUBAC - International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craftworkers
LEV - local exhaust ventilation
PACT - Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies
NIOSH - National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health
OEL - occupational exposure limit
OSHA - Occupational Safety and Health Administration
PAPR - powered air-purifying respirator
PEL - Permissible Exposure Limit
PVC - polyvinyl chloride
REL - Recommended Exposure Limit
RPM - revolutions per minute
TWA - time-weighted average
SP - static pressure
I. Introduction and Background
In 2010 CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training began a four-year project which seeks to identify and evaluate tuckpointing local exhaust ventilation (LEV) systems and disseminate information on their availability and effectiveness. A Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies (PACT) comprised of masonry contractors, representatives from unions, government, equipment manufacturers, and health and safety researcher was formed as part of this project. PACT members participated in identifying important characteristics for control technologies and this information was used to identify LEV systems for tuckpointing using that criteria. Contractor and labor members of the PACT selected specific tuckpointing LEV systems to be considered for evaluation. Each system consisted of a tuckpointing grinder, shroud, and vacuum. This report describes the second of four systems to be evaluated between 2012 the end of 2014, with and without LEV, in a controlled setting to determine effectiveness in silica exposure reduction. This report describes the methods and results of our evaluation of a system consisting of the DustControl 2900c vacuum with the ICS Dust Director shroud and a Bosch Model 1775E grinder.
Excessive exposure to respirable silica can result in silicosis or other silica-related diseases including pulmonary tuberculosis, lung cancer, silicoproteinosis (Lyons et al, 2007) and autoimmune disorders such as rheumatoid arthritis, sarcoidosis and scleroderma (Miller et al, 2012). Respirable silica is generally defined as particles less than 10 micrometers (μm) in aerodynamic diameter (ACGIH, 2013). Silicosis can lead to symptoms including shortness of breath, fatigue, chest pains, susceptibility to infection and possibly death. There is no cure for silicosis, however it is totally preventable. Construction workers exposed to dust, including silica, are also known to have higher rates of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD).
There are many sources of silica in construction that result in exposures of varying intensity among workers. Masonry restoration workers are among the most highly silica-exposed trades in construction. The process of grinding out deteriorated mortar joints between masonry units and replacing or repointing with fresh mortar (often referred to as tuckpointing) is a fundamental part of masonry restoration work. The removal of mortar with powered angle grinders generates enormous levels of dust. Between 2004 and 2006, NIOSH and CPWR evaluated silica exposures while grinding mortar in a controlled setting, at a local training center, where tasks, sample times and task variables were defined by the study design. These studies demonstrated that grinding mortar without controls can result in elevated respirable silica exposures. Meeker et al., (2009) reported exposures between 5 and 25.8 milligrams per cubic meter (mg/m3) in a controlled setting. This study also showed that LEV systems for tuckpointing grinders can reduce exposures to respirable silica by greater than 90 percent.II. Objectives
The objective of this evaluation was to assess the effectiveness of an LEV system for controlling exposure to silica during the grinding of mortar. The control technology was tested under controlled conditions, similar to those experienced by tuckpointers on actual job sites, using journeymen bricklayers experienced in tuckpointing and repeat, randomized trials with and without LEV. All other variables were held constant throughout so that the only variable was whether or not the tested control was used.
III. Description of Equipment Tested
A Bosch model 1775E grinder (Robert Bosch Tool Corporation, Prospect, IL) (Figures 1, 2 and 3) was fitted with a new 1/4-inch wide, 4½-inch diameter segmented diamond abrasive blade made by DeWalt (model #DW4740). The grinder weighs six and a half pounds, draws 8.5 amps and has a variable speed up to 11,000 revolutions per minute (RPMs). The DustControl 2900c vacuum (DustControl, Inc., Wilmington, NC) (Figure 3) was tested in combination with the Dust Director shroud (Industrial Contractors’ Supplies, Inc., Huntingdon, PA) (Figures 1 and 3) attached to the Bosch grinder.
Figure 1. Bosch grinder with Dust Director shroud
Figure 2. Bosch grinder without tuckpointing LEV system.
Figure 3: Bosch Grinder with LEV System
The vacuum is specified to weigh 31 pounds when empty and to provide a flow rate of 114 cubic feet of air per minute and a “static lift” or “vacuum suction pressure” of 84 inches of water. The vacuum is sold with a cyclonic pre-separator, to remove larger particles, a fine filter (rated 99.9 percent efficient) and a HEPA (high-efficiency particulate air) filter (rated to capture 99.97 percent of the particles with an aerodynamic diameter of 0.3 micrometers). The HEPA filter was removed based on the manufacturer’s recommendation due to the heavy dust loading associated with tuckpointing. CPWR sponsored research and contractor experience indicate that HEPA filters likely have an adverse effect on dust capture during tuckpointing because of extreme dust loading on filters. While the cyclone and the fine filter remove most of the dust, especially the large particles, before they reach the HEPA filter, the HEPA filter would still be subject to heavy loading, causing a substantial pressure drop and subsequent decrease in air flow rate. The relatively small increase in the efficiency of the filtration system while using the HEPA filter is expected to be quickly offset by a more significant decrease in capture efficiency as the air flow rate and ability to capture particles decreases.
Dust collects in relatively inexpensive, heavy-gauge plastic bags below and outside of the cyclone. The bags can be removed and replaced without opening the vacuum. Some vacuums are equipped with a light to indicate that the filters need to be cleaned or changed. The DC2900c features a “reverse air pulse cleaning system,” which removes accumulated dust from the filters without having to remove them from the vacuum. The system, as illustrated in Figure 4, requires the operator to disconnect the hose from the shroud, place it over an air stop so that air through the hose is cut off and pressure in the vacuum is maximized.
Figure 4. Procedure for "cleaning" of or dust removal from filters (source: http://dustcontrolusa.com/manuals/2800c.pdf)
The flap covering the port on the side of the vacuum is repeatedly flipped open to release built up pressure in strong pulses that dislodge dust from the filter.
The manufacturer indicates “the filter is generally cleaned once or twice daily during normal continuous operation.” The Dust Director shroud has a 2-inch diameter take-off that was connected to the antistatic, corrugated 1.5-inch diameter, 15-foot long vacuum hose supplied with the DustControl vacuum.
IV. Study Methods
This evaluation was conducted at the International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craft workers (IUBAC) Local 1 Philadelphia/Delaware Training Center in Philadelphia, PA on November 14 and 15, 2012. A single journeyman bricklayer, experienced in tuckpointing, used the grinder and LEV system being tested to remove mortar from joints wide enough to require two passes. The type S mortar had been allowed to cure for at least four weeks. The bricklayer either possessed or was provided with personal protective equipment including sturdy work boots, gloves, hearing protection and a powered air-purifying respirator (PAPR). The PAPR was a 3M GVP system with a bump cap, loose fitting face piece and a HEPA filter (3M, St Paul, MN).
The study was designed to include at least five rounds of sampling during mortar removal. Each round included a trial using the Bosch grinder with a Dust Director shroud and Dust Collector 2900c vacuum and a trial using the Bosch grinder with the factory-supplied guard and without a vacuum. The order of the two trials within each round was randomly selected to minimize bias that might be introduced due to variation associated with environmental factors, equipment operator, blade wear, vacuum performance over time and any other factors unrelated to LEV use. Tools were operated for approximately 16 minutes per trial with controls and for approximately 8 minutes when controls were not used. These times were selected based on the results of previous sampling efforts and estimates of the minimum sample time needed to achieve a limit of quantification low enough to accurately measure exposures down to or less than 0.05 mg/m3 – the NIOSH Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) for respirable silica. The bricklayer was required to take a 5 to 10 minute break in the middle of the 16-minute trials to reduce differences in fatigue, compared to the 8-minute trials. Personal air samples were collected in the breathing zone of the operator during each trial to measure respirable silica concentrations during grinding with and without LEV. The samples were collected using a GilAir-5 pump (Sensidyne, Inc., Clearwater, FL) to draw 4.2 liters of air per minute through a GK2.69 Respirable Cyclone (BGI Inc., Waltham, MA) with a pre-weighed, 37 mm diameter, 5-micron pore size polyvinyl chloride (PVC) filter positioned on the operator’s lapel.
The flow rates of the sampling pumps were calibrated at the beginning of each day using a DryCal DC-Lite Primary Flow Meter (Bios International Corporation, Butler, NJ). Flow rates were measured again near the middle and at the end of each day to ensure that sampling flow rates were maintained within 5% of pre-sampling flow rates throughout the day. Average flow rates were used to calculate sample air volumes. Samples were analyzed by R.J. Lee Group, Inc., (Monroeville, PA) using NIOSH Method 0600, to determine exposure to total mass of respirable dust. The same samples were also analyzed using X-Ray diffraction following NIOSH method 7500 to determine quartz, cristobalite and tridymite concentration in the respirable mass. Reported masses for these analytes were used with the sample air volumes to calculate airborne concentrations of total respirable dust, quartz, cristobalite and tridymite.
We used a reduction of greater than 50 percent in respirable silica exposure concentrations or a reduction to less than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 as our criteria for determining whether or not a control was considered efficacious. This is consistent with criteria used by NIOSH in conducting a similar study in 2004 described by Echt et al. (2007) and by CPWR in 2006 and described by Meeker et al. (2009). The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) and the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) publish additional occupational exposure limits (OELs) for silica which are listed in Table 1 with NIOSH RELs. OELs for silica are based on the respirable fraction of the aerosol, which consists of particles less than 10 micrometers in aerodynamic diameter.
| Organization or Agency | Form of Crystalline Silica | Occupational Exposure Limits (mg/m3) |
|---|---|---|
| NIOSHA | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 |
| OSHA - ConstructionB | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
PEL = 250 / (5 + % quartz) PEL = 250 / (5 + % cristobalite) PEL = 250 / (5 + % tridymite) |
| ACGIH | Crystalline Silica | TLV = 0.025 mg/m3 |
A NIOSH Publication No. 2005-151 indicates 10-hour time-weighted average during a 40-hr workweek B The PEL for silica in OSHA’s Safety and Health Regulations for Construction, 29 C.F.R. 1926.55(a), is an 8-hour time-weighted average (TWA) expressed in millions of particles per cubic foot (mppcf). However, the units mppcf can be converted to milligrams per cubic meter can by dividing mppcf by 10 (OSHA, 2009). The formula used by OSHA to determine the PEL for silica is dependent on the percentage of silica in each collected sample. The concentration of respirable dust measured is compared to the sample specific PEL to determine if the PEL has been exceeded. OSHA has proposed lowering the PEL to 0.05 mg/m3 of respirable silica as an 8 hour TWA. |
||
The flow of air in ventilation systems is governed by fundamental principles that describe the behavior of gases (in this case air). Pressure measurements taken within a ventilation system along with knowledge of hood (or shroud) entry losses can be used to calculate flow rates. Hood entry losses are dependent on the shape and configuration of a particular hood or shroud and described by the term “coefficient of entry (Ce)” which is the ratio of actual air flow through a hood and what the air flow would theoretically be if there were no hood entry losses. Given the coefficient of entry, static pressure measurements can be used to calculate air flow through a given hood. The coefficient of entry for the Dust Director shroud was previously determined by CPWR and used for calculating air flow based on static pressure measurements (Meeker et al., 2009). Static pressure, with the vacuum operating, was measured periodically throughout the evaluation to monitor the changes in air-flow rate following use and again after filter cleaning. The static pressure was measured at a port positioned more than 3 duct diameters downstream from the tool’s air intake using a UEi EM200 Electronic Manometer (Universal Enterprises, Inc., Beaverton, OR).
The dust in the vacuum bag was monitored and, per the manufacturer’s instructions, the bag was changed before the dust level was within 5 centimeters of the valve at the bottom of the vacuum. Each time a vacuum bag was removed, it was weighed to the nearest pound. The bag weights and corresponding grinding durations were used to calculate the average weight of dust collected per unit time. After each trial, cut lengths were measured on the wall to determine total linear feet of vertical (head) and horizontal (bed) joints per unit time.
A Haz-Dust III, Model HD-1003, Real-Time Aerosol Monitor (Environmental Devices Corporation, Plaistow, NH) was used to confirm clearance of dust between trials. The Haz-Dust monitor was positioned on the test wall near the operator at approximately breathing zone level and configured to measure respirable particulate concentration.
V. Results
Personal air monitoring
Five pairs of respirable dust samples were collected while grinding with and without the vacuum system. In addition, three respirable dust samples were collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place. One measurement collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard was shown to be a statistical outlier and was omitted from analysis. Personal air monitoring results for respirable silica and a comparison of average exposures relative to the NIOSH REL for silica (0.05 mg/m3) appears in Table 2. The mean respirable dust levels measured without LEV was 31.4 mg/m3. However, samples collected with LEV were below the limit of quantification (LOQ) which ranged from <1.29 to <1.46 mg/m3. Use of LEV resulted in a greater than 95% reduction in mean respirable dust levels using a mean value with use of LEV of <1.41 (n=5 samples with use of LEV and n=7 without use of LEV). The respirable dust samples collected during grinding without the LEV system contained an average of 24 percent silica. The mass of respirable dust in the samples collected with use of the LEV system was too low to determine the silica content.| Mean, mg/m3 (range) | Std. Dev. | Percent Reduction | Hazard RatioB | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bosch with Dust Director Shroud and DustControl 2900c Vacuum |
0.091 (<0.069 – 0.137) |
0.027 | 98.7 | 1.81 |
| Bosch with no Control | 7.23 (4.57 – 9.90) |
1.94 | NA | 145 |
A n = 5 samples for each tool/control combination and n = 7 samples without the use of the LEV system B Hazard Ratio = measured exposure / NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 |
||||
Average respirable silica and dust exposures, with and without the dust control system, appear as Figures 5 and 6, respectively.
Figure 5. Average respirable silica exposures with and without the Dustcontrol 2900c vacuum and Dust Director shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air - mg/m3)
Figure 6. Average respirable dust exposures with and without Dustcontrol 2900c Vacuum and Dust Director Shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air – mg/m3)
The mean respirable silica concentration measured during use of the control was significantly less than the concentration measured while using the same tool without controls (p<0.01). Grinding mortar with the Bosch angle grinder without dust controls resulted in an average exposure to respirable silica that was 145 times the NIOSH REL. Grinding with the Bosch angle grinder in combination with the Dust Director shroud and the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced the average concentration of respirable silica by 98.7 percent. With use of these controls, the concentration of respirable silica was 1.8 times greater than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3. However the NIOSH REL is based on a time-weighted average (TWA) over a 10-hour workday. Given these were task TWAs and samples were collected over continuous periods of grinding, they may overestimate exposures over an actual work day since some time would be spent performing tasks that would likely have lower, or no, silica exposures (setup, breaks, cleanup, etc.).
Static pressure, dust mass collection and grinding rates.
Static pressure was used as a surrogate for air flow as described earlier. Hood static pressure was measured periodically at a tap near the grinder more than 3 duct diameters from the air intake in the shroud. The static pressure, and thus air flow, was generally higher when the vacuum’s filter had recently been cleaned. The mean, median, and range of calculated flow rates are presented in Table A1 of the Appendix.
Based on the data we collected, the air-flow rate upstream from the Bosch grinder and Dust Director shroud ranged from 78 to 93 cubic feet per minute (cfm) with the DustControl vacuum. When the manufacturer’s filter cleaning procedure was followed the vacuum performed relatively well and flow could be maintained at slightly less than 90 cfm with cleaning. However, mean flow rates dropped substantially to 80 cfm after as little as 8 minutes of grinding without any filter cleaning. The flow rate returned to an average of 89 cfm when filters were cleaned correctly (without stopping air flow to the vacuum). Collingwood and Heitbrink (2007) found that the minimum exhaust flow rate for capture of silica and other particulate under ideal conditions is 21.25 cfm per inch of grinder blade diameter. This is equal to about 96 cfm when using a 4.5 inch diameter grinding blade. We set 106 cfm as the minimum desired flow rate for this study to allow a safety margin for potential decline in equipment performance and the possibility of inadequate maintenance, both of which may be likely after repeated use under actual work conditions. The DustControl vacuum provided slightly less than the minimum flow rate described by Collingwood and Heitbrink for a 4.5-inch blade and the peak flow rate fell with use.
The duration of vacuum bag use and mass of dust collected were recorded and are presented in Table A2 of the Appendix. The vacuum bags were changed and weighed after each trial utilizing the LEV system. A total of five bags were used to complete the five rounds of grinding. The DustControl vacuum captured 45 pounds of dust over 83 minutes of grinding for an average rate of dust collection of 0.54 pounds per minute. The rate of dust collection ranged from 0.47 to 0.63 pounds per minute. Based on these measurements, approximately 130 pounds of dust would likely be captured after just 4 hours of continuous grinding.
The rate of grinding a combination of vertical and horizontal joints while using the LEV system ranged from 2.3 to 3.3 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the use of the LEV system ranged from 2.6 to 3.4 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place ranged from 4.7 to 5.1 feet per minute. It’s important to note that: 1) the operator had limited experience using dust control systems and cut rates appeared to improve slightly over the 2-day period he used the tested equipment; and 2) the upper range of cut rates with the dust control system overlapped with the lowest cut rate with the original guard and without the LEV system in place indicating no statistical difference between cut rates. Given that grinding rates with and without use of this LEV system are only available for one operator and he had limited experience with the LEV system, these reported cut rates are in no way intended to represent the impact use of this LEV system is likely to have on productivity rates overall.
VI. Discussion
The objective of these trials was to evaluate the effectiveness of a tuckpointing LEV system for controlling respirable silica while grinding out mortar joints. The Dust Director shroud with the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced respirable silica concentrations when grinding with the Bosch grinder by approximately 99 percent. Despite being considered effective by our test criteria (greater than 50% reduction), it still resulted in task TWA exposures that exceeded the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 by 1.8 times. Depending on how much time is spent grinding over the course of a work day and on exposures while performing other tasks, the 8-hour TWA exposures may or may not exceed the REL with this system. Use of this system by workers with experience and training in proficient use will likely improve dust capture performance. Exposure reduction is greatly influenced by correct use of this system which includes grinding from right to left, making sure the shroud is held flush against the wall and that the tool travels at a pace that doesn’t exceed the ability of the system to capture dust as it’s generated. Deviation from any of these measures produces visible dust clouds which were observed during trials.
VII. Conclusions
With a 99 percent reduction in respirable silica exposure, the Dust Director shroud and DustControl 2900c vacuum with a Bosch Model 1775E grinder was effective in reducing silica exposures based on our criteria. Use of the tested dust control system may be effective in reducing silica exposure on the job to less than the NIOSH REL if used in combination with administrative controls such as work scheduling to reduce cutting times as needed. Training on correct use of the tested system is also essential. Personal air monitoring is necessary to verify control effectiveness on actual job sites and under “real-world” conditions. However, these results clearly demonstrate the availability of viable and effective engineering controls for tuckpointing operations associated with elevated silica exposure.
VIII. References
American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists. Threshold limit values for chemical substances (TLV®-CS). [2013]. ACGIH, Cincinnati, Ohio.
Bergdahl I.A,. Toren K., Eriksson K., et al. [2004]. Increased mortality in COPD among construction workers exposed to inorganic dust. European Respiratory Journal, 23: 402–06.
Blanc P.D. & Torén K. [2007]. Occupation in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and chronic bronchitis: an update [State of the Art Series. Occupational lung disease in high-and low-income countries, Edited by M. Chan-Yeung. Number 2 in the series]. The International Journal of Tuberculosis and Lung Disease, 11(3), 251-257.
Collingwood S. & Heitbrink W.A. [2007] 'Field Evaluation of an Engineering Control for Respirable Crystalline Silica Exposures During Mortar Removal'. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, 4:11, 875 – 887.
DHHS (NIOSH) Publication No. 2002-129 April 2002 http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/2002-129/
Echt A., Sieber W.K., Lefkowitz D., Meeker J., Susi P., Cardwell B., Heitbrink, W.A. In-depth survey of dust control technology for cutting concrete block and tuckpointing brick at The International Masonry Institute Bordentown Training Center, Bordentown, NJ. Cincinnati, OH: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Report. No. EPHB 282-13; 2007. http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ECTB-282-13.pdf
Heitbrink W., Bennett J. [2006]. A numerical and experimental investigation of crystalline silica exposure control during tuck pointing. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, Vol. 3, pp 366-378.
Lyons et al, [2007]. A breathless builder. Breathe, Vol. 3, no. 4, pp 386-390.
Mastrangelo G., Tartari M., Fedeli U., Fadda E., Saia B. [2003]. Ascertaining the risk of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease in relation to occupation using a case-control design. Occupational Medicine, 53: 165–172.
Meeker J., Cooper M., Lefrowitz D., Susi P. [2009]. Engineering control technologies to reduce occupational silica exposures in masonry cutting and tuckpointing. Public Health Reports, Supplement 1, Vol. 124, June.
Meeker J, Flynn M, Susi P, Cardwell, B [2004]. Performance evaluation of a masonry concrete vacuum. Unpublished Report.
Miller F. W., Alfredsson L., Costenbader K. H., Kamen D. L., Nelson L. M., Norris J. M., & De Roos A. J. [2012]. Epidemiology of environmental exposures and human autoimmune diseases: findings from a National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences Expert Panel workshop. Journal of autoimmunity. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3496812/
Occupational Safety and Health Administration U.S Department of Labor. Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction. [2009]. OSHA 3362-05.
Rappaport SM, Goldberg M, Susi P, Herrick RF [2003]. Excessive exposure to silica in the U.S. construction industry. Annals of Occupational Hygiene, Vol. 47, pp. 111-122.
IX. Appendices
| Measurement Conditions |
n | Mean Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Median
Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before filter cleaning | 5 | 80 | 81 | 78-81 |
| After filter cleaning following manufacturer directions | 9 | 89 | 90 | 84-93 |
| * Static pressure was measured in millibars and converted to inches of water gauge. Flow rates were calculated using the formula Q = Ce (A) 4005 (SP)1/2 where: Q = flow in cubic feet per minute (cfm), Ce = coefficient of entry, A = area of the duct where static pressure measurements were taken in square feet, and SP = static pressure in inches of water gauge. | ||||
| Tool/Control | Collection Period (min.) |
Dust Collection Rate (lb/min.) |
|---|---|---|
| Bosch grinder/Dust Director shroud & DustControl 2900c vacuum |
8 11 8 8 10 |
0.50 0.61 0.50 0.47 0.63 |
| Average | 0.54 |
[content_transformed:protected] =>
Executive Summary
This report describes the results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. It should also be noted that the NIOSH REL is based on exposures averaged over a ten hour work day and our results represent time weighted averages of the sample task duration periods.
Acronyms
ACGIH - American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists
CPWR - CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training
Ce - coefficient of entry
HEPA - high-efficiency particulate air
IUBAC - International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craftworkers
LEV - local exhaust ventilation
PACT - Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies
NIOSH - National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health
OEL - occupational exposure limit
OSHA - Occupational Safety and Health Administration
PAPR - powered air-purifying respirator
PEL - Permissible Exposure Limit
PVC - polyvinyl chloride
REL - Recommended Exposure Limit
RPM - revolutions per minute
TWA - time-weighted average
SP - static pressure
I. Introduction and Background
In 2010 CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training began a four-year project which seeks to identify and evaluate tuckpointing local exhaust ventilation (LEV) systems and disseminate information on their availability and effectiveness. A Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies (PACT) comprised of masonry contractors, representatives from unions, government, equipment manufacturers, and health and safety researcher was formed as part of this project. PACT members participated in identifying important characteristics for control technologies and this information was used to identify LEV systems for tuckpointing using that criteria. Contractor and labor members of the PACT selected specific tuckpointing LEV systems to be considered for evaluation. Each system consisted of a tuckpointing grinder, shroud, and vacuum. This report describes the second of four systems to be evaluated between 2012 the end of 2014, with and without LEV, in a controlled setting to determine effectiveness in silica exposure reduction. This report describes the methods and results of our evaluation of a system consisting of the DustControl 2900c vacuum with the ICS Dust Director shroud and a Bosch Model 1775E grinder.
Excessive exposure to respirable silica can result in silicosis or other silica-related diseases including pulmonary tuberculosis, lung cancer, silicoproteinosis (Lyons et al, 2007) and autoimmune disorders such as rheumatoid arthritis, sarcoidosis and scleroderma (Miller et al, 2012). Respirable silica is generally defined as particles less than 10 micrometers (μm) in aerodynamic diameter (ACGIH, 2013). Silicosis can lead to symptoms including shortness of breath, fatigue, chest pains, susceptibility to infection and possibly death. There is no cure for silicosis, however it is totally preventable. Construction workers exposed to dust, including silica, are also known to have higher rates of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD).
There are many sources of silica in construction that result in exposures of varying intensity among workers. Masonry restoration workers are among the most highly silica-exposed trades in construction. The process of grinding out deteriorated mortar joints between masonry units and replacing or repointing with fresh mortar (often referred to as tuckpointing) is a fundamental part of masonry restoration work. The removal of mortar with powered angle grinders generates enormous levels of dust. Between 2004 and 2006, NIOSH and CPWR evaluated silica exposures while grinding mortar in a controlled setting, at a local training center, where tasks, sample times and task variables were defined by the study design. These studies demonstrated that grinding mortar without controls can result in elevated respirable silica exposures. Meeker et al., (2009) reported exposures between 5 and 25.8 milligrams per cubic meter (mg/m3) in a controlled setting. This study also showed that LEV systems for tuckpointing grinders can reduce exposures to respirable silica by greater than 90 percent.II. Objectives
The objective of this evaluation was to assess the effectiveness of an LEV system for controlling exposure to silica during the grinding of mortar. The control technology was tested under controlled conditions, similar to those experienced by tuckpointers on actual job sites, using journeymen bricklayers experienced in tuckpointing and repeat, randomized trials with and without LEV. All other variables were held constant throughout so that the only variable was whether or not the tested control was used.
III. Description of Equipment Tested
A Bosch model 1775E grinder (Robert Bosch Tool Corporation, Prospect, IL) (Figures 1, 2 and 3) was fitted with a new 1/4-inch wide, 4½-inch diameter segmented diamond abrasive blade made by DeWalt (model #DW4740). The grinder weighs six and a half pounds, draws 8.5 amps and has a variable speed up to 11,000 revolutions per minute (RPMs). The DustControl 2900c vacuum (DustControl, Inc., Wilmington, NC) (Figure 3) was tested in combination with the Dust Director shroud (Industrial Contractors’ Supplies, Inc., Huntingdon, PA) (Figures 1 and 3) attached to the Bosch grinder.
Figure 1. Bosch grinder with Dust Director shroud
Figure 2. Bosch grinder without tuckpointing LEV system.
Figure 3: Bosch Grinder with LEV System
The vacuum is specified to weigh 31 pounds when empty and to provide a flow rate of 114 cubic feet of air per minute and a “static lift” or “vacuum suction pressure” of 84 inches of water. The vacuum is sold with a cyclonic pre-separator, to remove larger particles, a fine filter (rated 99.9 percent efficient) and a HEPA (high-efficiency particulate air) filter (rated to capture 99.97 percent of the particles with an aerodynamic diameter of 0.3 micrometers). The HEPA filter was removed based on the manufacturer’s recommendation due to the heavy dust loading associated with tuckpointing. CPWR sponsored research and contractor experience indicate that HEPA filters likely have an adverse effect on dust capture during tuckpointing because of extreme dust loading on filters. While the cyclone and the fine filter remove most of the dust, especially the large particles, before they reach the HEPA filter, the HEPA filter would still be subject to heavy loading, causing a substantial pressure drop and subsequent decrease in air flow rate. The relatively small increase in the efficiency of the filtration system while using the HEPA filter is expected to be quickly offset by a more significant decrease in capture efficiency as the air flow rate and ability to capture particles decreases.
Dust collects in relatively inexpensive, heavy-gauge plastic bags below and outside of the cyclone. The bags can be removed and replaced without opening the vacuum. Some vacuums are equipped with a light to indicate that the filters need to be cleaned or changed. The DC2900c features a “reverse air pulse cleaning system,” which removes accumulated dust from the filters without having to remove them from the vacuum. The system, as illustrated in Figure 4, requires the operator to disconnect the hose from the shroud, place it over an air stop so that air through the hose is cut off and pressure in the vacuum is maximized.
Figure 4. Procedure for "cleaning" of or dust removal from filters (source: http://dustcontrolusa.com/manuals/2800c.pdf)
The flap covering the port on the side of the vacuum is repeatedly flipped open to release built up pressure in strong pulses that dislodge dust from the filter.
The manufacturer indicates “the filter is generally cleaned once or twice daily during normal continuous operation.” The Dust Director shroud has a 2-inch diameter take-off that was connected to the antistatic, corrugated 1.5-inch diameter, 15-foot long vacuum hose supplied with the DustControl vacuum.
IV. Study Methods
This evaluation was conducted at the International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craft workers (IUBAC) Local 1 Philadelphia/Delaware Training Center in Philadelphia, PA on November 14 and 15, 2012. A single journeyman bricklayer, experienced in tuckpointing, used the grinder and LEV system being tested to remove mortar from joints wide enough to require two passes. The type S mortar had been allowed to cure for at least four weeks. The bricklayer either possessed or was provided with personal protective equipment including sturdy work boots, gloves, hearing protection and a powered air-purifying respirator (PAPR). The PAPR was a 3M GVP system with a bump cap, loose fitting face piece and a HEPA filter (3M, St Paul, MN).
The study was designed to include at least five rounds of sampling during mortar removal. Each round included a trial using the Bosch grinder with a Dust Director shroud and Dust Collector 2900c vacuum and a trial using the Bosch grinder with the factory-supplied guard and without a vacuum. The order of the two trials within each round was randomly selected to minimize bias that might be introduced due to variation associated with environmental factors, equipment operator, blade wear, vacuum performance over time and any other factors unrelated to LEV use. Tools were operated for approximately 16 minutes per trial with controls and for approximately 8 minutes when controls were not used. These times were selected based on the results of previous sampling efforts and estimates of the minimum sample time needed to achieve a limit of quantification low enough to accurately measure exposures down to or less than 0.05 mg/m3 – the NIOSH Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) for respirable silica. The bricklayer was required to take a 5 to 10 minute break in the middle of the 16-minute trials to reduce differences in fatigue, compared to the 8-minute trials. Personal air samples were collected in the breathing zone of the operator during each trial to measure respirable silica concentrations during grinding with and without LEV. The samples were collected using a GilAir-5 pump (Sensidyne, Inc., Clearwater, FL) to draw 4.2 liters of air per minute through a GK2.69 Respirable Cyclone (BGI Inc., Waltham, MA) with a pre-weighed, 37 mm diameter, 5-micron pore size polyvinyl chloride (PVC) filter positioned on the operator’s lapel.
The flow rates of the sampling pumps were calibrated at the beginning of each day using a DryCal DC-Lite Primary Flow Meter (Bios International Corporation, Butler, NJ). Flow rates were measured again near the middle and at the end of each day to ensure that sampling flow rates were maintained within 5% of pre-sampling flow rates throughout the day. Average flow rates were used to calculate sample air volumes. Samples were analyzed by R.J. Lee Group, Inc., (Monroeville, PA) using NIOSH Method 0600, to determine exposure to total mass of respirable dust. The same samples were also analyzed using X-Ray diffraction following NIOSH method 7500 to determine quartz, cristobalite and tridymite concentration in the respirable mass. Reported masses for these analytes were used with the sample air volumes to calculate airborne concentrations of total respirable dust, quartz, cristobalite and tridymite.
We used a reduction of greater than 50 percent in respirable silica exposure concentrations or a reduction to less than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 as our criteria for determining whether or not a control was considered efficacious. This is consistent with criteria used by NIOSH in conducting a similar study in 2004 described by Echt et al. (2007) and by CPWR in 2006 and described by Meeker et al. (2009). The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) and the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) publish additional occupational exposure limits (OELs) for silica which are listed in Table 1 with NIOSH RELs. OELs for silica are based on the respirable fraction of the aerosol, which consists of particles less than 10 micrometers in aerodynamic diameter.
| Organization or Agency | Form of Crystalline Silica | Occupational Exposure Limits (mg/m3) |
|---|---|---|
| NIOSHA | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 |
| OSHA - ConstructionB | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
PEL = 250 / (5 + % quartz) PEL = 250 / (5 + % cristobalite) PEL = 250 / (5 + % tridymite) |
| ACGIH | Crystalline Silica | TLV = 0.025 mg/m3 |
A NIOSH Publication No. 2005-151 indicates 10-hour time-weighted average during a 40-hr workweek B The PEL for silica in OSHA’s Safety and Health Regulations for Construction, 29 C.F.R. 1926.55(a), is an 8-hour time-weighted average (TWA) expressed in millions of particles per cubic foot (mppcf). However, the units mppcf can be converted to milligrams per cubic meter can by dividing mppcf by 10 (OSHA, 2009). The formula used by OSHA to determine the PEL for silica is dependent on the percentage of silica in each collected sample. The concentration of respirable dust measured is compared to the sample specific PEL to determine if the PEL has been exceeded. OSHA has proposed lowering the PEL to 0.05 mg/m3 of respirable silica as an 8 hour TWA. |
||
The flow of air in ventilation systems is governed by fundamental principles that describe the behavior of gases (in this case air). Pressure measurements taken within a ventilation system along with knowledge of hood (or shroud) entry losses can be used to calculate flow rates. Hood entry losses are dependent on the shape and configuration of a particular hood or shroud and described by the term “coefficient of entry (Ce)” which is the ratio of actual air flow through a hood and what the air flow would theoretically be if there were no hood entry losses. Given the coefficient of entry, static pressure measurements can be used to calculate air flow through a given hood. The coefficient of entry for the Dust Director shroud was previously determined by CPWR and used for calculating air flow based on static pressure measurements (Meeker et al., 2009). Static pressure, with the vacuum operating, was measured periodically throughout the evaluation to monitor the changes in air-flow rate following use and again after filter cleaning. The static pressure was measured at a port positioned more than 3 duct diameters downstream from the tool’s air intake using a UEi EM200 Electronic Manometer (Universal Enterprises, Inc., Beaverton, OR).
The dust in the vacuum bag was monitored and, per the manufacturer’s instructions, the bag was changed before the dust level was within 5 centimeters of the valve at the bottom of the vacuum. Each time a vacuum bag was removed, it was weighed to the nearest pound. The bag weights and corresponding grinding durations were used to calculate the average weight of dust collected per unit time. After each trial, cut lengths were measured on the wall to determine total linear feet of vertical (head) and horizontal (bed) joints per unit time.
A Haz-Dust III, Model HD-1003, Real-Time Aerosol Monitor (Environmental Devices Corporation, Plaistow, NH) was used to confirm clearance of dust between trials. The Haz-Dust monitor was positioned on the test wall near the operator at approximately breathing zone level and configured to measure respirable particulate concentration.
V. Results
Personal air monitoring
Five pairs of respirable dust samples were collected while grinding with and without the vacuum system. In addition, three respirable dust samples were collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place. One measurement collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard was shown to be a statistical outlier and was omitted from analysis. Personal air monitoring results for respirable silica and a comparison of average exposures relative to the NIOSH REL for silica (0.05 mg/m3) appears in Table 2. The mean respirable dust levels measured without LEV was 31.4 mg/m3. However, samples collected with LEV were below the limit of quantification (LOQ) which ranged from <1.29 to <1.46 mg/m3. Use of LEV resulted in a greater than 95% reduction in mean respirable dust levels using a mean value with use of LEV of <1.41 (n=5 samples with use of LEV and n=7 without use of LEV). The respirable dust samples collected during grinding without the LEV system contained an average of 24 percent silica. The mass of respirable dust in the samples collected with use of the LEV system was too low to determine the silica content.| Mean, mg/m3 (range) | Std. Dev. | Percent Reduction | Hazard RatioB | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bosch with Dust Director Shroud and DustControl 2900c Vacuum |
0.091 (<0.069 – 0.137) |
0.027 | 98.7 | 1.81 |
| Bosch with no Control | 7.23 (4.57 – 9.90) |
1.94 | NA | 145 |
A n = 5 samples for each tool/control combination and n = 7 samples without the use of the LEV system B Hazard Ratio = measured exposure / NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 |
||||
Average respirable silica and dust exposures, with and without the dust control system, appear as Figures 5 and 6, respectively.
Figure 5. Average respirable silica exposures with and without the Dustcontrol 2900c vacuum and Dust Director shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air - mg/m3)
Figure 6. Average respirable dust exposures with and without Dustcontrol 2900c Vacuum and Dust Director Shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air – mg/m3)
The mean respirable silica concentration measured during use of the control was significantly less than the concentration measured while using the same tool without controls (p<0.01). Grinding mortar with the Bosch angle grinder without dust controls resulted in an average exposure to respirable silica that was 145 times the NIOSH REL. Grinding with the Bosch angle grinder in combination with the Dust Director shroud and the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced the average concentration of respirable silica by 98.7 percent. With use of these controls, the concentration of respirable silica was 1.8 times greater than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3. However the NIOSH REL is based on a time-weighted average (TWA) over a 10-hour workday. Given these were task TWAs and samples were collected over continuous periods of grinding, they may overestimate exposures over an actual work day since some time would be spent performing tasks that would likely have lower, or no, silica exposures (setup, breaks, cleanup, etc.).
Static pressure, dust mass collection and grinding rates.
Static pressure was used as a surrogate for air flow as described earlier. Hood static pressure was measured periodically at a tap near the grinder more than 3 duct diameters from the air intake in the shroud. The static pressure, and thus air flow, was generally higher when the vacuum’s filter had recently been cleaned. The mean, median, and range of calculated flow rates are presented in Table A1 of the Appendix.
Based on the data we collected, the air-flow rate upstream from the Bosch grinder and Dust Director shroud ranged from 78 to 93 cubic feet per minute (cfm) with the DustControl vacuum. When the manufacturer’s filter cleaning procedure was followed the vacuum performed relatively well and flow could be maintained at slightly less than 90 cfm with cleaning. However, mean flow rates dropped substantially to 80 cfm after as little as 8 minutes of grinding without any filter cleaning. The flow rate returned to an average of 89 cfm when filters were cleaned correctly (without stopping air flow to the vacuum). Collingwood and Heitbrink (2007) found that the minimum exhaust flow rate for capture of silica and other particulate under ideal conditions is 21.25 cfm per inch of grinder blade diameter. This is equal to about 96 cfm when using a 4.5 inch diameter grinding blade. We set 106 cfm as the minimum desired flow rate for this study to allow a safety margin for potential decline in equipment performance and the possibility of inadequate maintenance, both of which may be likely after repeated use under actual work conditions. The DustControl vacuum provided slightly less than the minimum flow rate described by Collingwood and Heitbrink for a 4.5-inch blade and the peak flow rate fell with use.
The duration of vacuum bag use and mass of dust collected were recorded and are presented in Table A2 of the Appendix. The vacuum bags were changed and weighed after each trial utilizing the LEV system. A total of five bags were used to complete the five rounds of grinding. The DustControl vacuum captured 45 pounds of dust over 83 minutes of grinding for an average rate of dust collection of 0.54 pounds per minute. The rate of dust collection ranged from 0.47 to 0.63 pounds per minute. Based on these measurements, approximately 130 pounds of dust would likely be captured after just 4 hours of continuous grinding.
The rate of grinding a combination of vertical and horizontal joints while using the LEV system ranged from 2.3 to 3.3 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the use of the LEV system ranged from 2.6 to 3.4 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place ranged from 4.7 to 5.1 feet per minute. It’s important to note that: 1) the operator had limited experience using dust control systems and cut rates appeared to improve slightly over the 2-day period he used the tested equipment; and 2) the upper range of cut rates with the dust control system overlapped with the lowest cut rate with the original guard and without the LEV system in place indicating no statistical difference between cut rates. Given that grinding rates with and without use of this LEV system are only available for one operator and he had limited experience with the LEV system, these reported cut rates are in no way intended to represent the impact use of this LEV system is likely to have on productivity rates overall.
VI. Discussion
The objective of these trials was to evaluate the effectiveness of a tuckpointing LEV system for controlling respirable silica while grinding out mortar joints. The Dust Director shroud with the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced respirable silica concentrations when grinding with the Bosch grinder by approximately 99 percent. Despite being considered effective by our test criteria (greater than 50% reduction), it still resulted in task TWA exposures that exceeded the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 by 1.8 times. Depending on how much time is spent grinding over the course of a work day and on exposures while performing other tasks, the 8-hour TWA exposures may or may not exceed the REL with this system. Use of this system by workers with experience and training in proficient use will likely improve dust capture performance. Exposure reduction is greatly influenced by correct use of this system which includes grinding from right to left, making sure the shroud is held flush against the wall and that the tool travels at a pace that doesn’t exceed the ability of the system to capture dust as it’s generated. Deviation from any of these measures produces visible dust clouds which were observed during trials.
VII. Conclusions
With a 99 percent reduction in respirable silica exposure, the Dust Director shroud and DustControl 2900c vacuum with a Bosch Model 1775E grinder was effective in reducing silica exposures based on our criteria. Use of the tested dust control system may be effective in reducing silica exposure on the job to less than the NIOSH REL if used in combination with administrative controls such as work scheduling to reduce cutting times as needed. Training on correct use of the tested system is also essential. Personal air monitoring is necessary to verify control effectiveness on actual job sites and under “real-world” conditions. However, these results clearly demonstrate the availability of viable and effective engineering controls for tuckpointing operations associated with elevated silica exposure.
VIII. References
American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists. Threshold limit values for chemical substances (TLV®-CS). [2013]. ACGIH, Cincinnati, Ohio.
Bergdahl I.A,. Toren K., Eriksson K., et al. [2004]. Increased mortality in COPD among construction workers exposed to inorganic dust. European Respiratory Journal, 23: 402–06.
Blanc P.D. & Torén K. [2007]. Occupation in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and chronic bronchitis: an update [State of the Art Series. Occupational lung disease in high-and low-income countries, Edited by M. Chan-Yeung. Number 2 in the series]. The International Journal of Tuberculosis and Lung Disease, 11(3), 251-257.
Collingwood S. & Heitbrink W.A. [2007] 'Field Evaluation of an Engineering Control for Respirable Crystalline Silica Exposures During Mortar Removal'. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, 4:11, 875 – 887.
DHHS (NIOSH) Publication No. 2002-129 April 2002 http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/2002-129/
Echt A., Sieber W.K., Lefkowitz D., Meeker J., Susi P., Cardwell B., Heitbrink, W.A. In-depth survey of dust control technology for cutting concrete block and tuckpointing brick at The International Masonry Institute Bordentown Training Center, Bordentown, NJ. Cincinnati, OH: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Report. No. EPHB 282-13; 2007. http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ECTB-282-13.pdf
Heitbrink W., Bennett J. [2006]. A numerical and experimental investigation of crystalline silica exposure control during tuck pointing. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, Vol. 3, pp 366-378.
Lyons et al, [2007]. A breathless builder. Breathe, Vol. 3, no. 4, pp 386-390.
Mastrangelo G., Tartari M., Fedeli U., Fadda E., Saia B. [2003]. Ascertaining the risk of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease in relation to occupation using a case-control design. Occupational Medicine, 53: 165–172.
Meeker J., Cooper M., Lefrowitz D., Susi P. [2009]. Engineering control technologies to reduce occupational silica exposures in masonry cutting and tuckpointing. Public Health Reports, Supplement 1, Vol. 124, June.
Meeker J, Flynn M, Susi P, Cardwell, B [2004]. Performance evaluation of a masonry concrete vacuum. Unpublished Report.
Miller F. W., Alfredsson L., Costenbader K. H., Kamen D. L., Nelson L. M., Norris J. M., & De Roos A. J. [2012]. Epidemiology of environmental exposures and human autoimmune diseases: findings from a National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences Expert Panel workshop. Journal of autoimmunity. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3496812/
Occupational Safety and Health Administration U.S Department of Labor. Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction. [2009]. OSHA 3362-05.
Rappaport SM, Goldberg M, Susi P, Herrick RF [2003]. Excessive exposure to silica in the U.S. construction industry. Annals of Occupational Hygiene, Vol. 47, pp. 111-122.
IX. Appendices
| Measurement Conditions |
n | Mean Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Median
Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before filter cleaning | 5 | 80 | 81 | 78-81 |
| After filter cleaning following manufacturer directions | 9 | 89 | 90 | 84-93 |
| * Static pressure was measured in millibars and converted to inches of water gauge. Flow rates were calculated using the formula Q = Ce (A) 4005 (SP)1/2 where: Q = flow in cubic feet per minute (cfm), Ce = coefficient of entry, A = area of the duct where static pressure measurements were taken in square feet, and SP = static pressure in inches of water gauge. | ||||
| Tool/Control | Collection Period (min.) |
Dust Collection Rate (lb/min.) |
|---|---|---|
| Bosch grinder/Dust Director shroud & DustControl 2900c vacuum |
8 11 8 8 10 |
0.50 0.61 0.50 0.47 0.63 |
| Average | 0.54 |
[disclaimer:protected] => [disclaimer_transformed:protected] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [template] => record ) [_globalContext:PHPTAL_Context:private] => stdClass Object ( ) [_echoDeclarations:PHPTAL_Context:private] => [referer] => http://www.elcosh.org/document/3908/d001345/An%2BEvaluation%2Bof%2BSilica%2BExposure%2BControls%2Bfor%2BTuckpointing%253A%2BDustControl%2B2900c%2BVacuum%2Bwith%2Bthe%2BICS%2BDust%2BDirector%2BShroud%2Band%2BBosch%2BGrinder%2BModel%2B1775E%2BConducted%2BNovember%2B14-15%252C%2B2012.html [curr_module] => Record [styles] => Array ( ) [javascript] => Array ( [0] => jquery.min.js ) [metas] => Array ( [language] => en [robots] => index, follow ) [user] => [curr_url] => https://www.elcosh.org/index.php?module=Record&id=3908&type=document [base_url] => https://www.elcosh.org/index.php?module=Record [title] => eLCOSH : An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: DustControl 2900c Vacuum with the ICS Dust Director Shroud and Bosch Grinder Model 1775E Conducted November 14-15, 2012 [language] => en [search_query] => [module] => Record [new_records] => Array ( [0] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Fixed Ladder [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Fixed Ladders addresses the potential risks associated with using fixed ladders. The resource includes a brief case example,... [category] => Array ( [0] => 15 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 53 [5] => 55 [6] => 60 [7] => 64 [8] => 73 [9] => 76 [10] => 78 [11] => 80 [12] => 86 [13] => 87 [14] => 90 [15] => 92 [16] => 93 [17] => 94 [18] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Falls [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Concrete Polisher [11] => Electrical Worker [13] => HVAC [15] => Laborer [17] => PCC/Restoration [19] => Plumber/Pipefitter [21] => Roofer/Waterproofer [23] => Sheetmetal Worker [25] => Welder [27] => Commercial & Institutional [28] => Jobsites [29] => Industrial [31] => LEED/Green Construction [33] => Renovations [35] => Residential [37] => Toolbox Talks [38] => Documents [39] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4430/d001660/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BFixed%2BLadder.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [53] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 53 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Concrete Polisher [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [73] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 73 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => PCC/Restoration [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4430 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001660 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Fixed Ladder [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Fixed Ladders, Fall Prevention, Falls [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Fixed Ladders addresses the potential risks associated with using fixed ladders. The resource includes a brief case example, steps to prevent a related injury and questions for discussion. It includes an image that illustrates the hazard, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001257,d001254,d001255,d001256,d001258,d001262,d001279 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_completed:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/22/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [1] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Challenges Preventing Falling Objects [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Challenges Preventing Falling Objects addresses the hazards of being struck by falling objects on the job site. The resource... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 55 [5] => 64 [6] => 68 [7] => 71 [8] => 75 [9] => 78 [10] => 79 [11] => 82 [12] => 62 [13] => 86 [14] => 87 [15] => 88 [16] => 89 [17] => 91 [18] => 90 [19] => 92 [20] => 93 [21] => 94 [22] => 95 [23] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Electrical Worker [11] => Laborer [13] => Maintenance Worker [15] => Painter [17] => Plasterer [19] => Roofer/Waterproofer [21] => Scaffold Erector [23] => Stonemason [25] => Structural Ironworker [27] => Welder [29] => Commercial & Institutional [30] => Jobsites [31] => Demolition [33] => Disasters [35] => Heavy & Highway [37] => Industrial [39] => LEED/Green Construction [41] => Renovations [43] => Residential [45] => Underground [47] => Toolbox Talks [48] => Documents [49] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4431/d001661/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BChallenges%2BPreventing%2BFalling%2BObjects.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4431 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001661 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Challenges Preventing Falling Objects [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => dropped objects, falling objects, struck by incidents, struck by fatalities [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Challenges Preventing Falling Objects addresses the hazards of being struck by falling objects on the job site. The resource includes a brief example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates a group workers observing a scaffold free of debris during high winds, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001234,d001238,d001244,d001251,d001253,d001260,d001268,d001278 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_completed:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/22/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [2] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Tower Crane Safety [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Tower Crane Safety addresses the potential hazards of Tower Cranes and the importance of following procedure before and durin... [category] => Array ( [0] => 11 [1] => 12 [2] => 18 [3] => 70 [4] => 87 [5] => 88 [6] => 91 [7] => 90 [8] => 92 [9] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Cranes & Hoists [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Crushed/Struck By [6] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [9] => Operating Engineer [10] => Trades [11] => Commercial & Institutional [12] => Jobsites [13] => Demolition [15] => Heavy & Highway [17] => Industrial [19] => LEED/Green Construction [21] => Toolbox Talks [22] => Documents [23] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4427/d001657/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BTower%2BCrane%2BSafety.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [11] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 11 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Cranes & Hoists [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [18] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 18 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4427 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001657 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Tower Crane Safety [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Tower Crane, Crane, Stability, Tipping, Lift Zone Safety, Lift, Zone, Safety, Struck by [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Tower Crane Safety addresses the potential hazards of Tower Cranes and the importance of following procedure before and during Tower Crane operation. The resource includes a brief example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates a worker inspecting a Tower Crane before operation, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001234,d001238,d001250,d001251,d001253,d001258,d001262,d001273 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/19/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [3] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Work Zone Safety: Working Around Vehicles [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Working Around Vehicles in the Work Zone addresses methods to avoid being struck-by a vehicle on a construction site. The res... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 18 [2] => 52 [3] => 57 [4] => 70 [5] => 85 [6] => 87 [7] => 88 [8] => 89 [9] => 91 [10] => 90 [11] => 92 [12] => 93 [13] => 94 [14] => 95 [15] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [6] => Commercial Diver [7] => Trades [8] => Flagger [10] => Operating Engineer [12] => Truck Driver [14] => Commercial & Institutional [15] => Jobsites [16] => Demolition [18] => Disasters [20] => Heavy & Highway [22] => Industrial [24] => LEED/Green Construction [26] => Renovations [28] => Residential [30] => Underground [32] => Toolbox Talks [33] => Documents [34] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4428/d001658/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BWork%2BZone%2BSafety%253A%2BWorking%2BAround%2BVehicles.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [18] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 18 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [52] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 52 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Commercial Diver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [85] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 85 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Truck Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4428 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001658 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Daniela Caceres [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Work Zone Safety: Working Around Vehicles [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Struck, Struck by, Vehicle, Work Zone Safety, Truck, Operator, Driver, Mobile Equipment [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Working Around Vehicles in the Work Zone addresses methods to avoid being struck-by a vehicle on a construction site. The resource includes a case example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates the hazard, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001640 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/19/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [4] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Construction Dive -- DeWalt's Jobsite Pro headphones recalled for fire hazards [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => A recall notice by the United States Consumer Product Safety Commission affects over 300,000 DeWalt Jobsite Pro Headphones. The recall is a result of... [category] => Array ( [0] => 16 [1] => 44 [2] => 45 [3] => 46 [4] => 47 [5] => 48 [6] => 49 [7] => 50 [8] => 51 [9] => 52 [10] => 53 [11] => 54 [12] => 55 [13] => 56 [14] => 57 [15] => 58 [16] => 59 [17] => 60 [18] => 61 [19] => 64 [20] => 65 [21] => 66 [22] => 67 [23] => 68 [24] => 69 [25] => 70 [26] => 71 [27] => 72 [28] => 73 [29] => 74 [30] => 75 [31] => 76 [32] => 77 [33] => 63 [34] => 78 [35] => 79 [36] => 80 [37] => 81 [38] => 82 [39] => 62 [40] => 83 [41] => 84 [42] => 85 [43] => 86 [44] => 87 [45] => 88 [46] => 89 [47] => 91 [48] => 90 [49] => 92 [50] => 93 [51] => 94 [52] => 95 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Fire & Explosions [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Acoustical Ceiling Carpenter [4] => Trades [5] => Asbestos/Insulator [7] => Boilermaker [9] => Bricklayer [11] => Cabinetmaker [13] => Carpenter [15] => Carpet Layer [17] => Cement Mason [19] => Commercial Diver [21] => Concrete Polisher [23] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [25] => Electrical Worker [27] => Elevator Constructor [29] => Flagger [31] => Glazier [33] => Hazardous Waste Cleanup [35] => HVAC [37] => Interior Systems Carpenter [39] => Laborer [41] => Landscaper [43] => Lather [45] => Lead Abatement Worker [47] => Maintenance Worker [49] => Millwright [51] => Operating Engineer [53] => Painter [55] => Paper Hanger [57] => PCC/Restoration [59] => Pile Driver [61] => Plasterer [63] => Plumber/Pipefitter [65] => Refractory Worker [67] => Reinforcing Ironworker [69] => Roofer/Waterproofer [71] => Scaffold Erector [73] => Sheetmetal Worker [75] => Sprinkler Fitter [77] => Stonemason [79] => Structural Ironworker [81] => Terrazzo Worker [83] => Tile Setter [85] => Truck Driver [87] => Welder [89] => Commercial & Institutional [90] => Jobsites [91] => Demolition [93] => Disasters [95] => Heavy & Highway [97] => Industrial [99] => LEED/Green Construction [101] => Renovations [103] => Residential [105] => Underground ) [type] => [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4426/d001656/Construction%2BDive%2B--%2BDeWalt%2527s%2BJobsite%2BPro%2Bheadphones%2Brecalled%2Bfor%2Bfire%2Bhazards.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [16] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 16 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Fire & Explosions [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [44] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 44 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Acoustical Ceiling Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [45] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 45 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Asbestos/Insulator [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [46] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 46 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Boilermaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [48] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 48 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cabinetmaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [50] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 50 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpet Layer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [52] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 52 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Commercial Diver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [53] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 53 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Concrete Polisher [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [54] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 54 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [58] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 58 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Glazier [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [59] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 59 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Hazardous Waste Cleanup [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [65] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 65 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Landscaper [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [66] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 66 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Lather [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [67] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 67 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Lead Abatement Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [69] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 69 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Millwright [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [72] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 72 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Paper Hanger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [73] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 73 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => PCC/Restoration [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [77] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 77 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Refractory Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [81] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 81 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sprinkler Fitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [83] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 83 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Terrazzo Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [84] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 84 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Tile Setter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [85] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 85 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Truck Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4426 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001656 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Construction Dive -- DeWalt's Jobsite Pro headphones recalled for fire hazards [total_pages:protected] => 1 [billed_pages:protected] => 1 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => DeWalt, Fire Hazards, recall, headphones [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A recall notice by the United States Consumer Product Safety Commission affects over 300,000 DeWalt Jobsite Pro Headphones. The recall is a result of a malfunction that can cause earbuds to overheat while charging or during use, leading to fire and burn hazards. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => https://www.constructiondive.com/news/dewalts-jobsite-pro-headphones-recalled-for-fire-hazards/611248/?utm_source=Sailthru&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Issue:%202021-12-10%20Construction%20Dive%20Newsletter%20%5Bissue:38532%5D&utm_term=Construction%20Dive [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/13/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/13/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 12/13/21 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [new_images] => Array ( [0] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Morning Toolbox Talk [image] => /record/images/4003-p.jpg [blurb] => This photo is from an early morning toolbox talk on a construction job in Mclean, Virginia. It is being delivered in English and Spanish.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 20 [1] => 51 [2] => 57 [3] => 64 [4] => 70 [5] => 63 [6] => 78 [7] => 82 [8] => 62 [9] => 87 [10] => 88 [11] => 89 [12] => 91 [13] => 90 [14] => 93 [15] => 94 [16] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Safety Culture [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Cement Mason [4] => Trades [5] => Flagger [7] => Laborer [9] => Operating Engineer [11] => Reinforcing Ironworker [13] => Roofer/Waterproofer [15] => Stonemason [17] => Structural Ironworker [19] => Commercial & Institutional [20] => Jobsites [21] => Demolition [23] => Disasters [25] => Heavy & Highway [27] => Industrial [29] => Renovations [31] => Residential [33] => Images [34] => Media [35] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4003/i002691/Morning%2BToolbox%2BTalk.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4003 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002691 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Morning Toolbox Talk [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, Spanish, bilingual [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This photo is from an early morning toolbox talk on a construction job in Mclean, Virginia. It is being delivered in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001285,d001304,c000079 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [1] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox talk - crew view [image] => /record/images/4005-p.jpg [blurb] => Photo of crew listening to a toolbox safety talk before starting work.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 97 [1] => 20 [2] => 47 [3] => 49 [4] => 51 [5] => 55 [6] => 61 [7] => 64 [8] => 71 [9] => 75 [10] => 63 [11] => 79 [12] => 62 [13] => 87 [14] => 88 [15] => 91 [16] => 90 [17] => 93 [18] => 94 [19] => 95 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Images [1] => Media [2] => Media & Documents [3] => Safety Culture [4] => Work Environment [5] => Hazards [6] => Bricklayer [7] => Trades [8] => Carpenter [10] => Cement Mason [12] => Electrical Worker [14] => Interior Systems Carpenter [16] => Laborer [18] => Painter [20] => Plasterer [22] => Reinforcing Ironworker [24] => Scaffold Erector [26] => Structural Ironworker [28] => Commercial & Institutional [29] => Jobsites [30] => Demolition [32] => Heavy & Highway [34] => Industrial [36] => Renovations [38] => Residential [40] => Underground ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4005/i002692/Toolbox%2Btalk%2B-%2Bcrew%2Bview.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4005 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002692 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox talk - crew view [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, safety talk, Spanish [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Photo of crew listening to a toolbox safety talk before starting work. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002691,d001269, c000079, d001285 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [2] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox talk - long shot [image] => /record/images/4006-p.jpg [blurb] => This crew gathered every morning before starting work to discuss a new safety topic.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 20 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 55 [5] => 64 [6] => 68 [7] => 75 [8] => 76 [9] => 63 [10] => 78 [11] => 79 [12] => 82 [13] => 62 [14] => 87 [15] => 88 [16] => 91 [17] => 90 [18] => 93 [19] => 94 [20] => 95 [21] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Safety Culture [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Electrical Worker [11] => Laborer [13] => Maintenance Worker [15] => Plasterer [17] => Plumber/Pipefitter [19] => Reinforcing Ironworker [21] => Roofer/Waterproofer [23] => Scaffold Erector [25] => Stonemason [27] => Structural Ironworker [29] => Commercial & Institutional [30] => Jobsites [31] => Demolition [33] => Heavy & Highway [35] => Industrial [37] => Renovations [39] => Residential [41] => Underground [43] => Images [44] => Media [45] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4006/i002693/Toolbox%2Btalk%2B-%2Blong%2Bshot.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4006 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002693 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox talk - long shot [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, safety minute [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This crew gathered every morning before starting work to discuss a new safety topic. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002691,i002692,d001269,d000527 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [3] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Safety officer discussing ongoing project with marketing coordinator [image] => /record/images/4014-p.jpg [blurb] => The safety officer (left) points out the good safety practices on this project that reflect well on the firm and may influence future clients.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 97 [1] => 20 [2] => 46 [3] => 47 [4] => 49 [5] => 50 [6] => 51 [7] => 54 [8] => 55 [9] => 58 [10] => 60 [11] => 61 [12] => 64 [13] => 71 [14] => 75 [15] => 76 [16] => 63 [17] => 79 [18] => 80 [19] => 82 [20] => 62 [21] => 83 [22] => 87 [23] => 91 [24] => 90 [25] => 93 [26] => 94 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Images [1] => Media [2] => Media & Documents [3] => Safety Culture [4] => Work Environment [5] => Hazards [6] => Boilermaker [7] => Trades [8] => Bricklayer [10] => Carpenter [12] => Carpet Layer [14] => Cement Mason [16] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [18] => Electrical Worker [20] => Glazier [22] => HVAC [24] => Interior Systems Carpenter [26] => Laborer [28] => Painter [30] => Plasterer [32] => Plumber/Pipefitter [34] => Reinforcing Ironworker [36] => Scaffold Erector [38] => Sheetmetal Worker [40] => Stonemason [42] => Structural Ironworker [44] => Terrazzo Worker [46] => Commercial & Institutional [47] => Jobsites [48] => Heavy & Highway [50] => Industrial [52] => Renovations [54] => Residential ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4014/i002700/Safety%2Bofficer%2Bdiscussing%2Bongoing%2Bproject%2Bwith%2Bmarketing%2Bcoordinator.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [46] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 46 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Boilermaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [50] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 50 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpet Layer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [54] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 54 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [58] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 58 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Glazier [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [83] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 83 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Terrazzo Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4014 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002700 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Safety officer discussing ongoing project with marketing coordinator [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Latino, safety officer, safety culture [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The safety officer (left) points out the good safety practices on this project that reflect well on the firm and may influence future clients. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/index.php [more_like_this:protected] => d000989,d001351,d001362,d000652, d001101, d000931, d001395 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Hoar Construction, Photo by Neil Lippy [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 01/30/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [4] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Scaffolding at top of large column [image] => /record/images/3994-p.jpg [blurb] => This shot shows innovative guarding around the top of a large concrete column in the base of a high rise structure going up.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 15 [1] => 21 [2] => 47 [3] => 51 [4] => 63 [5] => 78 [6] => 79 [7] => 80 [8] => 62 [9] => 87 [10] => 97 [11] => 56 [12] => 64 [13] => 74 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Falls [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Scaffolds [6] => Bricklayer [7] => Trades [8] => Cement Mason [10] => Reinforcing Ironworker [12] => Roofer/Waterproofer [14] => Scaffold Erector [16] => Sheetmetal Worker [18] => Structural Ironworker [20] => Commercial & Institutional [21] => Jobsites [22] => Images [23] => Media [24] => Media & Documents [25] => Elevator Constructor [27] => Laborer [29] => Pile Driver ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/3994/i002689/Scaffolding%2Bat%2Btop%2Bof%2Blarge%2Bcolumn.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [21] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 21 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Scaffolds [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3994 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002689 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Scaffolding at top of large column [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Guardrail, railing, fall prevention, falls [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This shot shows innovative guarding around the top of a large concrete column in the base of a high rise structure going up. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/8/adjustable-tower-scaffold.html [more_like_this:protected] => c1002680,i002662,d000608,d001255 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Photo by Pam Susi [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2016 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_completed:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/01/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [5] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Construction bracing [image] => /record/images/3995-p.jpg [blurb] => This shows structural support that prevents collapses during construction.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 15 [2] => 21 [3] => 49 [4] => 51 [5] => 55 [6] => 56 [7] => 60 [8] => 64 [9] => 68 [10] => 74 [11] => 63 [12] => 78 [13] => 79 [14] => 80 [15] => 62 [16] => 87 [17] => 90 [18] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Falls [6] => Scaffolds [9] => Carpenter [10] => Trades [11] => Cement Mason [13] => Electrical Worker [15] => Elevator Constructor [17] => HVAC [19] => Laborer [21] => Maintenance Worker [23] => Pile Driver [25] => Reinforcing Ironworker [27] => Roofer/Waterproofer [29] => Scaffold Erector [31] => Sheetmetal Worker [33] => Structural Ironworker [35] => Commercial & Institutional [36] => Jobsites [37] => Industrial [39] => Images [40] => Media [41] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/3995/i002690/Construction%2Bbracing.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [21] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 21 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Scaffolds [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3995 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002690 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Construction bracing [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Bracing, support, scaffold [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This shows structural support that prevents collapses during construction. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/8/adjustable-tower-scaffold.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002660 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Photo by Pam Susi [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2016 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_completed:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/01/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [preview_mode] => [description] => The results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. [keywords] => tuckpointing, HEPA vacuum, dust control, LEV, local exhaust ventilation, silica [related_items] => Array ( [Research Reports] => Array ( [0] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1874 [old_id:protected] => 722 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000683 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Sharon Garber/COD [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Protecting Tuckpointing Workers from Silica Dust: Draft Recommendations for a Ventilated Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 12 [billed_pages:protected] => 12 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, vacuum, grinder, mortar, respirator, OSHA, NIOSH, exhaust, Heitbrink, tuckpointer, silica, masonry, dust, silicosis, LEV [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Describes draft recommendations for use of ventilated grinder to reduce dust during tuckpointing and describes field trials using these devices. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/hazard/67/chip-scrape-and-grind-surfaces-or-joints-silica.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001201,d000292,d000293,d000658 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2005 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/27/05 [date_completed:protected] => 04/26/05 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/20/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [1] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1940 [old_id:protected] => 909 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Workplace Solutions: Control of Hazardous Dust During Tuckpointing [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, silica, dust, tuckpoint, grinder, masonry restoration, mortar, vacuum [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d000819,d000820,d000730,d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 10/24/08 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/09 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [2] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3899 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001342 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: Hilti VC40-U Vacuum with Hilti DC-EX Dust Guard and Hilti Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 15 [billed_pages:protected] => 15 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP4 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => silica, tuckpointing, Hilti, local exhaust systems, LEV, shroud, quartz [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This report describes the results of an evaluation of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Hilti VC40-U vacuum, a Hilti DC-EX shroud, and a Hilti DAG-500 grinder. Randomized trials with and without use of the dust control system were conducted in a controlled setting. Removing mortar with the Hilti grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 220 times the National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05mg/m3. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 97 percent. However, exposures measured during the use of the dust control system still exceeded the NIOSH REL. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => December 1, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/05/14 [date_completed:protected] => 02/04/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/06/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [Handouts] => Array ( [0] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3656 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001198 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 24 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction While Doing Tuckpointing/Mortar Removal [total_pages:protected] => 2 [billed_pages:protected] => 2 [publication_number:protected] => DSG FS-3632 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Brick, block, tuckpointing, silica, local exhaust ventilation, LEV, masonry [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Tuckpointing creates some of the greatest exposures to silica in construction. This OSHA factsheet provides guidance on how to greatly reduce these exposures through the use of local exhaust ventilation. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863, d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => February 2013 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/04/13 [date_completed:protected] => 03/27/13 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [collections] => Array ( [3913] => ) [record] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => Array ( [867] => Author Object ( [id:protected] => 867 [organization_id:protected] => 0 [firstname:protected] => Michael [lastname:protected] => Cooper [address:protected] => [city:protected] => [province:protected] => [country:protected] => [postal_code:protected] => [department:protected] => [title:protected] => [phone:protected] => [fax:protected] => [email:protected] => [degree:protected] => [website:protected] => [about:protected] => [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => [date_completed:protected] => [date_billed:protected] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [481] => Author Object ( [id:protected] => 481 [organization_id:protected] => 0 [firstname:protected] => Pam [lastname:protected] => Susi [address:protected] => 8484 Georgia Avenue, Suite 1000 [city:protected] => Silver Spring [province:protected] => Maryland [country:protected] => USA [postal_code:protected] => 20910 [department:protected] => [title:protected] => [phone:protected] => 301-578-8500 ext.144 [fax:protected] => 301-578-8572 [email:protected] => plsusi@aol.com [degree:protected] => [website:protected] => http://www.cpwr.com [about:protected] => [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => 2003-10-02 [date_completed:protected] => 2003-10-06 [date_billed:protected] => 2003-11-03 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [organizations:protected] => Array ( [1] => Organization Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [elcosh_id:protected] => o000001 [user_id:protected] => 14 [province_id:protected] => 21 [country_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => CPWR - The Center for Construction Research and Training [address:protected] => Suite 1000, 8484 Georgia Ave [postal_code:protected] => 20910 [city:protected] => Silver Spring [department:protected] => [phone:protected] => 301-578-8500 [fax:protected] => 301-578-8572 [email:protected] => cpwrwebsite@cpwr.com [website:protected] => http://www.cpwr.com [filename:protected] => o000001.gif [about:protected] => CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training, developed, and continues to maintain/expand this website - The Electronic Library of Construction Occupational Safety and Health, www.elcosh.org. CPWR, formerly known as The Center to Protect Workers’ Rights, is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit research and training institution. Created by the Building and Construction Trades Department, AFL-CIO, CPWR serves as the research arm of the BCTD. Since the inception of its research agenda in 1990, CPWR has grown into a worldwide provider of safety and health information covering all aspects of the construction industry. CPWR launched eLCOSH in 2000, and the Spanish-language version of the site in 2001. CPWR also created, and continues to build, Construction Solutions - www.cpwrConstructionSolutions.org - a free, online database of construction hazards and ways to prevent, eliminate, or reduce them. [comments:protected] => [logo_available:protected] => T [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => 2000-08-18 [date_completed:protected] => 2000-08-30 [date_billed:protected] => 2000-09-05 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [collections:protected] => Array ( [3913] => ) [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => Array ( [1874] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1874 [old_id:protected] => 722 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000683 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Sharon Garber/COD [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Protecting Tuckpointing Workers from Silica Dust: Draft Recommendations for a Ventilated Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 12 [billed_pages:protected] => 12 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, vacuum, grinder, mortar, respirator, OSHA, NIOSH, exhaust, Heitbrink, tuckpointer, silica, masonry, dust, silicosis, LEV [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Describes draft recommendations for use of ventilated grinder to reduce dust during tuckpointing and describes field trials using these devices. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/hazard/67/chip-scrape-and-grind-surfaces-or-joints-silica.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001201,d000292,d000293,d000658 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2005 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/27/05 [date_completed:protected] => 04/26/05 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/20/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [1940] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1940 [old_id:protected] => 909 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Workplace Solutions: Control of Hazardous Dust During Tuckpointing [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, silica, dust, tuckpoint, grinder, masonry restoration, mortar, vacuum [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d000819,d000820,d000730,d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 10/24/08 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/09 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [2213] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 2213 [old_id:protected] => 1090 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => [language_id:protected] => 2 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Control del polvo peligroso que se genera durante los procesos de reparación de mortero [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => 2008-126 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => [comments:protected] => http://www.cdc.gov/spanish/niosh/docs/wp-solutions/2008-126_sp/ [summary:protected] => A Workplace Solutions de NIOSH que resume un estudio de NIOSH sobre los riesgos de exposición cuando se reparan las estructuras y los métodos para controlar el polvo. [A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust.] [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => D000819,D000820,D000730,d000819 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 01/07/10 [date_completed:protected] => 04/19/10 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 07/08/12 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [3656] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3656 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001198 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 24 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction While Doing Tuckpointing/Mortar Removal [total_pages:protected] => 2 [billed_pages:protected] => 2 [publication_number:protected] => DSG FS-3632 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Brick, block, tuckpointing, silica, local exhaust ventilation, LEV, masonry [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Tuckpointing creates some of the greatest exposures to silica in construction. This OSHA factsheet provides guidance on how to greatly reduce these exposures through the use of local exhaust ventilation. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863, d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => February 2013 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/04/13 [date_completed:protected] => 03/27/13 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [3899] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3899 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001342 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: Hilti VC40-U Vacuum with Hilti DC-EX Dust Guard and Hilti Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 15 [billed_pages:protected] => 15 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP4 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => silica, tuckpointing, Hilti, local exhaust systems, LEV, shroud, quartz [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This report describes the results of an evaluation of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Hilti VC40-U vacuum, a Hilti DC-EX shroud, and a Hilti DAG-500 grinder. Randomized trials with and without use of the dust control system were conducted in a controlled setting. Removing mortar with the Hilti grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 220 times the National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05mg/m3. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 97 percent. However, exposures measured during the use of the dust control system still exceeded the NIOSH REL. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => December 1, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/05/14 [date_completed:protected] => 02/04/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/06/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [content:protected] => [files:protected] => Array ( [559] => [560] => [546] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 546 [filename:protected] => 3.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:22 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [566] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 566 [filename:protected] => 4.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:23 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [720] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 720 [filename:protected] => 5.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [721] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 721 [filename:protected] => 6.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [722] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 722 [filename:protected] => 7.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [9765] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 9765 [filename:protected] => d001345.pdf [downloadable:protected] => T [timestamp:protected] => 2015-02-09 12:26:04 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3908 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001345 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: DustControl 2900c Vacuum with the ICS Dust Director Shroud and Bosch Grinder Model 1775E Conducted November 14-15, 2012 [total_pages:protected] => 13 [billed_pages:protected] => 13 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP2 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => tuckpointing, HEPA vacuum, dust control, LEV, local exhaust ventilation, silica [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => April 15, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 01/26/15 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/09/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [show_text] => [document_content] => ElcoshItemDocumentContent Object ( [id:protected] => 2934 [item_id:protected] => 3908 [type:protected] => main [title:protected] => [content:protected] =>
Executive Summary
This report describes the results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. It should also be noted that the NIOSH REL is based on exposures averaged over a ten hour work day and our results represent time weighted averages of the sample task duration periods.
Acronyms
ACGIH - American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists
CPWR - CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training
Ce - coefficient of entry
HEPA - high-efficiency particulate air
IUBAC - International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craftworkers
LEV - local exhaust ventilation
PACT - Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies
NIOSH - National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health
OEL - occupational exposure limit
OSHA - Occupational Safety and Health Administration
PAPR - powered air-purifying respirator
PEL - Permissible Exposure Limit
PVC - polyvinyl chloride
REL - Recommended Exposure Limit
RPM - revolutions per minute
TWA - time-weighted average
SP - static pressure
I. Introduction and Background
In 2010 CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training began a four-year project which seeks to identify and evaluate tuckpointing local exhaust ventilation (LEV) systems and disseminate information on their availability and effectiveness. A Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies (PACT) comprised of masonry contractors, representatives from unions, government, equipment manufacturers, and health and safety researcher was formed as part of this project. PACT members participated in identifying important characteristics for control technologies and this information was used to identify LEV systems for tuckpointing using that criteria. Contractor and labor members of the PACT selected specific tuckpointing LEV systems to be considered for evaluation. Each system consisted of a tuckpointing grinder, shroud, and vacuum. This report describes the second of four systems to be evaluated between 2012 the end of 2014, with and without LEV, in a controlled setting to determine effectiveness in silica exposure reduction. This report describes the methods and results of our evaluation of a system consisting of the DustControl 2900c vacuum with the ICS Dust Director shroud and a Bosch Model 1775E grinder.
Excessive exposure to respirable silica can result in silicosis or other silica-related diseases including pulmonary tuberculosis, lung cancer, silicoproteinosis (Lyons et al, 2007) and autoimmune disorders such as rheumatoid arthritis, sarcoidosis and scleroderma (Miller et al, 2012). Respirable silica is generally defined as particles less than 10 micrometers (μm) in aerodynamic diameter (ACGIH, 2013). Silicosis can lead to symptoms including shortness of breath, fatigue, chest pains, susceptibility to infection and possibly death. There is no cure for silicosis, however it is totally preventable. Construction workers exposed to dust, including silica, are also known to have higher rates of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD).
There are many sources of silica in construction that result in exposures of varying intensity among workers. Masonry restoration workers are among the most highly silica-exposed trades in construction. The process of grinding out deteriorated mortar joints between masonry units and replacing or repointing with fresh mortar (often referred to as tuckpointing) is a fundamental part of masonry restoration work. The removal of mortar with powered angle grinders generates enormous levels of dust. Between 2004 and 2006, NIOSH and CPWR evaluated silica exposures while grinding mortar in a controlled setting, at a local training center, where tasks, sample times and task variables were defined by the study design. These studies demonstrated that grinding mortar without controls can result in elevated respirable silica exposures. Meeker et al., (2009) reported exposures between 5 and 25.8 milligrams per cubic meter (mg/m3) in a controlled setting. This study also showed that LEV systems for tuckpointing grinders can reduce exposures to respirable silica by greater than 90 percent.II. Objectives
The objective of this evaluation was to assess the effectiveness of an LEV system for controlling exposure to silica during the grinding of mortar. The control technology was tested under controlled conditions, similar to those experienced by tuckpointers on actual job sites, using journeymen bricklayers experienced in tuckpointing and repeat, randomized trials with and without LEV. All other variables were held constant throughout so that the only variable was whether or not the tested control was used.
III. Description of Equipment Tested
A Bosch model 1775E grinder (Robert Bosch Tool Corporation, Prospect, IL) (Figures 1, 2 and 3) was fitted with a new 1/4-inch wide, 4½-inch diameter segmented diamond abrasive blade made by DeWalt (model #DW4740). The grinder weighs six and a half pounds, draws 8.5 amps and has a variable speed up to 11,000 revolutions per minute (RPMs). The DustControl 2900c vacuum (DustControl, Inc., Wilmington, NC) (Figure 3) was tested in combination with the Dust Director shroud (Industrial Contractors’ Supplies, Inc., Huntingdon, PA) (Figures 1 and 3) attached to the Bosch grinder.
Figure 1. Bosch grinder with Dust Director shroud
Figure 2. Bosch grinder without tuckpointing LEV system.
Figure 3: Bosch Grinder with LEV System
The vacuum is specified to weigh 31 pounds when empty and to provide a flow rate of 114 cubic feet of air per minute and a “static lift” or “vacuum suction pressure” of 84 inches of water. The vacuum is sold with a cyclonic pre-separator, to remove larger particles, a fine filter (rated 99.9 percent efficient) and a HEPA (high-efficiency particulate air) filter (rated to capture 99.97 percent of the particles with an aerodynamic diameter of 0.3 micrometers). The HEPA filter was removed based on the manufacturer’s recommendation due to the heavy dust loading associated with tuckpointing. CPWR sponsored research and contractor experience indicate that HEPA filters likely have an adverse effect on dust capture during tuckpointing because of extreme dust loading on filters. While the cyclone and the fine filter remove most of the dust, especially the large particles, before they reach the HEPA filter, the HEPA filter would still be subject to heavy loading, causing a substantial pressure drop and subsequent decrease in air flow rate. The relatively small increase in the efficiency of the filtration system while using the HEPA filter is expected to be quickly offset by a more significant decrease in capture efficiency as the air flow rate and ability to capture particles decreases.
Dust collects in relatively inexpensive, heavy-gauge plastic bags below and outside of the cyclone. The bags can be removed and replaced without opening the vacuum. Some vacuums are equipped with a light to indicate that the filters need to be cleaned or changed. The DC2900c features a “reverse air pulse cleaning system,” which removes accumulated dust from the filters without having to remove them from the vacuum. The system, as illustrated in Figure 4, requires the operator to disconnect the hose from the shroud, place it over an air stop so that air through the hose is cut off and pressure in the vacuum is maximized.
Figure 4. Procedure for "cleaning" of or dust removal from filters (source: http://dustcontrolusa.com/manuals/2800c.pdf)
The flap covering the port on the side of the vacuum is repeatedly flipped open to release built up pressure in strong pulses that dislodge dust from the filter.
The manufacturer indicates “the filter is generally cleaned once or twice daily during normal continuous operation.” The Dust Director shroud has a 2-inch diameter take-off that was connected to the antistatic, corrugated 1.5-inch diameter, 15-foot long vacuum hose supplied with the DustControl vacuum.
IV. Study Methods
This evaluation was conducted at the International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craft workers (IUBAC) Local 1 Philadelphia/Delaware Training Center in Philadelphia, PA on November 14 and 15, 2012. A single journeyman bricklayer, experienced in tuckpointing, used the grinder and LEV system being tested to remove mortar from joints wide enough to require two passes. The type S mortar had been allowed to cure for at least four weeks. The bricklayer either possessed or was provided with personal protective equipment including sturdy work boots, gloves, hearing protection and a powered air-purifying respirator (PAPR). The PAPR was a 3M GVP system with a bump cap, loose fitting face piece and a HEPA filter (3M, St Paul, MN).
The study was designed to include at least five rounds of sampling during mortar removal. Each round included a trial using the Bosch grinder with a Dust Director shroud and Dust Collector 2900c vacuum and a trial using the Bosch grinder with the factory-supplied guard and without a vacuum. The order of the two trials within each round was randomly selected to minimize bias that might be introduced due to variation associated with environmental factors, equipment operator, blade wear, vacuum performance over time and any other factors unrelated to LEV use. Tools were operated for approximately 16 minutes per trial with controls and for approximately 8 minutes when controls were not used. These times were selected based on the results of previous sampling efforts and estimates of the minimum sample time needed to achieve a limit of quantification low enough to accurately measure exposures down to or less than 0.05 mg/m3 – the NIOSH Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) for respirable silica. The bricklayer was required to take a 5 to 10 minute break in the middle of the 16-minute trials to reduce differences in fatigue, compared to the 8-minute trials. Personal air samples were collected in the breathing zone of the operator during each trial to measure respirable silica concentrations during grinding with and without LEV. The samples were collected using a GilAir-5 pump (Sensidyne, Inc., Clearwater, FL) to draw 4.2 liters of air per minute through a GK2.69 Respirable Cyclone (BGI Inc., Waltham, MA) with a pre-weighed, 37 mm diameter, 5-micron pore size polyvinyl chloride (PVC) filter positioned on the operator’s lapel.
The flow rates of the sampling pumps were calibrated at the beginning of each day using a DryCal DC-Lite Primary Flow Meter (Bios International Corporation, Butler, NJ). Flow rates were measured again near the middle and at the end of each day to ensure that sampling flow rates were maintained within 5% of pre-sampling flow rates throughout the day. Average flow rates were used to calculate sample air volumes. Samples were analyzed by R.J. Lee Group, Inc., (Monroeville, PA) using NIOSH Method 0600, to determine exposure to total mass of respirable dust. The same samples were also analyzed using X-Ray diffraction following NIOSH method 7500 to determine quartz, cristobalite and tridymite concentration in the respirable mass. Reported masses for these analytes were used with the sample air volumes to calculate airborne concentrations of total respirable dust, quartz, cristobalite and tridymite.
We used a reduction of greater than 50 percent in respirable silica exposure concentrations or a reduction to less than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 as our criteria for determining whether or not a control was considered efficacious. This is consistent with criteria used by NIOSH in conducting a similar study in 2004 described by Echt et al. (2007) and by CPWR in 2006 and described by Meeker et al. (2009). The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) and the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) publish additional occupational exposure limits (OELs) for silica which are listed in Table 1 with NIOSH RELs. OELs for silica are based on the respirable fraction of the aerosol, which consists of particles less than 10 micrometers in aerodynamic diameter.
| Organization or Agency | Form of Crystalline Silica | Occupational Exposure Limits (mg/m3) |
|---|---|---|
| NIOSHA | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 |
| OSHA - ConstructionB | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
PEL = 250 / (5 + % quartz) PEL = 250 / (5 + % cristobalite) PEL = 250 / (5 + % tridymite) |
| ACGIH | Crystalline Silica | TLV = 0.025 mg/m3 |
A NIOSH Publication No. 2005-151 indicates 10-hour time-weighted average during a 40-hr workweek B The PEL for silica in OSHA’s Safety and Health Regulations for Construction, 29 C.F.R. 1926.55(a), is an 8-hour time-weighted average (TWA) expressed in millions of particles per cubic foot (mppcf). However, the units mppcf can be converted to milligrams per cubic meter can by dividing mppcf by 10 (OSHA, 2009). The formula used by OSHA to determine the PEL for silica is dependent on the percentage of silica in each collected sample. The concentration of respirable dust measured is compared to the sample specific PEL to determine if the PEL has been exceeded. OSHA has proposed lowering the PEL to 0.05 mg/m3 of respirable silica as an 8 hour TWA. |
||
The flow of air in ventilation systems is governed by fundamental principles that describe the behavior of gases (in this case air). Pressure measurements taken within a ventilation system along with knowledge of hood (or shroud) entry losses can be used to calculate flow rates. Hood entry losses are dependent on the shape and configuration of a particular hood or shroud and described by the term “coefficient of entry (Ce)” which is the ratio of actual air flow through a hood and what the air flow would theoretically be if there were no hood entry losses. Given the coefficient of entry, static pressure measurements can be used to calculate air flow through a given hood. The coefficient of entry for the Dust Director shroud was previously determined by CPWR and used for calculating air flow based on static pressure measurements (Meeker et al., 2009). Static pressure, with the vacuum operating, was measured periodically throughout the evaluation to monitor the changes in air-flow rate following use and again after filter cleaning. The static pressure was measured at a port positioned more than 3 duct diameters downstream from the tool’s air intake using a UEi EM200 Electronic Manometer (Universal Enterprises, Inc., Beaverton, OR).
The dust in the vacuum bag was monitored and, per the manufacturer’s instructions, the bag was changed before the dust level was within 5 centimeters of the valve at the bottom of the vacuum. Each time a vacuum bag was removed, it was weighed to the nearest pound. The bag weights and corresponding grinding durations were used to calculate the average weight of dust collected per unit time. After each trial, cut lengths were measured on the wall to determine total linear feet of vertical (head) and horizontal (bed) joints per unit time.
A Haz-Dust III, Model HD-1003, Real-Time Aerosol Monitor (Environmental Devices Corporation, Plaistow, NH) was used to confirm clearance of dust between trials. The Haz-Dust monitor was positioned on the test wall near the operator at approximately breathing zone level and configured to measure respirable particulate concentration.
V. Results
Personal air monitoring
Five pairs of respirable dust samples were collected while grinding with and without the vacuum system. In addition, three respirable dust samples were collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place. One measurement collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard was shown to be a statistical outlier and was omitted from analysis. Personal air monitoring results for respirable silica and a comparison of average exposures relative to the NIOSH REL for silica (0.05 mg/m3) appears in Table 2. The mean respirable dust levels measured without LEV was 31.4 mg/m3. However, samples collected with LEV were below the limit of quantification (LOQ) which ranged from <1.29 to <1.46 mg/m3. Use of LEV resulted in a greater than 95% reduction in mean respirable dust levels using a mean value with use of LEV of <1.41 (n=5 samples with use of LEV and n=7 without use of LEV). The respirable dust samples collected during grinding without the LEV system contained an average of 24 percent silica. The mass of respirable dust in the samples collected with use of the LEV system was too low to determine the silica content.| Mean, mg/m3 (range) | Std. Dev. | Percent Reduction | Hazard RatioB | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bosch with Dust Director Shroud and DustControl 2900c Vacuum |
0.091 (<0.069 – 0.137) |
0.027 | 98.7 | 1.81 |
| Bosch with no Control | 7.23 (4.57 – 9.90) |
1.94 | NA | 145 |
A n = 5 samples for each tool/control combination and n = 7 samples without the use of the LEV system B Hazard Ratio = measured exposure / NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 |
||||
Average respirable silica and dust exposures, with and without the dust control system, appear as Figures 5 and 6, respectively.
Figure 5. Average respirable silica exposures with and without the Dustcontrol 2900c vacuum and Dust Director shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air - mg/m3)
Figure 6. Average respirable dust exposures with and without Dustcontrol 2900c Vacuum and Dust Director Shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air – mg/m3)
The mean respirable silica concentration measured during use of the control was significantly less than the concentration measured while using the same tool without controls (p<0.01). Grinding mortar with the Bosch angle grinder without dust controls resulted in an average exposure to respirable silica that was 145 times the NIOSH REL. Grinding with the Bosch angle grinder in combination with the Dust Director shroud and the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced the average concentration of respirable silica by 98.7 percent. With use of these controls, the concentration of respirable silica was 1.8 times greater than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3. However the NIOSH REL is based on a time-weighted average (TWA) over a 10-hour workday. Given these were task TWAs and samples were collected over continuous periods of grinding, they may overestimate exposures over an actual work day since some time would be spent performing tasks that would likely have lower, or no, silica exposures (setup, breaks, cleanup, etc.).
Static pressure, dust mass collection and grinding rates.
Static pressure was used as a surrogate for air flow as described earlier. Hood static pressure was measured periodically at a tap near the grinder more than 3 duct diameters from the air intake in the shroud. The static pressure, and thus air flow, was generally higher when the vacuum’s filter had recently been cleaned. The mean, median, and range of calculated flow rates are presented in Table A1 of the Appendix.
Based on the data we collected, the air-flow rate upstream from the Bosch grinder and Dust Director shroud ranged from 78 to 93 cubic feet per minute (cfm) with the DustControl vacuum. When the manufacturer’s filter cleaning procedure was followed the vacuum performed relatively well and flow could be maintained at slightly less than 90 cfm with cleaning. However, mean flow rates dropped substantially to 80 cfm after as little as 8 minutes of grinding without any filter cleaning. The flow rate returned to an average of 89 cfm when filters were cleaned correctly (without stopping air flow to the vacuum). Collingwood and Heitbrink (2007) found that the minimum exhaust flow rate for capture of silica and other particulate under ideal conditions is 21.25 cfm per inch of grinder blade diameter. This is equal to about 96 cfm when using a 4.5 inch diameter grinding blade. We set 106 cfm as the minimum desired flow rate for this study to allow a safety margin for potential decline in equipment performance and the possibility of inadequate maintenance, both of which may be likely after repeated use under actual work conditions. The DustControl vacuum provided slightly less than the minimum flow rate described by Collingwood and Heitbrink for a 4.5-inch blade and the peak flow rate fell with use.
The duration of vacuum bag use and mass of dust collected were recorded and are presented in Table A2 of the Appendix. The vacuum bags were changed and weighed after each trial utilizing the LEV system. A total of five bags were used to complete the five rounds of grinding. The DustControl vacuum captured 45 pounds of dust over 83 minutes of grinding for an average rate of dust collection of 0.54 pounds per minute. The rate of dust collection ranged from 0.47 to 0.63 pounds per minute. Based on these measurements, approximately 130 pounds of dust would likely be captured after just 4 hours of continuous grinding.
The rate of grinding a combination of vertical and horizontal joints while using the LEV system ranged from 2.3 to 3.3 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the use of the LEV system ranged from 2.6 to 3.4 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place ranged from 4.7 to 5.1 feet per minute. It’s important to note that: 1) the operator had limited experience using dust control systems and cut rates appeared to improve slightly over the 2-day period he used the tested equipment; and 2) the upper range of cut rates with the dust control system overlapped with the lowest cut rate with the original guard and without the LEV system in place indicating no statistical difference between cut rates. Given that grinding rates with and without use of this LEV system are only available for one operator and he had limited experience with the LEV system, these reported cut rates are in no way intended to represent the impact use of this LEV system is likely to have on productivity rates overall.
VI. Discussion
The objective of these trials was to evaluate the effectiveness of a tuckpointing LEV system for controlling respirable silica while grinding out mortar joints. The Dust Director shroud with the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced respirable silica concentrations when grinding with the Bosch grinder by approximately 99 percent. Despite being considered effective by our test criteria (greater than 50% reduction), it still resulted in task TWA exposures that exceeded the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 by 1.8 times. Depending on how much time is spent grinding over the course of a work day and on exposures while performing other tasks, the 8-hour TWA exposures may or may not exceed the REL with this system. Use of this system by workers with experience and training in proficient use will likely improve dust capture performance. Exposure reduction is greatly influenced by correct use of this system which includes grinding from right to left, making sure the shroud is held flush against the wall and that the tool travels at a pace that doesn’t exceed the ability of the system to capture dust as it’s generated. Deviation from any of these measures produces visible dust clouds which were observed during trials.
VII. Conclusions
With a 99 percent reduction in respirable silica exposure, the Dust Director shroud and DustControl 2900c vacuum with a Bosch Model 1775E grinder was effective in reducing silica exposures based on our criteria. Use of the tested dust control system may be effective in reducing silica exposure on the job to less than the NIOSH REL if used in combination with administrative controls such as work scheduling to reduce cutting times as needed. Training on correct use of the tested system is also essential. Personal air monitoring is necessary to verify control effectiveness on actual job sites and under “real-world” conditions. However, these results clearly demonstrate the availability of viable and effective engineering controls for tuckpointing operations associated with elevated silica exposure.
VIII. References
American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists. Threshold limit values for chemical substances (TLV®-CS). [2013]. ACGIH, Cincinnati, Ohio.
Bergdahl I.A,. Toren K., Eriksson K., et al. [2004]. Increased mortality in COPD among construction workers exposed to inorganic dust. European Respiratory Journal, 23: 402–06.
Blanc P.D. & Torén K. [2007]. Occupation in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and chronic bronchitis: an update [State of the Art Series. Occupational lung disease in high-and low-income countries, Edited by M. Chan-Yeung. Number 2 in the series]. The International Journal of Tuberculosis and Lung Disease, 11(3), 251-257.
Collingwood S. & Heitbrink W.A. [2007] 'Field Evaluation of an Engineering Control for Respirable Crystalline Silica Exposures During Mortar Removal'. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, 4:11, 875 – 887.
DHHS (NIOSH) Publication No. 2002-129 April 2002 http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/2002-129/
Echt A., Sieber W.K., Lefkowitz D., Meeker J., Susi P., Cardwell B., Heitbrink, W.A. In-depth survey of dust control technology for cutting concrete block and tuckpointing brick at The International Masonry Institute Bordentown Training Center, Bordentown, NJ. Cincinnati, OH: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Report. No. EPHB 282-13; 2007. http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ECTB-282-13.pdf
Heitbrink W., Bennett J. [2006]. A numerical and experimental investigation of crystalline silica exposure control during tuck pointing. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, Vol. 3, pp 366-378.
Lyons et al, [2007]. A breathless builder. Breathe, Vol. 3, no. 4, pp 386-390.
Mastrangelo G., Tartari M., Fedeli U., Fadda E., Saia B. [2003]. Ascertaining the risk of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease in relation to occupation using a case-control design. Occupational Medicine, 53: 165–172.
Meeker J., Cooper M., Lefrowitz D., Susi P. [2009]. Engineering control technologies to reduce occupational silica exposures in masonry cutting and tuckpointing. Public Health Reports, Supplement 1, Vol. 124, June.
Meeker J, Flynn M, Susi P, Cardwell, B [2004]. Performance evaluation of a masonry concrete vacuum. Unpublished Report.
Miller F. W., Alfredsson L., Costenbader K. H., Kamen D. L., Nelson L. M., Norris J. M., & De Roos A. J. [2012]. Epidemiology of environmental exposures and human autoimmune diseases: findings from a National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences Expert Panel workshop. Journal of autoimmunity. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3496812/
Occupational Safety and Health Administration U.S Department of Labor. Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction. [2009]. OSHA 3362-05.
Rappaport SM, Goldberg M, Susi P, Herrick RF [2003]. Excessive exposure to silica in the U.S. construction industry. Annals of Occupational Hygiene, Vol. 47, pp. 111-122.
IX. Appendices
| Measurement Conditions |
n | Mean Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Median
Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before filter cleaning | 5 | 80 | 81 | 78-81 |
| After filter cleaning following manufacturer directions | 9 | 89 | 90 | 84-93 |
| * Static pressure was measured in millibars and converted to inches of water gauge. Flow rates were calculated using the formula Q = Ce (A) 4005 (SP)1/2 where: Q = flow in cubic feet per minute (cfm), Ce = coefficient of entry, A = area of the duct where static pressure measurements were taken in square feet, and SP = static pressure in inches of water gauge. | ||||
| Tool/Control | Collection Period (min.) |
Dust Collection Rate (lb/min.) |
|---|---|---|
| Bosch grinder/Dust Director shroud & DustControl 2900c vacuum |
8 11 8 8 10 |
0.50 0.61 0.50 0.47 0.63 |
| Average | 0.54 |
[content_transformed:protected] =>
Executive Summary
This report describes the results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. It should also be noted that the NIOSH REL is based on exposures averaged over a ten hour work day and our results represent time weighted averages of the sample task duration periods.
Acronyms
ACGIH - American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists
CPWR - CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training
Ce - coefficient of entry
HEPA - high-efficiency particulate air
IUBAC - International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craftworkers
LEV - local exhaust ventilation
PACT - Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies
NIOSH - National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health
OEL - occupational exposure limit
OSHA - Occupational Safety and Health Administration
PAPR - powered air-purifying respirator
PEL - Permissible Exposure Limit
PVC - polyvinyl chloride
REL - Recommended Exposure Limit
RPM - revolutions per minute
TWA - time-weighted average
SP - static pressure
I. Introduction and Background
In 2010 CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training began a four-year project which seeks to identify and evaluate tuckpointing local exhaust ventilation (LEV) systems and disseminate information on their availability and effectiveness. A Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies (PACT) comprised of masonry contractors, representatives from unions, government, equipment manufacturers, and health and safety researcher was formed as part of this project. PACT members participated in identifying important characteristics for control technologies and this information was used to identify LEV systems for tuckpointing using that criteria. Contractor and labor members of the PACT selected specific tuckpointing LEV systems to be considered for evaluation. Each system consisted of a tuckpointing grinder, shroud, and vacuum. This report describes the second of four systems to be evaluated between 2012 the end of 2014, with and without LEV, in a controlled setting to determine effectiveness in silica exposure reduction. This report describes the methods and results of our evaluation of a system consisting of the DustControl 2900c vacuum with the ICS Dust Director shroud and a Bosch Model 1775E grinder.
Excessive exposure to respirable silica can result in silicosis or other silica-related diseases including pulmonary tuberculosis, lung cancer, silicoproteinosis (Lyons et al, 2007) and autoimmune disorders such as rheumatoid arthritis, sarcoidosis and scleroderma (Miller et al, 2012). Respirable silica is generally defined as particles less than 10 micrometers (μm) in aerodynamic diameter (ACGIH, 2013). Silicosis can lead to symptoms including shortness of breath, fatigue, chest pains, susceptibility to infection and possibly death. There is no cure for silicosis, however it is totally preventable. Construction workers exposed to dust, including silica, are also known to have higher rates of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD).
There are many sources of silica in construction that result in exposures of varying intensity among workers. Masonry restoration workers are among the most highly silica-exposed trades in construction. The process of grinding out deteriorated mortar joints between masonry units and replacing or repointing with fresh mortar (often referred to as tuckpointing) is a fundamental part of masonry restoration work. The removal of mortar with powered angle grinders generates enormous levels of dust. Between 2004 and 2006, NIOSH and CPWR evaluated silica exposures while grinding mortar in a controlled setting, at a local training center, where tasks, sample times and task variables were defined by the study design. These studies demonstrated that grinding mortar without controls can result in elevated respirable silica exposures. Meeker et al., (2009) reported exposures between 5 and 25.8 milligrams per cubic meter (mg/m3) in a controlled setting. This study also showed that LEV systems for tuckpointing grinders can reduce exposures to respirable silica by greater than 90 percent.II. Objectives
The objective of this evaluation was to assess the effectiveness of an LEV system for controlling exposure to silica during the grinding of mortar. The control technology was tested under controlled conditions, similar to those experienced by tuckpointers on actual job sites, using journeymen bricklayers experienced in tuckpointing and repeat, randomized trials with and without LEV. All other variables were held constant throughout so that the only variable was whether or not the tested control was used.
III. Description of Equipment Tested
A Bosch model 1775E grinder (Robert Bosch Tool Corporation, Prospect, IL) (Figures 1, 2 and 3) was fitted with a new 1/4-inch wide, 4½-inch diameter segmented diamond abrasive blade made by DeWalt (model #DW4740). The grinder weighs six and a half pounds, draws 8.5 amps and has a variable speed up to 11,000 revolutions per minute (RPMs). The DustControl 2900c vacuum (DustControl, Inc., Wilmington, NC) (Figure 3) was tested in combination with the Dust Director shroud (Industrial Contractors’ Supplies, Inc., Huntingdon, PA) (Figures 1 and 3) attached to the Bosch grinder.
Figure 1. Bosch grinder with Dust Director shroud
Figure 2. Bosch grinder without tuckpointing LEV system.
Figure 3: Bosch Grinder with LEV System
The vacuum is specified to weigh 31 pounds when empty and to provide a flow rate of 114 cubic feet of air per minute and a “static lift” or “vacuum suction pressure” of 84 inches of water. The vacuum is sold with a cyclonic pre-separator, to remove larger particles, a fine filter (rated 99.9 percent efficient) and a HEPA (high-efficiency particulate air) filter (rated to capture 99.97 percent of the particles with an aerodynamic diameter of 0.3 micrometers). The HEPA filter was removed based on the manufacturer’s recommendation due to the heavy dust loading associated with tuckpointing. CPWR sponsored research and contractor experience indicate that HEPA filters likely have an adverse effect on dust capture during tuckpointing because of extreme dust loading on filters. While the cyclone and the fine filter remove most of the dust, especially the large particles, before they reach the HEPA filter, the HEPA filter would still be subject to heavy loading, causing a substantial pressure drop and subsequent decrease in air flow rate. The relatively small increase in the efficiency of the filtration system while using the HEPA filter is expected to be quickly offset by a more significant decrease in capture efficiency as the air flow rate and ability to capture particles decreases.
Dust collects in relatively inexpensive, heavy-gauge plastic bags below and outside of the cyclone. The bags can be removed and replaced without opening the vacuum. Some vacuums are equipped with a light to indicate that the filters need to be cleaned or changed. The DC2900c features a “reverse air pulse cleaning system,” which removes accumulated dust from the filters without having to remove them from the vacuum. The system, as illustrated in Figure 4, requires the operator to disconnect the hose from the shroud, place it over an air stop so that air through the hose is cut off and pressure in the vacuum is maximized.
Figure 4. Procedure for "cleaning" of or dust removal from filters (source: http://dustcontrolusa.com/manuals/2800c.pdf)
The flap covering the port on the side of the vacuum is repeatedly flipped open to release built up pressure in strong pulses that dislodge dust from the filter.
The manufacturer indicates “the filter is generally cleaned once or twice daily during normal continuous operation.” The Dust Director shroud has a 2-inch diameter take-off that was connected to the antistatic, corrugated 1.5-inch diameter, 15-foot long vacuum hose supplied with the DustControl vacuum.
IV. Study Methods
This evaluation was conducted at the International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craft workers (IUBAC) Local 1 Philadelphia/Delaware Training Center in Philadelphia, PA on November 14 and 15, 2012. A single journeyman bricklayer, experienced in tuckpointing, used the grinder and LEV system being tested to remove mortar from joints wide enough to require two passes. The type S mortar had been allowed to cure for at least four weeks. The bricklayer either possessed or was provided with personal protective equipment including sturdy work boots, gloves, hearing protection and a powered air-purifying respirator (PAPR). The PAPR was a 3M GVP system with a bump cap, loose fitting face piece and a HEPA filter (3M, St Paul, MN).
The study was designed to include at least five rounds of sampling during mortar removal. Each round included a trial using the Bosch grinder with a Dust Director shroud and Dust Collector 2900c vacuum and a trial using the Bosch grinder with the factory-supplied guard and without a vacuum. The order of the two trials within each round was randomly selected to minimize bias that might be introduced due to variation associated with environmental factors, equipment operator, blade wear, vacuum performance over time and any other factors unrelated to LEV use. Tools were operated for approximately 16 minutes per trial with controls and for approximately 8 minutes when controls were not used. These times were selected based on the results of previous sampling efforts and estimates of the minimum sample time needed to achieve a limit of quantification low enough to accurately measure exposures down to or less than 0.05 mg/m3 – the NIOSH Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) for respirable silica. The bricklayer was required to take a 5 to 10 minute break in the middle of the 16-minute trials to reduce differences in fatigue, compared to the 8-minute trials. Personal air samples were collected in the breathing zone of the operator during each trial to measure respirable silica concentrations during grinding with and without LEV. The samples were collected using a GilAir-5 pump (Sensidyne, Inc., Clearwater, FL) to draw 4.2 liters of air per minute through a GK2.69 Respirable Cyclone (BGI Inc., Waltham, MA) with a pre-weighed, 37 mm diameter, 5-micron pore size polyvinyl chloride (PVC) filter positioned on the operator’s lapel.
The flow rates of the sampling pumps were calibrated at the beginning of each day using a DryCal DC-Lite Primary Flow Meter (Bios International Corporation, Butler, NJ). Flow rates were measured again near the middle and at the end of each day to ensure that sampling flow rates were maintained within 5% of pre-sampling flow rates throughout the day. Average flow rates were used to calculate sample air volumes. Samples were analyzed by R.J. Lee Group, Inc., (Monroeville, PA) using NIOSH Method 0600, to determine exposure to total mass of respirable dust. The same samples were also analyzed using X-Ray diffraction following NIOSH method 7500 to determine quartz, cristobalite and tridymite concentration in the respirable mass. Reported masses for these analytes were used with the sample air volumes to calculate airborne concentrations of total respirable dust, quartz, cristobalite and tridymite.
We used a reduction of greater than 50 percent in respirable silica exposure concentrations or a reduction to less than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 as our criteria for determining whether or not a control was considered efficacious. This is consistent with criteria used by NIOSH in conducting a similar study in 2004 described by Echt et al. (2007) and by CPWR in 2006 and described by Meeker et al. (2009). The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) and the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) publish additional occupational exposure limits (OELs) for silica which are listed in Table 1 with NIOSH RELs. OELs for silica are based on the respirable fraction of the aerosol, which consists of particles less than 10 micrometers in aerodynamic diameter.
| Organization or Agency | Form of Crystalline Silica | Occupational Exposure Limits (mg/m3) |
|---|---|---|
| NIOSHA | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 |
| OSHA - ConstructionB | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
PEL = 250 / (5 + % quartz) PEL = 250 / (5 + % cristobalite) PEL = 250 / (5 + % tridymite) |
| ACGIH | Crystalline Silica | TLV = 0.025 mg/m3 |
A NIOSH Publication No. 2005-151 indicates 10-hour time-weighted average during a 40-hr workweek B The PEL for silica in OSHA’s Safety and Health Regulations for Construction, 29 C.F.R. 1926.55(a), is an 8-hour time-weighted average (TWA) expressed in millions of particles per cubic foot (mppcf). However, the units mppcf can be converted to milligrams per cubic meter can by dividing mppcf by 10 (OSHA, 2009). The formula used by OSHA to determine the PEL for silica is dependent on the percentage of silica in each collected sample. The concentration of respirable dust measured is compared to the sample specific PEL to determine if the PEL has been exceeded. OSHA has proposed lowering the PEL to 0.05 mg/m3 of respirable silica as an 8 hour TWA. |
||
The flow of air in ventilation systems is governed by fundamental principles that describe the behavior of gases (in this case air). Pressure measurements taken within a ventilation system along with knowledge of hood (or shroud) entry losses can be used to calculate flow rates. Hood entry losses are dependent on the shape and configuration of a particular hood or shroud and described by the term “coefficient of entry (Ce)” which is the ratio of actual air flow through a hood and what the air flow would theoretically be if there were no hood entry losses. Given the coefficient of entry, static pressure measurements can be used to calculate air flow through a given hood. The coefficient of entry for the Dust Director shroud was previously determined by CPWR and used for calculating air flow based on static pressure measurements (Meeker et al., 2009). Static pressure, with the vacuum operating, was measured periodically throughout the evaluation to monitor the changes in air-flow rate following use and again after filter cleaning. The static pressure was measured at a port positioned more than 3 duct diameters downstream from the tool’s air intake using a UEi EM200 Electronic Manometer (Universal Enterprises, Inc., Beaverton, OR).
The dust in the vacuum bag was monitored and, per the manufacturer’s instructions, the bag was changed before the dust level was within 5 centimeters of the valve at the bottom of the vacuum. Each time a vacuum bag was removed, it was weighed to the nearest pound. The bag weights and corresponding grinding durations were used to calculate the average weight of dust collected per unit time. After each trial, cut lengths were measured on the wall to determine total linear feet of vertical (head) and horizontal (bed) joints per unit time.
A Haz-Dust III, Model HD-1003, Real-Time Aerosol Monitor (Environmental Devices Corporation, Plaistow, NH) was used to confirm clearance of dust between trials. The Haz-Dust monitor was positioned on the test wall near the operator at approximately breathing zone level and configured to measure respirable particulate concentration.
V. Results
Personal air monitoring
Five pairs of respirable dust samples were collected while grinding with and without the vacuum system. In addition, three respirable dust samples were collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place. One measurement collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard was shown to be a statistical outlier and was omitted from analysis. Personal air monitoring results for respirable silica and a comparison of average exposures relative to the NIOSH REL for silica (0.05 mg/m3) appears in Table 2. The mean respirable dust levels measured without LEV was 31.4 mg/m3. However, samples collected with LEV were below the limit of quantification (LOQ) which ranged from <1.29 to <1.46 mg/m3. Use of LEV resulted in a greater than 95% reduction in mean respirable dust levels using a mean value with use of LEV of <1.41 (n=5 samples with use of LEV and n=7 without use of LEV). The respirable dust samples collected during grinding without the LEV system contained an average of 24 percent silica. The mass of respirable dust in the samples collected with use of the LEV system was too low to determine the silica content.| Mean, mg/m3 (range) | Std. Dev. | Percent Reduction | Hazard RatioB | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bosch with Dust Director Shroud and DustControl 2900c Vacuum |
0.091 (<0.069 – 0.137) |
0.027 | 98.7 | 1.81 |
| Bosch with no Control | 7.23 (4.57 – 9.90) |
1.94 | NA | 145 |
A n = 5 samples for each tool/control combination and n = 7 samples without the use of the LEV system B Hazard Ratio = measured exposure / NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 |
||||
Average respirable silica and dust exposures, with and without the dust control system, appear as Figures 5 and 6, respectively.
Figure 5. Average respirable silica exposures with and without the Dustcontrol 2900c vacuum and Dust Director shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air - mg/m3)
Figure 6. Average respirable dust exposures with and without Dustcontrol 2900c Vacuum and Dust Director Shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air – mg/m3)
The mean respirable silica concentration measured during use of the control was significantly less than the concentration measured while using the same tool without controls (p<0.01). Grinding mortar with the Bosch angle grinder without dust controls resulted in an average exposure to respirable silica that was 145 times the NIOSH REL. Grinding with the Bosch angle grinder in combination with the Dust Director shroud and the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced the average concentration of respirable silica by 98.7 percent. With use of these controls, the concentration of respirable silica was 1.8 times greater than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3. However the NIOSH REL is based on a time-weighted average (TWA) over a 10-hour workday. Given these were task TWAs and samples were collected over continuous periods of grinding, they may overestimate exposures over an actual work day since some time would be spent performing tasks that would likely have lower, or no, silica exposures (setup, breaks, cleanup, etc.).
Static pressure, dust mass collection and grinding rates.
Static pressure was used as a surrogate for air flow as described earlier. Hood static pressure was measured periodically at a tap near the grinder more than 3 duct diameters from the air intake in the shroud. The static pressure, and thus air flow, was generally higher when the vacuum’s filter had recently been cleaned. The mean, median, and range of calculated flow rates are presented in Table A1 of the Appendix.
Based on the data we collected, the air-flow rate upstream from the Bosch grinder and Dust Director shroud ranged from 78 to 93 cubic feet per minute (cfm) with the DustControl vacuum. When the manufacturer’s filter cleaning procedure was followed the vacuum performed relatively well and flow could be maintained at slightly less than 90 cfm with cleaning. However, mean flow rates dropped substantially to 80 cfm after as little as 8 minutes of grinding without any filter cleaning. The flow rate returned to an average of 89 cfm when filters were cleaned correctly (without stopping air flow to the vacuum). Collingwood and Heitbrink (2007) found that the minimum exhaust flow rate for capture of silica and other particulate under ideal conditions is 21.25 cfm per inch of grinder blade diameter. This is equal to about 96 cfm when using a 4.5 inch diameter grinding blade. We set 106 cfm as the minimum desired flow rate for this study to allow a safety margin for potential decline in equipment performance and the possibility of inadequate maintenance, both of which may be likely after repeated use under actual work conditions. The DustControl vacuum provided slightly less than the minimum flow rate described by Collingwood and Heitbrink for a 4.5-inch blade and the peak flow rate fell with use.
The duration of vacuum bag use and mass of dust collected were recorded and are presented in Table A2 of the Appendix. The vacuum bags were changed and weighed after each trial utilizing the LEV system. A total of five bags were used to complete the five rounds of grinding. The DustControl vacuum captured 45 pounds of dust over 83 minutes of grinding for an average rate of dust collection of 0.54 pounds per minute. The rate of dust collection ranged from 0.47 to 0.63 pounds per minute. Based on these measurements, approximately 130 pounds of dust would likely be captured after just 4 hours of continuous grinding.
The rate of grinding a combination of vertical and horizontal joints while using the LEV system ranged from 2.3 to 3.3 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the use of the LEV system ranged from 2.6 to 3.4 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place ranged from 4.7 to 5.1 feet per minute. It’s important to note that: 1) the operator had limited experience using dust control systems and cut rates appeared to improve slightly over the 2-day period he used the tested equipment; and 2) the upper range of cut rates with the dust control system overlapped with the lowest cut rate with the original guard and without the LEV system in place indicating no statistical difference between cut rates. Given that grinding rates with and without use of this LEV system are only available for one operator and he had limited experience with the LEV system, these reported cut rates are in no way intended to represent the impact use of this LEV system is likely to have on productivity rates overall.
VI. Discussion
The objective of these trials was to evaluate the effectiveness of a tuckpointing LEV system for controlling respirable silica while grinding out mortar joints. The Dust Director shroud with the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced respirable silica concentrations when grinding with the Bosch grinder by approximately 99 percent. Despite being considered effective by our test criteria (greater than 50% reduction), it still resulted in task TWA exposures that exceeded the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 by 1.8 times. Depending on how much time is spent grinding over the course of a work day and on exposures while performing other tasks, the 8-hour TWA exposures may or may not exceed the REL with this system. Use of this system by workers with experience and training in proficient use will likely improve dust capture performance. Exposure reduction is greatly influenced by correct use of this system which includes grinding from right to left, making sure the shroud is held flush against the wall and that the tool travels at a pace that doesn’t exceed the ability of the system to capture dust as it’s generated. Deviation from any of these measures produces visible dust clouds which were observed during trials.
VII. Conclusions
With a 99 percent reduction in respirable silica exposure, the Dust Director shroud and DustControl 2900c vacuum with a Bosch Model 1775E grinder was effective in reducing silica exposures based on our criteria. Use of the tested dust control system may be effective in reducing silica exposure on the job to less than the NIOSH REL if used in combination with administrative controls such as work scheduling to reduce cutting times as needed. Training on correct use of the tested system is also essential. Personal air monitoring is necessary to verify control effectiveness on actual job sites and under “real-world” conditions. However, these results clearly demonstrate the availability of viable and effective engineering controls for tuckpointing operations associated with elevated silica exposure.
VIII. References
American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists. Threshold limit values for chemical substances (TLV®-CS). [2013]. ACGIH, Cincinnati, Ohio.
Bergdahl I.A,. Toren K., Eriksson K., et al. [2004]. Increased mortality in COPD among construction workers exposed to inorganic dust. European Respiratory Journal, 23: 402–06.
Blanc P.D. & Torén K. [2007]. Occupation in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and chronic bronchitis: an update [State of the Art Series. Occupational lung disease in high-and low-income countries, Edited by M. Chan-Yeung. Number 2 in the series]. The International Journal of Tuberculosis and Lung Disease, 11(3), 251-257.
Collingwood S. & Heitbrink W.A. [2007] 'Field Evaluation of an Engineering Control for Respirable Crystalline Silica Exposures During Mortar Removal'. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, 4:11, 875 – 887.
DHHS (NIOSH) Publication No. 2002-129 April 2002 http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/2002-129/
Echt A., Sieber W.K., Lefkowitz D., Meeker J., Susi P., Cardwell B., Heitbrink, W.A. In-depth survey of dust control technology for cutting concrete block and tuckpointing brick at The International Masonry Institute Bordentown Training Center, Bordentown, NJ. Cincinnati, OH: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Report. No. EPHB 282-13; 2007. http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ECTB-282-13.pdf
Heitbrink W., Bennett J. [2006]. A numerical and experimental investigation of crystalline silica exposure control during tuck pointing. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, Vol. 3, pp 366-378.
Lyons et al, [2007]. A breathless builder. Breathe, Vol. 3, no. 4, pp 386-390.
Mastrangelo G., Tartari M., Fedeli U., Fadda E., Saia B. [2003]. Ascertaining the risk of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease in relation to occupation using a case-control design. Occupational Medicine, 53: 165–172.
Meeker J., Cooper M., Lefrowitz D., Susi P. [2009]. Engineering control technologies to reduce occupational silica exposures in masonry cutting and tuckpointing. Public Health Reports, Supplement 1, Vol. 124, June.
Meeker J, Flynn M, Susi P, Cardwell, B [2004]. Performance evaluation of a masonry concrete vacuum. Unpublished Report.
Miller F. W., Alfredsson L., Costenbader K. H., Kamen D. L., Nelson L. M., Norris J. M., & De Roos A. J. [2012]. Epidemiology of environmental exposures and human autoimmune diseases: findings from a National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences Expert Panel workshop. Journal of autoimmunity. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3496812/
Occupational Safety and Health Administration U.S Department of Labor. Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction. [2009]. OSHA 3362-05.
Rappaport SM, Goldberg M, Susi P, Herrick RF [2003]. Excessive exposure to silica in the U.S. construction industry. Annals of Occupational Hygiene, Vol. 47, pp. 111-122.
IX. Appendices
| Measurement Conditions |
n | Mean Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Median
Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before filter cleaning | 5 | 80 | 81 | 78-81 |
| After filter cleaning following manufacturer directions | 9 | 89 | 90 | 84-93 |
| * Static pressure was measured in millibars and converted to inches of water gauge. Flow rates were calculated using the formula Q = Ce (A) 4005 (SP)1/2 where: Q = flow in cubic feet per minute (cfm), Ce = coefficient of entry, A = area of the duct where static pressure measurements were taken in square feet, and SP = static pressure in inches of water gauge. | ||||
| Tool/Control | Collection Period (min.) |
Dust Collection Rate (lb/min.) |
|---|---|---|
| Bosch grinder/Dust Director shroud & DustControl 2900c vacuum |
8 11 8 8 10 |
0.50 0.61 0.50 0.47 0.63 |
| Average | 0.54 |
[disclaimer:protected] => [disclaimer_transformed:protected] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [template] => record ) [_file] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/templates/elcosh/record_macros.html [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_encoding:protected] => UTF-8 [_outputMode:protected] => 11 [_forceReparse:protected] => [_phpCodeDestination:protected] => /tmp/ [_phpCodeExtension:protected] => php [_cacheLifetime:protected] => 30 [_cachePurgeFrequency:protected] => 30 [externalMacroTemplatesCache:PHPTAL:private] => Array ( ) ) ) ) ) ) [4] => Array ( [file] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/sblib/core/SB_PHPTAL/PHPTAL/PHPTAL.php [line] => 659 [function] => tpl_61515a6c_record__uvBJJSo8xT_sgOY5gjP7ug [args] => Array ( [0] => PHPTAL Object ( [_prefilters:protected] => Array ( ) [_prefilter:PHPTAL:private] => REMOVED: DO NOT USE [_postfilter:protected] => [_repositories:protected] => Array ( ) [_path:protected] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/templates/elcosh/record.html [_resolvers:protected] => Array ( ) [_source:protected] => PHPTAL_FileSource Object ( [_path:PHPTAL_FileSource:private] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/templates/elcosh/record.html ) [_codeFile:protected] => /tmp/tpl_61515a6c_record__uvBJJSo8xT_sgOY5gjP7ug.php [_functionName:protected] => tpl_61515a6c_record__uvBJJSo8xT_sgOY5gjP7ug [_prepared:protected] => 1 [_triggers:protected] => Array ( ) [_translator:protected] => [_globalContext:protected] => stdClass Object ( ) [_context:protected] => PHPTAL_Context Object ( [_line] => [_file] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/templates/elcosh/record.html [repeat] => stdClass Object ( ) [_xmlDeclaration] => [_docType] => [_nothrow:PHPTAL_Context:private] => [_slots:PHPTAL_Context:private] => Array ( ) [_slotsStack:PHPTAL_Context:private] => Array ( [0] => Array ( ) [1] => Array ( ) ) [_parentContext:PHPTAL_Context:private] => [_globalContext:PHPTAL_Context:private] => stdClass Object ( ) [_echoDeclarations:PHPTAL_Context:private] => [referer] => http://www.elcosh.org/document/3908/d001345/An%2BEvaluation%2Bof%2BSilica%2BExposure%2BControls%2Bfor%2BTuckpointing%253A%2BDustControl%2B2900c%2BVacuum%2Bwith%2Bthe%2BICS%2BDust%2BDirector%2BShroud%2Band%2BBosch%2BGrinder%2BModel%2B1775E%2BConducted%2BNovember%2B14-15%252C%2B2012.html [curr_module] => Record [styles] => Array ( ) [javascript] => Array ( [0] => jquery.min.js ) [metas] => Array ( [language] => en [robots] => index, follow ) [user] => [curr_url] => https://www.elcosh.org/index.php?module=Record&id=3908&type=document [base_url] => https://www.elcosh.org/index.php?module=Record [title] => eLCOSH : An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: DustControl 2900c Vacuum with the ICS Dust Director Shroud and Bosch Grinder Model 1775E Conducted November 14-15, 2012 [language] => en [search_query] => [module] => Record [new_records] => Array ( [0] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Fixed Ladder [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Fixed Ladders addresses the potential risks associated with using fixed ladders. The resource includes a brief case example,... [category] => Array ( [0] => 15 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 53 [5] => 55 [6] => 60 [7] => 64 [8] => 73 [9] => 76 [10] => 78 [11] => 80 [12] => 86 [13] => 87 [14] => 90 [15] => 92 [16] => 93 [17] => 94 [18] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Falls [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Concrete Polisher [11] => Electrical Worker [13] => HVAC [15] => Laborer [17] => PCC/Restoration [19] => Plumber/Pipefitter [21] => Roofer/Waterproofer [23] => Sheetmetal Worker [25] => Welder [27] => Commercial & Institutional [28] => Jobsites [29] => Industrial [31] => LEED/Green Construction [33] => Renovations [35] => Residential [37] => Toolbox Talks [38] => Documents [39] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4430/d001660/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BFixed%2BLadder.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [53] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 53 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Concrete Polisher [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [73] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 73 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => PCC/Restoration [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4430 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001660 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Fixed Ladder [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Fixed Ladders, Fall Prevention, Falls [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Fixed Ladders addresses the potential risks associated with using fixed ladders. The resource includes a brief case example, steps to prevent a related injury and questions for discussion. It includes an image that illustrates the hazard, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001257,d001254,d001255,d001256,d001258,d001262,d001279 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_completed:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/22/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [1] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Challenges Preventing Falling Objects [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Challenges Preventing Falling Objects addresses the hazards of being struck by falling objects on the job site. The resource... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 55 [5] => 64 [6] => 68 [7] => 71 [8] => 75 [9] => 78 [10] => 79 [11] => 82 [12] => 62 [13] => 86 [14] => 87 [15] => 88 [16] => 89 [17] => 91 [18] => 90 [19] => 92 [20] => 93 [21] => 94 [22] => 95 [23] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Electrical Worker [11] => Laborer [13] => Maintenance Worker [15] => Painter [17] => Plasterer [19] => Roofer/Waterproofer [21] => Scaffold Erector [23] => Stonemason [25] => Structural Ironworker [27] => Welder [29] => Commercial & Institutional [30] => Jobsites [31] => Demolition [33] => Disasters [35] => Heavy & Highway [37] => Industrial [39] => LEED/Green Construction [41] => Renovations [43] => Residential [45] => Underground [47] => Toolbox Talks [48] => Documents [49] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4431/d001661/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BChallenges%2BPreventing%2BFalling%2BObjects.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4431 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001661 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Challenges Preventing Falling Objects [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => dropped objects, falling objects, struck by incidents, struck by fatalities [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Challenges Preventing Falling Objects addresses the hazards of being struck by falling objects on the job site. The resource includes a brief example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates a group workers observing a scaffold free of debris during high winds, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001234,d001238,d001244,d001251,d001253,d001260,d001268,d001278 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_completed:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/22/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [2] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Tower Crane Safety [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Tower Crane Safety addresses the potential hazards of Tower Cranes and the importance of following procedure before and durin... [category] => Array ( [0] => 11 [1] => 12 [2] => 18 [3] => 70 [4] => 87 [5] => 88 [6] => 91 [7] => 90 [8] => 92 [9] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Cranes & Hoists [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Crushed/Struck By [6] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [9] => Operating Engineer [10] => Trades [11] => Commercial & Institutional [12] => Jobsites [13] => Demolition [15] => Heavy & Highway [17] => Industrial [19] => LEED/Green Construction [21] => Toolbox Talks [22] => Documents [23] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4427/d001657/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BTower%2BCrane%2BSafety.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [11] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 11 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Cranes & Hoists [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [18] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 18 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4427 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001657 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Tower Crane Safety [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Tower Crane, Crane, Stability, Tipping, Lift Zone Safety, Lift, Zone, Safety, Struck by [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Tower Crane Safety addresses the potential hazards of Tower Cranes and the importance of following procedure before and during Tower Crane operation. The resource includes a brief example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates a worker inspecting a Tower Crane before operation, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001234,d001238,d001250,d001251,d001253,d001258,d001262,d001273 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/19/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [3] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Work Zone Safety: Working Around Vehicles [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Working Around Vehicles in the Work Zone addresses methods to avoid being struck-by a vehicle on a construction site. The res... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 18 [2] => 52 [3] => 57 [4] => 70 [5] => 85 [6] => 87 [7] => 88 [8] => 89 [9] => 91 [10] => 90 [11] => 92 [12] => 93 [13] => 94 [14] => 95 [15] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [6] => Commercial Diver [7] => Trades [8] => Flagger [10] => Operating Engineer [12] => Truck Driver [14] => Commercial & Institutional [15] => Jobsites [16] => Demolition [18] => Disasters [20] => Heavy & Highway [22] => Industrial [24] => LEED/Green Construction [26] => Renovations [28] => Residential [30] => Underground [32] => Toolbox Talks [33] => Documents [34] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4428/d001658/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BWork%2BZone%2BSafety%253A%2BWorking%2BAround%2BVehicles.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [18] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 18 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [52] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 52 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Commercial Diver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [85] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 85 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Truck Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4428 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001658 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Daniela Caceres [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Work Zone Safety: Working Around Vehicles [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Struck, Struck by, Vehicle, Work Zone Safety, Truck, Operator, Driver, Mobile Equipment [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Working Around Vehicles in the Work Zone addresses methods to avoid being struck-by a vehicle on a construction site. The resource includes a case example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates the hazard, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001640 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/19/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [4] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Construction Dive -- DeWalt's Jobsite Pro headphones recalled for fire hazards [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => A recall notice by the United States Consumer Product Safety Commission affects over 300,000 DeWalt Jobsite Pro Headphones. The recall is a result of... [category] => Array ( [0] => 16 [1] => 44 [2] => 45 [3] => 46 [4] => 47 [5] => 48 [6] => 49 [7] => 50 [8] => 51 [9] => 52 [10] => 53 [11] => 54 [12] => 55 [13] => 56 [14] => 57 [15] => 58 [16] => 59 [17] => 60 [18] => 61 [19] => 64 [20] => 65 [21] => 66 [22] => 67 [23] => 68 [24] => 69 [25] => 70 [26] => 71 [27] => 72 [28] => 73 [29] => 74 [30] => 75 [31] => 76 [32] => 77 [33] => 63 [34] => 78 [35] => 79 [36] => 80 [37] => 81 [38] => 82 [39] => 62 [40] => 83 [41] => 84 [42] => 85 [43] => 86 [44] => 87 [45] => 88 [46] => 89 [47] => 91 [48] => 90 [49] => 92 [50] => 93 [51] => 94 [52] => 95 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Fire & Explosions [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Acoustical Ceiling Carpenter [4] => Trades [5] => Asbestos/Insulator [7] => Boilermaker [9] => Bricklayer [11] => Cabinetmaker [13] => Carpenter [15] => Carpet Layer [17] => Cement Mason [19] => Commercial Diver [21] => Concrete Polisher [23] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [25] => Electrical Worker [27] => Elevator Constructor [29] => Flagger [31] => Glazier [33] => Hazardous Waste Cleanup [35] => HVAC [37] => Interior Systems Carpenter [39] => Laborer [41] => Landscaper [43] => Lather [45] => Lead Abatement Worker [47] => Maintenance Worker [49] => Millwright [51] => Operating Engineer [53] => Painter [55] => Paper Hanger [57] => PCC/Restoration [59] => Pile Driver [61] => Plasterer [63] => Plumber/Pipefitter [65] => Refractory Worker [67] => Reinforcing Ironworker [69] => Roofer/Waterproofer [71] => Scaffold Erector [73] => Sheetmetal Worker [75] => Sprinkler Fitter [77] => Stonemason [79] => Structural Ironworker [81] => Terrazzo Worker [83] => Tile Setter [85] => Truck Driver [87] => Welder [89] => Commercial & Institutional [90] => Jobsites [91] => Demolition [93] => Disasters [95] => Heavy & Highway [97] => Industrial [99] => LEED/Green Construction [101] => Renovations [103] => Residential [105] => Underground ) [type] => [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4426/d001656/Construction%2BDive%2B--%2BDeWalt%2527s%2BJobsite%2BPro%2Bheadphones%2Brecalled%2Bfor%2Bfire%2Bhazards.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [16] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 16 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Fire & Explosions [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [44] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 44 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Acoustical Ceiling Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [45] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 45 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Asbestos/Insulator [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [46] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 46 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Boilermaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [48] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 48 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cabinetmaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [50] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 50 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpet Layer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [52] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 52 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Commercial Diver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [53] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 53 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Concrete Polisher [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [54] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 54 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [58] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 58 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Glazier [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [59] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 59 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Hazardous Waste Cleanup [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [65] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 65 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Landscaper [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [66] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 66 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Lather [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [67] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 67 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Lead Abatement Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [69] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 69 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Millwright [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [72] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 72 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Paper Hanger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [73] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 73 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => PCC/Restoration [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [77] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 77 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Refractory Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [81] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 81 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sprinkler Fitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [83] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 83 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Terrazzo Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [84] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 84 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Tile Setter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [85] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 85 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Truck Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4426 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001656 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Construction Dive -- DeWalt's Jobsite Pro headphones recalled for fire hazards [total_pages:protected] => 1 [billed_pages:protected] => 1 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => DeWalt, Fire Hazards, recall, headphones [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A recall notice by the United States Consumer Product Safety Commission affects over 300,000 DeWalt Jobsite Pro Headphones. The recall is a result of a malfunction that can cause earbuds to overheat while charging or during use, leading to fire and burn hazards. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => https://www.constructiondive.com/news/dewalts-jobsite-pro-headphones-recalled-for-fire-hazards/611248/?utm_source=Sailthru&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Issue:%202021-12-10%20Construction%20Dive%20Newsletter%20%5Bissue:38532%5D&utm_term=Construction%20Dive [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/13/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/13/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 12/13/21 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [new_images] => Array ( [0] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Morning Toolbox Talk [image] => /record/images/4003-p.jpg [blurb] => This photo is from an early morning toolbox talk on a construction job in Mclean, Virginia. It is being delivered in English and Spanish.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 20 [1] => 51 [2] => 57 [3] => 64 [4] => 70 [5] => 63 [6] => 78 [7] => 82 [8] => 62 [9] => 87 [10] => 88 [11] => 89 [12] => 91 [13] => 90 [14] => 93 [15] => 94 [16] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Safety Culture [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Cement Mason [4] => Trades [5] => Flagger [7] => Laborer [9] => Operating Engineer [11] => Reinforcing Ironworker [13] => Roofer/Waterproofer [15] => Stonemason [17] => Structural Ironworker [19] => Commercial & Institutional [20] => Jobsites [21] => Demolition [23] => Disasters [25] => Heavy & Highway [27] => Industrial [29] => Renovations [31] => Residential [33] => Images [34] => Media [35] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4003/i002691/Morning%2BToolbox%2BTalk.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4003 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002691 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Morning Toolbox Talk [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, Spanish, bilingual [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This photo is from an early morning toolbox talk on a construction job in Mclean, Virginia. It is being delivered in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001285,d001304,c000079 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [1] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox talk - crew view [image] => /record/images/4005-p.jpg [blurb] => Photo of crew listening to a toolbox safety talk before starting work.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 97 [1] => 20 [2] => 47 [3] => 49 [4] => 51 [5] => 55 [6] => 61 [7] => 64 [8] => 71 [9] => 75 [10] => 63 [11] => 79 [12] => 62 [13] => 87 [14] => 88 [15] => 91 [16] => 90 [17] => 93 [18] => 94 [19] => 95 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Images [1] => Media [2] => Media & Documents [3] => Safety Culture [4] => Work Environment [5] => Hazards [6] => Bricklayer [7] => Trades [8] => Carpenter [10] => Cement Mason [12] => Electrical Worker [14] => Interior Systems Carpenter [16] => Laborer [18] => Painter [20] => Plasterer [22] => Reinforcing Ironworker [24] => Scaffold Erector [26] => Structural Ironworker [28] => Commercial & Institutional [29] => Jobsites [30] => Demolition [32] => Heavy & Highway [34] => Industrial [36] => Renovations [38] => Residential [40] => Underground ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4005/i002692/Toolbox%2Btalk%2B-%2Bcrew%2Bview.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4005 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002692 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox talk - crew view [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, safety talk, Spanish [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Photo of crew listening to a toolbox safety talk before starting work. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002691,d001269, c000079, d001285 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [2] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox talk - long shot [image] => /record/images/4006-p.jpg [blurb] => This crew gathered every morning before starting work to discuss a new safety topic.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 20 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 55 [5] => 64 [6] => 68 [7] => 75 [8] => 76 [9] => 63 [10] => 78 [11] => 79 [12] => 82 [13] => 62 [14] => 87 [15] => 88 [16] => 91 [17] => 90 [18] => 93 [19] => 94 [20] => 95 [21] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Safety Culture [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Electrical Worker [11] => Laborer [13] => Maintenance Worker [15] => Plasterer [17] => Plumber/Pipefitter [19] => Reinforcing Ironworker [21] => Roofer/Waterproofer [23] => Scaffold Erector [25] => Stonemason [27] => Structural Ironworker [29] => Commercial & Institutional [30] => Jobsites [31] => Demolition [33] => Heavy & Highway [35] => Industrial [37] => Renovations [39] => Residential [41] => Underground [43] => Images [44] => Media [45] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4006/i002693/Toolbox%2Btalk%2B-%2Blong%2Bshot.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4006 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002693 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox talk - long shot [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, safety minute [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This crew gathered every morning before starting work to discuss a new safety topic. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002691,i002692,d001269,d000527 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [3] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Safety officer discussing ongoing project with marketing coordinator [image] => /record/images/4014-p.jpg [blurb] => The safety officer (left) points out the good safety practices on this project that reflect well on the firm and may influence future clients.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 97 [1] => 20 [2] => 46 [3] => 47 [4] => 49 [5] => 50 [6] => 51 [7] => 54 [8] => 55 [9] => 58 [10] => 60 [11] => 61 [12] => 64 [13] => 71 [14] => 75 [15] => 76 [16] => 63 [17] => 79 [18] => 80 [19] => 82 [20] => 62 [21] => 83 [22] => 87 [23] => 91 [24] => 90 [25] => 93 [26] => 94 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Images [1] => Media [2] => Media & Documents [3] => Safety Culture [4] => Work Environment [5] => Hazards [6] => Boilermaker [7] => Trades [8] => Bricklayer [10] => Carpenter [12] => Carpet Layer [14] => Cement Mason [16] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [18] => Electrical Worker [20] => Glazier [22] => HVAC [24] => Interior Systems Carpenter [26] => Laborer [28] => Painter [30] => Plasterer [32] => Plumber/Pipefitter [34] => Reinforcing Ironworker [36] => Scaffold Erector [38] => Sheetmetal Worker [40] => Stonemason [42] => Structural Ironworker [44] => Terrazzo Worker [46] => Commercial & Institutional [47] => Jobsites [48] => Heavy & Highway [50] => Industrial [52] => Renovations [54] => Residential ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4014/i002700/Safety%2Bofficer%2Bdiscussing%2Bongoing%2Bproject%2Bwith%2Bmarketing%2Bcoordinator.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [46] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 46 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Boilermaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [50] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 50 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpet Layer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [54] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 54 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [58] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 58 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Glazier [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [83] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 83 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Terrazzo Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4014 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002700 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Safety officer discussing ongoing project with marketing coordinator [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Latino, safety officer, safety culture [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The safety officer (left) points out the good safety practices on this project that reflect well on the firm and may influence future clients. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/index.php [more_like_this:protected] => d000989,d001351,d001362,d000652, d001101, d000931, d001395 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Hoar Construction, Photo by Neil Lippy [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 01/30/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [4] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Scaffolding at top of large column [image] => /record/images/3994-p.jpg [blurb] => This shot shows innovative guarding around the top of a large concrete column in the base of a high rise structure going up.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 15 [1] => 21 [2] => 47 [3] => 51 [4] => 63 [5] => 78 [6] => 79 [7] => 80 [8] => 62 [9] => 87 [10] => 97 [11] => 56 [12] => 64 [13] => 74 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Falls [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Scaffolds [6] => Bricklayer [7] => Trades [8] => Cement Mason [10] => Reinforcing Ironworker [12] => Roofer/Waterproofer [14] => Scaffold Erector [16] => Sheetmetal Worker [18] => Structural Ironworker [20] => Commercial & Institutional [21] => Jobsites [22] => Images [23] => Media [24] => Media & Documents [25] => Elevator Constructor [27] => Laborer [29] => Pile Driver ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/3994/i002689/Scaffolding%2Bat%2Btop%2Bof%2Blarge%2Bcolumn.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [21] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 21 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Scaffolds [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3994 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002689 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Scaffolding at top of large column [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Guardrail, railing, fall prevention, falls [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This shot shows innovative guarding around the top of a large concrete column in the base of a high rise structure going up. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/8/adjustable-tower-scaffold.html [more_like_this:protected] => c1002680,i002662,d000608,d001255 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Photo by Pam Susi [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2016 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_completed:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/01/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [5] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Construction bracing [image] => /record/images/3995-p.jpg [blurb] => This shows structural support that prevents collapses during construction.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 15 [2] => 21 [3] => 49 [4] => 51 [5] => 55 [6] => 56 [7] => 60 [8] => 64 [9] => 68 [10] => 74 [11] => 63 [12] => 78 [13] => 79 [14] => 80 [15] => 62 [16] => 87 [17] => 90 [18] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Falls [6] => Scaffolds [9] => Carpenter [10] => Trades [11] => Cement Mason [13] => Electrical Worker [15] => Elevator Constructor [17] => HVAC [19] => Laborer [21] => Maintenance Worker [23] => Pile Driver [25] => Reinforcing Ironworker [27] => Roofer/Waterproofer [29] => Scaffold Erector [31] => Sheetmetal Worker [33] => Structural Ironworker [35] => Commercial & Institutional [36] => Jobsites [37] => Industrial [39] => Images [40] => Media [41] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/3995/i002690/Construction%2Bbracing.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [21] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 21 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Scaffolds [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3995 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002690 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Construction bracing [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Bracing, support, scaffold [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This shows structural support that prevents collapses during construction. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/8/adjustable-tower-scaffold.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002660 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Photo by Pam Susi [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2016 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_completed:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/01/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [preview_mode] => [description] => The results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. [keywords] => tuckpointing, HEPA vacuum, dust control, LEV, local exhaust ventilation, silica [related_items] => Array ( [Research Reports] => Array ( [0] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1874 [old_id:protected] => 722 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000683 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Sharon Garber/COD [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Protecting Tuckpointing Workers from Silica Dust: Draft Recommendations for a Ventilated Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 12 [billed_pages:protected] => 12 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, vacuum, grinder, mortar, respirator, OSHA, NIOSH, exhaust, Heitbrink, tuckpointer, silica, masonry, dust, silicosis, LEV [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Describes draft recommendations for use of ventilated grinder to reduce dust during tuckpointing and describes field trials using these devices. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/hazard/67/chip-scrape-and-grind-surfaces-or-joints-silica.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001201,d000292,d000293,d000658 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2005 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/27/05 [date_completed:protected] => 04/26/05 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/20/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [1] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1940 [old_id:protected] => 909 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Workplace Solutions: Control of Hazardous Dust During Tuckpointing [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, silica, dust, tuckpoint, grinder, masonry restoration, mortar, vacuum [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d000819,d000820,d000730,d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 10/24/08 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/09 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [2] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3899 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001342 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: Hilti VC40-U Vacuum with Hilti DC-EX Dust Guard and Hilti Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 15 [billed_pages:protected] => 15 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP4 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => silica, tuckpointing, Hilti, local exhaust systems, LEV, shroud, quartz [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This report describes the results of an evaluation of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Hilti VC40-U vacuum, a Hilti DC-EX shroud, and a Hilti DAG-500 grinder. Randomized trials with and without use of the dust control system were conducted in a controlled setting. Removing mortar with the Hilti grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 220 times the National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05mg/m3. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 97 percent. However, exposures measured during the use of the dust control system still exceeded the NIOSH REL. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => December 1, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/05/14 [date_completed:protected] => 02/04/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/06/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [Handouts] => Array ( [0] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3656 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001198 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 24 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction While Doing Tuckpointing/Mortar Removal [total_pages:protected] => 2 [billed_pages:protected] => 2 [publication_number:protected] => DSG FS-3632 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Brick, block, tuckpointing, silica, local exhaust ventilation, LEV, masonry [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Tuckpointing creates some of the greatest exposures to silica in construction. This OSHA factsheet provides guidance on how to greatly reduce these exposures through the use of local exhaust ventilation. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863, d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => February 2013 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/04/13 [date_completed:protected] => 03/27/13 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [collections] => Array ( [3913] => ) [record] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => Array ( [867] => Author Object ( [id:protected] => 867 [organization_id:protected] => 0 [firstname:protected] => Michael [lastname:protected] => Cooper [address:protected] => [city:protected] => [province:protected] => [country:protected] => [postal_code:protected] => [department:protected] => [title:protected] => [phone:protected] => [fax:protected] => [email:protected] => [degree:protected] => [website:protected] => [about:protected] => [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => [date_completed:protected] => [date_billed:protected] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [481] => Author Object ( [id:protected] => 481 [organization_id:protected] => 0 [firstname:protected] => Pam [lastname:protected] => Susi [address:protected] => 8484 Georgia Avenue, Suite 1000 [city:protected] => Silver Spring [province:protected] => Maryland [country:protected] => USA [postal_code:protected] => 20910 [department:protected] => [title:protected] => [phone:protected] => 301-578-8500 ext.144 [fax:protected] => 301-578-8572 [email:protected] => plsusi@aol.com [degree:protected] => [website:protected] => http://www.cpwr.com [about:protected] => [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => 2003-10-02 [date_completed:protected] => 2003-10-06 [date_billed:protected] => 2003-11-03 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [organizations:protected] => Array ( [1] => Organization Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [elcosh_id:protected] => o000001 [user_id:protected] => 14 [province_id:protected] => 21 [country_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => CPWR - The Center for Construction Research and Training [address:protected] => Suite 1000, 8484 Georgia Ave [postal_code:protected] => 20910 [city:protected] => Silver Spring [department:protected] => [phone:protected] => 301-578-8500 [fax:protected] => 301-578-8572 [email:protected] => cpwrwebsite@cpwr.com [website:protected] => http://www.cpwr.com [filename:protected] => o000001.gif [about:protected] => CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training, developed, and continues to maintain/expand this website - The Electronic Library of Construction Occupational Safety and Health, www.elcosh.org. CPWR, formerly known as The Center to Protect Workers’ Rights, is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit research and training institution. Created by the Building and Construction Trades Department, AFL-CIO, CPWR serves as the research arm of the BCTD. Since the inception of its research agenda in 1990, CPWR has grown into a worldwide provider of safety and health information covering all aspects of the construction industry. CPWR launched eLCOSH in 2000, and the Spanish-language version of the site in 2001. CPWR also created, and continues to build, Construction Solutions - www.cpwrConstructionSolutions.org - a free, online database of construction hazards and ways to prevent, eliminate, or reduce them. [comments:protected] => [logo_available:protected] => T [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => 2000-08-18 [date_completed:protected] => 2000-08-30 [date_billed:protected] => 2000-09-05 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [collections:protected] => Array ( [3913] => ) [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => Array ( [1874] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1874 [old_id:protected] => 722 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000683 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Sharon Garber/COD [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Protecting Tuckpointing Workers from Silica Dust: Draft Recommendations for a Ventilated Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 12 [billed_pages:protected] => 12 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, vacuum, grinder, mortar, respirator, OSHA, NIOSH, exhaust, Heitbrink, tuckpointer, silica, masonry, dust, silicosis, LEV [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Describes draft recommendations for use of ventilated grinder to reduce dust during tuckpointing and describes field trials using these devices. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/hazard/67/chip-scrape-and-grind-surfaces-or-joints-silica.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001201,d000292,d000293,d000658 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2005 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/27/05 [date_completed:protected] => 04/26/05 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/20/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [1940] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1940 [old_id:protected] => 909 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Workplace Solutions: Control of Hazardous Dust During Tuckpointing [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, silica, dust, tuckpoint, grinder, masonry restoration, mortar, vacuum [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d000819,d000820,d000730,d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 10/24/08 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/09 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [2213] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 2213 [old_id:protected] => 1090 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => [language_id:protected] => 2 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Control del polvo peligroso que se genera durante los procesos de reparación de mortero [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => 2008-126 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => [comments:protected] => http://www.cdc.gov/spanish/niosh/docs/wp-solutions/2008-126_sp/ [summary:protected] => A Workplace Solutions de NIOSH que resume un estudio de NIOSH sobre los riesgos de exposición cuando se reparan las estructuras y los métodos para controlar el polvo. [A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust.] [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => D000819,D000820,D000730,d000819 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 01/07/10 [date_completed:protected] => 04/19/10 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 07/08/12 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [3656] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3656 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001198 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 24 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction While Doing Tuckpointing/Mortar Removal [total_pages:protected] => 2 [billed_pages:protected] => 2 [publication_number:protected] => DSG FS-3632 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Brick, block, tuckpointing, silica, local exhaust ventilation, LEV, masonry [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Tuckpointing creates some of the greatest exposures to silica in construction. This OSHA factsheet provides guidance on how to greatly reduce these exposures through the use of local exhaust ventilation. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863, d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => February 2013 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/04/13 [date_completed:protected] => 03/27/13 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [3899] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3899 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001342 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: Hilti VC40-U Vacuum with Hilti DC-EX Dust Guard and Hilti Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 15 [billed_pages:protected] => 15 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP4 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => silica, tuckpointing, Hilti, local exhaust systems, LEV, shroud, quartz [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This report describes the results of an evaluation of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Hilti VC40-U vacuum, a Hilti DC-EX shroud, and a Hilti DAG-500 grinder. Randomized trials with and without use of the dust control system were conducted in a controlled setting. Removing mortar with the Hilti grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 220 times the National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05mg/m3. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 97 percent. However, exposures measured during the use of the dust control system still exceeded the NIOSH REL. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => December 1, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/05/14 [date_completed:protected] => 02/04/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/06/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [content:protected] => [files:protected] => Array ( [559] => [560] => [546] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 546 [filename:protected] => 3.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:22 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [566] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 566 [filename:protected] => 4.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:23 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [720] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 720 [filename:protected] => 5.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [721] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 721 [filename:protected] => 6.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [722] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 722 [filename:protected] => 7.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [9765] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 9765 [filename:protected] => d001345.pdf [downloadable:protected] => T [timestamp:protected] => 2015-02-09 12:26:04 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3908 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001345 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: DustControl 2900c Vacuum with the ICS Dust Director Shroud and Bosch Grinder Model 1775E Conducted November 14-15, 2012 [total_pages:protected] => 13 [billed_pages:protected] => 13 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP2 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => tuckpointing, HEPA vacuum, dust control, LEV, local exhaust ventilation, silica [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => April 15, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 01/26/15 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/09/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [show_text] => [document_content] => ElcoshItemDocumentContent Object ( [id:protected] => 2934 [item_id:protected] => 3908 [type:protected] => main [title:protected] => [content:protected] =>
Executive Summary
This report describes the results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. It should also be noted that the NIOSH REL is based on exposures averaged over a ten hour work day and our results represent time weighted averages of the sample task duration periods.
Acronyms
ACGIH - American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists
CPWR - CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training
Ce - coefficient of entry
HEPA - high-efficiency particulate air
IUBAC - International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craftworkers
LEV - local exhaust ventilation
PACT - Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies
NIOSH - National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health
OEL - occupational exposure limit
OSHA - Occupational Safety and Health Administration
PAPR - powered air-purifying respirator
PEL - Permissible Exposure Limit
PVC - polyvinyl chloride
REL - Recommended Exposure Limit
RPM - revolutions per minute
TWA - time-weighted average
SP - static pressure
I. Introduction and Background
In 2010 CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training began a four-year project which seeks to identify and evaluate tuckpointing local exhaust ventilation (LEV) systems and disseminate information on their availability and effectiveness. A Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies (PACT) comprised of masonry contractors, representatives from unions, government, equipment manufacturers, and health and safety researcher was formed as part of this project. PACT members participated in identifying important characteristics for control technologies and this information was used to identify LEV systems for tuckpointing using that criteria. Contractor and labor members of the PACT selected specific tuckpointing LEV systems to be considered for evaluation. Each system consisted of a tuckpointing grinder, shroud, and vacuum. This report describes the second of four systems to be evaluated between 2012 the end of 2014, with and without LEV, in a controlled setting to determine effectiveness in silica exposure reduction. This report describes the methods and results of our evaluation of a system consisting of the DustControl 2900c vacuum with the ICS Dust Director shroud and a Bosch Model 1775E grinder.
Excessive exposure to respirable silica can result in silicosis or other silica-related diseases including pulmonary tuberculosis, lung cancer, silicoproteinosis (Lyons et al, 2007) and autoimmune disorders such as rheumatoid arthritis, sarcoidosis and scleroderma (Miller et al, 2012). Respirable silica is generally defined as particles less than 10 micrometers (μm) in aerodynamic diameter (ACGIH, 2013). Silicosis can lead to symptoms including shortness of breath, fatigue, chest pains, susceptibility to infection and possibly death. There is no cure for silicosis, however it is totally preventable. Construction workers exposed to dust, including silica, are also known to have higher rates of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD).
There are many sources of silica in construction that result in exposures of varying intensity among workers. Masonry restoration workers are among the most highly silica-exposed trades in construction. The process of grinding out deteriorated mortar joints between masonry units and replacing or repointing with fresh mortar (often referred to as tuckpointing) is a fundamental part of masonry restoration work. The removal of mortar with powered angle grinders generates enormous levels of dust. Between 2004 and 2006, NIOSH and CPWR evaluated silica exposures while grinding mortar in a controlled setting, at a local training center, where tasks, sample times and task variables were defined by the study design. These studies demonstrated that grinding mortar without controls can result in elevated respirable silica exposures. Meeker et al., (2009) reported exposures between 5 and 25.8 milligrams per cubic meter (mg/m3) in a controlled setting. This study also showed that LEV systems for tuckpointing grinders can reduce exposures to respirable silica by greater than 90 percent.II. Objectives
The objective of this evaluation was to assess the effectiveness of an LEV system for controlling exposure to silica during the grinding of mortar. The control technology was tested under controlled conditions, similar to those experienced by tuckpointers on actual job sites, using journeymen bricklayers experienced in tuckpointing and repeat, randomized trials with and without LEV. All other variables were held constant throughout so that the only variable was whether or not the tested control was used.
III. Description of Equipment Tested
A Bosch model 1775E grinder (Robert Bosch Tool Corporation, Prospect, IL) (Figures 1, 2 and 3) was fitted with a new 1/4-inch wide, 4½-inch diameter segmented diamond abrasive blade made by DeWalt (model #DW4740). The grinder weighs six and a half pounds, draws 8.5 amps and has a variable speed up to 11,000 revolutions per minute (RPMs). The DustControl 2900c vacuum (DustControl, Inc., Wilmington, NC) (Figure 3) was tested in combination with the Dust Director shroud (Industrial Contractors’ Supplies, Inc., Huntingdon, PA) (Figures 1 and 3) attached to the Bosch grinder.
Figure 1. Bosch grinder with Dust Director shroud
Figure 2. Bosch grinder without tuckpointing LEV system.
Figure 3: Bosch Grinder with LEV System
The vacuum is specified to weigh 31 pounds when empty and to provide a flow rate of 114 cubic feet of air per minute and a “static lift” or “vacuum suction pressure” of 84 inches of water. The vacuum is sold with a cyclonic pre-separator, to remove larger particles, a fine filter (rated 99.9 percent efficient) and a HEPA (high-efficiency particulate air) filter (rated to capture 99.97 percent of the particles with an aerodynamic diameter of 0.3 micrometers). The HEPA filter was removed based on the manufacturer’s recommendation due to the heavy dust loading associated with tuckpointing. CPWR sponsored research and contractor experience indicate that HEPA filters likely have an adverse effect on dust capture during tuckpointing because of extreme dust loading on filters. While the cyclone and the fine filter remove most of the dust, especially the large particles, before they reach the HEPA filter, the HEPA filter would still be subject to heavy loading, causing a substantial pressure drop and subsequent decrease in air flow rate. The relatively small increase in the efficiency of the filtration system while using the HEPA filter is expected to be quickly offset by a more significant decrease in capture efficiency as the air flow rate and ability to capture particles decreases.
Dust collects in relatively inexpensive, heavy-gauge plastic bags below and outside of the cyclone. The bags can be removed and replaced without opening the vacuum. Some vacuums are equipped with a light to indicate that the filters need to be cleaned or changed. The DC2900c features a “reverse air pulse cleaning system,” which removes accumulated dust from the filters without having to remove them from the vacuum. The system, as illustrated in Figure 4, requires the operator to disconnect the hose from the shroud, place it over an air stop so that air through the hose is cut off and pressure in the vacuum is maximized.
Figure 4. Procedure for "cleaning" of or dust removal from filters (source: http://dustcontrolusa.com/manuals/2800c.pdf)
The flap covering the port on the side of the vacuum is repeatedly flipped open to release built up pressure in strong pulses that dislodge dust from the filter.
The manufacturer indicates “the filter is generally cleaned once or twice daily during normal continuous operation.” The Dust Director shroud has a 2-inch diameter take-off that was connected to the antistatic, corrugated 1.5-inch diameter, 15-foot long vacuum hose supplied with the DustControl vacuum.
IV. Study Methods
This evaluation was conducted at the International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craft workers (IUBAC) Local 1 Philadelphia/Delaware Training Center in Philadelphia, PA on November 14 and 15, 2012. A single journeyman bricklayer, experienced in tuckpointing, used the grinder and LEV system being tested to remove mortar from joints wide enough to require two passes. The type S mortar had been allowed to cure for at least four weeks. The bricklayer either possessed or was provided with personal protective equipment including sturdy work boots, gloves, hearing protection and a powered air-purifying respirator (PAPR). The PAPR was a 3M GVP system with a bump cap, loose fitting face piece and a HEPA filter (3M, St Paul, MN).
The study was designed to include at least five rounds of sampling during mortar removal. Each round included a trial using the Bosch grinder with a Dust Director shroud and Dust Collector 2900c vacuum and a trial using the Bosch grinder with the factory-supplied guard and without a vacuum. The order of the two trials within each round was randomly selected to minimize bias that might be introduced due to variation associated with environmental factors, equipment operator, blade wear, vacuum performance over time and any other factors unrelated to LEV use. Tools were operated for approximately 16 minutes per trial with controls and for approximately 8 minutes when controls were not used. These times were selected based on the results of previous sampling efforts and estimates of the minimum sample time needed to achieve a limit of quantification low enough to accurately measure exposures down to or less than 0.05 mg/m3 – the NIOSH Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) for respirable silica. The bricklayer was required to take a 5 to 10 minute break in the middle of the 16-minute trials to reduce differences in fatigue, compared to the 8-minute trials. Personal air samples were collected in the breathing zone of the operator during each trial to measure respirable silica concentrations during grinding with and without LEV. The samples were collected using a GilAir-5 pump (Sensidyne, Inc., Clearwater, FL) to draw 4.2 liters of air per minute through a GK2.69 Respirable Cyclone (BGI Inc., Waltham, MA) with a pre-weighed, 37 mm diameter, 5-micron pore size polyvinyl chloride (PVC) filter positioned on the operator’s lapel.
The flow rates of the sampling pumps were calibrated at the beginning of each day using a DryCal DC-Lite Primary Flow Meter (Bios International Corporation, Butler, NJ). Flow rates were measured again near the middle and at the end of each day to ensure that sampling flow rates were maintained within 5% of pre-sampling flow rates throughout the day. Average flow rates were used to calculate sample air volumes. Samples were analyzed by R.J. Lee Group, Inc., (Monroeville, PA) using NIOSH Method 0600, to determine exposure to total mass of respirable dust. The same samples were also analyzed using X-Ray diffraction following NIOSH method 7500 to determine quartz, cristobalite and tridymite concentration in the respirable mass. Reported masses for these analytes were used with the sample air volumes to calculate airborne concentrations of total respirable dust, quartz, cristobalite and tridymite.
We used a reduction of greater than 50 percent in respirable silica exposure concentrations or a reduction to less than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 as our criteria for determining whether or not a control was considered efficacious. This is consistent with criteria used by NIOSH in conducting a similar study in 2004 described by Echt et al. (2007) and by CPWR in 2006 and described by Meeker et al. (2009). The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) and the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) publish additional occupational exposure limits (OELs) for silica which are listed in Table 1 with NIOSH RELs. OELs for silica are based on the respirable fraction of the aerosol, which consists of particles less than 10 micrometers in aerodynamic diameter.
| Organization or Agency | Form of Crystalline Silica | Occupational Exposure Limits (mg/m3) |
|---|---|---|
| NIOSHA | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 |
| OSHA - ConstructionB | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
PEL = 250 / (5 + % quartz) PEL = 250 / (5 + % cristobalite) PEL = 250 / (5 + % tridymite) |
| ACGIH | Crystalline Silica | TLV = 0.025 mg/m3 |
A NIOSH Publication No. 2005-151 indicates 10-hour time-weighted average during a 40-hr workweek B The PEL for silica in OSHA’s Safety and Health Regulations for Construction, 29 C.F.R. 1926.55(a), is an 8-hour time-weighted average (TWA) expressed in millions of particles per cubic foot (mppcf). However, the units mppcf can be converted to milligrams per cubic meter can by dividing mppcf by 10 (OSHA, 2009). The formula used by OSHA to determine the PEL for silica is dependent on the percentage of silica in each collected sample. The concentration of respirable dust measured is compared to the sample specific PEL to determine if the PEL has been exceeded. OSHA has proposed lowering the PEL to 0.05 mg/m3 of respirable silica as an 8 hour TWA. |
||
The flow of air in ventilation systems is governed by fundamental principles that describe the behavior of gases (in this case air). Pressure measurements taken within a ventilation system along with knowledge of hood (or shroud) entry losses can be used to calculate flow rates. Hood entry losses are dependent on the shape and configuration of a particular hood or shroud and described by the term “coefficient of entry (Ce)” which is the ratio of actual air flow through a hood and what the air flow would theoretically be if there were no hood entry losses. Given the coefficient of entry, static pressure measurements can be used to calculate air flow through a given hood. The coefficient of entry for the Dust Director shroud was previously determined by CPWR and used for calculating air flow based on static pressure measurements (Meeker et al., 2009). Static pressure, with the vacuum operating, was measured periodically throughout the evaluation to monitor the changes in air-flow rate following use and again after filter cleaning. The static pressure was measured at a port positioned more than 3 duct diameters downstream from the tool’s air intake using a UEi EM200 Electronic Manometer (Universal Enterprises, Inc., Beaverton, OR).
The dust in the vacuum bag was monitored and, per the manufacturer’s instructions, the bag was changed before the dust level was within 5 centimeters of the valve at the bottom of the vacuum. Each time a vacuum bag was removed, it was weighed to the nearest pound. The bag weights and corresponding grinding durations were used to calculate the average weight of dust collected per unit time. After each trial, cut lengths were measured on the wall to determine total linear feet of vertical (head) and horizontal (bed) joints per unit time.
A Haz-Dust III, Model HD-1003, Real-Time Aerosol Monitor (Environmental Devices Corporation, Plaistow, NH) was used to confirm clearance of dust between trials. The Haz-Dust monitor was positioned on the test wall near the operator at approximately breathing zone level and configured to measure respirable particulate concentration.
V. Results
Personal air monitoring
Five pairs of respirable dust samples were collected while grinding with and without the vacuum system. In addition, three respirable dust samples were collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place. One measurement collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard was shown to be a statistical outlier and was omitted from analysis. Personal air monitoring results for respirable silica and a comparison of average exposures relative to the NIOSH REL for silica (0.05 mg/m3) appears in Table 2. The mean respirable dust levels measured without LEV was 31.4 mg/m3. However, samples collected with LEV were below the limit of quantification (LOQ) which ranged from <1.29 to <1.46 mg/m3. Use of LEV resulted in a greater than 95% reduction in mean respirable dust levels using a mean value with use of LEV of <1.41 (n=5 samples with use of LEV and n=7 without use of LEV). The respirable dust samples collected during grinding without the LEV system contained an average of 24 percent silica. The mass of respirable dust in the samples collected with use of the LEV system was too low to determine the silica content.| Mean, mg/m3 (range) | Std. Dev. | Percent Reduction | Hazard RatioB | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bosch with Dust Director Shroud and DustControl 2900c Vacuum |
0.091 (<0.069 – 0.137) |
0.027 | 98.7 | 1.81 |
| Bosch with no Control | 7.23 (4.57 – 9.90) |
1.94 | NA | 145 |
A n = 5 samples for each tool/control combination and n = 7 samples without the use of the LEV system B Hazard Ratio = measured exposure / NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 |
||||
Average respirable silica and dust exposures, with and without the dust control system, appear as Figures 5 and 6, respectively.
Figure 5. Average respirable silica exposures with and without the Dustcontrol 2900c vacuum and Dust Director shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air - mg/m3)
Figure 6. Average respirable dust exposures with and without Dustcontrol 2900c Vacuum and Dust Director Shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air – mg/m3)
The mean respirable silica concentration measured during use of the control was significantly less than the concentration measured while using the same tool without controls (p<0.01). Grinding mortar with the Bosch angle grinder without dust controls resulted in an average exposure to respirable silica that was 145 times the NIOSH REL. Grinding with the Bosch angle grinder in combination with the Dust Director shroud and the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced the average concentration of respirable silica by 98.7 percent. With use of these controls, the concentration of respirable silica was 1.8 times greater than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3. However the NIOSH REL is based on a time-weighted average (TWA) over a 10-hour workday. Given these were task TWAs and samples were collected over continuous periods of grinding, they may overestimate exposures over an actual work day since some time would be spent performing tasks that would likely have lower, or no, silica exposures (setup, breaks, cleanup, etc.).
Static pressure, dust mass collection and grinding rates.
Static pressure was used as a surrogate for air flow as described earlier. Hood static pressure was measured periodically at a tap near the grinder more than 3 duct diameters from the air intake in the shroud. The static pressure, and thus air flow, was generally higher when the vacuum’s filter had recently been cleaned. The mean, median, and range of calculated flow rates are presented in Table A1 of the Appendix.
Based on the data we collected, the air-flow rate upstream from the Bosch grinder and Dust Director shroud ranged from 78 to 93 cubic feet per minute (cfm) with the DustControl vacuum. When the manufacturer’s filter cleaning procedure was followed the vacuum performed relatively well and flow could be maintained at slightly less than 90 cfm with cleaning. However, mean flow rates dropped substantially to 80 cfm after as little as 8 minutes of grinding without any filter cleaning. The flow rate returned to an average of 89 cfm when filters were cleaned correctly (without stopping air flow to the vacuum). Collingwood and Heitbrink (2007) found that the minimum exhaust flow rate for capture of silica and other particulate under ideal conditions is 21.25 cfm per inch of grinder blade diameter. This is equal to about 96 cfm when using a 4.5 inch diameter grinding blade. We set 106 cfm as the minimum desired flow rate for this study to allow a safety margin for potential decline in equipment performance and the possibility of inadequate maintenance, both of which may be likely after repeated use under actual work conditions. The DustControl vacuum provided slightly less than the minimum flow rate described by Collingwood and Heitbrink for a 4.5-inch blade and the peak flow rate fell with use.
The duration of vacuum bag use and mass of dust collected were recorded and are presented in Table A2 of the Appendix. The vacuum bags were changed and weighed after each trial utilizing the LEV system. A total of five bags were used to complete the five rounds of grinding. The DustControl vacuum captured 45 pounds of dust over 83 minutes of grinding for an average rate of dust collection of 0.54 pounds per minute. The rate of dust collection ranged from 0.47 to 0.63 pounds per minute. Based on these measurements, approximately 130 pounds of dust would likely be captured after just 4 hours of continuous grinding.
The rate of grinding a combination of vertical and horizontal joints while using the LEV system ranged from 2.3 to 3.3 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the use of the LEV system ranged from 2.6 to 3.4 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place ranged from 4.7 to 5.1 feet per minute. It’s important to note that: 1) the operator had limited experience using dust control systems and cut rates appeared to improve slightly over the 2-day period he used the tested equipment; and 2) the upper range of cut rates with the dust control system overlapped with the lowest cut rate with the original guard and without the LEV system in place indicating no statistical difference between cut rates. Given that grinding rates with and without use of this LEV system are only available for one operator and he had limited experience with the LEV system, these reported cut rates are in no way intended to represent the impact use of this LEV system is likely to have on productivity rates overall.
VI. Discussion
The objective of these trials was to evaluate the effectiveness of a tuckpointing LEV system for controlling respirable silica while grinding out mortar joints. The Dust Director shroud with the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced respirable silica concentrations when grinding with the Bosch grinder by approximately 99 percent. Despite being considered effective by our test criteria (greater than 50% reduction), it still resulted in task TWA exposures that exceeded the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 by 1.8 times. Depending on how much time is spent grinding over the course of a work day and on exposures while performing other tasks, the 8-hour TWA exposures may or may not exceed the REL with this system. Use of this system by workers with experience and training in proficient use will likely improve dust capture performance. Exposure reduction is greatly influenced by correct use of this system which includes grinding from right to left, making sure the shroud is held flush against the wall and that the tool travels at a pace that doesn’t exceed the ability of the system to capture dust as it’s generated. Deviation from any of these measures produces visible dust clouds which were observed during trials.
VII. Conclusions
With a 99 percent reduction in respirable silica exposure, the Dust Director shroud and DustControl 2900c vacuum with a Bosch Model 1775E grinder was effective in reducing silica exposures based on our criteria. Use of the tested dust control system may be effective in reducing silica exposure on the job to less than the NIOSH REL if used in combination with administrative controls such as work scheduling to reduce cutting times as needed. Training on correct use of the tested system is also essential. Personal air monitoring is necessary to verify control effectiveness on actual job sites and under “real-world” conditions. However, these results clearly demonstrate the availability of viable and effective engineering controls for tuckpointing operations associated with elevated silica exposure.
VIII. References
American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists. Threshold limit values for chemical substances (TLV®-CS). [2013]. ACGIH, Cincinnati, Ohio.
Bergdahl I.A,. Toren K., Eriksson K., et al. [2004]. Increased mortality in COPD among construction workers exposed to inorganic dust. European Respiratory Journal, 23: 402–06.
Blanc P.D. & Torén K. [2007]. Occupation in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and chronic bronchitis: an update [State of the Art Series. Occupational lung disease in high-and low-income countries, Edited by M. Chan-Yeung. Number 2 in the series]. The International Journal of Tuberculosis and Lung Disease, 11(3), 251-257.
Collingwood S. & Heitbrink W.A. [2007] 'Field Evaluation of an Engineering Control for Respirable Crystalline Silica Exposures During Mortar Removal'. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, 4:11, 875 – 887.
DHHS (NIOSH) Publication No. 2002-129 April 2002 http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/2002-129/
Echt A., Sieber W.K., Lefkowitz D., Meeker J., Susi P., Cardwell B., Heitbrink, W.A. In-depth survey of dust control technology for cutting concrete block and tuckpointing brick at The International Masonry Institute Bordentown Training Center, Bordentown, NJ. Cincinnati, OH: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Report. No. EPHB 282-13; 2007. http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ECTB-282-13.pdf
Heitbrink W., Bennett J. [2006]. A numerical and experimental investigation of crystalline silica exposure control during tuck pointing. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, Vol. 3, pp 366-378.
Lyons et al, [2007]. A breathless builder. Breathe, Vol. 3, no. 4, pp 386-390.
Mastrangelo G., Tartari M., Fedeli U., Fadda E., Saia B. [2003]. Ascertaining the risk of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease in relation to occupation using a case-control design. Occupational Medicine, 53: 165–172.
Meeker J., Cooper M., Lefrowitz D., Susi P. [2009]. Engineering control technologies to reduce occupational silica exposures in masonry cutting and tuckpointing. Public Health Reports, Supplement 1, Vol. 124, June.
Meeker J, Flynn M, Susi P, Cardwell, B [2004]. Performance evaluation of a masonry concrete vacuum. Unpublished Report.
Miller F. W., Alfredsson L., Costenbader K. H., Kamen D. L., Nelson L. M., Norris J. M., & De Roos A. J. [2012]. Epidemiology of environmental exposures and human autoimmune diseases: findings from a National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences Expert Panel workshop. Journal of autoimmunity. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3496812/
Occupational Safety and Health Administration U.S Department of Labor. Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction. [2009]. OSHA 3362-05.
Rappaport SM, Goldberg M, Susi P, Herrick RF [2003]. Excessive exposure to silica in the U.S. construction industry. Annals of Occupational Hygiene, Vol. 47, pp. 111-122.
IX. Appendices
| Measurement Conditions |
n | Mean Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Median
Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before filter cleaning | 5 | 80 | 81 | 78-81 |
| After filter cleaning following manufacturer directions | 9 | 89 | 90 | 84-93 |
| * Static pressure was measured in millibars and converted to inches of water gauge. Flow rates were calculated using the formula Q = Ce (A) 4005 (SP)1/2 where: Q = flow in cubic feet per minute (cfm), Ce = coefficient of entry, A = area of the duct where static pressure measurements were taken in square feet, and SP = static pressure in inches of water gauge. | ||||
| Tool/Control | Collection Period (min.) |
Dust Collection Rate (lb/min.) |
|---|---|---|
| Bosch grinder/Dust Director shroud & DustControl 2900c vacuum |
8 11 8 8 10 |
0.50 0.61 0.50 0.47 0.63 |
| Average | 0.54 |
[content_transformed:protected] =>
Executive Summary
This report describes the results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. It should also be noted that the NIOSH REL is based on exposures averaged over a ten hour work day and our results represent time weighted averages of the sample task duration periods.
Acronyms
ACGIH - American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists
CPWR - CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training
Ce - coefficient of entry
HEPA - high-efficiency particulate air
IUBAC - International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craftworkers
LEV - local exhaust ventilation
PACT - Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies
NIOSH - National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health
OEL - occupational exposure limit
OSHA - Occupational Safety and Health Administration
PAPR - powered air-purifying respirator
PEL - Permissible Exposure Limit
PVC - polyvinyl chloride
REL - Recommended Exposure Limit
RPM - revolutions per minute
TWA - time-weighted average
SP - static pressure
I. Introduction and Background
In 2010 CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training began a four-year project which seeks to identify and evaluate tuckpointing local exhaust ventilation (LEV) systems and disseminate information on their availability and effectiveness. A Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies (PACT) comprised of masonry contractors, representatives from unions, government, equipment manufacturers, and health and safety researcher was formed as part of this project. PACT members participated in identifying important characteristics for control technologies and this information was used to identify LEV systems for tuckpointing using that criteria. Contractor and labor members of the PACT selected specific tuckpointing LEV systems to be considered for evaluation. Each system consisted of a tuckpointing grinder, shroud, and vacuum. This report describes the second of four systems to be evaluated between 2012 the end of 2014, with and without LEV, in a controlled setting to determine effectiveness in silica exposure reduction. This report describes the methods and results of our evaluation of a system consisting of the DustControl 2900c vacuum with the ICS Dust Director shroud and a Bosch Model 1775E grinder.
Excessive exposure to respirable silica can result in silicosis or other silica-related diseases including pulmonary tuberculosis, lung cancer, silicoproteinosis (Lyons et al, 2007) and autoimmune disorders such as rheumatoid arthritis, sarcoidosis and scleroderma (Miller et al, 2012). Respirable silica is generally defined as particles less than 10 micrometers (μm) in aerodynamic diameter (ACGIH, 2013). Silicosis can lead to symptoms including shortness of breath, fatigue, chest pains, susceptibility to infection and possibly death. There is no cure for silicosis, however it is totally preventable. Construction workers exposed to dust, including silica, are also known to have higher rates of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD).
There are many sources of silica in construction that result in exposures of varying intensity among workers. Masonry restoration workers are among the most highly silica-exposed trades in construction. The process of grinding out deteriorated mortar joints between masonry units and replacing or repointing with fresh mortar (often referred to as tuckpointing) is a fundamental part of masonry restoration work. The removal of mortar with powered angle grinders generates enormous levels of dust. Between 2004 and 2006, NIOSH and CPWR evaluated silica exposures while grinding mortar in a controlled setting, at a local training center, where tasks, sample times and task variables were defined by the study design. These studies demonstrated that grinding mortar without controls can result in elevated respirable silica exposures. Meeker et al., (2009) reported exposures between 5 and 25.8 milligrams per cubic meter (mg/m3) in a controlled setting. This study also showed that LEV systems for tuckpointing grinders can reduce exposures to respirable silica by greater than 90 percent.II. Objectives
The objective of this evaluation was to assess the effectiveness of an LEV system for controlling exposure to silica during the grinding of mortar. The control technology was tested under controlled conditions, similar to those experienced by tuckpointers on actual job sites, using journeymen bricklayers experienced in tuckpointing and repeat, randomized trials with and without LEV. All other variables were held constant throughout so that the only variable was whether or not the tested control was used.
III. Description of Equipment Tested
A Bosch model 1775E grinder (Robert Bosch Tool Corporation, Prospect, IL) (Figures 1, 2 and 3) was fitted with a new 1/4-inch wide, 4½-inch diameter segmented diamond abrasive blade made by DeWalt (model #DW4740). The grinder weighs six and a half pounds, draws 8.5 amps and has a variable speed up to 11,000 revolutions per minute (RPMs). The DustControl 2900c vacuum (DustControl, Inc., Wilmington, NC) (Figure 3) was tested in combination with the Dust Director shroud (Industrial Contractors’ Supplies, Inc., Huntingdon, PA) (Figures 1 and 3) attached to the Bosch grinder.
Figure 1. Bosch grinder with Dust Director shroud
Figure 2. Bosch grinder without tuckpointing LEV system.
Figure 3: Bosch Grinder with LEV System
The vacuum is specified to weigh 31 pounds when empty and to provide a flow rate of 114 cubic feet of air per minute and a “static lift” or “vacuum suction pressure” of 84 inches of water. The vacuum is sold with a cyclonic pre-separator, to remove larger particles, a fine filter (rated 99.9 percent efficient) and a HEPA (high-efficiency particulate air) filter (rated to capture 99.97 percent of the particles with an aerodynamic diameter of 0.3 micrometers). The HEPA filter was removed based on the manufacturer’s recommendation due to the heavy dust loading associated with tuckpointing. CPWR sponsored research and contractor experience indicate that HEPA filters likely have an adverse effect on dust capture during tuckpointing because of extreme dust loading on filters. While the cyclone and the fine filter remove most of the dust, especially the large particles, before they reach the HEPA filter, the HEPA filter would still be subject to heavy loading, causing a substantial pressure drop and subsequent decrease in air flow rate. The relatively small increase in the efficiency of the filtration system while using the HEPA filter is expected to be quickly offset by a more significant decrease in capture efficiency as the air flow rate and ability to capture particles decreases.
Dust collects in relatively inexpensive, heavy-gauge plastic bags below and outside of the cyclone. The bags can be removed and replaced without opening the vacuum. Some vacuums are equipped with a light to indicate that the filters need to be cleaned or changed. The DC2900c features a “reverse air pulse cleaning system,” which removes accumulated dust from the filters without having to remove them from the vacuum. The system, as illustrated in Figure 4, requires the operator to disconnect the hose from the shroud, place it over an air stop so that air through the hose is cut off and pressure in the vacuum is maximized.
Figure 4. Procedure for "cleaning" of or dust removal from filters (source: http://dustcontrolusa.com/manuals/2800c.pdf)
The flap covering the port on the side of the vacuum is repeatedly flipped open to release built up pressure in strong pulses that dislodge dust from the filter.
The manufacturer indicates “the filter is generally cleaned once or twice daily during normal continuous operation.” The Dust Director shroud has a 2-inch diameter take-off that was connected to the antistatic, corrugated 1.5-inch diameter, 15-foot long vacuum hose supplied with the DustControl vacuum.
IV. Study Methods
This evaluation was conducted at the International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craft workers (IUBAC) Local 1 Philadelphia/Delaware Training Center in Philadelphia, PA on November 14 and 15, 2012. A single journeyman bricklayer, experienced in tuckpointing, used the grinder and LEV system being tested to remove mortar from joints wide enough to require two passes. The type S mortar had been allowed to cure for at least four weeks. The bricklayer either possessed or was provided with personal protective equipment including sturdy work boots, gloves, hearing protection and a powered air-purifying respirator (PAPR). The PAPR was a 3M GVP system with a bump cap, loose fitting face piece and a HEPA filter (3M, St Paul, MN).
The study was designed to include at least five rounds of sampling during mortar removal. Each round included a trial using the Bosch grinder with a Dust Director shroud and Dust Collector 2900c vacuum and a trial using the Bosch grinder with the factory-supplied guard and without a vacuum. The order of the two trials within each round was randomly selected to minimize bias that might be introduced due to variation associated with environmental factors, equipment operator, blade wear, vacuum performance over time and any other factors unrelated to LEV use. Tools were operated for approximately 16 minutes per trial with controls and for approximately 8 minutes when controls were not used. These times were selected based on the results of previous sampling efforts and estimates of the minimum sample time needed to achieve a limit of quantification low enough to accurately measure exposures down to or less than 0.05 mg/m3 – the NIOSH Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) for respirable silica. The bricklayer was required to take a 5 to 10 minute break in the middle of the 16-minute trials to reduce differences in fatigue, compared to the 8-minute trials. Personal air samples were collected in the breathing zone of the operator during each trial to measure respirable silica concentrations during grinding with and without LEV. The samples were collected using a GilAir-5 pump (Sensidyne, Inc., Clearwater, FL) to draw 4.2 liters of air per minute through a GK2.69 Respirable Cyclone (BGI Inc., Waltham, MA) with a pre-weighed, 37 mm diameter, 5-micron pore size polyvinyl chloride (PVC) filter positioned on the operator’s lapel.
The flow rates of the sampling pumps were calibrated at the beginning of each day using a DryCal DC-Lite Primary Flow Meter (Bios International Corporation, Butler, NJ). Flow rates were measured again near the middle and at the end of each day to ensure that sampling flow rates were maintained within 5% of pre-sampling flow rates throughout the day. Average flow rates were used to calculate sample air volumes. Samples were analyzed by R.J. Lee Group, Inc., (Monroeville, PA) using NIOSH Method 0600, to determine exposure to total mass of respirable dust. The same samples were also analyzed using X-Ray diffraction following NIOSH method 7500 to determine quartz, cristobalite and tridymite concentration in the respirable mass. Reported masses for these analytes were used with the sample air volumes to calculate airborne concentrations of total respirable dust, quartz, cristobalite and tridymite.
We used a reduction of greater than 50 percent in respirable silica exposure concentrations or a reduction to less than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 as our criteria for determining whether or not a control was considered efficacious. This is consistent with criteria used by NIOSH in conducting a similar study in 2004 described by Echt et al. (2007) and by CPWR in 2006 and described by Meeker et al. (2009). The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) and the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) publish additional occupational exposure limits (OELs) for silica which are listed in Table 1 with NIOSH RELs. OELs for silica are based on the respirable fraction of the aerosol, which consists of particles less than 10 micrometers in aerodynamic diameter.
| Organization or Agency | Form of Crystalline Silica | Occupational Exposure Limits (mg/m3) |
|---|---|---|
| NIOSHA | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 |
| OSHA - ConstructionB | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
PEL = 250 / (5 + % quartz) PEL = 250 / (5 + % cristobalite) PEL = 250 / (5 + % tridymite) |
| ACGIH | Crystalline Silica | TLV = 0.025 mg/m3 |
A NIOSH Publication No. 2005-151 indicates 10-hour time-weighted average during a 40-hr workweek B The PEL for silica in OSHA’s Safety and Health Regulations for Construction, 29 C.F.R. 1926.55(a), is an 8-hour time-weighted average (TWA) expressed in millions of particles per cubic foot (mppcf). However, the units mppcf can be converted to milligrams per cubic meter can by dividing mppcf by 10 (OSHA, 2009). The formula used by OSHA to determine the PEL for silica is dependent on the percentage of silica in each collected sample. The concentration of respirable dust measured is compared to the sample specific PEL to determine if the PEL has been exceeded. OSHA has proposed lowering the PEL to 0.05 mg/m3 of respirable silica as an 8 hour TWA. |
||
The flow of air in ventilation systems is governed by fundamental principles that describe the behavior of gases (in this case air). Pressure measurements taken within a ventilation system along with knowledge of hood (or shroud) entry losses can be used to calculate flow rates. Hood entry losses are dependent on the shape and configuration of a particular hood or shroud and described by the term “coefficient of entry (Ce)” which is the ratio of actual air flow through a hood and what the air flow would theoretically be if there were no hood entry losses. Given the coefficient of entry, static pressure measurements can be used to calculate air flow through a given hood. The coefficient of entry for the Dust Director shroud was previously determined by CPWR and used for calculating air flow based on static pressure measurements (Meeker et al., 2009). Static pressure, with the vacuum operating, was measured periodically throughout the evaluation to monitor the changes in air-flow rate following use and again after filter cleaning. The static pressure was measured at a port positioned more than 3 duct diameters downstream from the tool’s air intake using a UEi EM200 Electronic Manometer (Universal Enterprises, Inc., Beaverton, OR).
The dust in the vacuum bag was monitored and, per the manufacturer’s instructions, the bag was changed before the dust level was within 5 centimeters of the valve at the bottom of the vacuum. Each time a vacuum bag was removed, it was weighed to the nearest pound. The bag weights and corresponding grinding durations were used to calculate the average weight of dust collected per unit time. After each trial, cut lengths were measured on the wall to determine total linear feet of vertical (head) and horizontal (bed) joints per unit time.
A Haz-Dust III, Model HD-1003, Real-Time Aerosol Monitor (Environmental Devices Corporation, Plaistow, NH) was used to confirm clearance of dust between trials. The Haz-Dust monitor was positioned on the test wall near the operator at approximately breathing zone level and configured to measure respirable particulate concentration.
V. Results
Personal air monitoring
Five pairs of respirable dust samples were collected while grinding with and without the vacuum system. In addition, three respirable dust samples were collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place. One measurement collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard was shown to be a statistical outlier and was omitted from analysis. Personal air monitoring results for respirable silica and a comparison of average exposures relative to the NIOSH REL for silica (0.05 mg/m3) appears in Table 2. The mean respirable dust levels measured without LEV was 31.4 mg/m3. However, samples collected with LEV were below the limit of quantification (LOQ) which ranged from <1.29 to <1.46 mg/m3. Use of LEV resulted in a greater than 95% reduction in mean respirable dust levels using a mean value with use of LEV of <1.41 (n=5 samples with use of LEV and n=7 without use of LEV). The respirable dust samples collected during grinding without the LEV system contained an average of 24 percent silica. The mass of respirable dust in the samples collected with use of the LEV system was too low to determine the silica content.| Mean, mg/m3 (range) | Std. Dev. | Percent Reduction | Hazard RatioB | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bosch with Dust Director Shroud and DustControl 2900c Vacuum |
0.091 (<0.069 – 0.137) |
0.027 | 98.7 | 1.81 |
| Bosch with no Control | 7.23 (4.57 – 9.90) |
1.94 | NA | 145 |
A n = 5 samples for each tool/control combination and n = 7 samples without the use of the LEV system B Hazard Ratio = measured exposure / NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 |
||||
Average respirable silica and dust exposures, with and without the dust control system, appear as Figures 5 and 6, respectively.
Figure 5. Average respirable silica exposures with and without the Dustcontrol 2900c vacuum and Dust Director shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air - mg/m3)
Figure 6. Average respirable dust exposures with and without Dustcontrol 2900c Vacuum and Dust Director Shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air – mg/m3)
The mean respirable silica concentration measured during use of the control was significantly less than the concentration measured while using the same tool without controls (p<0.01). Grinding mortar with the Bosch angle grinder without dust controls resulted in an average exposure to respirable silica that was 145 times the NIOSH REL. Grinding with the Bosch angle grinder in combination with the Dust Director shroud and the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced the average concentration of respirable silica by 98.7 percent. With use of these controls, the concentration of respirable silica was 1.8 times greater than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3. However the NIOSH REL is based on a time-weighted average (TWA) over a 10-hour workday. Given these were task TWAs and samples were collected over continuous periods of grinding, they may overestimate exposures over an actual work day since some time would be spent performing tasks that would likely have lower, or no, silica exposures (setup, breaks, cleanup, etc.).
Static pressure, dust mass collection and grinding rates.
Static pressure was used as a surrogate for air flow as described earlier. Hood static pressure was measured periodically at a tap near the grinder more than 3 duct diameters from the air intake in the shroud. The static pressure, and thus air flow, was generally higher when the vacuum’s filter had recently been cleaned. The mean, median, and range of calculated flow rates are presented in Table A1 of the Appendix.
Based on the data we collected, the air-flow rate upstream from the Bosch grinder and Dust Director shroud ranged from 78 to 93 cubic feet per minute (cfm) with the DustControl vacuum. When the manufacturer’s filter cleaning procedure was followed the vacuum performed relatively well and flow could be maintained at slightly less than 90 cfm with cleaning. However, mean flow rates dropped substantially to 80 cfm after as little as 8 minutes of grinding without any filter cleaning. The flow rate returned to an average of 89 cfm when filters were cleaned correctly (without stopping air flow to the vacuum). Collingwood and Heitbrink (2007) found that the minimum exhaust flow rate for capture of silica and other particulate under ideal conditions is 21.25 cfm per inch of grinder blade diameter. This is equal to about 96 cfm when using a 4.5 inch diameter grinding blade. We set 106 cfm as the minimum desired flow rate for this study to allow a safety margin for potential decline in equipment performance and the possibility of inadequate maintenance, both of which may be likely after repeated use under actual work conditions. The DustControl vacuum provided slightly less than the minimum flow rate described by Collingwood and Heitbrink for a 4.5-inch blade and the peak flow rate fell with use.
The duration of vacuum bag use and mass of dust collected were recorded and are presented in Table A2 of the Appendix. The vacuum bags were changed and weighed after each trial utilizing the LEV system. A total of five bags were used to complete the five rounds of grinding. The DustControl vacuum captured 45 pounds of dust over 83 minutes of grinding for an average rate of dust collection of 0.54 pounds per minute. The rate of dust collection ranged from 0.47 to 0.63 pounds per minute. Based on these measurements, approximately 130 pounds of dust would likely be captured after just 4 hours of continuous grinding.
The rate of grinding a combination of vertical and horizontal joints while using the LEV system ranged from 2.3 to 3.3 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the use of the LEV system ranged from 2.6 to 3.4 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place ranged from 4.7 to 5.1 feet per minute. It’s important to note that: 1) the operator had limited experience using dust control systems and cut rates appeared to improve slightly over the 2-day period he used the tested equipment; and 2) the upper range of cut rates with the dust control system overlapped with the lowest cut rate with the original guard and without the LEV system in place indicating no statistical difference between cut rates. Given that grinding rates with and without use of this LEV system are only available for one operator and he had limited experience with the LEV system, these reported cut rates are in no way intended to represent the impact use of this LEV system is likely to have on productivity rates overall.
VI. Discussion
The objective of these trials was to evaluate the effectiveness of a tuckpointing LEV system for controlling respirable silica while grinding out mortar joints. The Dust Director shroud with the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced respirable silica concentrations when grinding with the Bosch grinder by approximately 99 percent. Despite being considered effective by our test criteria (greater than 50% reduction), it still resulted in task TWA exposures that exceeded the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 by 1.8 times. Depending on how much time is spent grinding over the course of a work day and on exposures while performing other tasks, the 8-hour TWA exposures may or may not exceed the REL with this system. Use of this system by workers with experience and training in proficient use will likely improve dust capture performance. Exposure reduction is greatly influenced by correct use of this system which includes grinding from right to left, making sure the shroud is held flush against the wall and that the tool travels at a pace that doesn’t exceed the ability of the system to capture dust as it’s generated. Deviation from any of these measures produces visible dust clouds which were observed during trials.
VII. Conclusions
With a 99 percent reduction in respirable silica exposure, the Dust Director shroud and DustControl 2900c vacuum with a Bosch Model 1775E grinder was effective in reducing silica exposures based on our criteria. Use of the tested dust control system may be effective in reducing silica exposure on the job to less than the NIOSH REL if used in combination with administrative controls such as work scheduling to reduce cutting times as needed. Training on correct use of the tested system is also essential. Personal air monitoring is necessary to verify control effectiveness on actual job sites and under “real-world” conditions. However, these results clearly demonstrate the availability of viable and effective engineering controls for tuckpointing operations associated with elevated silica exposure.
VIII. References
American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists. Threshold limit values for chemical substances (TLV®-CS). [2013]. ACGIH, Cincinnati, Ohio.
Bergdahl I.A,. Toren K., Eriksson K., et al. [2004]. Increased mortality in COPD among construction workers exposed to inorganic dust. European Respiratory Journal, 23: 402–06.
Blanc P.D. & Torén K. [2007]. Occupation in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and chronic bronchitis: an update [State of the Art Series. Occupational lung disease in high-and low-income countries, Edited by M. Chan-Yeung. Number 2 in the series]. The International Journal of Tuberculosis and Lung Disease, 11(3), 251-257.
Collingwood S. & Heitbrink W.A. [2007] 'Field Evaluation of an Engineering Control for Respirable Crystalline Silica Exposures During Mortar Removal'. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, 4:11, 875 – 887.
DHHS (NIOSH) Publication No. 2002-129 April 2002 http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/2002-129/
Echt A., Sieber W.K., Lefkowitz D., Meeker J., Susi P., Cardwell B., Heitbrink, W.A. In-depth survey of dust control technology for cutting concrete block and tuckpointing brick at The International Masonry Institute Bordentown Training Center, Bordentown, NJ. Cincinnati, OH: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Report. No. EPHB 282-13; 2007. http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ECTB-282-13.pdf
Heitbrink W., Bennett J. [2006]. A numerical and experimental investigation of crystalline silica exposure control during tuck pointing. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, Vol. 3, pp 366-378.
Lyons et al, [2007]. A breathless builder. Breathe, Vol. 3, no. 4, pp 386-390.
Mastrangelo G., Tartari M., Fedeli U., Fadda E., Saia B. [2003]. Ascertaining the risk of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease in relation to occupation using a case-control design. Occupational Medicine, 53: 165–172.
Meeker J., Cooper M., Lefrowitz D., Susi P. [2009]. Engineering control technologies to reduce occupational silica exposures in masonry cutting and tuckpointing. Public Health Reports, Supplement 1, Vol. 124, June.
Meeker J, Flynn M, Susi P, Cardwell, B [2004]. Performance evaluation of a masonry concrete vacuum. Unpublished Report.
Miller F. W., Alfredsson L., Costenbader K. H., Kamen D. L., Nelson L. M., Norris J. M., & De Roos A. J. [2012]. Epidemiology of environmental exposures and human autoimmune diseases: findings from a National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences Expert Panel workshop. Journal of autoimmunity. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3496812/
Occupational Safety and Health Administration U.S Department of Labor. Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction. [2009]. OSHA 3362-05.
Rappaport SM, Goldberg M, Susi P, Herrick RF [2003]. Excessive exposure to silica in the U.S. construction industry. Annals of Occupational Hygiene, Vol. 47, pp. 111-122.
IX. Appendices
| Measurement Conditions |
n | Mean Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Median
Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before filter cleaning | 5 | 80 | 81 | 78-81 |
| After filter cleaning following manufacturer directions | 9 | 89 | 90 | 84-93 |
| * Static pressure was measured in millibars and converted to inches of water gauge. Flow rates were calculated using the formula Q = Ce (A) 4005 (SP)1/2 where: Q = flow in cubic feet per minute (cfm), Ce = coefficient of entry, A = area of the duct where static pressure measurements were taken in square feet, and SP = static pressure in inches of water gauge. | ||||
| Tool/Control | Collection Period (min.) |
Dust Collection Rate (lb/min.) |
|---|---|---|
| Bosch grinder/Dust Director shroud & DustControl 2900c vacuum |
8 11 8 8 10 |
0.50 0.61 0.50 0.47 0.63 |
| Average | 0.54 |
[disclaimer:protected] => [disclaimer_transformed:protected] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [template] => record ) [_file] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/templates/elcosh/record.html [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_encoding:protected] => UTF-8 [_outputMode:protected] => 11 [_forceReparse:protected] => [_phpCodeDestination:protected] => /tmp/ [_phpCodeExtension:protected] => php [_cacheLifetime:protected] => 30 [_cachePurgeFrequency:protected] => 30 [externalMacroTemplatesCache:PHPTAL:private] => Array ( [macros.html] => PHPTAL Object ( [_prefilters:protected] => Array ( ) [_prefilter:PHPTAL:private] => REMOVED: DO NOT USE [_postfilter:protected] => [_repositories:protected] => Array ( [0] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/templates/elcosh ) [_path:protected] => macros.html [_resolvers:protected] => Array ( ) [_source:protected] => PHPTAL_FileSource Object ( [_path:PHPTAL_FileSource:private] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/templates/elcosh/macros.html ) [_codeFile:protected] => /tmp/tpl_61515a6c_macros__EnKHR8AWVA3oW7OmomvoZw.php [_functionName:protected] => tpl_61515a6c_macros__EnKHR8AWVA3oW7OmomvoZw [_prepared:protected] => 1 [_triggers:protected] => Array ( ) [_translator:protected] => [_globalContext:protected] => stdClass Object ( ) [_context:protected] => PHPTAL_Context Object ( [_line] => [_file] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/templates/elcosh/record.html [repeat] => stdClass Object ( ) [_xmlDeclaration] => [_docType] => [_nothrow:PHPTAL_Context:private] => [_slots:PHPTAL_Context:private] => Array ( ) [_slotsStack:PHPTAL_Context:private] => Array ( [0] => Array ( ) [1] => Array ( ) ) [_parentContext:PHPTAL_Context:private] => PHPTAL_Context Object ( [_line] => [_file] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/templates/elcosh/record.html [repeat] => stdClass Object ( ) [_xmlDeclaration] => [_docType] => [_nothrow:PHPTAL_Context:private] => [_slots:PHPTAL_Context:private] => Array ( ) [_slotsStack:PHPTAL_Context:private] => Array ( [0] => Array ( ) [1] => Array ( ) ) [_parentContext:PHPTAL_Context:private] => [_globalContext:PHPTAL_Context:private] => stdClass Object ( ) [_echoDeclarations:PHPTAL_Context:private] => [referer] => http://www.elcosh.org/document/3908/d001345/An%2BEvaluation%2Bof%2BSilica%2BExposure%2BControls%2Bfor%2BTuckpointing%253A%2BDustControl%2B2900c%2BVacuum%2Bwith%2Bthe%2BICS%2BDust%2BDirector%2BShroud%2Band%2BBosch%2BGrinder%2BModel%2B1775E%2BConducted%2BNovember%2B14-15%252C%2B2012.html [curr_module] => Record [styles] => Array ( ) [javascript] => Array ( [0] => jquery.min.js ) [metas] => Array ( [language] => en [robots] => index, follow ) [user] => [curr_url] => https://www.elcosh.org/index.php?module=Record&id=3908&type=document [base_url] => https://www.elcosh.org/index.php?module=Record [title] => eLCOSH : An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: DustControl 2900c Vacuum with the ICS Dust Director Shroud and Bosch Grinder Model 1775E Conducted November 14-15, 2012 [language] => en [search_query] => [module] => Record [new_records] => Array ( [0] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Fixed Ladder [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Fixed Ladders addresses the potential risks associated with using fixed ladders. The resource includes a brief case example,... [category] => Array ( [0] => 15 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 53 [5] => 55 [6] => 60 [7] => 64 [8] => 73 [9] => 76 [10] => 78 [11] => 80 [12] => 86 [13] => 87 [14] => 90 [15] => 92 [16] => 93 [17] => 94 [18] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Falls [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Concrete Polisher [11] => Electrical Worker [13] => HVAC [15] => Laborer [17] => PCC/Restoration [19] => Plumber/Pipefitter [21] => Roofer/Waterproofer [23] => Sheetmetal Worker [25] => Welder [27] => Commercial & Institutional [28] => Jobsites [29] => Industrial [31] => LEED/Green Construction [33] => Renovations [35] => Residential [37] => Toolbox Talks [38] => Documents [39] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4430/d001660/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BFixed%2BLadder.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [53] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 53 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Concrete Polisher [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [73] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 73 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => PCC/Restoration [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4430 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001660 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Fixed Ladder [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Fixed Ladders, Fall Prevention, Falls [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Fixed Ladders addresses the potential risks associated with using fixed ladders. The resource includes a brief case example, steps to prevent a related injury and questions for discussion. It includes an image that illustrates the hazard, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001257,d001254,d001255,d001256,d001258,d001262,d001279 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_completed:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/22/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [1] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Challenges Preventing Falling Objects [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Challenges Preventing Falling Objects addresses the hazards of being struck by falling objects on the job site. The resource... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 55 [5] => 64 [6] => 68 [7] => 71 [8] => 75 [9] => 78 [10] => 79 [11] => 82 [12] => 62 [13] => 86 [14] => 87 [15] => 88 [16] => 89 [17] => 91 [18] => 90 [19] => 92 [20] => 93 [21] => 94 [22] => 95 [23] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Electrical Worker [11] => Laborer [13] => Maintenance Worker [15] => Painter [17] => Plasterer [19] => Roofer/Waterproofer [21] => Scaffold Erector [23] => Stonemason [25] => Structural Ironworker [27] => Welder [29] => Commercial & Institutional [30] => Jobsites [31] => Demolition [33] => Disasters [35] => Heavy & Highway [37] => Industrial [39] => LEED/Green Construction [41] => Renovations [43] => Residential [45] => Underground [47] => Toolbox Talks [48] => Documents [49] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4431/d001661/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BChallenges%2BPreventing%2BFalling%2BObjects.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4431 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001661 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Challenges Preventing Falling Objects [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => dropped objects, falling objects, struck by incidents, struck by fatalities [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Challenges Preventing Falling Objects addresses the hazards of being struck by falling objects on the job site. The resource includes a brief example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates a group workers observing a scaffold free of debris during high winds, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001234,d001238,d001244,d001251,d001253,d001260,d001268,d001278 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_completed:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/22/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [2] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Tower Crane Safety [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Tower Crane Safety addresses the potential hazards of Tower Cranes and the importance of following procedure before and durin... [category] => Array ( [0] => 11 [1] => 12 [2] => 18 [3] => 70 [4] => 87 [5] => 88 [6] => 91 [7] => 90 [8] => 92 [9] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Cranes & Hoists [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Crushed/Struck By [6] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [9] => Operating Engineer [10] => Trades [11] => Commercial & Institutional [12] => Jobsites [13] => Demolition [15] => Heavy & Highway [17] => Industrial [19] => LEED/Green Construction [21] => Toolbox Talks [22] => Documents [23] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4427/d001657/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BTower%2BCrane%2BSafety.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [11] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 11 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Cranes & Hoists [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [18] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 18 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4427 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001657 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Tower Crane Safety [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Tower Crane, Crane, Stability, Tipping, Lift Zone Safety, Lift, Zone, Safety, Struck by [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Tower Crane Safety addresses the potential hazards of Tower Cranes and the importance of following procedure before and during Tower Crane operation. The resource includes a brief example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates a worker inspecting a Tower Crane before operation, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001234,d001238,d001250,d001251,d001253,d001258,d001262,d001273 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/19/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [3] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Work Zone Safety: Working Around Vehicles [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Working Around Vehicles in the Work Zone addresses methods to avoid being struck-by a vehicle on a construction site. The res... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 18 [2] => 52 [3] => 57 [4] => 70 [5] => 85 [6] => 87 [7] => 88 [8] => 89 [9] => 91 [10] => 90 [11] => 92 [12] => 93 [13] => 94 [14] => 95 [15] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [6] => Commercial Diver [7] => Trades [8] => Flagger [10] => Operating Engineer [12] => Truck Driver [14] => Commercial & Institutional [15] => Jobsites [16] => Demolition [18] => Disasters [20] => Heavy & Highway [22] => Industrial [24] => LEED/Green Construction [26] => Renovations [28] => Residential [30] => Underground [32] => Toolbox Talks [33] => Documents [34] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4428/d001658/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BWork%2BZone%2BSafety%253A%2BWorking%2BAround%2BVehicles.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [18] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 18 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [52] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 52 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Commercial Diver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [85] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 85 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Truck Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4428 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001658 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Daniela Caceres [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Work Zone Safety: Working Around Vehicles [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Struck, Struck by, Vehicle, Work Zone Safety, Truck, Operator, Driver, Mobile Equipment [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Working Around Vehicles in the Work Zone addresses methods to avoid being struck-by a vehicle on a construction site. The resource includes a case example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates the hazard, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001640 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/19/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [4] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Construction Dive -- DeWalt's Jobsite Pro headphones recalled for fire hazards [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => A recall notice by the United States Consumer Product Safety Commission affects over 300,000 DeWalt Jobsite Pro Headphones. The recall is a result of... [category] => Array ( [0] => 16 [1] => 44 [2] => 45 [3] => 46 [4] => 47 [5] => 48 [6] => 49 [7] => 50 [8] => 51 [9] => 52 [10] => 53 [11] => 54 [12] => 55 [13] => 56 [14] => 57 [15] => 58 [16] => 59 [17] => 60 [18] => 61 [19] => 64 [20] => 65 [21] => 66 [22] => 67 [23] => 68 [24] => 69 [25] => 70 [26] => 71 [27] => 72 [28] => 73 [29] => 74 [30] => 75 [31] => 76 [32] => 77 [33] => 63 [34] => 78 [35] => 79 [36] => 80 [37] => 81 [38] => 82 [39] => 62 [40] => 83 [41] => 84 [42] => 85 [43] => 86 [44] => 87 [45] => 88 [46] => 89 [47] => 91 [48] => 90 [49] => 92 [50] => 93 [51] => 94 [52] => 95 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Fire & Explosions [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Acoustical Ceiling Carpenter [4] => Trades [5] => Asbestos/Insulator [7] => Boilermaker [9] => Bricklayer [11] => Cabinetmaker [13] => Carpenter [15] => Carpet Layer [17] => Cement Mason [19] => Commercial Diver [21] => Concrete Polisher [23] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [25] => Electrical Worker [27] => Elevator Constructor [29] => Flagger [31] => Glazier [33] => Hazardous Waste Cleanup [35] => HVAC [37] => Interior Systems Carpenter [39] => Laborer [41] => Landscaper [43] => Lather [45] => Lead Abatement Worker [47] => Maintenance Worker [49] => Millwright [51] => Operating Engineer [53] => Painter [55] => Paper Hanger [57] => PCC/Restoration [59] => Pile Driver [61] => Plasterer [63] => Plumber/Pipefitter [65] => Refractory Worker [67] => Reinforcing Ironworker [69] => Roofer/Waterproofer [71] => Scaffold Erector [73] => Sheetmetal Worker [75] => Sprinkler Fitter [77] => Stonemason [79] => Structural Ironworker [81] => Terrazzo Worker [83] => Tile Setter [85] => Truck Driver [87] => Welder [89] => Commercial & Institutional [90] => Jobsites [91] => Demolition [93] => Disasters [95] => Heavy & Highway [97] => Industrial [99] => LEED/Green Construction [101] => Renovations [103] => Residential [105] => Underground ) [type] => [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4426/d001656/Construction%2BDive%2B--%2BDeWalt%2527s%2BJobsite%2BPro%2Bheadphones%2Brecalled%2Bfor%2Bfire%2Bhazards.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [16] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 16 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Fire & Explosions [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [44] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 44 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Acoustical Ceiling Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [45] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 45 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Asbestos/Insulator [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [46] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 46 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Boilermaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [48] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 48 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cabinetmaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [50] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 50 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpet Layer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [52] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 52 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Commercial Diver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [53] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 53 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Concrete Polisher [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [54] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 54 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [58] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 58 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Glazier [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [59] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 59 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Hazardous Waste Cleanup [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [65] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 65 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Landscaper [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [66] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 66 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Lather [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [67] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 67 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Lead Abatement Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [69] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 69 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Millwright [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [72] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 72 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Paper Hanger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [73] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 73 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => PCC/Restoration [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [77] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 77 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Refractory Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [81] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 81 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sprinkler Fitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [83] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 83 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Terrazzo Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [84] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 84 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Tile Setter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [85] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 85 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Truck Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4426 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001656 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Construction Dive -- DeWalt's Jobsite Pro headphones recalled for fire hazards [total_pages:protected] => 1 [billed_pages:protected] => 1 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => DeWalt, Fire Hazards, recall, headphones [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A recall notice by the United States Consumer Product Safety Commission affects over 300,000 DeWalt Jobsite Pro Headphones. The recall is a result of a malfunction that can cause earbuds to overheat while charging or during use, leading to fire and burn hazards. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => https://www.constructiondive.com/news/dewalts-jobsite-pro-headphones-recalled-for-fire-hazards/611248/?utm_source=Sailthru&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Issue:%202021-12-10%20Construction%20Dive%20Newsletter%20%5Bissue:38532%5D&utm_term=Construction%20Dive [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/13/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/13/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 12/13/21 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [new_images] => Array ( [0] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Morning Toolbox Talk [image] => /record/images/4003-p.jpg [blurb] => This photo is from an early morning toolbox talk on a construction job in Mclean, Virginia. It is being delivered in English and Spanish.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 20 [1] => 51 [2] => 57 [3] => 64 [4] => 70 [5] => 63 [6] => 78 [7] => 82 [8] => 62 [9] => 87 [10] => 88 [11] => 89 [12] => 91 [13] => 90 [14] => 93 [15] => 94 [16] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Safety Culture [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Cement Mason [4] => Trades [5] => Flagger [7] => Laborer [9] => Operating Engineer [11] => Reinforcing Ironworker [13] => Roofer/Waterproofer [15] => Stonemason [17] => Structural Ironworker [19] => Commercial & Institutional [20] => Jobsites [21] => Demolition [23] => Disasters [25] => Heavy & Highway [27] => Industrial [29] => Renovations [31] => Residential [33] => Images [34] => Media [35] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4003/i002691/Morning%2BToolbox%2BTalk.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4003 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002691 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Morning Toolbox Talk [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, Spanish, bilingual [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This photo is from an early morning toolbox talk on a construction job in Mclean, Virginia. It is being delivered in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001285,d001304,c000079 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [1] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox talk - crew view [image] => /record/images/4005-p.jpg [blurb] => Photo of crew listening to a toolbox safety talk before starting work.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 97 [1] => 20 [2] => 47 [3] => 49 [4] => 51 [5] => 55 [6] => 61 [7] => 64 [8] => 71 [9] => 75 [10] => 63 [11] => 79 [12] => 62 [13] => 87 [14] => 88 [15] => 91 [16] => 90 [17] => 93 [18] => 94 [19] => 95 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Images [1] => Media [2] => Media & Documents [3] => Safety Culture [4] => Work Environment [5] => Hazards [6] => Bricklayer [7] => Trades [8] => Carpenter [10] => Cement Mason [12] => Electrical Worker [14] => Interior Systems Carpenter [16] => Laborer [18] => Painter [20] => Plasterer [22] => Reinforcing Ironworker [24] => Scaffold Erector [26] => Structural Ironworker [28] => Commercial & Institutional [29] => Jobsites [30] => Demolition [32] => Heavy & Highway [34] => Industrial [36] => Renovations [38] => Residential [40] => Underground ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4005/i002692/Toolbox%2Btalk%2B-%2Bcrew%2Bview.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4005 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002692 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox talk - crew view [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, safety talk, Spanish [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Photo of crew listening to a toolbox safety talk before starting work. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002691,d001269, c000079, d001285 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [2] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox talk - long shot [image] => /record/images/4006-p.jpg [blurb] => This crew gathered every morning before starting work to discuss a new safety topic.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 20 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 55 [5] => 64 [6] => 68 [7] => 75 [8] => 76 [9] => 63 [10] => 78 [11] => 79 [12] => 82 [13] => 62 [14] => 87 [15] => 88 [16] => 91 [17] => 90 [18] => 93 [19] => 94 [20] => 95 [21] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Safety Culture [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Electrical Worker [11] => Laborer [13] => Maintenance Worker [15] => Plasterer [17] => Plumber/Pipefitter [19] => Reinforcing Ironworker [21] => Roofer/Waterproofer [23] => Scaffold Erector [25] => Stonemason [27] => Structural Ironworker [29] => Commercial & Institutional [30] => Jobsites [31] => Demolition [33] => Heavy & Highway [35] => Industrial [37] => Renovations [39] => Residential [41] => Underground [43] => Images [44] => Media [45] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4006/i002693/Toolbox%2Btalk%2B-%2Blong%2Bshot.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4006 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002693 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox talk - long shot [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, safety minute [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This crew gathered every morning before starting work to discuss a new safety topic. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002691,i002692,d001269,d000527 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [3] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Safety officer discussing ongoing project with marketing coordinator [image] => /record/images/4014-p.jpg [blurb] => The safety officer (left) points out the good safety practices on this project that reflect well on the firm and may influence future clients.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 97 [1] => 20 [2] => 46 [3] => 47 [4] => 49 [5] => 50 [6] => 51 [7] => 54 [8] => 55 [9] => 58 [10] => 60 [11] => 61 [12] => 64 [13] => 71 [14] => 75 [15] => 76 [16] => 63 [17] => 79 [18] => 80 [19] => 82 [20] => 62 [21] => 83 [22] => 87 [23] => 91 [24] => 90 [25] => 93 [26] => 94 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Images [1] => Media [2] => Media & Documents [3] => Safety Culture [4] => Work Environment [5] => Hazards [6] => Boilermaker [7] => Trades [8] => Bricklayer [10] => Carpenter [12] => Carpet Layer [14] => Cement Mason [16] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [18] => Electrical Worker [20] => Glazier [22] => HVAC [24] => Interior Systems Carpenter [26] => Laborer [28] => Painter [30] => Plasterer [32] => Plumber/Pipefitter [34] => Reinforcing Ironworker [36] => Scaffold Erector [38] => Sheetmetal Worker [40] => Stonemason [42] => Structural Ironworker [44] => Terrazzo Worker [46] => Commercial & Institutional [47] => Jobsites [48] => Heavy & Highway [50] => Industrial [52] => Renovations [54] => Residential ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4014/i002700/Safety%2Bofficer%2Bdiscussing%2Bongoing%2Bproject%2Bwith%2Bmarketing%2Bcoordinator.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [46] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 46 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Boilermaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [50] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 50 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpet Layer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [54] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 54 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [58] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 58 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Glazier [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [83] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 83 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Terrazzo Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4014 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002700 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Safety officer discussing ongoing project with marketing coordinator [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Latino, safety officer, safety culture [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The safety officer (left) points out the good safety practices on this project that reflect well on the firm and may influence future clients. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/index.php [more_like_this:protected] => d000989,d001351,d001362,d000652, d001101, d000931, d001395 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Hoar Construction, Photo by Neil Lippy [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 01/30/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [4] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Scaffolding at top of large column [image] => /record/images/3994-p.jpg [blurb] => This shot shows innovative guarding around the top of a large concrete column in the base of a high rise structure going up.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 15 [1] => 21 [2] => 47 [3] => 51 [4] => 63 [5] => 78 [6] => 79 [7] => 80 [8] => 62 [9] => 87 [10] => 97 [11] => 56 [12] => 64 [13] => 74 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Falls [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Scaffolds [6] => Bricklayer [7] => Trades [8] => Cement Mason [10] => Reinforcing Ironworker [12] => Roofer/Waterproofer [14] => Scaffold Erector [16] => Sheetmetal Worker [18] => Structural Ironworker [20] => Commercial & Institutional [21] => Jobsites [22] => Images [23] => Media [24] => Media & Documents [25] => Elevator Constructor [27] => Laborer [29] => Pile Driver ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/3994/i002689/Scaffolding%2Bat%2Btop%2Bof%2Blarge%2Bcolumn.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [21] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 21 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Scaffolds [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3994 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002689 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Scaffolding at top of large column [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Guardrail, railing, fall prevention, falls [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This shot shows innovative guarding around the top of a large concrete column in the base of a high rise structure going up. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/8/adjustable-tower-scaffold.html [more_like_this:protected] => c1002680,i002662,d000608,d001255 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Photo by Pam Susi [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2016 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_completed:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/01/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [5] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Construction bracing [image] => /record/images/3995-p.jpg [blurb] => This shows structural support that prevents collapses during construction.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 15 [2] => 21 [3] => 49 [4] => 51 [5] => 55 [6] => 56 [7] => 60 [8] => 64 [9] => 68 [10] => 74 [11] => 63 [12] => 78 [13] => 79 [14] => 80 [15] => 62 [16] => 87 [17] => 90 [18] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Falls [6] => Scaffolds [9] => Carpenter [10] => Trades [11] => Cement Mason [13] => Electrical Worker [15] => Elevator Constructor [17] => HVAC [19] => Laborer [21] => Maintenance Worker [23] => Pile Driver [25] => Reinforcing Ironworker [27] => Roofer/Waterproofer [29] => Scaffold Erector [31] => Sheetmetal Worker [33] => Structural Ironworker [35] => Commercial & Institutional [36] => Jobsites [37] => Industrial [39] => Images [40] => Media [41] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/3995/i002690/Construction%2Bbracing.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [21] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 21 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Scaffolds [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3995 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002690 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Construction bracing [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Bracing, support, scaffold [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This shows structural support that prevents collapses during construction. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/8/adjustable-tower-scaffold.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002660 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Photo by Pam Susi [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2016 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_completed:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/01/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [preview_mode] => [description] => The results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. [keywords] => tuckpointing, HEPA vacuum, dust control, LEV, local exhaust ventilation, silica [related_items] => Array ( [Research Reports] => Array ( [0] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1874 [old_id:protected] => 722 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000683 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Sharon Garber/COD [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Protecting Tuckpointing Workers from Silica Dust: Draft Recommendations for a Ventilated Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 12 [billed_pages:protected] => 12 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, vacuum, grinder, mortar, respirator, OSHA, NIOSH, exhaust, Heitbrink, tuckpointer, silica, masonry, dust, silicosis, LEV [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Describes draft recommendations for use of ventilated grinder to reduce dust during tuckpointing and describes field trials using these devices. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/hazard/67/chip-scrape-and-grind-surfaces-or-joints-silica.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001201,d000292,d000293,d000658 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2005 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/27/05 [date_completed:protected] => 04/26/05 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/20/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [1] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1940 [old_id:protected] => 909 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Workplace Solutions: Control of Hazardous Dust During Tuckpointing [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, silica, dust, tuckpoint, grinder, masonry restoration, mortar, vacuum [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d000819,d000820,d000730,d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 10/24/08 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/09 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [2] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3899 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001342 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: Hilti VC40-U Vacuum with Hilti DC-EX Dust Guard and Hilti Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 15 [billed_pages:protected] => 15 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP4 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => silica, tuckpointing, Hilti, local exhaust systems, LEV, shroud, quartz [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This report describes the results of an evaluation of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Hilti VC40-U vacuum, a Hilti DC-EX shroud, and a Hilti DAG-500 grinder. Randomized trials with and without use of the dust control system were conducted in a controlled setting. Removing mortar with the Hilti grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 220 times the National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05mg/m3. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 97 percent. However, exposures measured during the use of the dust control system still exceeded the NIOSH REL. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => December 1, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/05/14 [date_completed:protected] => 02/04/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/06/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [Handouts] => Array ( [0] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3656 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001198 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 24 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction While Doing Tuckpointing/Mortar Removal [total_pages:protected] => 2 [billed_pages:protected] => 2 [publication_number:protected] => DSG FS-3632 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Brick, block, tuckpointing, silica, local exhaust ventilation, LEV, masonry [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Tuckpointing creates some of the greatest exposures to silica in construction. This OSHA factsheet provides guidance on how to greatly reduce these exposures through the use of local exhaust ventilation. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863, d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => February 2013 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/04/13 [date_completed:protected] => 03/27/13 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [collections] => Array ( [3913] => ) [record] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => Array ( [867] => Author Object ( [id:protected] => 867 [organization_id:protected] => 0 [firstname:protected] => Michael [lastname:protected] => Cooper [address:protected] => [city:protected] => [province:protected] => [country:protected] => [postal_code:protected] => [department:protected] => [title:protected] => [phone:protected] => [fax:protected] => [email:protected] => [degree:protected] => [website:protected] => [about:protected] => [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => [date_completed:protected] => [date_billed:protected] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [481] => Author Object ( [id:protected] => 481 [organization_id:protected] => 0 [firstname:protected] => Pam [lastname:protected] => Susi [address:protected] => 8484 Georgia Avenue, Suite 1000 [city:protected] => Silver Spring [province:protected] => Maryland [country:protected] => USA [postal_code:protected] => 20910 [department:protected] => [title:protected] => [phone:protected] => 301-578-8500 ext.144 [fax:protected] => 301-578-8572 [email:protected] => plsusi@aol.com [degree:protected] => [website:protected] => http://www.cpwr.com [about:protected] => [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => 2003-10-02 [date_completed:protected] => 2003-10-06 [date_billed:protected] => 2003-11-03 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [organizations:protected] => Array ( [1] => Organization Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [elcosh_id:protected] => o000001 [user_id:protected] => 14 [province_id:protected] => 21 [country_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => CPWR - The Center for Construction Research and Training [address:protected] => Suite 1000, 8484 Georgia Ave [postal_code:protected] => 20910 [city:protected] => Silver Spring [department:protected] => [phone:protected] => 301-578-8500 [fax:protected] => 301-578-8572 [email:protected] => cpwrwebsite@cpwr.com [website:protected] => http://www.cpwr.com [filename:protected] => o000001.gif [about:protected] => CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training, developed, and continues to maintain/expand this website - The Electronic Library of Construction Occupational Safety and Health, www.elcosh.org. CPWR, formerly known as The Center to Protect Workers’ Rights, is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit research and training institution. Created by the Building and Construction Trades Department, AFL-CIO, CPWR serves as the research arm of the BCTD. Since the inception of its research agenda in 1990, CPWR has grown into a worldwide provider of safety and health information covering all aspects of the construction industry. CPWR launched eLCOSH in 2000, and the Spanish-language version of the site in 2001. CPWR also created, and continues to build, Construction Solutions - www.cpwrConstructionSolutions.org - a free, online database of construction hazards and ways to prevent, eliminate, or reduce them. [comments:protected] => [logo_available:protected] => T [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => 2000-08-18 [date_completed:protected] => 2000-08-30 [date_billed:protected] => 2000-09-05 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [collections:protected] => Array ( [3913] => ) [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => Array ( [1874] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1874 [old_id:protected] => 722 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000683 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Sharon Garber/COD [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Protecting Tuckpointing Workers from Silica Dust: Draft Recommendations for a Ventilated Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 12 [billed_pages:protected] => 12 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, vacuum, grinder, mortar, respirator, OSHA, NIOSH, exhaust, Heitbrink, tuckpointer, silica, masonry, dust, silicosis, LEV [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Describes draft recommendations for use of ventilated grinder to reduce dust during tuckpointing and describes field trials using these devices. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/hazard/67/chip-scrape-and-grind-surfaces-or-joints-silica.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001201,d000292,d000293,d000658 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2005 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/27/05 [date_completed:protected] => 04/26/05 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/20/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [1940] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1940 [old_id:protected] => 909 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Workplace Solutions: Control of Hazardous Dust During Tuckpointing [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, silica, dust, tuckpoint, grinder, masonry restoration, mortar, vacuum [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d000819,d000820,d000730,d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 10/24/08 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/09 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [2213] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 2213 [old_id:protected] => 1090 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => [language_id:protected] => 2 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Control del polvo peligroso que se genera durante los procesos de reparación de mortero [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => 2008-126 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => [comments:protected] => http://www.cdc.gov/spanish/niosh/docs/wp-solutions/2008-126_sp/ [summary:protected] => A Workplace Solutions de NIOSH que resume un estudio de NIOSH sobre los riesgos de exposición cuando se reparan las estructuras y los métodos para controlar el polvo. [A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust.] [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => D000819,D000820,D000730,d000819 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 01/07/10 [date_completed:protected] => 04/19/10 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 07/08/12 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [3656] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3656 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001198 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 24 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction While Doing Tuckpointing/Mortar Removal [total_pages:protected] => 2 [billed_pages:protected] => 2 [publication_number:protected] => DSG FS-3632 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Brick, block, tuckpointing, silica, local exhaust ventilation, LEV, masonry [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Tuckpointing creates some of the greatest exposures to silica in construction. This OSHA factsheet provides guidance on how to greatly reduce these exposures through the use of local exhaust ventilation. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863, d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => February 2013 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/04/13 [date_completed:protected] => 03/27/13 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [3899] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3899 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001342 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: Hilti VC40-U Vacuum with Hilti DC-EX Dust Guard and Hilti Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 15 [billed_pages:protected] => 15 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP4 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => silica, tuckpointing, Hilti, local exhaust systems, LEV, shroud, quartz [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This report describes the results of an evaluation of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Hilti VC40-U vacuum, a Hilti DC-EX shroud, and a Hilti DAG-500 grinder. Randomized trials with and without use of the dust control system were conducted in a controlled setting. Removing mortar with the Hilti grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 220 times the National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05mg/m3. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 97 percent. However, exposures measured during the use of the dust control system still exceeded the NIOSH REL. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => December 1, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/05/14 [date_completed:protected] => 02/04/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/06/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [content:protected] => [files:protected] => Array ( [559] => [560] => [546] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 546 [filename:protected] => 3.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:22 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [566] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 566 [filename:protected] => 4.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:23 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [720] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 720 [filename:protected] => 5.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [721] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 721 [filename:protected] => 6.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [722] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 722 [filename:protected] => 7.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [9765] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 9765 [filename:protected] => d001345.pdf [downloadable:protected] => T [timestamp:protected] => 2015-02-09 12:26:04 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3908 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001345 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: DustControl 2900c Vacuum with the ICS Dust Director Shroud and Bosch Grinder Model 1775E Conducted November 14-15, 2012 [total_pages:protected] => 13 [billed_pages:protected] => 13 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP2 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => tuckpointing, HEPA vacuum, dust control, LEV, local exhaust ventilation, silica [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => April 15, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 01/26/15 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/09/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [show_text] => [document_content] => ElcoshItemDocumentContent Object ( [id:protected] => 2934 [item_id:protected] => 3908 [type:protected] => main [title:protected] => [content:protected] =>
Executive Summary
This report describes the results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. It should also be noted that the NIOSH REL is based on exposures averaged over a ten hour work day and our results represent time weighted averages of the sample task duration periods.
Acronyms
ACGIH - American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists
CPWR - CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training
Ce - coefficient of entry
HEPA - high-efficiency particulate air
IUBAC - International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craftworkers
LEV - local exhaust ventilation
PACT - Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies
NIOSH - National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health
OEL - occupational exposure limit
OSHA - Occupational Safety and Health Administration
PAPR - powered air-purifying respirator
PEL - Permissible Exposure Limit
PVC - polyvinyl chloride
REL - Recommended Exposure Limit
RPM - revolutions per minute
TWA - time-weighted average
SP - static pressure
I. Introduction and Background
In 2010 CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training began a four-year project which seeks to identify and evaluate tuckpointing local exhaust ventilation (LEV) systems and disseminate information on their availability and effectiveness. A Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies (PACT) comprised of masonry contractors, representatives from unions, government, equipment manufacturers, and health and safety researcher was formed as part of this project. PACT members participated in identifying important characteristics for control technologies and this information was used to identify LEV systems for tuckpointing using that criteria. Contractor and labor members of the PACT selected specific tuckpointing LEV systems to be considered for evaluation. Each system consisted of a tuckpointing grinder, shroud, and vacuum. This report describes the second of four systems to be evaluated between 2012 the end of 2014, with and without LEV, in a controlled setting to determine effectiveness in silica exposure reduction. This report describes the methods and results of our evaluation of a system consisting of the DustControl 2900c vacuum with the ICS Dust Director shroud and a Bosch Model 1775E grinder.
Excessive exposure to respirable silica can result in silicosis or other silica-related diseases including pulmonary tuberculosis, lung cancer, silicoproteinosis (Lyons et al, 2007) and autoimmune disorders such as rheumatoid arthritis, sarcoidosis and scleroderma (Miller et al, 2012). Respirable silica is generally defined as particles less than 10 micrometers (μm) in aerodynamic diameter (ACGIH, 2013). Silicosis can lead to symptoms including shortness of breath, fatigue, chest pains, susceptibility to infection and possibly death. There is no cure for silicosis, however it is totally preventable. Construction workers exposed to dust, including silica, are also known to have higher rates of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD).
There are many sources of silica in construction that result in exposures of varying intensity among workers. Masonry restoration workers are among the most highly silica-exposed trades in construction. The process of grinding out deteriorated mortar joints between masonry units and replacing or repointing with fresh mortar (often referred to as tuckpointing) is a fundamental part of masonry restoration work. The removal of mortar with powered angle grinders generates enormous levels of dust. Between 2004 and 2006, NIOSH and CPWR evaluated silica exposures while grinding mortar in a controlled setting, at a local training center, where tasks, sample times and task variables were defined by the study design. These studies demonstrated that grinding mortar without controls can result in elevated respirable silica exposures. Meeker et al., (2009) reported exposures between 5 and 25.8 milligrams per cubic meter (mg/m3) in a controlled setting. This study also showed that LEV systems for tuckpointing grinders can reduce exposures to respirable silica by greater than 90 percent.II. Objectives
The objective of this evaluation was to assess the effectiveness of an LEV system for controlling exposure to silica during the grinding of mortar. The control technology was tested under controlled conditions, similar to those experienced by tuckpointers on actual job sites, using journeymen bricklayers experienced in tuckpointing and repeat, randomized trials with and without LEV. All other variables were held constant throughout so that the only variable was whether or not the tested control was used.
III. Description of Equipment Tested
A Bosch model 1775E grinder (Robert Bosch Tool Corporation, Prospect, IL) (Figures 1, 2 and 3) was fitted with a new 1/4-inch wide, 4½-inch diameter segmented diamond abrasive blade made by DeWalt (model #DW4740). The grinder weighs six and a half pounds, draws 8.5 amps and has a variable speed up to 11,000 revolutions per minute (RPMs). The DustControl 2900c vacuum (DustControl, Inc., Wilmington, NC) (Figure 3) was tested in combination with the Dust Director shroud (Industrial Contractors’ Supplies, Inc., Huntingdon, PA) (Figures 1 and 3) attached to the Bosch grinder.
Figure 1. Bosch grinder with Dust Director shroud
Figure 2. Bosch grinder without tuckpointing LEV system.
Figure 3: Bosch Grinder with LEV System
The vacuum is specified to weigh 31 pounds when empty and to provide a flow rate of 114 cubic feet of air per minute and a “static lift” or “vacuum suction pressure” of 84 inches of water. The vacuum is sold with a cyclonic pre-separator, to remove larger particles, a fine filter (rated 99.9 percent efficient) and a HEPA (high-efficiency particulate air) filter (rated to capture 99.97 percent of the particles with an aerodynamic diameter of 0.3 micrometers). The HEPA filter was removed based on the manufacturer’s recommendation due to the heavy dust loading associated with tuckpointing. CPWR sponsored research and contractor experience indicate that HEPA filters likely have an adverse effect on dust capture during tuckpointing because of extreme dust loading on filters. While the cyclone and the fine filter remove most of the dust, especially the large particles, before they reach the HEPA filter, the HEPA filter would still be subject to heavy loading, causing a substantial pressure drop and subsequent decrease in air flow rate. The relatively small increase in the efficiency of the filtration system while using the HEPA filter is expected to be quickly offset by a more significant decrease in capture efficiency as the air flow rate and ability to capture particles decreases.
Dust collects in relatively inexpensive, heavy-gauge plastic bags below and outside of the cyclone. The bags can be removed and replaced without opening the vacuum. Some vacuums are equipped with a light to indicate that the filters need to be cleaned or changed. The DC2900c features a “reverse air pulse cleaning system,” which removes accumulated dust from the filters without having to remove them from the vacuum. The system, as illustrated in Figure 4, requires the operator to disconnect the hose from the shroud, place it over an air stop so that air through the hose is cut off and pressure in the vacuum is maximized.
Figure 4. Procedure for "cleaning" of or dust removal from filters (source: http://dustcontrolusa.com/manuals/2800c.pdf)
The flap covering the port on the side of the vacuum is repeatedly flipped open to release built up pressure in strong pulses that dislodge dust from the filter.
The manufacturer indicates “the filter is generally cleaned once or twice daily during normal continuous operation.” The Dust Director shroud has a 2-inch diameter take-off that was connected to the antistatic, corrugated 1.5-inch diameter, 15-foot long vacuum hose supplied with the DustControl vacuum.
IV. Study Methods
This evaluation was conducted at the International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craft workers (IUBAC) Local 1 Philadelphia/Delaware Training Center in Philadelphia, PA on November 14 and 15, 2012. A single journeyman bricklayer, experienced in tuckpointing, used the grinder and LEV system being tested to remove mortar from joints wide enough to require two passes. The type S mortar had been allowed to cure for at least four weeks. The bricklayer either possessed or was provided with personal protective equipment including sturdy work boots, gloves, hearing protection and a powered air-purifying respirator (PAPR). The PAPR was a 3M GVP system with a bump cap, loose fitting face piece and a HEPA filter (3M, St Paul, MN).
The study was designed to include at least five rounds of sampling during mortar removal. Each round included a trial using the Bosch grinder with a Dust Director shroud and Dust Collector 2900c vacuum and a trial using the Bosch grinder with the factory-supplied guard and without a vacuum. The order of the two trials within each round was randomly selected to minimize bias that might be introduced due to variation associated with environmental factors, equipment operator, blade wear, vacuum performance over time and any other factors unrelated to LEV use. Tools were operated for approximately 16 minutes per trial with controls and for approximately 8 minutes when controls were not used. These times were selected based on the results of previous sampling efforts and estimates of the minimum sample time needed to achieve a limit of quantification low enough to accurately measure exposures down to or less than 0.05 mg/m3 – the NIOSH Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) for respirable silica. The bricklayer was required to take a 5 to 10 minute break in the middle of the 16-minute trials to reduce differences in fatigue, compared to the 8-minute trials. Personal air samples were collected in the breathing zone of the operator during each trial to measure respirable silica concentrations during grinding with and without LEV. The samples were collected using a GilAir-5 pump (Sensidyne, Inc., Clearwater, FL) to draw 4.2 liters of air per minute through a GK2.69 Respirable Cyclone (BGI Inc., Waltham, MA) with a pre-weighed, 37 mm diameter, 5-micron pore size polyvinyl chloride (PVC) filter positioned on the operator’s lapel.
The flow rates of the sampling pumps were calibrated at the beginning of each day using a DryCal DC-Lite Primary Flow Meter (Bios International Corporation, Butler, NJ). Flow rates were measured again near the middle and at the end of each day to ensure that sampling flow rates were maintained within 5% of pre-sampling flow rates throughout the day. Average flow rates were used to calculate sample air volumes. Samples were analyzed by R.J. Lee Group, Inc., (Monroeville, PA) using NIOSH Method 0600, to determine exposure to total mass of respirable dust. The same samples were also analyzed using X-Ray diffraction following NIOSH method 7500 to determine quartz, cristobalite and tridymite concentration in the respirable mass. Reported masses for these analytes were used with the sample air volumes to calculate airborne concentrations of total respirable dust, quartz, cristobalite and tridymite.
We used a reduction of greater than 50 percent in respirable silica exposure concentrations or a reduction to less than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 as our criteria for determining whether or not a control was considered efficacious. This is consistent with criteria used by NIOSH in conducting a similar study in 2004 described by Echt et al. (2007) and by CPWR in 2006 and described by Meeker et al. (2009). The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) and the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) publish additional occupational exposure limits (OELs) for silica which are listed in Table 1 with NIOSH RELs. OELs for silica are based on the respirable fraction of the aerosol, which consists of particles less than 10 micrometers in aerodynamic diameter.
| Organization or Agency | Form of Crystalline Silica | Occupational Exposure Limits (mg/m3) |
|---|---|---|
| NIOSHA | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 |
| OSHA - ConstructionB | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
PEL = 250 / (5 + % quartz) PEL = 250 / (5 + % cristobalite) PEL = 250 / (5 + % tridymite) |
| ACGIH | Crystalline Silica | TLV = 0.025 mg/m3 |
A NIOSH Publication No. 2005-151 indicates 10-hour time-weighted average during a 40-hr workweek B The PEL for silica in OSHA’s Safety and Health Regulations for Construction, 29 C.F.R. 1926.55(a), is an 8-hour time-weighted average (TWA) expressed in millions of particles per cubic foot (mppcf). However, the units mppcf can be converted to milligrams per cubic meter can by dividing mppcf by 10 (OSHA, 2009). The formula used by OSHA to determine the PEL for silica is dependent on the percentage of silica in each collected sample. The concentration of respirable dust measured is compared to the sample specific PEL to determine if the PEL has been exceeded. OSHA has proposed lowering the PEL to 0.05 mg/m3 of respirable silica as an 8 hour TWA. |
||
The flow of air in ventilation systems is governed by fundamental principles that describe the behavior of gases (in this case air). Pressure measurements taken within a ventilation system along with knowledge of hood (or shroud) entry losses can be used to calculate flow rates. Hood entry losses are dependent on the shape and configuration of a particular hood or shroud and described by the term “coefficient of entry (Ce)” which is the ratio of actual air flow through a hood and what the air flow would theoretically be if there were no hood entry losses. Given the coefficient of entry, static pressure measurements can be used to calculate air flow through a given hood. The coefficient of entry for the Dust Director shroud was previously determined by CPWR and used for calculating air flow based on static pressure measurements (Meeker et al., 2009). Static pressure, with the vacuum operating, was measured periodically throughout the evaluation to monitor the changes in air-flow rate following use and again after filter cleaning. The static pressure was measured at a port positioned more than 3 duct diameters downstream from the tool’s air intake using a UEi EM200 Electronic Manometer (Universal Enterprises, Inc., Beaverton, OR).
The dust in the vacuum bag was monitored and, per the manufacturer’s instructions, the bag was changed before the dust level was within 5 centimeters of the valve at the bottom of the vacuum. Each time a vacuum bag was removed, it was weighed to the nearest pound. The bag weights and corresponding grinding durations were used to calculate the average weight of dust collected per unit time. After each trial, cut lengths were measured on the wall to determine total linear feet of vertical (head) and horizontal (bed) joints per unit time.
A Haz-Dust III, Model HD-1003, Real-Time Aerosol Monitor (Environmental Devices Corporation, Plaistow, NH) was used to confirm clearance of dust between trials. The Haz-Dust monitor was positioned on the test wall near the operator at approximately breathing zone level and configured to measure respirable particulate concentration.
V. Results
Personal air monitoring
Five pairs of respirable dust samples were collected while grinding with and without the vacuum system. In addition, three respirable dust samples were collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place. One measurement collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard was shown to be a statistical outlier and was omitted from analysis. Personal air monitoring results for respirable silica and a comparison of average exposures relative to the NIOSH REL for silica (0.05 mg/m3) appears in Table 2. The mean respirable dust levels measured without LEV was 31.4 mg/m3. However, samples collected with LEV were below the limit of quantification (LOQ) which ranged from <1.29 to <1.46 mg/m3. Use of LEV resulted in a greater than 95% reduction in mean respirable dust levels using a mean value with use of LEV of <1.41 (n=5 samples with use of LEV and n=7 without use of LEV). The respirable dust samples collected during grinding without the LEV system contained an average of 24 percent silica. The mass of respirable dust in the samples collected with use of the LEV system was too low to determine the silica content.| Mean, mg/m3 (range) | Std. Dev. | Percent Reduction | Hazard RatioB | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bosch with Dust Director Shroud and DustControl 2900c Vacuum |
0.091 (<0.069 – 0.137) |
0.027 | 98.7 | 1.81 |
| Bosch with no Control | 7.23 (4.57 – 9.90) |
1.94 | NA | 145 |
A n = 5 samples for each tool/control combination and n = 7 samples without the use of the LEV system B Hazard Ratio = measured exposure / NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 |
||||
Average respirable silica and dust exposures, with and without the dust control system, appear as Figures 5 and 6, respectively.
Figure 5. Average respirable silica exposures with and without the Dustcontrol 2900c vacuum and Dust Director shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air - mg/m3)
Figure 6. Average respirable dust exposures with and without Dustcontrol 2900c Vacuum and Dust Director Shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air – mg/m3)
The mean respirable silica concentration measured during use of the control was significantly less than the concentration measured while using the same tool without controls (p<0.01). Grinding mortar with the Bosch angle grinder without dust controls resulted in an average exposure to respirable silica that was 145 times the NIOSH REL. Grinding with the Bosch angle grinder in combination with the Dust Director shroud and the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced the average concentration of respirable silica by 98.7 percent. With use of these controls, the concentration of respirable silica was 1.8 times greater than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3. However the NIOSH REL is based on a time-weighted average (TWA) over a 10-hour workday. Given these were task TWAs and samples were collected over continuous periods of grinding, they may overestimate exposures over an actual work day since some time would be spent performing tasks that would likely have lower, or no, silica exposures (setup, breaks, cleanup, etc.).
Static pressure, dust mass collection and grinding rates.
Static pressure was used as a surrogate for air flow as described earlier. Hood static pressure was measured periodically at a tap near the grinder more than 3 duct diameters from the air intake in the shroud. The static pressure, and thus air flow, was generally higher when the vacuum’s filter had recently been cleaned. The mean, median, and range of calculated flow rates are presented in Table A1 of the Appendix.
Based on the data we collected, the air-flow rate upstream from the Bosch grinder and Dust Director shroud ranged from 78 to 93 cubic feet per minute (cfm) with the DustControl vacuum. When the manufacturer’s filter cleaning procedure was followed the vacuum performed relatively well and flow could be maintained at slightly less than 90 cfm with cleaning. However, mean flow rates dropped substantially to 80 cfm after as little as 8 minutes of grinding without any filter cleaning. The flow rate returned to an average of 89 cfm when filters were cleaned correctly (without stopping air flow to the vacuum). Collingwood and Heitbrink (2007) found that the minimum exhaust flow rate for capture of silica and other particulate under ideal conditions is 21.25 cfm per inch of grinder blade diameter. This is equal to about 96 cfm when using a 4.5 inch diameter grinding blade. We set 106 cfm as the minimum desired flow rate for this study to allow a safety margin for potential decline in equipment performance and the possibility of inadequate maintenance, both of which may be likely after repeated use under actual work conditions. The DustControl vacuum provided slightly less than the minimum flow rate described by Collingwood and Heitbrink for a 4.5-inch blade and the peak flow rate fell with use.
The duration of vacuum bag use and mass of dust collected were recorded and are presented in Table A2 of the Appendix. The vacuum bags were changed and weighed after each trial utilizing the LEV system. A total of five bags were used to complete the five rounds of grinding. The DustControl vacuum captured 45 pounds of dust over 83 minutes of grinding for an average rate of dust collection of 0.54 pounds per minute. The rate of dust collection ranged from 0.47 to 0.63 pounds per minute. Based on these measurements, approximately 130 pounds of dust would likely be captured after just 4 hours of continuous grinding.
The rate of grinding a combination of vertical and horizontal joints while using the LEV system ranged from 2.3 to 3.3 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the use of the LEV system ranged from 2.6 to 3.4 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place ranged from 4.7 to 5.1 feet per minute. It’s important to note that: 1) the operator had limited experience using dust control systems and cut rates appeared to improve slightly over the 2-day period he used the tested equipment; and 2) the upper range of cut rates with the dust control system overlapped with the lowest cut rate with the original guard and without the LEV system in place indicating no statistical difference between cut rates. Given that grinding rates with and without use of this LEV system are only available for one operator and he had limited experience with the LEV system, these reported cut rates are in no way intended to represent the impact use of this LEV system is likely to have on productivity rates overall.
VI. Discussion
The objective of these trials was to evaluate the effectiveness of a tuckpointing LEV system for controlling respirable silica while grinding out mortar joints. The Dust Director shroud with the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced respirable silica concentrations when grinding with the Bosch grinder by approximately 99 percent. Despite being considered effective by our test criteria (greater than 50% reduction), it still resulted in task TWA exposures that exceeded the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 by 1.8 times. Depending on how much time is spent grinding over the course of a work day and on exposures while performing other tasks, the 8-hour TWA exposures may or may not exceed the REL with this system. Use of this system by workers with experience and training in proficient use will likely improve dust capture performance. Exposure reduction is greatly influenced by correct use of this system which includes grinding from right to left, making sure the shroud is held flush against the wall and that the tool travels at a pace that doesn’t exceed the ability of the system to capture dust as it’s generated. Deviation from any of these measures produces visible dust clouds which were observed during trials.
VII. Conclusions
With a 99 percent reduction in respirable silica exposure, the Dust Director shroud and DustControl 2900c vacuum with a Bosch Model 1775E grinder was effective in reducing silica exposures based on our criteria. Use of the tested dust control system may be effective in reducing silica exposure on the job to less than the NIOSH REL if used in combination with administrative controls such as work scheduling to reduce cutting times as needed. Training on correct use of the tested system is also essential. Personal air monitoring is necessary to verify control effectiveness on actual job sites and under “real-world” conditions. However, these results clearly demonstrate the availability of viable and effective engineering controls for tuckpointing operations associated with elevated silica exposure.
VIII. References
American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists. Threshold limit values for chemical substances (TLV®-CS). [2013]. ACGIH, Cincinnati, Ohio.
Bergdahl I.A,. Toren K., Eriksson K., et al. [2004]. Increased mortality in COPD among construction workers exposed to inorganic dust. European Respiratory Journal, 23: 402–06.
Blanc P.D. & Torén K. [2007]. Occupation in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and chronic bronchitis: an update [State of the Art Series. Occupational lung disease in high-and low-income countries, Edited by M. Chan-Yeung. Number 2 in the series]. The International Journal of Tuberculosis and Lung Disease, 11(3), 251-257.
Collingwood S. & Heitbrink W.A. [2007] 'Field Evaluation of an Engineering Control for Respirable Crystalline Silica Exposures During Mortar Removal'. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, 4:11, 875 – 887.
DHHS (NIOSH) Publication No. 2002-129 April 2002 http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/2002-129/
Echt A., Sieber W.K., Lefkowitz D., Meeker J., Susi P., Cardwell B., Heitbrink, W.A. In-depth survey of dust control technology for cutting concrete block and tuckpointing brick at The International Masonry Institute Bordentown Training Center, Bordentown, NJ. Cincinnati, OH: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Report. No. EPHB 282-13; 2007. http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ECTB-282-13.pdf
Heitbrink W., Bennett J. [2006]. A numerical and experimental investigation of crystalline silica exposure control during tuck pointing. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, Vol. 3, pp 366-378.
Lyons et al, [2007]. A breathless builder. Breathe, Vol. 3, no. 4, pp 386-390.
Mastrangelo G., Tartari M., Fedeli U., Fadda E., Saia B. [2003]. Ascertaining the risk of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease in relation to occupation using a case-control design. Occupational Medicine, 53: 165–172.
Meeker J., Cooper M., Lefrowitz D., Susi P. [2009]. Engineering control technologies to reduce occupational silica exposures in masonry cutting and tuckpointing. Public Health Reports, Supplement 1, Vol. 124, June.
Meeker J, Flynn M, Susi P, Cardwell, B [2004]. Performance evaluation of a masonry concrete vacuum. Unpublished Report.
Miller F. W., Alfredsson L., Costenbader K. H., Kamen D. L., Nelson L. M., Norris J. M., & De Roos A. J. [2012]. Epidemiology of environmental exposures and human autoimmune diseases: findings from a National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences Expert Panel workshop. Journal of autoimmunity. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3496812/
Occupational Safety and Health Administration U.S Department of Labor. Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction. [2009]. OSHA 3362-05.
Rappaport SM, Goldberg M, Susi P, Herrick RF [2003]. Excessive exposure to silica in the U.S. construction industry. Annals of Occupational Hygiene, Vol. 47, pp. 111-122.
IX. Appendices
| Measurement Conditions |
n | Mean Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Median
Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before filter cleaning | 5 | 80 | 81 | 78-81 |
| After filter cleaning following manufacturer directions | 9 | 89 | 90 | 84-93 |
| * Static pressure was measured in millibars and converted to inches of water gauge. Flow rates were calculated using the formula Q = Ce (A) 4005 (SP)1/2 where: Q = flow in cubic feet per minute (cfm), Ce = coefficient of entry, A = area of the duct where static pressure measurements were taken in square feet, and SP = static pressure in inches of water gauge. | ||||
| Tool/Control | Collection Period (min.) |
Dust Collection Rate (lb/min.) |
|---|---|---|
| Bosch grinder/Dust Director shroud & DustControl 2900c vacuum |
8 11 8 8 10 |
0.50 0.61 0.50 0.47 0.63 |
| Average | 0.54 |
[content_transformed:protected] =>
Executive Summary
This report describes the results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. It should also be noted that the NIOSH REL is based on exposures averaged over a ten hour work day and our results represent time weighted averages of the sample task duration periods.
Acronyms
ACGIH - American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists
CPWR - CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training
Ce - coefficient of entry
HEPA - high-efficiency particulate air
IUBAC - International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craftworkers
LEV - local exhaust ventilation
PACT - Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies
NIOSH - National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health
OEL - occupational exposure limit
OSHA - Occupational Safety and Health Administration
PAPR - powered air-purifying respirator
PEL - Permissible Exposure Limit
PVC - polyvinyl chloride
REL - Recommended Exposure Limit
RPM - revolutions per minute
TWA - time-weighted average
SP - static pressure
I. Introduction and Background
In 2010 CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training began a four-year project which seeks to identify and evaluate tuckpointing local exhaust ventilation (LEV) systems and disseminate information on their availability and effectiveness. A Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies (PACT) comprised of masonry contractors, representatives from unions, government, equipment manufacturers, and health and safety researcher was formed as part of this project. PACT members participated in identifying important characteristics for control technologies and this information was used to identify LEV systems for tuckpointing using that criteria. Contractor and labor members of the PACT selected specific tuckpointing LEV systems to be considered for evaluation. Each system consisted of a tuckpointing grinder, shroud, and vacuum. This report describes the second of four systems to be evaluated between 2012 the end of 2014, with and without LEV, in a controlled setting to determine effectiveness in silica exposure reduction. This report describes the methods and results of our evaluation of a system consisting of the DustControl 2900c vacuum with the ICS Dust Director shroud and a Bosch Model 1775E grinder.
Excessive exposure to respirable silica can result in silicosis or other silica-related diseases including pulmonary tuberculosis, lung cancer, silicoproteinosis (Lyons et al, 2007) and autoimmune disorders such as rheumatoid arthritis, sarcoidosis and scleroderma (Miller et al, 2012). Respirable silica is generally defined as particles less than 10 micrometers (μm) in aerodynamic diameter (ACGIH, 2013). Silicosis can lead to symptoms including shortness of breath, fatigue, chest pains, susceptibility to infection and possibly death. There is no cure for silicosis, however it is totally preventable. Construction workers exposed to dust, including silica, are also known to have higher rates of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD).
There are many sources of silica in construction that result in exposures of varying intensity among workers. Masonry restoration workers are among the most highly silica-exposed trades in construction. The process of grinding out deteriorated mortar joints between masonry units and replacing or repointing with fresh mortar (often referred to as tuckpointing) is a fundamental part of masonry restoration work. The removal of mortar with powered angle grinders generates enormous levels of dust. Between 2004 and 2006, NIOSH and CPWR evaluated silica exposures while grinding mortar in a controlled setting, at a local training center, where tasks, sample times and task variables were defined by the study design. These studies demonstrated that grinding mortar without controls can result in elevated respirable silica exposures. Meeker et al., (2009) reported exposures between 5 and 25.8 milligrams per cubic meter (mg/m3) in a controlled setting. This study also showed that LEV systems for tuckpointing grinders can reduce exposures to respirable silica by greater than 90 percent.II. Objectives
The objective of this evaluation was to assess the effectiveness of an LEV system for controlling exposure to silica during the grinding of mortar. The control technology was tested under controlled conditions, similar to those experienced by tuckpointers on actual job sites, using journeymen bricklayers experienced in tuckpointing and repeat, randomized trials with and without LEV. All other variables were held constant throughout so that the only variable was whether or not the tested control was used.
III. Description of Equipment Tested
A Bosch model 1775E grinder (Robert Bosch Tool Corporation, Prospect, IL) (Figures 1, 2 and 3) was fitted with a new 1/4-inch wide, 4½-inch diameter segmented diamond abrasive blade made by DeWalt (model #DW4740). The grinder weighs six and a half pounds, draws 8.5 amps and has a variable speed up to 11,000 revolutions per minute (RPMs). The DustControl 2900c vacuum (DustControl, Inc., Wilmington, NC) (Figure 3) was tested in combination with the Dust Director shroud (Industrial Contractors’ Supplies, Inc., Huntingdon, PA) (Figures 1 and 3) attached to the Bosch grinder.
Figure 1. Bosch grinder with Dust Director shroud
Figure 2. Bosch grinder without tuckpointing LEV system.
Figure 3: Bosch Grinder with LEV System
The vacuum is specified to weigh 31 pounds when empty and to provide a flow rate of 114 cubic feet of air per minute and a “static lift” or “vacuum suction pressure” of 84 inches of water. The vacuum is sold with a cyclonic pre-separator, to remove larger particles, a fine filter (rated 99.9 percent efficient) and a HEPA (high-efficiency particulate air) filter (rated to capture 99.97 percent of the particles with an aerodynamic diameter of 0.3 micrometers). The HEPA filter was removed based on the manufacturer’s recommendation due to the heavy dust loading associated with tuckpointing. CPWR sponsored research and contractor experience indicate that HEPA filters likely have an adverse effect on dust capture during tuckpointing because of extreme dust loading on filters. While the cyclone and the fine filter remove most of the dust, especially the large particles, before they reach the HEPA filter, the HEPA filter would still be subject to heavy loading, causing a substantial pressure drop and subsequent decrease in air flow rate. The relatively small increase in the efficiency of the filtration system while using the HEPA filter is expected to be quickly offset by a more significant decrease in capture efficiency as the air flow rate and ability to capture particles decreases.
Dust collects in relatively inexpensive, heavy-gauge plastic bags below and outside of the cyclone. The bags can be removed and replaced without opening the vacuum. Some vacuums are equipped with a light to indicate that the filters need to be cleaned or changed. The DC2900c features a “reverse air pulse cleaning system,” which removes accumulated dust from the filters without having to remove them from the vacuum. The system, as illustrated in Figure 4, requires the operator to disconnect the hose from the shroud, place it over an air stop so that air through the hose is cut off and pressure in the vacuum is maximized.
Figure 4. Procedure for "cleaning" of or dust removal from filters (source: http://dustcontrolusa.com/manuals/2800c.pdf)
The flap covering the port on the side of the vacuum is repeatedly flipped open to release built up pressure in strong pulses that dislodge dust from the filter.
The manufacturer indicates “the filter is generally cleaned once or twice daily during normal continuous operation.” The Dust Director shroud has a 2-inch diameter take-off that was connected to the antistatic, corrugated 1.5-inch diameter, 15-foot long vacuum hose supplied with the DustControl vacuum.
IV. Study Methods
This evaluation was conducted at the International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craft workers (IUBAC) Local 1 Philadelphia/Delaware Training Center in Philadelphia, PA on November 14 and 15, 2012. A single journeyman bricklayer, experienced in tuckpointing, used the grinder and LEV system being tested to remove mortar from joints wide enough to require two passes. The type S mortar had been allowed to cure for at least four weeks. The bricklayer either possessed or was provided with personal protective equipment including sturdy work boots, gloves, hearing protection and a powered air-purifying respirator (PAPR). The PAPR was a 3M GVP system with a bump cap, loose fitting face piece and a HEPA filter (3M, St Paul, MN).
The study was designed to include at least five rounds of sampling during mortar removal. Each round included a trial using the Bosch grinder with a Dust Director shroud and Dust Collector 2900c vacuum and a trial using the Bosch grinder with the factory-supplied guard and without a vacuum. The order of the two trials within each round was randomly selected to minimize bias that might be introduced due to variation associated with environmental factors, equipment operator, blade wear, vacuum performance over time and any other factors unrelated to LEV use. Tools were operated for approximately 16 minutes per trial with controls and for approximately 8 minutes when controls were not used. These times were selected based on the results of previous sampling efforts and estimates of the minimum sample time needed to achieve a limit of quantification low enough to accurately measure exposures down to or less than 0.05 mg/m3 – the NIOSH Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) for respirable silica. The bricklayer was required to take a 5 to 10 minute break in the middle of the 16-minute trials to reduce differences in fatigue, compared to the 8-minute trials. Personal air samples were collected in the breathing zone of the operator during each trial to measure respirable silica concentrations during grinding with and without LEV. The samples were collected using a GilAir-5 pump (Sensidyne, Inc., Clearwater, FL) to draw 4.2 liters of air per minute through a GK2.69 Respirable Cyclone (BGI Inc., Waltham, MA) with a pre-weighed, 37 mm diameter, 5-micron pore size polyvinyl chloride (PVC) filter positioned on the operator’s lapel.
The flow rates of the sampling pumps were calibrated at the beginning of each day using a DryCal DC-Lite Primary Flow Meter (Bios International Corporation, Butler, NJ). Flow rates were measured again near the middle and at the end of each day to ensure that sampling flow rates were maintained within 5% of pre-sampling flow rates throughout the day. Average flow rates were used to calculate sample air volumes. Samples were analyzed by R.J. Lee Group, Inc., (Monroeville, PA) using NIOSH Method 0600, to determine exposure to total mass of respirable dust. The same samples were also analyzed using X-Ray diffraction following NIOSH method 7500 to determine quartz, cristobalite and tridymite concentration in the respirable mass. Reported masses for these analytes were used with the sample air volumes to calculate airborne concentrations of total respirable dust, quartz, cristobalite and tridymite.
We used a reduction of greater than 50 percent in respirable silica exposure concentrations or a reduction to less than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 as our criteria for determining whether or not a control was considered efficacious. This is consistent with criteria used by NIOSH in conducting a similar study in 2004 described by Echt et al. (2007) and by CPWR in 2006 and described by Meeker et al. (2009). The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) and the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) publish additional occupational exposure limits (OELs) for silica which are listed in Table 1 with NIOSH RELs. OELs for silica are based on the respirable fraction of the aerosol, which consists of particles less than 10 micrometers in aerodynamic diameter.
| Organization or Agency | Form of Crystalline Silica | Occupational Exposure Limits (mg/m3) |
|---|---|---|
| NIOSHA | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 |
| OSHA - ConstructionB | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
PEL = 250 / (5 + % quartz) PEL = 250 / (5 + % cristobalite) PEL = 250 / (5 + % tridymite) |
| ACGIH | Crystalline Silica | TLV = 0.025 mg/m3 |
A NIOSH Publication No. 2005-151 indicates 10-hour time-weighted average during a 40-hr workweek B The PEL for silica in OSHA’s Safety and Health Regulations for Construction, 29 C.F.R. 1926.55(a), is an 8-hour time-weighted average (TWA) expressed in millions of particles per cubic foot (mppcf). However, the units mppcf can be converted to milligrams per cubic meter can by dividing mppcf by 10 (OSHA, 2009). The formula used by OSHA to determine the PEL for silica is dependent on the percentage of silica in each collected sample. The concentration of respirable dust measured is compared to the sample specific PEL to determine if the PEL has been exceeded. OSHA has proposed lowering the PEL to 0.05 mg/m3 of respirable silica as an 8 hour TWA. |
||
The flow of air in ventilation systems is governed by fundamental principles that describe the behavior of gases (in this case air). Pressure measurements taken within a ventilation system along with knowledge of hood (or shroud) entry losses can be used to calculate flow rates. Hood entry losses are dependent on the shape and configuration of a particular hood or shroud and described by the term “coefficient of entry (Ce)” which is the ratio of actual air flow through a hood and what the air flow would theoretically be if there were no hood entry losses. Given the coefficient of entry, static pressure measurements can be used to calculate air flow through a given hood. The coefficient of entry for the Dust Director shroud was previously determined by CPWR and used for calculating air flow based on static pressure measurements (Meeker et al., 2009). Static pressure, with the vacuum operating, was measured periodically throughout the evaluation to monitor the changes in air-flow rate following use and again after filter cleaning. The static pressure was measured at a port positioned more than 3 duct diameters downstream from the tool’s air intake using a UEi EM200 Electronic Manometer (Universal Enterprises, Inc., Beaverton, OR).
The dust in the vacuum bag was monitored and, per the manufacturer’s instructions, the bag was changed before the dust level was within 5 centimeters of the valve at the bottom of the vacuum. Each time a vacuum bag was removed, it was weighed to the nearest pound. The bag weights and corresponding grinding durations were used to calculate the average weight of dust collected per unit time. After each trial, cut lengths were measured on the wall to determine total linear feet of vertical (head) and horizontal (bed) joints per unit time.
A Haz-Dust III, Model HD-1003, Real-Time Aerosol Monitor (Environmental Devices Corporation, Plaistow, NH) was used to confirm clearance of dust between trials. The Haz-Dust monitor was positioned on the test wall near the operator at approximately breathing zone level and configured to measure respirable particulate concentration.
V. Results
Personal air monitoring
Five pairs of respirable dust samples were collected while grinding with and without the vacuum system. In addition, three respirable dust samples were collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place. One measurement collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard was shown to be a statistical outlier and was omitted from analysis. Personal air monitoring results for respirable silica and a comparison of average exposures relative to the NIOSH REL for silica (0.05 mg/m3) appears in Table 2. The mean respirable dust levels measured without LEV was 31.4 mg/m3. However, samples collected with LEV were below the limit of quantification (LOQ) which ranged from <1.29 to <1.46 mg/m3. Use of LEV resulted in a greater than 95% reduction in mean respirable dust levels using a mean value with use of LEV of <1.41 (n=5 samples with use of LEV and n=7 without use of LEV). The respirable dust samples collected during grinding without the LEV system contained an average of 24 percent silica. The mass of respirable dust in the samples collected with use of the LEV system was too low to determine the silica content.| Mean, mg/m3 (range) | Std. Dev. | Percent Reduction | Hazard RatioB | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bosch with Dust Director Shroud and DustControl 2900c Vacuum |
0.091 (<0.069 – 0.137) |
0.027 | 98.7 | 1.81 |
| Bosch with no Control | 7.23 (4.57 – 9.90) |
1.94 | NA | 145 |
A n = 5 samples for each tool/control combination and n = 7 samples without the use of the LEV system B Hazard Ratio = measured exposure / NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 |
||||
Average respirable silica and dust exposures, with and without the dust control system, appear as Figures 5 and 6, respectively.
Figure 5. Average respirable silica exposures with and without the Dustcontrol 2900c vacuum and Dust Director shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air - mg/m3)
Figure 6. Average respirable dust exposures with and without Dustcontrol 2900c Vacuum and Dust Director Shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air – mg/m3)
The mean respirable silica concentration measured during use of the control was significantly less than the concentration measured while using the same tool without controls (p<0.01). Grinding mortar with the Bosch angle grinder without dust controls resulted in an average exposure to respirable silica that was 145 times the NIOSH REL. Grinding with the Bosch angle grinder in combination with the Dust Director shroud and the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced the average concentration of respirable silica by 98.7 percent. With use of these controls, the concentration of respirable silica was 1.8 times greater than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3. However the NIOSH REL is based on a time-weighted average (TWA) over a 10-hour workday. Given these were task TWAs and samples were collected over continuous periods of grinding, they may overestimate exposures over an actual work day since some time would be spent performing tasks that would likely have lower, or no, silica exposures (setup, breaks, cleanup, etc.).
Static pressure, dust mass collection and grinding rates.
Static pressure was used as a surrogate for air flow as described earlier. Hood static pressure was measured periodically at a tap near the grinder more than 3 duct diameters from the air intake in the shroud. The static pressure, and thus air flow, was generally higher when the vacuum’s filter had recently been cleaned. The mean, median, and range of calculated flow rates are presented in Table A1 of the Appendix.
Based on the data we collected, the air-flow rate upstream from the Bosch grinder and Dust Director shroud ranged from 78 to 93 cubic feet per minute (cfm) with the DustControl vacuum. When the manufacturer’s filter cleaning procedure was followed the vacuum performed relatively well and flow could be maintained at slightly less than 90 cfm with cleaning. However, mean flow rates dropped substantially to 80 cfm after as little as 8 minutes of grinding without any filter cleaning. The flow rate returned to an average of 89 cfm when filters were cleaned correctly (without stopping air flow to the vacuum). Collingwood and Heitbrink (2007) found that the minimum exhaust flow rate for capture of silica and other particulate under ideal conditions is 21.25 cfm per inch of grinder blade diameter. This is equal to about 96 cfm when using a 4.5 inch diameter grinding blade. We set 106 cfm as the minimum desired flow rate for this study to allow a safety margin for potential decline in equipment performance and the possibility of inadequate maintenance, both of which may be likely after repeated use under actual work conditions. The DustControl vacuum provided slightly less than the minimum flow rate described by Collingwood and Heitbrink for a 4.5-inch blade and the peak flow rate fell with use.
The duration of vacuum bag use and mass of dust collected were recorded and are presented in Table A2 of the Appendix. The vacuum bags were changed and weighed after each trial utilizing the LEV system. A total of five bags were used to complete the five rounds of grinding. The DustControl vacuum captured 45 pounds of dust over 83 minutes of grinding for an average rate of dust collection of 0.54 pounds per minute. The rate of dust collection ranged from 0.47 to 0.63 pounds per minute. Based on these measurements, approximately 130 pounds of dust would likely be captured after just 4 hours of continuous grinding.
The rate of grinding a combination of vertical and horizontal joints while using the LEV system ranged from 2.3 to 3.3 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the use of the LEV system ranged from 2.6 to 3.4 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place ranged from 4.7 to 5.1 feet per minute. It’s important to note that: 1) the operator had limited experience using dust control systems and cut rates appeared to improve slightly over the 2-day period he used the tested equipment; and 2) the upper range of cut rates with the dust control system overlapped with the lowest cut rate with the original guard and without the LEV system in place indicating no statistical difference between cut rates. Given that grinding rates with and without use of this LEV system are only available for one operator and he had limited experience with the LEV system, these reported cut rates are in no way intended to represent the impact use of this LEV system is likely to have on productivity rates overall.
VI. Discussion
The objective of these trials was to evaluate the effectiveness of a tuckpointing LEV system for controlling respirable silica while grinding out mortar joints. The Dust Director shroud with the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced respirable silica concentrations when grinding with the Bosch grinder by approximately 99 percent. Despite being considered effective by our test criteria (greater than 50% reduction), it still resulted in task TWA exposures that exceeded the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 by 1.8 times. Depending on how much time is spent grinding over the course of a work day and on exposures while performing other tasks, the 8-hour TWA exposures may or may not exceed the REL with this system. Use of this system by workers with experience and training in proficient use will likely improve dust capture performance. Exposure reduction is greatly influenced by correct use of this system which includes grinding from right to left, making sure the shroud is held flush against the wall and that the tool travels at a pace that doesn’t exceed the ability of the system to capture dust as it’s generated. Deviation from any of these measures produces visible dust clouds which were observed during trials.
VII. Conclusions
With a 99 percent reduction in respirable silica exposure, the Dust Director shroud and DustControl 2900c vacuum with a Bosch Model 1775E grinder was effective in reducing silica exposures based on our criteria. Use of the tested dust control system may be effective in reducing silica exposure on the job to less than the NIOSH REL if used in combination with administrative controls such as work scheduling to reduce cutting times as needed. Training on correct use of the tested system is also essential. Personal air monitoring is necessary to verify control effectiveness on actual job sites and under “real-world” conditions. However, these results clearly demonstrate the availability of viable and effective engineering controls for tuckpointing operations associated with elevated silica exposure.
VIII. References
American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists. Threshold limit values for chemical substances (TLV®-CS). [2013]. ACGIH, Cincinnati, Ohio.
Bergdahl I.A,. Toren K., Eriksson K., et al. [2004]. Increased mortality in COPD among construction workers exposed to inorganic dust. European Respiratory Journal, 23: 402–06.
Blanc P.D. & Torén K. [2007]. Occupation in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and chronic bronchitis: an update [State of the Art Series. Occupational lung disease in high-and low-income countries, Edited by M. Chan-Yeung. Number 2 in the series]. The International Journal of Tuberculosis and Lung Disease, 11(3), 251-257.
Collingwood S. & Heitbrink W.A. [2007] 'Field Evaluation of an Engineering Control for Respirable Crystalline Silica Exposures During Mortar Removal'. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, 4:11, 875 – 887.
DHHS (NIOSH) Publication No. 2002-129 April 2002 http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/2002-129/
Echt A., Sieber W.K., Lefkowitz D., Meeker J., Susi P., Cardwell B., Heitbrink, W.A. In-depth survey of dust control technology for cutting concrete block and tuckpointing brick at The International Masonry Institute Bordentown Training Center, Bordentown, NJ. Cincinnati, OH: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Report. No. EPHB 282-13; 2007. http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ECTB-282-13.pdf
Heitbrink W., Bennett J. [2006]. A numerical and experimental investigation of crystalline silica exposure control during tuck pointing. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, Vol. 3, pp 366-378.
Lyons et al, [2007]. A breathless builder. Breathe, Vol. 3, no. 4, pp 386-390.
Mastrangelo G., Tartari M., Fedeli U., Fadda E., Saia B. [2003]. Ascertaining the risk of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease in relation to occupation using a case-control design. Occupational Medicine, 53: 165–172.
Meeker J., Cooper M., Lefrowitz D., Susi P. [2009]. Engineering control technologies to reduce occupational silica exposures in masonry cutting and tuckpointing. Public Health Reports, Supplement 1, Vol. 124, June.
Meeker J, Flynn M, Susi P, Cardwell, B [2004]. Performance evaluation of a masonry concrete vacuum. Unpublished Report.
Miller F. W., Alfredsson L., Costenbader K. H., Kamen D. L., Nelson L. M., Norris J. M., & De Roos A. J. [2012]. Epidemiology of environmental exposures and human autoimmune diseases: findings from a National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences Expert Panel workshop. Journal of autoimmunity. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3496812/
Occupational Safety and Health Administration U.S Department of Labor. Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction. [2009]. OSHA 3362-05.
Rappaport SM, Goldberg M, Susi P, Herrick RF [2003]. Excessive exposure to silica in the U.S. construction industry. Annals of Occupational Hygiene, Vol. 47, pp. 111-122.
IX. Appendices
| Measurement Conditions |
n | Mean Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Median
Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before filter cleaning | 5 | 80 | 81 | 78-81 |
| After filter cleaning following manufacturer directions | 9 | 89 | 90 | 84-93 |
| * Static pressure was measured in millibars and converted to inches of water gauge. Flow rates were calculated using the formula Q = Ce (A) 4005 (SP)1/2 where: Q = flow in cubic feet per minute (cfm), Ce = coefficient of entry, A = area of the duct where static pressure measurements were taken in square feet, and SP = static pressure in inches of water gauge. | ||||
| Tool/Control | Collection Period (min.) |
Dust Collection Rate (lb/min.) |
|---|---|---|
| Bosch grinder/Dust Director shroud & DustControl 2900c vacuum |
8 11 8 8 10 |
0.50 0.61 0.50 0.47 0.63 |
| Average | 0.54 |
[disclaimer:protected] => [disclaimer_transformed:protected] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [template] => record ) [_globalContext:PHPTAL_Context:private] => stdClass Object ( ) [_echoDeclarations:PHPTAL_Context:private] => [referer] => http://www.elcosh.org/document/3908/d001345/An%2BEvaluation%2Bof%2BSilica%2BExposure%2BControls%2Bfor%2BTuckpointing%253A%2BDustControl%2B2900c%2BVacuum%2Bwith%2Bthe%2BICS%2BDust%2BDirector%2BShroud%2Band%2BBosch%2BGrinder%2BModel%2B1775E%2BConducted%2BNovember%2B14-15%252C%2B2012.html [curr_module] => Record [styles] => Array ( ) [javascript] => Array ( [0] => jquery.min.js ) [metas] => Array ( [language] => en [robots] => index, follow ) [user] => [curr_url] => https://www.elcosh.org/index.php?module=Record&id=3908&type=document [base_url] => https://www.elcosh.org/index.php?module=Record [title] => eLCOSH : An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: DustControl 2900c Vacuum with the ICS Dust Director Shroud and Bosch Grinder Model 1775E Conducted November 14-15, 2012 [language] => en [search_query] => [module] => Record [new_records] => Array ( [0] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Fixed Ladder [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Fixed Ladders addresses the potential risks associated with using fixed ladders. The resource includes a brief case example,... [category] => Array ( [0] => 15 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 53 [5] => 55 [6] => 60 [7] => 64 [8] => 73 [9] => 76 [10] => 78 [11] => 80 [12] => 86 [13] => 87 [14] => 90 [15] => 92 [16] => 93 [17] => 94 [18] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Falls [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Concrete Polisher [11] => Electrical Worker [13] => HVAC [15] => Laborer [17] => PCC/Restoration [19] => Plumber/Pipefitter [21] => Roofer/Waterproofer [23] => Sheetmetal Worker [25] => Welder [27] => Commercial & Institutional [28] => Jobsites [29] => Industrial [31] => LEED/Green Construction [33] => Renovations [35] => Residential [37] => Toolbox Talks [38] => Documents [39] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4430/d001660/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BFixed%2BLadder.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [53] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 53 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Concrete Polisher [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [73] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 73 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => PCC/Restoration [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4430 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001660 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Fixed Ladder [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Fixed Ladders, Fall Prevention, Falls [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Fixed Ladders addresses the potential risks associated with using fixed ladders. The resource includes a brief case example, steps to prevent a related injury and questions for discussion. It includes an image that illustrates the hazard, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001257,d001254,d001255,d001256,d001258,d001262,d001279 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_completed:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/22/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [1] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Challenges Preventing Falling Objects [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Challenges Preventing Falling Objects addresses the hazards of being struck by falling objects on the job site. The resource... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 55 [5] => 64 [6] => 68 [7] => 71 [8] => 75 [9] => 78 [10] => 79 [11] => 82 [12] => 62 [13] => 86 [14] => 87 [15] => 88 [16] => 89 [17] => 91 [18] => 90 [19] => 92 [20] => 93 [21] => 94 [22] => 95 [23] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Electrical Worker [11] => Laborer [13] => Maintenance Worker [15] => Painter [17] => Plasterer [19] => Roofer/Waterproofer [21] => Scaffold Erector [23] => Stonemason [25] => Structural Ironworker [27] => Welder [29] => Commercial & Institutional [30] => Jobsites [31] => Demolition [33] => Disasters [35] => Heavy & Highway [37] => Industrial [39] => LEED/Green Construction [41] => Renovations [43] => Residential [45] => Underground [47] => Toolbox Talks [48] => Documents [49] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4431/d001661/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BChallenges%2BPreventing%2BFalling%2BObjects.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4431 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001661 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Challenges Preventing Falling Objects [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => dropped objects, falling objects, struck by incidents, struck by fatalities [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Challenges Preventing Falling Objects addresses the hazards of being struck by falling objects on the job site. The resource includes a brief example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates a group workers observing a scaffold free of debris during high winds, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001234,d001238,d001244,d001251,d001253,d001260,d001268,d001278 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_completed:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/22/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [2] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Tower Crane Safety [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Tower Crane Safety addresses the potential hazards of Tower Cranes and the importance of following procedure before and durin... [category] => Array ( [0] => 11 [1] => 12 [2] => 18 [3] => 70 [4] => 87 [5] => 88 [6] => 91 [7] => 90 [8] => 92 [9] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Cranes & Hoists [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Crushed/Struck By [6] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [9] => Operating Engineer [10] => Trades [11] => Commercial & Institutional [12] => Jobsites [13] => Demolition [15] => Heavy & Highway [17] => Industrial [19] => LEED/Green Construction [21] => Toolbox Talks [22] => Documents [23] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4427/d001657/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BTower%2BCrane%2BSafety.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [11] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 11 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Cranes & Hoists [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [18] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 18 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4427 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001657 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Tower Crane Safety [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Tower Crane, Crane, Stability, Tipping, Lift Zone Safety, Lift, Zone, Safety, Struck by [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Tower Crane Safety addresses the potential hazards of Tower Cranes and the importance of following procedure before and during Tower Crane operation. The resource includes a brief example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates a worker inspecting a Tower Crane before operation, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001234,d001238,d001250,d001251,d001253,d001258,d001262,d001273 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/19/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [3] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Work Zone Safety: Working Around Vehicles [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Working Around Vehicles in the Work Zone addresses methods to avoid being struck-by a vehicle on a construction site. The res... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 18 [2] => 52 [3] => 57 [4] => 70 [5] => 85 [6] => 87 [7] => 88 [8] => 89 [9] => 91 [10] => 90 [11] => 92 [12] => 93 [13] => 94 [14] => 95 [15] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [6] => Commercial Diver [7] => Trades [8] => Flagger [10] => Operating Engineer [12] => Truck Driver [14] => Commercial & Institutional [15] => Jobsites [16] => Demolition [18] => Disasters [20] => Heavy & Highway [22] => Industrial [24] => LEED/Green Construction [26] => Renovations [28] => Residential [30] => Underground [32] => Toolbox Talks [33] => Documents [34] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4428/d001658/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BWork%2BZone%2BSafety%253A%2BWorking%2BAround%2BVehicles.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [18] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 18 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [52] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 52 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Commercial Diver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [85] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 85 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Truck Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4428 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001658 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Daniela Caceres [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Work Zone Safety: Working Around Vehicles [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Struck, Struck by, Vehicle, Work Zone Safety, Truck, Operator, Driver, Mobile Equipment [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Working Around Vehicles in the Work Zone addresses methods to avoid being struck-by a vehicle on a construction site. The resource includes a case example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates the hazard, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001640 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/19/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [4] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Construction Dive -- DeWalt's Jobsite Pro headphones recalled for fire hazards [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => A recall notice by the United States Consumer Product Safety Commission affects over 300,000 DeWalt Jobsite Pro Headphones. The recall is a result of... [category] => Array ( [0] => 16 [1] => 44 [2] => 45 [3] => 46 [4] => 47 [5] => 48 [6] => 49 [7] => 50 [8] => 51 [9] => 52 [10] => 53 [11] => 54 [12] => 55 [13] => 56 [14] => 57 [15] => 58 [16] => 59 [17] => 60 [18] => 61 [19] => 64 [20] => 65 [21] => 66 [22] => 67 [23] => 68 [24] => 69 [25] => 70 [26] => 71 [27] => 72 [28] => 73 [29] => 74 [30] => 75 [31] => 76 [32] => 77 [33] => 63 [34] => 78 [35] => 79 [36] => 80 [37] => 81 [38] => 82 [39] => 62 [40] => 83 [41] => 84 [42] => 85 [43] => 86 [44] => 87 [45] => 88 [46] => 89 [47] => 91 [48] => 90 [49] => 92 [50] => 93 [51] => 94 [52] => 95 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Fire & Explosions [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Acoustical Ceiling Carpenter [4] => Trades [5] => Asbestos/Insulator [7] => Boilermaker [9] => Bricklayer [11] => Cabinetmaker [13] => Carpenter [15] => Carpet Layer [17] => Cement Mason [19] => Commercial Diver [21] => Concrete Polisher [23] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [25] => Electrical Worker [27] => Elevator Constructor [29] => Flagger [31] => Glazier [33] => Hazardous Waste Cleanup [35] => HVAC [37] => Interior Systems Carpenter [39] => Laborer [41] => Landscaper [43] => Lather [45] => Lead Abatement Worker [47] => Maintenance Worker [49] => Millwright [51] => Operating Engineer [53] => Painter [55] => Paper Hanger [57] => PCC/Restoration [59] => Pile Driver [61] => Plasterer [63] => Plumber/Pipefitter [65] => Refractory Worker [67] => Reinforcing Ironworker [69] => Roofer/Waterproofer [71] => Scaffold Erector [73] => Sheetmetal Worker [75] => Sprinkler Fitter [77] => Stonemason [79] => Structural Ironworker [81] => Terrazzo Worker [83] => Tile Setter [85] => Truck Driver [87] => Welder [89] => Commercial & Institutional [90] => Jobsites [91] => Demolition [93] => Disasters [95] => Heavy & Highway [97] => Industrial [99] => LEED/Green Construction [101] => Renovations [103] => Residential [105] => Underground ) [type] => [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4426/d001656/Construction%2BDive%2B--%2BDeWalt%2527s%2BJobsite%2BPro%2Bheadphones%2Brecalled%2Bfor%2Bfire%2Bhazards.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [16] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 16 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Fire & Explosions [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [44] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 44 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Acoustical Ceiling Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [45] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 45 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Asbestos/Insulator [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [46] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 46 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Boilermaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [48] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 48 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cabinetmaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [50] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 50 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpet Layer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [52] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 52 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Commercial Diver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [53] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 53 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Concrete Polisher [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [54] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 54 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [58] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 58 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Glazier [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [59] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 59 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Hazardous Waste Cleanup [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [65] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 65 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Landscaper [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [66] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 66 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Lather [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [67] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 67 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Lead Abatement Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [69] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 69 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Millwright [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [72] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 72 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Paper Hanger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [73] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 73 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => PCC/Restoration [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [77] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 77 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Refractory Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [81] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 81 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sprinkler Fitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [83] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 83 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Terrazzo Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [84] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 84 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Tile Setter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [85] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 85 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Truck Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4426 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001656 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Construction Dive -- DeWalt's Jobsite Pro headphones recalled for fire hazards [total_pages:protected] => 1 [billed_pages:protected] => 1 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => DeWalt, Fire Hazards, recall, headphones [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A recall notice by the United States Consumer Product Safety Commission affects over 300,000 DeWalt Jobsite Pro Headphones. The recall is a result of a malfunction that can cause earbuds to overheat while charging or during use, leading to fire and burn hazards. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => https://www.constructiondive.com/news/dewalts-jobsite-pro-headphones-recalled-for-fire-hazards/611248/?utm_source=Sailthru&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Issue:%202021-12-10%20Construction%20Dive%20Newsletter%20%5Bissue:38532%5D&utm_term=Construction%20Dive [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/13/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/13/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 12/13/21 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [new_images] => Array ( [0] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Morning Toolbox Talk [image] => /record/images/4003-p.jpg [blurb] => This photo is from an early morning toolbox talk on a construction job in Mclean, Virginia. It is being delivered in English and Spanish.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 20 [1] => 51 [2] => 57 [3] => 64 [4] => 70 [5] => 63 [6] => 78 [7] => 82 [8] => 62 [9] => 87 [10] => 88 [11] => 89 [12] => 91 [13] => 90 [14] => 93 [15] => 94 [16] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Safety Culture [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Cement Mason [4] => Trades [5] => Flagger [7] => Laborer [9] => Operating Engineer [11] => Reinforcing Ironworker [13] => Roofer/Waterproofer [15] => Stonemason [17] => Structural Ironworker [19] => Commercial & Institutional [20] => Jobsites [21] => Demolition [23] => Disasters [25] => Heavy & Highway [27] => Industrial [29] => Renovations [31] => Residential [33] => Images [34] => Media [35] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4003/i002691/Morning%2BToolbox%2BTalk.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4003 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002691 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Morning Toolbox Talk [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, Spanish, bilingual [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This photo is from an early morning toolbox talk on a construction job in Mclean, Virginia. It is being delivered in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001285,d001304,c000079 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [1] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox talk - crew view [image] => /record/images/4005-p.jpg [blurb] => Photo of crew listening to a toolbox safety talk before starting work.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 97 [1] => 20 [2] => 47 [3] => 49 [4] => 51 [5] => 55 [6] => 61 [7] => 64 [8] => 71 [9] => 75 [10] => 63 [11] => 79 [12] => 62 [13] => 87 [14] => 88 [15] => 91 [16] => 90 [17] => 93 [18] => 94 [19] => 95 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Images [1] => Media [2] => Media & Documents [3] => Safety Culture [4] => Work Environment [5] => Hazards [6] => Bricklayer [7] => Trades [8] => Carpenter [10] => Cement Mason [12] => Electrical Worker [14] => Interior Systems Carpenter [16] => Laborer [18] => Painter [20] => Plasterer [22] => Reinforcing Ironworker [24] => Scaffold Erector [26] => Structural Ironworker [28] => Commercial & Institutional [29] => Jobsites [30] => Demolition [32] => Heavy & Highway [34] => Industrial [36] => Renovations [38] => Residential [40] => Underground ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4005/i002692/Toolbox%2Btalk%2B-%2Bcrew%2Bview.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4005 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002692 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox talk - crew view [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, safety talk, Spanish [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Photo of crew listening to a toolbox safety talk before starting work. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002691,d001269, c000079, d001285 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [2] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox talk - long shot [image] => /record/images/4006-p.jpg [blurb] => This crew gathered every morning before starting work to discuss a new safety topic.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 20 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 55 [5] => 64 [6] => 68 [7] => 75 [8] => 76 [9] => 63 [10] => 78 [11] => 79 [12] => 82 [13] => 62 [14] => 87 [15] => 88 [16] => 91 [17] => 90 [18] => 93 [19] => 94 [20] => 95 [21] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Safety Culture [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Electrical Worker [11] => Laborer [13] => Maintenance Worker [15] => Plasterer [17] => Plumber/Pipefitter [19] => Reinforcing Ironworker [21] => Roofer/Waterproofer [23] => Scaffold Erector [25] => Stonemason [27] => Structural Ironworker [29] => Commercial & Institutional [30] => Jobsites [31] => Demolition [33] => Heavy & Highway [35] => Industrial [37] => Renovations [39] => Residential [41] => Underground [43] => Images [44] => Media [45] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4006/i002693/Toolbox%2Btalk%2B-%2Blong%2Bshot.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4006 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002693 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox talk - long shot [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, safety minute [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This crew gathered every morning before starting work to discuss a new safety topic. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002691,i002692,d001269,d000527 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [3] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Safety officer discussing ongoing project with marketing coordinator [image] => /record/images/4014-p.jpg [blurb] => The safety officer (left) points out the good safety practices on this project that reflect well on the firm and may influence future clients.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 97 [1] => 20 [2] => 46 [3] => 47 [4] => 49 [5] => 50 [6] => 51 [7] => 54 [8] => 55 [9] => 58 [10] => 60 [11] => 61 [12] => 64 [13] => 71 [14] => 75 [15] => 76 [16] => 63 [17] => 79 [18] => 80 [19] => 82 [20] => 62 [21] => 83 [22] => 87 [23] => 91 [24] => 90 [25] => 93 [26] => 94 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Images [1] => Media [2] => Media & Documents [3] => Safety Culture [4] => Work Environment [5] => Hazards [6] => Boilermaker [7] => Trades [8] => Bricklayer [10] => Carpenter [12] => Carpet Layer [14] => Cement Mason [16] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [18] => Electrical Worker [20] => Glazier [22] => HVAC [24] => Interior Systems Carpenter [26] => Laborer [28] => Painter [30] => Plasterer [32] => Plumber/Pipefitter [34] => Reinforcing Ironworker [36] => Scaffold Erector [38] => Sheetmetal Worker [40] => Stonemason [42] => Structural Ironworker [44] => Terrazzo Worker [46] => Commercial & Institutional [47] => Jobsites [48] => Heavy & Highway [50] => Industrial [52] => Renovations [54] => Residential ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4014/i002700/Safety%2Bofficer%2Bdiscussing%2Bongoing%2Bproject%2Bwith%2Bmarketing%2Bcoordinator.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [46] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 46 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Boilermaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [50] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 50 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpet Layer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [54] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 54 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [58] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 58 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Glazier [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [83] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 83 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Terrazzo Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4014 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002700 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Safety officer discussing ongoing project with marketing coordinator [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Latino, safety officer, safety culture [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The safety officer (left) points out the good safety practices on this project that reflect well on the firm and may influence future clients. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/index.php [more_like_this:protected] => d000989,d001351,d001362,d000652, d001101, d000931, d001395 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Hoar Construction, Photo by Neil Lippy [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 01/30/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [4] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Scaffolding at top of large column [image] => /record/images/3994-p.jpg [blurb] => This shot shows innovative guarding around the top of a large concrete column in the base of a high rise structure going up.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 15 [1] => 21 [2] => 47 [3] => 51 [4] => 63 [5] => 78 [6] => 79 [7] => 80 [8] => 62 [9] => 87 [10] => 97 [11] => 56 [12] => 64 [13] => 74 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Falls [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Scaffolds [6] => Bricklayer [7] => Trades [8] => Cement Mason [10] => Reinforcing Ironworker [12] => Roofer/Waterproofer [14] => Scaffold Erector [16] => Sheetmetal Worker [18] => Structural Ironworker [20] => Commercial & Institutional [21] => Jobsites [22] => Images [23] => Media [24] => Media & Documents [25] => Elevator Constructor [27] => Laborer [29] => Pile Driver ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/3994/i002689/Scaffolding%2Bat%2Btop%2Bof%2Blarge%2Bcolumn.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [21] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 21 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Scaffolds [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3994 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002689 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Scaffolding at top of large column [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Guardrail, railing, fall prevention, falls [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This shot shows innovative guarding around the top of a large concrete column in the base of a high rise structure going up. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/8/adjustable-tower-scaffold.html [more_like_this:protected] => c1002680,i002662,d000608,d001255 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Photo by Pam Susi [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2016 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_completed:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/01/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [5] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Construction bracing [image] => /record/images/3995-p.jpg [blurb] => This shows structural support that prevents collapses during construction.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 15 [2] => 21 [3] => 49 [4] => 51 [5] => 55 [6] => 56 [7] => 60 [8] => 64 [9] => 68 [10] => 74 [11] => 63 [12] => 78 [13] => 79 [14] => 80 [15] => 62 [16] => 87 [17] => 90 [18] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Falls [6] => Scaffolds [9] => Carpenter [10] => Trades [11] => Cement Mason [13] => Electrical Worker [15] => Elevator Constructor [17] => HVAC [19] => Laborer [21] => Maintenance Worker [23] => Pile Driver [25] => Reinforcing Ironworker [27] => Roofer/Waterproofer [29] => Scaffold Erector [31] => Sheetmetal Worker [33] => Structural Ironworker [35] => Commercial & Institutional [36] => Jobsites [37] => Industrial [39] => Images [40] => Media [41] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/3995/i002690/Construction%2Bbracing.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [21] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 21 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Scaffolds [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3995 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002690 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Construction bracing [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Bracing, support, scaffold [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This shows structural support that prevents collapses during construction. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/8/adjustable-tower-scaffold.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002660 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Photo by Pam Susi [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2016 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_completed:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/01/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [preview_mode] => [description] => The results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. [keywords] => tuckpointing, HEPA vacuum, dust control, LEV, local exhaust ventilation, silica [related_items] => Array ( [Research Reports] => Array ( [0] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1874 [old_id:protected] => 722 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000683 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Sharon Garber/COD [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Protecting Tuckpointing Workers from Silica Dust: Draft Recommendations for a Ventilated Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 12 [billed_pages:protected] => 12 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, vacuum, grinder, mortar, respirator, OSHA, NIOSH, exhaust, Heitbrink, tuckpointer, silica, masonry, dust, silicosis, LEV [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Describes draft recommendations for use of ventilated grinder to reduce dust during tuckpointing and describes field trials using these devices. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/hazard/67/chip-scrape-and-grind-surfaces-or-joints-silica.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001201,d000292,d000293,d000658 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2005 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/27/05 [date_completed:protected] => 04/26/05 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/20/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [1] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1940 [old_id:protected] => 909 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Workplace Solutions: Control of Hazardous Dust During Tuckpointing [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, silica, dust, tuckpoint, grinder, masonry restoration, mortar, vacuum [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d000819,d000820,d000730,d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 10/24/08 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/09 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [2] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3899 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001342 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: Hilti VC40-U Vacuum with Hilti DC-EX Dust Guard and Hilti Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 15 [billed_pages:protected] => 15 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP4 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => silica, tuckpointing, Hilti, local exhaust systems, LEV, shroud, quartz [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This report describes the results of an evaluation of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Hilti VC40-U vacuum, a Hilti DC-EX shroud, and a Hilti DAG-500 grinder. Randomized trials with and without use of the dust control system were conducted in a controlled setting. Removing mortar with the Hilti grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 220 times the National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05mg/m3. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 97 percent. However, exposures measured during the use of the dust control system still exceeded the NIOSH REL. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => December 1, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/05/14 [date_completed:protected] => 02/04/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/06/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [Handouts] => Array ( [0] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3656 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001198 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 24 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction While Doing Tuckpointing/Mortar Removal [total_pages:protected] => 2 [billed_pages:protected] => 2 [publication_number:protected] => DSG FS-3632 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Brick, block, tuckpointing, silica, local exhaust ventilation, LEV, masonry [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Tuckpointing creates some of the greatest exposures to silica in construction. This OSHA factsheet provides guidance on how to greatly reduce these exposures through the use of local exhaust ventilation. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863, d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => February 2013 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/04/13 [date_completed:protected] => 03/27/13 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [collections] => Array ( [3913] => ) [record] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => Array ( [867] => Author Object ( [id:protected] => 867 [organization_id:protected] => 0 [firstname:protected] => Michael [lastname:protected] => Cooper [address:protected] => [city:protected] => [province:protected] => [country:protected] => [postal_code:protected] => [department:protected] => [title:protected] => [phone:protected] => [fax:protected] => [email:protected] => [degree:protected] => [website:protected] => [about:protected] => [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => [date_completed:protected] => [date_billed:protected] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [481] => Author Object ( [id:protected] => 481 [organization_id:protected] => 0 [firstname:protected] => Pam [lastname:protected] => Susi [address:protected] => 8484 Georgia Avenue, Suite 1000 [city:protected] => Silver Spring [province:protected] => Maryland [country:protected] => USA [postal_code:protected] => 20910 [department:protected] => [title:protected] => [phone:protected] => 301-578-8500 ext.144 [fax:protected] => 301-578-8572 [email:protected] => plsusi@aol.com [degree:protected] => [website:protected] => http://www.cpwr.com [about:protected] => [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => 2003-10-02 [date_completed:protected] => 2003-10-06 [date_billed:protected] => 2003-11-03 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [organizations:protected] => Array ( [1] => Organization Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [elcosh_id:protected] => o000001 [user_id:protected] => 14 [province_id:protected] => 21 [country_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => CPWR - The Center for Construction Research and Training [address:protected] => Suite 1000, 8484 Georgia Ave [postal_code:protected] => 20910 [city:protected] => Silver Spring [department:protected] => [phone:protected] => 301-578-8500 [fax:protected] => 301-578-8572 [email:protected] => cpwrwebsite@cpwr.com [website:protected] => http://www.cpwr.com [filename:protected] => o000001.gif [about:protected] => CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training, developed, and continues to maintain/expand this website - The Electronic Library of Construction Occupational Safety and Health, www.elcosh.org. CPWR, formerly known as The Center to Protect Workers’ Rights, is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit research and training institution. Created by the Building and Construction Trades Department, AFL-CIO, CPWR serves as the research arm of the BCTD. Since the inception of its research agenda in 1990, CPWR has grown into a worldwide provider of safety and health information covering all aspects of the construction industry. CPWR launched eLCOSH in 2000, and the Spanish-language version of the site in 2001. CPWR also created, and continues to build, Construction Solutions - www.cpwrConstructionSolutions.org - a free, online database of construction hazards and ways to prevent, eliminate, or reduce them. [comments:protected] => [logo_available:protected] => T [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => 2000-08-18 [date_completed:protected] => 2000-08-30 [date_billed:protected] => 2000-09-05 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [collections:protected] => Array ( [3913] => ) [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => Array ( [1874] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1874 [old_id:protected] => 722 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000683 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Sharon Garber/COD [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Protecting Tuckpointing Workers from Silica Dust: Draft Recommendations for a Ventilated Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 12 [billed_pages:protected] => 12 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, vacuum, grinder, mortar, respirator, OSHA, NIOSH, exhaust, Heitbrink, tuckpointer, silica, masonry, dust, silicosis, LEV [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Describes draft recommendations for use of ventilated grinder to reduce dust during tuckpointing and describes field trials using these devices. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/hazard/67/chip-scrape-and-grind-surfaces-or-joints-silica.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001201,d000292,d000293,d000658 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2005 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/27/05 [date_completed:protected] => 04/26/05 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/20/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [1940] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1940 [old_id:protected] => 909 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Workplace Solutions: Control of Hazardous Dust During Tuckpointing [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, silica, dust, tuckpoint, grinder, masonry restoration, mortar, vacuum [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d000819,d000820,d000730,d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 10/24/08 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/09 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [2213] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 2213 [old_id:protected] => 1090 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => [language_id:protected] => 2 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Control del polvo peligroso que se genera durante los procesos de reparación de mortero [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => 2008-126 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => [comments:protected] => http://www.cdc.gov/spanish/niosh/docs/wp-solutions/2008-126_sp/ [summary:protected] => A Workplace Solutions de NIOSH que resume un estudio de NIOSH sobre los riesgos de exposición cuando se reparan las estructuras y los métodos para controlar el polvo. [A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust.] [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => D000819,D000820,D000730,d000819 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 01/07/10 [date_completed:protected] => 04/19/10 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 07/08/12 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [3656] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3656 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001198 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 24 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction While Doing Tuckpointing/Mortar Removal [total_pages:protected] => 2 [billed_pages:protected] => 2 [publication_number:protected] => DSG FS-3632 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Brick, block, tuckpointing, silica, local exhaust ventilation, LEV, masonry [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Tuckpointing creates some of the greatest exposures to silica in construction. This OSHA factsheet provides guidance on how to greatly reduce these exposures through the use of local exhaust ventilation. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863, d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => February 2013 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/04/13 [date_completed:protected] => 03/27/13 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [3899] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3899 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001342 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: Hilti VC40-U Vacuum with Hilti DC-EX Dust Guard and Hilti Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 15 [billed_pages:protected] => 15 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP4 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => silica, tuckpointing, Hilti, local exhaust systems, LEV, shroud, quartz [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This report describes the results of an evaluation of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Hilti VC40-U vacuum, a Hilti DC-EX shroud, and a Hilti DAG-500 grinder. Randomized trials with and without use of the dust control system were conducted in a controlled setting. Removing mortar with the Hilti grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 220 times the National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05mg/m3. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 97 percent. However, exposures measured during the use of the dust control system still exceeded the NIOSH REL. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => December 1, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/05/14 [date_completed:protected] => 02/04/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/06/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [content:protected] => [files:protected] => Array ( [559] => [560] => [546] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 546 [filename:protected] => 3.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:22 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [566] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 566 [filename:protected] => 4.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:23 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [720] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 720 [filename:protected] => 5.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [721] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 721 [filename:protected] => 6.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [722] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 722 [filename:protected] => 7.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [9765] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 9765 [filename:protected] => d001345.pdf [downloadable:protected] => T [timestamp:protected] => 2015-02-09 12:26:04 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3908 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001345 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: DustControl 2900c Vacuum with the ICS Dust Director Shroud and Bosch Grinder Model 1775E Conducted November 14-15, 2012 [total_pages:protected] => 13 [billed_pages:protected] => 13 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP2 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => tuckpointing, HEPA vacuum, dust control, LEV, local exhaust ventilation, silica [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => April 15, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 01/26/15 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/09/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [show_text] => [document_content] => ElcoshItemDocumentContent Object ( [id:protected] => 2934 [item_id:protected] => 3908 [type:protected] => main [title:protected] => [content:protected] =>
Executive Summary
This report describes the results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. It should also be noted that the NIOSH REL is based on exposures averaged over a ten hour work day and our results represent time weighted averages of the sample task duration periods.
Acronyms
ACGIH - American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists
CPWR - CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training
Ce - coefficient of entry
HEPA - high-efficiency particulate air
IUBAC - International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craftworkers
LEV - local exhaust ventilation
PACT - Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies
NIOSH - National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health
OEL - occupational exposure limit
OSHA - Occupational Safety and Health Administration
PAPR - powered air-purifying respirator
PEL - Permissible Exposure Limit
PVC - polyvinyl chloride
REL - Recommended Exposure Limit
RPM - revolutions per minute
TWA - time-weighted average
SP - static pressure
I. Introduction and Background
In 2010 CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training began a four-year project which seeks to identify and evaluate tuckpointing local exhaust ventilation (LEV) systems and disseminate information on their availability and effectiveness. A Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies (PACT) comprised of masonry contractors, representatives from unions, government, equipment manufacturers, and health and safety researcher was formed as part of this project. PACT members participated in identifying important characteristics for control technologies and this information was used to identify LEV systems for tuckpointing using that criteria. Contractor and labor members of the PACT selected specific tuckpointing LEV systems to be considered for evaluation. Each system consisted of a tuckpointing grinder, shroud, and vacuum. This report describes the second of four systems to be evaluated between 2012 the end of 2014, with and without LEV, in a controlled setting to determine effectiveness in silica exposure reduction. This report describes the methods and results of our evaluation of a system consisting of the DustControl 2900c vacuum with the ICS Dust Director shroud and a Bosch Model 1775E grinder.
Excessive exposure to respirable silica can result in silicosis or other silica-related diseases including pulmonary tuberculosis, lung cancer, silicoproteinosis (Lyons et al, 2007) and autoimmune disorders such as rheumatoid arthritis, sarcoidosis and scleroderma (Miller et al, 2012). Respirable silica is generally defined as particles less than 10 micrometers (μm) in aerodynamic diameter (ACGIH, 2013). Silicosis can lead to symptoms including shortness of breath, fatigue, chest pains, susceptibility to infection and possibly death. There is no cure for silicosis, however it is totally preventable. Construction workers exposed to dust, including silica, are also known to have higher rates of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD).
There are many sources of silica in construction that result in exposures of varying intensity among workers. Masonry restoration workers are among the most highly silica-exposed trades in construction. The process of grinding out deteriorated mortar joints between masonry units and replacing or repointing with fresh mortar (often referred to as tuckpointing) is a fundamental part of masonry restoration work. The removal of mortar with powered angle grinders generates enormous levels of dust. Between 2004 and 2006, NIOSH and CPWR evaluated silica exposures while grinding mortar in a controlled setting, at a local training center, where tasks, sample times and task variables were defined by the study design. These studies demonstrated that grinding mortar without controls can result in elevated respirable silica exposures. Meeker et al., (2009) reported exposures between 5 and 25.8 milligrams per cubic meter (mg/m3) in a controlled setting. This study also showed that LEV systems for tuckpointing grinders can reduce exposures to respirable silica by greater than 90 percent.II. Objectives
The objective of this evaluation was to assess the effectiveness of an LEV system for controlling exposure to silica during the grinding of mortar. The control technology was tested under controlled conditions, similar to those experienced by tuckpointers on actual job sites, using journeymen bricklayers experienced in tuckpointing and repeat, randomized trials with and without LEV. All other variables were held constant throughout so that the only variable was whether or not the tested control was used.
III. Description of Equipment Tested
A Bosch model 1775E grinder (Robert Bosch Tool Corporation, Prospect, IL) (Figures 1, 2 and 3) was fitted with a new 1/4-inch wide, 4½-inch diameter segmented diamond abrasive blade made by DeWalt (model #DW4740). The grinder weighs six and a half pounds, draws 8.5 amps and has a variable speed up to 11,000 revolutions per minute (RPMs). The DustControl 2900c vacuum (DustControl, Inc., Wilmington, NC) (Figure 3) was tested in combination with the Dust Director shroud (Industrial Contractors’ Supplies, Inc., Huntingdon, PA) (Figures 1 and 3) attached to the Bosch grinder.
Figure 1. Bosch grinder with Dust Director shroud
Figure 2. Bosch grinder without tuckpointing LEV system.
Figure 3: Bosch Grinder with LEV System
The vacuum is specified to weigh 31 pounds when empty and to provide a flow rate of 114 cubic feet of air per minute and a “static lift” or “vacuum suction pressure” of 84 inches of water. The vacuum is sold with a cyclonic pre-separator, to remove larger particles, a fine filter (rated 99.9 percent efficient) and a HEPA (high-efficiency particulate air) filter (rated to capture 99.97 percent of the particles with an aerodynamic diameter of 0.3 micrometers). The HEPA filter was removed based on the manufacturer’s recommendation due to the heavy dust loading associated with tuckpointing. CPWR sponsored research and contractor experience indicate that HEPA filters likely have an adverse effect on dust capture during tuckpointing because of extreme dust loading on filters. While the cyclone and the fine filter remove most of the dust, especially the large particles, before they reach the HEPA filter, the HEPA filter would still be subject to heavy loading, causing a substantial pressure drop and subsequent decrease in air flow rate. The relatively small increase in the efficiency of the filtration system while using the HEPA filter is expected to be quickly offset by a more significant decrease in capture efficiency as the air flow rate and ability to capture particles decreases.
Dust collects in relatively inexpensive, heavy-gauge plastic bags below and outside of the cyclone. The bags can be removed and replaced without opening the vacuum. Some vacuums are equipped with a light to indicate that the filters need to be cleaned or changed. The DC2900c features a “reverse air pulse cleaning system,” which removes accumulated dust from the filters without having to remove them from the vacuum. The system, as illustrated in Figure 4, requires the operator to disconnect the hose from the shroud, place it over an air stop so that air through the hose is cut off and pressure in the vacuum is maximized.
Figure 4. Procedure for "cleaning" of or dust removal from filters (source: http://dustcontrolusa.com/manuals/2800c.pdf)
The flap covering the port on the side of the vacuum is repeatedly flipped open to release built up pressure in strong pulses that dislodge dust from the filter.
The manufacturer indicates “the filter is generally cleaned once or twice daily during normal continuous operation.” The Dust Director shroud has a 2-inch diameter take-off that was connected to the antistatic, corrugated 1.5-inch diameter, 15-foot long vacuum hose supplied with the DustControl vacuum.
IV. Study Methods
This evaluation was conducted at the International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craft workers (IUBAC) Local 1 Philadelphia/Delaware Training Center in Philadelphia, PA on November 14 and 15, 2012. A single journeyman bricklayer, experienced in tuckpointing, used the grinder and LEV system being tested to remove mortar from joints wide enough to require two passes. The type S mortar had been allowed to cure for at least four weeks. The bricklayer either possessed or was provided with personal protective equipment including sturdy work boots, gloves, hearing protection and a powered air-purifying respirator (PAPR). The PAPR was a 3M GVP system with a bump cap, loose fitting face piece and a HEPA filter (3M, St Paul, MN).
The study was designed to include at least five rounds of sampling during mortar removal. Each round included a trial using the Bosch grinder with a Dust Director shroud and Dust Collector 2900c vacuum and a trial using the Bosch grinder with the factory-supplied guard and without a vacuum. The order of the two trials within each round was randomly selected to minimize bias that might be introduced due to variation associated with environmental factors, equipment operator, blade wear, vacuum performance over time and any other factors unrelated to LEV use. Tools were operated for approximately 16 minutes per trial with controls and for approximately 8 minutes when controls were not used. These times were selected based on the results of previous sampling efforts and estimates of the minimum sample time needed to achieve a limit of quantification low enough to accurately measure exposures down to or less than 0.05 mg/m3 – the NIOSH Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) for respirable silica. The bricklayer was required to take a 5 to 10 minute break in the middle of the 16-minute trials to reduce differences in fatigue, compared to the 8-minute trials. Personal air samples were collected in the breathing zone of the operator during each trial to measure respirable silica concentrations during grinding with and without LEV. The samples were collected using a GilAir-5 pump (Sensidyne, Inc., Clearwater, FL) to draw 4.2 liters of air per minute through a GK2.69 Respirable Cyclone (BGI Inc., Waltham, MA) with a pre-weighed, 37 mm diameter, 5-micron pore size polyvinyl chloride (PVC) filter positioned on the operator’s lapel.
The flow rates of the sampling pumps were calibrated at the beginning of each day using a DryCal DC-Lite Primary Flow Meter (Bios International Corporation, Butler, NJ). Flow rates were measured again near the middle and at the end of each day to ensure that sampling flow rates were maintained within 5% of pre-sampling flow rates throughout the day. Average flow rates were used to calculate sample air volumes. Samples were analyzed by R.J. Lee Group, Inc., (Monroeville, PA) using NIOSH Method 0600, to determine exposure to total mass of respirable dust. The same samples were also analyzed using X-Ray diffraction following NIOSH method 7500 to determine quartz, cristobalite and tridymite concentration in the respirable mass. Reported masses for these analytes were used with the sample air volumes to calculate airborne concentrations of total respirable dust, quartz, cristobalite and tridymite.
We used a reduction of greater than 50 percent in respirable silica exposure concentrations or a reduction to less than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 as our criteria for determining whether or not a control was considered efficacious. This is consistent with criteria used by NIOSH in conducting a similar study in 2004 described by Echt et al. (2007) and by CPWR in 2006 and described by Meeker et al. (2009). The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) and the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) publish additional occupational exposure limits (OELs) for silica which are listed in Table 1 with NIOSH RELs. OELs for silica are based on the respirable fraction of the aerosol, which consists of particles less than 10 micrometers in aerodynamic diameter.
| Organization or Agency | Form of Crystalline Silica | Occupational Exposure Limits (mg/m3) |
|---|---|---|
| NIOSHA | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 |
| OSHA - ConstructionB | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
PEL = 250 / (5 + % quartz) PEL = 250 / (5 + % cristobalite) PEL = 250 / (5 + % tridymite) |
| ACGIH | Crystalline Silica | TLV = 0.025 mg/m3 |
A NIOSH Publication No. 2005-151 indicates 10-hour time-weighted average during a 40-hr workweek B The PEL for silica in OSHA’s Safety and Health Regulations for Construction, 29 C.F.R. 1926.55(a), is an 8-hour time-weighted average (TWA) expressed in millions of particles per cubic foot (mppcf). However, the units mppcf can be converted to milligrams per cubic meter can by dividing mppcf by 10 (OSHA, 2009). The formula used by OSHA to determine the PEL for silica is dependent on the percentage of silica in each collected sample. The concentration of respirable dust measured is compared to the sample specific PEL to determine if the PEL has been exceeded. OSHA has proposed lowering the PEL to 0.05 mg/m3 of respirable silica as an 8 hour TWA. |
||
The flow of air in ventilation systems is governed by fundamental principles that describe the behavior of gases (in this case air). Pressure measurements taken within a ventilation system along with knowledge of hood (or shroud) entry losses can be used to calculate flow rates. Hood entry losses are dependent on the shape and configuration of a particular hood or shroud and described by the term “coefficient of entry (Ce)” which is the ratio of actual air flow through a hood and what the air flow would theoretically be if there were no hood entry losses. Given the coefficient of entry, static pressure measurements can be used to calculate air flow through a given hood. The coefficient of entry for the Dust Director shroud was previously determined by CPWR and used for calculating air flow based on static pressure measurements (Meeker et al., 2009). Static pressure, with the vacuum operating, was measured periodically throughout the evaluation to monitor the changes in air-flow rate following use and again after filter cleaning. The static pressure was measured at a port positioned more than 3 duct diameters downstream from the tool’s air intake using a UEi EM200 Electronic Manometer (Universal Enterprises, Inc., Beaverton, OR).
The dust in the vacuum bag was monitored and, per the manufacturer’s instructions, the bag was changed before the dust level was within 5 centimeters of the valve at the bottom of the vacuum. Each time a vacuum bag was removed, it was weighed to the nearest pound. The bag weights and corresponding grinding durations were used to calculate the average weight of dust collected per unit time. After each trial, cut lengths were measured on the wall to determine total linear feet of vertical (head) and horizontal (bed) joints per unit time.
A Haz-Dust III, Model HD-1003, Real-Time Aerosol Monitor (Environmental Devices Corporation, Plaistow, NH) was used to confirm clearance of dust between trials. The Haz-Dust monitor was positioned on the test wall near the operator at approximately breathing zone level and configured to measure respirable particulate concentration.
V. Results
Personal air monitoring
Five pairs of respirable dust samples were collected while grinding with and without the vacuum system. In addition, three respirable dust samples were collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place. One measurement collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard was shown to be a statistical outlier and was omitted from analysis. Personal air monitoring results for respirable silica and a comparison of average exposures relative to the NIOSH REL for silica (0.05 mg/m3) appears in Table 2. The mean respirable dust levels measured without LEV was 31.4 mg/m3. However, samples collected with LEV were below the limit of quantification (LOQ) which ranged from <1.29 to <1.46 mg/m3. Use of LEV resulted in a greater than 95% reduction in mean respirable dust levels using a mean value with use of LEV of <1.41 (n=5 samples with use of LEV and n=7 without use of LEV). The respirable dust samples collected during grinding without the LEV system contained an average of 24 percent silica. The mass of respirable dust in the samples collected with use of the LEV system was too low to determine the silica content.| Mean, mg/m3 (range) | Std. Dev. | Percent Reduction | Hazard RatioB | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bosch with Dust Director Shroud and DustControl 2900c Vacuum |
0.091 (<0.069 – 0.137) |
0.027 | 98.7 | 1.81 |
| Bosch with no Control | 7.23 (4.57 – 9.90) |
1.94 | NA | 145 |
A n = 5 samples for each tool/control combination and n = 7 samples without the use of the LEV system B Hazard Ratio = measured exposure / NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 |
||||
Average respirable silica and dust exposures, with and without the dust control system, appear as Figures 5 and 6, respectively.
Figure 5. Average respirable silica exposures with and without the Dustcontrol 2900c vacuum and Dust Director shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air - mg/m3)
Figure 6. Average respirable dust exposures with and without Dustcontrol 2900c Vacuum and Dust Director Shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air – mg/m3)
The mean respirable silica concentration measured during use of the control was significantly less than the concentration measured while using the same tool without controls (p<0.01). Grinding mortar with the Bosch angle grinder without dust controls resulted in an average exposure to respirable silica that was 145 times the NIOSH REL. Grinding with the Bosch angle grinder in combination with the Dust Director shroud and the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced the average concentration of respirable silica by 98.7 percent. With use of these controls, the concentration of respirable silica was 1.8 times greater than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3. However the NIOSH REL is based on a time-weighted average (TWA) over a 10-hour workday. Given these were task TWAs and samples were collected over continuous periods of grinding, they may overestimate exposures over an actual work day since some time would be spent performing tasks that would likely have lower, or no, silica exposures (setup, breaks, cleanup, etc.).
Static pressure, dust mass collection and grinding rates.
Static pressure was used as a surrogate for air flow as described earlier. Hood static pressure was measured periodically at a tap near the grinder more than 3 duct diameters from the air intake in the shroud. The static pressure, and thus air flow, was generally higher when the vacuum’s filter had recently been cleaned. The mean, median, and range of calculated flow rates are presented in Table A1 of the Appendix.
Based on the data we collected, the air-flow rate upstream from the Bosch grinder and Dust Director shroud ranged from 78 to 93 cubic feet per minute (cfm) with the DustControl vacuum. When the manufacturer’s filter cleaning procedure was followed the vacuum performed relatively well and flow could be maintained at slightly less than 90 cfm with cleaning. However, mean flow rates dropped substantially to 80 cfm after as little as 8 minutes of grinding without any filter cleaning. The flow rate returned to an average of 89 cfm when filters were cleaned correctly (without stopping air flow to the vacuum). Collingwood and Heitbrink (2007) found that the minimum exhaust flow rate for capture of silica and other particulate under ideal conditions is 21.25 cfm per inch of grinder blade diameter. This is equal to about 96 cfm when using a 4.5 inch diameter grinding blade. We set 106 cfm as the minimum desired flow rate for this study to allow a safety margin for potential decline in equipment performance and the possibility of inadequate maintenance, both of which may be likely after repeated use under actual work conditions. The DustControl vacuum provided slightly less than the minimum flow rate described by Collingwood and Heitbrink for a 4.5-inch blade and the peak flow rate fell with use.
The duration of vacuum bag use and mass of dust collected were recorded and are presented in Table A2 of the Appendix. The vacuum bags were changed and weighed after each trial utilizing the LEV system. A total of five bags were used to complete the five rounds of grinding. The DustControl vacuum captured 45 pounds of dust over 83 minutes of grinding for an average rate of dust collection of 0.54 pounds per minute. The rate of dust collection ranged from 0.47 to 0.63 pounds per minute. Based on these measurements, approximately 130 pounds of dust would likely be captured after just 4 hours of continuous grinding.
The rate of grinding a combination of vertical and horizontal joints while using the LEV system ranged from 2.3 to 3.3 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the use of the LEV system ranged from 2.6 to 3.4 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place ranged from 4.7 to 5.1 feet per minute. It’s important to note that: 1) the operator had limited experience using dust control systems and cut rates appeared to improve slightly over the 2-day period he used the tested equipment; and 2) the upper range of cut rates with the dust control system overlapped with the lowest cut rate with the original guard and without the LEV system in place indicating no statistical difference between cut rates. Given that grinding rates with and without use of this LEV system are only available for one operator and he had limited experience with the LEV system, these reported cut rates are in no way intended to represent the impact use of this LEV system is likely to have on productivity rates overall.
VI. Discussion
The objective of these trials was to evaluate the effectiveness of a tuckpointing LEV system for controlling respirable silica while grinding out mortar joints. The Dust Director shroud with the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced respirable silica concentrations when grinding with the Bosch grinder by approximately 99 percent. Despite being considered effective by our test criteria (greater than 50% reduction), it still resulted in task TWA exposures that exceeded the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 by 1.8 times. Depending on how much time is spent grinding over the course of a work day and on exposures while performing other tasks, the 8-hour TWA exposures may or may not exceed the REL with this system. Use of this system by workers with experience and training in proficient use will likely improve dust capture performance. Exposure reduction is greatly influenced by correct use of this system which includes grinding from right to left, making sure the shroud is held flush against the wall and that the tool travels at a pace that doesn’t exceed the ability of the system to capture dust as it’s generated. Deviation from any of these measures produces visible dust clouds which were observed during trials.
VII. Conclusions
With a 99 percent reduction in respirable silica exposure, the Dust Director shroud and DustControl 2900c vacuum with a Bosch Model 1775E grinder was effective in reducing silica exposures based on our criteria. Use of the tested dust control system may be effective in reducing silica exposure on the job to less than the NIOSH REL if used in combination with administrative controls such as work scheduling to reduce cutting times as needed. Training on correct use of the tested system is also essential. Personal air monitoring is necessary to verify control effectiveness on actual job sites and under “real-world” conditions. However, these results clearly demonstrate the availability of viable and effective engineering controls for tuckpointing operations associated with elevated silica exposure.
VIII. References
American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists. Threshold limit values for chemical substances (TLV®-CS). [2013]. ACGIH, Cincinnati, Ohio.
Bergdahl I.A,. Toren K., Eriksson K., et al. [2004]. Increased mortality in COPD among construction workers exposed to inorganic dust. European Respiratory Journal, 23: 402–06.
Blanc P.D. & Torén K. [2007]. Occupation in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and chronic bronchitis: an update [State of the Art Series. Occupational lung disease in high-and low-income countries, Edited by M. Chan-Yeung. Number 2 in the series]. The International Journal of Tuberculosis and Lung Disease, 11(3), 251-257.
Collingwood S. & Heitbrink W.A. [2007] 'Field Evaluation of an Engineering Control for Respirable Crystalline Silica Exposures During Mortar Removal'. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, 4:11, 875 – 887.
DHHS (NIOSH) Publication No. 2002-129 April 2002 http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/2002-129/
Echt A., Sieber W.K., Lefkowitz D., Meeker J., Susi P., Cardwell B., Heitbrink, W.A. In-depth survey of dust control technology for cutting concrete block and tuckpointing brick at The International Masonry Institute Bordentown Training Center, Bordentown, NJ. Cincinnati, OH: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Report. No. EPHB 282-13; 2007. http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ECTB-282-13.pdf
Heitbrink W., Bennett J. [2006]. A numerical and experimental investigation of crystalline silica exposure control during tuck pointing. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, Vol. 3, pp 366-378.
Lyons et al, [2007]. A breathless builder. Breathe, Vol. 3, no. 4, pp 386-390.
Mastrangelo G., Tartari M., Fedeli U., Fadda E., Saia B. [2003]. Ascertaining the risk of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease in relation to occupation using a case-control design. Occupational Medicine, 53: 165–172.
Meeker J., Cooper M., Lefrowitz D., Susi P. [2009]. Engineering control technologies to reduce occupational silica exposures in masonry cutting and tuckpointing. Public Health Reports, Supplement 1, Vol. 124, June.
Meeker J, Flynn M, Susi P, Cardwell, B [2004]. Performance evaluation of a masonry concrete vacuum. Unpublished Report.
Miller F. W., Alfredsson L., Costenbader K. H., Kamen D. L., Nelson L. M., Norris J. M., & De Roos A. J. [2012]. Epidemiology of environmental exposures and human autoimmune diseases: findings from a National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences Expert Panel workshop. Journal of autoimmunity. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3496812/
Occupational Safety and Health Administration U.S Department of Labor. Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction. [2009]. OSHA 3362-05.
Rappaport SM, Goldberg M, Susi P, Herrick RF [2003]. Excessive exposure to silica in the U.S. construction industry. Annals of Occupational Hygiene, Vol. 47, pp. 111-122.
IX. Appendices
| Measurement Conditions |
n | Mean Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Median
Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before filter cleaning | 5 | 80 | 81 | 78-81 |
| After filter cleaning following manufacturer directions | 9 | 89 | 90 | 84-93 |
| * Static pressure was measured in millibars and converted to inches of water gauge. Flow rates were calculated using the formula Q = Ce (A) 4005 (SP)1/2 where: Q = flow in cubic feet per minute (cfm), Ce = coefficient of entry, A = area of the duct where static pressure measurements were taken in square feet, and SP = static pressure in inches of water gauge. | ||||
| Tool/Control | Collection Period (min.) |
Dust Collection Rate (lb/min.) |
|---|---|---|
| Bosch grinder/Dust Director shroud & DustControl 2900c vacuum |
8 11 8 8 10 |
0.50 0.61 0.50 0.47 0.63 |
| Average | 0.54 |
[content_transformed:protected] =>
Executive Summary
This report describes the results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. It should also be noted that the NIOSH REL is based on exposures averaged over a ten hour work day and our results represent time weighted averages of the sample task duration periods.
Acronyms
ACGIH - American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists
CPWR - CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training
Ce - coefficient of entry
HEPA - high-efficiency particulate air
IUBAC - International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craftworkers
LEV - local exhaust ventilation
PACT - Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies
NIOSH - National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health
OEL - occupational exposure limit
OSHA - Occupational Safety and Health Administration
PAPR - powered air-purifying respirator
PEL - Permissible Exposure Limit
PVC - polyvinyl chloride
REL - Recommended Exposure Limit
RPM - revolutions per minute
TWA - time-weighted average
SP - static pressure
I. Introduction and Background
In 2010 CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training began a four-year project which seeks to identify and evaluate tuckpointing local exhaust ventilation (LEV) systems and disseminate information on their availability and effectiveness. A Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies (PACT) comprised of masonry contractors, representatives from unions, government, equipment manufacturers, and health and safety researcher was formed as part of this project. PACT members participated in identifying important characteristics for control technologies and this information was used to identify LEV systems for tuckpointing using that criteria. Contractor and labor members of the PACT selected specific tuckpointing LEV systems to be considered for evaluation. Each system consisted of a tuckpointing grinder, shroud, and vacuum. This report describes the second of four systems to be evaluated between 2012 the end of 2014, with and without LEV, in a controlled setting to determine effectiveness in silica exposure reduction. This report describes the methods and results of our evaluation of a system consisting of the DustControl 2900c vacuum with the ICS Dust Director shroud and a Bosch Model 1775E grinder.
Excessive exposure to respirable silica can result in silicosis or other silica-related diseases including pulmonary tuberculosis, lung cancer, silicoproteinosis (Lyons et al, 2007) and autoimmune disorders such as rheumatoid arthritis, sarcoidosis and scleroderma (Miller et al, 2012). Respirable silica is generally defined as particles less than 10 micrometers (μm) in aerodynamic diameter (ACGIH, 2013). Silicosis can lead to symptoms including shortness of breath, fatigue, chest pains, susceptibility to infection and possibly death. There is no cure for silicosis, however it is totally preventable. Construction workers exposed to dust, including silica, are also known to have higher rates of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD).
There are many sources of silica in construction that result in exposures of varying intensity among workers. Masonry restoration workers are among the most highly silica-exposed trades in construction. The process of grinding out deteriorated mortar joints between masonry units and replacing or repointing with fresh mortar (often referred to as tuckpointing) is a fundamental part of masonry restoration work. The removal of mortar with powered angle grinders generates enormous levels of dust. Between 2004 and 2006, NIOSH and CPWR evaluated silica exposures while grinding mortar in a controlled setting, at a local training center, where tasks, sample times and task variables were defined by the study design. These studies demonstrated that grinding mortar without controls can result in elevated respirable silica exposures. Meeker et al., (2009) reported exposures between 5 and 25.8 milligrams per cubic meter (mg/m3) in a controlled setting. This study also showed that LEV systems for tuckpointing grinders can reduce exposures to respirable silica by greater than 90 percent.II. Objectives
The objective of this evaluation was to assess the effectiveness of an LEV system for controlling exposure to silica during the grinding of mortar. The control technology was tested under controlled conditions, similar to those experienced by tuckpointers on actual job sites, using journeymen bricklayers experienced in tuckpointing and repeat, randomized trials with and without LEV. All other variables were held constant throughout so that the only variable was whether or not the tested control was used.
III. Description of Equipment Tested
A Bosch model 1775E grinder (Robert Bosch Tool Corporation, Prospect, IL) (Figures 1, 2 and 3) was fitted with a new 1/4-inch wide, 4½-inch diameter segmented diamond abrasive blade made by DeWalt (model #DW4740). The grinder weighs six and a half pounds, draws 8.5 amps and has a variable speed up to 11,000 revolutions per minute (RPMs). The DustControl 2900c vacuum (DustControl, Inc., Wilmington, NC) (Figure 3) was tested in combination with the Dust Director shroud (Industrial Contractors’ Supplies, Inc., Huntingdon, PA) (Figures 1 and 3) attached to the Bosch grinder.
Figure 1. Bosch grinder with Dust Director shroud
Figure 2. Bosch grinder without tuckpointing LEV system.
Figure 3: Bosch Grinder with LEV System
The vacuum is specified to weigh 31 pounds when empty and to provide a flow rate of 114 cubic feet of air per minute and a “static lift” or “vacuum suction pressure” of 84 inches of water. The vacuum is sold with a cyclonic pre-separator, to remove larger particles, a fine filter (rated 99.9 percent efficient) and a HEPA (high-efficiency particulate air) filter (rated to capture 99.97 percent of the particles with an aerodynamic diameter of 0.3 micrometers). The HEPA filter was removed based on the manufacturer’s recommendation due to the heavy dust loading associated with tuckpointing. CPWR sponsored research and contractor experience indicate that HEPA filters likely have an adverse effect on dust capture during tuckpointing because of extreme dust loading on filters. While the cyclone and the fine filter remove most of the dust, especially the large particles, before they reach the HEPA filter, the HEPA filter would still be subject to heavy loading, causing a substantial pressure drop and subsequent decrease in air flow rate. The relatively small increase in the efficiency of the filtration system while using the HEPA filter is expected to be quickly offset by a more significant decrease in capture efficiency as the air flow rate and ability to capture particles decreases.
Dust collects in relatively inexpensive, heavy-gauge plastic bags below and outside of the cyclone. The bags can be removed and replaced without opening the vacuum. Some vacuums are equipped with a light to indicate that the filters need to be cleaned or changed. The DC2900c features a “reverse air pulse cleaning system,” which removes accumulated dust from the filters without having to remove them from the vacuum. The system, as illustrated in Figure 4, requires the operator to disconnect the hose from the shroud, place it over an air stop so that air through the hose is cut off and pressure in the vacuum is maximized.
Figure 4. Procedure for "cleaning" of or dust removal from filters (source: http://dustcontrolusa.com/manuals/2800c.pdf)
The flap covering the port on the side of the vacuum is repeatedly flipped open to release built up pressure in strong pulses that dislodge dust from the filter.
The manufacturer indicates “the filter is generally cleaned once or twice daily during normal continuous operation.” The Dust Director shroud has a 2-inch diameter take-off that was connected to the antistatic, corrugated 1.5-inch diameter, 15-foot long vacuum hose supplied with the DustControl vacuum.
IV. Study Methods
This evaluation was conducted at the International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craft workers (IUBAC) Local 1 Philadelphia/Delaware Training Center in Philadelphia, PA on November 14 and 15, 2012. A single journeyman bricklayer, experienced in tuckpointing, used the grinder and LEV system being tested to remove mortar from joints wide enough to require two passes. The type S mortar had been allowed to cure for at least four weeks. The bricklayer either possessed or was provided with personal protective equipment including sturdy work boots, gloves, hearing protection and a powered air-purifying respirator (PAPR). The PAPR was a 3M GVP system with a bump cap, loose fitting face piece and a HEPA filter (3M, St Paul, MN).
The study was designed to include at least five rounds of sampling during mortar removal. Each round included a trial using the Bosch grinder with a Dust Director shroud and Dust Collector 2900c vacuum and a trial using the Bosch grinder with the factory-supplied guard and without a vacuum. The order of the two trials within each round was randomly selected to minimize bias that might be introduced due to variation associated with environmental factors, equipment operator, blade wear, vacuum performance over time and any other factors unrelated to LEV use. Tools were operated for approximately 16 minutes per trial with controls and for approximately 8 minutes when controls were not used. These times were selected based on the results of previous sampling efforts and estimates of the minimum sample time needed to achieve a limit of quantification low enough to accurately measure exposures down to or less than 0.05 mg/m3 – the NIOSH Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) for respirable silica. The bricklayer was required to take a 5 to 10 minute break in the middle of the 16-minute trials to reduce differences in fatigue, compared to the 8-minute trials. Personal air samples were collected in the breathing zone of the operator during each trial to measure respirable silica concentrations during grinding with and without LEV. The samples were collected using a GilAir-5 pump (Sensidyne, Inc., Clearwater, FL) to draw 4.2 liters of air per minute through a GK2.69 Respirable Cyclone (BGI Inc., Waltham, MA) with a pre-weighed, 37 mm diameter, 5-micron pore size polyvinyl chloride (PVC) filter positioned on the operator’s lapel.
The flow rates of the sampling pumps were calibrated at the beginning of each day using a DryCal DC-Lite Primary Flow Meter (Bios International Corporation, Butler, NJ). Flow rates were measured again near the middle and at the end of each day to ensure that sampling flow rates were maintained within 5% of pre-sampling flow rates throughout the day. Average flow rates were used to calculate sample air volumes. Samples were analyzed by R.J. Lee Group, Inc., (Monroeville, PA) using NIOSH Method 0600, to determine exposure to total mass of respirable dust. The same samples were also analyzed using X-Ray diffraction following NIOSH method 7500 to determine quartz, cristobalite and tridymite concentration in the respirable mass. Reported masses for these analytes were used with the sample air volumes to calculate airborne concentrations of total respirable dust, quartz, cristobalite and tridymite.
We used a reduction of greater than 50 percent in respirable silica exposure concentrations or a reduction to less than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 as our criteria for determining whether or not a control was considered efficacious. This is consistent with criteria used by NIOSH in conducting a similar study in 2004 described by Echt et al. (2007) and by CPWR in 2006 and described by Meeker et al. (2009). The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) and the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) publish additional occupational exposure limits (OELs) for silica which are listed in Table 1 with NIOSH RELs. OELs for silica are based on the respirable fraction of the aerosol, which consists of particles less than 10 micrometers in aerodynamic diameter.
| Organization or Agency | Form of Crystalline Silica | Occupational Exposure Limits (mg/m3) |
|---|---|---|
| NIOSHA | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 |
| OSHA - ConstructionB | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
PEL = 250 / (5 + % quartz) PEL = 250 / (5 + % cristobalite) PEL = 250 / (5 + % tridymite) |
| ACGIH | Crystalline Silica | TLV = 0.025 mg/m3 |
A NIOSH Publication No. 2005-151 indicates 10-hour time-weighted average during a 40-hr workweek B The PEL for silica in OSHA’s Safety and Health Regulations for Construction, 29 C.F.R. 1926.55(a), is an 8-hour time-weighted average (TWA) expressed in millions of particles per cubic foot (mppcf). However, the units mppcf can be converted to milligrams per cubic meter can by dividing mppcf by 10 (OSHA, 2009). The formula used by OSHA to determine the PEL for silica is dependent on the percentage of silica in each collected sample. The concentration of respirable dust measured is compared to the sample specific PEL to determine if the PEL has been exceeded. OSHA has proposed lowering the PEL to 0.05 mg/m3 of respirable silica as an 8 hour TWA. |
||
The flow of air in ventilation systems is governed by fundamental principles that describe the behavior of gases (in this case air). Pressure measurements taken within a ventilation system along with knowledge of hood (or shroud) entry losses can be used to calculate flow rates. Hood entry losses are dependent on the shape and configuration of a particular hood or shroud and described by the term “coefficient of entry (Ce)” which is the ratio of actual air flow through a hood and what the air flow would theoretically be if there were no hood entry losses. Given the coefficient of entry, static pressure measurements can be used to calculate air flow through a given hood. The coefficient of entry for the Dust Director shroud was previously determined by CPWR and used for calculating air flow based on static pressure measurements (Meeker et al., 2009). Static pressure, with the vacuum operating, was measured periodically throughout the evaluation to monitor the changes in air-flow rate following use and again after filter cleaning. The static pressure was measured at a port positioned more than 3 duct diameters downstream from the tool’s air intake using a UEi EM200 Electronic Manometer (Universal Enterprises, Inc., Beaverton, OR).
The dust in the vacuum bag was monitored and, per the manufacturer’s instructions, the bag was changed before the dust level was within 5 centimeters of the valve at the bottom of the vacuum. Each time a vacuum bag was removed, it was weighed to the nearest pound. The bag weights and corresponding grinding durations were used to calculate the average weight of dust collected per unit time. After each trial, cut lengths were measured on the wall to determine total linear feet of vertical (head) and horizontal (bed) joints per unit time.
A Haz-Dust III, Model HD-1003, Real-Time Aerosol Monitor (Environmental Devices Corporation, Plaistow, NH) was used to confirm clearance of dust between trials. The Haz-Dust monitor was positioned on the test wall near the operator at approximately breathing zone level and configured to measure respirable particulate concentration.
V. Results
Personal air monitoring
Five pairs of respirable dust samples were collected while grinding with and without the vacuum system. In addition, three respirable dust samples were collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place. One measurement collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard was shown to be a statistical outlier and was omitted from analysis. Personal air monitoring results for respirable silica and a comparison of average exposures relative to the NIOSH REL for silica (0.05 mg/m3) appears in Table 2. The mean respirable dust levels measured without LEV was 31.4 mg/m3. However, samples collected with LEV were below the limit of quantification (LOQ) which ranged from <1.29 to <1.46 mg/m3. Use of LEV resulted in a greater than 95% reduction in mean respirable dust levels using a mean value with use of LEV of <1.41 (n=5 samples with use of LEV and n=7 without use of LEV). The respirable dust samples collected during grinding without the LEV system contained an average of 24 percent silica. The mass of respirable dust in the samples collected with use of the LEV system was too low to determine the silica content.| Mean, mg/m3 (range) | Std. Dev. | Percent Reduction | Hazard RatioB | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bosch with Dust Director Shroud and DustControl 2900c Vacuum |
0.091 (<0.069 – 0.137) |
0.027 | 98.7 | 1.81 |
| Bosch with no Control | 7.23 (4.57 – 9.90) |
1.94 | NA | 145 |
A n = 5 samples for each tool/control combination and n = 7 samples without the use of the LEV system B Hazard Ratio = measured exposure / NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 |
||||
Average respirable silica and dust exposures, with and without the dust control system, appear as Figures 5 and 6, respectively.
Figure 5. Average respirable silica exposures with and without the Dustcontrol 2900c vacuum and Dust Director shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air - mg/m3)
Figure 6. Average respirable dust exposures with and without Dustcontrol 2900c Vacuum and Dust Director Shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air – mg/m3)
The mean respirable silica concentration measured during use of the control was significantly less than the concentration measured while using the same tool without controls (p<0.01). Grinding mortar with the Bosch angle grinder without dust controls resulted in an average exposure to respirable silica that was 145 times the NIOSH REL. Grinding with the Bosch angle grinder in combination with the Dust Director shroud and the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced the average concentration of respirable silica by 98.7 percent. With use of these controls, the concentration of respirable silica was 1.8 times greater than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3. However the NIOSH REL is based on a time-weighted average (TWA) over a 10-hour workday. Given these were task TWAs and samples were collected over continuous periods of grinding, they may overestimate exposures over an actual work day since some time would be spent performing tasks that would likely have lower, or no, silica exposures (setup, breaks, cleanup, etc.).
Static pressure, dust mass collection and grinding rates.
Static pressure was used as a surrogate for air flow as described earlier. Hood static pressure was measured periodically at a tap near the grinder more than 3 duct diameters from the air intake in the shroud. The static pressure, and thus air flow, was generally higher when the vacuum’s filter had recently been cleaned. The mean, median, and range of calculated flow rates are presented in Table A1 of the Appendix.
Based on the data we collected, the air-flow rate upstream from the Bosch grinder and Dust Director shroud ranged from 78 to 93 cubic feet per minute (cfm) with the DustControl vacuum. When the manufacturer’s filter cleaning procedure was followed the vacuum performed relatively well and flow could be maintained at slightly less than 90 cfm with cleaning. However, mean flow rates dropped substantially to 80 cfm after as little as 8 minutes of grinding without any filter cleaning. The flow rate returned to an average of 89 cfm when filters were cleaned correctly (without stopping air flow to the vacuum). Collingwood and Heitbrink (2007) found that the minimum exhaust flow rate for capture of silica and other particulate under ideal conditions is 21.25 cfm per inch of grinder blade diameter. This is equal to about 96 cfm when using a 4.5 inch diameter grinding blade. We set 106 cfm as the minimum desired flow rate for this study to allow a safety margin for potential decline in equipment performance and the possibility of inadequate maintenance, both of which may be likely after repeated use under actual work conditions. The DustControl vacuum provided slightly less than the minimum flow rate described by Collingwood and Heitbrink for a 4.5-inch blade and the peak flow rate fell with use.
The duration of vacuum bag use and mass of dust collected were recorded and are presented in Table A2 of the Appendix. The vacuum bags were changed and weighed after each trial utilizing the LEV system. A total of five bags were used to complete the five rounds of grinding. The DustControl vacuum captured 45 pounds of dust over 83 minutes of grinding for an average rate of dust collection of 0.54 pounds per minute. The rate of dust collection ranged from 0.47 to 0.63 pounds per minute. Based on these measurements, approximately 130 pounds of dust would likely be captured after just 4 hours of continuous grinding.
The rate of grinding a combination of vertical and horizontal joints while using the LEV system ranged from 2.3 to 3.3 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the use of the LEV system ranged from 2.6 to 3.4 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place ranged from 4.7 to 5.1 feet per minute. It’s important to note that: 1) the operator had limited experience using dust control systems and cut rates appeared to improve slightly over the 2-day period he used the tested equipment; and 2) the upper range of cut rates with the dust control system overlapped with the lowest cut rate with the original guard and without the LEV system in place indicating no statistical difference between cut rates. Given that grinding rates with and without use of this LEV system are only available for one operator and he had limited experience with the LEV system, these reported cut rates are in no way intended to represent the impact use of this LEV system is likely to have on productivity rates overall.
VI. Discussion
The objective of these trials was to evaluate the effectiveness of a tuckpointing LEV system for controlling respirable silica while grinding out mortar joints. The Dust Director shroud with the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced respirable silica concentrations when grinding with the Bosch grinder by approximately 99 percent. Despite being considered effective by our test criteria (greater than 50% reduction), it still resulted in task TWA exposures that exceeded the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 by 1.8 times. Depending on how much time is spent grinding over the course of a work day and on exposures while performing other tasks, the 8-hour TWA exposures may or may not exceed the REL with this system. Use of this system by workers with experience and training in proficient use will likely improve dust capture performance. Exposure reduction is greatly influenced by correct use of this system which includes grinding from right to left, making sure the shroud is held flush against the wall and that the tool travels at a pace that doesn’t exceed the ability of the system to capture dust as it’s generated. Deviation from any of these measures produces visible dust clouds which were observed during trials.
VII. Conclusions
With a 99 percent reduction in respirable silica exposure, the Dust Director shroud and DustControl 2900c vacuum with a Bosch Model 1775E grinder was effective in reducing silica exposures based on our criteria. Use of the tested dust control system may be effective in reducing silica exposure on the job to less than the NIOSH REL if used in combination with administrative controls such as work scheduling to reduce cutting times as needed. Training on correct use of the tested system is also essential. Personal air monitoring is necessary to verify control effectiveness on actual job sites and under “real-world” conditions. However, these results clearly demonstrate the availability of viable and effective engineering controls for tuckpointing operations associated with elevated silica exposure.
VIII. References
American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists. Threshold limit values for chemical substances (TLV®-CS). [2013]. ACGIH, Cincinnati, Ohio.
Bergdahl I.A,. Toren K., Eriksson K., et al. [2004]. Increased mortality in COPD among construction workers exposed to inorganic dust. European Respiratory Journal, 23: 402–06.
Blanc P.D. & Torén K. [2007]. Occupation in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and chronic bronchitis: an update [State of the Art Series. Occupational lung disease in high-and low-income countries, Edited by M. Chan-Yeung. Number 2 in the series]. The International Journal of Tuberculosis and Lung Disease, 11(3), 251-257.
Collingwood S. & Heitbrink W.A. [2007] 'Field Evaluation of an Engineering Control for Respirable Crystalline Silica Exposures During Mortar Removal'. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, 4:11, 875 – 887.
DHHS (NIOSH) Publication No. 2002-129 April 2002 http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/2002-129/
Echt A., Sieber W.K., Lefkowitz D., Meeker J., Susi P., Cardwell B., Heitbrink, W.A. In-depth survey of dust control technology for cutting concrete block and tuckpointing brick at The International Masonry Institute Bordentown Training Center, Bordentown, NJ. Cincinnati, OH: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Report. No. EPHB 282-13; 2007. http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ECTB-282-13.pdf
Heitbrink W., Bennett J. [2006]. A numerical and experimental investigation of crystalline silica exposure control during tuck pointing. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, Vol. 3, pp 366-378.
Lyons et al, [2007]. A breathless builder. Breathe, Vol. 3, no. 4, pp 386-390.
Mastrangelo G., Tartari M., Fedeli U., Fadda E., Saia B. [2003]. Ascertaining the risk of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease in relation to occupation using a case-control design. Occupational Medicine, 53: 165–172.
Meeker J., Cooper M., Lefrowitz D., Susi P. [2009]. Engineering control technologies to reduce occupational silica exposures in masonry cutting and tuckpointing. Public Health Reports, Supplement 1, Vol. 124, June.
Meeker J, Flynn M, Susi P, Cardwell, B [2004]. Performance evaluation of a masonry concrete vacuum. Unpublished Report.
Miller F. W., Alfredsson L., Costenbader K. H., Kamen D. L., Nelson L. M., Norris J. M., & De Roos A. J. [2012]. Epidemiology of environmental exposures and human autoimmune diseases: findings from a National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences Expert Panel workshop. Journal of autoimmunity. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3496812/
Occupational Safety and Health Administration U.S Department of Labor. Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction. [2009]. OSHA 3362-05.
Rappaport SM, Goldberg M, Susi P, Herrick RF [2003]. Excessive exposure to silica in the U.S. construction industry. Annals of Occupational Hygiene, Vol. 47, pp. 111-122.
IX. Appendices
| Measurement Conditions |
n | Mean Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Median
Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before filter cleaning | 5 | 80 | 81 | 78-81 |
| After filter cleaning following manufacturer directions | 9 | 89 | 90 | 84-93 |
| * Static pressure was measured in millibars and converted to inches of water gauge. Flow rates were calculated using the formula Q = Ce (A) 4005 (SP)1/2 where: Q = flow in cubic feet per minute (cfm), Ce = coefficient of entry, A = area of the duct where static pressure measurements were taken in square feet, and SP = static pressure in inches of water gauge. | ||||
| Tool/Control | Collection Period (min.) |
Dust Collection Rate (lb/min.) |
|---|---|---|
| Bosch grinder/Dust Director shroud & DustControl 2900c vacuum |
8 11 8 8 10 |
0.50 0.61 0.50 0.47 0.63 |
| Average | 0.54 |
[disclaimer:protected] => [disclaimer_transformed:protected] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [template] => record ) [_file] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/templates/elcosh/macros.html [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_encoding:protected] => UTF-8 [_outputMode:protected] => 11 [_forceReparse:protected] => [_phpCodeDestination:protected] => /tmp/ [_phpCodeExtension:protected] => php [_cacheLifetime:protected] => 30 [_cachePurgeFrequency:protected] => 30 [externalMacroTemplatesCache:PHPTAL:private] => Array ( ) ) [record_macros.html] => PHPTAL Object ( [_prefilters:protected] => Array ( ) [_prefilter:PHPTAL:private] => REMOVED: DO NOT USE [_postfilter:protected] => [_repositories:protected] => Array ( [0] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/templates/elcosh ) [_path:protected] => record_macros.html [_resolvers:protected] => Array ( ) [_source:protected] => PHPTAL_FileSource Object ( [_path:PHPTAL_FileSource:private] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/templates/elcosh/record_macros.html ) [_codeFile:protected] => /tmp/tpl_61515a6c_record_macros__gMFg5NvPLybiFfYjAv9Aag.php [_functionName:protected] => tpl_61515a6c_record_macros__gMFg5NvPLybiFfYjAv9Aag [_prepared:protected] => 1 [_triggers:protected] => Array ( ) [_translator:protected] => [_globalContext:protected] => stdClass Object ( ) [_context:protected] => PHPTAL_Context Object ( [_line] => [_file] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/templates/elcosh/record.html [repeat] => stdClass Object ( ) [_xmlDeclaration] => [_docType] => [_nothrow:PHPTAL_Context:private] => [_slots:PHPTAL_Context:private] => Array ( ) [_slotsStack:PHPTAL_Context:private] => Array ( [0] => Array ( ) [1] => Array ( ) ) [_parentContext:PHPTAL_Context:private] => PHPTAL_Context Object ( [_line] => [_file] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/templates/elcosh/record.html [repeat] => stdClass Object ( ) [_xmlDeclaration] => [_docType] => [_nothrow:PHPTAL_Context:private] => [_slots:PHPTAL_Context:private] => Array ( ) [_slotsStack:PHPTAL_Context:private] => Array ( [0] => Array ( ) [1] => Array ( ) ) [_parentContext:PHPTAL_Context:private] => [_globalContext:PHPTAL_Context:private] => stdClass Object ( ) [_echoDeclarations:PHPTAL_Context:private] => [referer] => http://www.elcosh.org/document/3908/d001345/An%2BEvaluation%2Bof%2BSilica%2BExposure%2BControls%2Bfor%2BTuckpointing%253A%2BDustControl%2B2900c%2BVacuum%2Bwith%2Bthe%2BICS%2BDust%2BDirector%2BShroud%2Band%2BBosch%2BGrinder%2BModel%2B1775E%2BConducted%2BNovember%2B14-15%252C%2B2012.html [curr_module] => Record [styles] => Array ( ) [javascript] => Array ( [0] => jquery.min.js ) [metas] => Array ( [language] => en [robots] => index, follow ) [user] => [curr_url] => https://www.elcosh.org/index.php?module=Record&id=3908&type=document [base_url] => https://www.elcosh.org/index.php?module=Record [title] => eLCOSH : An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: DustControl 2900c Vacuum with the ICS Dust Director Shroud and Bosch Grinder Model 1775E Conducted November 14-15, 2012 [language] => en [search_query] => [module] => Record [new_records] => Array ( [0] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Fixed Ladder [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Fixed Ladders addresses the potential risks associated with using fixed ladders. The resource includes a brief case example,... [category] => Array ( [0] => 15 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 53 [5] => 55 [6] => 60 [7] => 64 [8] => 73 [9] => 76 [10] => 78 [11] => 80 [12] => 86 [13] => 87 [14] => 90 [15] => 92 [16] => 93 [17] => 94 [18] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Falls [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Concrete Polisher [11] => Electrical Worker [13] => HVAC [15] => Laborer [17] => PCC/Restoration [19] => Plumber/Pipefitter [21] => Roofer/Waterproofer [23] => Sheetmetal Worker [25] => Welder [27] => Commercial & Institutional [28] => Jobsites [29] => Industrial [31] => LEED/Green Construction [33] => Renovations [35] => Residential [37] => Toolbox Talks [38] => Documents [39] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4430/d001660/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BFixed%2BLadder.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [53] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 53 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Concrete Polisher [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [73] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 73 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => PCC/Restoration [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4430 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001660 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Fixed Ladder [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Fixed Ladders, Fall Prevention, Falls [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Fixed Ladders addresses the potential risks associated with using fixed ladders. The resource includes a brief case example, steps to prevent a related injury and questions for discussion. It includes an image that illustrates the hazard, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001257,d001254,d001255,d001256,d001258,d001262,d001279 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_completed:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/22/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [1] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Challenges Preventing Falling Objects [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Challenges Preventing Falling Objects addresses the hazards of being struck by falling objects on the job site. The resource... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 55 [5] => 64 [6] => 68 [7] => 71 [8] => 75 [9] => 78 [10] => 79 [11] => 82 [12] => 62 [13] => 86 [14] => 87 [15] => 88 [16] => 89 [17] => 91 [18] => 90 [19] => 92 [20] => 93 [21] => 94 [22] => 95 [23] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Electrical Worker [11] => Laborer [13] => Maintenance Worker [15] => Painter [17] => Plasterer [19] => Roofer/Waterproofer [21] => Scaffold Erector [23] => Stonemason [25] => Structural Ironworker [27] => Welder [29] => Commercial & Institutional [30] => Jobsites [31] => Demolition [33] => Disasters [35] => Heavy & Highway [37] => Industrial [39] => LEED/Green Construction [41] => Renovations [43] => Residential [45] => Underground [47] => Toolbox Talks [48] => Documents [49] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4431/d001661/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BChallenges%2BPreventing%2BFalling%2BObjects.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4431 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001661 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Challenges Preventing Falling Objects [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => dropped objects, falling objects, struck by incidents, struck by fatalities [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Challenges Preventing Falling Objects addresses the hazards of being struck by falling objects on the job site. The resource includes a brief example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates a group workers observing a scaffold free of debris during high winds, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001234,d001238,d001244,d001251,d001253,d001260,d001268,d001278 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_completed:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/22/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [2] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Tower Crane Safety [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Tower Crane Safety addresses the potential hazards of Tower Cranes and the importance of following procedure before and durin... [category] => Array ( [0] => 11 [1] => 12 [2] => 18 [3] => 70 [4] => 87 [5] => 88 [6] => 91 [7] => 90 [8] => 92 [9] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Cranes & Hoists [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Crushed/Struck By [6] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [9] => Operating Engineer [10] => Trades [11] => Commercial & Institutional [12] => Jobsites [13] => Demolition [15] => Heavy & Highway [17] => Industrial [19] => LEED/Green Construction [21] => Toolbox Talks [22] => Documents [23] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4427/d001657/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BTower%2BCrane%2BSafety.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [11] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 11 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Cranes & Hoists [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [18] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 18 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4427 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001657 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Tower Crane Safety [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Tower Crane, Crane, Stability, Tipping, Lift Zone Safety, Lift, Zone, Safety, Struck by [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Tower Crane Safety addresses the potential hazards of Tower Cranes and the importance of following procedure before and during Tower Crane operation. The resource includes a brief example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates a worker inspecting a Tower Crane before operation, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001234,d001238,d001250,d001251,d001253,d001258,d001262,d001273 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/19/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [3] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Work Zone Safety: Working Around Vehicles [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Working Around Vehicles in the Work Zone addresses methods to avoid being struck-by a vehicle on a construction site. The res... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 18 [2] => 52 [3] => 57 [4] => 70 [5] => 85 [6] => 87 [7] => 88 [8] => 89 [9] => 91 [10] => 90 [11] => 92 [12] => 93 [13] => 94 [14] => 95 [15] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [6] => Commercial Diver [7] => Trades [8] => Flagger [10] => Operating Engineer [12] => Truck Driver [14] => Commercial & Institutional [15] => Jobsites [16] => Demolition [18] => Disasters [20] => Heavy & Highway [22] => Industrial [24] => LEED/Green Construction [26] => Renovations [28] => Residential [30] => Underground [32] => Toolbox Talks [33] => Documents [34] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4428/d001658/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BWork%2BZone%2BSafety%253A%2BWorking%2BAround%2BVehicles.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [18] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 18 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [52] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 52 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Commercial Diver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [85] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 85 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Truck Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4428 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001658 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Daniela Caceres [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Work Zone Safety: Working Around Vehicles [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Struck, Struck by, Vehicle, Work Zone Safety, Truck, Operator, Driver, Mobile Equipment [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Working Around Vehicles in the Work Zone addresses methods to avoid being struck-by a vehicle on a construction site. The resource includes a case example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates the hazard, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001640 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/19/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [4] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Construction Dive -- DeWalt's Jobsite Pro headphones recalled for fire hazards [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => A recall notice by the United States Consumer Product Safety Commission affects over 300,000 DeWalt Jobsite Pro Headphones. The recall is a result of... [category] => Array ( [0] => 16 [1] => 44 [2] => 45 [3] => 46 [4] => 47 [5] => 48 [6] => 49 [7] => 50 [8] => 51 [9] => 52 [10] => 53 [11] => 54 [12] => 55 [13] => 56 [14] => 57 [15] => 58 [16] => 59 [17] => 60 [18] => 61 [19] => 64 [20] => 65 [21] => 66 [22] => 67 [23] => 68 [24] => 69 [25] => 70 [26] => 71 [27] => 72 [28] => 73 [29] => 74 [30] => 75 [31] => 76 [32] => 77 [33] => 63 [34] => 78 [35] => 79 [36] => 80 [37] => 81 [38] => 82 [39] => 62 [40] => 83 [41] => 84 [42] => 85 [43] => 86 [44] => 87 [45] => 88 [46] => 89 [47] => 91 [48] => 90 [49] => 92 [50] => 93 [51] => 94 [52] => 95 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Fire & Explosions [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Acoustical Ceiling Carpenter [4] => Trades [5] => Asbestos/Insulator [7] => Boilermaker [9] => Bricklayer [11] => Cabinetmaker [13] => Carpenter [15] => Carpet Layer [17] => Cement Mason [19] => Commercial Diver [21] => Concrete Polisher [23] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [25] => Electrical Worker [27] => Elevator Constructor [29] => Flagger [31] => Glazier [33] => Hazardous Waste Cleanup [35] => HVAC [37] => Interior Systems Carpenter [39] => Laborer [41] => Landscaper [43] => Lather [45] => Lead Abatement Worker [47] => Maintenance Worker [49] => Millwright [51] => Operating Engineer [53] => Painter [55] => Paper Hanger [57] => PCC/Restoration [59] => Pile Driver [61] => Plasterer [63] => Plumber/Pipefitter [65] => Refractory Worker [67] => Reinforcing Ironworker [69] => Roofer/Waterproofer [71] => Scaffold Erector [73] => Sheetmetal Worker [75] => Sprinkler Fitter [77] => Stonemason [79] => Structural Ironworker [81] => Terrazzo Worker [83] => Tile Setter [85] => Truck Driver [87] => Welder [89] => Commercial & Institutional [90] => Jobsites [91] => Demolition [93] => Disasters [95] => Heavy & Highway [97] => Industrial [99] => LEED/Green Construction [101] => Renovations [103] => Residential [105] => Underground ) [type] => [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4426/d001656/Construction%2BDive%2B--%2BDeWalt%2527s%2BJobsite%2BPro%2Bheadphones%2Brecalled%2Bfor%2Bfire%2Bhazards.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [16] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 16 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Fire & Explosions [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [44] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 44 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Acoustical Ceiling Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [45] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 45 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Asbestos/Insulator [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [46] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 46 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Boilermaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [48] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 48 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cabinetmaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [50] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 50 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpet Layer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [52] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 52 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Commercial Diver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [53] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 53 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Concrete Polisher [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [54] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 54 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [58] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 58 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Glazier [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [59] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 59 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Hazardous Waste Cleanup [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [65] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 65 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Landscaper [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [66] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 66 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Lather [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [67] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 67 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Lead Abatement Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [69] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 69 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Millwright [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [72] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 72 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Paper Hanger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [73] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 73 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => PCC/Restoration [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [77] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 77 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Refractory Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [81] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 81 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sprinkler Fitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [83] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 83 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Terrazzo Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [84] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 84 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Tile Setter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [85] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 85 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Truck Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4426 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001656 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Construction Dive -- DeWalt's Jobsite Pro headphones recalled for fire hazards [total_pages:protected] => 1 [billed_pages:protected] => 1 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => DeWalt, Fire Hazards, recall, headphones [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A recall notice by the United States Consumer Product Safety Commission affects over 300,000 DeWalt Jobsite Pro Headphones. The recall is a result of a malfunction that can cause earbuds to overheat while charging or during use, leading to fire and burn hazards. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => https://www.constructiondive.com/news/dewalts-jobsite-pro-headphones-recalled-for-fire-hazards/611248/?utm_source=Sailthru&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Issue:%202021-12-10%20Construction%20Dive%20Newsletter%20%5Bissue:38532%5D&utm_term=Construction%20Dive [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/13/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/13/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 12/13/21 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [new_images] => Array ( [0] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Morning Toolbox Talk [image] => /record/images/4003-p.jpg [blurb] => This photo is from an early morning toolbox talk on a construction job in Mclean, Virginia. It is being delivered in English and Spanish.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 20 [1] => 51 [2] => 57 [3] => 64 [4] => 70 [5] => 63 [6] => 78 [7] => 82 [8] => 62 [9] => 87 [10] => 88 [11] => 89 [12] => 91 [13] => 90 [14] => 93 [15] => 94 [16] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Safety Culture [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Cement Mason [4] => Trades [5] => Flagger [7] => Laborer [9] => Operating Engineer [11] => Reinforcing Ironworker [13] => Roofer/Waterproofer [15] => Stonemason [17] => Structural Ironworker [19] => Commercial & Institutional [20] => Jobsites [21] => Demolition [23] => Disasters [25] => Heavy & Highway [27] => Industrial [29] => Renovations [31] => Residential [33] => Images [34] => Media [35] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4003/i002691/Morning%2BToolbox%2BTalk.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4003 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002691 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Morning Toolbox Talk [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, Spanish, bilingual [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This photo is from an early morning toolbox talk on a construction job in Mclean, Virginia. It is being delivered in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001285,d001304,c000079 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [1] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox talk - crew view [image] => /record/images/4005-p.jpg [blurb] => Photo of crew listening to a toolbox safety talk before starting work.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 97 [1] => 20 [2] => 47 [3] => 49 [4] => 51 [5] => 55 [6] => 61 [7] => 64 [8] => 71 [9] => 75 [10] => 63 [11] => 79 [12] => 62 [13] => 87 [14] => 88 [15] => 91 [16] => 90 [17] => 93 [18] => 94 [19] => 95 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Images [1] => Media [2] => Media & Documents [3] => Safety Culture [4] => Work Environment [5] => Hazards [6] => Bricklayer [7] => Trades [8] => Carpenter [10] => Cement Mason [12] => Electrical Worker [14] => Interior Systems Carpenter [16] => Laborer [18] => Painter [20] => Plasterer [22] => Reinforcing Ironworker [24] => Scaffold Erector [26] => Structural Ironworker [28] => Commercial & Institutional [29] => Jobsites [30] => Demolition [32] => Heavy & Highway [34] => Industrial [36] => Renovations [38] => Residential [40] => Underground ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4005/i002692/Toolbox%2Btalk%2B-%2Bcrew%2Bview.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4005 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002692 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox talk - crew view [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, safety talk, Spanish [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Photo of crew listening to a toolbox safety talk before starting work. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002691,d001269, c000079, d001285 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [2] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox talk - long shot [image] => /record/images/4006-p.jpg [blurb] => This crew gathered every morning before starting work to discuss a new safety topic.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 20 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 55 [5] => 64 [6] => 68 [7] => 75 [8] => 76 [9] => 63 [10] => 78 [11] => 79 [12] => 82 [13] => 62 [14] => 87 [15] => 88 [16] => 91 [17] => 90 [18] => 93 [19] => 94 [20] => 95 [21] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Safety Culture [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Electrical Worker [11] => Laborer [13] => Maintenance Worker [15] => Plasterer [17] => Plumber/Pipefitter [19] => Reinforcing Ironworker [21] => Roofer/Waterproofer [23] => Scaffold Erector [25] => Stonemason [27] => Structural Ironworker [29] => Commercial & Institutional [30] => Jobsites [31] => Demolition [33] => Heavy & Highway [35] => Industrial [37] => Renovations [39] => Residential [41] => Underground [43] => Images [44] => Media [45] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4006/i002693/Toolbox%2Btalk%2B-%2Blong%2Bshot.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4006 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002693 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox talk - long shot [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, safety minute [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This crew gathered every morning before starting work to discuss a new safety topic. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002691,i002692,d001269,d000527 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [3] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Safety officer discussing ongoing project with marketing coordinator [image] => /record/images/4014-p.jpg [blurb] => The safety officer (left) points out the good safety practices on this project that reflect well on the firm and may influence future clients.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 97 [1] => 20 [2] => 46 [3] => 47 [4] => 49 [5] => 50 [6] => 51 [7] => 54 [8] => 55 [9] => 58 [10] => 60 [11] => 61 [12] => 64 [13] => 71 [14] => 75 [15] => 76 [16] => 63 [17] => 79 [18] => 80 [19] => 82 [20] => 62 [21] => 83 [22] => 87 [23] => 91 [24] => 90 [25] => 93 [26] => 94 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Images [1] => Media [2] => Media & Documents [3] => Safety Culture [4] => Work Environment [5] => Hazards [6] => Boilermaker [7] => Trades [8] => Bricklayer [10] => Carpenter [12] => Carpet Layer [14] => Cement Mason [16] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [18] => Electrical Worker [20] => Glazier [22] => HVAC [24] => Interior Systems Carpenter [26] => Laborer [28] => Painter [30] => Plasterer [32] => Plumber/Pipefitter [34] => Reinforcing Ironworker [36] => Scaffold Erector [38] => Sheetmetal Worker [40] => Stonemason [42] => Structural Ironworker [44] => Terrazzo Worker [46] => Commercial & Institutional [47] => Jobsites [48] => Heavy & Highway [50] => Industrial [52] => Renovations [54] => Residential ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4014/i002700/Safety%2Bofficer%2Bdiscussing%2Bongoing%2Bproject%2Bwith%2Bmarketing%2Bcoordinator.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [46] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 46 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Boilermaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [50] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 50 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpet Layer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [54] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 54 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [58] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 58 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Glazier [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [83] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 83 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Terrazzo Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4014 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002700 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Safety officer discussing ongoing project with marketing coordinator [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Latino, safety officer, safety culture [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The safety officer (left) points out the good safety practices on this project that reflect well on the firm and may influence future clients. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/index.php [more_like_this:protected] => d000989,d001351,d001362,d000652, d001101, d000931, d001395 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Hoar Construction, Photo by Neil Lippy [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 01/30/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [4] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Scaffolding at top of large column [image] => /record/images/3994-p.jpg [blurb] => This shot shows innovative guarding around the top of a large concrete column in the base of a high rise structure going up.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 15 [1] => 21 [2] => 47 [3] => 51 [4] => 63 [5] => 78 [6] => 79 [7] => 80 [8] => 62 [9] => 87 [10] => 97 [11] => 56 [12] => 64 [13] => 74 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Falls [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Scaffolds [6] => Bricklayer [7] => Trades [8] => Cement Mason [10] => Reinforcing Ironworker [12] => Roofer/Waterproofer [14] => Scaffold Erector [16] => Sheetmetal Worker [18] => Structural Ironworker [20] => Commercial & Institutional [21] => Jobsites [22] => Images [23] => Media [24] => Media & Documents [25] => Elevator Constructor [27] => Laborer [29] => Pile Driver ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/3994/i002689/Scaffolding%2Bat%2Btop%2Bof%2Blarge%2Bcolumn.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [21] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 21 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Scaffolds [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3994 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002689 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Scaffolding at top of large column [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Guardrail, railing, fall prevention, falls [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This shot shows innovative guarding around the top of a large concrete column in the base of a high rise structure going up. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/8/adjustable-tower-scaffold.html [more_like_this:protected] => c1002680,i002662,d000608,d001255 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Photo by Pam Susi [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2016 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_completed:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/01/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [5] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Construction bracing [image] => /record/images/3995-p.jpg [blurb] => This shows structural support that prevents collapses during construction.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 15 [2] => 21 [3] => 49 [4] => 51 [5] => 55 [6] => 56 [7] => 60 [8] => 64 [9] => 68 [10] => 74 [11] => 63 [12] => 78 [13] => 79 [14] => 80 [15] => 62 [16] => 87 [17] => 90 [18] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Falls [6] => Scaffolds [9] => Carpenter [10] => Trades [11] => Cement Mason [13] => Electrical Worker [15] => Elevator Constructor [17] => HVAC [19] => Laborer [21] => Maintenance Worker [23] => Pile Driver [25] => Reinforcing Ironworker [27] => Roofer/Waterproofer [29] => Scaffold Erector [31] => Sheetmetal Worker [33] => Structural Ironworker [35] => Commercial & Institutional [36] => Jobsites [37] => Industrial [39] => Images [40] => Media [41] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/3995/i002690/Construction%2Bbracing.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [21] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 21 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Scaffolds [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3995 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002690 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Construction bracing [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Bracing, support, scaffold [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This shows structural support that prevents collapses during construction. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/8/adjustable-tower-scaffold.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002660 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Photo by Pam Susi [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2016 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_completed:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/01/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [preview_mode] => [description] => The results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. [keywords] => tuckpointing, HEPA vacuum, dust control, LEV, local exhaust ventilation, silica [related_items] => Array ( [Research Reports] => Array ( [0] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1874 [old_id:protected] => 722 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000683 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Sharon Garber/COD [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Protecting Tuckpointing Workers from Silica Dust: Draft Recommendations for a Ventilated Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 12 [billed_pages:protected] => 12 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, vacuum, grinder, mortar, respirator, OSHA, NIOSH, exhaust, Heitbrink, tuckpointer, silica, masonry, dust, silicosis, LEV [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Describes draft recommendations for use of ventilated grinder to reduce dust during tuckpointing and describes field trials using these devices. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/hazard/67/chip-scrape-and-grind-surfaces-or-joints-silica.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001201,d000292,d000293,d000658 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2005 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/27/05 [date_completed:protected] => 04/26/05 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/20/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [1] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1940 [old_id:protected] => 909 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Workplace Solutions: Control of Hazardous Dust During Tuckpointing [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, silica, dust, tuckpoint, grinder, masonry restoration, mortar, vacuum [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d000819,d000820,d000730,d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 10/24/08 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/09 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [2] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3899 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001342 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: Hilti VC40-U Vacuum with Hilti DC-EX Dust Guard and Hilti Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 15 [billed_pages:protected] => 15 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP4 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => silica, tuckpointing, Hilti, local exhaust systems, LEV, shroud, quartz [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This report describes the results of an evaluation of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Hilti VC40-U vacuum, a Hilti DC-EX shroud, and a Hilti DAG-500 grinder. Randomized trials with and without use of the dust control system were conducted in a controlled setting. Removing mortar with the Hilti grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 220 times the National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05mg/m3. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 97 percent. However, exposures measured during the use of the dust control system still exceeded the NIOSH REL. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => December 1, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/05/14 [date_completed:protected] => 02/04/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/06/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [Handouts] => Array ( [0] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3656 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001198 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 24 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction While Doing Tuckpointing/Mortar Removal [total_pages:protected] => 2 [billed_pages:protected] => 2 [publication_number:protected] => DSG FS-3632 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Brick, block, tuckpointing, silica, local exhaust ventilation, LEV, masonry [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Tuckpointing creates some of the greatest exposures to silica in construction. This OSHA factsheet provides guidance on how to greatly reduce these exposures through the use of local exhaust ventilation. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863, d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => February 2013 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/04/13 [date_completed:protected] => 03/27/13 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [collections] => Array ( [3913] => ) [record] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => Array ( [867] => Author Object ( [id:protected] => 867 [organization_id:protected] => 0 [firstname:protected] => Michael [lastname:protected] => Cooper [address:protected] => [city:protected] => [province:protected] => [country:protected] => [postal_code:protected] => [department:protected] => [title:protected] => [phone:protected] => [fax:protected] => [email:protected] => [degree:protected] => [website:protected] => [about:protected] => [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => [date_completed:protected] => [date_billed:protected] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [481] => Author Object ( [id:protected] => 481 [organization_id:protected] => 0 [firstname:protected] => Pam [lastname:protected] => Susi [address:protected] => 8484 Georgia Avenue, Suite 1000 [city:protected] => Silver Spring [province:protected] => Maryland [country:protected] => USA [postal_code:protected] => 20910 [department:protected] => [title:protected] => [phone:protected] => 301-578-8500 ext.144 [fax:protected] => 301-578-8572 [email:protected] => plsusi@aol.com [degree:protected] => [website:protected] => http://www.cpwr.com [about:protected] => [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => 2003-10-02 [date_completed:protected] => 2003-10-06 [date_billed:protected] => 2003-11-03 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [organizations:protected] => Array ( [1] => Organization Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [elcosh_id:protected] => o000001 [user_id:protected] => 14 [province_id:protected] => 21 [country_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => CPWR - The Center for Construction Research and Training [address:protected] => Suite 1000, 8484 Georgia Ave [postal_code:protected] => 20910 [city:protected] => Silver Spring [department:protected] => [phone:protected] => 301-578-8500 [fax:protected] => 301-578-8572 [email:protected] => cpwrwebsite@cpwr.com [website:protected] => http://www.cpwr.com [filename:protected] => o000001.gif [about:protected] => CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training, developed, and continues to maintain/expand this website - The Electronic Library of Construction Occupational Safety and Health, www.elcosh.org. CPWR, formerly known as The Center to Protect Workers’ Rights, is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit research and training institution. Created by the Building and Construction Trades Department, AFL-CIO, CPWR serves as the research arm of the BCTD. Since the inception of its research agenda in 1990, CPWR has grown into a worldwide provider of safety and health information covering all aspects of the construction industry. CPWR launched eLCOSH in 2000, and the Spanish-language version of the site in 2001. CPWR also created, and continues to build, Construction Solutions - www.cpwrConstructionSolutions.org - a free, online database of construction hazards and ways to prevent, eliminate, or reduce them. [comments:protected] => [logo_available:protected] => T [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => 2000-08-18 [date_completed:protected] => 2000-08-30 [date_billed:protected] => 2000-09-05 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [collections:protected] => Array ( [3913] => ) [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => Array ( [1874] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1874 [old_id:protected] => 722 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000683 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Sharon Garber/COD [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Protecting Tuckpointing Workers from Silica Dust: Draft Recommendations for a Ventilated Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 12 [billed_pages:protected] => 12 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, vacuum, grinder, mortar, respirator, OSHA, NIOSH, exhaust, Heitbrink, tuckpointer, silica, masonry, dust, silicosis, LEV [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Describes draft recommendations for use of ventilated grinder to reduce dust during tuckpointing and describes field trials using these devices. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/hazard/67/chip-scrape-and-grind-surfaces-or-joints-silica.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001201,d000292,d000293,d000658 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2005 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/27/05 [date_completed:protected] => 04/26/05 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/20/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [1940] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1940 [old_id:protected] => 909 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Workplace Solutions: Control of Hazardous Dust During Tuckpointing [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, silica, dust, tuckpoint, grinder, masonry restoration, mortar, vacuum [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d000819,d000820,d000730,d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 10/24/08 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/09 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [2213] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 2213 [old_id:protected] => 1090 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => [language_id:protected] => 2 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Control del polvo peligroso que se genera durante los procesos de reparación de mortero [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => 2008-126 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => [comments:protected] => http://www.cdc.gov/spanish/niosh/docs/wp-solutions/2008-126_sp/ [summary:protected] => A Workplace Solutions de NIOSH que resume un estudio de NIOSH sobre los riesgos de exposición cuando se reparan las estructuras y los métodos para controlar el polvo. [A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust.] [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => D000819,D000820,D000730,d000819 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 01/07/10 [date_completed:protected] => 04/19/10 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 07/08/12 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [3656] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3656 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001198 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 24 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction While Doing Tuckpointing/Mortar Removal [total_pages:protected] => 2 [billed_pages:protected] => 2 [publication_number:protected] => DSG FS-3632 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Brick, block, tuckpointing, silica, local exhaust ventilation, LEV, masonry [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Tuckpointing creates some of the greatest exposures to silica in construction. This OSHA factsheet provides guidance on how to greatly reduce these exposures through the use of local exhaust ventilation. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863, d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => February 2013 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/04/13 [date_completed:protected] => 03/27/13 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [3899] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3899 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001342 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: Hilti VC40-U Vacuum with Hilti DC-EX Dust Guard and Hilti Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 15 [billed_pages:protected] => 15 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP4 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => silica, tuckpointing, Hilti, local exhaust systems, LEV, shroud, quartz [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This report describes the results of an evaluation of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Hilti VC40-U vacuum, a Hilti DC-EX shroud, and a Hilti DAG-500 grinder. Randomized trials with and without use of the dust control system were conducted in a controlled setting. Removing mortar with the Hilti grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 220 times the National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05mg/m3. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 97 percent. However, exposures measured during the use of the dust control system still exceeded the NIOSH REL. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => December 1, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/05/14 [date_completed:protected] => 02/04/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/06/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [content:protected] => [files:protected] => Array ( [559] => [560] => [546] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 546 [filename:protected] => 3.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:22 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [566] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 566 [filename:protected] => 4.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:23 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [720] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 720 [filename:protected] => 5.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [721] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 721 [filename:protected] => 6.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [722] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 722 [filename:protected] => 7.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [9765] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 9765 [filename:protected] => d001345.pdf [downloadable:protected] => T [timestamp:protected] => 2015-02-09 12:26:04 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3908 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001345 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: DustControl 2900c Vacuum with the ICS Dust Director Shroud and Bosch Grinder Model 1775E Conducted November 14-15, 2012 [total_pages:protected] => 13 [billed_pages:protected] => 13 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP2 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => tuckpointing, HEPA vacuum, dust control, LEV, local exhaust ventilation, silica [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => April 15, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 01/26/15 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/09/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [show_text] => [document_content] => ElcoshItemDocumentContent Object ( [id:protected] => 2934 [item_id:protected] => 3908 [type:protected] => main [title:protected] => [content:protected] =>
Executive Summary
This report describes the results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. It should also be noted that the NIOSH REL is based on exposures averaged over a ten hour work day and our results represent time weighted averages of the sample task duration periods.
Acronyms
ACGIH - American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists
CPWR - CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training
Ce - coefficient of entry
HEPA - high-efficiency particulate air
IUBAC - International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craftworkers
LEV - local exhaust ventilation
PACT - Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies
NIOSH - National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health
OEL - occupational exposure limit
OSHA - Occupational Safety and Health Administration
PAPR - powered air-purifying respirator
PEL - Permissible Exposure Limit
PVC - polyvinyl chloride
REL - Recommended Exposure Limit
RPM - revolutions per minute
TWA - time-weighted average
SP - static pressure
I. Introduction and Background
In 2010 CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training began a four-year project which seeks to identify and evaluate tuckpointing local exhaust ventilation (LEV) systems and disseminate information on their availability and effectiveness. A Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies (PACT) comprised of masonry contractors, representatives from unions, government, equipment manufacturers, and health and safety researcher was formed as part of this project. PACT members participated in identifying important characteristics for control technologies and this information was used to identify LEV systems for tuckpointing using that criteria. Contractor and labor members of the PACT selected specific tuckpointing LEV systems to be considered for evaluation. Each system consisted of a tuckpointing grinder, shroud, and vacuum. This report describes the second of four systems to be evaluated between 2012 the end of 2014, with and without LEV, in a controlled setting to determine effectiveness in silica exposure reduction. This report describes the methods and results of our evaluation of a system consisting of the DustControl 2900c vacuum with the ICS Dust Director shroud and a Bosch Model 1775E grinder.
Excessive exposure to respirable silica can result in silicosis or other silica-related diseases including pulmonary tuberculosis, lung cancer, silicoproteinosis (Lyons et al, 2007) and autoimmune disorders such as rheumatoid arthritis, sarcoidosis and scleroderma (Miller et al, 2012). Respirable silica is generally defined as particles less than 10 micrometers (μm) in aerodynamic diameter (ACGIH, 2013). Silicosis can lead to symptoms including shortness of breath, fatigue, chest pains, susceptibility to infection and possibly death. There is no cure for silicosis, however it is totally preventable. Construction workers exposed to dust, including silica, are also known to have higher rates of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD).
There are many sources of silica in construction that result in exposures of varying intensity among workers. Masonry restoration workers are among the most highly silica-exposed trades in construction. The process of grinding out deteriorated mortar joints between masonry units and replacing or repointing with fresh mortar (often referred to as tuckpointing) is a fundamental part of masonry restoration work. The removal of mortar with powered angle grinders generates enormous levels of dust. Between 2004 and 2006, NIOSH and CPWR evaluated silica exposures while grinding mortar in a controlled setting, at a local training center, where tasks, sample times and task variables were defined by the study design. These studies demonstrated that grinding mortar without controls can result in elevated respirable silica exposures. Meeker et al., (2009) reported exposures between 5 and 25.8 milligrams per cubic meter (mg/m3) in a controlled setting. This study also showed that LEV systems for tuckpointing grinders can reduce exposures to respirable silica by greater than 90 percent.II. Objectives
The objective of this evaluation was to assess the effectiveness of an LEV system for controlling exposure to silica during the grinding of mortar. The control technology was tested under controlled conditions, similar to those experienced by tuckpointers on actual job sites, using journeymen bricklayers experienced in tuckpointing and repeat, randomized trials with and without LEV. All other variables were held constant throughout so that the only variable was whether or not the tested control was used.
III. Description of Equipment Tested
A Bosch model 1775E grinder (Robert Bosch Tool Corporation, Prospect, IL) (Figures 1, 2 and 3) was fitted with a new 1/4-inch wide, 4½-inch diameter segmented diamond abrasive blade made by DeWalt (model #DW4740). The grinder weighs six and a half pounds, draws 8.5 amps and has a variable speed up to 11,000 revolutions per minute (RPMs). The DustControl 2900c vacuum (DustControl, Inc., Wilmington, NC) (Figure 3) was tested in combination with the Dust Director shroud (Industrial Contractors’ Supplies, Inc., Huntingdon, PA) (Figures 1 and 3) attached to the Bosch grinder.
Figure 1. Bosch grinder with Dust Director shroud
Figure 2. Bosch grinder without tuckpointing LEV system.
Figure 3: Bosch Grinder with LEV System
The vacuum is specified to weigh 31 pounds when empty and to provide a flow rate of 114 cubic feet of air per minute and a “static lift” or “vacuum suction pressure” of 84 inches of water. The vacuum is sold with a cyclonic pre-separator, to remove larger particles, a fine filter (rated 99.9 percent efficient) and a HEPA (high-efficiency particulate air) filter (rated to capture 99.97 percent of the particles with an aerodynamic diameter of 0.3 micrometers). The HEPA filter was removed based on the manufacturer’s recommendation due to the heavy dust loading associated with tuckpointing. CPWR sponsored research and contractor experience indicate that HEPA filters likely have an adverse effect on dust capture during tuckpointing because of extreme dust loading on filters. While the cyclone and the fine filter remove most of the dust, especially the large particles, before they reach the HEPA filter, the HEPA filter would still be subject to heavy loading, causing a substantial pressure drop and subsequent decrease in air flow rate. The relatively small increase in the efficiency of the filtration system while using the HEPA filter is expected to be quickly offset by a more significant decrease in capture efficiency as the air flow rate and ability to capture particles decreases.
Dust collects in relatively inexpensive, heavy-gauge plastic bags below and outside of the cyclone. The bags can be removed and replaced without opening the vacuum. Some vacuums are equipped with a light to indicate that the filters need to be cleaned or changed. The DC2900c features a “reverse air pulse cleaning system,” which removes accumulated dust from the filters without having to remove them from the vacuum. The system, as illustrated in Figure 4, requires the operator to disconnect the hose from the shroud, place it over an air stop so that air through the hose is cut off and pressure in the vacuum is maximized.
Figure 4. Procedure for "cleaning" of or dust removal from filters (source: http://dustcontrolusa.com/manuals/2800c.pdf)
The flap covering the port on the side of the vacuum is repeatedly flipped open to release built up pressure in strong pulses that dislodge dust from the filter.
The manufacturer indicates “the filter is generally cleaned once or twice daily during normal continuous operation.” The Dust Director shroud has a 2-inch diameter take-off that was connected to the antistatic, corrugated 1.5-inch diameter, 15-foot long vacuum hose supplied with the DustControl vacuum.
IV. Study Methods
This evaluation was conducted at the International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craft workers (IUBAC) Local 1 Philadelphia/Delaware Training Center in Philadelphia, PA on November 14 and 15, 2012. A single journeyman bricklayer, experienced in tuckpointing, used the grinder and LEV system being tested to remove mortar from joints wide enough to require two passes. The type S mortar had been allowed to cure for at least four weeks. The bricklayer either possessed or was provided with personal protective equipment including sturdy work boots, gloves, hearing protection and a powered air-purifying respirator (PAPR). The PAPR was a 3M GVP system with a bump cap, loose fitting face piece and a HEPA filter (3M, St Paul, MN).
The study was designed to include at least five rounds of sampling during mortar removal. Each round included a trial using the Bosch grinder with a Dust Director shroud and Dust Collector 2900c vacuum and a trial using the Bosch grinder with the factory-supplied guard and without a vacuum. The order of the two trials within each round was randomly selected to minimize bias that might be introduced due to variation associated with environmental factors, equipment operator, blade wear, vacuum performance over time and any other factors unrelated to LEV use. Tools were operated for approximately 16 minutes per trial with controls and for approximately 8 minutes when controls were not used. These times were selected based on the results of previous sampling efforts and estimates of the minimum sample time needed to achieve a limit of quantification low enough to accurately measure exposures down to or less than 0.05 mg/m3 – the NIOSH Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) for respirable silica. The bricklayer was required to take a 5 to 10 minute break in the middle of the 16-minute trials to reduce differences in fatigue, compared to the 8-minute trials. Personal air samples were collected in the breathing zone of the operator during each trial to measure respirable silica concentrations during grinding with and without LEV. The samples were collected using a GilAir-5 pump (Sensidyne, Inc., Clearwater, FL) to draw 4.2 liters of air per minute through a GK2.69 Respirable Cyclone (BGI Inc., Waltham, MA) with a pre-weighed, 37 mm diameter, 5-micron pore size polyvinyl chloride (PVC) filter positioned on the operator’s lapel.
The flow rates of the sampling pumps were calibrated at the beginning of each day using a DryCal DC-Lite Primary Flow Meter (Bios International Corporation, Butler, NJ). Flow rates were measured again near the middle and at the end of each day to ensure that sampling flow rates were maintained within 5% of pre-sampling flow rates throughout the day. Average flow rates were used to calculate sample air volumes. Samples were analyzed by R.J. Lee Group, Inc., (Monroeville, PA) using NIOSH Method 0600, to determine exposure to total mass of respirable dust. The same samples were also analyzed using X-Ray diffraction following NIOSH method 7500 to determine quartz, cristobalite and tridymite concentration in the respirable mass. Reported masses for these analytes were used with the sample air volumes to calculate airborne concentrations of total respirable dust, quartz, cristobalite and tridymite.
We used a reduction of greater than 50 percent in respirable silica exposure concentrations or a reduction to less than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 as our criteria for determining whether or not a control was considered efficacious. This is consistent with criteria used by NIOSH in conducting a similar study in 2004 described by Echt et al. (2007) and by CPWR in 2006 and described by Meeker et al. (2009). The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) and the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) publish additional occupational exposure limits (OELs) for silica which are listed in Table 1 with NIOSH RELs. OELs for silica are based on the respirable fraction of the aerosol, which consists of particles less than 10 micrometers in aerodynamic diameter.
| Organization or Agency | Form of Crystalline Silica | Occupational Exposure Limits (mg/m3) |
|---|---|---|
| NIOSHA | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 |
| OSHA - ConstructionB | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
PEL = 250 / (5 + % quartz) PEL = 250 / (5 + % cristobalite) PEL = 250 / (5 + % tridymite) |
| ACGIH | Crystalline Silica | TLV = 0.025 mg/m3 |
A NIOSH Publication No. 2005-151 indicates 10-hour time-weighted average during a 40-hr workweek B The PEL for silica in OSHA’s Safety and Health Regulations for Construction, 29 C.F.R. 1926.55(a), is an 8-hour time-weighted average (TWA) expressed in millions of particles per cubic foot (mppcf). However, the units mppcf can be converted to milligrams per cubic meter can by dividing mppcf by 10 (OSHA, 2009). The formula used by OSHA to determine the PEL for silica is dependent on the percentage of silica in each collected sample. The concentration of respirable dust measured is compared to the sample specific PEL to determine if the PEL has been exceeded. OSHA has proposed lowering the PEL to 0.05 mg/m3 of respirable silica as an 8 hour TWA. |
||
The flow of air in ventilation systems is governed by fundamental principles that describe the behavior of gases (in this case air). Pressure measurements taken within a ventilation system along with knowledge of hood (or shroud) entry losses can be used to calculate flow rates. Hood entry losses are dependent on the shape and configuration of a particular hood or shroud and described by the term “coefficient of entry (Ce)” which is the ratio of actual air flow through a hood and what the air flow would theoretically be if there were no hood entry losses. Given the coefficient of entry, static pressure measurements can be used to calculate air flow through a given hood. The coefficient of entry for the Dust Director shroud was previously determined by CPWR and used for calculating air flow based on static pressure measurements (Meeker et al., 2009). Static pressure, with the vacuum operating, was measured periodically throughout the evaluation to monitor the changes in air-flow rate following use and again after filter cleaning. The static pressure was measured at a port positioned more than 3 duct diameters downstream from the tool’s air intake using a UEi EM200 Electronic Manometer (Universal Enterprises, Inc., Beaverton, OR).
The dust in the vacuum bag was monitored and, per the manufacturer’s instructions, the bag was changed before the dust level was within 5 centimeters of the valve at the bottom of the vacuum. Each time a vacuum bag was removed, it was weighed to the nearest pound. The bag weights and corresponding grinding durations were used to calculate the average weight of dust collected per unit time. After each trial, cut lengths were measured on the wall to determine total linear feet of vertical (head) and horizontal (bed) joints per unit time.
A Haz-Dust III, Model HD-1003, Real-Time Aerosol Monitor (Environmental Devices Corporation, Plaistow, NH) was used to confirm clearance of dust between trials. The Haz-Dust monitor was positioned on the test wall near the operator at approximately breathing zone level and configured to measure respirable particulate concentration.
V. Results
Personal air monitoring
Five pairs of respirable dust samples were collected while grinding with and without the vacuum system. In addition, three respirable dust samples were collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place. One measurement collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard was shown to be a statistical outlier and was omitted from analysis. Personal air monitoring results for respirable silica and a comparison of average exposures relative to the NIOSH REL for silica (0.05 mg/m3) appears in Table 2. The mean respirable dust levels measured without LEV was 31.4 mg/m3. However, samples collected with LEV were below the limit of quantification (LOQ) which ranged from <1.29 to <1.46 mg/m3. Use of LEV resulted in a greater than 95% reduction in mean respirable dust levels using a mean value with use of LEV of <1.41 (n=5 samples with use of LEV and n=7 without use of LEV). The respirable dust samples collected during grinding without the LEV system contained an average of 24 percent silica. The mass of respirable dust in the samples collected with use of the LEV system was too low to determine the silica content.| Mean, mg/m3 (range) | Std. Dev. | Percent Reduction | Hazard RatioB | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bosch with Dust Director Shroud and DustControl 2900c Vacuum |
0.091 (<0.069 – 0.137) |
0.027 | 98.7 | 1.81 |
| Bosch with no Control | 7.23 (4.57 – 9.90) |
1.94 | NA | 145 |
A n = 5 samples for each tool/control combination and n = 7 samples without the use of the LEV system B Hazard Ratio = measured exposure / NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 |
||||
Average respirable silica and dust exposures, with and without the dust control system, appear as Figures 5 and 6, respectively.
Figure 5. Average respirable silica exposures with and without the Dustcontrol 2900c vacuum and Dust Director shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air - mg/m3)
Figure 6. Average respirable dust exposures with and without Dustcontrol 2900c Vacuum and Dust Director Shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air – mg/m3)
The mean respirable silica concentration measured during use of the control was significantly less than the concentration measured while using the same tool without controls (p<0.01). Grinding mortar with the Bosch angle grinder without dust controls resulted in an average exposure to respirable silica that was 145 times the NIOSH REL. Grinding with the Bosch angle grinder in combination with the Dust Director shroud and the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced the average concentration of respirable silica by 98.7 percent. With use of these controls, the concentration of respirable silica was 1.8 times greater than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3. However the NIOSH REL is based on a time-weighted average (TWA) over a 10-hour workday. Given these were task TWAs and samples were collected over continuous periods of grinding, they may overestimate exposures over an actual work day since some time would be spent performing tasks that would likely have lower, or no, silica exposures (setup, breaks, cleanup, etc.).
Static pressure, dust mass collection and grinding rates.
Static pressure was used as a surrogate for air flow as described earlier. Hood static pressure was measured periodically at a tap near the grinder more than 3 duct diameters from the air intake in the shroud. The static pressure, and thus air flow, was generally higher when the vacuum’s filter had recently been cleaned. The mean, median, and range of calculated flow rates are presented in Table A1 of the Appendix.
Based on the data we collected, the air-flow rate upstream from the Bosch grinder and Dust Director shroud ranged from 78 to 93 cubic feet per minute (cfm) with the DustControl vacuum. When the manufacturer’s filter cleaning procedure was followed the vacuum performed relatively well and flow could be maintained at slightly less than 90 cfm with cleaning. However, mean flow rates dropped substantially to 80 cfm after as little as 8 minutes of grinding without any filter cleaning. The flow rate returned to an average of 89 cfm when filters were cleaned correctly (without stopping air flow to the vacuum). Collingwood and Heitbrink (2007) found that the minimum exhaust flow rate for capture of silica and other particulate under ideal conditions is 21.25 cfm per inch of grinder blade diameter. This is equal to about 96 cfm when using a 4.5 inch diameter grinding blade. We set 106 cfm as the minimum desired flow rate for this study to allow a safety margin for potential decline in equipment performance and the possibility of inadequate maintenance, both of which may be likely after repeated use under actual work conditions. The DustControl vacuum provided slightly less than the minimum flow rate described by Collingwood and Heitbrink for a 4.5-inch blade and the peak flow rate fell with use.
The duration of vacuum bag use and mass of dust collected were recorded and are presented in Table A2 of the Appendix. The vacuum bags were changed and weighed after each trial utilizing the LEV system. A total of five bags were used to complete the five rounds of grinding. The DustControl vacuum captured 45 pounds of dust over 83 minutes of grinding for an average rate of dust collection of 0.54 pounds per minute. The rate of dust collection ranged from 0.47 to 0.63 pounds per minute. Based on these measurements, approximately 130 pounds of dust would likely be captured after just 4 hours of continuous grinding.
The rate of grinding a combination of vertical and horizontal joints while using the LEV system ranged from 2.3 to 3.3 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the use of the LEV system ranged from 2.6 to 3.4 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place ranged from 4.7 to 5.1 feet per minute. It’s important to note that: 1) the operator had limited experience using dust control systems and cut rates appeared to improve slightly over the 2-day period he used the tested equipment; and 2) the upper range of cut rates with the dust control system overlapped with the lowest cut rate with the original guard and without the LEV system in place indicating no statistical difference between cut rates. Given that grinding rates with and without use of this LEV system are only available for one operator and he had limited experience with the LEV system, these reported cut rates are in no way intended to represent the impact use of this LEV system is likely to have on productivity rates overall.
VI. Discussion
The objective of these trials was to evaluate the effectiveness of a tuckpointing LEV system for controlling respirable silica while grinding out mortar joints. The Dust Director shroud with the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced respirable silica concentrations when grinding with the Bosch grinder by approximately 99 percent. Despite being considered effective by our test criteria (greater than 50% reduction), it still resulted in task TWA exposures that exceeded the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 by 1.8 times. Depending on how much time is spent grinding over the course of a work day and on exposures while performing other tasks, the 8-hour TWA exposures may or may not exceed the REL with this system. Use of this system by workers with experience and training in proficient use will likely improve dust capture performance. Exposure reduction is greatly influenced by correct use of this system which includes grinding from right to left, making sure the shroud is held flush against the wall and that the tool travels at a pace that doesn’t exceed the ability of the system to capture dust as it’s generated. Deviation from any of these measures produces visible dust clouds which were observed during trials.
VII. Conclusions
With a 99 percent reduction in respirable silica exposure, the Dust Director shroud and DustControl 2900c vacuum with a Bosch Model 1775E grinder was effective in reducing silica exposures based on our criteria. Use of the tested dust control system may be effective in reducing silica exposure on the job to less than the NIOSH REL if used in combination with administrative controls such as work scheduling to reduce cutting times as needed. Training on correct use of the tested system is also essential. Personal air monitoring is necessary to verify control effectiveness on actual job sites and under “real-world” conditions. However, these results clearly demonstrate the availability of viable and effective engineering controls for tuckpointing operations associated with elevated silica exposure.
VIII. References
American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists. Threshold limit values for chemical substances (TLV®-CS). [2013]. ACGIH, Cincinnati, Ohio.
Bergdahl I.A,. Toren K., Eriksson K., et al. [2004]. Increased mortality in COPD among construction workers exposed to inorganic dust. European Respiratory Journal, 23: 402–06.
Blanc P.D. & Torén K. [2007]. Occupation in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and chronic bronchitis: an update [State of the Art Series. Occupational lung disease in high-and low-income countries, Edited by M. Chan-Yeung. Number 2 in the series]. The International Journal of Tuberculosis and Lung Disease, 11(3), 251-257.
Collingwood S. & Heitbrink W.A. [2007] 'Field Evaluation of an Engineering Control for Respirable Crystalline Silica Exposures During Mortar Removal'. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, 4:11, 875 – 887.
DHHS (NIOSH) Publication No. 2002-129 April 2002 http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/2002-129/
Echt A., Sieber W.K., Lefkowitz D., Meeker J., Susi P., Cardwell B., Heitbrink, W.A. In-depth survey of dust control technology for cutting concrete block and tuckpointing brick at The International Masonry Institute Bordentown Training Center, Bordentown, NJ. Cincinnati, OH: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Report. No. EPHB 282-13; 2007. http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ECTB-282-13.pdf
Heitbrink W., Bennett J. [2006]. A numerical and experimental investigation of crystalline silica exposure control during tuck pointing. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, Vol. 3, pp 366-378.
Lyons et al, [2007]. A breathless builder. Breathe, Vol. 3, no. 4, pp 386-390.
Mastrangelo G., Tartari M., Fedeli U., Fadda E., Saia B. [2003]. Ascertaining the risk of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease in relation to occupation using a case-control design. Occupational Medicine, 53: 165–172.
Meeker J., Cooper M., Lefrowitz D., Susi P. [2009]. Engineering control technologies to reduce occupational silica exposures in masonry cutting and tuckpointing. Public Health Reports, Supplement 1, Vol. 124, June.
Meeker J, Flynn M, Susi P, Cardwell, B [2004]. Performance evaluation of a masonry concrete vacuum. Unpublished Report.
Miller F. W., Alfredsson L., Costenbader K. H., Kamen D. L., Nelson L. M., Norris J. M., & De Roos A. J. [2012]. Epidemiology of environmental exposures and human autoimmune diseases: findings from a National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences Expert Panel workshop. Journal of autoimmunity. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3496812/
Occupational Safety and Health Administration U.S Department of Labor. Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction. [2009]. OSHA 3362-05.
Rappaport SM, Goldberg M, Susi P, Herrick RF [2003]. Excessive exposure to silica in the U.S. construction industry. Annals of Occupational Hygiene, Vol. 47, pp. 111-122.
IX. Appendices
| Measurement Conditions |
n | Mean Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Median
Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before filter cleaning | 5 | 80 | 81 | 78-81 |
| After filter cleaning following manufacturer directions | 9 | 89 | 90 | 84-93 |
| * Static pressure was measured in millibars and converted to inches of water gauge. Flow rates were calculated using the formula Q = Ce (A) 4005 (SP)1/2 where: Q = flow in cubic feet per minute (cfm), Ce = coefficient of entry, A = area of the duct where static pressure measurements were taken in square feet, and SP = static pressure in inches of water gauge. | ||||
| Tool/Control | Collection Period (min.) |
Dust Collection Rate (lb/min.) |
|---|---|---|
| Bosch grinder/Dust Director shroud & DustControl 2900c vacuum |
8 11 8 8 10 |
0.50 0.61 0.50 0.47 0.63 |
| Average | 0.54 |
[content_transformed:protected] =>
Executive Summary
This report describes the results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. It should also be noted that the NIOSH REL is based on exposures averaged over a ten hour work day and our results represent time weighted averages of the sample task duration periods.
Acronyms
ACGIH - American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists
CPWR - CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training
Ce - coefficient of entry
HEPA - high-efficiency particulate air
IUBAC - International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craftworkers
LEV - local exhaust ventilation
PACT - Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies
NIOSH - National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health
OEL - occupational exposure limit
OSHA - Occupational Safety and Health Administration
PAPR - powered air-purifying respirator
PEL - Permissible Exposure Limit
PVC - polyvinyl chloride
REL - Recommended Exposure Limit
RPM - revolutions per minute
TWA - time-weighted average
SP - static pressure
I. Introduction and Background
In 2010 CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training began a four-year project which seeks to identify and evaluate tuckpointing local exhaust ventilation (LEV) systems and disseminate information on their availability and effectiveness. A Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies (PACT) comprised of masonry contractors, representatives from unions, government, equipment manufacturers, and health and safety researcher was formed as part of this project. PACT members participated in identifying important characteristics for control technologies and this information was used to identify LEV systems for tuckpointing using that criteria. Contractor and labor members of the PACT selected specific tuckpointing LEV systems to be considered for evaluation. Each system consisted of a tuckpointing grinder, shroud, and vacuum. This report describes the second of four systems to be evaluated between 2012 the end of 2014, with and without LEV, in a controlled setting to determine effectiveness in silica exposure reduction. This report describes the methods and results of our evaluation of a system consisting of the DustControl 2900c vacuum with the ICS Dust Director shroud and a Bosch Model 1775E grinder.
Excessive exposure to respirable silica can result in silicosis or other silica-related diseases including pulmonary tuberculosis, lung cancer, silicoproteinosis (Lyons et al, 2007) and autoimmune disorders such as rheumatoid arthritis, sarcoidosis and scleroderma (Miller et al, 2012). Respirable silica is generally defined as particles less than 10 micrometers (μm) in aerodynamic diameter (ACGIH, 2013). Silicosis can lead to symptoms including shortness of breath, fatigue, chest pains, susceptibility to infection and possibly death. There is no cure for silicosis, however it is totally preventable. Construction workers exposed to dust, including silica, are also known to have higher rates of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD).
There are many sources of silica in construction that result in exposures of varying intensity among workers. Masonry restoration workers are among the most highly silica-exposed trades in construction. The process of grinding out deteriorated mortar joints between masonry units and replacing or repointing with fresh mortar (often referred to as tuckpointing) is a fundamental part of masonry restoration work. The removal of mortar with powered angle grinders generates enormous levels of dust. Between 2004 and 2006, NIOSH and CPWR evaluated silica exposures while grinding mortar in a controlled setting, at a local training center, where tasks, sample times and task variables were defined by the study design. These studies demonstrated that grinding mortar without controls can result in elevated respirable silica exposures. Meeker et al., (2009) reported exposures between 5 and 25.8 milligrams per cubic meter (mg/m3) in a controlled setting. This study also showed that LEV systems for tuckpointing grinders can reduce exposures to respirable silica by greater than 90 percent.II. Objectives
The objective of this evaluation was to assess the effectiveness of an LEV system for controlling exposure to silica during the grinding of mortar. The control technology was tested under controlled conditions, similar to those experienced by tuckpointers on actual job sites, using journeymen bricklayers experienced in tuckpointing and repeat, randomized trials with and without LEV. All other variables were held constant throughout so that the only variable was whether or not the tested control was used.
III. Description of Equipment Tested
A Bosch model 1775E grinder (Robert Bosch Tool Corporation, Prospect, IL) (Figures 1, 2 and 3) was fitted with a new 1/4-inch wide, 4½-inch diameter segmented diamond abrasive blade made by DeWalt (model #DW4740). The grinder weighs six and a half pounds, draws 8.5 amps and has a variable speed up to 11,000 revolutions per minute (RPMs). The DustControl 2900c vacuum (DustControl, Inc., Wilmington, NC) (Figure 3) was tested in combination with the Dust Director shroud (Industrial Contractors’ Supplies, Inc., Huntingdon, PA) (Figures 1 and 3) attached to the Bosch grinder.
Figure 1. Bosch grinder with Dust Director shroud
Figure 2. Bosch grinder without tuckpointing LEV system.
Figure 3: Bosch Grinder with LEV System
The vacuum is specified to weigh 31 pounds when empty and to provide a flow rate of 114 cubic feet of air per minute and a “static lift” or “vacuum suction pressure” of 84 inches of water. The vacuum is sold with a cyclonic pre-separator, to remove larger particles, a fine filter (rated 99.9 percent efficient) and a HEPA (high-efficiency particulate air) filter (rated to capture 99.97 percent of the particles with an aerodynamic diameter of 0.3 micrometers). The HEPA filter was removed based on the manufacturer’s recommendation due to the heavy dust loading associated with tuckpointing. CPWR sponsored research and contractor experience indicate that HEPA filters likely have an adverse effect on dust capture during tuckpointing because of extreme dust loading on filters. While the cyclone and the fine filter remove most of the dust, especially the large particles, before they reach the HEPA filter, the HEPA filter would still be subject to heavy loading, causing a substantial pressure drop and subsequent decrease in air flow rate. The relatively small increase in the efficiency of the filtration system while using the HEPA filter is expected to be quickly offset by a more significant decrease in capture efficiency as the air flow rate and ability to capture particles decreases.
Dust collects in relatively inexpensive, heavy-gauge plastic bags below and outside of the cyclone. The bags can be removed and replaced without opening the vacuum. Some vacuums are equipped with a light to indicate that the filters need to be cleaned or changed. The DC2900c features a “reverse air pulse cleaning system,” which removes accumulated dust from the filters without having to remove them from the vacuum. The system, as illustrated in Figure 4, requires the operator to disconnect the hose from the shroud, place it over an air stop so that air through the hose is cut off and pressure in the vacuum is maximized.
Figure 4. Procedure for "cleaning" of or dust removal from filters (source: http://dustcontrolusa.com/manuals/2800c.pdf)
The flap covering the port on the side of the vacuum is repeatedly flipped open to release built up pressure in strong pulses that dislodge dust from the filter.
The manufacturer indicates “the filter is generally cleaned once or twice daily during normal continuous operation.” The Dust Director shroud has a 2-inch diameter take-off that was connected to the antistatic, corrugated 1.5-inch diameter, 15-foot long vacuum hose supplied with the DustControl vacuum.
IV. Study Methods
This evaluation was conducted at the International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craft workers (IUBAC) Local 1 Philadelphia/Delaware Training Center in Philadelphia, PA on November 14 and 15, 2012. A single journeyman bricklayer, experienced in tuckpointing, used the grinder and LEV system being tested to remove mortar from joints wide enough to require two passes. The type S mortar had been allowed to cure for at least four weeks. The bricklayer either possessed or was provided with personal protective equipment including sturdy work boots, gloves, hearing protection and a powered air-purifying respirator (PAPR). The PAPR was a 3M GVP system with a bump cap, loose fitting face piece and a HEPA filter (3M, St Paul, MN).
The study was designed to include at least five rounds of sampling during mortar removal. Each round included a trial using the Bosch grinder with a Dust Director shroud and Dust Collector 2900c vacuum and a trial using the Bosch grinder with the factory-supplied guard and without a vacuum. The order of the two trials within each round was randomly selected to minimize bias that might be introduced due to variation associated with environmental factors, equipment operator, blade wear, vacuum performance over time and any other factors unrelated to LEV use. Tools were operated for approximately 16 minutes per trial with controls and for approximately 8 minutes when controls were not used. These times were selected based on the results of previous sampling efforts and estimates of the minimum sample time needed to achieve a limit of quantification low enough to accurately measure exposures down to or less than 0.05 mg/m3 – the NIOSH Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) for respirable silica. The bricklayer was required to take a 5 to 10 minute break in the middle of the 16-minute trials to reduce differences in fatigue, compared to the 8-minute trials. Personal air samples were collected in the breathing zone of the operator during each trial to measure respirable silica concentrations during grinding with and without LEV. The samples were collected using a GilAir-5 pump (Sensidyne, Inc., Clearwater, FL) to draw 4.2 liters of air per minute through a GK2.69 Respirable Cyclone (BGI Inc., Waltham, MA) with a pre-weighed, 37 mm diameter, 5-micron pore size polyvinyl chloride (PVC) filter positioned on the operator’s lapel.
The flow rates of the sampling pumps were calibrated at the beginning of each day using a DryCal DC-Lite Primary Flow Meter (Bios International Corporation, Butler, NJ). Flow rates were measured again near the middle and at the end of each day to ensure that sampling flow rates were maintained within 5% of pre-sampling flow rates throughout the day. Average flow rates were used to calculate sample air volumes. Samples were analyzed by R.J. Lee Group, Inc., (Monroeville, PA) using NIOSH Method 0600, to determine exposure to total mass of respirable dust. The same samples were also analyzed using X-Ray diffraction following NIOSH method 7500 to determine quartz, cristobalite and tridymite concentration in the respirable mass. Reported masses for these analytes were used with the sample air volumes to calculate airborne concentrations of total respirable dust, quartz, cristobalite and tridymite.
We used a reduction of greater than 50 percent in respirable silica exposure concentrations or a reduction to less than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 as our criteria for determining whether or not a control was considered efficacious. This is consistent with criteria used by NIOSH in conducting a similar study in 2004 described by Echt et al. (2007) and by CPWR in 2006 and described by Meeker et al. (2009). The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) and the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) publish additional occupational exposure limits (OELs) for silica which are listed in Table 1 with NIOSH RELs. OELs for silica are based on the respirable fraction of the aerosol, which consists of particles less than 10 micrometers in aerodynamic diameter.
| Organization or Agency | Form of Crystalline Silica | Occupational Exposure Limits (mg/m3) |
|---|---|---|
| NIOSHA | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 |
| OSHA - ConstructionB | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
PEL = 250 / (5 + % quartz) PEL = 250 / (5 + % cristobalite) PEL = 250 / (5 + % tridymite) |
| ACGIH | Crystalline Silica | TLV = 0.025 mg/m3 |
A NIOSH Publication No. 2005-151 indicates 10-hour time-weighted average during a 40-hr workweek B The PEL for silica in OSHA’s Safety and Health Regulations for Construction, 29 C.F.R. 1926.55(a), is an 8-hour time-weighted average (TWA) expressed in millions of particles per cubic foot (mppcf). However, the units mppcf can be converted to milligrams per cubic meter can by dividing mppcf by 10 (OSHA, 2009). The formula used by OSHA to determine the PEL for silica is dependent on the percentage of silica in each collected sample. The concentration of respirable dust measured is compared to the sample specific PEL to determine if the PEL has been exceeded. OSHA has proposed lowering the PEL to 0.05 mg/m3 of respirable silica as an 8 hour TWA. |
||
The flow of air in ventilation systems is governed by fundamental principles that describe the behavior of gases (in this case air). Pressure measurements taken within a ventilation system along with knowledge of hood (or shroud) entry losses can be used to calculate flow rates. Hood entry losses are dependent on the shape and configuration of a particular hood or shroud and described by the term “coefficient of entry (Ce)” which is the ratio of actual air flow through a hood and what the air flow would theoretically be if there were no hood entry losses. Given the coefficient of entry, static pressure measurements can be used to calculate air flow through a given hood. The coefficient of entry for the Dust Director shroud was previously determined by CPWR and used for calculating air flow based on static pressure measurements (Meeker et al., 2009). Static pressure, with the vacuum operating, was measured periodically throughout the evaluation to monitor the changes in air-flow rate following use and again after filter cleaning. The static pressure was measured at a port positioned more than 3 duct diameters downstream from the tool’s air intake using a UEi EM200 Electronic Manometer (Universal Enterprises, Inc., Beaverton, OR).
The dust in the vacuum bag was monitored and, per the manufacturer’s instructions, the bag was changed before the dust level was within 5 centimeters of the valve at the bottom of the vacuum. Each time a vacuum bag was removed, it was weighed to the nearest pound. The bag weights and corresponding grinding durations were used to calculate the average weight of dust collected per unit time. After each trial, cut lengths were measured on the wall to determine total linear feet of vertical (head) and horizontal (bed) joints per unit time.
A Haz-Dust III, Model HD-1003, Real-Time Aerosol Monitor (Environmental Devices Corporation, Plaistow, NH) was used to confirm clearance of dust between trials. The Haz-Dust monitor was positioned on the test wall near the operator at approximately breathing zone level and configured to measure respirable particulate concentration.
V. Results
Personal air monitoring
Five pairs of respirable dust samples were collected while grinding with and without the vacuum system. In addition, three respirable dust samples were collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place. One measurement collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard was shown to be a statistical outlier and was omitted from analysis. Personal air monitoring results for respirable silica and a comparison of average exposures relative to the NIOSH REL for silica (0.05 mg/m3) appears in Table 2. The mean respirable dust levels measured without LEV was 31.4 mg/m3. However, samples collected with LEV were below the limit of quantification (LOQ) which ranged from <1.29 to <1.46 mg/m3. Use of LEV resulted in a greater than 95% reduction in mean respirable dust levels using a mean value with use of LEV of <1.41 (n=5 samples with use of LEV and n=7 without use of LEV). The respirable dust samples collected during grinding without the LEV system contained an average of 24 percent silica. The mass of respirable dust in the samples collected with use of the LEV system was too low to determine the silica content.| Mean, mg/m3 (range) | Std. Dev. | Percent Reduction | Hazard RatioB | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bosch with Dust Director Shroud and DustControl 2900c Vacuum |
0.091 (<0.069 – 0.137) |
0.027 | 98.7 | 1.81 |
| Bosch with no Control | 7.23 (4.57 – 9.90) |
1.94 | NA | 145 |
A n = 5 samples for each tool/control combination and n = 7 samples without the use of the LEV system B Hazard Ratio = measured exposure / NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 |
||||
Average respirable silica and dust exposures, with and without the dust control system, appear as Figures 5 and 6, respectively.
Figure 5. Average respirable silica exposures with and without the Dustcontrol 2900c vacuum and Dust Director shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air - mg/m3)
Figure 6. Average respirable dust exposures with and without Dustcontrol 2900c Vacuum and Dust Director Shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air – mg/m3)
The mean respirable silica concentration measured during use of the control was significantly less than the concentration measured while using the same tool without controls (p<0.01). Grinding mortar with the Bosch angle grinder without dust controls resulted in an average exposure to respirable silica that was 145 times the NIOSH REL. Grinding with the Bosch angle grinder in combination with the Dust Director shroud and the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced the average concentration of respirable silica by 98.7 percent. With use of these controls, the concentration of respirable silica was 1.8 times greater than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3. However the NIOSH REL is based on a time-weighted average (TWA) over a 10-hour workday. Given these were task TWAs and samples were collected over continuous periods of grinding, they may overestimate exposures over an actual work day since some time would be spent performing tasks that would likely have lower, or no, silica exposures (setup, breaks, cleanup, etc.).
Static pressure, dust mass collection and grinding rates.
Static pressure was used as a surrogate for air flow as described earlier. Hood static pressure was measured periodically at a tap near the grinder more than 3 duct diameters from the air intake in the shroud. The static pressure, and thus air flow, was generally higher when the vacuum’s filter had recently been cleaned. The mean, median, and range of calculated flow rates are presented in Table A1 of the Appendix.
Based on the data we collected, the air-flow rate upstream from the Bosch grinder and Dust Director shroud ranged from 78 to 93 cubic feet per minute (cfm) with the DustControl vacuum. When the manufacturer’s filter cleaning procedure was followed the vacuum performed relatively well and flow could be maintained at slightly less than 90 cfm with cleaning. However, mean flow rates dropped substantially to 80 cfm after as little as 8 minutes of grinding without any filter cleaning. The flow rate returned to an average of 89 cfm when filters were cleaned correctly (without stopping air flow to the vacuum). Collingwood and Heitbrink (2007) found that the minimum exhaust flow rate for capture of silica and other particulate under ideal conditions is 21.25 cfm per inch of grinder blade diameter. This is equal to about 96 cfm when using a 4.5 inch diameter grinding blade. We set 106 cfm as the minimum desired flow rate for this study to allow a safety margin for potential decline in equipment performance and the possibility of inadequate maintenance, both of which may be likely after repeated use under actual work conditions. The DustControl vacuum provided slightly less than the minimum flow rate described by Collingwood and Heitbrink for a 4.5-inch blade and the peak flow rate fell with use.
The duration of vacuum bag use and mass of dust collected were recorded and are presented in Table A2 of the Appendix. The vacuum bags were changed and weighed after each trial utilizing the LEV system. A total of five bags were used to complete the five rounds of grinding. The DustControl vacuum captured 45 pounds of dust over 83 minutes of grinding for an average rate of dust collection of 0.54 pounds per minute. The rate of dust collection ranged from 0.47 to 0.63 pounds per minute. Based on these measurements, approximately 130 pounds of dust would likely be captured after just 4 hours of continuous grinding.
The rate of grinding a combination of vertical and horizontal joints while using the LEV system ranged from 2.3 to 3.3 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the use of the LEV system ranged from 2.6 to 3.4 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place ranged from 4.7 to 5.1 feet per minute. It’s important to note that: 1) the operator had limited experience using dust control systems and cut rates appeared to improve slightly over the 2-day period he used the tested equipment; and 2) the upper range of cut rates with the dust control system overlapped with the lowest cut rate with the original guard and without the LEV system in place indicating no statistical difference between cut rates. Given that grinding rates with and without use of this LEV system are only available for one operator and he had limited experience with the LEV system, these reported cut rates are in no way intended to represent the impact use of this LEV system is likely to have on productivity rates overall.
VI. Discussion
The objective of these trials was to evaluate the effectiveness of a tuckpointing LEV system for controlling respirable silica while grinding out mortar joints. The Dust Director shroud with the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced respirable silica concentrations when grinding with the Bosch grinder by approximately 99 percent. Despite being considered effective by our test criteria (greater than 50% reduction), it still resulted in task TWA exposures that exceeded the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 by 1.8 times. Depending on how much time is spent grinding over the course of a work day and on exposures while performing other tasks, the 8-hour TWA exposures may or may not exceed the REL with this system. Use of this system by workers with experience and training in proficient use will likely improve dust capture performance. Exposure reduction is greatly influenced by correct use of this system which includes grinding from right to left, making sure the shroud is held flush against the wall and that the tool travels at a pace that doesn’t exceed the ability of the system to capture dust as it’s generated. Deviation from any of these measures produces visible dust clouds which were observed during trials.
VII. Conclusions
With a 99 percent reduction in respirable silica exposure, the Dust Director shroud and DustControl 2900c vacuum with a Bosch Model 1775E grinder was effective in reducing silica exposures based on our criteria. Use of the tested dust control system may be effective in reducing silica exposure on the job to less than the NIOSH REL if used in combination with administrative controls such as work scheduling to reduce cutting times as needed. Training on correct use of the tested system is also essential. Personal air monitoring is necessary to verify control effectiveness on actual job sites and under “real-world” conditions. However, these results clearly demonstrate the availability of viable and effective engineering controls for tuckpointing operations associated with elevated silica exposure.
VIII. References
American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists. Threshold limit values for chemical substances (TLV®-CS). [2013]. ACGIH, Cincinnati, Ohio.
Bergdahl I.A,. Toren K., Eriksson K., et al. [2004]. Increased mortality in COPD among construction workers exposed to inorganic dust. European Respiratory Journal, 23: 402–06.
Blanc P.D. & Torén K. [2007]. Occupation in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and chronic bronchitis: an update [State of the Art Series. Occupational lung disease in high-and low-income countries, Edited by M. Chan-Yeung. Number 2 in the series]. The International Journal of Tuberculosis and Lung Disease, 11(3), 251-257.
Collingwood S. & Heitbrink W.A. [2007] 'Field Evaluation of an Engineering Control for Respirable Crystalline Silica Exposures During Mortar Removal'. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, 4:11, 875 – 887.
DHHS (NIOSH) Publication No. 2002-129 April 2002 http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/2002-129/
Echt A., Sieber W.K., Lefkowitz D., Meeker J., Susi P., Cardwell B., Heitbrink, W.A. In-depth survey of dust control technology for cutting concrete block and tuckpointing brick at The International Masonry Institute Bordentown Training Center, Bordentown, NJ. Cincinnati, OH: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Report. No. EPHB 282-13; 2007. http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ECTB-282-13.pdf
Heitbrink W., Bennett J. [2006]. A numerical and experimental investigation of crystalline silica exposure control during tuck pointing. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, Vol. 3, pp 366-378.
Lyons et al, [2007]. A breathless builder. Breathe, Vol. 3, no. 4, pp 386-390.
Mastrangelo G., Tartari M., Fedeli U., Fadda E., Saia B. [2003]. Ascertaining the risk of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease in relation to occupation using a case-control design. Occupational Medicine, 53: 165–172.
Meeker J., Cooper M., Lefrowitz D., Susi P. [2009]. Engineering control technologies to reduce occupational silica exposures in masonry cutting and tuckpointing. Public Health Reports, Supplement 1, Vol. 124, June.
Meeker J, Flynn M, Susi P, Cardwell, B [2004]. Performance evaluation of a masonry concrete vacuum. Unpublished Report.
Miller F. W., Alfredsson L., Costenbader K. H., Kamen D. L., Nelson L. M., Norris J. M., & De Roos A. J. [2012]. Epidemiology of environmental exposures and human autoimmune diseases: findings from a National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences Expert Panel workshop. Journal of autoimmunity. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3496812/
Occupational Safety and Health Administration U.S Department of Labor. Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction. [2009]. OSHA 3362-05.
Rappaport SM, Goldberg M, Susi P, Herrick RF [2003]. Excessive exposure to silica in the U.S. construction industry. Annals of Occupational Hygiene, Vol. 47, pp. 111-122.
IX. Appendices
| Measurement Conditions |
n | Mean Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Median
Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before filter cleaning | 5 | 80 | 81 | 78-81 |
| After filter cleaning following manufacturer directions | 9 | 89 | 90 | 84-93 |
| * Static pressure was measured in millibars and converted to inches of water gauge. Flow rates were calculated using the formula Q = Ce (A) 4005 (SP)1/2 where: Q = flow in cubic feet per minute (cfm), Ce = coefficient of entry, A = area of the duct where static pressure measurements were taken in square feet, and SP = static pressure in inches of water gauge. | ||||
| Tool/Control | Collection Period (min.) |
Dust Collection Rate (lb/min.) |
|---|---|---|
| Bosch grinder/Dust Director shroud & DustControl 2900c vacuum |
8 11 8 8 10 |
0.50 0.61 0.50 0.47 0.63 |
| Average | 0.54 |
[disclaimer:protected] => [disclaimer_transformed:protected] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [template] => record ) [_globalContext:PHPTAL_Context:private] => stdClass Object ( ) [_echoDeclarations:PHPTAL_Context:private] => [referer] => http://www.elcosh.org/document/3908/d001345/An%2BEvaluation%2Bof%2BSilica%2BExposure%2BControls%2Bfor%2BTuckpointing%253A%2BDustControl%2B2900c%2BVacuum%2Bwith%2Bthe%2BICS%2BDust%2BDirector%2BShroud%2Band%2BBosch%2BGrinder%2BModel%2B1775E%2BConducted%2BNovember%2B14-15%252C%2B2012.html [curr_module] => Record [styles] => Array ( ) [javascript] => Array ( [0] => jquery.min.js ) [metas] => Array ( [language] => en [robots] => index, follow ) [user] => [curr_url] => https://www.elcosh.org/index.php?module=Record&id=3908&type=document [base_url] => https://www.elcosh.org/index.php?module=Record [title] => eLCOSH : An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: DustControl 2900c Vacuum with the ICS Dust Director Shroud and Bosch Grinder Model 1775E Conducted November 14-15, 2012 [language] => en [search_query] => [module] => Record [new_records] => Array ( [0] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Fixed Ladder [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Fixed Ladders addresses the potential risks associated with using fixed ladders. The resource includes a brief case example,... [category] => Array ( [0] => 15 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 53 [5] => 55 [6] => 60 [7] => 64 [8] => 73 [9] => 76 [10] => 78 [11] => 80 [12] => 86 [13] => 87 [14] => 90 [15] => 92 [16] => 93 [17] => 94 [18] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Falls [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Concrete Polisher [11] => Electrical Worker [13] => HVAC [15] => Laborer [17] => PCC/Restoration [19] => Plumber/Pipefitter [21] => Roofer/Waterproofer [23] => Sheetmetal Worker [25] => Welder [27] => Commercial & Institutional [28] => Jobsites [29] => Industrial [31] => LEED/Green Construction [33] => Renovations [35] => Residential [37] => Toolbox Talks [38] => Documents [39] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4430/d001660/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BFixed%2BLadder.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [53] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 53 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Concrete Polisher [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [73] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 73 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => PCC/Restoration [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4430 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001660 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Fixed Ladder [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Fixed Ladders, Fall Prevention, Falls [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Fixed Ladders addresses the potential risks associated with using fixed ladders. The resource includes a brief case example, steps to prevent a related injury and questions for discussion. It includes an image that illustrates the hazard, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001257,d001254,d001255,d001256,d001258,d001262,d001279 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_completed:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/22/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [1] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Challenges Preventing Falling Objects [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Challenges Preventing Falling Objects addresses the hazards of being struck by falling objects on the job site. The resource... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 55 [5] => 64 [6] => 68 [7] => 71 [8] => 75 [9] => 78 [10] => 79 [11] => 82 [12] => 62 [13] => 86 [14] => 87 [15] => 88 [16] => 89 [17] => 91 [18] => 90 [19] => 92 [20] => 93 [21] => 94 [22] => 95 [23] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Electrical Worker [11] => Laborer [13] => Maintenance Worker [15] => Painter [17] => Plasterer [19] => Roofer/Waterproofer [21] => Scaffold Erector [23] => Stonemason [25] => Structural Ironworker [27] => Welder [29] => Commercial & Institutional [30] => Jobsites [31] => Demolition [33] => Disasters [35] => Heavy & Highway [37] => Industrial [39] => LEED/Green Construction [41] => Renovations [43] => Residential [45] => Underground [47] => Toolbox Talks [48] => Documents [49] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4431/d001661/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BChallenges%2BPreventing%2BFalling%2BObjects.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4431 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001661 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Challenges Preventing Falling Objects [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => dropped objects, falling objects, struck by incidents, struck by fatalities [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Challenges Preventing Falling Objects addresses the hazards of being struck by falling objects on the job site. The resource includes a brief example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates a group workers observing a scaffold free of debris during high winds, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001234,d001238,d001244,d001251,d001253,d001260,d001268,d001278 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_completed:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/22/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [2] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Tower Crane Safety [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Tower Crane Safety addresses the potential hazards of Tower Cranes and the importance of following procedure before and durin... [category] => Array ( [0] => 11 [1] => 12 [2] => 18 [3] => 70 [4] => 87 [5] => 88 [6] => 91 [7] => 90 [8] => 92 [9] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Cranes & Hoists [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Crushed/Struck By [6] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [9] => Operating Engineer [10] => Trades [11] => Commercial & Institutional [12] => Jobsites [13] => Demolition [15] => Heavy & Highway [17] => Industrial [19] => LEED/Green Construction [21] => Toolbox Talks [22] => Documents [23] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4427/d001657/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BTower%2BCrane%2BSafety.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [11] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 11 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Cranes & Hoists [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [18] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 18 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4427 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001657 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Tower Crane Safety [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Tower Crane, Crane, Stability, Tipping, Lift Zone Safety, Lift, Zone, Safety, Struck by [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Tower Crane Safety addresses the potential hazards of Tower Cranes and the importance of following procedure before and during Tower Crane operation. The resource includes a brief example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates a worker inspecting a Tower Crane before operation, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001234,d001238,d001250,d001251,d001253,d001258,d001262,d001273 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/19/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [3] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Work Zone Safety: Working Around Vehicles [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Working Around Vehicles in the Work Zone addresses methods to avoid being struck-by a vehicle on a construction site. The res... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 18 [2] => 52 [3] => 57 [4] => 70 [5] => 85 [6] => 87 [7] => 88 [8] => 89 [9] => 91 [10] => 90 [11] => 92 [12] => 93 [13] => 94 [14] => 95 [15] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [6] => Commercial Diver [7] => Trades [8] => Flagger [10] => Operating Engineer [12] => Truck Driver [14] => Commercial & Institutional [15] => Jobsites [16] => Demolition [18] => Disasters [20] => Heavy & Highway [22] => Industrial [24] => LEED/Green Construction [26] => Renovations [28] => Residential [30] => Underground [32] => Toolbox Talks [33] => Documents [34] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4428/d001658/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BWork%2BZone%2BSafety%253A%2BWorking%2BAround%2BVehicles.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [18] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 18 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [52] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 52 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Commercial Diver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [85] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 85 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Truck Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4428 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001658 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Daniela Caceres [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Work Zone Safety: Working Around Vehicles [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Struck, Struck by, Vehicle, Work Zone Safety, Truck, Operator, Driver, Mobile Equipment [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Working Around Vehicles in the Work Zone addresses methods to avoid being struck-by a vehicle on a construction site. The resource includes a case example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates the hazard, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001640 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/19/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [4] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Construction Dive -- DeWalt's Jobsite Pro headphones recalled for fire hazards [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => A recall notice by the United States Consumer Product Safety Commission affects over 300,000 DeWalt Jobsite Pro Headphones. The recall is a result of... [category] => Array ( [0] => 16 [1] => 44 [2] => 45 [3] => 46 [4] => 47 [5] => 48 [6] => 49 [7] => 50 [8] => 51 [9] => 52 [10] => 53 [11] => 54 [12] => 55 [13] => 56 [14] => 57 [15] => 58 [16] => 59 [17] => 60 [18] => 61 [19] => 64 [20] => 65 [21] => 66 [22] => 67 [23] => 68 [24] => 69 [25] => 70 [26] => 71 [27] => 72 [28] => 73 [29] => 74 [30] => 75 [31] => 76 [32] => 77 [33] => 63 [34] => 78 [35] => 79 [36] => 80 [37] => 81 [38] => 82 [39] => 62 [40] => 83 [41] => 84 [42] => 85 [43] => 86 [44] => 87 [45] => 88 [46] => 89 [47] => 91 [48] => 90 [49] => 92 [50] => 93 [51] => 94 [52] => 95 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Fire & Explosions [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Acoustical Ceiling Carpenter [4] => Trades [5] => Asbestos/Insulator [7] => Boilermaker [9] => Bricklayer [11] => Cabinetmaker [13] => Carpenter [15] => Carpet Layer [17] => Cement Mason [19] => Commercial Diver [21] => Concrete Polisher [23] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [25] => Electrical Worker [27] => Elevator Constructor [29] => Flagger [31] => Glazier [33] => Hazardous Waste Cleanup [35] => HVAC [37] => Interior Systems Carpenter [39] => Laborer [41] => Landscaper [43] => Lather [45] => Lead Abatement Worker [47] => Maintenance Worker [49] => Millwright [51] => Operating Engineer [53] => Painter [55] => Paper Hanger [57] => PCC/Restoration [59] => Pile Driver [61] => Plasterer [63] => Plumber/Pipefitter [65] => Refractory Worker [67] => Reinforcing Ironworker [69] => Roofer/Waterproofer [71] => Scaffold Erector [73] => Sheetmetal Worker [75] => Sprinkler Fitter [77] => Stonemason [79] => Structural Ironworker [81] => Terrazzo Worker [83] => Tile Setter [85] => Truck Driver [87] => Welder [89] => Commercial & Institutional [90] => Jobsites [91] => Demolition [93] => Disasters [95] => Heavy & Highway [97] => Industrial [99] => LEED/Green Construction [101] => Renovations [103] => Residential [105] => Underground ) [type] => [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4426/d001656/Construction%2BDive%2B--%2BDeWalt%2527s%2BJobsite%2BPro%2Bheadphones%2Brecalled%2Bfor%2Bfire%2Bhazards.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [16] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 16 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Fire & Explosions [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [44] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 44 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Acoustical Ceiling Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [45] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 45 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Asbestos/Insulator [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [46] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 46 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Boilermaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [48] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 48 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cabinetmaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [50] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 50 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpet Layer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [52] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 52 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Commercial Diver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [53] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 53 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Concrete Polisher [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [54] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 54 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [58] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 58 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Glazier [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [59] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 59 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Hazardous Waste Cleanup [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [65] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 65 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Landscaper [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [66] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 66 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Lather [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [67] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 67 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Lead Abatement Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [69] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 69 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Millwright [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [72] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 72 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Paper Hanger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [73] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 73 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => PCC/Restoration [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [77] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 77 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Refractory Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [81] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 81 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sprinkler Fitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [83] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 83 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Terrazzo Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [84] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 84 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Tile Setter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [85] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 85 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Truck Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4426 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001656 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Construction Dive -- DeWalt's Jobsite Pro headphones recalled for fire hazards [total_pages:protected] => 1 [billed_pages:protected] => 1 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => DeWalt, Fire Hazards, recall, headphones [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A recall notice by the United States Consumer Product Safety Commission affects over 300,000 DeWalt Jobsite Pro Headphones. The recall is a result of a malfunction that can cause earbuds to overheat while charging or during use, leading to fire and burn hazards. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => https://www.constructiondive.com/news/dewalts-jobsite-pro-headphones-recalled-for-fire-hazards/611248/?utm_source=Sailthru&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Issue:%202021-12-10%20Construction%20Dive%20Newsletter%20%5Bissue:38532%5D&utm_term=Construction%20Dive [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/13/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/13/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 12/13/21 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [new_images] => Array ( [0] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Morning Toolbox Talk [image] => /record/images/4003-p.jpg [blurb] => This photo is from an early morning toolbox talk on a construction job in Mclean, Virginia. It is being delivered in English and Spanish.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 20 [1] => 51 [2] => 57 [3] => 64 [4] => 70 [5] => 63 [6] => 78 [7] => 82 [8] => 62 [9] => 87 [10] => 88 [11] => 89 [12] => 91 [13] => 90 [14] => 93 [15] => 94 [16] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Safety Culture [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Cement Mason [4] => Trades [5] => Flagger [7] => Laborer [9] => Operating Engineer [11] => Reinforcing Ironworker [13] => Roofer/Waterproofer [15] => Stonemason [17] => Structural Ironworker [19] => Commercial & Institutional [20] => Jobsites [21] => Demolition [23] => Disasters [25] => Heavy & Highway [27] => Industrial [29] => Renovations [31] => Residential [33] => Images [34] => Media [35] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4003/i002691/Morning%2BToolbox%2BTalk.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4003 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002691 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Morning Toolbox Talk [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, Spanish, bilingual [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This photo is from an early morning toolbox talk on a construction job in Mclean, Virginia. It is being delivered in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001285,d001304,c000079 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [1] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox talk - crew view [image] => /record/images/4005-p.jpg [blurb] => Photo of crew listening to a toolbox safety talk before starting work.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 97 [1] => 20 [2] => 47 [3] => 49 [4] => 51 [5] => 55 [6] => 61 [7] => 64 [8] => 71 [9] => 75 [10] => 63 [11] => 79 [12] => 62 [13] => 87 [14] => 88 [15] => 91 [16] => 90 [17] => 93 [18] => 94 [19] => 95 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Images [1] => Media [2] => Media & Documents [3] => Safety Culture [4] => Work Environment [5] => Hazards [6] => Bricklayer [7] => Trades [8] => Carpenter [10] => Cement Mason [12] => Electrical Worker [14] => Interior Systems Carpenter [16] => Laborer [18] => Painter [20] => Plasterer [22] => Reinforcing Ironworker [24] => Scaffold Erector [26] => Structural Ironworker [28] => Commercial & Institutional [29] => Jobsites [30] => Demolition [32] => Heavy & Highway [34] => Industrial [36] => Renovations [38] => Residential [40] => Underground ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4005/i002692/Toolbox%2Btalk%2B-%2Bcrew%2Bview.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4005 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002692 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox talk - crew view [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, safety talk, Spanish [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Photo of crew listening to a toolbox safety talk before starting work. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002691,d001269, c000079, d001285 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [2] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox talk - long shot [image] => /record/images/4006-p.jpg [blurb] => This crew gathered every morning before starting work to discuss a new safety topic.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 20 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 55 [5] => 64 [6] => 68 [7] => 75 [8] => 76 [9] => 63 [10] => 78 [11] => 79 [12] => 82 [13] => 62 [14] => 87 [15] => 88 [16] => 91 [17] => 90 [18] => 93 [19] => 94 [20] => 95 [21] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Safety Culture [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Electrical Worker [11] => Laborer [13] => Maintenance Worker [15] => Plasterer [17] => Plumber/Pipefitter [19] => Reinforcing Ironworker [21] => Roofer/Waterproofer [23] => Scaffold Erector [25] => Stonemason [27] => Structural Ironworker [29] => Commercial & Institutional [30] => Jobsites [31] => Demolition [33] => Heavy & Highway [35] => Industrial [37] => Renovations [39] => Residential [41] => Underground [43] => Images [44] => Media [45] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4006/i002693/Toolbox%2Btalk%2B-%2Blong%2Bshot.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4006 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002693 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox talk - long shot [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, safety minute [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This crew gathered every morning before starting work to discuss a new safety topic. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002691,i002692,d001269,d000527 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [3] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Safety officer discussing ongoing project with marketing coordinator [image] => /record/images/4014-p.jpg [blurb] => The safety officer (left) points out the good safety practices on this project that reflect well on the firm and may influence future clients.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 97 [1] => 20 [2] => 46 [3] => 47 [4] => 49 [5] => 50 [6] => 51 [7] => 54 [8] => 55 [9] => 58 [10] => 60 [11] => 61 [12] => 64 [13] => 71 [14] => 75 [15] => 76 [16] => 63 [17] => 79 [18] => 80 [19] => 82 [20] => 62 [21] => 83 [22] => 87 [23] => 91 [24] => 90 [25] => 93 [26] => 94 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Images [1] => Media [2] => Media & Documents [3] => Safety Culture [4] => Work Environment [5] => Hazards [6] => Boilermaker [7] => Trades [8] => Bricklayer [10] => Carpenter [12] => Carpet Layer [14] => Cement Mason [16] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [18] => Electrical Worker [20] => Glazier [22] => HVAC [24] => Interior Systems Carpenter [26] => Laborer [28] => Painter [30] => Plasterer [32] => Plumber/Pipefitter [34] => Reinforcing Ironworker [36] => Scaffold Erector [38] => Sheetmetal Worker [40] => Stonemason [42] => Structural Ironworker [44] => Terrazzo Worker [46] => Commercial & Institutional [47] => Jobsites [48] => Heavy & Highway [50] => Industrial [52] => Renovations [54] => Residential ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4014/i002700/Safety%2Bofficer%2Bdiscussing%2Bongoing%2Bproject%2Bwith%2Bmarketing%2Bcoordinator.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [46] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 46 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Boilermaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [50] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 50 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpet Layer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [54] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 54 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [58] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 58 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Glazier [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [83] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 83 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Terrazzo Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4014 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002700 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Safety officer discussing ongoing project with marketing coordinator [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Latino, safety officer, safety culture [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The safety officer (left) points out the good safety practices on this project that reflect well on the firm and may influence future clients. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/index.php [more_like_this:protected] => d000989,d001351,d001362,d000652, d001101, d000931, d001395 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Hoar Construction, Photo by Neil Lippy [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 01/30/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [4] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Scaffolding at top of large column [image] => /record/images/3994-p.jpg [blurb] => This shot shows innovative guarding around the top of a large concrete column in the base of a high rise structure going up.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 15 [1] => 21 [2] => 47 [3] => 51 [4] => 63 [5] => 78 [6] => 79 [7] => 80 [8] => 62 [9] => 87 [10] => 97 [11] => 56 [12] => 64 [13] => 74 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Falls [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Scaffolds [6] => Bricklayer [7] => Trades [8] => Cement Mason [10] => Reinforcing Ironworker [12] => Roofer/Waterproofer [14] => Scaffold Erector [16] => Sheetmetal Worker [18] => Structural Ironworker [20] => Commercial & Institutional [21] => Jobsites [22] => Images [23] => Media [24] => Media & Documents [25] => Elevator Constructor [27] => Laborer [29] => Pile Driver ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/3994/i002689/Scaffolding%2Bat%2Btop%2Bof%2Blarge%2Bcolumn.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [21] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 21 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Scaffolds [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3994 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002689 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Scaffolding at top of large column [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Guardrail, railing, fall prevention, falls [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This shot shows innovative guarding around the top of a large concrete column in the base of a high rise structure going up. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/8/adjustable-tower-scaffold.html [more_like_this:protected] => c1002680,i002662,d000608,d001255 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Photo by Pam Susi [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2016 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_completed:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/01/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [5] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Construction bracing [image] => /record/images/3995-p.jpg [blurb] => This shows structural support that prevents collapses during construction.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 15 [2] => 21 [3] => 49 [4] => 51 [5] => 55 [6] => 56 [7] => 60 [8] => 64 [9] => 68 [10] => 74 [11] => 63 [12] => 78 [13] => 79 [14] => 80 [15] => 62 [16] => 87 [17] => 90 [18] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Falls [6] => Scaffolds [9] => Carpenter [10] => Trades [11] => Cement Mason [13] => Electrical Worker [15] => Elevator Constructor [17] => HVAC [19] => Laborer [21] => Maintenance Worker [23] => Pile Driver [25] => Reinforcing Ironworker [27] => Roofer/Waterproofer [29] => Scaffold Erector [31] => Sheetmetal Worker [33] => Structural Ironworker [35] => Commercial & Institutional [36] => Jobsites [37] => Industrial [39] => Images [40] => Media [41] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/3995/i002690/Construction%2Bbracing.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [21] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 21 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Scaffolds [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3995 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002690 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Construction bracing [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Bracing, support, scaffold [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This shows structural support that prevents collapses during construction. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/8/adjustable-tower-scaffold.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002660 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Photo by Pam Susi [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2016 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_completed:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/01/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [preview_mode] => [description] => The results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. [keywords] => tuckpointing, HEPA vacuum, dust control, LEV, local exhaust ventilation, silica [related_items] => Array ( [Research Reports] => Array ( [0] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1874 [old_id:protected] => 722 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000683 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Sharon Garber/COD [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Protecting Tuckpointing Workers from Silica Dust: Draft Recommendations for a Ventilated Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 12 [billed_pages:protected] => 12 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, vacuum, grinder, mortar, respirator, OSHA, NIOSH, exhaust, Heitbrink, tuckpointer, silica, masonry, dust, silicosis, LEV [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Describes draft recommendations for use of ventilated grinder to reduce dust during tuckpointing and describes field trials using these devices. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/hazard/67/chip-scrape-and-grind-surfaces-or-joints-silica.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001201,d000292,d000293,d000658 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2005 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/27/05 [date_completed:protected] => 04/26/05 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/20/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [1] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1940 [old_id:protected] => 909 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Workplace Solutions: Control of Hazardous Dust During Tuckpointing [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, silica, dust, tuckpoint, grinder, masonry restoration, mortar, vacuum [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d000819,d000820,d000730,d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 10/24/08 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/09 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [2] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3899 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001342 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: Hilti VC40-U Vacuum with Hilti DC-EX Dust Guard and Hilti Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 15 [billed_pages:protected] => 15 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP4 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => silica, tuckpointing, Hilti, local exhaust systems, LEV, shroud, quartz [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This report describes the results of an evaluation of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Hilti VC40-U vacuum, a Hilti DC-EX shroud, and a Hilti DAG-500 grinder. Randomized trials with and without use of the dust control system were conducted in a controlled setting. Removing mortar with the Hilti grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 220 times the National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05mg/m3. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 97 percent. However, exposures measured during the use of the dust control system still exceeded the NIOSH REL. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => December 1, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/05/14 [date_completed:protected] => 02/04/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/06/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [Handouts] => Array ( [0] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3656 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001198 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 24 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction While Doing Tuckpointing/Mortar Removal [total_pages:protected] => 2 [billed_pages:protected] => 2 [publication_number:protected] => DSG FS-3632 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Brick, block, tuckpointing, silica, local exhaust ventilation, LEV, masonry [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Tuckpointing creates some of the greatest exposures to silica in construction. This OSHA factsheet provides guidance on how to greatly reduce these exposures through the use of local exhaust ventilation. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863, d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => February 2013 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/04/13 [date_completed:protected] => 03/27/13 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [collections] => Array ( [3913] => ) [record] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => Array ( [867] => Author Object ( [id:protected] => 867 [organization_id:protected] => 0 [firstname:protected] => Michael [lastname:protected] => Cooper [address:protected] => [city:protected] => [province:protected] => [country:protected] => [postal_code:protected] => [department:protected] => [title:protected] => [phone:protected] => [fax:protected] => [email:protected] => [degree:protected] => [website:protected] => [about:protected] => [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => [date_completed:protected] => [date_billed:protected] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [481] => Author Object ( [id:protected] => 481 [organization_id:protected] => 0 [firstname:protected] => Pam [lastname:protected] => Susi [address:protected] => 8484 Georgia Avenue, Suite 1000 [city:protected] => Silver Spring [province:protected] => Maryland [country:protected] => USA [postal_code:protected] => 20910 [department:protected] => [title:protected] => [phone:protected] => 301-578-8500 ext.144 [fax:protected] => 301-578-8572 [email:protected] => plsusi@aol.com [degree:protected] => [website:protected] => http://www.cpwr.com [about:protected] => [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => 2003-10-02 [date_completed:protected] => 2003-10-06 [date_billed:protected] => 2003-11-03 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [organizations:protected] => Array ( [1] => Organization Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [elcosh_id:protected] => o000001 [user_id:protected] => 14 [province_id:protected] => 21 [country_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => CPWR - The Center for Construction Research and Training [address:protected] => Suite 1000, 8484 Georgia Ave [postal_code:protected] => 20910 [city:protected] => Silver Spring [department:protected] => [phone:protected] => 301-578-8500 [fax:protected] => 301-578-8572 [email:protected] => cpwrwebsite@cpwr.com [website:protected] => http://www.cpwr.com [filename:protected] => o000001.gif [about:protected] => CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training, developed, and continues to maintain/expand this website - The Electronic Library of Construction Occupational Safety and Health, www.elcosh.org. CPWR, formerly known as The Center to Protect Workers’ Rights, is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit research and training institution. Created by the Building and Construction Trades Department, AFL-CIO, CPWR serves as the research arm of the BCTD. Since the inception of its research agenda in 1990, CPWR has grown into a worldwide provider of safety and health information covering all aspects of the construction industry. CPWR launched eLCOSH in 2000, and the Spanish-language version of the site in 2001. CPWR also created, and continues to build, Construction Solutions - www.cpwrConstructionSolutions.org - a free, online database of construction hazards and ways to prevent, eliminate, or reduce them. [comments:protected] => [logo_available:protected] => T [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => 2000-08-18 [date_completed:protected] => 2000-08-30 [date_billed:protected] => 2000-09-05 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [collections:protected] => Array ( [3913] => ) [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => Array ( [1874] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1874 [old_id:protected] => 722 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000683 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Sharon Garber/COD [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Protecting Tuckpointing Workers from Silica Dust: Draft Recommendations for a Ventilated Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 12 [billed_pages:protected] => 12 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, vacuum, grinder, mortar, respirator, OSHA, NIOSH, exhaust, Heitbrink, tuckpointer, silica, masonry, dust, silicosis, LEV [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Describes draft recommendations for use of ventilated grinder to reduce dust during tuckpointing and describes field trials using these devices. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/hazard/67/chip-scrape-and-grind-surfaces-or-joints-silica.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001201,d000292,d000293,d000658 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2005 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/27/05 [date_completed:protected] => 04/26/05 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/20/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [1940] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1940 [old_id:protected] => 909 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Workplace Solutions: Control of Hazardous Dust During Tuckpointing [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, silica, dust, tuckpoint, grinder, masonry restoration, mortar, vacuum [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d000819,d000820,d000730,d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 10/24/08 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/09 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [2213] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 2213 [old_id:protected] => 1090 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => [language_id:protected] => 2 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Control del polvo peligroso que se genera durante los procesos de reparación de mortero [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => 2008-126 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => [comments:protected] => http://www.cdc.gov/spanish/niosh/docs/wp-solutions/2008-126_sp/ [summary:protected] => A Workplace Solutions de NIOSH que resume un estudio de NIOSH sobre los riesgos de exposición cuando se reparan las estructuras y los métodos para controlar el polvo. [A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust.] [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => D000819,D000820,D000730,d000819 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 01/07/10 [date_completed:protected] => 04/19/10 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 07/08/12 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [3656] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3656 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001198 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 24 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction While Doing Tuckpointing/Mortar Removal [total_pages:protected] => 2 [billed_pages:protected] => 2 [publication_number:protected] => DSG FS-3632 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Brick, block, tuckpointing, silica, local exhaust ventilation, LEV, masonry [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Tuckpointing creates some of the greatest exposures to silica in construction. This OSHA factsheet provides guidance on how to greatly reduce these exposures through the use of local exhaust ventilation. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863, d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => February 2013 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/04/13 [date_completed:protected] => 03/27/13 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [3899] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3899 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001342 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: Hilti VC40-U Vacuum with Hilti DC-EX Dust Guard and Hilti Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 15 [billed_pages:protected] => 15 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP4 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => silica, tuckpointing, Hilti, local exhaust systems, LEV, shroud, quartz [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This report describes the results of an evaluation of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Hilti VC40-U vacuum, a Hilti DC-EX shroud, and a Hilti DAG-500 grinder. Randomized trials with and without use of the dust control system were conducted in a controlled setting. Removing mortar with the Hilti grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 220 times the National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05mg/m3. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 97 percent. However, exposures measured during the use of the dust control system still exceeded the NIOSH REL. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => December 1, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/05/14 [date_completed:protected] => 02/04/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/06/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [content:protected] => [files:protected] => Array ( [559] => [560] => [546] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 546 [filename:protected] => 3.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:22 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [566] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 566 [filename:protected] => 4.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:23 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [720] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 720 [filename:protected] => 5.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [721] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 721 [filename:protected] => 6.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [722] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 722 [filename:protected] => 7.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [9765] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 9765 [filename:protected] => d001345.pdf [downloadable:protected] => T [timestamp:protected] => 2015-02-09 12:26:04 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3908 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001345 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: DustControl 2900c Vacuum with the ICS Dust Director Shroud and Bosch Grinder Model 1775E Conducted November 14-15, 2012 [total_pages:protected] => 13 [billed_pages:protected] => 13 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP2 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => tuckpointing, HEPA vacuum, dust control, LEV, local exhaust ventilation, silica [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => April 15, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 01/26/15 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/09/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [show_text] => [document_content] => ElcoshItemDocumentContent Object ( [id:protected] => 2934 [item_id:protected] => 3908 [type:protected] => main [title:protected] => [content:protected] =>
Executive Summary
This report describes the results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. It should also be noted that the NIOSH REL is based on exposures averaged over a ten hour work day and our results represent time weighted averages of the sample task duration periods.
Acronyms
ACGIH - American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists
CPWR - CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training
Ce - coefficient of entry
HEPA - high-efficiency particulate air
IUBAC - International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craftworkers
LEV - local exhaust ventilation
PACT - Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies
NIOSH - National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health
OEL - occupational exposure limit
OSHA - Occupational Safety and Health Administration
PAPR - powered air-purifying respirator
PEL - Permissible Exposure Limit
PVC - polyvinyl chloride
REL - Recommended Exposure Limit
RPM - revolutions per minute
TWA - time-weighted average
SP - static pressure
I. Introduction and Background
In 2010 CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training began a four-year project which seeks to identify and evaluate tuckpointing local exhaust ventilation (LEV) systems and disseminate information on their availability and effectiveness. A Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies (PACT) comprised of masonry contractors, representatives from unions, government, equipment manufacturers, and health and safety researcher was formed as part of this project. PACT members participated in identifying important characteristics for control technologies and this information was used to identify LEV systems for tuckpointing using that criteria. Contractor and labor members of the PACT selected specific tuckpointing LEV systems to be considered for evaluation. Each system consisted of a tuckpointing grinder, shroud, and vacuum. This report describes the second of four systems to be evaluated between 2012 the end of 2014, with and without LEV, in a controlled setting to determine effectiveness in silica exposure reduction. This report describes the methods and results of our evaluation of a system consisting of the DustControl 2900c vacuum with the ICS Dust Director shroud and a Bosch Model 1775E grinder.
Excessive exposure to respirable silica can result in silicosis or other silica-related diseases including pulmonary tuberculosis, lung cancer, silicoproteinosis (Lyons et al, 2007) and autoimmune disorders such as rheumatoid arthritis, sarcoidosis and scleroderma (Miller et al, 2012). Respirable silica is generally defined as particles less than 10 micrometers (μm) in aerodynamic diameter (ACGIH, 2013). Silicosis can lead to symptoms including shortness of breath, fatigue, chest pains, susceptibility to infection and possibly death. There is no cure for silicosis, however it is totally preventable. Construction workers exposed to dust, including silica, are also known to have higher rates of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD).
There are many sources of silica in construction that result in exposures of varying intensity among workers. Masonry restoration workers are among the most highly silica-exposed trades in construction. The process of grinding out deteriorated mortar joints between masonry units and replacing or repointing with fresh mortar (often referred to as tuckpointing) is a fundamental part of masonry restoration work. The removal of mortar with powered angle grinders generates enormous levels of dust. Between 2004 and 2006, NIOSH and CPWR evaluated silica exposures while grinding mortar in a controlled setting, at a local training center, where tasks, sample times and task variables were defined by the study design. These studies demonstrated that grinding mortar without controls can result in elevated respirable silica exposures. Meeker et al., (2009) reported exposures between 5 and 25.8 milligrams per cubic meter (mg/m3) in a controlled setting. This study also showed that LEV systems for tuckpointing grinders can reduce exposures to respirable silica by greater than 90 percent.II. Objectives
The objective of this evaluation was to assess the effectiveness of an LEV system for controlling exposure to silica during the grinding of mortar. The control technology was tested under controlled conditions, similar to those experienced by tuckpointers on actual job sites, using journeymen bricklayers experienced in tuckpointing and repeat, randomized trials with and without LEV. All other variables were held constant throughout so that the only variable was whether or not the tested control was used.
III. Description of Equipment Tested
A Bosch model 1775E grinder (Robert Bosch Tool Corporation, Prospect, IL) (Figures 1, 2 and 3) was fitted with a new 1/4-inch wide, 4½-inch diameter segmented diamond abrasive blade made by DeWalt (model #DW4740). The grinder weighs six and a half pounds, draws 8.5 amps and has a variable speed up to 11,000 revolutions per minute (RPMs). The DustControl 2900c vacuum (DustControl, Inc., Wilmington, NC) (Figure 3) was tested in combination with the Dust Director shroud (Industrial Contractors’ Supplies, Inc., Huntingdon, PA) (Figures 1 and 3) attached to the Bosch grinder.
Figure 1. Bosch grinder with Dust Director shroud
Figure 2. Bosch grinder without tuckpointing LEV system.
Figure 3: Bosch Grinder with LEV System
The vacuum is specified to weigh 31 pounds when empty and to provide a flow rate of 114 cubic feet of air per minute and a “static lift” or “vacuum suction pressure” of 84 inches of water. The vacuum is sold with a cyclonic pre-separator, to remove larger particles, a fine filter (rated 99.9 percent efficient) and a HEPA (high-efficiency particulate air) filter (rated to capture 99.97 percent of the particles with an aerodynamic diameter of 0.3 micrometers). The HEPA filter was removed based on the manufacturer’s recommendation due to the heavy dust loading associated with tuckpointing. CPWR sponsored research and contractor experience indicate that HEPA filters likely have an adverse effect on dust capture during tuckpointing because of extreme dust loading on filters. While the cyclone and the fine filter remove most of the dust, especially the large particles, before they reach the HEPA filter, the HEPA filter would still be subject to heavy loading, causing a substantial pressure drop and subsequent decrease in air flow rate. The relatively small increase in the efficiency of the filtration system while using the HEPA filter is expected to be quickly offset by a more significant decrease in capture efficiency as the air flow rate and ability to capture particles decreases.
Dust collects in relatively inexpensive, heavy-gauge plastic bags below and outside of the cyclone. The bags can be removed and replaced without opening the vacuum. Some vacuums are equipped with a light to indicate that the filters need to be cleaned or changed. The DC2900c features a “reverse air pulse cleaning system,” which removes accumulated dust from the filters without having to remove them from the vacuum. The system, as illustrated in Figure 4, requires the operator to disconnect the hose from the shroud, place it over an air stop so that air through the hose is cut off and pressure in the vacuum is maximized.
Figure 4. Procedure for "cleaning" of or dust removal from filters (source: http://dustcontrolusa.com/manuals/2800c.pdf)
The flap covering the port on the side of the vacuum is repeatedly flipped open to release built up pressure in strong pulses that dislodge dust from the filter.
The manufacturer indicates “the filter is generally cleaned once or twice daily during normal continuous operation.” The Dust Director shroud has a 2-inch diameter take-off that was connected to the antistatic, corrugated 1.5-inch diameter, 15-foot long vacuum hose supplied with the DustControl vacuum.
IV. Study Methods
This evaluation was conducted at the International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craft workers (IUBAC) Local 1 Philadelphia/Delaware Training Center in Philadelphia, PA on November 14 and 15, 2012. A single journeyman bricklayer, experienced in tuckpointing, used the grinder and LEV system being tested to remove mortar from joints wide enough to require two passes. The type S mortar had been allowed to cure for at least four weeks. The bricklayer either possessed or was provided with personal protective equipment including sturdy work boots, gloves, hearing protection and a powered air-purifying respirator (PAPR). The PAPR was a 3M GVP system with a bump cap, loose fitting face piece and a HEPA filter (3M, St Paul, MN).
The study was designed to include at least five rounds of sampling during mortar removal. Each round included a trial using the Bosch grinder with a Dust Director shroud and Dust Collector 2900c vacuum and a trial using the Bosch grinder with the factory-supplied guard and without a vacuum. The order of the two trials within each round was randomly selected to minimize bias that might be introduced due to variation associated with environmental factors, equipment operator, blade wear, vacuum performance over time and any other factors unrelated to LEV use. Tools were operated for approximately 16 minutes per trial with controls and for approximately 8 minutes when controls were not used. These times were selected based on the results of previous sampling efforts and estimates of the minimum sample time needed to achieve a limit of quantification low enough to accurately measure exposures down to or less than 0.05 mg/m3 – the NIOSH Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) for respirable silica. The bricklayer was required to take a 5 to 10 minute break in the middle of the 16-minute trials to reduce differences in fatigue, compared to the 8-minute trials. Personal air samples were collected in the breathing zone of the operator during each trial to measure respirable silica concentrations during grinding with and without LEV. The samples were collected using a GilAir-5 pump (Sensidyne, Inc., Clearwater, FL) to draw 4.2 liters of air per minute through a GK2.69 Respirable Cyclone (BGI Inc., Waltham, MA) with a pre-weighed, 37 mm diameter, 5-micron pore size polyvinyl chloride (PVC) filter positioned on the operator’s lapel.
The flow rates of the sampling pumps were calibrated at the beginning of each day using a DryCal DC-Lite Primary Flow Meter (Bios International Corporation, Butler, NJ). Flow rates were measured again near the middle and at the end of each day to ensure that sampling flow rates were maintained within 5% of pre-sampling flow rates throughout the day. Average flow rates were used to calculate sample air volumes. Samples were analyzed by R.J. Lee Group, Inc., (Monroeville, PA) using NIOSH Method 0600, to determine exposure to total mass of respirable dust. The same samples were also analyzed using X-Ray diffraction following NIOSH method 7500 to determine quartz, cristobalite and tridymite concentration in the respirable mass. Reported masses for these analytes were used with the sample air volumes to calculate airborne concentrations of total respirable dust, quartz, cristobalite and tridymite.
We used a reduction of greater than 50 percent in respirable silica exposure concentrations or a reduction to less than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 as our criteria for determining whether or not a control was considered efficacious. This is consistent with criteria used by NIOSH in conducting a similar study in 2004 described by Echt et al. (2007) and by CPWR in 2006 and described by Meeker et al. (2009). The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) and the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) publish additional occupational exposure limits (OELs) for silica which are listed in Table 1 with NIOSH RELs. OELs for silica are based on the respirable fraction of the aerosol, which consists of particles less than 10 micrometers in aerodynamic diameter.
| Organization or Agency | Form of Crystalline Silica | Occupational Exposure Limits (mg/m3) |
|---|---|---|
| NIOSHA | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 |
| OSHA - ConstructionB | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
PEL = 250 / (5 + % quartz) PEL = 250 / (5 + % cristobalite) PEL = 250 / (5 + % tridymite) |
| ACGIH | Crystalline Silica | TLV = 0.025 mg/m3 |
A NIOSH Publication No. 2005-151 indicates 10-hour time-weighted average during a 40-hr workweek B The PEL for silica in OSHA’s Safety and Health Regulations for Construction, 29 C.F.R. 1926.55(a), is an 8-hour time-weighted average (TWA) expressed in millions of particles per cubic foot (mppcf). However, the units mppcf can be converted to milligrams per cubic meter can by dividing mppcf by 10 (OSHA, 2009). The formula used by OSHA to determine the PEL for silica is dependent on the percentage of silica in each collected sample. The concentration of respirable dust measured is compared to the sample specific PEL to determine if the PEL has been exceeded. OSHA has proposed lowering the PEL to 0.05 mg/m3 of respirable silica as an 8 hour TWA. |
||
The flow of air in ventilation systems is governed by fundamental principles that describe the behavior of gases (in this case air). Pressure measurements taken within a ventilation system along with knowledge of hood (or shroud) entry losses can be used to calculate flow rates. Hood entry losses are dependent on the shape and configuration of a particular hood or shroud and described by the term “coefficient of entry (Ce)” which is the ratio of actual air flow through a hood and what the air flow would theoretically be if there were no hood entry losses. Given the coefficient of entry, static pressure measurements can be used to calculate air flow through a given hood. The coefficient of entry for the Dust Director shroud was previously determined by CPWR and used for calculating air flow based on static pressure measurements (Meeker et al., 2009). Static pressure, with the vacuum operating, was measured periodically throughout the evaluation to monitor the changes in air-flow rate following use and again after filter cleaning. The static pressure was measured at a port positioned more than 3 duct diameters downstream from the tool’s air intake using a UEi EM200 Electronic Manometer (Universal Enterprises, Inc., Beaverton, OR).
The dust in the vacuum bag was monitored and, per the manufacturer’s instructions, the bag was changed before the dust level was within 5 centimeters of the valve at the bottom of the vacuum. Each time a vacuum bag was removed, it was weighed to the nearest pound. The bag weights and corresponding grinding durations were used to calculate the average weight of dust collected per unit time. After each trial, cut lengths were measured on the wall to determine total linear feet of vertical (head) and horizontal (bed) joints per unit time.
A Haz-Dust III, Model HD-1003, Real-Time Aerosol Monitor (Environmental Devices Corporation, Plaistow, NH) was used to confirm clearance of dust between trials. The Haz-Dust monitor was positioned on the test wall near the operator at approximately breathing zone level and configured to measure respirable particulate concentration.
V. Results
Personal air monitoring
Five pairs of respirable dust samples were collected while grinding with and without the vacuum system. In addition, three respirable dust samples were collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place. One measurement collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard was shown to be a statistical outlier and was omitted from analysis. Personal air monitoring results for respirable silica and a comparison of average exposures relative to the NIOSH REL for silica (0.05 mg/m3) appears in Table 2. The mean respirable dust levels measured without LEV was 31.4 mg/m3. However, samples collected with LEV were below the limit of quantification (LOQ) which ranged from <1.29 to <1.46 mg/m3. Use of LEV resulted in a greater than 95% reduction in mean respirable dust levels using a mean value with use of LEV of <1.41 (n=5 samples with use of LEV and n=7 without use of LEV). The respirable dust samples collected during grinding without the LEV system contained an average of 24 percent silica. The mass of respirable dust in the samples collected with use of the LEV system was too low to determine the silica content.| Mean, mg/m3 (range) | Std. Dev. | Percent Reduction | Hazard RatioB | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bosch with Dust Director Shroud and DustControl 2900c Vacuum |
0.091 (<0.069 – 0.137) |
0.027 | 98.7 | 1.81 |
| Bosch with no Control | 7.23 (4.57 – 9.90) |
1.94 | NA | 145 |
A n = 5 samples for each tool/control combination and n = 7 samples without the use of the LEV system B Hazard Ratio = measured exposure / NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 |
||||
Average respirable silica and dust exposures, with and without the dust control system, appear as Figures 5 and 6, respectively.
Figure 5. Average respirable silica exposures with and without the Dustcontrol 2900c vacuum and Dust Director shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air - mg/m3)
Figure 6. Average respirable dust exposures with and without Dustcontrol 2900c Vacuum and Dust Director Shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air – mg/m3)
The mean respirable silica concentration measured during use of the control was significantly less than the concentration measured while using the same tool without controls (p<0.01). Grinding mortar with the Bosch angle grinder without dust controls resulted in an average exposure to respirable silica that was 145 times the NIOSH REL. Grinding with the Bosch angle grinder in combination with the Dust Director shroud and the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced the average concentration of respirable silica by 98.7 percent. With use of these controls, the concentration of respirable silica was 1.8 times greater than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3. However the NIOSH REL is based on a time-weighted average (TWA) over a 10-hour workday. Given these were task TWAs and samples were collected over continuous periods of grinding, they may overestimate exposures over an actual work day since some time would be spent performing tasks that would likely have lower, or no, silica exposures (setup, breaks, cleanup, etc.).
Static pressure, dust mass collection and grinding rates.
Static pressure was used as a surrogate for air flow as described earlier. Hood static pressure was measured periodically at a tap near the grinder more than 3 duct diameters from the air intake in the shroud. The static pressure, and thus air flow, was generally higher when the vacuum’s filter had recently been cleaned. The mean, median, and range of calculated flow rates are presented in Table A1 of the Appendix.
Based on the data we collected, the air-flow rate upstream from the Bosch grinder and Dust Director shroud ranged from 78 to 93 cubic feet per minute (cfm) with the DustControl vacuum. When the manufacturer’s filter cleaning procedure was followed the vacuum performed relatively well and flow could be maintained at slightly less than 90 cfm with cleaning. However, mean flow rates dropped substantially to 80 cfm after as little as 8 minutes of grinding without any filter cleaning. The flow rate returned to an average of 89 cfm when filters were cleaned correctly (without stopping air flow to the vacuum). Collingwood and Heitbrink (2007) found that the minimum exhaust flow rate for capture of silica and other particulate under ideal conditions is 21.25 cfm per inch of grinder blade diameter. This is equal to about 96 cfm when using a 4.5 inch diameter grinding blade. We set 106 cfm as the minimum desired flow rate for this study to allow a safety margin for potential decline in equipment performance and the possibility of inadequate maintenance, both of which may be likely after repeated use under actual work conditions. The DustControl vacuum provided slightly less than the minimum flow rate described by Collingwood and Heitbrink for a 4.5-inch blade and the peak flow rate fell with use.
The duration of vacuum bag use and mass of dust collected were recorded and are presented in Table A2 of the Appendix. The vacuum bags were changed and weighed after each trial utilizing the LEV system. A total of five bags were used to complete the five rounds of grinding. The DustControl vacuum captured 45 pounds of dust over 83 minutes of grinding for an average rate of dust collection of 0.54 pounds per minute. The rate of dust collection ranged from 0.47 to 0.63 pounds per minute. Based on these measurements, approximately 130 pounds of dust would likely be captured after just 4 hours of continuous grinding.
The rate of grinding a combination of vertical and horizontal joints while using the LEV system ranged from 2.3 to 3.3 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the use of the LEV system ranged from 2.6 to 3.4 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place ranged from 4.7 to 5.1 feet per minute. It’s important to note that: 1) the operator had limited experience using dust control systems and cut rates appeared to improve slightly over the 2-day period he used the tested equipment; and 2) the upper range of cut rates with the dust control system overlapped with the lowest cut rate with the original guard and without the LEV system in place indicating no statistical difference between cut rates. Given that grinding rates with and without use of this LEV system are only available for one operator and he had limited experience with the LEV system, these reported cut rates are in no way intended to represent the impact use of this LEV system is likely to have on productivity rates overall.
VI. Discussion
The objective of these trials was to evaluate the effectiveness of a tuckpointing LEV system for controlling respirable silica while grinding out mortar joints. The Dust Director shroud with the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced respirable silica concentrations when grinding with the Bosch grinder by approximately 99 percent. Despite being considered effective by our test criteria (greater than 50% reduction), it still resulted in task TWA exposures that exceeded the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 by 1.8 times. Depending on how much time is spent grinding over the course of a work day and on exposures while performing other tasks, the 8-hour TWA exposures may or may not exceed the REL with this system. Use of this system by workers with experience and training in proficient use will likely improve dust capture performance. Exposure reduction is greatly influenced by correct use of this system which includes grinding from right to left, making sure the shroud is held flush against the wall and that the tool travels at a pace that doesn’t exceed the ability of the system to capture dust as it’s generated. Deviation from any of these measures produces visible dust clouds which were observed during trials.
VII. Conclusions
With a 99 percent reduction in respirable silica exposure, the Dust Director shroud and DustControl 2900c vacuum with a Bosch Model 1775E grinder was effective in reducing silica exposures based on our criteria. Use of the tested dust control system may be effective in reducing silica exposure on the job to less than the NIOSH REL if used in combination with administrative controls such as work scheduling to reduce cutting times as needed. Training on correct use of the tested system is also essential. Personal air monitoring is necessary to verify control effectiveness on actual job sites and under “real-world” conditions. However, these results clearly demonstrate the availability of viable and effective engineering controls for tuckpointing operations associated with elevated silica exposure.
VIII. References
American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists. Threshold limit values for chemical substances (TLV®-CS). [2013]. ACGIH, Cincinnati, Ohio.
Bergdahl I.A,. Toren K., Eriksson K., et al. [2004]. Increased mortality in COPD among construction workers exposed to inorganic dust. European Respiratory Journal, 23: 402–06.
Blanc P.D. & Torén K. [2007]. Occupation in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and chronic bronchitis: an update [State of the Art Series. Occupational lung disease in high-and low-income countries, Edited by M. Chan-Yeung. Number 2 in the series]. The International Journal of Tuberculosis and Lung Disease, 11(3), 251-257.
Collingwood S. & Heitbrink W.A. [2007] 'Field Evaluation of an Engineering Control for Respirable Crystalline Silica Exposures During Mortar Removal'. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, 4:11, 875 – 887.
DHHS (NIOSH) Publication No. 2002-129 April 2002 http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/2002-129/
Echt A., Sieber W.K., Lefkowitz D., Meeker J., Susi P., Cardwell B., Heitbrink, W.A. In-depth survey of dust control technology for cutting concrete block and tuckpointing brick at The International Masonry Institute Bordentown Training Center, Bordentown, NJ. Cincinnati, OH: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Report. No. EPHB 282-13; 2007. http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ECTB-282-13.pdf
Heitbrink W., Bennett J. [2006]. A numerical and experimental investigation of crystalline silica exposure control during tuck pointing. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, Vol. 3, pp 366-378.
Lyons et al, [2007]. A breathless builder. Breathe, Vol. 3, no. 4, pp 386-390.
Mastrangelo G., Tartari M., Fedeli U., Fadda E., Saia B. [2003]. Ascertaining the risk of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease in relation to occupation using a case-control design. Occupational Medicine, 53: 165–172.
Meeker J., Cooper M., Lefrowitz D., Susi P. [2009]. Engineering control technologies to reduce occupational silica exposures in masonry cutting and tuckpointing. Public Health Reports, Supplement 1, Vol. 124, June.
Meeker J, Flynn M, Susi P, Cardwell, B [2004]. Performance evaluation of a masonry concrete vacuum. Unpublished Report.
Miller F. W., Alfredsson L., Costenbader K. H., Kamen D. L., Nelson L. M., Norris J. M., & De Roos A. J. [2012]. Epidemiology of environmental exposures and human autoimmune diseases: findings from a National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences Expert Panel workshop. Journal of autoimmunity. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3496812/
Occupational Safety and Health Administration U.S Department of Labor. Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction. [2009]. OSHA 3362-05.
Rappaport SM, Goldberg M, Susi P, Herrick RF [2003]. Excessive exposure to silica in the U.S. construction industry. Annals of Occupational Hygiene, Vol. 47, pp. 111-122.
IX. Appendices
| Measurement Conditions |
n | Mean Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Median
Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before filter cleaning | 5 | 80 | 81 | 78-81 |
| After filter cleaning following manufacturer directions | 9 | 89 | 90 | 84-93 |
| * Static pressure was measured in millibars and converted to inches of water gauge. Flow rates were calculated using the formula Q = Ce (A) 4005 (SP)1/2 where: Q = flow in cubic feet per minute (cfm), Ce = coefficient of entry, A = area of the duct where static pressure measurements were taken in square feet, and SP = static pressure in inches of water gauge. | ||||
| Tool/Control | Collection Period (min.) |
Dust Collection Rate (lb/min.) |
|---|---|---|
| Bosch grinder/Dust Director shroud & DustControl 2900c vacuum |
8 11 8 8 10 |
0.50 0.61 0.50 0.47 0.63 |
| Average | 0.54 |
[content_transformed:protected] =>
Executive Summary
This report describes the results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. It should also be noted that the NIOSH REL is based on exposures averaged over a ten hour work day and our results represent time weighted averages of the sample task duration periods.
Acronyms
ACGIH - American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists
CPWR - CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training
Ce - coefficient of entry
HEPA - high-efficiency particulate air
IUBAC - International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craftworkers
LEV - local exhaust ventilation
PACT - Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies
NIOSH - National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health
OEL - occupational exposure limit
OSHA - Occupational Safety and Health Administration
PAPR - powered air-purifying respirator
PEL - Permissible Exposure Limit
PVC - polyvinyl chloride
REL - Recommended Exposure Limit
RPM - revolutions per minute
TWA - time-weighted average
SP - static pressure
I. Introduction and Background
In 2010 CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training began a four-year project which seeks to identify and evaluate tuckpointing local exhaust ventilation (LEV) systems and disseminate information on their availability and effectiveness. A Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies (PACT) comprised of masonry contractors, representatives from unions, government, equipment manufacturers, and health and safety researcher was formed as part of this project. PACT members participated in identifying important characteristics for control technologies and this information was used to identify LEV systems for tuckpointing using that criteria. Contractor and labor members of the PACT selected specific tuckpointing LEV systems to be considered for evaluation. Each system consisted of a tuckpointing grinder, shroud, and vacuum. This report describes the second of four systems to be evaluated between 2012 the end of 2014, with and without LEV, in a controlled setting to determine effectiveness in silica exposure reduction. This report describes the methods and results of our evaluation of a system consisting of the DustControl 2900c vacuum with the ICS Dust Director shroud and a Bosch Model 1775E grinder.
Excessive exposure to respirable silica can result in silicosis or other silica-related diseases including pulmonary tuberculosis, lung cancer, silicoproteinosis (Lyons et al, 2007) and autoimmune disorders such as rheumatoid arthritis, sarcoidosis and scleroderma (Miller et al, 2012). Respirable silica is generally defined as particles less than 10 micrometers (μm) in aerodynamic diameter (ACGIH, 2013). Silicosis can lead to symptoms including shortness of breath, fatigue, chest pains, susceptibility to infection and possibly death. There is no cure for silicosis, however it is totally preventable. Construction workers exposed to dust, including silica, are also known to have higher rates of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD).
There are many sources of silica in construction that result in exposures of varying intensity among workers. Masonry restoration workers are among the most highly silica-exposed trades in construction. The process of grinding out deteriorated mortar joints between masonry units and replacing or repointing with fresh mortar (often referred to as tuckpointing) is a fundamental part of masonry restoration work. The removal of mortar with powered angle grinders generates enormous levels of dust. Between 2004 and 2006, NIOSH and CPWR evaluated silica exposures while grinding mortar in a controlled setting, at a local training center, where tasks, sample times and task variables were defined by the study design. These studies demonstrated that grinding mortar without controls can result in elevated respirable silica exposures. Meeker et al., (2009) reported exposures between 5 and 25.8 milligrams per cubic meter (mg/m3) in a controlled setting. This study also showed that LEV systems for tuckpointing grinders can reduce exposures to respirable silica by greater than 90 percent.II. Objectives
The objective of this evaluation was to assess the effectiveness of an LEV system for controlling exposure to silica during the grinding of mortar. The control technology was tested under controlled conditions, similar to those experienced by tuckpointers on actual job sites, using journeymen bricklayers experienced in tuckpointing and repeat, randomized trials with and without LEV. All other variables were held constant throughout so that the only variable was whether or not the tested control was used.
III. Description of Equipment Tested
A Bosch model 1775E grinder (Robert Bosch Tool Corporation, Prospect, IL) (Figures 1, 2 and 3) was fitted with a new 1/4-inch wide, 4½-inch diameter segmented diamond abrasive blade made by DeWalt (model #DW4740). The grinder weighs six and a half pounds, draws 8.5 amps and has a variable speed up to 11,000 revolutions per minute (RPMs). The DustControl 2900c vacuum (DustControl, Inc., Wilmington, NC) (Figure 3) was tested in combination with the Dust Director shroud (Industrial Contractors’ Supplies, Inc., Huntingdon, PA) (Figures 1 and 3) attached to the Bosch grinder.
Figure 1. Bosch grinder with Dust Director shroud
Figure 2. Bosch grinder without tuckpointing LEV system.
Figure 3: Bosch Grinder with LEV System
The vacuum is specified to weigh 31 pounds when empty and to provide a flow rate of 114 cubic feet of air per minute and a “static lift” or “vacuum suction pressure” of 84 inches of water. The vacuum is sold with a cyclonic pre-separator, to remove larger particles, a fine filter (rated 99.9 percent efficient) and a HEPA (high-efficiency particulate air) filter (rated to capture 99.97 percent of the particles with an aerodynamic diameter of 0.3 micrometers). The HEPA filter was removed based on the manufacturer’s recommendation due to the heavy dust loading associated with tuckpointing. CPWR sponsored research and contractor experience indicate that HEPA filters likely have an adverse effect on dust capture during tuckpointing because of extreme dust loading on filters. While the cyclone and the fine filter remove most of the dust, especially the large particles, before they reach the HEPA filter, the HEPA filter would still be subject to heavy loading, causing a substantial pressure drop and subsequent decrease in air flow rate. The relatively small increase in the efficiency of the filtration system while using the HEPA filter is expected to be quickly offset by a more significant decrease in capture efficiency as the air flow rate and ability to capture particles decreases.
Dust collects in relatively inexpensive, heavy-gauge plastic bags below and outside of the cyclone. The bags can be removed and replaced without opening the vacuum. Some vacuums are equipped with a light to indicate that the filters need to be cleaned or changed. The DC2900c features a “reverse air pulse cleaning system,” which removes accumulated dust from the filters without having to remove them from the vacuum. The system, as illustrated in Figure 4, requires the operator to disconnect the hose from the shroud, place it over an air stop so that air through the hose is cut off and pressure in the vacuum is maximized.
Figure 4. Procedure for "cleaning" of or dust removal from filters (source: http://dustcontrolusa.com/manuals/2800c.pdf)
The flap covering the port on the side of the vacuum is repeatedly flipped open to release built up pressure in strong pulses that dislodge dust from the filter.
The manufacturer indicates “the filter is generally cleaned once or twice daily during normal continuous operation.” The Dust Director shroud has a 2-inch diameter take-off that was connected to the antistatic, corrugated 1.5-inch diameter, 15-foot long vacuum hose supplied with the DustControl vacuum.
IV. Study Methods
This evaluation was conducted at the International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craft workers (IUBAC) Local 1 Philadelphia/Delaware Training Center in Philadelphia, PA on November 14 and 15, 2012. A single journeyman bricklayer, experienced in tuckpointing, used the grinder and LEV system being tested to remove mortar from joints wide enough to require two passes. The type S mortar had been allowed to cure for at least four weeks. The bricklayer either possessed or was provided with personal protective equipment including sturdy work boots, gloves, hearing protection and a powered air-purifying respirator (PAPR). The PAPR was a 3M GVP system with a bump cap, loose fitting face piece and a HEPA filter (3M, St Paul, MN).
The study was designed to include at least five rounds of sampling during mortar removal. Each round included a trial using the Bosch grinder with a Dust Director shroud and Dust Collector 2900c vacuum and a trial using the Bosch grinder with the factory-supplied guard and without a vacuum. The order of the two trials within each round was randomly selected to minimize bias that might be introduced due to variation associated with environmental factors, equipment operator, blade wear, vacuum performance over time and any other factors unrelated to LEV use. Tools were operated for approximately 16 minutes per trial with controls and for approximately 8 minutes when controls were not used. These times were selected based on the results of previous sampling efforts and estimates of the minimum sample time needed to achieve a limit of quantification low enough to accurately measure exposures down to or less than 0.05 mg/m3 – the NIOSH Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) for respirable silica. The bricklayer was required to take a 5 to 10 minute break in the middle of the 16-minute trials to reduce differences in fatigue, compared to the 8-minute trials. Personal air samples were collected in the breathing zone of the operator during each trial to measure respirable silica concentrations during grinding with and without LEV. The samples were collected using a GilAir-5 pump (Sensidyne, Inc., Clearwater, FL) to draw 4.2 liters of air per minute through a GK2.69 Respirable Cyclone (BGI Inc., Waltham, MA) with a pre-weighed, 37 mm diameter, 5-micron pore size polyvinyl chloride (PVC) filter positioned on the operator’s lapel.
The flow rates of the sampling pumps were calibrated at the beginning of each day using a DryCal DC-Lite Primary Flow Meter (Bios International Corporation, Butler, NJ). Flow rates were measured again near the middle and at the end of each day to ensure that sampling flow rates were maintained within 5% of pre-sampling flow rates throughout the day. Average flow rates were used to calculate sample air volumes. Samples were analyzed by R.J. Lee Group, Inc., (Monroeville, PA) using NIOSH Method 0600, to determine exposure to total mass of respirable dust. The same samples were also analyzed using X-Ray diffraction following NIOSH method 7500 to determine quartz, cristobalite and tridymite concentration in the respirable mass. Reported masses for these analytes were used with the sample air volumes to calculate airborne concentrations of total respirable dust, quartz, cristobalite and tridymite.
We used a reduction of greater than 50 percent in respirable silica exposure concentrations or a reduction to less than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 as our criteria for determining whether or not a control was considered efficacious. This is consistent with criteria used by NIOSH in conducting a similar study in 2004 described by Echt et al. (2007) and by CPWR in 2006 and described by Meeker et al. (2009). The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) and the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) publish additional occupational exposure limits (OELs) for silica which are listed in Table 1 with NIOSH RELs. OELs for silica are based on the respirable fraction of the aerosol, which consists of particles less than 10 micrometers in aerodynamic diameter.
| Organization or Agency | Form of Crystalline Silica | Occupational Exposure Limits (mg/m3) |
|---|---|---|
| NIOSHA | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 |
| OSHA - ConstructionB | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
PEL = 250 / (5 + % quartz) PEL = 250 / (5 + % cristobalite) PEL = 250 / (5 + % tridymite) |
| ACGIH | Crystalline Silica | TLV = 0.025 mg/m3 |
A NIOSH Publication No. 2005-151 indicates 10-hour time-weighted average during a 40-hr workweek B The PEL for silica in OSHA’s Safety and Health Regulations for Construction, 29 C.F.R. 1926.55(a), is an 8-hour time-weighted average (TWA) expressed in millions of particles per cubic foot (mppcf). However, the units mppcf can be converted to milligrams per cubic meter can by dividing mppcf by 10 (OSHA, 2009). The formula used by OSHA to determine the PEL for silica is dependent on the percentage of silica in each collected sample. The concentration of respirable dust measured is compared to the sample specific PEL to determine if the PEL has been exceeded. OSHA has proposed lowering the PEL to 0.05 mg/m3 of respirable silica as an 8 hour TWA. |
||
The flow of air in ventilation systems is governed by fundamental principles that describe the behavior of gases (in this case air). Pressure measurements taken within a ventilation system along with knowledge of hood (or shroud) entry losses can be used to calculate flow rates. Hood entry losses are dependent on the shape and configuration of a particular hood or shroud and described by the term “coefficient of entry (Ce)” which is the ratio of actual air flow through a hood and what the air flow would theoretically be if there were no hood entry losses. Given the coefficient of entry, static pressure measurements can be used to calculate air flow through a given hood. The coefficient of entry for the Dust Director shroud was previously determined by CPWR and used for calculating air flow based on static pressure measurements (Meeker et al., 2009). Static pressure, with the vacuum operating, was measured periodically throughout the evaluation to monitor the changes in air-flow rate following use and again after filter cleaning. The static pressure was measured at a port positioned more than 3 duct diameters downstream from the tool’s air intake using a UEi EM200 Electronic Manometer (Universal Enterprises, Inc., Beaverton, OR).
The dust in the vacuum bag was monitored and, per the manufacturer’s instructions, the bag was changed before the dust level was within 5 centimeters of the valve at the bottom of the vacuum. Each time a vacuum bag was removed, it was weighed to the nearest pound. The bag weights and corresponding grinding durations were used to calculate the average weight of dust collected per unit time. After each trial, cut lengths were measured on the wall to determine total linear feet of vertical (head) and horizontal (bed) joints per unit time.
A Haz-Dust III, Model HD-1003, Real-Time Aerosol Monitor (Environmental Devices Corporation, Plaistow, NH) was used to confirm clearance of dust between trials. The Haz-Dust monitor was positioned on the test wall near the operator at approximately breathing zone level and configured to measure respirable particulate concentration.
V. Results
Personal air monitoring
Five pairs of respirable dust samples were collected while grinding with and without the vacuum system. In addition, three respirable dust samples were collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place. One measurement collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard was shown to be a statistical outlier and was omitted from analysis. Personal air monitoring results for respirable silica and a comparison of average exposures relative to the NIOSH REL for silica (0.05 mg/m3) appears in Table 2. The mean respirable dust levels measured without LEV was 31.4 mg/m3. However, samples collected with LEV were below the limit of quantification (LOQ) which ranged from <1.29 to <1.46 mg/m3. Use of LEV resulted in a greater than 95% reduction in mean respirable dust levels using a mean value with use of LEV of <1.41 (n=5 samples with use of LEV and n=7 without use of LEV). The respirable dust samples collected during grinding without the LEV system contained an average of 24 percent silica. The mass of respirable dust in the samples collected with use of the LEV system was too low to determine the silica content.| Mean, mg/m3 (range) | Std. Dev. | Percent Reduction | Hazard RatioB | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bosch with Dust Director Shroud and DustControl 2900c Vacuum |
0.091 (<0.069 – 0.137) |
0.027 | 98.7 | 1.81 |
| Bosch with no Control | 7.23 (4.57 – 9.90) |
1.94 | NA | 145 |
A n = 5 samples for each tool/control combination and n = 7 samples without the use of the LEV system B Hazard Ratio = measured exposure / NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 |
||||
Average respirable silica and dust exposures, with and without the dust control system, appear as Figures 5 and 6, respectively.
Figure 5. Average respirable silica exposures with and without the Dustcontrol 2900c vacuum and Dust Director shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air - mg/m3)
Figure 6. Average respirable dust exposures with and without Dustcontrol 2900c Vacuum and Dust Director Shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air – mg/m3)
The mean respirable silica concentration measured during use of the control was significantly less than the concentration measured while using the same tool without controls (p<0.01). Grinding mortar with the Bosch angle grinder without dust controls resulted in an average exposure to respirable silica that was 145 times the NIOSH REL. Grinding with the Bosch angle grinder in combination with the Dust Director shroud and the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced the average concentration of respirable silica by 98.7 percent. With use of these controls, the concentration of respirable silica was 1.8 times greater than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3. However the NIOSH REL is based on a time-weighted average (TWA) over a 10-hour workday. Given these were task TWAs and samples were collected over continuous periods of grinding, they may overestimate exposures over an actual work day since some time would be spent performing tasks that would likely have lower, or no, silica exposures (setup, breaks, cleanup, etc.).
Static pressure, dust mass collection and grinding rates.
Static pressure was used as a surrogate for air flow as described earlier. Hood static pressure was measured periodically at a tap near the grinder more than 3 duct diameters from the air intake in the shroud. The static pressure, and thus air flow, was generally higher when the vacuum’s filter had recently been cleaned. The mean, median, and range of calculated flow rates are presented in Table A1 of the Appendix.
Based on the data we collected, the air-flow rate upstream from the Bosch grinder and Dust Director shroud ranged from 78 to 93 cubic feet per minute (cfm) with the DustControl vacuum. When the manufacturer’s filter cleaning procedure was followed the vacuum performed relatively well and flow could be maintained at slightly less than 90 cfm with cleaning. However, mean flow rates dropped substantially to 80 cfm after as little as 8 minutes of grinding without any filter cleaning. The flow rate returned to an average of 89 cfm when filters were cleaned correctly (without stopping air flow to the vacuum). Collingwood and Heitbrink (2007) found that the minimum exhaust flow rate for capture of silica and other particulate under ideal conditions is 21.25 cfm per inch of grinder blade diameter. This is equal to about 96 cfm when using a 4.5 inch diameter grinding blade. We set 106 cfm as the minimum desired flow rate for this study to allow a safety margin for potential decline in equipment performance and the possibility of inadequate maintenance, both of which may be likely after repeated use under actual work conditions. The DustControl vacuum provided slightly less than the minimum flow rate described by Collingwood and Heitbrink for a 4.5-inch blade and the peak flow rate fell with use.
The duration of vacuum bag use and mass of dust collected were recorded and are presented in Table A2 of the Appendix. The vacuum bags were changed and weighed after each trial utilizing the LEV system. A total of five bags were used to complete the five rounds of grinding. The DustControl vacuum captured 45 pounds of dust over 83 minutes of grinding for an average rate of dust collection of 0.54 pounds per minute. The rate of dust collection ranged from 0.47 to 0.63 pounds per minute. Based on these measurements, approximately 130 pounds of dust would likely be captured after just 4 hours of continuous grinding.
The rate of grinding a combination of vertical and horizontal joints while using the LEV system ranged from 2.3 to 3.3 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the use of the LEV system ranged from 2.6 to 3.4 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place ranged from 4.7 to 5.1 feet per minute. It’s important to note that: 1) the operator had limited experience using dust control systems and cut rates appeared to improve slightly over the 2-day period he used the tested equipment; and 2) the upper range of cut rates with the dust control system overlapped with the lowest cut rate with the original guard and without the LEV system in place indicating no statistical difference between cut rates. Given that grinding rates with and without use of this LEV system are only available for one operator and he had limited experience with the LEV system, these reported cut rates are in no way intended to represent the impact use of this LEV system is likely to have on productivity rates overall.
VI. Discussion
The objective of these trials was to evaluate the effectiveness of a tuckpointing LEV system for controlling respirable silica while grinding out mortar joints. The Dust Director shroud with the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced respirable silica concentrations when grinding with the Bosch grinder by approximately 99 percent. Despite being considered effective by our test criteria (greater than 50% reduction), it still resulted in task TWA exposures that exceeded the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 by 1.8 times. Depending on how much time is spent grinding over the course of a work day and on exposures while performing other tasks, the 8-hour TWA exposures may or may not exceed the REL with this system. Use of this system by workers with experience and training in proficient use will likely improve dust capture performance. Exposure reduction is greatly influenced by correct use of this system which includes grinding from right to left, making sure the shroud is held flush against the wall and that the tool travels at a pace that doesn’t exceed the ability of the system to capture dust as it’s generated. Deviation from any of these measures produces visible dust clouds which were observed during trials.
VII. Conclusions
With a 99 percent reduction in respirable silica exposure, the Dust Director shroud and DustControl 2900c vacuum with a Bosch Model 1775E grinder was effective in reducing silica exposures based on our criteria. Use of the tested dust control system may be effective in reducing silica exposure on the job to less than the NIOSH REL if used in combination with administrative controls such as work scheduling to reduce cutting times as needed. Training on correct use of the tested system is also essential. Personal air monitoring is necessary to verify control effectiveness on actual job sites and under “real-world” conditions. However, these results clearly demonstrate the availability of viable and effective engineering controls for tuckpointing operations associated with elevated silica exposure.
VIII. References
American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists. Threshold limit values for chemical substances (TLV®-CS). [2013]. ACGIH, Cincinnati, Ohio.
Bergdahl I.A,. Toren K., Eriksson K., et al. [2004]. Increased mortality in COPD among construction workers exposed to inorganic dust. European Respiratory Journal, 23: 402–06.
Blanc P.D. & Torén K. [2007]. Occupation in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and chronic bronchitis: an update [State of the Art Series. Occupational lung disease in high-and low-income countries, Edited by M. Chan-Yeung. Number 2 in the series]. The International Journal of Tuberculosis and Lung Disease, 11(3), 251-257.
Collingwood S. & Heitbrink W.A. [2007] 'Field Evaluation of an Engineering Control for Respirable Crystalline Silica Exposures During Mortar Removal'. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, 4:11, 875 – 887.
DHHS (NIOSH) Publication No. 2002-129 April 2002 http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/2002-129/
Echt A., Sieber W.K., Lefkowitz D., Meeker J., Susi P., Cardwell B., Heitbrink, W.A. In-depth survey of dust control technology for cutting concrete block and tuckpointing brick at The International Masonry Institute Bordentown Training Center, Bordentown, NJ. Cincinnati, OH: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Report. No. EPHB 282-13; 2007. http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ECTB-282-13.pdf
Heitbrink W., Bennett J. [2006]. A numerical and experimental investigation of crystalline silica exposure control during tuck pointing. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, Vol. 3, pp 366-378.
Lyons et al, [2007]. A breathless builder. Breathe, Vol. 3, no. 4, pp 386-390.
Mastrangelo G., Tartari M., Fedeli U., Fadda E., Saia B. [2003]. Ascertaining the risk of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease in relation to occupation using a case-control design. Occupational Medicine, 53: 165–172.
Meeker J., Cooper M., Lefrowitz D., Susi P. [2009]. Engineering control technologies to reduce occupational silica exposures in masonry cutting and tuckpointing. Public Health Reports, Supplement 1, Vol. 124, June.
Meeker J, Flynn M, Susi P, Cardwell, B [2004]. Performance evaluation of a masonry concrete vacuum. Unpublished Report.
Miller F. W., Alfredsson L., Costenbader K. H., Kamen D. L., Nelson L. M., Norris J. M., & De Roos A. J. [2012]. Epidemiology of environmental exposures and human autoimmune diseases: findings from a National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences Expert Panel workshop. Journal of autoimmunity. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3496812/
Occupational Safety and Health Administration U.S Department of Labor. Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction. [2009]. OSHA 3362-05.
Rappaport SM, Goldberg M, Susi P, Herrick RF [2003]. Excessive exposure to silica in the U.S. construction industry. Annals of Occupational Hygiene, Vol. 47, pp. 111-122.
IX. Appendices
| Measurement Conditions |
n | Mean Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Median
Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before filter cleaning | 5 | 80 | 81 | 78-81 |
| After filter cleaning following manufacturer directions | 9 | 89 | 90 | 84-93 |
| * Static pressure was measured in millibars and converted to inches of water gauge. Flow rates were calculated using the formula Q = Ce (A) 4005 (SP)1/2 where: Q = flow in cubic feet per minute (cfm), Ce = coefficient of entry, A = area of the duct where static pressure measurements were taken in square feet, and SP = static pressure in inches of water gauge. | ||||
| Tool/Control | Collection Period (min.) |
Dust Collection Rate (lb/min.) |
|---|---|---|
| Bosch grinder/Dust Director shroud & DustControl 2900c vacuum |
8 11 8 8 10 |
0.50 0.61 0.50 0.47 0.63 |
| Average | 0.54 |
[disclaimer:protected] => [disclaimer_transformed:protected] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [template] => record ) [_file] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/templates/elcosh/record_macros.html [_errors:protected] => Array ( ) [_encoding:protected] => UTF-8 [_outputMode:protected] => 11 [_forceReparse:protected] => [_phpCodeDestination:protected] => /tmp/ [_phpCodeExtension:protected] => php [_cacheLifetime:protected] => 30 [_cachePurgeFrequency:protected] => 30 [externalMacroTemplatesCache:PHPTAL:private] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [1] => PHPTAL_Context Object ( [_line] => [_file] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/templates/elcosh/record.html [repeat] => stdClass Object ( ) [_xmlDeclaration] => [_docType] => [_nothrow:PHPTAL_Context:private] => [_slots:PHPTAL_Context:private] => Array ( ) [_slotsStack:PHPTAL_Context:private] => Array ( [0] => Array ( ) [1] => Array ( ) ) [_parentContext:PHPTAL_Context:private] => [_globalContext:PHPTAL_Context:private] => stdClass Object ( ) [_echoDeclarations:PHPTAL_Context:private] => [referer] => http://www.elcosh.org/document/3908/d001345/An%2BEvaluation%2Bof%2BSilica%2BExposure%2BControls%2Bfor%2BTuckpointing%253A%2BDustControl%2B2900c%2BVacuum%2Bwith%2Bthe%2BICS%2BDust%2BDirector%2BShroud%2Band%2BBosch%2BGrinder%2BModel%2B1775E%2BConducted%2BNovember%2B14-15%252C%2B2012.html [curr_module] => Record [styles] => Array ( ) [javascript] => Array ( [0] => jquery.min.js ) [metas] => Array ( [language] => en [robots] => index, follow ) [user] => [curr_url] => https://www.elcosh.org/index.php?module=Record&id=3908&type=document [base_url] => https://www.elcosh.org/index.php?module=Record [title] => eLCOSH : An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: DustControl 2900c Vacuum with the ICS Dust Director Shroud and Bosch Grinder Model 1775E Conducted November 14-15, 2012 [language] => en [search_query] => [module] => Record [new_records] => Array ( [0] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Fixed Ladder [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Fixed Ladders addresses the potential risks associated with using fixed ladders. The resource includes a brief case example,... [category] => Array ( [0] => 15 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 53 [5] => 55 [6] => 60 [7] => 64 [8] => 73 [9] => 76 [10] => 78 [11] => 80 [12] => 86 [13] => 87 [14] => 90 [15] => 92 [16] => 93 [17] => 94 [18] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Falls [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Concrete Polisher [11] => Electrical Worker [13] => HVAC [15] => Laborer [17] => PCC/Restoration [19] => Plumber/Pipefitter [21] => Roofer/Waterproofer [23] => Sheetmetal Worker [25] => Welder [27] => Commercial & Institutional [28] => Jobsites [29] => Industrial [31] => LEED/Green Construction [33] => Renovations [35] => Residential [37] => Toolbox Talks [38] => Documents [39] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4430/d001660/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BFixed%2BLadder.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [53] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 53 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Concrete Polisher [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [73] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 73 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => PCC/Restoration [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4430 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001660 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Fixed Ladder [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Fixed Ladders, Fall Prevention, Falls [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Fixed Ladders addresses the potential risks associated with using fixed ladders. The resource includes a brief case example, steps to prevent a related injury and questions for discussion. It includes an image that illustrates the hazard, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001257,d001254,d001255,d001256,d001258,d001262,d001279 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_completed:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/22/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [1] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Challenges Preventing Falling Objects [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Challenges Preventing Falling Objects addresses the hazards of being struck by falling objects on the job site. The resource... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 55 [5] => 64 [6] => 68 [7] => 71 [8] => 75 [9] => 78 [10] => 79 [11] => 82 [12] => 62 [13] => 86 [14] => 87 [15] => 88 [16] => 89 [17] => 91 [18] => 90 [19] => 92 [20] => 93 [21] => 94 [22] => 95 [23] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Electrical Worker [11] => Laborer [13] => Maintenance Worker [15] => Painter [17] => Plasterer [19] => Roofer/Waterproofer [21] => Scaffold Erector [23] => Stonemason [25] => Structural Ironworker [27] => Welder [29] => Commercial & Institutional [30] => Jobsites [31] => Demolition [33] => Disasters [35] => Heavy & Highway [37] => Industrial [39] => LEED/Green Construction [41] => Renovations [43] => Residential [45] => Underground [47] => Toolbox Talks [48] => Documents [49] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4431/d001661/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BChallenges%2BPreventing%2BFalling%2BObjects.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4431 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001661 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Challenges Preventing Falling Objects [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => dropped objects, falling objects, struck by incidents, struck by fatalities [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Challenges Preventing Falling Objects addresses the hazards of being struck by falling objects on the job site. The resource includes a brief example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates a group workers observing a scaffold free of debris during high winds, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001234,d001238,d001244,d001251,d001253,d001260,d001268,d001278 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_completed:protected] => 06/10/22 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/22/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [2] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Tower Crane Safety [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Tower Crane Safety addresses the potential hazards of Tower Cranes and the importance of following procedure before and durin... [category] => Array ( [0] => 11 [1] => 12 [2] => 18 [3] => 70 [4] => 87 [5] => 88 [6] => 91 [7] => 90 [8] => 92 [9] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Cranes & Hoists [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Crushed/Struck By [6] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [9] => Operating Engineer [10] => Trades [11] => Commercial & Institutional [12] => Jobsites [13] => Demolition [15] => Heavy & Highway [17] => Industrial [19] => LEED/Green Construction [21] => Toolbox Talks [22] => Documents [23] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4427/d001657/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BTower%2BCrane%2BSafety.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [11] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 11 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Cranes & Hoists [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [18] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 18 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4427 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001657 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Tower Crane Safety [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Tower Crane, Crane, Stability, Tipping, Lift Zone Safety, Lift, Zone, Safety, Struck by [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Tower Crane Safety addresses the potential hazards of Tower Cranes and the importance of following procedure before and during Tower Crane operation. The resource includes a brief example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates a worker inspecting a Tower Crane before operation, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001234,d001238,d001250,d001251,d001253,d001258,d001262,d001273 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/19/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [3] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox Talk: Work Zone Safety: Working Around Vehicles [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Working Around Vehicles in the Work Zone addresses methods to avoid being struck-by a vehicle on a construction site. The res... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 18 [2] => 52 [3] => 57 [4] => 70 [5] => 85 [6] => 87 [7] => 88 [8] => 89 [9] => 91 [10] => 90 [11] => 92 [12] => 93 [13] => 94 [14] => 95 [15] => 100 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [6] => Commercial Diver [7] => Trades [8] => Flagger [10] => Operating Engineer [12] => Truck Driver [14] => Commercial & Institutional [15] => Jobsites [16] => Demolition [18] => Disasters [20] => Heavy & Highway [22] => Industrial [24] => LEED/Green Construction [26] => Renovations [28] => Residential [30] => Underground [32] => Toolbox Talks [33] => Documents [34] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Toolbox Talks [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4428/d001658/Toolbox%2BTalk%253A%2BWork%2BZone%2BSafety%253A%2BWorking%2BAround%2BVehicles.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [18] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 18 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Motor Vehicles/Heavy Equipment [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [52] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 52 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Commercial Diver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [85] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 85 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Truck Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [100] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 100 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 6 [label:protected] => Toolbox Talks [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4428 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001658 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Daniela Caceres [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox Talk: Work Zone Safety: Working Around Vehicles [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Struck, Struck by, Vehicle, Work Zone Safety, Truck, Operator, Driver, Mobile Equipment [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The CPWR Toolbox Talk on Working Around Vehicles in the Work Zone addresses methods to avoid being struck-by a vehicle on a construction site. The resource includes a case example, steps to prevent a related injury, and questions for discussion. It includes a graphic that illustrates the hazard, which can be posted in a central location as a reminder of steps to work safely. Available in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d001640 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/23/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/19/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [4] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Construction Dive -- DeWalt's Jobsite Pro headphones recalled for fire hazards [image] => /record/images/notavailable-p.png [blurb] => A recall notice by the United States Consumer Product Safety Commission affects over 300,000 DeWalt Jobsite Pro Headphones. The recall is a result of... [category] => Array ( [0] => 16 [1] => 44 [2] => 45 [3] => 46 [4] => 47 [5] => 48 [6] => 49 [7] => 50 [8] => 51 [9] => 52 [10] => 53 [11] => 54 [12] => 55 [13] => 56 [14] => 57 [15] => 58 [16] => 59 [17] => 60 [18] => 61 [19] => 64 [20] => 65 [21] => 66 [22] => 67 [23] => 68 [24] => 69 [25] => 70 [26] => 71 [27] => 72 [28] => 73 [29] => 74 [30] => 75 [31] => 76 [32] => 77 [33] => 63 [34] => 78 [35] => 79 [36] => 80 [37] => 81 [38] => 82 [39] => 62 [40] => 83 [41] => 84 [42] => 85 [43] => 86 [44] => 87 [45] => 88 [46] => 89 [47] => 91 [48] => 90 [49] => 92 [50] => 93 [51] => 94 [52] => 95 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Fire & Explosions [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Acoustical Ceiling Carpenter [4] => Trades [5] => Asbestos/Insulator [7] => Boilermaker [9] => Bricklayer [11] => Cabinetmaker [13] => Carpenter [15] => Carpet Layer [17] => Cement Mason [19] => Commercial Diver [21] => Concrete Polisher [23] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [25] => Electrical Worker [27] => Elevator Constructor [29] => Flagger [31] => Glazier [33] => Hazardous Waste Cleanup [35] => HVAC [37] => Interior Systems Carpenter [39] => Laborer [41] => Landscaper [43] => Lather [45] => Lead Abatement Worker [47] => Maintenance Worker [49] => Millwright [51] => Operating Engineer [53] => Painter [55] => Paper Hanger [57] => PCC/Restoration [59] => Pile Driver [61] => Plasterer [63] => Plumber/Pipefitter [65] => Refractory Worker [67] => Reinforcing Ironworker [69] => Roofer/Waterproofer [71] => Scaffold Erector [73] => Sheetmetal Worker [75] => Sprinkler Fitter [77] => Stonemason [79] => Structural Ironworker [81] => Terrazzo Worker [83] => Tile Setter [85] => Truck Driver [87] => Welder [89] => Commercial & Institutional [90] => Jobsites [91] => Demolition [93] => Disasters [95] => Heavy & Highway [97] => Industrial [99] => LEED/Green Construction [101] => Renovations [103] => Residential [105] => Underground ) [type] => [sub_category] => [url] => /document/4426/d001656/Construction%2BDive%2B--%2BDeWalt%2527s%2BJobsite%2BPro%2Bheadphones%2Brecalled%2Bfor%2Bfire%2Bhazards.html [item:protected] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [16] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 16 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Fire & Explosions [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [44] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 44 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Acoustical Ceiling Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [45] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 45 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Asbestos/Insulator [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [46] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 46 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Boilermaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [48] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 48 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cabinetmaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [50] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 50 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpet Layer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [52] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 52 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Commercial Diver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [53] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 53 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Concrete Polisher [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [54] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 54 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [58] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 58 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Glazier [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [59] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 59 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Hazardous Waste Cleanup [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [65] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 65 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Landscaper [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [66] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 66 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Lather [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [67] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 67 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Lead Abatement Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [69] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 69 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Millwright [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [72] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 72 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Paper Hanger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [73] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 73 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => PCC/Restoration [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [77] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 77 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Refractory Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [81] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 81 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sprinkler Fitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [83] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 83 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Terrazzo Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [84] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 84 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Tile Setter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [85] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 85 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Truck Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [86] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 86 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Welder [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [92] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 92 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => LEED/Green Construction [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4426 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001656 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML only (and links) [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Mike Aguilar [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Construction Dive -- DeWalt's Jobsite Pro headphones recalled for fire hazards [total_pages:protected] => 1 [billed_pages:protected] => 1 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => DeWalt, Fire Hazards, recall, headphones [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A recall notice by the United States Consumer Product Safety Commission affects over 300,000 DeWalt Jobsite Pro Headphones. The recall is a result of a malfunction that can cause earbuds to overheat while charging or during use, leading to fire and burn hazards. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => https://www.constructiondive.com/news/dewalts-jobsite-pro-headphones-recalled-for-fire-hazards/611248/?utm_source=Sailthru&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Issue:%202021-12-10%20Construction%20Dive%20Newsletter%20%5Bissue:38532%5D&utm_term=Construction%20Dive [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/13/21 [date_completed:protected] => 12/13/21 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 12/13/21 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [new_images] => Array ( [0] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Morning Toolbox Talk [image] => /record/images/4003-p.jpg [blurb] => This photo is from an early morning toolbox talk on a construction job in Mclean, Virginia. It is being delivered in English and Spanish.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 20 [1] => 51 [2] => 57 [3] => 64 [4] => 70 [5] => 63 [6] => 78 [7] => 82 [8] => 62 [9] => 87 [10] => 88 [11] => 89 [12] => 91 [13] => 90 [14] => 93 [15] => 94 [16] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Safety Culture [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Cement Mason [4] => Trades [5] => Flagger [7] => Laborer [9] => Operating Engineer [11] => Reinforcing Ironworker [13] => Roofer/Waterproofer [15] => Stonemason [17] => Structural Ironworker [19] => Commercial & Institutional [20] => Jobsites [21] => Demolition [23] => Disasters [25] => Heavy & Highway [27] => Industrial [29] => Renovations [31] => Residential [33] => Images [34] => Media [35] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4003/i002691/Morning%2BToolbox%2BTalk.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [57] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 57 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Flagger [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [70] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 70 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Operating Engineer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [89] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 89 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Disasters [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4003 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002691 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Morning Toolbox Talk [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, Spanish, bilingual [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This photo is from an early morning toolbox talk on a construction job in Mclean, Virginia. It is being delivered in English and Spanish. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001285,d001304,c000079 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [1] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox talk - crew view [image] => /record/images/4005-p.jpg [blurb] => Photo of crew listening to a toolbox safety talk before starting work.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 97 [1] => 20 [2] => 47 [3] => 49 [4] => 51 [5] => 55 [6] => 61 [7] => 64 [8] => 71 [9] => 75 [10] => 63 [11] => 79 [12] => 62 [13] => 87 [14] => 88 [15] => 91 [16] => 90 [17] => 93 [18] => 94 [19] => 95 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Images [1] => Media [2] => Media & Documents [3] => Safety Culture [4] => Work Environment [5] => Hazards [6] => Bricklayer [7] => Trades [8] => Carpenter [10] => Cement Mason [12] => Electrical Worker [14] => Interior Systems Carpenter [16] => Laborer [18] => Painter [20] => Plasterer [22] => Reinforcing Ironworker [24] => Scaffold Erector [26] => Structural Ironworker [28] => Commercial & Institutional [29] => Jobsites [30] => Demolition [32] => Heavy & Highway [34] => Industrial [36] => Renovations [38] => Residential [40] => Underground ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4005/i002692/Toolbox%2Btalk%2B-%2Bcrew%2Bview.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4005 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002692 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox talk - crew view [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, safety talk, Spanish [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Photo of crew listening to a toolbox safety talk before starting work. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002691,d001269, c000079, d001285 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [2] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Toolbox talk - long shot [image] => /record/images/4006-p.jpg [blurb] => This crew gathered every morning before starting work to discuss a new safety topic.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 20 [1] => 47 [2] => 49 [3] => 51 [4] => 55 [5] => 64 [6] => 68 [7] => 75 [8] => 76 [9] => 63 [10] => 78 [11] => 79 [12] => 82 [13] => 62 [14] => 87 [15] => 88 [16] => 91 [17] => 90 [18] => 93 [19] => 94 [20] => 95 [21] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Safety Culture [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Bricklayer [4] => Trades [5] => Carpenter [7] => Cement Mason [9] => Electrical Worker [11] => Laborer [13] => Maintenance Worker [15] => Plasterer [17] => Plumber/Pipefitter [19] => Reinforcing Ironworker [21] => Roofer/Waterproofer [23] => Scaffold Erector [25] => Stonemason [27] => Structural Ironworker [29] => Commercial & Institutional [30] => Jobsites [31] => Demolition [33] => Heavy & Highway [35] => Industrial [37] => Renovations [39] => Residential [41] => Underground [43] => Images [44] => Media [45] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4006/i002693/Toolbox%2Btalk%2B-%2Blong%2Bshot.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [88] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 88 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Demolition [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [95] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 95 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Underground [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4006 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002693 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Toolbox talk - long shot [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => toolbox talk, tailgate talk, safety minute [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This crew gathered every morning before starting work to discuss a new safety topic. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/electrical/solution/662/worker-training.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002691,i002692,d001269,d000527 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Morgan Zavertnik and Hoar Construction [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/02/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [3] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Safety officer discussing ongoing project with marketing coordinator [image] => /record/images/4014-p.jpg [blurb] => The safety officer (left) points out the good safety practices on this project that reflect well on the firm and may influence future clients.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 97 [1] => 20 [2] => 46 [3] => 47 [4] => 49 [5] => 50 [6] => 51 [7] => 54 [8] => 55 [9] => 58 [10] => 60 [11] => 61 [12] => 64 [13] => 71 [14] => 75 [15] => 76 [16] => 63 [17] => 79 [18] => 80 [19] => 82 [20] => 62 [21] => 83 [22] => 87 [23] => 91 [24] => 90 [25] => 93 [26] => 94 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Images [1] => Media [2] => Media & Documents [3] => Safety Culture [4] => Work Environment [5] => Hazards [6] => Boilermaker [7] => Trades [8] => Bricklayer [10] => Carpenter [12] => Carpet Layer [14] => Cement Mason [16] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [18] => Electrical Worker [20] => Glazier [22] => HVAC [24] => Interior Systems Carpenter [26] => Laborer [28] => Painter [30] => Plasterer [32] => Plumber/Pipefitter [34] => Reinforcing Ironworker [36] => Scaffold Erector [38] => Sheetmetal Worker [40] => Stonemason [42] => Structural Ironworker [44] => Terrazzo Worker [46] => Commercial & Institutional [47] => Jobsites [48] => Heavy & Highway [50] => Industrial [52] => Renovations [54] => Residential ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/4014/i002700/Safety%2Bofficer%2Bdiscussing%2Bongoing%2Bproject%2Bwith%2Bmarketing%2Bcoordinator.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [20] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 20 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Safety Culture [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [46] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 46 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Boilermaker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [50] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 50 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpet Layer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [54] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 54 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Drywall Applicator Specialist [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [58] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 58 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Glazier [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [61] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 61 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Interior Systems Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [71] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 71 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Painter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [75] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 75 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plasterer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [76] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 76 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Plumber/Pipefitter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [82] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 82 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Stonemason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [83] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 83 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Terrazzo Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [91] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 91 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Heavy & Highway [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [93] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 93 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Renovations [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [94] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 94 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Residential [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 4014 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002700 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Safety officer discussing ongoing project with marketing coordinator [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Latino, safety officer, safety culture [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The safety officer (left) points out the good safety practices on this project that reflect well on the firm and may influence future clients. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/index.php [more_like_this:protected] => d000989,d001351,d001362,d000652, d001101, d000931, d001395 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Hoar Construction, Photo by Neil Lippy [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => November 2015 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_completed:protected] => 03/02/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 01/30/23 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [4] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Scaffolding at top of large column [image] => /record/images/3994-p.jpg [blurb] => This shot shows innovative guarding around the top of a large concrete column in the base of a high rise structure going up.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 15 [1] => 21 [2] => 47 [3] => 51 [4] => 63 [5] => 78 [6] => 79 [7] => 80 [8] => 62 [9] => 87 [10] => 97 [11] => 56 [12] => 64 [13] => 74 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Falls [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Scaffolds [6] => Bricklayer [7] => Trades [8] => Cement Mason [10] => Reinforcing Ironworker [12] => Roofer/Waterproofer [14] => Scaffold Erector [16] => Sheetmetal Worker [18] => Structural Ironworker [20] => Commercial & Institutional [21] => Jobsites [22] => Images [23] => Media [24] => Media & Documents [25] => Elevator Constructor [27] => Laborer [29] => Pile Driver ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/3994/i002689/Scaffolding%2Bat%2Btop%2Bof%2Blarge%2Bcolumn.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [21] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 21 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Scaffolds [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [47] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 47 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Bricklayer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3994 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002689 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Scaffolding at top of large column [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Guardrail, railing, fall prevention, falls [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This shot shows innovative guarding around the top of a large concrete column in the base of a high rise structure going up. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/8/adjustable-tower-scaffold.html [more_like_this:protected] => c1002680,i002662,d000608,d001255 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Photo by Pam Susi [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2016 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_completed:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/01/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [5] => Search_Result Object ( [title] => Construction bracing [image] => /record/images/3995-p.jpg [blurb] => This shows structural support that prevents collapses during construction.... [category] => Array ( [0] => 12 [1] => 15 [2] => 21 [3] => 49 [4] => 51 [5] => 55 [6] => 56 [7] => 60 [8] => 64 [9] => 68 [10] => 74 [11] => 63 [12] => 78 [13] => 79 [14] => 80 [15] => 62 [16] => 87 [17] => 90 [18] => 97 ) [labels] => Array ( [0] => Crushed/Struck By [1] => Work Environment [2] => Hazards [3] => Falls [6] => Scaffolds [9] => Carpenter [10] => Trades [11] => Cement Mason [13] => Electrical Worker [15] => Elevator Constructor [17] => HVAC [19] => Laborer [21] => Maintenance Worker [23] => Pile Driver [25] => Reinforcing Ironworker [27] => Roofer/Waterproofer [29] => Scaffold Erector [31] => Sheetmetal Worker [33] => Structural Ironworker [35] => Commercial & Institutional [36] => Jobsites [37] => Industrial [39] => Images [40] => Media [41] => Media & Documents ) [type] => Images [sub_category] => [url] => /image/3995/i002690/Construction%2Bbracing.html [item:protected] => ImageRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => Array ( [12] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 12 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Crushed/Struck By [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [15] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 15 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Falls [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [21] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 21 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 7 [label:protected] => Scaffolds [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [49] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 49 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Carpenter [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [51] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 51 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Cement Mason [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [55] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 55 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Electrical Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [56] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 56 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Elevator Constructor [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [60] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 60 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => HVAC [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [64] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 64 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Laborer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [68] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 68 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Maintenance Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [74] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 74 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Pile Driver [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [63] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 63 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Reinforcing Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [78] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 78 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Roofer/Waterproofer [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [79] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 79 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Scaffold Erector [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [80] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 80 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Sheetmetal Worker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [62] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 62 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 2 [label:protected] => Structural Ironworker [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [87] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 87 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Commercial & Institutional [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [90] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 90 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 3 [label:protected] => Industrial [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [97] => Category Object ( [languages:protected] => [bok_resources:protected] => [bok_topics:protected] => [bok_keywords:protected] => [id:protected] => 97 [type:protected] => category [parent:protected] => 5 [label:protected] => Images [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [categories_initialized:protected] => 1 [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3995 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => i002690 [type:protected] => image [display_type:protected] => Image [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Construction bracing [total_pages:protected] => 0 [billed_pages:protected] => 0 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Bracing, support, scaffold [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This shows structural support that prevents collapses during construction. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/8/adjustable-tower-scaffold.html [more_like_this:protected] => i002660 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => Photo by Pam Susi [img_practice:protected] => good [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2016 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_completed:protected] => 02/01/16 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/01/16 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [preview_mode] => [description] => The results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. [keywords] => tuckpointing, HEPA vacuum, dust control, LEV, local exhaust ventilation, silica [related_items] => Array ( [Research Reports] => Array ( [0] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1874 [old_id:protected] => 722 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000683 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Sharon Garber/COD [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Protecting Tuckpointing Workers from Silica Dust: Draft Recommendations for a Ventilated Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 12 [billed_pages:protected] => 12 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, vacuum, grinder, mortar, respirator, OSHA, NIOSH, exhaust, Heitbrink, tuckpointer, silica, masonry, dust, silicosis, LEV [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Describes draft recommendations for use of ventilated grinder to reduce dust during tuckpointing and describes field trials using these devices. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/hazard/67/chip-scrape-and-grind-surfaces-or-joints-silica.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001201,d000292,d000293,d000658 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2005 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/27/05 [date_completed:protected] => 04/26/05 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/20/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [1] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1940 [old_id:protected] => 909 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Workplace Solutions: Control of Hazardous Dust During Tuckpointing [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, silica, dust, tuckpoint, grinder, masonry restoration, mortar, vacuum [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d000819,d000820,d000730,d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 10/24/08 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/09 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [2] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3899 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001342 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: Hilti VC40-U Vacuum with Hilti DC-EX Dust Guard and Hilti Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 15 [billed_pages:protected] => 15 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP4 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => silica, tuckpointing, Hilti, local exhaust systems, LEV, shroud, quartz [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This report describes the results of an evaluation of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Hilti VC40-U vacuum, a Hilti DC-EX shroud, and a Hilti DAG-500 grinder. Randomized trials with and without use of the dust control system were conducted in a controlled setting. Removing mortar with the Hilti grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 220 times the National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05mg/m3. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 97 percent. However, exposures measured during the use of the dust control system still exceeded the NIOSH REL. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => December 1, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/05/14 [date_completed:protected] => 02/04/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/06/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [Handouts] => Array ( [0] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3656 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001198 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 24 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction While Doing Tuckpointing/Mortar Removal [total_pages:protected] => 2 [billed_pages:protected] => 2 [publication_number:protected] => DSG FS-3632 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Brick, block, tuckpointing, silica, local exhaust ventilation, LEV, masonry [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Tuckpointing creates some of the greatest exposures to silica in construction. This OSHA factsheet provides guidance on how to greatly reduce these exposures through the use of local exhaust ventilation. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863, d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => February 2013 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/04/13 [date_completed:protected] => 03/27/13 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) ) [collections] => Array ( [3913] => ) [record] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => Array ( [867] => Author Object ( [id:protected] => 867 [organization_id:protected] => 0 [firstname:protected] => Michael [lastname:protected] => Cooper [address:protected] => [city:protected] => [province:protected] => [country:protected] => [postal_code:protected] => [department:protected] => [title:protected] => [phone:protected] => [fax:protected] => [email:protected] => [degree:protected] => [website:protected] => [about:protected] => [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => [date_completed:protected] => [date_billed:protected] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [481] => Author Object ( [id:protected] => 481 [organization_id:protected] => 0 [firstname:protected] => Pam [lastname:protected] => Susi [address:protected] => 8484 Georgia Avenue, Suite 1000 [city:protected] => Silver Spring [province:protected] => Maryland [country:protected] => USA [postal_code:protected] => 20910 [department:protected] => [title:protected] => [phone:protected] => 301-578-8500 ext.144 [fax:protected] => 301-578-8572 [email:protected] => plsusi@aol.com [degree:protected] => [website:protected] => http://www.cpwr.com [about:protected] => [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => 2003-10-02 [date_completed:protected] => 2003-10-06 [date_billed:protected] => 2003-11-03 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [organizations:protected] => Array ( [1] => Organization Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [elcosh_id:protected] => o000001 [user_id:protected] => 14 [province_id:protected] => 21 [country_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => CPWR - The Center for Construction Research and Training [address:protected] => Suite 1000, 8484 Georgia Ave [postal_code:protected] => 20910 [city:protected] => Silver Spring [department:protected] => [phone:protected] => 301-578-8500 [fax:protected] => 301-578-8572 [email:protected] => cpwrwebsite@cpwr.com [website:protected] => http://www.cpwr.com [filename:protected] => o000001.gif [about:protected] => CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training, developed, and continues to maintain/expand this website - The Electronic Library of Construction Occupational Safety and Health, www.elcosh.org. CPWR, formerly known as The Center to Protect Workers’ Rights, is a 501(c)(3) nonprofit research and training institution. Created by the Building and Construction Trades Department, AFL-CIO, CPWR serves as the research arm of the BCTD. Since the inception of its research agenda in 1990, CPWR has grown into a worldwide provider of safety and health information covering all aspects of the construction industry. CPWR launched eLCOSH in 2000, and the Spanish-language version of the site in 2001. CPWR also created, and continues to build, Construction Solutions - www.cpwrConstructionSolutions.org - a free, online database of construction hazards and ways to prevent, eliminate, or reduce them. [comments:protected] => [logo_available:protected] => T [no_details:protected] => F [date_received:protected] => 2000-08-18 [date_completed:protected] => 2000-08-30 [date_billed:protected] => 2000-09-05 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [collections:protected] => Array ( [3913] => ) [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => Array ( [1874] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1874 [old_id:protected] => 722 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000683 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Sharon Garber/COD [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Protecting Tuckpointing Workers from Silica Dust: Draft Recommendations for a Ventilated Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 12 [billed_pages:protected] => 12 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, vacuum, grinder, mortar, respirator, OSHA, NIOSH, exhaust, Heitbrink, tuckpointer, silica, masonry, dust, silicosis, LEV [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Describes draft recommendations for use of ventilated grinder to reduce dust during tuckpointing and describes field trials using these devices. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/hazard/67/chip-scrape-and-grind-surfaces-or-joints-silica.html [more_like_this:protected] => d001201,d000292,d000293,d000658 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => January 2005 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 02/27/05 [date_completed:protected] => 04/26/05 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 03/20/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [1940] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 1940 [old_id:protected] => 909 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 0 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Workplace Solutions: Control of Hazardous Dust During Tuckpointing [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Occupation, construction, safety, health, hazards, work, worker, workplace, silica, dust, tuckpoint, grinder, masonry restoration, mortar, vacuum [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => d000819,d000820,d000730,d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 10/24/08 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/09 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [2213] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 2213 [old_id:protected] => 1090 [elcosh_id:protected] => d000863 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => [language_id:protected] => 2 [tagging_id:protected] => eileen and sharretta [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Control del polvo peligroso que se genera durante los procesos de reparación de mortero [total_pages:protected] => 4 [billed_pages:protected] => 4 [publication_number:protected] => 2008-126 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => [comments:protected] => http://www.cdc.gov/spanish/niosh/docs/wp-solutions/2008-126_sp/ [summary:protected] => A Workplace Solutions de NIOSH que resume un estudio de NIOSH sobre los riesgos de exposición cuando se reparan las estructuras y los métodos para controlar el polvo. [A NIOSH Workplace Solutions that summarizes a NIOSH study on exposure hazards when tuckpointing and methods to control the dust.] [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => [more_like_this:protected] => D000819,D000820,D000730,d000819 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => 2008 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 01/07/10 [date_completed:protected] => 04/19/10 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 07/08/12 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [3656] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3656 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001198 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 24 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction While Doing Tuckpointing/Mortar Removal [total_pages:protected] => 2 [billed_pages:protected] => 2 [publication_number:protected] => DSG FS-3632 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => Brick, block, tuckpointing, silica, local exhaust ventilation, LEV, masonry [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => Tuckpointing creates some of the greatest exposures to silica in construction. This OSHA factsheet provides guidance on how to greatly reduce these exposures through the use of local exhaust ventilation. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863, d001201 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => jpg [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => February 2013 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 03/04/13 [date_completed:protected] => 03/27/13 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 04/26/13 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [3899] => DocumentRecord Object ( [records:protected] => Array ( ) [recordId:protected] => [searchWordClass:protected] => [searchWordPeerClass:protected] => [bok_record:protected] => [authors:protected] => [organizations:protected] => [collections:protected] => [categories:protected] => [categories_initialized:protected] => [mapped_items:protected] => [content:protected] => [files:protected] => [language:protected] => [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3899 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001342 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: Hilti VC40-U Vacuum with Hilti DC-EX Dust Guard and Hilti Grinder [total_pages:protected] => 15 [billed_pages:protected] => 15 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP4 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => silica, tuckpointing, Hilti, local exhaust systems, LEV, shroud, quartz [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => This report describes the results of an evaluation of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Hilti VC40-U vacuum, a Hilti DC-EX shroud, and a Hilti DAG-500 grinder. Randomized trials with and without use of the dust control system were conducted in a controlled setting. Removing mortar with the Hilti grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 220 times the National Institute of Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05mg/m3. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 97 percent. However, exposures measured during the use of the dust control system still exceeded the NIOSH REL. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => December 1, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 12/05/14 [date_completed:protected] => 02/04/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 05/06/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [content:protected] => [files:protected] => Array ( [559] => [560] => [546] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 546 [filename:protected] => 3.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:22 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [566] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 566 [filename:protected] => 4.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:23 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [720] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 720 [filename:protected] => 5.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [721] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 721 [filename:protected] => 6.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [722] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 722 [filename:protected] => 7.jpg [downloadable:protected] => F [timestamp:protected] => 2009-07-03 12:54:31 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [9765] => File Object ( [id:protected] => 9765 [filename:protected] => d001345.pdf [downloadable:protected] => T [timestamp:protected] => 2015-02-09 12:26:04 [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) ) [language:protected] => Language Object ( [id:protected] => 1 [code:protected] => en [name:protected] => English [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [old_record:protected] => [id:protected] => 3908 [old_id:protected] => [elcosh_id:protected] => d001345 [type:protected] => document [display_type:protected] => HTML w/ PDF [user_id:protected] => 23 [language_id:protected] => 1 [tagging_id:protected] => Bruce Lippy [priority_id:protected] => 1 [title:protected] => An Evaluation of Silica Exposure Controls for Tuckpointing: DustControl 2900c Vacuum with the ICS Dust Director Shroud and Bosch Grinder Model 1775E Conducted November 14-15, 2012 [total_pages:protected] => 13 [billed_pages:protected] => 13 [publication_number:protected] => LEV-E-TP2 [part_of:protected] => [keywords:protected] => tuckpointing, HEPA vacuum, dust control, LEV, local exhaust ventilation, silica [comments:protected] => [summary:protected] => The results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. [transition_comments:protected] => [external_link:protected] => [consol_link:protected] => http://www.cpwrconstructionsolutions.org/masonry/solution/52/tuckpointing-nbsp-grinder-with-vacuum-dust-control.html [more_like_this:protected] => d000683,d000863,d001198,d001342 [permission_given_by:protected] => [published:protected] => T [billable:protected] => F [img_name:protected] => [img_ext:protected] => png [img_width:protected] => [img_height:protected] => [img_credit:protected] => [img_practice:protected] => [vid_source_id:protected] => [vid_running_time:protected] => [vid_intended_audience:protected] => [vid_acquisition_info:protected] => [vid_cost:protected] => [vid_producer:protected] => [vid_filename:protected] => [vid_filename_downloadable:protected] => [date_summary:protected] => April 15, 2014 [date_permission_requested:protected] => [date_permission_received:protected] => [date_review_needed:protected] => [date_received:protected] => 01/26/15 [date_completed:protected] => 02/05/15 [date_billed:protected] => [date_modified:protected] => 02/09/15 [collBokExports:protected] => [lastBokExportCriteria:BaseElcoshItem:private] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [show_text] => [document_content] => ElcoshItemDocumentContent Object ( [id:protected] => 2934 [item_id:protected] => 3908 [type:protected] => main [title:protected] => [content:protected] =>
Executive Summary
This report describes the results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. It should also be noted that the NIOSH REL is based on exposures averaged over a ten hour work day and our results represent time weighted averages of the sample task duration periods.
Acronyms
ACGIH - American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists
CPWR - CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training
Ce - coefficient of entry
HEPA - high-efficiency particulate air
IUBAC - International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craftworkers
LEV - local exhaust ventilation
PACT - Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies
NIOSH - National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health
OEL - occupational exposure limit
OSHA - Occupational Safety and Health Administration
PAPR - powered air-purifying respirator
PEL - Permissible Exposure Limit
PVC - polyvinyl chloride
REL - Recommended Exposure Limit
RPM - revolutions per minute
TWA - time-weighted average
SP - static pressure
I. Introduction and Background
In 2010 CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training began a four-year project which seeks to identify and evaluate tuckpointing local exhaust ventilation (LEV) systems and disseminate information on their availability and effectiveness. A Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies (PACT) comprised of masonry contractors, representatives from unions, government, equipment manufacturers, and health and safety researcher was formed as part of this project. PACT members participated in identifying important characteristics for control technologies and this information was used to identify LEV systems for tuckpointing using that criteria. Contractor and labor members of the PACT selected specific tuckpointing LEV systems to be considered for evaluation. Each system consisted of a tuckpointing grinder, shroud, and vacuum. This report describes the second of four systems to be evaluated between 2012 the end of 2014, with and without LEV, in a controlled setting to determine effectiveness in silica exposure reduction. This report describes the methods and results of our evaluation of a system consisting of the DustControl 2900c vacuum with the ICS Dust Director shroud and a Bosch Model 1775E grinder.
Excessive exposure to respirable silica can result in silicosis or other silica-related diseases including pulmonary tuberculosis, lung cancer, silicoproteinosis (Lyons et al, 2007) and autoimmune disorders such as rheumatoid arthritis, sarcoidosis and scleroderma (Miller et al, 2012). Respirable silica is generally defined as particles less than 10 micrometers (μm) in aerodynamic diameter (ACGIH, 2013). Silicosis can lead to symptoms including shortness of breath, fatigue, chest pains, susceptibility to infection and possibly death. There is no cure for silicosis, however it is totally preventable. Construction workers exposed to dust, including silica, are also known to have higher rates of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD).
There are many sources of silica in construction that result in exposures of varying intensity among workers. Masonry restoration workers are among the most highly silica-exposed trades in construction. The process of grinding out deteriorated mortar joints between masonry units and replacing or repointing with fresh mortar (often referred to as tuckpointing) is a fundamental part of masonry restoration work. The removal of mortar with powered angle grinders generates enormous levels of dust. Between 2004 and 2006, NIOSH and CPWR evaluated silica exposures while grinding mortar in a controlled setting, at a local training center, where tasks, sample times and task variables were defined by the study design. These studies demonstrated that grinding mortar without controls can result in elevated respirable silica exposures. Meeker et al., (2009) reported exposures between 5 and 25.8 milligrams per cubic meter (mg/m3) in a controlled setting. This study also showed that LEV systems for tuckpointing grinders can reduce exposures to respirable silica by greater than 90 percent.II. Objectives
The objective of this evaluation was to assess the effectiveness of an LEV system for controlling exposure to silica during the grinding of mortar. The control technology was tested under controlled conditions, similar to those experienced by tuckpointers on actual job sites, using journeymen bricklayers experienced in tuckpointing and repeat, randomized trials with and without LEV. All other variables were held constant throughout so that the only variable was whether or not the tested control was used.
III. Description of Equipment Tested
A Bosch model 1775E grinder (Robert Bosch Tool Corporation, Prospect, IL) (Figures 1, 2 and 3) was fitted with a new 1/4-inch wide, 4½-inch diameter segmented diamond abrasive blade made by DeWalt (model #DW4740). The grinder weighs six and a half pounds, draws 8.5 amps and has a variable speed up to 11,000 revolutions per minute (RPMs). The DustControl 2900c vacuum (DustControl, Inc., Wilmington, NC) (Figure 3) was tested in combination with the Dust Director shroud (Industrial Contractors’ Supplies, Inc., Huntingdon, PA) (Figures 1 and 3) attached to the Bosch grinder.
Figure 1. Bosch grinder with Dust Director shroud
Figure 2. Bosch grinder without tuckpointing LEV system.
Figure 3: Bosch Grinder with LEV System
The vacuum is specified to weigh 31 pounds when empty and to provide a flow rate of 114 cubic feet of air per minute and a “static lift” or “vacuum suction pressure” of 84 inches of water. The vacuum is sold with a cyclonic pre-separator, to remove larger particles, a fine filter (rated 99.9 percent efficient) and a HEPA (high-efficiency particulate air) filter (rated to capture 99.97 percent of the particles with an aerodynamic diameter of 0.3 micrometers). The HEPA filter was removed based on the manufacturer’s recommendation due to the heavy dust loading associated with tuckpointing. CPWR sponsored research and contractor experience indicate that HEPA filters likely have an adverse effect on dust capture during tuckpointing because of extreme dust loading on filters. While the cyclone and the fine filter remove most of the dust, especially the large particles, before they reach the HEPA filter, the HEPA filter would still be subject to heavy loading, causing a substantial pressure drop and subsequent decrease in air flow rate. The relatively small increase in the efficiency of the filtration system while using the HEPA filter is expected to be quickly offset by a more significant decrease in capture efficiency as the air flow rate and ability to capture particles decreases.
Dust collects in relatively inexpensive, heavy-gauge plastic bags below and outside of the cyclone. The bags can be removed and replaced without opening the vacuum. Some vacuums are equipped with a light to indicate that the filters need to be cleaned or changed. The DC2900c features a “reverse air pulse cleaning system,” which removes accumulated dust from the filters without having to remove them from the vacuum. The system, as illustrated in Figure 4, requires the operator to disconnect the hose from the shroud, place it over an air stop so that air through the hose is cut off and pressure in the vacuum is maximized.
Figure 4. Procedure for "cleaning" of or dust removal from filters (source: http://dustcontrolusa.com/manuals/2800c.pdf)
The flap covering the port on the side of the vacuum is repeatedly flipped open to release built up pressure in strong pulses that dislodge dust from the filter.
The manufacturer indicates “the filter is generally cleaned once or twice daily during normal continuous operation.” The Dust Director shroud has a 2-inch diameter take-off that was connected to the antistatic, corrugated 1.5-inch diameter, 15-foot long vacuum hose supplied with the DustControl vacuum.
IV. Study Methods
This evaluation was conducted at the International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craft workers (IUBAC) Local 1 Philadelphia/Delaware Training Center in Philadelphia, PA on November 14 and 15, 2012. A single journeyman bricklayer, experienced in tuckpointing, used the grinder and LEV system being tested to remove mortar from joints wide enough to require two passes. The type S mortar had been allowed to cure for at least four weeks. The bricklayer either possessed or was provided with personal protective equipment including sturdy work boots, gloves, hearing protection and a powered air-purifying respirator (PAPR). The PAPR was a 3M GVP system with a bump cap, loose fitting face piece and a HEPA filter (3M, St Paul, MN).
The study was designed to include at least five rounds of sampling during mortar removal. Each round included a trial using the Bosch grinder with a Dust Director shroud and Dust Collector 2900c vacuum and a trial using the Bosch grinder with the factory-supplied guard and without a vacuum. The order of the two trials within each round was randomly selected to minimize bias that might be introduced due to variation associated with environmental factors, equipment operator, blade wear, vacuum performance over time and any other factors unrelated to LEV use. Tools were operated for approximately 16 minutes per trial with controls and for approximately 8 minutes when controls were not used. These times were selected based on the results of previous sampling efforts and estimates of the minimum sample time needed to achieve a limit of quantification low enough to accurately measure exposures down to or less than 0.05 mg/m3 – the NIOSH Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) for respirable silica. The bricklayer was required to take a 5 to 10 minute break in the middle of the 16-minute trials to reduce differences in fatigue, compared to the 8-minute trials. Personal air samples were collected in the breathing zone of the operator during each trial to measure respirable silica concentrations during grinding with and without LEV. The samples were collected using a GilAir-5 pump (Sensidyne, Inc., Clearwater, FL) to draw 4.2 liters of air per minute through a GK2.69 Respirable Cyclone (BGI Inc., Waltham, MA) with a pre-weighed, 37 mm diameter, 5-micron pore size polyvinyl chloride (PVC) filter positioned on the operator’s lapel.
The flow rates of the sampling pumps were calibrated at the beginning of each day using a DryCal DC-Lite Primary Flow Meter (Bios International Corporation, Butler, NJ). Flow rates were measured again near the middle and at the end of each day to ensure that sampling flow rates were maintained within 5% of pre-sampling flow rates throughout the day. Average flow rates were used to calculate sample air volumes. Samples were analyzed by R.J. Lee Group, Inc., (Monroeville, PA) using NIOSH Method 0600, to determine exposure to total mass of respirable dust. The same samples were also analyzed using X-Ray diffraction following NIOSH method 7500 to determine quartz, cristobalite and tridymite concentration in the respirable mass. Reported masses for these analytes were used with the sample air volumes to calculate airborne concentrations of total respirable dust, quartz, cristobalite and tridymite.
We used a reduction of greater than 50 percent in respirable silica exposure concentrations or a reduction to less than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 as our criteria for determining whether or not a control was considered efficacious. This is consistent with criteria used by NIOSH in conducting a similar study in 2004 described by Echt et al. (2007) and by CPWR in 2006 and described by Meeker et al. (2009). The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) and the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) publish additional occupational exposure limits (OELs) for silica which are listed in Table 1 with NIOSH RELs. OELs for silica are based on the respirable fraction of the aerosol, which consists of particles less than 10 micrometers in aerodynamic diameter.
| Organization or Agency | Form of Crystalline Silica | Occupational Exposure Limits (mg/m3) |
|---|---|---|
| NIOSHA | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 |
| OSHA - ConstructionB | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
PEL = 250 / (5 + % quartz) PEL = 250 / (5 + % cristobalite) PEL = 250 / (5 + % tridymite) |
| ACGIH | Crystalline Silica | TLV = 0.025 mg/m3 |
A NIOSH Publication No. 2005-151 indicates 10-hour time-weighted average during a 40-hr workweek B The PEL for silica in OSHA’s Safety and Health Regulations for Construction, 29 C.F.R. 1926.55(a), is an 8-hour time-weighted average (TWA) expressed in millions of particles per cubic foot (mppcf). However, the units mppcf can be converted to milligrams per cubic meter can by dividing mppcf by 10 (OSHA, 2009). The formula used by OSHA to determine the PEL for silica is dependent on the percentage of silica in each collected sample. The concentration of respirable dust measured is compared to the sample specific PEL to determine if the PEL has been exceeded. OSHA has proposed lowering the PEL to 0.05 mg/m3 of respirable silica as an 8 hour TWA. |
||
The flow of air in ventilation systems is governed by fundamental principles that describe the behavior of gases (in this case air). Pressure measurements taken within a ventilation system along with knowledge of hood (or shroud) entry losses can be used to calculate flow rates. Hood entry losses are dependent on the shape and configuration of a particular hood or shroud and described by the term “coefficient of entry (Ce)” which is the ratio of actual air flow through a hood and what the air flow would theoretically be if there were no hood entry losses. Given the coefficient of entry, static pressure measurements can be used to calculate air flow through a given hood. The coefficient of entry for the Dust Director shroud was previously determined by CPWR and used for calculating air flow based on static pressure measurements (Meeker et al., 2009). Static pressure, with the vacuum operating, was measured periodically throughout the evaluation to monitor the changes in air-flow rate following use and again after filter cleaning. The static pressure was measured at a port positioned more than 3 duct diameters downstream from the tool’s air intake using a UEi EM200 Electronic Manometer (Universal Enterprises, Inc., Beaverton, OR).
The dust in the vacuum bag was monitored and, per the manufacturer’s instructions, the bag was changed before the dust level was within 5 centimeters of the valve at the bottom of the vacuum. Each time a vacuum bag was removed, it was weighed to the nearest pound. The bag weights and corresponding grinding durations were used to calculate the average weight of dust collected per unit time. After each trial, cut lengths were measured on the wall to determine total linear feet of vertical (head) and horizontal (bed) joints per unit time.
A Haz-Dust III, Model HD-1003, Real-Time Aerosol Monitor (Environmental Devices Corporation, Plaistow, NH) was used to confirm clearance of dust between trials. The Haz-Dust monitor was positioned on the test wall near the operator at approximately breathing zone level and configured to measure respirable particulate concentration.
V. Results
Personal air monitoring
Five pairs of respirable dust samples were collected while grinding with and without the vacuum system. In addition, three respirable dust samples were collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place. One measurement collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard was shown to be a statistical outlier and was omitted from analysis. Personal air monitoring results for respirable silica and a comparison of average exposures relative to the NIOSH REL for silica (0.05 mg/m3) appears in Table 2. The mean respirable dust levels measured without LEV was 31.4 mg/m3. However, samples collected with LEV were below the limit of quantification (LOQ) which ranged from <1.29 to <1.46 mg/m3. Use of LEV resulted in a greater than 95% reduction in mean respirable dust levels using a mean value with use of LEV of <1.41 (n=5 samples with use of LEV and n=7 without use of LEV). The respirable dust samples collected during grinding without the LEV system contained an average of 24 percent silica. The mass of respirable dust in the samples collected with use of the LEV system was too low to determine the silica content.| Mean, mg/m3 (range) | Std. Dev. | Percent Reduction | Hazard RatioB | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bosch with Dust Director Shroud and DustControl 2900c Vacuum |
0.091 (<0.069 – 0.137) |
0.027 | 98.7 | 1.81 |
| Bosch with no Control | 7.23 (4.57 – 9.90) |
1.94 | NA | 145 |
A n = 5 samples for each tool/control combination and n = 7 samples without the use of the LEV system B Hazard Ratio = measured exposure / NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 |
||||
Average respirable silica and dust exposures, with and without the dust control system, appear as Figures 5 and 6, respectively.
Figure 5. Average respirable silica exposures with and without the Dustcontrol 2900c vacuum and Dust Director shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air - mg/m3)
Figure 6. Average respirable dust exposures with and without Dustcontrol 2900c Vacuum and Dust Director Shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air – mg/m3)
The mean respirable silica concentration measured during use of the control was significantly less than the concentration measured while using the same tool without controls (p<0.01). Grinding mortar with the Bosch angle grinder without dust controls resulted in an average exposure to respirable silica that was 145 times the NIOSH REL. Grinding with the Bosch angle grinder in combination with the Dust Director shroud and the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced the average concentration of respirable silica by 98.7 percent. With use of these controls, the concentration of respirable silica was 1.8 times greater than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3. However the NIOSH REL is based on a time-weighted average (TWA) over a 10-hour workday. Given these were task TWAs and samples were collected over continuous periods of grinding, they may overestimate exposures over an actual work day since some time would be spent performing tasks that would likely have lower, or no, silica exposures (setup, breaks, cleanup, etc.).
Static pressure, dust mass collection and grinding rates.
Static pressure was used as a surrogate for air flow as described earlier. Hood static pressure was measured periodically at a tap near the grinder more than 3 duct diameters from the air intake in the shroud. The static pressure, and thus air flow, was generally higher when the vacuum’s filter had recently been cleaned. The mean, median, and range of calculated flow rates are presented in Table A1 of the Appendix.
Based on the data we collected, the air-flow rate upstream from the Bosch grinder and Dust Director shroud ranged from 78 to 93 cubic feet per minute (cfm) with the DustControl vacuum. When the manufacturer’s filter cleaning procedure was followed the vacuum performed relatively well and flow could be maintained at slightly less than 90 cfm with cleaning. However, mean flow rates dropped substantially to 80 cfm after as little as 8 minutes of grinding without any filter cleaning. The flow rate returned to an average of 89 cfm when filters were cleaned correctly (without stopping air flow to the vacuum). Collingwood and Heitbrink (2007) found that the minimum exhaust flow rate for capture of silica and other particulate under ideal conditions is 21.25 cfm per inch of grinder blade diameter. This is equal to about 96 cfm when using a 4.5 inch diameter grinding blade. We set 106 cfm as the minimum desired flow rate for this study to allow a safety margin for potential decline in equipment performance and the possibility of inadequate maintenance, both of which may be likely after repeated use under actual work conditions. The DustControl vacuum provided slightly less than the minimum flow rate described by Collingwood and Heitbrink for a 4.5-inch blade and the peak flow rate fell with use.
The duration of vacuum bag use and mass of dust collected were recorded and are presented in Table A2 of the Appendix. The vacuum bags were changed and weighed after each trial utilizing the LEV system. A total of five bags were used to complete the five rounds of grinding. The DustControl vacuum captured 45 pounds of dust over 83 minutes of grinding for an average rate of dust collection of 0.54 pounds per minute. The rate of dust collection ranged from 0.47 to 0.63 pounds per minute. Based on these measurements, approximately 130 pounds of dust would likely be captured after just 4 hours of continuous grinding.
The rate of grinding a combination of vertical and horizontal joints while using the LEV system ranged from 2.3 to 3.3 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the use of the LEV system ranged from 2.6 to 3.4 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place ranged from 4.7 to 5.1 feet per minute. It’s important to note that: 1) the operator had limited experience using dust control systems and cut rates appeared to improve slightly over the 2-day period he used the tested equipment; and 2) the upper range of cut rates with the dust control system overlapped with the lowest cut rate with the original guard and without the LEV system in place indicating no statistical difference between cut rates. Given that grinding rates with and without use of this LEV system are only available for one operator and he had limited experience with the LEV system, these reported cut rates are in no way intended to represent the impact use of this LEV system is likely to have on productivity rates overall.
VI. Discussion
The objective of these trials was to evaluate the effectiveness of a tuckpointing LEV system for controlling respirable silica while grinding out mortar joints. The Dust Director shroud with the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced respirable silica concentrations when grinding with the Bosch grinder by approximately 99 percent. Despite being considered effective by our test criteria (greater than 50% reduction), it still resulted in task TWA exposures that exceeded the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 by 1.8 times. Depending on how much time is spent grinding over the course of a work day and on exposures while performing other tasks, the 8-hour TWA exposures may or may not exceed the REL with this system. Use of this system by workers with experience and training in proficient use will likely improve dust capture performance. Exposure reduction is greatly influenced by correct use of this system which includes grinding from right to left, making sure the shroud is held flush against the wall and that the tool travels at a pace that doesn’t exceed the ability of the system to capture dust as it’s generated. Deviation from any of these measures produces visible dust clouds which were observed during trials.
VII. Conclusions
With a 99 percent reduction in respirable silica exposure, the Dust Director shroud and DustControl 2900c vacuum with a Bosch Model 1775E grinder was effective in reducing silica exposures based on our criteria. Use of the tested dust control system may be effective in reducing silica exposure on the job to less than the NIOSH REL if used in combination with administrative controls such as work scheduling to reduce cutting times as needed. Training on correct use of the tested system is also essential. Personal air monitoring is necessary to verify control effectiveness on actual job sites and under “real-world” conditions. However, these results clearly demonstrate the availability of viable and effective engineering controls for tuckpointing operations associated with elevated silica exposure.
VIII. References
American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists. Threshold limit values for chemical substances (TLV®-CS). [2013]. ACGIH, Cincinnati, Ohio.
Bergdahl I.A,. Toren K., Eriksson K., et al. [2004]. Increased mortality in COPD among construction workers exposed to inorganic dust. European Respiratory Journal, 23: 402–06.
Blanc P.D. & Torén K. [2007]. Occupation in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and chronic bronchitis: an update [State of the Art Series. Occupational lung disease in high-and low-income countries, Edited by M. Chan-Yeung. Number 2 in the series]. The International Journal of Tuberculosis and Lung Disease, 11(3), 251-257.
Collingwood S. & Heitbrink W.A. [2007] 'Field Evaluation of an Engineering Control for Respirable Crystalline Silica Exposures During Mortar Removal'. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, 4:11, 875 – 887.
DHHS (NIOSH) Publication No. 2002-129 April 2002 http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/2002-129/
Echt A., Sieber W.K., Lefkowitz D., Meeker J., Susi P., Cardwell B., Heitbrink, W.A. In-depth survey of dust control technology for cutting concrete block and tuckpointing brick at The International Masonry Institute Bordentown Training Center, Bordentown, NJ. Cincinnati, OH: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Report. No. EPHB 282-13; 2007. http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ECTB-282-13.pdf
Heitbrink W., Bennett J. [2006]. A numerical and experimental investigation of crystalline silica exposure control during tuck pointing. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, Vol. 3, pp 366-378.
Lyons et al, [2007]. A breathless builder. Breathe, Vol. 3, no. 4, pp 386-390.
Mastrangelo G., Tartari M., Fedeli U., Fadda E., Saia B. [2003]. Ascertaining the risk of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease in relation to occupation using a case-control design. Occupational Medicine, 53: 165–172.
Meeker J., Cooper M., Lefrowitz D., Susi P. [2009]. Engineering control technologies to reduce occupational silica exposures in masonry cutting and tuckpointing. Public Health Reports, Supplement 1, Vol. 124, June.
Meeker J, Flynn M, Susi P, Cardwell, B [2004]. Performance evaluation of a masonry concrete vacuum. Unpublished Report.
Miller F. W., Alfredsson L., Costenbader K. H., Kamen D. L., Nelson L. M., Norris J. M., & De Roos A. J. [2012]. Epidemiology of environmental exposures and human autoimmune diseases: findings from a National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences Expert Panel workshop. Journal of autoimmunity. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3496812/
Occupational Safety and Health Administration U.S Department of Labor. Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction. [2009]. OSHA 3362-05.
Rappaport SM, Goldberg M, Susi P, Herrick RF [2003]. Excessive exposure to silica in the U.S. construction industry. Annals of Occupational Hygiene, Vol. 47, pp. 111-122.
IX. Appendices
| Measurement Conditions |
n | Mean Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Median
Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before filter cleaning | 5 | 80 | 81 | 78-81 |
| After filter cleaning following manufacturer directions | 9 | 89 | 90 | 84-93 |
| * Static pressure was measured in millibars and converted to inches of water gauge. Flow rates were calculated using the formula Q = Ce (A) 4005 (SP)1/2 where: Q = flow in cubic feet per minute (cfm), Ce = coefficient of entry, A = area of the duct where static pressure measurements were taken in square feet, and SP = static pressure in inches of water gauge. | ||||
| Tool/Control | Collection Period (min.) |
Dust Collection Rate (lb/min.) |
|---|---|---|
| Bosch grinder/Dust Director shroud & DustControl 2900c vacuum |
8 11 8 8 10 |
0.50 0.61 0.50 0.47 0.63 |
| Average | 0.54 |
[content_transformed:protected] =>
Executive Summary
This report describes the results of an evaluation, in a controlled setting, of a tuckpointing dust control system consisting of a Bosch model 1775E grinder, a Dust Director shroud, and a DustControl 2900c vacuum. Removing mortar with a Bosch grinder without the dust control system resulted in a mean task time-weighted average (TWA) respirable silica exposure 145 times the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH) Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) of 0.05 mg/m3 for respirable silica. Use of the same grinder with the dust control system reduced exposures by approximately 99 percent. However, exposures measured during use of the dust control system still exceeded the selected occupational exposure limit. It should also be noted that the NIOSH REL is based on exposures averaged over a ten hour work day and our results represent time weighted averages of the sample task duration periods.
Acronyms
ACGIH - American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists
CPWR - CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training
Ce - coefficient of entry
HEPA - high-efficiency particulate air
IUBAC - International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craftworkers
LEV - local exhaust ventilation
PACT - Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies
NIOSH - National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health
OEL - occupational exposure limit
OSHA - Occupational Safety and Health Administration
PAPR - powered air-purifying respirator
PEL - Permissible Exposure Limit
PVC - polyvinyl chloride
REL - Recommended Exposure Limit
RPM - revolutions per minute
TWA - time-weighted average
SP - static pressure
I. Introduction and Background
In 2010 CPWR – The Center for Construction Research and Training began a four-year project which seeks to identify and evaluate tuckpointing local exhaust ventilation (LEV) systems and disseminate information on their availability and effectiveness. A Partnership for Advancing Control Technologies (PACT) comprised of masonry contractors, representatives from unions, government, equipment manufacturers, and health and safety researcher was formed as part of this project. PACT members participated in identifying important characteristics for control technologies and this information was used to identify LEV systems for tuckpointing using that criteria. Contractor and labor members of the PACT selected specific tuckpointing LEV systems to be considered for evaluation. Each system consisted of a tuckpointing grinder, shroud, and vacuum. This report describes the second of four systems to be evaluated between 2012 the end of 2014, with and without LEV, in a controlled setting to determine effectiveness in silica exposure reduction. This report describes the methods and results of our evaluation of a system consisting of the DustControl 2900c vacuum with the ICS Dust Director shroud and a Bosch Model 1775E grinder.
Excessive exposure to respirable silica can result in silicosis or other silica-related diseases including pulmonary tuberculosis, lung cancer, silicoproteinosis (Lyons et al, 2007) and autoimmune disorders such as rheumatoid arthritis, sarcoidosis and scleroderma (Miller et al, 2012). Respirable silica is generally defined as particles less than 10 micrometers (μm) in aerodynamic diameter (ACGIH, 2013). Silicosis can lead to symptoms including shortness of breath, fatigue, chest pains, susceptibility to infection and possibly death. There is no cure for silicosis, however it is totally preventable. Construction workers exposed to dust, including silica, are also known to have higher rates of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD).
There are many sources of silica in construction that result in exposures of varying intensity among workers. Masonry restoration workers are among the most highly silica-exposed trades in construction. The process of grinding out deteriorated mortar joints between masonry units and replacing or repointing with fresh mortar (often referred to as tuckpointing) is a fundamental part of masonry restoration work. The removal of mortar with powered angle grinders generates enormous levels of dust. Between 2004 and 2006, NIOSH and CPWR evaluated silica exposures while grinding mortar in a controlled setting, at a local training center, where tasks, sample times and task variables were defined by the study design. These studies demonstrated that grinding mortar without controls can result in elevated respirable silica exposures. Meeker et al., (2009) reported exposures between 5 and 25.8 milligrams per cubic meter (mg/m3) in a controlled setting. This study also showed that LEV systems for tuckpointing grinders can reduce exposures to respirable silica by greater than 90 percent.II. Objectives
The objective of this evaluation was to assess the effectiveness of an LEV system for controlling exposure to silica during the grinding of mortar. The control technology was tested under controlled conditions, similar to those experienced by tuckpointers on actual job sites, using journeymen bricklayers experienced in tuckpointing and repeat, randomized trials with and without LEV. All other variables were held constant throughout so that the only variable was whether or not the tested control was used.
III. Description of Equipment Tested
A Bosch model 1775E grinder (Robert Bosch Tool Corporation, Prospect, IL) (Figures 1, 2 and 3) was fitted with a new 1/4-inch wide, 4½-inch diameter segmented diamond abrasive blade made by DeWalt (model #DW4740). The grinder weighs six and a half pounds, draws 8.5 amps and has a variable speed up to 11,000 revolutions per minute (RPMs). The DustControl 2900c vacuum (DustControl, Inc., Wilmington, NC) (Figure 3) was tested in combination with the Dust Director shroud (Industrial Contractors’ Supplies, Inc., Huntingdon, PA) (Figures 1 and 3) attached to the Bosch grinder.
Figure 1. Bosch grinder with Dust Director shroud
Figure 2. Bosch grinder without tuckpointing LEV system.
Figure 3: Bosch Grinder with LEV System
The vacuum is specified to weigh 31 pounds when empty and to provide a flow rate of 114 cubic feet of air per minute and a “static lift” or “vacuum suction pressure” of 84 inches of water. The vacuum is sold with a cyclonic pre-separator, to remove larger particles, a fine filter (rated 99.9 percent efficient) and a HEPA (high-efficiency particulate air) filter (rated to capture 99.97 percent of the particles with an aerodynamic diameter of 0.3 micrometers). The HEPA filter was removed based on the manufacturer’s recommendation due to the heavy dust loading associated with tuckpointing. CPWR sponsored research and contractor experience indicate that HEPA filters likely have an adverse effect on dust capture during tuckpointing because of extreme dust loading on filters. While the cyclone and the fine filter remove most of the dust, especially the large particles, before they reach the HEPA filter, the HEPA filter would still be subject to heavy loading, causing a substantial pressure drop and subsequent decrease in air flow rate. The relatively small increase in the efficiency of the filtration system while using the HEPA filter is expected to be quickly offset by a more significant decrease in capture efficiency as the air flow rate and ability to capture particles decreases.
Dust collects in relatively inexpensive, heavy-gauge plastic bags below and outside of the cyclone. The bags can be removed and replaced without opening the vacuum. Some vacuums are equipped with a light to indicate that the filters need to be cleaned or changed. The DC2900c features a “reverse air pulse cleaning system,” which removes accumulated dust from the filters without having to remove them from the vacuum. The system, as illustrated in Figure 4, requires the operator to disconnect the hose from the shroud, place it over an air stop so that air through the hose is cut off and pressure in the vacuum is maximized.
Figure 4. Procedure for "cleaning" of or dust removal from filters (source: http://dustcontrolusa.com/manuals/2800c.pdf)
The flap covering the port on the side of the vacuum is repeatedly flipped open to release built up pressure in strong pulses that dislodge dust from the filter.
The manufacturer indicates “the filter is generally cleaned once or twice daily during normal continuous operation.” The Dust Director shroud has a 2-inch diameter take-off that was connected to the antistatic, corrugated 1.5-inch diameter, 15-foot long vacuum hose supplied with the DustControl vacuum.
IV. Study Methods
This evaluation was conducted at the International Union of Bricklayers and Allied Craft workers (IUBAC) Local 1 Philadelphia/Delaware Training Center in Philadelphia, PA on November 14 and 15, 2012. A single journeyman bricklayer, experienced in tuckpointing, used the grinder and LEV system being tested to remove mortar from joints wide enough to require two passes. The type S mortar had been allowed to cure for at least four weeks. The bricklayer either possessed or was provided with personal protective equipment including sturdy work boots, gloves, hearing protection and a powered air-purifying respirator (PAPR). The PAPR was a 3M GVP system with a bump cap, loose fitting face piece and a HEPA filter (3M, St Paul, MN).
The study was designed to include at least five rounds of sampling during mortar removal. Each round included a trial using the Bosch grinder with a Dust Director shroud and Dust Collector 2900c vacuum and a trial using the Bosch grinder with the factory-supplied guard and without a vacuum. The order of the two trials within each round was randomly selected to minimize bias that might be introduced due to variation associated with environmental factors, equipment operator, blade wear, vacuum performance over time and any other factors unrelated to LEV use. Tools were operated for approximately 16 minutes per trial with controls and for approximately 8 minutes when controls were not used. These times were selected based on the results of previous sampling efforts and estimates of the minimum sample time needed to achieve a limit of quantification low enough to accurately measure exposures down to or less than 0.05 mg/m3 – the NIOSH Recommended Exposure Limit (REL) for respirable silica. The bricklayer was required to take a 5 to 10 minute break in the middle of the 16-minute trials to reduce differences in fatigue, compared to the 8-minute trials. Personal air samples were collected in the breathing zone of the operator during each trial to measure respirable silica concentrations during grinding with and without LEV. The samples were collected using a GilAir-5 pump (Sensidyne, Inc., Clearwater, FL) to draw 4.2 liters of air per minute through a GK2.69 Respirable Cyclone (BGI Inc., Waltham, MA) with a pre-weighed, 37 mm diameter, 5-micron pore size polyvinyl chloride (PVC) filter positioned on the operator’s lapel.
The flow rates of the sampling pumps were calibrated at the beginning of each day using a DryCal DC-Lite Primary Flow Meter (Bios International Corporation, Butler, NJ). Flow rates were measured again near the middle and at the end of each day to ensure that sampling flow rates were maintained within 5% of pre-sampling flow rates throughout the day. Average flow rates were used to calculate sample air volumes. Samples were analyzed by R.J. Lee Group, Inc., (Monroeville, PA) using NIOSH Method 0600, to determine exposure to total mass of respirable dust. The same samples were also analyzed using X-Ray diffraction following NIOSH method 7500 to determine quartz, cristobalite and tridymite concentration in the respirable mass. Reported masses for these analytes were used with the sample air volumes to calculate airborne concentrations of total respirable dust, quartz, cristobalite and tridymite.
We used a reduction of greater than 50 percent in respirable silica exposure concentrations or a reduction to less than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 as our criteria for determining whether or not a control was considered efficacious. This is consistent with criteria used by NIOSH in conducting a similar study in 2004 described by Echt et al. (2007) and by CPWR in 2006 and described by Meeker et al. (2009). The Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) and the American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists (ACGIH) publish additional occupational exposure limits (OELs) for silica which are listed in Table 1 with NIOSH RELs. OELs for silica are based on the respirable fraction of the aerosol, which consists of particles less than 10 micrometers in aerodynamic diameter.
| Organization or Agency | Form of Crystalline Silica | Occupational Exposure Limits (mg/m3) |
|---|---|---|
| NIOSHA | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 REL = 0.05 mg/m3 |
| OSHA - ConstructionB | Quartz Cristobalite Tridymite |
PEL = 250 / (5 + % quartz) PEL = 250 / (5 + % cristobalite) PEL = 250 / (5 + % tridymite) |
| ACGIH | Crystalline Silica | TLV = 0.025 mg/m3 |
A NIOSH Publication No. 2005-151 indicates 10-hour time-weighted average during a 40-hr workweek B The PEL for silica in OSHA’s Safety and Health Regulations for Construction, 29 C.F.R. 1926.55(a), is an 8-hour time-weighted average (TWA) expressed in millions of particles per cubic foot (mppcf). However, the units mppcf can be converted to milligrams per cubic meter can by dividing mppcf by 10 (OSHA, 2009). The formula used by OSHA to determine the PEL for silica is dependent on the percentage of silica in each collected sample. The concentration of respirable dust measured is compared to the sample specific PEL to determine if the PEL has been exceeded. OSHA has proposed lowering the PEL to 0.05 mg/m3 of respirable silica as an 8 hour TWA. |
||
The flow of air in ventilation systems is governed by fundamental principles that describe the behavior of gases (in this case air). Pressure measurements taken within a ventilation system along with knowledge of hood (or shroud) entry losses can be used to calculate flow rates. Hood entry losses are dependent on the shape and configuration of a particular hood or shroud and described by the term “coefficient of entry (Ce)” which is the ratio of actual air flow through a hood and what the air flow would theoretically be if there were no hood entry losses. Given the coefficient of entry, static pressure measurements can be used to calculate air flow through a given hood. The coefficient of entry for the Dust Director shroud was previously determined by CPWR and used for calculating air flow based on static pressure measurements (Meeker et al., 2009). Static pressure, with the vacuum operating, was measured periodically throughout the evaluation to monitor the changes in air-flow rate following use and again after filter cleaning. The static pressure was measured at a port positioned more than 3 duct diameters downstream from the tool’s air intake using a UEi EM200 Electronic Manometer (Universal Enterprises, Inc., Beaverton, OR).
The dust in the vacuum bag was monitored and, per the manufacturer’s instructions, the bag was changed before the dust level was within 5 centimeters of the valve at the bottom of the vacuum. Each time a vacuum bag was removed, it was weighed to the nearest pound. The bag weights and corresponding grinding durations were used to calculate the average weight of dust collected per unit time. After each trial, cut lengths were measured on the wall to determine total linear feet of vertical (head) and horizontal (bed) joints per unit time.
A Haz-Dust III, Model HD-1003, Real-Time Aerosol Monitor (Environmental Devices Corporation, Plaistow, NH) was used to confirm clearance of dust between trials. The Haz-Dust monitor was positioned on the test wall near the operator at approximately breathing zone level and configured to measure respirable particulate concentration.
V. Results
Personal air monitoring
Five pairs of respirable dust samples were collected while grinding with and without the vacuum system. In addition, three respirable dust samples were collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place. One measurement collected while grinding without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard was shown to be a statistical outlier and was omitted from analysis. Personal air monitoring results for respirable silica and a comparison of average exposures relative to the NIOSH REL for silica (0.05 mg/m3) appears in Table 2. The mean respirable dust levels measured without LEV was 31.4 mg/m3. However, samples collected with LEV were below the limit of quantification (LOQ) which ranged from <1.29 to <1.46 mg/m3. Use of LEV resulted in a greater than 95% reduction in mean respirable dust levels using a mean value with use of LEV of <1.41 (n=5 samples with use of LEV and n=7 without use of LEV). The respirable dust samples collected during grinding without the LEV system contained an average of 24 percent silica. The mass of respirable dust in the samples collected with use of the LEV system was too low to determine the silica content.| Mean, mg/m3 (range) | Std. Dev. | Percent Reduction | Hazard RatioB | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bosch with Dust Director Shroud and DustControl 2900c Vacuum |
0.091 (<0.069 – 0.137) |
0.027 | 98.7 | 1.81 |
| Bosch with no Control | 7.23 (4.57 – 9.90) |
1.94 | NA | 145 |
A n = 5 samples for each tool/control combination and n = 7 samples without the use of the LEV system B Hazard Ratio = measured exposure / NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 |
||||
Average respirable silica and dust exposures, with and without the dust control system, appear as Figures 5 and 6, respectively.
Figure 5. Average respirable silica exposures with and without the Dustcontrol 2900c vacuum and Dust Director shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air - mg/m3)
Figure 6. Average respirable dust exposures with and without Dustcontrol 2900c Vacuum and Dust Director Shroud (milligrams per cubic meter of air – mg/m3)
The mean respirable silica concentration measured during use of the control was significantly less than the concentration measured while using the same tool without controls (p<0.01). Grinding mortar with the Bosch angle grinder without dust controls resulted in an average exposure to respirable silica that was 145 times the NIOSH REL. Grinding with the Bosch angle grinder in combination with the Dust Director shroud and the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced the average concentration of respirable silica by 98.7 percent. With use of these controls, the concentration of respirable silica was 1.8 times greater than the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3. However the NIOSH REL is based on a time-weighted average (TWA) over a 10-hour workday. Given these were task TWAs and samples were collected over continuous periods of grinding, they may overestimate exposures over an actual work day since some time would be spent performing tasks that would likely have lower, or no, silica exposures (setup, breaks, cleanup, etc.).
Static pressure, dust mass collection and grinding rates.
Static pressure was used as a surrogate for air flow as described earlier. Hood static pressure was measured periodically at a tap near the grinder more than 3 duct diameters from the air intake in the shroud. The static pressure, and thus air flow, was generally higher when the vacuum’s filter had recently been cleaned. The mean, median, and range of calculated flow rates are presented in Table A1 of the Appendix.
Based on the data we collected, the air-flow rate upstream from the Bosch grinder and Dust Director shroud ranged from 78 to 93 cubic feet per minute (cfm) with the DustControl vacuum. When the manufacturer’s filter cleaning procedure was followed the vacuum performed relatively well and flow could be maintained at slightly less than 90 cfm with cleaning. However, mean flow rates dropped substantially to 80 cfm after as little as 8 minutes of grinding without any filter cleaning. The flow rate returned to an average of 89 cfm when filters were cleaned correctly (without stopping air flow to the vacuum). Collingwood and Heitbrink (2007) found that the minimum exhaust flow rate for capture of silica and other particulate under ideal conditions is 21.25 cfm per inch of grinder blade diameter. This is equal to about 96 cfm when using a 4.5 inch diameter grinding blade. We set 106 cfm as the minimum desired flow rate for this study to allow a safety margin for potential decline in equipment performance and the possibility of inadequate maintenance, both of which may be likely after repeated use under actual work conditions. The DustControl vacuum provided slightly less than the minimum flow rate described by Collingwood and Heitbrink for a 4.5-inch blade and the peak flow rate fell with use.
The duration of vacuum bag use and mass of dust collected were recorded and are presented in Table A2 of the Appendix. The vacuum bags were changed and weighed after each trial utilizing the LEV system. A total of five bags were used to complete the five rounds of grinding. The DustControl vacuum captured 45 pounds of dust over 83 minutes of grinding for an average rate of dust collection of 0.54 pounds per minute. The rate of dust collection ranged from 0.47 to 0.63 pounds per minute. Based on these measurements, approximately 130 pounds of dust would likely be captured after just 4 hours of continuous grinding.
The rate of grinding a combination of vertical and horizontal joints while using the LEV system ranged from 2.3 to 3.3 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the use of the LEV system ranged from 2.6 to 3.4 feet per minute. The rate of grinding vertical and horizontal joints without the LEV system and with the stock blade guard in place ranged from 4.7 to 5.1 feet per minute. It’s important to note that: 1) the operator had limited experience using dust control systems and cut rates appeared to improve slightly over the 2-day period he used the tested equipment; and 2) the upper range of cut rates with the dust control system overlapped with the lowest cut rate with the original guard and without the LEV system in place indicating no statistical difference between cut rates. Given that grinding rates with and without use of this LEV system are only available for one operator and he had limited experience with the LEV system, these reported cut rates are in no way intended to represent the impact use of this LEV system is likely to have on productivity rates overall.
VI. Discussion
The objective of these trials was to evaluate the effectiveness of a tuckpointing LEV system for controlling respirable silica while grinding out mortar joints. The Dust Director shroud with the DustControl 2900c vacuum reduced respirable silica concentrations when grinding with the Bosch grinder by approximately 99 percent. Despite being considered effective by our test criteria (greater than 50% reduction), it still resulted in task TWA exposures that exceeded the NIOSH REL of 0.05 mg/m3 by 1.8 times. Depending on how much time is spent grinding over the course of a work day and on exposures while performing other tasks, the 8-hour TWA exposures may or may not exceed the REL with this system. Use of this system by workers with experience and training in proficient use will likely improve dust capture performance. Exposure reduction is greatly influenced by correct use of this system which includes grinding from right to left, making sure the shroud is held flush against the wall and that the tool travels at a pace that doesn’t exceed the ability of the system to capture dust as it’s generated. Deviation from any of these measures produces visible dust clouds which were observed during trials.
VII. Conclusions
With a 99 percent reduction in respirable silica exposure, the Dust Director shroud and DustControl 2900c vacuum with a Bosch Model 1775E grinder was effective in reducing silica exposures based on our criteria. Use of the tested dust control system may be effective in reducing silica exposure on the job to less than the NIOSH REL if used in combination with administrative controls such as work scheduling to reduce cutting times as needed. Training on correct use of the tested system is also essential. Personal air monitoring is necessary to verify control effectiveness on actual job sites and under “real-world” conditions. However, these results clearly demonstrate the availability of viable and effective engineering controls for tuckpointing operations associated with elevated silica exposure.
VIII. References
American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists. Threshold limit values for chemical substances (TLV®-CS). [2013]. ACGIH, Cincinnati, Ohio.
Bergdahl I.A,. Toren K., Eriksson K., et al. [2004]. Increased mortality in COPD among construction workers exposed to inorganic dust. European Respiratory Journal, 23: 402–06.
Blanc P.D. & Torén K. [2007]. Occupation in chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and chronic bronchitis: an update [State of the Art Series. Occupational lung disease in high-and low-income countries, Edited by M. Chan-Yeung. Number 2 in the series]. The International Journal of Tuberculosis and Lung Disease, 11(3), 251-257.
Collingwood S. & Heitbrink W.A. [2007] 'Field Evaluation of an Engineering Control for Respirable Crystalline Silica Exposures During Mortar Removal'. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, 4:11, 875 – 887.
DHHS (NIOSH) Publication No. 2002-129 April 2002 http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/docs/2002-129/
Echt A., Sieber W.K., Lefkowitz D., Meeker J., Susi P., Cardwell B., Heitbrink, W.A. In-depth survey of dust control technology for cutting concrete block and tuckpointing brick at The International Masonry Institute Bordentown Training Center, Bordentown, NJ. Cincinnati, OH: U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health, Report. No. EPHB 282-13; 2007. http://www.cdc.gov/niosh/surveyreports/pdfs/ECTB-282-13.pdf
Heitbrink W., Bennett J. [2006]. A numerical and experimental investigation of crystalline silica exposure control during tuck pointing. Journal of Occupational and Environmental Hygiene, Vol. 3, pp 366-378.
Lyons et al, [2007]. A breathless builder. Breathe, Vol. 3, no. 4, pp 386-390.
Mastrangelo G., Tartari M., Fedeli U., Fadda E., Saia B. [2003]. Ascertaining the risk of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease in relation to occupation using a case-control design. Occupational Medicine, 53: 165–172.
Meeker J., Cooper M., Lefrowitz D., Susi P. [2009]. Engineering control technologies to reduce occupational silica exposures in masonry cutting and tuckpointing. Public Health Reports, Supplement 1, Vol. 124, June.
Meeker J, Flynn M, Susi P, Cardwell, B [2004]. Performance evaluation of a masonry concrete vacuum. Unpublished Report.
Miller F. W., Alfredsson L., Costenbader K. H., Kamen D. L., Nelson L. M., Norris J. M., & De Roos A. J. [2012]. Epidemiology of environmental exposures and human autoimmune diseases: findings from a National Institute of Environmental Health Sciences Expert Panel workshop. Journal of autoimmunity. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3496812/
Occupational Safety and Health Administration U.S Department of Labor. Controlling Silica Exposures in Construction. [2009]. OSHA 3362-05.
Rappaport SM, Goldberg M, Susi P, Herrick RF [2003]. Excessive exposure to silica in the U.S. construction industry. Annals of Occupational Hygiene, Vol. 47, pp. 111-122.
IX. Appendices
| Measurement Conditions |
n | Mean Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Median
Flow Rate (cfm)* |
Range |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Before filter cleaning | 5 | 80 | 81 | 78-81 |
| After filter cleaning following manufacturer directions | 9 | 89 | 90 | 84-93 |
| * Static pressure was measured in millibars and converted to inches of water gauge. Flow rates were calculated using the formula Q = Ce (A) 4005 (SP)1/2 where: Q = flow in cubic feet per minute (cfm), Ce = coefficient of entry, A = area of the duct where static pressure measurements were taken in square feet, and SP = static pressure in inches of water gauge. | ||||
| Tool/Control | Collection Period (min.) |
Dust Collection Rate (lb/min.) |
|---|---|---|
| Bosch grinder/Dust Director shroud & DustControl 2900c vacuum |
8 11 8 8 10 |
0.50 0.61 0.50 0.47 0.63 |
| Average | 0.54 |
[disclaimer:protected] => [disclaimer_transformed:protected] => [alreadyInSave:protected] => [alreadyInValidation:protected] => [validationFailures:protected] => Array ( ) [_new:BaseObject:private] => [_deleted:BaseObject:private] => [modifiedColumns:protected] => Array ( ) ) [template] => record ) ) ) [5] => Array ( [file] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/sblib/core/SB_Engine/page/PHPTAL_Page.php [line] => 38 [function] => execute [class] => PHPTAL [type] => -> [args] => Array ( ) ) [6] => Array ( [file] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/sblib/core/SB_Engine/page/Decorator_Page.php [line] => 34 [function] => render [class] => SB_PHPTAL_Page [type] => -> [args] => Array ( ) ) [7] => Array ( [file] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/sblib/core/SB_Engine/page/Decorator_Page.php [line] => 23 [function] => render [class] => SB_Decorator_Page [type] => -> [args] => Array ( ) ) [8] => Array ( [file] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/sblib/core/SB_Engine/module/Module.php [line] => 35 [function] => display [class] => SB_Decorator_Page [type] => -> [args] => Array ( ) ) [9] => Array ( [file] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/sblib/core/SB_Engine/Controller.php [line] => 48 [function] => display [class] => SB_Module [type] => -> [args] => Array ( ) ) [10] => Array ( [file] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/sblib/core/SB_Engine/Controller.php [line] => 36 [function] => main [class] => SBE_Controller [type] => -> [args] => Array ( [0] => [1] => Array ( ) ) ) [11] => Array ( [file] => /home/agsafe5/repositories/elcosh/live/web_root/elcosh/index.php [line] => 14 [function] => run [class] => SBE_Controller [type] => -> [args] => Array ( ) ) ) [previous:Exception:private] => )